Main features of the heat transfer passive devices.
The heat pipe and thermosyphon are passive heat transfer devices with phase change, which can be applied for thermal management of thermoelectric cooling, such as the TEC hot side. The heat pipes basically consist of a metal tube sealed with capillary structure internally that is embedded with a working fluid. This capillary structure can be made of screen meshes, grooves, or sintered media. The thermosyphon is a heat pipe assisted by gravity, because it has no capillary structure. Then, in this chapter, manufacturing of low cost and easy-to-manufacture heat pipes and thermosyphon is described in detail, and an experimental evaluation of their thermal performance is accomplished. The considered devices were a rod, a thermosyphon, a mesh heat pipe, a grooved heat pipe, and a sintered heat pipe. According to the behavior of the global thermal resistance and the effective thermal conductivity, the passive devices operated satisfactorily with the exception of the rod and the thermosyphon in the horizontal position. The heat pipes were the best among the tested devices and the best position was vertical.
- heat pipe
- thermal management
- experimental thermal performance
Nowadays the advance in the development of computer systems has helped the science to find out computational solutions on understanding phenomena inherent to the problems faced by engineering . The increase of computer system performance has resulted in a high heat generation. On the other hand, the computers’ performance can be potentially reduced due to these high heat flux densities . Therefore, the thermal management of this kind of electronic equipment has become a challenge in order to avoid the overheating and, as a consequence, the hardware failure .
According to Sun et al. , passive cooling systems such as air, liquid, and heat exchangers with phase change are used to regulate the temperature of CPU and other electronic components at desired levels. Nevertheless, these traditional passive cooling systems are restricted to the working fluid limitations. In this scenario, the thermoelectric cooling (TEC) system can be considered as an alternative to the thermal management of CPU and other electronic components.
A TEC system is composed of a thermoelectric module, a cold, and a hot region. Thermoelectric modules work under the Peltier effect when a DC current passes through a cell made of semiconductor materials; one of the junctions is cooled while the other is heated. In general, the cold region of TEC can be used for cooling the components of personal computers, CPU, graphics processors, and so on. However, its cooling performance is restricted by the thermal resistance at TEC hot region. Besides, TEC is attractive for cooling these devices due to its low weight, compact size, and vibration free characteristics .
In order to improve the TEC cooling performance, the heat pipes or thermosyphons can be used as an alternative for TEC hot side cooling . A schematic diagram of a TEC/Heat Pipes (or thermosyphons) system coupled to CPU is shown in Figure 1. The principle of this technology is: the heat generated in CPU is transferred to the TEC cold region, where the conversion of electrical energy into thermal energy occurs by Peltier effect, and after this process, the heat is transferred to the TEC hot side. In order to increase the TEC hot side cooling, a heat dissipation system is used, which is composed of a heat sink and heat pipes (or thermosyphons). Thus, the evaporators of heat pipes (or thermosyphons) are fixed in the heat sink and absorb the heat generated by CPU and transfer this heat to the condensers of the heat pipes (or thermosyphons), where finally it is dissipated to the environment.
Heat pipes and thermosyphons are passive heat transfer devices capable of transferring large amounts of heat with a small temperature difference. They became popular in recent decades because of their effectiveness and convenience. These devices are used to improve heat transfer in many industrial fields such as electronics, telecommunications, aerospace, among others . The heat transmitted through these devices is based on phase change. Major advantages of heat pipes include a very high thermal conductance, no pumping power requirements, no moving parts, and relatively low-pressure drops . Furthermore, the heat pipes and thermosyphons are devices relatively simple to manufacture and, therefore, have low cost when their geometry is favorable .
