Hall thrusters are common examples of E × B configuration, where electron trajectory gets trapped along the external magnetic field lines. This significantly increases the residence time of electrons in the plasma discharge channel. Hall thrusters are potential candidates for spacecraft station keeping, rephrasing and orbit topping applications because of its high thrust resolutions and efficiency. The goal of this chapter is to explain the working principle of Hall thrusters and to characterize the resistive instability in hot dusty plasma. The studies of these instabilities are useful to design efficient Hall thrusters and to understand the solar dusty plasma. The large amplitude of these oscillations has an adverse effect on the power processing unit of the devices. This reduces the efficiency and specific impulse and shortens the operating life of the Hall thruster. The theory of linearization of fluid equation for small oscillation has been given. The chapter also discusses the origin of plasma oscillation in a plasma discharge mechanics.
- plasma oscillations
- Hall thrusters
- resistive plasma
- growth rate
1. Introduction to E × B devices
There are some devices where plasma is weakly magnetized because of the larger Larmor radius of the massive ions against the length of the discharge channel. Electrons get trapped along the magnetic field lines in the channel. Hall thrusters and magnetrons are the common examples of E × B devices. The E × B configuration is used to confine electrons, increasing the electron residence time and allowing ionization and plasma sustainment. Hall thrusters have emerged as an integral part of propulsion technology. Unlike chemicals and electric rockets, in a Hall thruster, the propulsion thrust is achieved by gas which has high atomic number and low ionization potential. For this Xenon is mostly used. In the discharge channel, Xenon is ionized and then accelerated by electrostatic forces. Hall thrusters are versatile electric propulsion devices, where thrust efficiencies can exceed 50% and specific impulses are typically between 20 min and 1 h. The specific impulse has the dimension of time and is a measure for the effective lifetime of the thruster, when lifting its own propellant from the earth’s surface. The specific impulse is defined as , where is the mass flow rate;
Figure 1 shows the internal components of a Hall thruster which is generally made of an axis-symmetric cylindrical discharge chamber. A cathode is fixed outside to produce electrons to neutralize the outer surface of the device to overcome the space-charging problems. A high atomic weight number and low ionization potential gases are preferred propellant (Xenon, Argon) for Hall thrusters to get more thrust. The propellant enters from the left side of the channel via anode and gets ionized through the hollow cathode of the device. The electric field of strength ∼1000 V/m gets generated inside the discharge channel along the axial direction of the device. By using magnets around the annular channel and along the thruster centreline, a radial magnetic field of moderate strength (∼150–200 G) is created, which is strong enough for the electrons to get magnetized, i.e. they are able to gyrate within the discharge channel, but the ions remain unaffected due to their Larmor radius much larger than the dimension of the thruster .
We used a Cartesian coordinate system to understand the different forces on the particles inside the channel and let us suppose, the X-axis represents, the axis of the thruster. Generally, the applied electric and magnetic fields are in axial (along X axis) and radial (along Z axis) directions, respectively, of the device. Therefore because of the perpendicular electric and magnetic fields, the Lorentz forces act on the electrons along the Y axis ( azimuthal direction). Since electrons have smaller Larmor radius than the length of the channel, therefore electrons rotate along the azimuthal direction under the influences of the Lorentz force [1, 2, 3, 4].
2. Review on plasma instabilities in Hall thrusters
It is well known that plasma pressure drives the instabilities in plasma. Therefore the confined plasma is prone to non-equilibrium thermodynamic state. Therefore it must be important to know the consequences of these instabilities. It has been established that the amplitude and frequency of the oscillations in the Hall thrusters depend on mass flow rate, discharge voltage, geometry, magnetic field profile and cathode operation mode. On the other hand, the plasma in a Hall thruster does not stay uniform, and an inhomogeneous plasma immersed in the external electric and magnetic fields is not in the thermodynamically equilibrium state; this deviation in general is a source of plasma instabilities.
