State of microstructure, degree of exhaustion and hardness of the material of homogeneous butt joint components of test critical pressure components of power units after long-term service under creep conditions beyond the design service time, based on examples.
The assessment of suitability for further service of the basic material and circumferential welded joints of primary steam pipelines made of 14MoV6-3 steel was made based on the determined characteristics of their mechanical properties and structure. The tests were carried out on materials after service significantly exceeding the design time and 200,000 h. The mechanical properties with respect to the determined class of structure for the basic and welded joint material were compared to the determined class of damage in accordance with the Institute for Ferrous Metallurgy’s own classification of the condition of materials after service under creep conditions. The residual life and disposable residual life were determined based on short-term creep tests and referred to the class of existing structure and the class of damage. The assessment of the suitability of the basic and circumferential welded joint material for further service was made.
- welded joint
- Cr-Mo-V steel
- residual life
In the European conventional power generation, a small number of newly constructed units have been recorded in at least several recent years, which is caused by, but not limited to, a lot of factors related mainly to environmental protection. Therefore, the electricity producers direct their main efforts at maintaining the availability of existing power units while ensuring their safe service. The inspections of and repairs to the energy installations that are in use and whose design service life was in most cases significantly exceeded while at the same time providing the reliable efficient diagnostics seem to be the proper way for the achievement of these objectives.
However, the performance of periodic inspections and repairs is not sufficient to maintain the current level of electricity and heat production in Poland. The modernisation of the units being operated is required as well. To maintain the current level of production, it is estimated that each year the modernisation of units with a total capacity of at least 2000 MW is necessary. Therefore, the important issue to be resolved has become not only the condition assessment of the pressure section of boiler and forecast about its further safe service but also the design modernisation with selection and use of new materials allowing for construction and installation of new components [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10]. The required increase in efficiency and extension of service time of the operating high-power units, i.e. 200, 360 and 500 MW, far beyond the design time up to the expected min. 350,000 h involves the need to replace certain components because of the end of their life and to modernise them. Certain critical components being replaced are often made of new-generation steel for the power generation industry [11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20]. At the same time, these units are expected to be operated in the control system and to comply with standards of the European directive on limitation of harmful emissions into the atmosphere.
As part of the diagnostics, it is necessary to perform the condition assessment not only for the basic material of the components working under creep conditions but also for the material of welded joints. The condition assessment of the welded joint material is necessary to determine the ability of the components to transfer the required service loads during their further service [21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34].
If there is a need to repair or replace a part or entire component with a new one, the capability of the basic material of the operated component to make such a repair or replacement should be determined. When condition of this material after service allows a repair, it is necessary to develop the repair technology from time to time.
The subject matter of the testing, including non-destructive and destructive tests, related to the long-time operated and repair welded joints of materials after long-term service with materials after service or with new materials is a separate issue dealt with by the Institute for Ferrous Metallurgy for many years.
The developed and applied research methods and the adopted procedure allow for the correct condition assessment of the basic material and welded joint material (HAZ and weld). The test results for long-time operated as well as repair and modernisation welded joints obtained so far allowed expanding the material database with such data and proposing the procedure for making such welded joints when necessary.
2. Condition assessment of the material of welded joints in components operated beyond the design time by non-destructive methods
The criterial element deciding about the suitability for further service of butt-welded joints of components operating under creep conditions is the exhaustion degree of basic materials determined based on the revealed state of microstructure and its determined class as well as the degree of internal damages and the class of damages of the heat-affected zone (HAZ) and weld material. The example of the results of non-destructive tests on microstructure of the primary steam pipeline components after long-term service under creep conditions far beyond the design service time without internal damages caused by creep is shown in Figure 1, while those with disclosed damages in the form of voids both in the basic material and in the heat-affected zone and weld material are shown in Figure 2. The results of these tests allow to take decisions whether the test pipelines can be left and only some of its components need to be replaced using the joining technology by welding materials with significant changes in microstructure caused by creep with new materials.
The assessment of the exhaustion degree and the degree of internal damages in the material of welded joint components allows for determination of the residual and disposable life of the welded joint, capability of the materials of welded joint components to make a possible repair to the test joint, capability of the test basic materials to produce a repair (old/old material) or modernisation (old/new material) welded joint and propose the appropriate welding technology.
