Comparison of the Rct slope values of Au/Fe(III)TMPP electrode for different phenolic analytes.
In this chapter, an impedimetric response of iron (III) porphyrin (Fe(III)TMPP) functionalized on gold transducer towards the detection of three phenolic compounds entitled bisphenol A (BPA), 2,2′-biphenol and catechol has been studied. The bisphenol A that has revealed the best affinity with Fe(III)TMPP membrane has been chosen as the target analyte. For improved sensitivity of Au/Fe(III)TMPP sensor towards BPA, a facile and efficient Au/RGO nanocarbon transducer based on reduced graphene oxide (RGO) has been prepared and used to support Fe(III)TMPP membrane. The obtained Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP structure was characterized by UV–visible (UV–vis) and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) measurements, then applied as electrochemical platform for BPA detection. It has been discovered that the Au/RGO nanocarbon transducer has an amplified electron transfer kinetic compared to unmodified Au transducer. The Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP structure has showed a better affinity towards BPA with a doubled sensitivity compared to that obtained with Au/Fe(III)TMPP electrode. We demonstrated that the Au/RGO nanocarbon transducer not only enhances the electron transfer ability but also serves as a good template for the attachment of Fe(III)TMPP throughπ-π interaction. This study reveals new high-potential of nanocarbon transducer based on RGO for the conception of electrochemical sensors with high sensitivity and short response time.
- iron (III) porphyrin
- reduced graphene oxide
- impedimetric sensor
- nanocarbon transducer
- bisphenol A
Bisphenol A (BPA, 2, 2-bis (4-hydroxy phenyl) propane), is one of the most extensively used industrial compounds in the production of plastics due to its transparent, strong and light characteristics . Till now, BPA has been widely employed as a monomer to synthesize polycarbonate, expoxy resin, polysulfone resin and other various polymer materials . These polymer materials are mostly used to produce storage containers, nursing bottles, thermal papers, medical apparatus, food can linings and supply pipes . However, toxicology studies have shown that BPA is a typical endocrine-disrupting compound (EDC) in which even a low level can mimic and interfere with hormonal activity by interfering with growth and reproductive development [4, 5]. Consequently, the popular use of BPA has raised serious concerns regarding its implications for food safety and environmental health. In fact, BPA can be released from waste plastics, thermal printing papers, compact disks, powder paints, and adhesives into food and water samples at low concentration (ppb level) and will eventually find its way into the human body . Unsurprisingly, BPA was found to be present in many biological fluids such as human blood, serum, and urine . Although many countries have begun to phase out the use of BPA , several of the BPA-containing products that often occupy landfills are still around. This means that BPA will continue to migrate into the environment through runoff and wastewater discharges, eventually contaminating our water resources and food supplies. Therefore, it is still needed to develop a sensitive and simple method for the determination of trace amounts of BPA in the environment. Notably, multiple procedures have been utilized for determining the contents of BPA in diverse matrices, including liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry , electrochemiluminescence, colorimetry, liquid chromatography coupled to UV/vis, fluorescence spectrometry, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) , surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS)  and so forth. These methods can offer good accuracy and sensitivity, however they have some drawbacks, such as high-cost equipment, time consuming operation and unsuitability for onsite analysis [11, 12], thus restricting their application. On contrary, electrochemical sensors have been extensively used as an alternative solution for detecting trace levels of BPA due to their inherent advantages such as low cost, short analysis time, portability and excellent sensitivity . Direct monitor BPA using an electrochemical sensor with a bare electrode has a poor response due to fouling and sluggish electron transfer kinetics . In order to avoid and reduce this problem, several kinds of nanomaterials or their composites with excellent catalytic properties have been employed to modify the electrode. Amongst such materials, porphyrins and their derivatives have been long employed in electrochemical sensors applications  thanks to their special electrochemical properties . These latter originated from the highly -conjugated system of porphyrin which is an efficient platform for electron transfer . Indeed, porphyrins are naturally occurring macrocyclic species that bind metals
2. Experimental procedure
The triflato iron porphyrin (Fe(III)TMPP) has been synthesized and characterized by proton NMR and FTIR according to the previously reported procedure . The reduced graphene oxide (RGO) has been synthesized and characterized by FTIR and XPS as described previously . Carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) used in this study, have been obtained commercially from Baytubes, and produced in a high-yield catalytic process based on chemical vapor deposition (CVD). The diameter of these MWCNTs varies between 5 and 20 nm with a length of over 1 mm. Gold transducer (bare Au), indium tin oxide (ITO), phosphate-buffered saline tablets (PBS, pH = 7.4), acetone (≥ 99.5%), dimethylformamide (DMF, 99.8%), ethanol (≥99.9%), bisphenol A (BPA, ≥99%), catechol (≥99%) and 2,2′-biphenol (99%) were purchased from Sigma Aldrich (France).
2.2 Instruments and characterization methods
Electrochemical measurements were performed using an AUTOLAB PGSTAT 100 (supported by “FRA 4.9” software (Methrom)) coupled to a computer and an electrochemical cell (Figure 1). The electrochemical measurements were carried out in an electrochemical cell involving a three electrodes system purchased from BASi: bare Au (surface 2.01 × 10−2 cm2) or modified Au with Fe(III)TMPP or RGO/Fe(III)TMPP membranes as the working electrode, Ag/AgCl (3 M KCl) as the reference electrode and platinum wire as the counter electrode. The analyses were performed by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). The modified Au transducer is normally placed in a 0.1 M phosphate buffer solution (PBS (0.1 M), pH = 7) containing target species such as bisphenol A, 2,2′-biphenol and catechol and then simply followed by fixing the potential. All experiments were conducted at ambient temperature (25°C).