In Hall thrusters, from low frequencies (few Hertz) to high frequencies (few GHz), oscillation spectra have been observed on theoretically as well as experimentally based studies. The oscillations in the range of 10–20 kHz are called as discharge oscillations, and oscillations in the range of 5–25 kHz are said to be ionization-driven oscillations. The drift instabilities and density gradient plasma are responsible to produce oscillations in the range of 20–60 kHz in a Hall thruster. The oscillations in the range of 70–500 kHz are also called transient time oscillations and are the order of ion residence time in the channel of the device. The oscillations associated with azimuthal waves are represented by high-frequency (0.5–5 MHz) oscillations . Litvak and Fisch  have developed an analytical model for electrostatic and electromagnetic resistive instabilities in a Hall plasma for azimuthal disturbances. Singh and Malik investigated resistive instabilities for axial and azimuthal disturbances in a Hall thrusters [7, 8]. Fernandez et al.  did simulations for the growth of resistive instability. Litvak and Fisch  have analysed gradient-driven Rayleigh-type instabilities in a Hall thruster using two fluid hydrodynamic equations. Ducrocq et al.  have investigated high-frequency electron drift instability in the cross-field configuration of a Hall thruster. Barral and Ahedo  have developed a low-frequency model of breathing oscillations in Hall discharges, where they observed that unstable modes are strongly nonlinear and are characterized by frequencies obeying a scaling law different from that of linear modes. Chesta et al.  have developed a theoretical model to obtain the growth rate and frequencies of axial and azimuthally propagating plasma disturbances.
3. Studies of fine particles in plasma
The presence of heavy fine particles with a size of 1–50 microns and mass of orders 10−10 to 10−15 kg in a classical plasma acts as a external component in plasma. If the density of the dust particles is less than the plasma density, the system is called dusty plasma. These fine particles acquire some charges from the electrons to get charged. The magnitude of charge on dust grain is not constant. It depends on the type of dust grain, the surface properties of dust grain, the dust dynamics, the temperature, the density of plasma and the wave motion in the medium. The presence of fine particles in a plasma makes it more complex and these particles alter the dynamics of the plasma species which generate new propagating modes by exhibit their own dynamics. The dusty plasmas have an exciting property which has attracted researchers over the world in this area [14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22]. The presence of charged dust grains modifies the ion-acoustic waves, lower hybrid waves, ion-acoustic and introduces dust acoustic waves and dust ion acoustic waves . Verma et al. have studied the electrostatic oscillation in the presence of grain charge perturbation in a dusty plasma . They studied the property of electrostatic oscillation and instability phenomena taking into account the temporal evolution of the grain charge in an unmagnetized dusty plasma. Cui and Goree have studied the effect of fluctuations of the charge on a dust grain in plasma . Sharma and Sugawa studied the effect of ion beam on dust charge fluctuations . It is observed that growth rate of the instability increases with the relative density of negatively charged dust. If dust particle charge is . The quasineutrality condition is given for dust particles by .
4. Electron plasma discharge oscillation
When electrons are displaced from the equilibrium position of the charged particles relative to the uniform background of the ions in plasma, an electric field is developed in such a direction that it tries to pull the electrons back to its equilibrium position to restore the neutrality. Because of the inertia effect, the electrons overshoot the equilibrium position, and now the electric field is developed in the opposite direction which again tries to pull back the electrons to their position of equilibrium. The massive ions are supposed to be fixed in the background and are not capable to respond the oscillating field generated by the oscillation of electrons. If is the number of electrons per unit volume in infinite sheet plasma of thickness
5. Plasma oscillation when the motion of ions is also taken into account
Let and are the displacement from the equilibrium positions of electrons and ions, respectively, then the equation of motions is
By combining the above equations, we obtain
Therefore the frequency of oscillation is
5.1 Frequency of oscillation for pair plasma
The pair plasma comprise of particles with opposite charge but equal mass, which gives plasma frequency .
6. Concept of plasma resistivity
The equation of motion for electron in unmagnetized cold plasma can be given by the equation . In a steady state, the collisional friction balances the electric acceleration, and the above equation results to . Since electrons move with respect to the ions, they carry the current density . Substituting the current density into electric field equation yields . Here we have defined the plasma resistivity . Therefore plasma resistivity depends on the collision frequency between the neutral particles with plasma species.
7. Plasma model and basic equations
A Hall thruster with two-component plasma consisting of ions and electrons is considered in which only the electrons are magnetized and the ions are not. For the case of simplicity, the presence of dust particles has been ignored; otherwise the mathematical expression would become cumbersome. In order to realize the exact behaviour and the consequences of finite temperature on the thruster efficiency, it is of much importance to investigate the plasma disturbances in Hall thrusters by including the finite temperatures of the plasma species.