To ensure that the condition assessment of the material of welded joint components after long-term service under creep conditions by non-destructive methods is accurate and the estimated exhaustion degree is reliable, the results of destructive materials testing of these components are required. The results of these tests should allow the assignment of exhaustion degree to determined degrees of microstructural degradation of such joints.
The material for destructive materials testing is selected based on the results obtained by non-destructive method of matrix replicas, which determine the class of microstructure and the estimated exhaustion degree for parent material and the class of damage for butt components of welded joints. The material for destructive testing in the form of a test specimen of the component with butt-welded joint is taken from the areas with the highest exhaustion degree and adopted as representative for the component or installation.
3. Condition assessment of the material of welded joints operated beyond the design time using destructive methods
The destructive materials testing on long-time operated welded joints are carried out on homogeneous butt-welded joints of thick-walled components. Most often, these are welded joints of steam pipelines as well as steam superheater chambers and temperature controllers made of the following steel grades: 13CrMo4-5, 10CrMo9-10, 14MoV6-3, X20CrMoV121 and sometimes 15Mo3.
These tests include the observations of microstructure and hardness measurement of different areas of joints from parent material through heat-affected zone and weld. The simultaneous testing of mechanical properties and residual life of the welded joints and parent material are used to search for relations between the state of microstructure and these properties. It is also important to search for correlation between the mechanical properties, especially residual life, of the parent material and welded joint.
The characteristics created based on the obtained test results are used for assessing the condition and forecasting the further safe service of the parent material and welded joints operated beyond the design service time. Moreover, they are decisive in making decisions on the possibility of repairing welded joints using the materials after long-term service under creep conditions and developing the joining technologies.
3.1 Structure assessment of the material of welded joints operated for a long time under creep conditions
The selected example showing the state of structure of homogeneous butt-welded joints after long-term service compared to the structure of the parent material of a component after service far beyond the design service life is shown in Figure 3 and summarised in Table 1.
|Material used in testing||Description of microstructure
Material condition—exhaustion degree
Grade of material
|Primary steam pipeline
||Ferritic-bainitic structure. Partially coagulated bainitic areas. Few precipitates of various sizes at the ferrite grain boundaries. Precipitates inside ferrite grains, mostly very fine, distributed evenly
No discontinuities and micro-cracks are observed in the structure
Bainitic areas: class I, precipitates: class a
Damaging processes: class O
||Bainite with a small amount of ferrite. Significant number of fine precipitates in the bainitic areas and ferrite
No discontinuities and micro-cracks are found in the structure
||Bainitic areas of various sizes with a small number of ferrite. Bainitic areas with precipitates of various sizes
No discontinuities and micro-cracks found in the structure
||Mixture of bainite and ferrite. Fine precipitates: in the bainite areas—distributed unevenly, in ferrite—distributed evenly.
No discontinuities and micro-cracks found in the structure
Figure 3 reveals the images of microstructure and the results of hardness measurements of components of the butt-welded joint in the main primary steam pipeline, whereas the description, state of microstructure of the parent material and its exhaustion degree as well as the class of internal damages of the heat-affected zones and weld for the selected example of welded joint are summarised in Table 1. The image of microstructure of the welded joint components after service, exceeding twice the value of the design service time, most often corresponds to the exhaustion degree which allows the material to be used in further service. It mainly results from significant difference between the design thickness and the actual thickness of the assessed components (go < gact), which causes that the actual operating stress is lower than the design one (σact < σ), the as-received condition of the test materials and the correct previous service. Also, the frequent small differences in hardness level in the individual areas of the joints are a positive phenomenon affecting the suitability for further service.
