PFC performances by using different fuels in 0.1M Na2SO4 with a TiO2photoanode and Pt/Pt black cathode. (Kaneko M et al., 2006).
Fuel cells are electrochemical devices which can convert chemical energy into electrical power. They have the advantages of quiet in operation, high efficiency and low pollutant emissions. Photoelectrochemical fuel cells(PEFCs or PECs) are special fuel cells. PEFCs are used in organic waste degradation (Patsoura A et al.,2006),solar energy utilization (BakT et al.,2002), gaseous product decomposition(Ollis DF et al., 2000), aqueous pollutants removal (Sakthivel S et al., 2004) and photocatalytic sterilization(Fujishima A et al., 1972). A PEFC or PFC consumes fuels and utilizesluminous energyto generate electricity power when the photoanode is excited by radiation. (LianosP et al.,2010).
Fig. 1 shows a typical two-compartment photo fuel cell separated by a silica frit (Antoniadou M et al., 2010). The electrolyte is NaOH. The anode is nanocrystallinetitania. The cathode is a carbon black deposited with Pt as the catalyst. This device works under UV irradiation. The open circuit voltage was 0.88V without ethanol and 1.22 V with ethanol.
2. Mechanisms of Photoelectrochemical Fuel Cells (PEFCs)
PEFCs normally consist of a semiconductor photoanode, metal cathode and electrolyte which could be an acid, base or just water. Light excites electrons at the photoanode if the light energy is larger than the material energy bandgap. The photoanode generates electrons (e-) and holes (h+). At the anode, production of oxygen happens. Hydrogen generates at the water/cathode interface. The reactions are shown as follows (Chang C et al., 2012):
3. Photoanode materials
Fig. 2 shows light absorption and electron transport on a photo sensitive material. The light energy is absorbed by the photo sensitive material. Electrons and holes generate. The electrons flow to cathode. The holes decompose water to produce oxygen. Nanostructured materials may be added to substrates such as Ti, glass, copper etc.
Semiconductor is widely used asphotoelectrode which including n-type (TiO2), p-type (lnP) and n-p type (n-GaAs/p-InP). They can be combined together to form multi-layered structures to tune the band gaps (Minggu L et al., 2010).In Fig. 3, SC stands for a semiconductor and M stands for a metal which is usually used as a substrate. Nanoporous materials are widely used in fuel cells. There are a number of transparent conductive oxides (TCOs) used as photoanode materials including indium-tin-oxide and fluorine-doped tin oxide. Some non-transparent conductive oxides (NTCOs) including nanocrystallinetitania TiO2, n-type semiconductor ZnO, Fe2O3,SrTiO3 etc. can also be used as photoanode materials. Among them, TiO2is the most commonly used one due to its stability and high photo activity.
Fig. 4 shows the design of photoelectrode(Miller EL et al., 2003). Fig. 4a shows the first stage of design using p-type silicon. The catalyst layeris on the left side and the platinum catalyst is deposited on the right side. The arrow indicates the direction of light illumination. In Fig. 4b, the right side is coated with a Shottky barrier metal. Fig. 4c illustrates a three-junction structure consisting of Si-Ge-glass. The photo-hydrogen conversion efficiency is up to 7.8%. This design needs an external connection. Fig. 4d has no external connection, as compared with Fig. 4c. Fig. 4e is the latest integrated planar photoelectrode design. On the right side, there is a highly transparent and corrosion-resistant film to keep the high efficiency. This new design can connect single cells in series, which can generate large power.
TiO2 is an effective photocatalysis (PC). It is often used as the anode of PFC (GratzelM et al.,2001). The reaction of TiO2 under UV illumination is follows (Park KW et al., 2007):
This formula is applicable for any metal oxide as the anode in a photo fuel cell. When the metal oxide absorbs photons from any light sources, electron-hole pairs are produced. The photo-generated holes react with fuels.