As discussed in Section 1, the electrons experience force along the azimuthal direction, and ions are accelerated along the exit side of the device to produce thrust by the external electric field. We use the common symbols to write the continuity and equation of motion for the ions and electrons under the thermal effects of ion and electron pressure gradient forces. The collision momentum transfer frequency () between the electrons and neutral atoms is also taken into account to see the resistive effects in the plasma:
8. Linearization of fluid equations
We consider the perturbed densities for ions and electrons as and velocities as and indicated by subscript 1 along with their unperturbed values as and in the X and Y directions respectively. The unperturbed part represents the state of the plasma in the absence of oscillations and is indicated by a subscript 0. The unperturbed density is taken as , the electric field (magnetic field) as () and the perturbed value of the electric field (magnetic field) as (). To linearize all the equations, let us write , , and . In view of small variations of both the density and magnetic field along the channel, the plasma inhomogeneities are neglected. The perturbations of the ion and electron densities are taken small enough so that the collisional effect due to the velocity perturbations dominate over the one due to the density perturbation. Since and are constant, the terms , and are equal to zero. Further the terms and are neglected as they are quadratic in perturbation. The linearized form of the above equations thus reads
The initial drifts and of the ions and electrons in the channel are related to the electric and magnetic fields according to and obtained from the unperturbed part of Eqs. (7) and (9). The electron pressure in Eqs. (9) and (13) is given by together with as the electron temperature, which we consider to be constant, and as the ratio of specific heats.
9. Dispersion equation and growth rate of electrostatic oscillations
Since, we are only interested in electrostatic oscillations, and therefore in the meanwhile, the perturbed magnetic field can be ignored in Eq. (13). By using Fourier analysis in Eq. (10) and Eq. (13), the perturbed ion and electron densities are given as follows:
Using Eq. (11) into Eq. (14) gives
where we used .
The expression for the electron density contains the velocity components and , which are derived in terms of the potential under the assumption , and in view of the oscillations observed in Hall thrusters [13, 22, 23]. Letting , , , and .
we use Eq. (13) to write the velocity components
Further simplification gives
With the above velocity components, the perturbed electron density can be expressed in terms of perturbed potential as follows:
Finally, we use the expressions for the perturbed ion density and electron density in Poisson’s equation in order to obtain
Since the perturbed potential is , we have from Eq. (21)
This is the dispersion relation that governs the electrostatic waves in the Hall thruster’s channel.
9.1 The limiting case
For smaller oscillations, that is, , the above relation yields
Now, using the conditions and in the above equation and letting ,
Since the last terms in the second brackets of the numerator and denominator in the right-hand side of Eq. (25) are small, we obtain the following
10. Instability analysis
The roots of the above polynomial may be real and/or complex number. For a real root, sinusoidal behaviour gives showing an oscillatory behaviour. For complex roots which always occur in complex conjugate, we write , where and are real numbers and the sinusoidal behaviour becomes which is showing an exponentially growing wave for a positive value of or an exponentially damped wave for a negative value of . Since the complex roots always appear in a conjugate pair, i.e. we have both negative and positive values of simultaneously. Hence, for the complex roots, one of the waves is always unstable.
Finally, the growth rate of the resistive instability is calculated from Eq. (26) as below:
The corresponding real frequency is obtained as
From Eq. (27), it is obvious that growth rate is directly proportional to the collisional (dissipative effects) frequency of the electrons which depends on various plasma parameters.
The results obtained in Eq. (27) matches with Litvak and Fisch  when the thermal effects become ignorable (i.e. ). Under this situation, the growth rate takes the form
In terms of lower hybrid frequency and in the limit , the growth rate can be written as .
The above relation matches with Eq. (21) of .
Since it is not possible to find an analytical solution of the above equation, we look for the numerical solution along with typical values of , , , ,, and . In Hall plasma thrusters, these parameters can have the values as thruster channel diameter = 4–10 cm, G, /m3, eV, ∼ m/s, ∼/s and m/s [6, 7, 8, 9, 10]. With regard to the value of , we constraint (where is the radius of thruster channel) together with for the azimuthal mode propagation [6, 7]. Accordingly we set /m; however, for higher mode (m > 1) or larger value of , the wavelength would be much smaller than the azimuthal dimension of the channel. The variations of the resistive growth rate are seen in the figures by solving Eq. (23) numerically. Some propagating modes and instabilities with smaller growth are also observed during the analysis of Eq. (23).
Figure 3 confirms that the growth rate of the instability gets enhanced with the increase of collision frequency of the electrons due to the resistive coupling of the oscillations to the electron azimuthal drift. The growth rate also increases with the increase of the electron temperature (Figure 4), and it also increases with higher electron density of plasma. Therefore it can be concluded that the collisional effect is responsible to unstable the plasma system. The numerical value of the growth under the collision frequency is observed in the order of ∼/s.