Table 2 presents an analysis of the chemical composition of the tested sections. The mechanical properties of the material obtained from pipeline sections were shown in graphical form in Figures 4, 5, 6, 7, 8. In order to assess the properties of the tested steels and their welded joints, reference was made to the requirements contained in PN-75/H-84024.
|Standard||Chemical composition, %|
|Examined element MR1||0.16||0.61||0.33||0.020||0.020||0.48||0.51||0.31||0.08|
|Examined element MR 2||0.14||0.51||0.29||0.018||0.019||0.52||0.51||0.28||0.09|
3.2 Assessment of mechanical properties of the material of welded joints operated for a long time under creep conditions
Another element of the materials characteristics is the mechanical properties of welded joints after service and their level. Most often, the level of tensile strength and yield point at room temperature and of tensile strength at elevated temperature of such welded joints after service, for a time much longer than the design time, corresponds to the required minimum values for the parent material in the as-received condition, or their actual values are not much lower. The example of such characteristics is shown in Figure 4. The level of these properties is very important for the determination of the rate of start-ups and shutdowns, which is connected with the level of instantaneous internal stresses resulting from the temperature gradient, particularly of thick-walled components. It is also important to know the formability of the material of welded joints, which can be reflected by the elongation in tensile test, its impact energy and brittle fracture appearance transition temperature both in the weld and the heat-affected zones. The example of elongation test results depending on the test temperature of welded joints compared to the parent material after long-term service far beyond the design service time is shown in Figure 5, whereas Figure 8 presents the comparison of mechanical properties of the parent material and butt-welded joint with regard to the requirements for the parent material in the as-received condition.
The test results for impact energy measured on V-notch test specimens depending on the test temperature of parent material and weld of homogeneous butt-welded joint of the pipeline components after long-term service under creep conditions are compared in Figure 7, whereas Figure 8 shows the relationship between the impact energy measured on V-notch test specimens and the test temperature of the parent material, heat-affected zone and weld of the butt-welded joint of the main steam pipeline made of 14MoV6-3 steel after 20,000 h service as well as brittle fracture appearance transition temperatures determined for the materials of these areas. This example illustrates how diversified the level of brittle fracture appearance transition temperature of the material of individual welded joint components after long-term service under creep conditions can be.
In accordance with the results of long-term own research, for the materials that most often exist in the components operated under creep conditions far beyond the design service time, such as 13CrMo4-5, 14MoV6-3, 10CrMo9-10 low-alloy steels and X20CrMoV121 high-chromium steel, the highest trend towards the loss of plastic properties is shown by the components made of 14MoV6-3 steel and then those made of X20CrMoV121 steel. The knowledge of these material features is necessary for the selection of water-pressure test parameters and the method for overhaul works and repairs.
It should be noted that for components in long-term use, the leak water tests can only be carried out. The use of strength water test may result in destruction of the component being operated. Such a test can only be carried out for the new equipment, and the governing standards apply to new equipment only.
It can be concluded that with an increase in the exhaustion degree, the mechanical properties of the material being operated are reduced. However, no unambiguous relationships between the level of properties, both strength and plastic, and the residual life and exhaustion degree caused by creep were observed so far. According to the present knowledge, such a correlation does not exist.
3.3 Assessment of residual life and disposable residual life of the material of welded joints operated for a long time under creep conditions
The most critical element of the materials characteristics is the creep resistance level of the welded joints being operated. This creep resistance is responsible for their ability to transfer the actual service loads of the component, which occur under operating conditions. A measure of creep resistance is the level of residual creep resistance, which is able to meet these expectations. However, in the engineering practice, the safe service of the welded joints operated under the preset temperature and pressure conditions is important. The time of safe service is the disposable residual life, which is part of the residual life being determined.
The examples of residual life, which is the time to rupture under the temperature and stress conditions equal to operating ones, determined in short-term creep tests and compared to the residual life of the parent material after service are shown in Figure 9.
The determined residual life and disposal residual life for the presented examples are summarised in Table 3. The comparison of the residual life and disposable residual life determined for the material of two primary steam pipelines made of 14MoV6-3 steel after 200,000 h service shows significant differences. These differences probably result mainly from differences in the as-received condition of the operated material and welded joint as well as different service history. This confirms the need of an individual assessment, mainly based on the assessment of the actual condition of the component and its material.