EIS was measured at −0.9 V using an alternating potential of 10 mV amplitude in the frequency range from 100 kHz to 30 mHz.
The UV–vis spectra have been recorded with a Win ASPECT PLUS (validation for SPECORD PLUS version 4.2) spectrometer using a 100 μl quartz cell.
2.3 Preparation and measurement of electrochemical sensor
The used gold electrodes in this work have a dimension of 1 cm × 1 cm, where the thickness of the gold deposited by evaporation on Si/SiO2 substrates is of the order of 50 nm . Before the analysis, in order to improve the adhesion of the sensitive membrane on the electrode surface, the gold substrates were cleaned with acetone in an ultrasonic bath for 10 min and dried under nitrogen flow. Then, the gold substrate has been cleaned in piranha solution (1/3 H2O2 + 2/3 H2SO4) for about 2 min to activate the surface , after this treatment, the gold substrates were rinsed with ultra-pure water and dried under nitrogen flow.
For the preparation of Au/Fe(III)TMPP sensor, the pretreated gold was drop-casted by 20 μL of Fe(III)TMPP solution (4.7 mg in 500 μl DMF) and dried at 80°C in an oven for 1 h to evaporate residual solvent. The obtained modified electrode was then rinsed with distilled water to remove the non- attached Fe(III)TMPP and dried under nitrogen flow.
The nanocomposites 2%CNTs/Fe(III)TMPP and 4%CNTs/Fe(III)TMPP were prepared by mixing 4.7 mg of Fe(III)TMPP and different weight proportions of CNTs (2% and 4%) in 500 μl of DMF followed by sonication in an ultrasonic bath for 2 hours. Then, 20 μl of each nanocomposite solution was dropped onto the Au electrode, dried at 80°C in an oven for 1 h and rinsed with distilled water prior to electrochemical measurements.
For the construction of Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP sensor, the preparation was divided into two steps. In the first step, the pretreated gold was drop-casted by 20 μL of RGO solution (1 mg in 1 ml DMF) and dried at 80°C in an oven for 1 h. The obtained Au/RGO nanocarbon transducer electrode was rinsed with distilled water to remove the non-adsorbed materials. In the second step, 20 μl of Fe(III)TMPP solution was deposited onto the Au/RGO electrode by drop-casted method. After being dried and washed, the Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP modified electrode was ready to be used for electrochemical measurements.
ITO/Fe(III)TMPP and ITO/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP electrodes were prepared using the same procedure for Au/Fe(III)TMPP and Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP sensors preparations respectively.
3. BPA sensor based on usual transducer functionalized by Fe(III)TMPP
In order to check the attachment of the Fe(III)TMPP on the bare Au electrode, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) has been selected as a method of characterization thanks to the interfacial charge transfer properties that it can provide for the electrode surface during the modification process [30, 31].
Usually for EIS studies, the first step is to optimize the polarization potential by reducing the warburg diffusion component at low frequencies, which facilitates the interpretation of physico-chemical phenomena . For our study, different negative potentials (E = −0.6 V, −0.7 V, −0.8 V and − 0.9 V) have been applied in a large frequency range (100 kHz to 30 mHz). We observe in Figure 2 an obvious decrease of the half circle diameter correlated with the decrease of the applied potential. This decrease can be explained by the reduction of the charge transfer resistance as a function of the
Figure 3 shows the recorded Nyquist plots for bare Au before and after its modification by Fe(III)TMPP membrane in a PBS solution without any additional external redox probe. The semicircle diameter is related to the charge transfer resistance (Rct) of the electronic transfer from the porphyrin to the electrode . Upon the modification of the Au transducer using Fe(III)TMPP membrane, the semicircle diameter increased, which means the increase of Rct. This is indicative of a better Au electrode surface coverage with Fe(III)TMPP accompanied by the decrease in the electronic charge transfer.
The Nyquist diagram of Au/Fe(III)TMPP electrode can be modeled by an equivalent electrical circuit formed by electrical components. This modeling is done thanks to a software “FRA2” which makes it possible to draw the proposed equivalent electrical circuit optimized by iteration. The choice of the latter is made according to the best fit which corresponds to the lowest value of the total error 𝜒2 as well as the error on each parameter. The values of the electrical components given for each Nyquist plot illustrate the electronic properties between the transducer/membrane/electrolyte interfaces which facilitate the interpretation of the electronic phenomena during the modification process.
In this study, the choice of the equivalent electric circuit was chosen based on the shape of the Nyquist diagram of the Au/Fe(III)TMPP electrode as well as on its corresponding bode diagram (Figure 4). As can be seen in Figure 4A, the total impedance plot of the Au/Fe(III)TMPP electrode has an enlarged shape. Consequently the Nyquist diagram of the modified electrode can be considered as an overlap of two closely interacting semicircles  which can indicate the presence of more than one dipole in the equivalent electrical circuit model . Figure 4B shows the bode diagram fit of Au/Fe(III)TMPP electrode. This figure reveals that phase plot presents one phase pic maxima. Consequently, the equivalent electric circuit is analyzed as one dipole . Taking into account the interpretation of Nyquist and bode diagrams of Au/Fe(III)TMPP, the best circuit that has been chosen is shown in Figure 5. This circuit has shown the best fit with low total error 𝜒2. This circuit consists of an electrolyte resistance denoted Rs placed in series with one electrical dipole which divides itself into two dipoles. The first dipole is formed by (Rm, CPE1) corresponding to the first high frequency loop and describes the electrochemical phenomena occurring at the electrolyte/membrane interface where Rm is the resistance of the membrane and CPE1 is called the constant phase element. The second dipole is made up by (Rct, CPE2) describing the second loop at low frequencies and describes the electrochemical phenomena occurring at the membrane/electrode interface where Rct represents the charge transfer resistance at the membrane/electrode interface.