There are many types of fuels for PECs including pure water, alcohols (MeOH,EtOH, PrOH), polyols (glycerol, xylitol, sorbito, glucose, fructose, lactose), organic pollutants (urea, ammonia, triton X-100, SDS, CTAB). Alcohols have larger efficiencies than others do (Antoniadou M et al., 2009). In polyols, glycerol has the highest current density. Pure water has the lowest efficiency. Fuels are decomposed in the ways as described below.
Methanol (Lianos P, 2010):
Anode electrode in acidic media：
Anode electrode in base media:
Under the photo illumination, PFC absorbs light energy and the TiO2 is excited to release electrons. By this method, higher electric potential can be generated compared with other fuel cells. The completely reaction of TiO2 with methanol’s shown as:
The completely reaction of TiO2 with ethanol is as follows:
Reber JF et al., (1984) stated that a common formula could be:
Several types of biomass used in fuel cells are reported by Kaneko M et al., (2006), and shown in Table 1. The experimental condition is in acid solutions contain 0.1M Na2SO4. The anode of PEC is TiO2nanoporous film and the cathode is Pt black on Pt foil. The light intensity is 503 mW/cm2 and ambient temperature is 25 °C. The results of open circuit voltage show that acetic acid is the best. Ammonia, glycine, phenylalanine and glutamic acid also show good performances. The short circuit current of methanol has the highest value. The fill factor (FF) as defined by the ratio of maximum obtainable power to the product of the open circuit voltage and short circuit current was calculated. Ammonia has the maximum FF of 0.63.
LiuY et al.,(2011), did similar research on various fuels with a self-organized TiO2 nanotube array (STNA) as the photoanodeof the photo fuel cell (Table 2). Multiply fuels were tested but each fuel’s concentration was smaller than what Kaneko et al. used. By comparing the data in these two tables, we can see that the open circuit voltage and short circuit current obtained by Liu et al. are slightly larger, which means that they got higher efficiencies from the PFC system they built. When they varied the concentration of Na2SO4 from 0 to 0.5M, Voc and Jscreached the peak values at 0.1 M and the FF has the maximum value at 0.05 M. All the experiments were done under solar light illumination.
|Water (not controlled)||0.44||0.76||0.28|
|Water (not controlled)||0.94||0.47||0.37|
|Water (not controlled)||0.56||0.29||0.34|
|Water (not controlled)||0.57||0.02||0.51|
(COD =10842 mg/L)
|Original urine solution|
5. Cathode materials
As compared with multiple choices of photoanodes, the materials for the cathode of photo fuel cells are limited. Normally a Pt wire or a Pt foil is used. Another option is to use Pt-black. The Pt black powders can be cast, sprayed or hot-pressed on the surface of a Pt (Kaneko M et al., 2006). The surface area becomes larger when the Pt-black powers were deposited ontoPt wires or foils. In addition to platinumcathodes including platinum wire, non-platinized platinum foil, platinized platinum foil, platinized SnO2 with F, metal nanoparticles deposited on a TiO2/SnO2 with F doping are made into electrodes. Pt/TiO2/SnO2, Pd/TiO2/SnO2, Au/TiO2/SnO2, Ag/TiO2/SnO2, and Ni/TiO2/SnO2) are some of the examples. A platinum-loaded carbon cloth has also been used as a cathode material. The platinized SnO2 with F electrode has better performance than others. It speaks current, voltage and efficiency are 1.15 mA/cm2, 1340 mV and 12.3%, respectively. The platinum-loaded carbon cloth has the maximum efficiency of 32.3%. Thin layer of Si-H film photo cathode can be made by plasmaassisted chemical vapordeposition (PECVD). A Si-H cathode deposited organic or inorganic protective layer or coating with catalytic platinum can enhance the stability for long time use. The best thickness of the polymer protective layer is 5 nm. The optimized thickness of Pt coating is 2 nm.
