Iron oxides were synthesized in conditions similar to those that prevail in deeps of the Red Sea (2–5M NaCl, temperatures 60–80°C, and pH 6.5–10.4). The main phase that was crystallized was submicron magnetite. Additional phases of feroxyhyte, goethite, and akagenéite were also detected. Magnetite morphology observed through high-resolution scanning electron microscopy (HRSEM) varied between euhedral plates and octahedral or unhedral crystals. The euhedral plates were probably crystallized pseudomorphically after platy green rust or Fe(OH)2 due to its quick crystallization. Size of magnetite varied between 18 and 45 nm. The addition of Si retarded crystal growth, and at Si/Fe = 0.5, short-range ordered phases are formed and not magnetite. This finding is in line with earlier laboratory experiments in which Si was found to retard goethite and lepidocrocite crystallization.
- hypersaline environment
- goethite lepidocrocite
Synthesis of iron oxides in hypersaline solutions was performed to imitate conditions that prevail in the Dead Sea and in deeps of the Red Sea. Salinity in the Dead Sea reaches 340 g/l. In the Red Sea, hydrothermal hypersaline brine discharges into the Atlantis II Deep with Cl concentrations in the upper layer of the brine at 67 g of Cl per kg of water (67 g/kg) and at the lower layer of the brine, 158 g/kg. The pH value decreases from 8.13 at RSDW to 5.2 at the lower layer . The temperature of the lower layer is ∼68°C measured in 2008 . A narrow channel that connects the southern part of the Atlantis II Deep with the Chain Deeps enables overflowing of the brine of the lower convecting layer to Chain A, B, and C deeps. It was suggested that not only does the overflowing brine feed the adjacent deeps, but a fracture and fissure system enables a sub-bottom flow of the brine of the LCL from the Atlantis II Deep into the Chain and Discovery Deeps, leading to hydrothermal conditions in those deeps [1, 3]. The temperature in Chain A is 52.4–54°C; in Chain B, 46°C; in Chain C, 44.3°C; and in Discovery Deep, 44.7°C [4, 5]. There is no current hydrothermal activity in the Thetis Deep, yet it was active in the past but without a brine that filled the Deep .
Iron oxides (hematite-Fe2O3 and magnetite-Fe3O4), well-crystallized oxyhydroxides (goethite-αFeOOH, lepidocrocite-γFeOOH, feroxyhyte-δFeOOH, and akaganéite-βFeOOH), and short-range ordered oxyhydroxides (ferrihydrite-Fe5HO8·4H2O and singerite-SiFe4O6(OH)4H2O) precipitated in the hypersaline environment of the Dead Sea and in the deeps of the Red Sea (Atlantis II, Chain A, Chain B, Discovery, and Thetis) [7, 8, 9, 10] (Figure 1). Precipitation of these phases occurs at hypersaline environment with elevated temperatures and varying pH. Morphology of the crystals and their size is observed by high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM). Using electron diffraction enables identifying the crystallographic structure. Goethite and lepidocrocite have orthorhombic structure, akaganéite has monoclinic structure, and feroxyhyte has hexagonal structure .
Short-range ordered ferrihydrite recrystallizes into well-crystallized phase, yet its initial morphology of plates at the size of <10 nm is preserved. Singerite (100 nm) disintegrates into iron-rich clay mineral . Magnetite has a cubic morphology of octahedron or cubes 2–4 μm as observed in the Thetis Deep of the Red Sea.
Goethite has acicular form and changes at elevated pH from mono-domain to multi-domain rods. Crystal size at the Dead Sea area and the Red Sea varied from few 100 nm to 3 μm.
Lepidocrocite usually precipitates at fast oxidation rate at the presence of chloride, and its morphology changes from plates formed at lower pH to multi-domain rods that are formed at elevated pH. Lepidocrocite crystals size varied from 100 nm in the Dead Sea to 300 nm in the Red Sea deeps.
Rods and multi-domain akaganéite were observed at the Dead Sea with crystal size that varied from 100 nm to 1 μm.
Feroxyhyte plates are formed at very high oxidation rate and had a plate morphology with crystals size that reached 300 nm.
In earlier study, synthesis was performed imitating the upper convecting layer of the Atlantis II Deep with lower temperatures and salinity . In this research, iron oxides were synthesized at higher pH, elevated temperatures, and hypersaline brines.
Iron oxides were synthesized under changing conditions of salinity, temperature, pH, and oxidation rates.