The heat pipes and thermosyphons operate according to the following principle : in the evaporator region, heat is transferred to the heat pipe or thermosyphon, vaporizing the working fluid contained inside this region. The steam generated is moved, due to the pressure and density differences, to the cooling regions of the heat pipe or thermosyphon (condenser region) where heat transported is rejected to the cold source. In the heat rejection process, the steam condenses, and the condensate returns back to the evaporator closing the cycle. The adiabatic region, which may have variable dimensions (in some cases it is absent), is located between the evaporator and the condenser being insulated from the external environment. In the heat pipes, the working fluid returns from the condenser to the evaporator due to capillary pumping effect while in the thermosyphon the working fluid returns exclusively by gravity because it has no capillary structure. A schematic diagram of the operating principle of heat pipes is presented in Figure 2 . More details on the principle of the heat pipes and thermosyphons can be found in [7, 8, 9, 10].
The heat pipes basically consist of a metal tube sealed with capillary structure internally, which is embedded with a working fluid . This capillary structure can be made of screen meshes, grooves, or sintered media . The metal screen is the most commonly used capillary structure because of availability, ease of construction and good capillary pumping . The grooves, as capillary structure, have a high thermal conductivity and good permeability . The sintered metal wicks are manufactured by packing tiny metal particles between the inner heat pipe wall and a mandrel in powder form . As mentioned earlier, the thermosyphon is a heat pipe assisted by gravity, which means that it has no capillary structure to return the working fluid . Some researches available in the literature about thermal management of thermoelectric cooling used heat pipes and thermosyphons [4, 5, 18, 19, 20].
Thus, in this chapter, manufacturing of low cost and easy-to-manufacture heat pipes and thermosyphon is described in detail, and an experimental evaluation of the thermal performance is accomplished for several different passive devices that can be used for thermal management of thermoelectric cooling. The considered devices were a rod, a thermosyphon, a mesh heat pipe, a grooved heat pipe, and a sintered heat pipe. In order to evaluate the best passive heat transfer device, their thermal performance was compared.
2. Heat pipe and Thermosyphon manufacturing
In this section, each step of a heat pipe and a thermosyphon manufacturing is described in detail. The proposed procedure has low-cost and the heat transfer passive devices are easy-to-manufacture. The steps are cleaning, assembly, tightness test, evacuation procedure, and filling with the working fluid. These procedures were based on [21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26].
If the operation conditions are favorable to gravity, a thermosyphon can be manufactured. As a result, a capillary structure is not necessary. However, in adverse conditions, a wick should be selected and accommodated in the involucre inner. As mentioned before, the capillary structures can be screen meshes, grooves, sintered powder, among others.
The involucre material, capillary structure (if applicable), and the working fluid depend on the application, and they need to be chemically and mechanically compatible. For thermoelectric cooling, the operation temperature is around 150°C, which makes suitable to use copper and distilled water for involucre and working fluid, respectively.
First of all, the main components of the heat pipe or the thermosyphon have to be prepared. The sintered heat pipe involucre consists of the casing, the closing lids, and the capillary, as shown in Figure 3.
2.1. Cleaning process
The cleaning of the heat pipe or the thermosyphon is necessary to ensure the working fluid wettability, the impurity elimination, and the vacuum quality improvement . Consequently, the heat pipe or thermosyphon components need to be thoroughly cleaned, before the introduction of the working fluid. For this purpose, first, the casing, the closing lids, the capillary, and the capillary structure (if applicable) are cleaned with acetone in order to remove larger dirties. Then, they are thoroughly cleaned with a sulfuric acid solution (H2SO4 of 0.1 M). After that, these components are taken to an ultrasonic bath, where they remained immersed in acetone for 30 min. Finally, the cleaning is completed. Figure 4 shows the cleaning of the sintered heat pipe components in an ultrasonic bath.
2.2. Assembling of the heat pipes and the thermosyphon
After the cleaning process, the heat pipe or thermosyphon can be properly assembled. As the wick is inside the casing, the closing lids and the capillary are welded to the tube extremities (Figure 5). In the case of copper involucres, the welding process can be performed with the aid of a soldering iron and the parts can be brazed using a tin alloy as filler material.