CuO is a cheap material. CuOnanoparticles and films prepared by flame spray pyrolysis (FSP) were used as photocathodes by Chiang C et al., (2011). The optical band gap was decreased from 1.68 eV to 1.44 eV with the annealing temperature increasing from room temperature to 600°C. The nanoparticle size is from 50 nm to 150 nm, as shown in Fig. 5.The best photocurrent density is 1.2 mA/cm2 obtained from CuO particles which were annealed at 600 °Cfor 3 hour. The bias voltage is 0.55 V in 1M KOH. The total conversion efficiency is 1.48% and the hydrogen generation efficiency is 0.91%.
6.Terminologies associated with the photo fuel cells
6.1. Optical absorption coefficient for band gap determination
The optical absorption coefficient, α, is related to the wavelength, transmittance, reflectance of the light illuminating on a material. Low absorption coefficient means low photo absorption ability. The following equation holds (Pihosh Y et al., 2009)
where T is the transmittance, R the reflectance, and d the thickness of the material. The term hrefers to the photon energy.
The optical coefficient is used to obtain the band gap Egfollowing
6.2. Roughness factor
Roughness factor is related to the surface area of an electrode. For nanotubes, the geometry roughness is calculated as (Shankar K et al., 2007)
whereDis theinner diameter,Wthewall thicknessand L the tube length of the nanotubes. From the experiment on titania nanotubes by Isimjan TT et al., (2012), a higher surface area (roughness) was obtained at higher processing voltages. At a constant voltage, the pore size of nanotubes is dependent of distance between anode and cathode in the electrochemical process.
6.3. Photo conversion efficiency
The photo conversion efficiency is the overall efficiency of a PEC which can be defined by the following equation
7. Nanostructures photoanodematerials processing
7.1. TiO2nanotube (TNT)photoanode
TiO2 nanotubes on the surface of Ti as shown in Fig. 6 demonstrate a self-organized nanostructure. The advantage of the nanobutes is the high surface/volume ratio. TiO2nanotubes have active photo catalysis characteristic, good corrosion resistance, thermal stability and good operation stability as described by Mahajan V et al., (2008). TiO2 nanotubes can be made by various ways including hydro/solvothermal method (Kasuga T et al., 1998), template-assisted approach (carbon nanotube, alumina or monocrystal as the template), sol–gel method (Kasuga T et al., 1998), microwave irradiation (Zhao Q et al., 2009),and direct electrochemicalanodization. The advantage of the hydro/solvothermal method is easy to operate. The disadvantage is that only disordered and twisted TiO2 nanotubes can be obtained. For the template-assisted method, the size of the nanobutes is uniform. For the electrochemical anodic oxidation method, it has the advantage of easy to operate and the obtained nanotubes are highly ordered. Therefore, many researchers prefer the electrochemical method.
7.1.1. Hydrothermal treatment
Hydrothermal method is one of the popular approaches to prepare TNTs. The first group having successfully fabricated TiO2 nanotubes by hydrothermal method is Kasuga T et al., in 1998. During the process, titaniananopowdersare placed in alkaline aqueous solutions held in high pressure steel vessels. The temperate should be between 50-180°C. The process continues for 10 to 20 hours. Some post treatment can be applied, for example, washing with acid or alkaline solutions for 10 hours, drying at 80 °C and annealing at 500 °C. The reaction process is divided into four steps (Hafez H et al., 2009) i.e. (1) synthesis of TiO2 nanotubes in alkaline aqueous solutions, (2) protons replacing alkali ions in the reaction, (3) drying, (4) acid washing (post treatment). There is controversy about the necessity of the acid washing. Some researchers (Liu S et al., 2009) think acid washing is a necessary procedure to form TNTs, but other researchers (Chen X et al., 2007) think hydrothermal is more important than the acid washing step as sketched in Fig. 7. The step of washing by acid is not even necessary to form TNTs.