NaCl salt (Loba Chemie) was used to prepare NaCl solutions (2, 4, and 5M) that were used as a matrix and were kept in water bath at 40, 60, 70, and 80°C. Prior to synthesis, N2 was bubbled through the solutions for 20 minutes to remove dissolved oxygen. pH buffering of the solutions was accomplished by adding either NaOH (Daejung) or NaHCO3 (Carlo Erba) in small amounts, hence slightly changing Na concentration. pH of the solutions were 5.5, 7, 8.2, and 10.5. Cl concentration also changed due to dissolution of FeCl2·4H2O (Sigma-Aldrich) that was chosen for the Fe2+ solutions to yield a concentration of 0.06M.
Fe oxidation was carried out by introducing air at flow rates of 25, 40, 110, and 200 ml/min which was monitored with a flow meter and was kept stable during the hours of synthesis.
In order to isolate Si effects on the crystallization of iron oxides, Na2SiO3 (Sigma) was added to some of the solutions. To avoid any side effects, all of the samples were synthesized using the same polyethylene ware and under constant stirring speed. The precipitates were slightly washed and freeze-dried immediately after their synthesis.
Analyses of the precipitates were performed using X-ray diffraction (XRD).
The fitting of the peak profiles was performed by using Pseudo-Voigt function with the APD computer program developed by Philips Export B.V. A least square process using “Celsiz” software did the unit cell refinement.
Sample morphology was observed through transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and high-resolution scanning electron microscopy (HRSEM). Transmission electron microscopy was carried out on a JEOL FasTEM 2010 electron microscope equipped with the Noran energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS) for microprobe elemental analyses.
All chemical analyses were obtained by point analyses with beam width of 25 nm and are presented as atomic ratios. A NORAN Standardless Metallurgical Thin Films program based on the
3. Results and discussion
Initial identification of iron oxides was obtained by using X-ray diffractions (Figure 2). X-ray diffraction of all samples synthesized yielded the following results: At elevated temperatures, alkaline media and concentrated brine magnetite was the main phase that precipitated. At neutral to slightly acidic conditions, lepidocrocite, akaganéite, and goethite co-precipitated. Additional NaHCO3 caused precipitation of siderite at 60°C.
In this study, pictures of iron oxides obtained by high-resolution scanning electron microscope and high-resolution transmission electron microscope are presented.
3.1 Magnetite FeO-Fe2O3
Unit cell parameters of magnetite vary from 0.8373 to 0.8396 nm with upper limit of 0.8396 nm, identical to that of well-crystallized magnetite . Crystallite size changes from 18 to 45 nm. The smallest crystallites were obtained at pH 7.5 in 4 or 5M NaCl at all temperatures, whereas the largest crystallites were obtained at under elevated pH (9.5) and temperatures. The lowermost unit cell parameter was obtained for samples that crystallized at 60°C pH 8.5 and in 4M NaCl matrix. The largest unit cell parameter was obtained for samples that crystallized under elevated pH 9.5, 5M NaCl and at 80°C. Overall, crystallite size and unit cell parameters were mainly affected by pH values, rather than by salinity or temperature changes (Figure 3).
Magnetite Fe3O4: FeO-Fe2O3 crystallizes in cubic system with a = 0.8396 nm.
Crystallization from Fe2+ solutions usually involves crystallization of hexagonal flakes of Fe(OH)2, which transforms to magnetite in moderately alkaline solutions (pH > 8). Under slightly acid to slightly alkaline conditions, green rust phases are formed, and upon further oxidation they are transformed into goethite and/or lepidocrocite . Formation of magnetite in the hypersaline brines results from slow oxidation, elevated temperatures, and higher pH. The morphology of the magnetite crystals was mainly affected by pH. In strongly alkaline brine, hexagonal flakes of Fe(OH)2 were initially formed recrystallized into magnetite, preserving the initial morphology.
The morphology of magnetite of the Thetis Deep indicates that precipitation occurred at lower pH and lower salinity, suggesting that no brine pool filled the Thetis Deep .
3.2 Goethite (α-FeOOH)
Goethite precipitated along with other iron oxides. The morphologies of the crystals formed varied between mono-domain and multi-domain crystals. Twinning and star-shaped multi-domain crystals were formed at elevated temperatures. In higher salinity of 5M NaCl, goethite precipitated at pH 8.2 and 40°C, and at pH 7 and 40°C, it co-precipitated with lepidocrocite and akaganéite. Adding NaHCO3 to the solution caused co-precipitation of goethite with lepidocrocite at 40°C in 2M NaCl, co-precipitation of goethite with magnetite at 60°C and at 5M NaCl solutions, at pH 8.2, only magnetite precipitated magnetite  (Figure 9).