2.3. Tightness test
A tightness test has to be conducted to verify if there was no flaw in the welding process of the heat pipe or thermosyphon. A manual positive displacement pump, a water container (e.g., a sink full of water), and a polymeric tube are necessary to accomplish a low-cost test (Figure 6). The polymeric tube makes the connection between the pump and the capillary tube. The heat pipe or thermosyphon is inserted into the water container and the air is pumped into the tube using the positive displacement pump. If there are any flaws in the solder, bubbles will appear in the water. In case of the presence of bubbles, the heat pipe or thermosyphon has to be disassembled, cleaned, welded, and retested.
2.4. Evacuation procedure
First, the heat pipe or thermosyphon is connected to a vacuum pump (
2.5. Filling with working fluid
The amount of working fluid inserted in the heat pipe or thermosyphon is essential for capillary pumping system because the heat transfer depends on that amount of fluid. If there is not enough fluid, the pumping system stop to work and the heat pipe or thermosyphon collapses and as a result, the transferring heat is ceased. As a result, the filling ratio should be carefully chosen. Usually, the filling ratio is based on the evaporator volume.
To perform the filling procedure with the working fluid, a small filling station has to be developed. The filling station is composed of a universal support, a graduated burette (scale of 0.1 mL) with a capacity of 25 mL, and a forceps (Figure 8). The burette and the polymeric hose are completely filled with the working fluid. The evacuated heat pipe or thermosyphon is coupled to the burette by the polymeric hose. Make sure that there are no air bubbles in the tube connecting the burette and the heat pipe or thermosyphon. The next step is to carefully open the burette valve. The forceps are carefully opened to drain the working fluid until the heat pipe or thermosyphon was charged with the correct quantity. It is emphasized that at the moment of filling, great care must be taken; otherwise, the heat pipe or thermosyphon vacuum will be lost. If this happens, the entire vacuum process must be performed again. After charging, the capillary is closed with grip pliers and the capillary end is welded to the completely sealing (Figure 9).
3. Characteristics of the developed passive devices
The heat pipes and thermosyphon were produced by copper tubes ASTM B-75 Alloy 122 with an outer diameter of 9.45 mm, an inner diameter of 7.75 mm, and a length of 200 mm. The rod was obtained from a full copper bar ASTM B-75 Alloy 122 with the same dimensions of the developed heat pipes and thermosyphon. All the devices had an evaporator of 80 mm in length, an adiabatic region of 20 mm in length, and a condenser of 100 mm in length. The working fluid used is distilled water with filling ratios related to the evaporator volume based on the best performance of each capillary structure. Table 1 shows the main characteristics of the heat transfer passive devices analyzed in this research.
|Inner diameter [mm]||—||7.75||7.75||6.20||7.75|
|Outer diameter [mm]||9.45||9.45||9.45||9.45||9.45|
|Evaporator length [mm]||80.0||80.0||80.0||80.0||80.0|
|Adiabatic section length [mm]||20.0||20.0||20.0||20.0||20.0|
|Condenser length [mm]||100||100||100||100||100|
|Volume of working fluid [mL]||—||2.26||2.19||1.73||2.26|
|Filling ratio [%]||—||60||60||60||80|
|Capillary structure||—||No capillary structure||Phosphor bronze screen mesh #100||Microgrooves by the wire-EDM||Copper powder sintered|
The mesh heat pipe used one layer of phosphor bronze screen mesh #100 (Figure 10a) as capillary structure. A microscale image of screen mesh #100 is shown in Figure 10b. The image was obtained by backscattered electron detector (BSD) for scanning electron microscope (SEM). More information about this mesh heat pipe can be found in .
The grooved heat pipe shown schematically in Figure 11a had 32 microgrooves made by the wire electrical discharge machining (wire-EDM). Figure 11b presents the axial microgrooves details with an average diameter of 220 μm by a micro-scale image. The image was obtained by backscattered electron detector (BSD) for scanning electron microscope (SEM). More details about this heat pipe can be found in [24, 28].