7.1.2. The effects factors of material and solution
With different raw materials and reaction solutions, the different morphology of TiO2was obtained by hydrothermal method (Yuan ZY et al., 2004). When crystalline TiO2 react with NaOH under 100-160 °C, the TiO2 nanotubes was obtained. When amorphous TiO2 be used under same conditions, the TiO2nanofibers are fabricated. Either crystalline or amorphous TiO2 can be used reaction with NaOH can result TiO2nanoribbons when temperature rise to 180 °C. If the solution used by KOH, the nanowires morphology is formed. The pH value of solution also plays an important role in morphologyof TiO2nanomaterials (Xu YM et al., 2010). Fen LB et al., (2011) used anataseTiO2nanopowders (Aldrich 637254-50G, 99.7%) with NaOH solution fabricated TNTs. The inner diameter is 3-6 nm and wall thickness is 1.9 nm. LanY et al., (2005) used rutile nanopowders with 10 M NaOH solution obtained TNTs which inner diameter 2-3 nm and wall thickness is 7-8 nm, besides the length is 200-300 nm. The inner diameter is smaller but the wall thickness is larger than the TNTs made by Fen LB et al., (2011).
Hydrothermal treatment temperature and time are significant factors during the formation of TNTs. The temperature range should be from 100°C to 180 °C and the time range should be from 1 to 24 hours. Sreekantan S et al., (2010), selected the temperatures at 90, 110, 130, 150 °Cand time for 3, 6, 9, 15, 18, 24 hours. The NaOH/TiO2 solution was used. At 90 °C, the TiO2 particles form sheets. When the temperature was set at 110 °C, the sheets were transformed into nanotubes because the thermal energy increases with temperature (Seo HK et al., 2008). With the temperature increasing to 130, 150 °C, there is no change of the outer diameter (10 nm) of nanotubes but the TNTs transform to anatase phase. For the effect of reaction time, particles begin to form sheet at 3 hours. SreekantanS et al.,(2010) indicated that Ti-O-Ti bond is replaced by Ti–O–Na and Ti–OH bonds at this time. After 6 and 9 hours, more and more sheets form nanotubes (10 nm). After 15 hours, TNTs form completely. They found that 150 °Cis the best temperature for making TNTs with the highest photocatalyticactivity.
SeoHK et al., (2008), studied the phase transformation of TNTs at different hydrothermal temperatures. They used a 10 M NaOH solution and the temperature range was from 70°C to 150 °C. A 0.1 M HCl solution was used for washing the TNTs. They founded that at 70 °C, the particles begun forming nanosheets. Nanosheets and nanofibers co-existed at 90 °C. At 110 °C, the nanosheets were transformed into nanotubes. This conclusion is also reported by Sreekantan S et al., (2009).Hydrothermal processing can also produce nanoribbons instead of nanotubes if the reaction temperature is higher than 180 °C.
7.2. Synthesis of self-organized TiO2 nanotubes via electrochemical anodization
In 1999, Zwilling V et al. first used electrochemical anodization method for synthesis of TiO2 nanotubesin the solution containing chromic acid and hydrofluoric acid. Later many researchers (e.g. MacakJM et al., 2005) showed that using different applied potentials, electrolytes, pH values (much longer nanotubes at neutral pH electrolytes) and anodization time can control the lengths, thickness, diameters and morphology of TiO2 nanotubes.Zeng X et al., (2011), reported electrochemical oxidation of Ti in a1.0 M H3PO4 and 0.25 M NaF solution. With the increasing in the potential, TiO2 experienced three forms. When the potential was very low, Ti dissolved into the solution. With the increasing of potential, Ti was oxidized toform TiO2. When the potential was less than 2.5 V, TiO2 film was obtained. Between 2.5 V and 6.0 V, the TiO2 porous structure formed. When potential was higher than 6, the self-organized TiO2 nanotubes were obtained (Fig. 9b).