In conclusions, we can say that the waves propagating in azimuthal and axial direction in a Hall thruster channel become unstable due to the resistive coupling to the electrons’ flow in the presence of their collisions. By controlling the various parameters, the growth rate and the propagating frequency of the oscillation may be controlled to optimize the performance and lifetime of the device.
The University Grants Commission (UGC), New Delhi, India, is thankfully acknowledged for providing the startup grant (No. F. 30-356/2017/BSR).
Ahedo E. Plasmas for space propulsion. Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion. 2011; 53(12):124037. DOI: 10.1088/0741-3335/53/12/124037
Kaufman HR. Technology of closed-drift thrusters. AIAA Journal. 2012; 23(1):78-86. DOI: 10.2514/3.8874
Singh S, Malik HK. Resistive instabilities in a Hall thruster under the presence of collisions and thermal motion of electrons. The Open Plasma Physics Journal. 2011; 4:16-23. DOI: 10.2174/1876534301104010016
Boeuf JP, Garrigues LJ. Low frequency oscillations in a stationary plasma thruster. Journal of Applied Physics. 1998; 84(7):3541-3554. DOI: 10.1063/1.36852
Choueiri EY. Plasma oscillations in Hall thrusters. Physics of Plasmas. 2001; 8(4):1411-1426. DOI: 10.1063/1.1354644
Litvak AA, Fisch NJ. Resistive instabilities in Hall current plasma discharge. Physics of Plasmas. 2001; 8(2):648-651. DOI: 10.1063/1.1336531
Singh S, Malik HK, Nishida Y. High frequency electromagnetic resistive instability in a Hall thruster under the effect of ionization. Physics of Plasmas. 2013; 20:102109
Malik HK, Singh S. Resistive instability in a Hall plasma discharge under ionization effect. Physics of Plasmas. 2013; 20:052115
Fernandez E, Scharfe MK, Thomas CA, Gascon N, Cappelli MA. Growth of resistive instabilities in E×B plasma discharge simulations. Physics of Plasmas. 2008; 15:012102
Litvak AA, Fisch NJ. Rayleigh instability in Hall thrusters. Physics of Plasmas. 2004; 11:1379-1382
Ducrocq A, Adam JC, Heron A, Laval G. High-frequency electron drift instability in the cross-field configuration of Hall thrusters. Physics of Plasmas. 2006; 13:102111
Barral S, Ahedo E. Low-frequency model of breathing oscillations in Hall discharges. Physical Review E. 2009; 79:046401
Chesta E, Meezan NB, Cappelli MA. Stability of a magnetized Hall plasma discharge. Journal of Applied Physics. 2001; 89:3099-3107
Resendes DP. Dipolar interaction in a colloidal plasma. Physical Review E. 2000; 61(1):793
Resendes DP, Mendonca JT, Shukla PK. Formation of dusty plasma molecules. Physics Letters A. 1998; 239(3):181-186
Resendes DP, Shukla PK. Self-excited oscillations of charged dust grains in the plasma sheath. Physica Scripta. 2001; T89:101
Rosenberg M. Ion-and dust-acoustic instabilities in dusty plasmas. Planetary and Space Science. 1993; 41(3):229-233
Rosenberg M. Ion-dust streaming instability in processing plasmas. Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology, A: Vacuum, Surfaces, and Films. 1996; 14(2):631-633
Salimullah M, Shukla PK. On the stability of self-gravitating magnetized dusty plasmas. Physics of Plasmas. 1999; 6(3):686-691
Rao NN, Shukla PK, Yu MY. Dust-acoustic waves in dusty plasmas. Planetary and Space Science. 1990; 38(4):543-546
Pandey BP, Avinash K, Dwivedi CB. Jeans instability of a dusty plasma. Physical Review E. 1994; 49(6):5599
Shukla PK, Mamun AA, editors. Handbook of Introduction to Dusty Plasma Physics. Bristol: IOP Publishing; 2002. DOI: 10.1088/0741-3335/44/3/701
Varma RK, Shukla PK, Krishan V. Electrostatic oscillations in the presence of grain-charge perturbations in dusty plasmas. Physical Review E. 1993; 47(5):3612
Cui C, Goree J. Fluctuations of the charge on a dust grain in a plasma. IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science. 1994; 22(2):151-158
Sharma SC, Sugawa M. The effect of dust charge fluctuations on ion cyclotron wave instability in the presence of an ion beam in a plasma cylinder. Physics of Plasmas. 1999; 6(2):444-448