The sintered heat pipe was produced by the sintering process with a copper powder and a temporary mandrel. The average diameter of the copper powder particle is 10.9 μm. The porous structure manufactured has a thickness of 1.5 mm (Figure 12a). The microscale image of the capillary structure of sintered copper powder is presented in Figure 12b. More information about this sintered heat pipe can be found in .
4. Experimental tests
To achieve successful results, the experimental tests must reproduce the operation conditions as close as possible to the application for thermal management of thermoelectric cooling. Then, to evaluate the thermal performance of the analyzed passive heat transfer devices, an experimental apparatus and some experimental procedures were used.
4.1. Experimental apparatus
The essential experimental apparatus for the experimental tests, shown in Figure 13, is composed of a data logger (
For the evaluation of the temperature of the different heat transfer passive devices, K-type thermocouples
As is already known, for the correct operation of the heat pipe and thermosyphon, a heating system is needed in the evaporator and a cooling system in the condenser. The evaporator can be power dissipation in any kind of resistor (strip, cartridge) or a heat source, as the TEC hot side. The cooling system can consist of forced convection by air, water, or coolant, in most of the cases. The adiabatic section may have variable dimensions (in some cases, it is absent) and should be insulated from the external environment.
Thus, in this research, the heating system of the evaporator is conducted by power dissipation from the passage of an electric current in a nickel-chromium alloy power strip resistor
4.2. Experimental procedure
To ensure the best results and the repeatability of experimental tests, the environment temperature was maintained at 20°C ± 0.5°C. A thermal conditioning system
5. Data reduction
5.1. Thermal parameters
The thermal performance of the heat pipes and the thermosyphon was analyzed and compared by the operating temperatures (
The effective thermal conductivity,
The heat transfer cross-sectional area can be defined by:
5.2. Uncertainties analysis
In general, the experimental uncertainties are associated to the K-type thermocouples, the data logger, and the power supply unit. The experimental measurement uncertainties were analyzed using the uncertainty combination method described in  considering the combination of uncertainties of correlated quantities. They are shown in the obtained results. It is known that the accuracy of the thermocouples is ±2.2°C and the uncertainty was evaluated as the rectangle type. Thus, the uncertainty values of the temperature sensors were estimated in:
The combined uncertainties of the evaporator, adiabatic section, and condenser temperatures were calculated according to the following equations respectively:
The measurement uncertainties associated with the dissipated power in the evaporator were estimated according to the power supply in the electrical resistance of the tests. The uncertainties were evaluated as the rectangle type, considering the voltage accuracy of 0.35% + 20 mV and the current accuracy of 0.35% + 20 mA. The electrical power dissipated by the electric resistance,
Considering that thermal losses in the evaporator region are negligible and that all energy is transferred to the wall of the heat pipe, the uncertainty of the heat transfer capacity can be estimated as:
The global thermal resistance uncertainty can be calculated by the following equation:
where the uncertainty of the temperature difference can be defined as:
6. Evaluation of the thermal performance
To summarize the analysis of the thermal performance of the heat pipes and the thermosyphon, different types of passive heat transfer devices were experimentally evaluated and compared. The considered devices were a rod, a thermosyphon, a mesh heat pipe, a grooved heat pipe, and a sintered heat pipe. The analyzed operating positions were vertical and horizontal. The experimental tests were repeated three times and the errors were compared taking into account the difference between the mean values less than 0.5°C. The tests were performed at increasing heat loads of 5 W, ranging from 5 to 45 W for both positions.
6.1. Temperature distribution
Figure 15 shows the temperature distributions as a function of time for the heat pipe with axial microgrooves in the vertical position. The heat pipe starts to work at a temperature of 44° C, for a heat load of 5 W. The maximum dissipated power of the grooved heat pipe was 45 W. Figure 16 presents the temperature distribution in function of the thermocouple position in the heat pipe length for different heat loads.
6.2. Operation temperature
The behavior of the operating temperature as a function of the dissipated power for different passive devices is shown in Figure 17. It may be noted that as the dissipated power increases, the operating temperature also increases for all the devices in both positions.