In our previous optical study, Fe(III)TMPP was able to detect BPA molecules through the strong coordination ability of Fe(III) cation to oxygen atoms . Thus, in this study, the Au/Fe(III)TMPP electrode has been used to test its ability towards the impedimetric detection of BPA and 2 other interferent molecules. These interfering molecules are 2,2-'biphenol and catechol, which have a structure similar to BPA. The choice of EIS technique to detect these phenolic compounds was made because of its several advantages, such as simplicity, label-free, high sensitivity, and serving as a way to interface recognition events and signal transduction.
BPA is an electron-rich system favorable for the strong interaction with porphyrin ring. Hence, we explore the use of the electrostatic interaction between BPA and cell porphyrin membrane without using any external redox indicator. Thus the detection is directly proportional to the change in the electrical properties of the electroactive Fe(III)TMPP membrane. Figure 6 shows the Nyquist plot of Au/Fe(III)TMPP for different BPA, 2,2-‘biphenol and catechol concentrations (from 10−12 to 10−7 M). Au/Fe(III)TMPP electrode shows a large increase in diameter of the semicircle, after BPA, 2,2’-biphenol and catechol attachment, correlated with their increasing concentrations, indicating much higher Rct values. This increase can be associated with the multilayer adsorption of BPA, 2,2′-biphenol and catechol molecules on the surface of Fe(III)TMPP membrane, which leads to the modification of electrochemical properties at the interface.
To confirm this mechanism of detection, the electrochemical proprieties of the sensor have been quantified by fitting the Nyquist plots using the equivalent circuit shown in Figure 5. The different fits are done with a total error value (χ2) less than 10−3. Figure 7 shows the variation of the membrane resistance Rm as a function of the BPA, 2,2′-biphenol and catechol concentrations cologarithm p[X] = −log[CX], where X = BPA, 2,2′-biphenol and catechol. We can observe that the value of Rm increases when increasing the concentration of the three studied analytes. This result indicates an increase in the thickness of the Fe(III)TMPP membrane, which is proportional to Rm according to the following Eq. (1).
Where d is the membrane thickness,
Consequently, the increase of the thickness of the Fe(III)TMPP membrane correlated with the increase of BPA, 2,2′-biphenol and catechol concentrations proves the adsorption of these molecules on the surface of the Fe(III)TMPP membrane through their π electron system .
To fully understand the charge transfer kinetics at the interfaces, the Rct values after BPA, 2,2′-biphenol and catechol attachment were obtained from the equivalent circuit model and used to generate Figure 8. This figure describes the evolution of the charge transfer resistance Rct characteristic of the Au/Fe(III)TMPP interface, as a function of the logarithm of the concentration of BPA, 2,2′-biphenol and catechol. We report, from the curve of Rct = f (p [X]), that the charge transfer resistance increased with the increase of BPA, 2,2′-biphenol and catechol concentrations leading to down the electron transfer to Au/Fe(III)TMPP electrode. This is due to the steric hindrance favored by the multi layers adsorption of the target molecules, which seems logical since it has been shown from Eq. (1) that the sensitive membrane thickness has already increased upon the increasing of the analyte concentrations.
The Rct slope values of the Au transducer coated by Fe(III)TMPP membrane for the impedimetric detection of BPA, 2,2′-biphenol and catechol are illustrated in Table 1. As can be seen, the slope associated with the catechol molecule has a lower value, whereas the slope associated with BPA and 2,2′-biphenol molecules has a higher value. These results show a better sensitivity of Fe(III)TMPP towards BPA molecules. This can be explained by the higher number of aromatic groups in the structures of BPA and 2,2′-biphenol than in the structure of catechol (Figure 9). According to these results, we have chosen BPA as the target molecule for Fe(III)TMPP membrane throughout our next measurements.
|Sensitive membrane||Analytes||Rct slope (k/decade)|
4. BPA sensor based on carbon nanotubes/Fe(III)TMPP nanocomposite
In order to enhance the sensitivity of the Fe(III)TMPP towards the detection of BPA, carbon nanotubes (CNTs) has been used to dope iron (III) porphyrin as it has attracted considerable interest due to its excellent electrochemical properties and its high ability to amplify the detection signal [38, 39]. Hence, Fe(III)TMPP was doped by 2% CNTs and 4% CNTs, then the obtained 2% CNTs/Fe(III)TMPP and 4%CNTs/Fe(III)TMPP nanocomposites have been used for the detection of different concentrations of BPA (Figure 10). As can be seen, the Nyquist plots of 2%CNTs/Fe(III)TMPP and 4%CNTs/Fe(III)TMPP modified Au electrodes show a very small variation with increasing BPA concentrations. This result shows that the doping of porphyrin by CNTs did not improve its sensitivity towards the detection of BPA molecules. This can be explained by the planar structure of Fe(III)TMPP making difficult the -interaction with the rolled up tubular structure of CNT (Figure 11). These results led us to think about improving the sensitivity of the Au/Fe(III)TMPP sensor using another carbon material having a 2D planar structure which can make easier the -interaction with Fe(III)TMPP and preserves its structure. Because of its fascinating electronic properties and extremely high specific surface area, this chosen carbon material is known as reduced graphene oxide (RGO), a graphene derivate that has attracted a lot of attention in improving the sensing ability of BPA sensors .