Before 2005, all of these researches were exclusively using inorganic solutions as electrolytes, such as HF (Varghese OK et al., 2003), KF, NaF (Cai QY et al., 2005). Macak JM et al., (2005), investigated TiO2 nanotube formation in Na2SO4 electrolytes with NaF. The maximum length of nanotubes was up to 2.4 µm. It takes about 6 hours. But longer than this time, the irregular morphologyshowed up. As compared with HF, NaF can thicker the porous layers. The use of organic electrolytes is a milestone for the TiO2 nanotubes fabrication. Liu H et al., (2011), studied the temperature effect on morphology of TiO2 nanotubes. The specified temperatures are -5, 0, 5, 10, 15 °Cand the applied potentials are 10, 30, 50V. It helped control the nanotube size and structure under the complex condition as show in Fig. 8. In summary, there are two types of electrolytes in TiO2andoization, one is aqueous-based electrolytes, and the other is organics-based electrolytes. Aqueous electrolytes allow the nanotubes to form more quickly because of the low electrical resistance. Besides, lower voltage is enough. However, it is hard to form longer nanotubes because of the dissolution of the nanotubes in the solutions. The organic electrolytes, for example, ethylene glycol and glycerol, have higher electrical resistances. They can slow down the ion transfer. Therefore, higher voltages and longer times are needed. In organic electrolytes, it is easier to form long nanotubes.
During anodization, a constant voltage in the range from 1V to 150V is applied. The electrolytes containing fluorides have the concentration range from 0.05 to 0.5M.The processing time ranges from a few minutes to a couple of days.
There are two main reactions with the anodization of Ti (Macak JM et al., 2005):
First, titanium in the electrolyte produces Ti4+. Then Ti4+ reacts with water to formTiO2and hydrogen ion (Eq. 18).TiO2 becomes oxide film on the surface of the titanium as a barrier layer. Meantime, TiO2 is etched by F- and many holes form in the film (Eq. 19). With the processing time increasing, the holes become deeper and form nanotubes. When the anodization rate of Ti is equal to the etching rate ofTiO2, the process reaches to a steady-state. The length of nanotubes keeps unchanged.
F ion plays an important role in synthesizingTiO2 nanotubes. Fig. 10 shows the results of NTs obtained from different solutions with and without F-. Without F- the TiO2 is flat without porous structure. With F-, reaction (Eq.19) occurs. F ion generates TiF62- which is the driving force of etchingTiO2. H+ can enhance the etching ability of F-. TiF62-ions owing the small diameter can easily move through TiO2 crystal lattice. Comparing the electrolytes containing Cl- and Br- (Chen X et al., 2007),TiO2 nanotubes arrays fabricated in electrolytescontaining F- have better quality. Fluoride concentration can affect the electrochemical characteristics (BeranekR et al., 2003). If the fluoride concentration is low (less than 0.05 wt. %), there are almost no fluoride ions. If the fluoride concentration is high (1 wt. %), no oxide formation can be observed.Ti4+ reacts with F- immediately to form TiF62-. The maximum nanotube length is about 500 nm synthesized in HF electrolytes. The maximum length is several micron meters using NaF andNH4F electrolytes.
The mechanism of TiO2 growth can be shown in Fig. 11. TiO2 grows on the Ti substrate gradually. With the TiO2 film being thicker and thicker, TiO2 has the function of a protecting film to slow down the Ti dissolution. With the development of F- etching TiO2, the self-organized TiO2 nanotubes form as illustrated in Fig.11d.
7.2.2. Synthesis of TiO2 nanotubes using organic electrolytes
Organic electrolytes containing F- have some advantages. In 2005, RuanCM et al. used dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) and ethylalcohol (1:1) as electrolytes for fabricating TiO2 nanotubes with a length of 2.3μm.MacakMJ et al., (2005) used glycerinumsynthesized TiO2 nanotubes with 7μm length. The maximum length could over 1000μm. Prakasam HE et al.,(2007), using ethylene glycol with 1%-3% H2O volume and 0.1% to 0.5 % wt of NH4F solution, anodized Ti foil for 17 h at 20, 40, 50, 60 and 65 V. The result showed that with the increase in the voltage, the inner diameter, outer diameter and length of nanotubes were increased. The maximum values are 135 nm, 185 nm and 105 µm, respectively. The nanotubes grow rate is15 µm/h. The important factor to affect the length of the nanotubes is the water content. The water volume content should be under 5% for obtain good quality of nanotubes. The morphology of TiO2 nanotubesformed in organic electrolytesis more smooth and orderly. Besides, the nanotubes have higher photocatalytic efficiencies.