3.3 Lepidocrocite (γ-FeOOH)
Lepidocrocite precipitated at lower temperatures than magnetite. By using NaCl solutions of 5M and temperature of 40°C, the morphology of the crystals formed was affected by the pH. Plates crystallized at pH 5.5, rods at pH 7, and multi-domain crystals at pH 8.2 (Figure 10). The difference between the morphologies results from faster crystallization of 010 along c direction in crystals formed at higher pH leading to multi-domain crystals at pH 8.2. Similar results were also obtained at 25°C .
3.4 Effect of additional Si
Addition of Na2SiO3H2O into the solutions was selected to see the effect of Si on iron oxide crystallization. In precipitation of magnetite crystals, Na2SiO3H2O was added to a solution of 4M NaCl, pH 7.5 at a temperature of 60°C. The presence of Si affected crystal size, which became smaller, from 30 to 26 nm, and unit cell parameter decreased from 0.8392 to 0.8380 nm.
Addition of 0.0135 g Na2SiO3H2O to the solutions at the initial crystallization stage hindered crystal growth of goethite crystals (Figure 11). Elevated amounts of Si added as 0.135 g Na2SiO3 and 1.35 g caused formation of short-range ordered phases (suggested name singerite) .
Magnetite crystalized in hypersaline 2–5M brine at elevated temperatures 60–80°C and pH 6.5–10. At high alkalinity, their initial formation stage of hexagonal plates was preserved. At lower alkalinity, their morphology was unhedral cubes. Additional Si to the brines caused smaller crystals.
Lepidocrocite and goethite were formed at lower temperatures (40°C). High alkalinity effected crystal morphologies causing multi-domain structure in goethite and in lepidocrocite and twinning formation.
Additional Si hindered crystal growth.
Hartmann M, Scholten JC, Stoffers P, Wehner F. Hydrographic structure of brine-filled deeps in the Red Sea—New results from the Shaban, Kerbit, Atlantis II, and discovery deep. Marine Geology. 1998a; 144:311-330
Swift A, Bower AS, Schmitt R. Vertical, horizontal, and temporal changes in temperature in the Atlantis II and discovery hot brine pools, Red Sea. Deep Sea Research Part I: Oceanographic Research Papers. 2012; 1(64):118-128
Pierret MC, Clauer N, Bosch D, Blanc C, France-Lanord C. Chemical and isotopic (87Sr/86Sr, d18O, dD) constraints in the formation processes of Red Sea brines. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta. 2001; 65:1259-1275
Ramboz C, Danis M. Superheating in the Red Sea? The heat-mass balance of the Atlantis II deep revisited. Earth and Planetary Science Letters. 1990; 97:190-210
Hartmann M, Scholten JC, Stoffers P. Hydrographic structure of brine-filled deeps in the Red Sea: Correction of Atlantis II deep temperatures. Marine Geology. 1998b; 144:331-332
Pierret MC, Clauer N, Bosch D, Blanc G. Formation of Thetis deep metal-rich sediments in the absence of brines, Red Sea. Journal of Geochemical Exploration. 2010; 104:12-26
Taitel-Goldman N, Bender-Koch C, Singer A. Lepidocrocite in hydrothermal sediments of the Atlantis II and Thetis deeps, Red Sea. Clays and Clay Minerals. 2002; 50:186-197
Taitel-Goldman N, Bender-Koch C, Singer A. Si-associated goethite in hydrothermal sediments of the Atlantis II and Thetis deeps, Red Sea. Clays and Clay Minerals. 2004; 52:115-129
Taitel-Goldman N, Ezerski V, Mogilyanski D. High resolution transmission electron microscopy study of Fe-Mn oxides in the hydrothermal sediments of the Red Sea deeps system. Clays and Clay Minerals. 2009; 57:465-475
Taitel-Goldman N, Ezerski V, Mogilyanski D. Nano-sized iron-oxides in the Dead Sea area. Journal of Earth Science. 2016; 2:94-104
Cornell RM, Schwertmann U. The Iron Oxides: Structure, Properties, Reactions, Occurrences. Weinheim, Germany: Wiley VCH; 2003
Taitel-Goldman N, Singer A. Metastable Si-Fe phases in hydrothermal sediments of Atlantis II deep, Red Sea. Clay Minerals. 2002; 37:235-248
Taitel-Goldman N, Singer A. Synthesis of clay-sized iron oxides under marine hydrothermal conditions. Clay Minerals. 2002; 37:719-731