5. BPA sensor based on nanocarbon transducer functionalized by Fe(III)TMPP
After proving the good affinity of Fe(III)TMPP towards BPA molecules, we aim to improve the sensitivity of Au/Fe(III)TMPP sensor by involving the use of nano-sized electrodes based on nanocarbon transducers. Hence, owing to its strong electrocatalytic activity and minimal surface fouling, RGO has been chosen as a nanocarbon material to functionalize it on Au electrode to form a new Au/RGO nanocarbon transducer with enhanced charge transfer ability than the Au transducer. Then, the Au/RGO nanocarbon transducer has been prepared and functionalized with Fe(III)TMPP membrane to form Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP platform.
With the objective of highlighting the interaction between the Fe(III)TMPP and the Au/RGO nanocarbon transducer, UV/vis has been used. Hence, the prepared ITO/RGO, ITO/Fe(III)TMPP and ITO/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP electrodes were characterized by UV–vis (Figure 12). As shown in Figure 12, the UV/vis absorption spectrum of ITO/Fe(III)TMPP exhibits a strong peak at 438 nm and a weak peak at 527 nm ascribed to the Soret band and the Q-band of porphyrin respectively. After we have deposited the Fe(III)TMPP on ITO/RGO, we have observed a decrease in the Soret and Q band intensities with a red shift from 438 nm to 431 nm for the Soret band and the Q-band shift from 527 nm to 536 nm. These shifts prove the strong π-π interactions between the aromatic rings of RGO and the Fe(III)TMPP macrocycles [41, 42]. These results confirm the formation of the graphene–porphyrin complex, being in agreement with the proposed hypothesis of the easier interaction of the flattened structure of porphyrin with the 2D surface of graphene (Figure 13).
Bare Au, Au/Fe(III)TMPP, Au/RGO and Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP electrodes have been characterized by EIS in PBS (0.1 M, pH = 7) with an optimized potential of −0.9 V (Figure 14).
As shown in Figure 14, the total impedance plot of Au/RGO shows a semi cercle with a diameter smaller than obtained with bare Au. Consequently, the Rct value of Au/RGO decreased compared to that of bare Au. This result proves that the fabricated Au/RGO nanocarbon transducer has improved charge transfer ability than the usual transducer (Bare Au) thanks to the electron catalyst role of RGO. As illustrated in Figure 14, the impedance plot of Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP structure presents a very smaller semi cercle diameter compared to Au/Fe(III)TMPP electrode which is explained by smaller Rct value for Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP, thus better charge transfer ability at the interface electrode/electrolyte. This result demonstrates that the Au/RGO nanocarbon transducer ensured the good attachment of the porphyrin on its surface via π-π interaction as we have proved by UV–visible which leads to enhanced kinetic charge transfer of the Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP structure.
The Nyquist diagram of Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP electrode, as shown in Figure 15, reveals the presence of a small semicircle at high frequency, corresponding to a small phase pic maxima in the phase diagram, and a large second semicircle at low frequency, corresponding to an intense phase pic maxima in the phase diagram. Hence, the proposed equivalent electrical circuit should be composed by more than one dipole . The best fit was done using an equivalent electrical circuit formed by a parallel association of two dipoles placed in series with the electrolyte resistance (Rs) (Figure 16). The first dipole, which is attributed to the high frequency loop and the electrochemical phenomena occurring at the electrolyte
The sensing properties of Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP electrode towards BPA concentrations in PBS electrolyte have been studied and presented in Figure 17. The semicircle diameter related to the charge transfer resistance (Rct) from the RGO/Fe(III)TMPP to the electrode is observed to increase upon the addition of BPA concentration. This considerable dependance affirms the high affinity of Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP sensor towards BPA molecules.
The electrical parameters values of Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP electrode after BPA attachment were obtained from the equivalent circuit model presented in Figure 16. Then a comparative study of Rm and Rct variations versus p[BPA] for Au/Fe(III)TMPP and Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP electrodes has been studied (Figure 18).
As can be observed in Figure 18, Rm and Rct variations increase with the successive addition of BPA concentration for the Au/Fe(III)TMPP and Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP electrodes. This result confirms the adsorption mechanism of BPA on the surface of the two modified electrodes, resulting in an increase of their thickness membranes correlated with a decrease of the electron transfer ability at the membrane/electrode interface. The slope of Rm and Rct variations curves versus p[BPA] for Au/Fe(III)TMPP and Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP electrodes are summarized in Table 2. This table shows that the slopes of Rm and Rct variations curves obtained with Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP electrode are 2 times higher than those obtained with Au/Fe(III)TMPP electrode. This result proves the doubled sensitivity with the Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP electrode towards BPA. This improved sensitivity comes from the catalyst role of RGO  which has created a nanocarbon transducer with enhanced electrical property and signal transfer. Based on the calibration curve (Figure 18B), the sensitivity (slope of the calibration curve) of our proposed sensor Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP was found to be 0.4218 per decade with an intercept of 5.6509. The correlation regression coefficient was obtained at 0.9987 in the concentration range from 10−12 M to 10−8 M. The detection limit of the sensor was estimated to be 2.1 10−13 M (signal-to-noise ratio of 3 independent measurements).