Non-F- electrolytes were also used (AllamN et al., 2007) for the environmental protection purpose. Pulse anodization (ChanmaneeW et al., 2008)generated TiO2 nanotubeswith good photoelectrochemical property. Glancing angle deposition (GLAD) was used to obtain Ti films. The anodization of the Ti films produced nanotubes and nanorods (NRs) on a glass substrate. Even brush type nanostructures (BTNs) were obtained (Pihosh Y et al., 2009) as shown in Fig. 12. As compared with the plate counterparts, the TiO2 NRs, NTs and BTNs have significantly higher photocatalytic activity under Vis-light and UV illumination. The NTs and BTNs have better photocatalytic activity than the NRs because of their larger surface areas. The BTNs can be obtained by andoization of NRs in base.
7.3. Post-treatmentof TiO2 nanostructures
The purpose of annealing is to change the morphology of TiO2nanotubes from amorphous to crystalline (anatase or rutile). Over the past 10 to 15 years, there were a large number of researchers focusing on annealing. Stem N et al., (2011), thermal treated TiO2 at 1000 °Cin wet N2 for 2 hours, which enhances the photocatalytic performance.Wang MC et al., (2012), showed that annealing temperature affected photocatalytic capability of N-doped TiO2 thin films. The temperature ranges from 250 °C to 550 °C. The time lasts for 1 hour. Below 350 °C, the surface roughness is low. The photocatalytic activity is the highest after the 350 °C annealing. Lin JY et al., (2011), applied the rapid thermal annealing (RTA) method. Thetemperatures been used that were 700, 800, 900, 1000 and 1100 °C. The temperate increasing rate was 5 °C/s. The total annealing time was 30 s in oxygen. Through the X-ray diffraction (XRD) examination, it was found that oxygen-related defects were reduced when the TiO2 nanotubes changed from amorphous to anatase phase. Fang D et al., (2011), studied high temperate calcinations.TiO2 nanotubeswere exposed atthe temperatures of 450,600, 800,and 900°C. The results (Fig. 13) showthat 450 °Chelps generate a pure anatasephase. At 600 °C, a mixed phase of anatase and rutile can be got. At 800°C, pure anatase phase grows into large crystallites. As the conclusion, 450°C is the best calcination temperature. Bauer S et al., (2011), showed that the nanotube’s size affects the crystal phase. When the nanotube’s diameter is smaller than 30 nm, it is more likely to form rutile. In contrary, when the diameter is larger than 30 nm,anatase can be obtained. Not only the temperate, the type of gases used also affects the properties of the nanotubes (Sang LX et al., 2011). Annealing in air (TNT-A), nitrogen (TNT-N) and 5% hydrogen/nitrogen (TNT-H)generate the similar morphology and band gap. But the difference in the UV absorption photocurrent density exists. The maximum photocurrent density is 0.60 mA/cm2 for the nanotubes named as TNT-H. The minimum is 0.27 mA/cm2 for TNT-A. TNT-H has more surface defects. The more surface defects, the higher the photocurrent was generated.
On the contrary to traditional annealing process, Liu JM et al., (2011), performed vacuum annealing and multi-cycle annealing on theNb-doped TiO2 thin film. During the three-cycle vacuum annealing, the TiO2 was heated up to 550 °C(0.05 Pa air pressure) for 1 hour in one cycle. This process was repeated for three times. In another experiment, the TiO2 film was held at 550 °Cat 5 Pa air pressure for 1 hour. Then the annealing was repeated for three times. These two different procedures both can improve the conductivity of the Nb-doped TiO2 thin film. At different annealing temperatures, the TiO2 nanotubes showed different photoelectrochemical characteristics (Tang Y et al., 2008). The treatment temperatures are in the range from 300 °C to 550 °C. Again, the sample annealed at 450 °C showed better performance under UV light. With the UV on, the nanotube electrode showed good photoelectric current stability. When the UV was off, the photocurrent quickly decreased to the initial value.