|Steel grade||Test area||Material used in testing||Adopted operating parameters of further service||Determined residual life, h||Estimated disposable residual life, h|
|Type of component
|Dimensions of Dout × gn, mm||Stress
|temperature Tr, °C|
|Parent material||Primary steam pipeline
|ϕ327 × 40||60||540|
|Parent material||Primary steam pipeline
|ϕ327 × 40||50||540|
Based on many power units in use, the results of creep tests on the butt-welded joints after long-term service beyond the design time carried out on the parent material and butt-welded joints of the components operating under creep conditions invalidate the generally accepted principle that the residual creep strength of the material of welded joint is no less than 80% the residual creep strength of the basic material. The principle of the relationship of residual creep strength between them transferred from that applicable to the basic material and welded joint in the as-received condition is not supported by the investigations of real cases. Also, in many investigated cases, the residual life of the welded joint is significantly lower than that obtained for the parent material. Therefore, for the components and materials operated far beyond the design time, it is necessary to determine the residual life not only for the basic material of the representative test specimen of the component but also for the welded joint (Table 3).
Zieliński A, Sroka M, Dudziak T. Microstructure and mechanical properties of Inconel 740H after long-term service. Materials. 2018; 11:2130. DOI: 10.3390/ma11112130
Zieliński A, Dobrzański J, Purzyńska H, Sikora R, Dziuba-Kałuża M, Kania Z. Evaluation of creep strength of heterogeneous welded joint in HR6W alloy and Sanicro 25 steel. Archives of Metallurgy and Materials. 2017; 62(4):2057-2064
Sroka M, Zielinski A, Hernas A, Kania Z, Rozmus R, Tanski T, et al. The effect of long-term impact of elevated temperature on changes in the microstructure of Inconel 740H alloy. Metalurgija. 2017; 56(3-4):333-336
Sroka M, Nabialek M, Szota M, Zielinski A. The influence of the temperature and ageing time on the NiCr23Co12Mo alloy microstructure. Revista de Chimie. 2017; 68(4):737-741
Golanski G, Zielinska-Lipiec A, Zielinski A, Sroka M. Effect of long-term service on microstructure and mechanical properties of martensitic 9% Cr steel. Journal of Materials Engineering and Performance. 2017; 26(3):1101-1107
Zieliński A, Golański G, Sroka M. Influence of long-term ageing on the microstructure and mechanical properties of T24 steel. Materials Science & Engineering, A: Structural Materials: Properties, Microstructure and Processing. 2017; 682:664-672
Dudziak T, Deodeshmukh V, Backert L, Sobczak N, Witkowska M, Ratuszek W, et al. Phase investigations under steam oxidation process at 800°C for 1000 h of advanced steels and Ni-based alloys. Oxidation of Metals. 2017; 87(1-2):139-158
Zieliński A, Golański G, Sroka M, Skupień P. Microstructure and mechanical properties of the T23 steel after long-term ageing at elevated temperature. Materials at High Temperatures. 2016; 33:154-163
Zieliński A, Golański G, Dobrzański J, Sroka M. Creep resistance of VM12 steel. Archives of Metallurgy and Materials. 2016; 61:1289-1294
Wojsyk K, Golański G, Jasek J, Słania J, Zieliński A, Urbańczyk P. Influence of the annealing time after welding on the mechanical properties of welded joint of T91 steel. Archives of Metallurgy and Materials. 2016; 61:1079-1084
Zieliński A, Boryczko B, Miczka M, Sroka M. Forecasting in the presence of microstructural changes for the case of P91 steel after long-term ageing. Archives of Civil and Mechanical Engineering. 2016; 16:813-824
Zieliński A, Sroka M, Miczka M, Śliwa A. Forecasting the particle diameter size distribution in P92 (X10CrWMoVNb9-2) steel after long-term ageing at 600 and 650°C. Archives of Metallurgy and Materials. 2016; 61:753-760
Zieliński A, Sroka M, Hernas A, Kremzer M. The effect of long-term impact of elevated temperature on changes in microstructure and mechanical properties of HR3C steel. Archives of Metallurgy and Materials. 2016; 61:761-765
Zieliński A, Purzyńska H, Dobrzański J, Golański G. Changes in properties and structure of high-chromium 9-12% Cr steels due to long-term exposure at elevated temperature. Archives of Metallurgy and Materials. 2016; 61:957-964