|Electrodes||Slope of Rm variation||Slope of Rct variation|
6. Comparative study
Because of the biologically harmful and toxicologically relevant of BPA even at low doses, researchers are competing to develop a new electrochemical sensor to track low BPA levels. Table 3 illustrates a comparison of the analytical performances between our BPA sensor based on RGO nanocarbon transducer (Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP) and other recently reported BPA sensors. Alam et al. reported graphene oxide and β-cyclodextrin functionalized multiwalled carbon nanotubes (GO-MWCNT-βCD) for the detection of BPA at nanomolar level (6 nM) with good reproducibility (n = 3) and a two-step linear response from 0.05 to 5 μM and 5–30 μM . The GO-MWCNT-βCD modified screen-printed electrode (SPE) showed the highest oxidation peak current of 49.4 μA at Epa of 595 mV for BPA, which is at least 1.6 times higher than other modified SPEs. This was explained by the synergistic effect between GO, MWCNT and βCD leading to a fast electron transfer kinetics, consequently an amplified signal detection of BPA. Wan et al. reported an eco-friendly electrochemical sensor based on Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotubes (MWCNT)/Polythiophene(PTh)/Pt nanocomposites-modified glassy carbon electrode for determination of BPA molecules in aqueous media . The working electrode captures BPA electrochemically and consequently gets adsorbed on the MWCNT-PTh-Pt electrode surface electrode followed by electrochemical oxidation by differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) with the increased oxidation current at 0.5 V. This affinity was explained by the Pt nanocluster that acted as a suitable catalyst of MWCNT-PTh nanocomposite and enhanced the electrochemical detection signal of BPA. Moreover, this sensor platform revealed linear response for BPA detection from 0.005 to 0.4 μM in phosphate buffer saline (PBS) solution and the detection limit was found to be 0.003 μM (S/N = 3). Ponnaiah et al. designed a GCE modified with a new nanocomposite composed of ruthenium nanoparticles, polyaniline and graphitic carbon nitride (Ru0/PANI/g-C3N4) as an electrochemical sensor for the detection of BPA . The sensor system exhibits picomolar-level detection limits, good sensitivity and stability with a detection range from 0.01 to 1.1 μM. This result was explained by the synergistic effect of the nanocomposite: the high activity of ruthenium nanoparticles, the porous structure of the conducting PANI and the catalyst role of g-C3N4 that created an amplified detection system. Jiang et al. reported the development of electrochemical sensors based on carbon nanomaterials, i.e. nanodiamond (ND/GCE) and nanocarbon (NC/GCE) . These carbon materials have achieved a good sensitivity towards BPA monitored by Square Wave Voltammetry (SWV) thanks to their low fouling properties and porous structures. The limit of detection of the proposed sensor was at the nanomolar level with an acceptable liner range from 0.1 to 80 μM. Tsekeli et al. reported the synthesis of silver nanoparticle-exfoliated graphite nanocomposite (AgNPs-EG) for the application of BPA sensor . The AgNPs-EG nanocomposite-based electrode has demonstrated antifouling property and acceptable affinity towards BPA with LOD of 0.23 μM and a linear range from 5.0 to 100 μM.
|Sensor material||Detection method||LOD (μM)||Linear range (μM)||Preparation method of the sensor||Reference|
|GO-MWCNT-βCD/SPE||LSV||6||0.05–5/5–30||Covalent modification of MWCNTs with βCD/ drop casting of GO-MWCNT-βCD|
suspension on SPE
|MWCNT/PTh/Pt/GCE||DPV||3.0 × 10−3||0.005–0.4||Electrodeposition of MWCNT-PTh-Pt on GCE|||
|Ru0/PANI@g-C3N4||DPV||0.18 × 10−3||0.01–1.1||Long time ultrasonication of the Ru0/PANI/g-C3N4 nanocomposite /drop casting of Ru0/PANI/g-C3N4 suspension on GCE|||
|ND-GCE||SWV||13 × 10−3||0.1–80||Ultrasonication of ND in water followed by drop casting on GCE|||
|AgNPs-EG||SWV||0.23||5.0–100||Long term preparation of AgNPs-EG electrode|||
|Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP||EIS||2.1 × 10−7||10−6–10−2||Simple and fast ultrasonication of RGO and Fe(III)TMPP/drop casting deposition of RGO and Fe(III)TMPP on Au electrode respectively||This work|
Compared with all these recently reported BPA sensors (Table 3), our work based on Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP sensor presents the best sensing platform because of its lower limit of detection in the picomolar level (2.1 10−7 μM) and wider linear range spreading from 10−6 to 10−2 μM. Hence, the sensor based on nanocarbon transducer functionalized by Fe(III)TMPP presented in this work is capable of measuring BPA at concentrations lower than the daily dose limits set by recent medical advice. In addition to a lower detection limit and wide detection range, our fabrication method is based only on drop-casting and drying, which is more facile and less time consuming than other methods. Furthermore, the modification of our sensor is based on non-covalent bonding which preserves the sp2 structures of each membrane, leading to a good stability of the BPA response signal. Another advantage of our proposed sensor was that, in our work, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy was used to follow the detection signal of BPA, while it was rarely used compared to DPV and SWV methods to monitor the attachment of BPA on the sensor surface. The advantage of the EIS method compared to the most frequently used SWV and DPV methods is that it does not damage the electrode surface and also enables low detection limits .We envisage that such sensors are promising tools to face the challenges of the detection of BPA at trace level in aqueous media, as an alternative to the conventional test or central lab equipment.