7.3.2. Ultrasonic clean
During anodization synthesis, TiO2 nanotubes formed, but unexpected deposits may also be on the nanotubes. They can be cleaned by ultrasonic waves (Cai QY et al., 2005).Xu H et al., (2011), applied ultrasonic waves to clean the surface of TiO2 nanotubes for different time periods. They employed the ultrasonic wave with the power of 80 W at40 kHz. 9 min is the best treatment time for cleaning the nanotubes. When the time was extended to 40 min, the nanotubes were broken. The nanotubes were peeled off from the Ti completely at 60min.
There are two main limitations of pure TiO2 nanotubes
Pure TiO2 can only absorb UV light of wavelength shorter than 400 nm because the band gap of TiO2 is 3.2 eV, which means that pure TiO2 can only utilize 6% solar energy. The visible light has the energy band gaps from 1.8 eV to 3.1 eV.
High electrical resistance of pure TiO2 at the room temperature results in very low electron transfer rate. This causes electric energy loss. The converted heat energy dissipates into ambient. At 20 °C, TiO2 is not a conductor. Only when the temperature rises to 400 °C, the resistance of TiO2 becomes lower.
Direct doping is one way to overcome the limitations of pure titania. Another method of doping is to stack different materials which have different band gaps. That could make hybrid photoanode (HPE)as first reported by Morisaki H et al., (1976).
Some noble metals doped to TNTs such as gold (Malwadkar SS et al., 2009), silver (Guo GM et al., 2009), platinum can improve the photocatalytic activity of the TNTs. This is because these noble metals can inhibit recombination of electron (Chan SC et al., 2005). Metal doped-TNTs for photo fuel cell applications are reported.
In addition to using noble metals, Macak JM et al., (2007) showed doping copper by electrodeposition. First, synthesis of TiO2 nanotubes which have low conductivity especially at the bottom of the nanotubes was carried out. Second, using an aqueous electrolyte, about 1% of Ti4+ in the TiO2 outer layer was converted into Ti3+ (Ti4++ e-+ H+= Ti3+H+ and 2H++ 2e-= H2).With Ti3+, the mobility gap of TiO2 was reduced from 3.2 eV to 2.4 eV and the bottom of the nanotubes become highly conductive. The third step is to dope the nanotubes with Cu. Since the bottom has a high conductivity with Ti3+ and H-, Cu is easily be doped in the nanotubes by a current pulsing electroplating approach.
Sun L et al., (2009), fabricated Fe-doped TNTs using Fe ion containing electrolytes. This study shows that the content of Fe3+ is a significant factor affecting the photo catalysis capacity. They used three Fe(NO3)3 solutions for comparison. The concentrations are 0.05M, 0.1M and 0.2M. The result shows that 0.1M Fe(NO3)3doped TNTs have the maximum photo current and photocatalytic degradation rate.0.15M Fe(NO3)3 doped nanotubes have the maximum absorbance under UV-Vis. Different application need different Fe(NO3)3 contents. Tu YF et al., (2010), employed template-based LPD method to dopeFe to TNTs. Redshift of the absorption was found. The best Fe content was 5.9 at %. The doped-TNTs achieved the best efficiency of photo catalysis under visible light. Wu Q et al., (2012), fabricated Fe-doped (Fe2O3 and Fe3+) with ultrasoundassisted impregnating calcinations method. Results showed that Fe2O3 went into the TNTs and Fe3+ into the TiO2 lattice. The operation time and temperatures affect the photo responses of Fe-doped TNTs. Ultrasound treating for 5 min following by annealing at 500 °C provides NTNs the highest photo catalysis efficiency.