6.3. Global thermal resistance
Figure 18 presents the global thermal resistance as a function of the power dissipation considering the rod, the thermosyphon, and the heat pipes. The results of two operating positions are compared. As the heat dissipation is increased, the thermal resistance decreases for the thermosyphon and the heat pipes in the vertical position. In horizontal, the heat pipes obtain the same behavior; however, the thermosyphon has changed dramatically. It happens due to the necessity of gravity for the fluid return in the thermosyphon. The rod thermal resistance remains almost constant for the entire heat loads in both positions.
As mentioned, the global thermal resistance of the heat pipes and the thermosyphon take into consideration the temperature difference between the evaporator and the condenser and, the dissipated power. However, the processes governing the global thermal resistance are related to the fluid dynamics and the heat transfer. The fluid dynamics is influenced by the gravity and the capillary pumping. In the thermosyphon, the fluid flow from the condenser to the evaporator occurs exclusively by gravity. On the other hand, in the heat pipes, besides gravity, the capillary pumping also has a positive influence on the fluid flow. The heat transfer in the evaporators is governed by boiling, which is facilitated due to the existence of nucleation sites. Thermosyphon nucleation sites happen due to the surface roughness (imperfections). In the heat pipes, the capillary structures (screen meshes, microgrooves, or sintered media) provide the nucleation sites, making the boiling process more efficient. Thus, according to Figure 18, the global thermal resistance of the heat pipes is lower than the rod and the thermosyphon. This can be explained by the influence of gravity and the capillary pumping. Also, the boiling process is more efficient due to the existence of more nucleation sites. Finally, note that values of global thermal resistance could be lower if the overall heat transfer coefficient in the condenser of the passive devices were higher, which could be achieved, for example, using fins or liquid cooling.
6.4. Effective thermal conductivity
In Figure 19, the behavior of the effective thermal conductivity of the passive heat transfer devices is shown as a function of the power dissipated for vertical (a) and horizontal (b) positions. As expected, it can be seen that the passive devices that use phase change (heat pipes and thermosyphon) have a higher effective thermal conductivity and that this parameter increases with increasing power dissipation.
In this research, each step of the heat pipes and the thermosyphon manufacturing (cleaning, assembly, tightness test, evacuation procedure, and filling with the working fluid) was described in detail. The proposed procedure has low-cost and the heat transfer passive devices are easy-to-manufacture. Then, an experimental investigation of the thermal performance of different heat transfer passive devices (solid rod, thermosyphon, mesh heat pipe, grooved heat pipe, and sintered heat pipe) was performed. These passive heat transfer devices were tested in vertical and horizontal positions under thermal loads between 5 and 45 W and worked satisfactorily, except rod and thermosyphon in the horizontal position. The vertical position showed better results than the horizontal one due to gravity. The thermosyphon showed a satisfactory thermal performance in the vertical position. However, in the horizontal, its behavior was worse than a rod. The heat pipes were the devices with the best thermal performance due to the use of the vaporization heat of the working fluid concurrently with the capillary structure. The grooved heat pipe had a better thermal performance based on the lower global thermal resistance or the higher effective thermal conductivity. The experimental results showed that heat pipes and thermosyphon can be successfully used in TEC hot side cooling, and due to the behavior of the global thermal resistance and the effective thermal conductivity, on the other hand, a solid rod cannot be used.
Acknowledgments are provided to the CAPES, the CNPq, the PROPPG/UTFPR, the DIRPPG/UTFPR, the PPGEM/UTFPR/Ponta Grossa, and the DAMEC/UTFPR/Ponta Grossa.
|AC||cross-sectional area, [m2]|
|Di||inner diameter, [m]|
|k||thermal conductivity, [W/mK]|
|P||electrical power dissipated, [W]|
|q||heat transfer rate, [W]|
|Rth||total thermal resistance, [°C/W]|