The better sensing performance of our sensor based on Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP could be attributed to different aspects such as the architecture of the modified electrode that is based on Au/RGO nanocarbon transducer for immobilized Fe(III)TMPP to retain its stability and activity which can facilitate the reaction towards BPA. Moreover, the high electric conductivity of RGO nanocarbon material can create a novel nanocarbon transducer with higher kinetic charge transfer compared to usual used transducers which facilitates the mediation of electrocommunication between the BPA and the electrode.
In this chapter, a label-free impedimetric sensor using Au/RGO nanocarbon transducer functionalized by Fe(III)TMPP has been successfully designed for the detection of trace BPA. The Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP electrode was fabricated by loading RGO and Fe(III)TMPP membrane on Au transducer, respectively. The Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP sensor has demonstrated an amplified response towards BPA compared to that of Au/Fe(III)TMPP electrode. This enhancement was attributed to the Au/RGO nanocarbon transducer which acted as a charge transfer catalyst and good platform for the attachment of Fe(III)TMPP via -staking. The suggested Au/RGO/Fe(III)TMPP has offered a few advantages compared to the previously reported strategy for the determination of BPA, including excellent low LOD (2.1 10−13 M) and wide linear dynamic range with a simple and efficient fabrication method. The findings from this study will be valuable for constructing highly sensitive sensors based on modified Au/RGO nanocarbon transducer to detect various substances with low concentration and trace amount.
Lee E-H, Lim HJ, Lee S-D, Son A. Highly Sensitive Detection of Bisphenol A by NanoAptamer Assay with Truncated Aptamer. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces 2017;9:14889–98. https://doi.org/10.1021/acsami.7b02377
Liu Y, Yao L, He L, Liu N, Piao Y. Electrochemical Enzyme Biosensor Bearing Biochar Nanoparticle as Signal Enhancer for Bisphenol A Detection in Water. Sensors (Basel) 2019;19. https://doi.org/10.3390/s19071619
Kazane I, Gorgy K, Gondran C, Spinelli N, Zazoua A, Defrancq E, et al. Highly Sensitive Bisphenol-A Electrochemical Aptasensor Based on Poly(Pyrrole-Nitrilotriacetic Acid)-Aptamer Film. Anal Chem 2016;88:7268–73. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.analchem.6b01574
Manna B. Rational functionalization of reduced graphene oxide with an imidazole group for the electrochemical sensing of bisphenol A - an endocrine disruptor. Analyst 2018;143:3451–7. https://doi.org/10.1039/c8an00642c
Zainul R, Abd Azis N, Md Isa I, Hashim N, Ahmad MS, Saidin MI, et al. Zinc/Aluminium–Quinclorac Layered Nanocomposite Modified Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotube Paste Electrode for Electrochemical Determination of Bisphenol A. Sensors 2019;19:941. https://doi.org/10.3390/s19040941
Li X, Huang Y, Chen M, Tong Y, Zhang C. A label-free electrochemical bisphenol A immunosensor based on chlorogenic acid as a redox probe. Anal Methods 2017;9:2183–8. https://doi.org/10.1039/C6AY02997C
Song Y, Xu M, Li Z, He L, Hu M, He L, et al. Ultrasensitive detection of bisphenol A under diverse environments with an electrochemical aptasensor based on multicomponent AgMo heteronanostructure. Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical 2020;321:128527. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.snb.2020.128527
Kesavan G, Nataraj N, Chen S-M, Lin L-H. Hydrothermal synthesis of NiFe2O4 nanoparticles as an efficient electrocatalyst for the electrochemical detection of bisphenol A. New J Chem 2020;44:7698–707. https://doi.org/10.1039/D0NJ00608D
Wang X, Li Y, Zhou Y, He Y. Application of a novel endocrine disruptor bisphenol A electrochemical sensor based on analogous heterostructure characteristics of La-doped Yb2O3 nanomaterials. Anal Methods 2019;11:5613–22. https://doi.org/10.1039/C9AY01694E
Ali H, Mukhopadhyay S, Jana NR. Selective electrochemical detection of bisphenol A using a molecularly imprinted polymer nanocomposite. New J Chem 2019;43:1536–43. https://doi.org/10.1039/C8NJ05883K
Lu YC, Xiao WW, Wang JY, Xiong XH. Rapid isolation and determination of bisphenol A in complicated matrices by magnetic molecularly imprinted electrochemical sensing. Anal Bioanal Chem 2021;413:389–401. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00216-020-03006-8
Ben Messaoud N, Ait Lahcen A, Dridi C, Amine A. Ultrasound assisted magnetic imprinted polymer combined sensor based on carbon black and gold nanoparticles for selective and sensitive electrochemical detection of Bisphenol A. Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical 2018;276:304–12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.snb.2018.08.092
Yu Z, Luan Y, Li H, Wang W, Wang X, Zhang Q. A disposable electrochemical aptasensor using single-stranded DNA–methylene blue complex as signal-amplification platform for sensitive sensing of bisphenol A. Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical 2019;284:73–80. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.snb.2018.12.126