Zieliński A, Paszkowska H, Skupień P, Golański G. Assessment of service life of HCM12 steel after 100,000 hrs of service. Archives of Metallurgy and Materials. 2016; 61:1021-1029
Zieliński A, Dobrzański J, Purzyńska H, Golański G. Properties, structure and creep resistance of austenitic steel super 304H. Materials Testing. 2015; 57:859-865
Golański G, Lis A, Słania J, Zieliński A. Microstructural aspect of long term service of the austenitic TP347HFG steel. Archives of Metallurgy and Materials. 2015; 60:2901-2904
Golański G, Zieliński A, Zielińska-Lipiec A. Degradation of microstructure and mechanical properties in martensitic cast steel after ageing. Materialwissenschaft und Werkstofftechnik. 2015; 46(3):248-255
Golański G, Zieliński A, Słania J, Jasak J. Mechanical properties of VM12 steel after 30000 hrs of ageing at 600°C temperature. Archives of Metallurgy and Materials. 2014; 59(4):1351-1354
Kępa J, Golański G, Zieliński A, Brodziak-Hyska A. Precipitation process in VM12 steel after ageing at 650°C temperature. JVE - Journal of Vibroengineering. 2012; 14(1):143-150
Dobrzański J, Hernas A. Correlation between phase composition and life-time of 1Cr-0.5Mo steels during long term service at elevated temperature. Journal of Materials Processing Technology. 1995; 53:101-108
Dobrzański J, Hernas A. Relationship between microstructure and remanent life-time of low alloy Cr-Mo steels. In: 6th International Conference on Creep and Fatigue. London; 1996. p. 451
Dobrzański J. The classification method and the technical condition evaluation of the critical elements’ material of power boilers in creep service made from the 12Cr-1Mo-V. Journal of Materials Processing Technology. 2005; 164-165:785-794
Neubauer B. Creep damage evolution in power plants. In: Proceeding of the Second International Conference on Creep and Fracture of Engineering Materials and Structures. Swansea, UK; 1984. pp. 1226-1271
Dobrzański J. Internal damage processes in low alloy chromium-molibdenum steels during high-temperature creep service. Journal of Materials Processing Technology. 2004; 157-158:297-303
Dobrzański J, Sroka M, Zieliński A. Methodology of classification of internal damage the steels during creep service. Journal of Achievements in Materials and Manufacturing Engineering. 2006; 18:263-266
Dobrzański J, Sroka M. Computer aided classification of internal damages the chromium-molybdenum steels during creep service. Journal of Achievements in Materials and Manufacturing Engineering. 2007; 24(3):143-146
Zieliński A, Dobrzański J, Krztoń H. Structural changes in low alloy cast steel Cr-Mo-V after long time creep service. Journal of Achievements in Materials and Manufacturing Engineering. 2007; 25(1):33-36
Dobrzański J, Krztoń H, Zieliński A. Development of the precipitation processes in low-alloy Cr-Mo type steel for evolution of the material state after exceeding the assessed lifetime. Journal of Achievements in Materials and Manufacturing Engineering. 2007; 23(2):19-22
Dobrzański J, Zieliński A, Krztoń H. Mechanical properties and structure of the Cr-Mo-V low-alloyed steel after long-term service in creep condition. Journal of Achievements in Materials and Manufacturing Engineering. 2007; 23(1):39-42
Zieliński A. The effect of long-term service under creep conditions on mechanical properties of Cr-Mo-V cast steel. In: 8th International Scientific Conference—New Technologies and Achievements in Metallurgy and Materials Engineering. Vol. II. Czestochowa: Publishing House of the Czestochowa University of Technology; 2007. pp. 717-721
Hernas A, Dobrzański J. Life Time and Destruction of Steam Boilers and Turbines. Gliwice: The Silesian University of Technology Publishing House; 2003
Dobrzański J, Hernas A, Pasternak J, Zieliński A. Microstructure and mechanical properties characteristics of welded joints made of creep-resistant steel with 12% Cr, V, W and Co additions. In: Advances in Materials Technology for Fossil Power Plants. ASM International; 2008. pp. 303-319. DOI: 10.1361/cp2007epri0303
Zieliński A, Dobrzański J, Renowicz D, Hernas A. The estimation of residual life of low-alloy cast steel Cr-Mo-V type after long-term creep service. In: Advances in Materials Technology for Fossil Power Plants. ASM International; 2008. pp. 616-626. DOI: 10.1361/cp2007epri0616