Huang X, Huang D, Chen J, Ye R, Lin Q, Chen S. Fabrication of novel electrochemical sensor based on bimetallic Ce-Ni-MOF for sensitive detection of bisphenol A. Anal Bioanal Chem 2020;412:849–60. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00216-019-02282-3
Carbone M, Micheli L, Limosani F, Possanza F, Abdallah Y, Tagliatesta P. Ruthenium and manganese metalloporphyrins modified screen-printed electrodes for bio-relevant electroactive targets. J Porphyrins Phthalocyanines 2018;22:491–500. https://doi.org/10.1142/S1088424618500402
Sakthinathan S, Kubendhiran S, Chen SM, Manibalan K, Govindasamy M, Tamizhdurai P, et al. Reduced Graphene Oxide Non-covalent Functionalized with Zinc Tetra Phenyl Porphyrin Nanocomposite for Electrochemical Detection of Dopamine in Human Serum and Rat Brain Samples. Electroanalysis 2016;28:2126–35. https://doi.org/10.1002/elan.201600085
Mashazi PN, Nombona N, Muchindu M, Vilakazi S. Metallophthalocyanines and metalloporphyrins as electrocatalysts: a case of hydrogen peroxide and glucose detection. J Porphyrins Phthalocyanines 2012;16:741–53. https://doi.org/10.1142/S1088424612300066
Jemmeli D, Mchiri C, Dridi C, Nasri H, Dempsey E. Development of a new bisphenol A electrochemical sensor based on a cadmium(II) porphyrin modified carbon paste electrode. RSC Adv 2020;10:31740–7. https://doi.org/10.1039/D0RA04793G
Negut CC, Staden R-IS- van, Staden JF van. Porphyrins-as Active Materials in the Design of Sensors. An Overview. ECS J Solid State Sci Technol 2020;9:051005. https://doi.org/10.1149/2162-8777/ab9a5d
Salimi A, MamKhezri H, Hallaj R, Zandi S. Modification of glassy carbon electrode with multi-walled carbon nanotubes and iron(III)-porphyrin film: Application to chlorate, bromate and iodate detection. Electrochimica Acta 2007;52:6097–105. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.electacta.2007.03.046
Li J, Tu W, Lei J, Tang S, Ju H. Porphyrin-functionalized gold nanoparticles for selective electrochemical detection of peroxyacetic acid. Electrochimica Acta 2011;56:3159–63. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.electacta.2011.01.060
Wang C, Yuan R, Chai Y, Chen S, Zhang Y, Hu F, et al. Non-covalent iron(III)-porphyrin functionalized multi-walled carbon nanotubes for the simultaneous determination of ascorbic acid, dopamine, uric acid and nitrite. Electrochimica Acta 2012;62:109–15. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.electacta.2011.11.115
Huang N, Liu M, Li H, Zhang Y, Yao S. Synergetic signal amplification based on electrochemical reduced graphene oxide-ferrocene derivative hybrid and gold nanoparticles as an ultra-sensitive detection platform for bisphenol A. Analytica Chimica Acta 2015;853:249–57. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aca.2014.10.016
Kumar DR, Dhakal G, Nguyen VQ, Shim J-J. Molecularly imprinted hornlike polymer@electrochemically reduced graphene oxide electrode for the highly selective determination of an antiemetic drug. Analytica Chimica Acta 2021;1141:71–82. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aca.2020.10.014
Bezzon VDN, Montanheiro TLA, de Menezes BRC, Ribas RG, Righetti VAN, Rodrigues KF, et al. Carbon Nanostructure-based Sensors: A Brief Review on Recent Advances. Advances in Materials Science and Engineering 2019;2019:e4293073. https://doi.org/10.1155/2019/4293073
Zahou I, Hassen LBH, Mlika R, Ben Chaabane R, Nasri H, Ouada HB. Synthesis and investigation on optical and electrical properties of a triflato iron porphyrin: Application as an optical BPA sensor. Synthetic Metals 2016;221:75–85. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.synthmet.2016.07.020
Hsine Z, Bizid S, Mlika R, Sauriat-Dorizon H, Haj Said A, Korri-Youssoufi H. Nanocomposite Based on Poly (para-phenylene)/Chemical Reduced Graphene Oxide as a Platform for Simultaneous Detection of Ascorbic Acid, Dopamine and Uric Acid. Sensors 2020;20:1256. https://doi.org/10.3390/s20051256
Mlika R, Hbaieb S, Ben Chaabene R, Chevalier Y, Kalfat R, Ben Ouada H. Electrochemical properties of gold electrodes functionalized by new pseudo-polyrotaxanes of polyaniline and chemically modified β-cyclodextrin inclusion complex. Synthetic Metals 2012;162:186–92. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.synthmet.2011.11.029
Touzi H, Chevalier Y, Martin M, Ben Ouada H, Jaffrezic-Renault N. Detection of Gadolinium with an Impedimetric Platform Based on Gold Electrodes Functionalized by 2-Methylpyridine-Substituted Cyclam. Sensors 2021;21:1658. https://doi.org/10.3390/s21051658
Erdem A, Congur G, Mayer G. Aptasensor platform based on carbon nanofibers enriched screen printed electrodes for impedimetric detection of thrombin. Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry 2015;758:12–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jelechem.2015.10.002
Mahmoud A, Echabaane M, Omri K, El Mir L, Ben Chaabane R. Development of an impedimetric non enzymatic sensor based on ZnO and Cu doped ZnO nanoparticles for the detection of glucose. Journal of Alloys and Compounds 2019;786:960–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2019.02.060
da Silva W, Ghica ME, Ajayi RF, Iwuoha EI, Brett CMA. Impedimetric sensor for tyramine based on gold nanoparticle doped-poly(8-anilino-1-naphthalene sulphonic acid) modified gold electrodes. Talanta 2019;195:604–12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.talanta.2018.11.054
Bolat G, Vural OA, Yaman YT, Abaci S. Polydopamine nanoparticles-assisted impedimetric sensor towards label-free lung cancer cell detection. Materials Science and Engineering: C 2021;119:111549. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msec.2020.111549
Elgiddawy N, Ren S, Ghattas W, Rouby WMAE, El-Gendy AO, Farghali AA, et al. Antimicrobial Activity of Cationic Poly(3-hexylthiophene) Nanoparticles Coupled with Dual Fluorescent and Electrochemical Sensing: Theragnostic Prospect. Sensors 2021;21:1715. https://doi.org/10.3390/s21051715
Ebdelli R, Rouis A, Mlika R, Bonnamour I, Jaffrezic-Renault N, Ben Ouada H, et al. Electrochemical impedance detection of Hg2+, Ni2+ and Eu3+ ions by a new azo-calixarene membrane. Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry 2011;661:31–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jelechem.2011.07.007
Mlika R, Rouis A, Bonnamour I, Ouada HB. Impedance spectroscopic investigation of the effect of thin azo-calixarene film type on the cation sensitivity of the gold electrodes. Materials Science and Engineering: C 2011;31:1466–71. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msec.2011.05.017
Roales J, Pedrosa JM, Guillén MG, Lopes-Costa T, Pinto SMA, Calvete MJF, et al. Optical detection of amine vapors using ZnTriad porphyrin thin films. Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical 2015;210:28–35. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.snb.2014.12.080
Ali MY, Alam AU, Howlader MMR. Fabrication of highly sensitive Bisphenol A electrochemical sensor amplified with chemically modified multiwall carbon nanotubes and β-cyclodextrin. Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical 2020;320:128319. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.snb.2020.128319
Mo F, Xie J, Wu T, Liu M, Zhang Y, Yao S. A sensitive electrochemical sensor for bisphenol A on the basis of the AuPd incorporated carboxylic multi-walled carbon nanotubes. Food Chemistry 2019;292:253–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodchem.2019.04.034
Akilarasan M, Kogularasu S, Chen S-M, Chen T-W, Lin S-H. One-step synthesis of reduced graphene oxide sheathed zinc oxide nanoclusters for the trace level detection of bisphenol A in tissue papers. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 2018;161:699–705. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2018.06.045
Chen Y, Mei T, Chen Y, Wang J, Li J, Fu Y, et al. A sensitive porphyrin/reduced graphene oxide electrode for simultaneous detection of guanine and adenine. J Solid State Electrochem 2016;20:2055–62. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10008-016-3214-7
Xie H, Li Y-T, Lei Y-M, Liu Y-L, Xiao M-M, Gao C, et al. Real-Time Monitoring of Nitric Oxide at Single-Cell Level with Porphyrin-Functionalized Graphene Field-Effect Transistor Biosensor. Anal Chem 2016;88:11115–22. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.analchem.6b03208
Yang S, Zhang F, Liang Q, Wang Z. A three-dimensional graphene-based ratiometric signal amplification aptasensor for MUC1 detection. Biosensors and Bioelectronics 2018;120:85–92. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bios.2018.08.036
Alam AU, Deen MJ. Bisphenol A Electrochemical Sensor Using Graphene Oxide and β-Cyclodextrin-Functionalized Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotubes. Anal Chem 2020;92:5532–9. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.analchem.0c00402
Wan J, Si Y, Li C, Zhang K. Bisphenol a electrochemical sensor based on multi-walled carbon nanotubes/polythiophene/Pt nanocomposites modified electrode. Anal Methods 2016;8:3333–8. https://doi.org/10.1039/C6AY00850J
Ponnaiah SK, Prakash P, Muthupandian S. Ultrasonic energy-assisted in-situ synthesis of Ru0/PANI/g-C3N4 nanocomposite: Application for picomolar-level electrochemical detection of endocrine disruptor (Bisphenol-A) in humans and animals. Ultrasonics Sonochemistry 2019;58:104629. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ultsonch.2019.104629
Jiang L, Santiago I, Foord J. A comparative study of fouling-free nanodiamond and nanocarbon electrochemical sensors for sensitive bisphenol A detection. Carbon 2021;174:390–5. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2020.11.073
Tsekeli TR, Sebokolodi TI, Karimi-Maleh H, Arotiba OA. A Silver-Loaded Exfoliated Graphite Nanocomposite Anti-Fouling Electrochemical Sensor for Bisphenol A in Thermal Paper Samples. ACS Omega 2021;6:9401–9. https://doi.org/10.1021/acsomega.0c05836
Yaman YT, Vural OA, Bolat G, Abaci S. One-pot synthesized gold nanoparticle- peptide nanotube modified disposable sensor for impedimetric recognition of miRNA 410. Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical 2020;320:128343. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.snb.2020.128343