C and N doping are non-metal doping examples. B, P, and other nonmetallic dopants are also used. Nitrogen is the earliest, most effective and most studied doping element for TNTs. There are many methods to dope nitrogen into TNTs such as annealing TNTs in ammonia (Vitiello RP, et al., 2006), ion implantation (Ghicov A et al., 2006) etc. Asahi R et al., (2001), doped TiO2 with nitrogen using a solution method. Vitiello RP et al., (2006), showed a simple method for making N-doped TNTs, which is treating TNTs at 300-600 °C in NH3 atmosphere. Results showed that 500 °C-600 °C is the best annealing temperate range at which TNTs transfer to anatase and have the most effective photoresponse.Xu JJ et al., (2010), showed difference in photo catalytic activity between N-doped and Non-doped TiO2 nanotubes under Vis-light. The photocurrent density of N-doped nanotubes was twice as that of the non-doped nanotubes under visible light illumination.Yuan J et al., (2006), synthesized N-doped TiO2 by heating urea with TiO2 at 300-700°C. The doped TiO2 can absorb light with the wavelength up to 600 nm. The result shows that urea changes to chemisorbed N2 and substituted N staying in the TiO2.
Liu ZY et al., (2009), doped carbon into TNTs for solar photochemical cellhydrogen generation. Shaban YA et al., (2007), studied the fabrication time and temperature effects on grooved and non-grooved Ti metal sheet doped with carbon for photochemical catalysis. The result shows that the grooved sample has higher photocurrent density than the non-grooved one. The grooved simple with a depth of 0.005 inch has the maximum photo conversion efficiency of 11.37 % (treated at 820 °C, 18 minutes, thermal flame oxidation, tested in 5.0 M KOH, illuminated by a 150 W Xenon lamp).The non-grooved simple, 0.003 inch grooved one, and 0.001 inch groove done have the maximum photo conversion efficiency of 9.08 %, 8.68 %, 7.20 %, respectively under the same treatment condition.
Co-doping multiple elements was also applied to TiO2 nanotubes. Tungsten and nitrogen co-doping is a typical example (Shen YF et al., 2008). Nitrogen and sulfur (Yan GT et al., 2011), fluorine and boron (Su YL et al., 2008), Pt and N (Huang LH et al., 2007) co-doping has also been studied. Liu SH et al., (2009), developed a carbon and nitrogen co-doping method by adding 5 mg polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) and 20 mg urea. Then calcination was performed in nitrogenat 600 °C. The photocurrent density is 3 times, 2 times, and 1.2 times compared with the non-doped, C-doped and N-doped TiO2 nanotubes under solar light and 0.2 V bias-potential combined excitation. He HC et al., (2011), doped Pt-Ni into NTNs using pulsedelectrodeposition method. The photo catalytic activity is better than that of only Pt-doped NTNs. Pt-Ni doped NTN is a good anode material for photo fuel cell (direct methanol type). The performance of co-doped TNT is better than that of Pt doped one. Huang LH et al., (2007), synthesized Pt-N doped TNTs by two steps. First, they obtained N-doped TNTs. Second, they used H2PtCl6 solution to supply Pt, resulting in Pt-N co-doping. N-doping can enhance the photo response activity and Pt-doping can strengthen the electron separation from holes. Ag can be deposited into N-doped TNTs (Zhang SS et al., 2011), via electrochemical deposition in a0.2 g/L AgNO3 solution. The result shows that the average photocurrent density of the Ag/N-doped TiO2 nanotubes is 6 times higher.
Li XQ et al., (2011), developed the CdS nanoparticle and CuTsPc molecule co-doped TNTs. The I-V curve shows that CdS-CuTsPc has the maximum photocurrent density as compared with CdS-CuTsPc, CdS–CuPc, CdS, and CuTsPc doped TNTs. Jia FZ et al., (2012), successful processedZnS-In2S3-Ag2S doped TiO2-xSxby a two-step(anodization and solvothermal) approach.Zhang X et al. (2009), doped PW12O403− and Cr3+ into TNTs through the anodization and impregnation methods. The function of Cr3+ is narrowing the band gap of TiO2. They have found that the synergetic factor is 1.42. Su Y et al., (2008), doped nitrogen and fluorine into TNTs. They simply usedanodization (20 V) of Ti in the C2H2O4 2H2O+NH4F electrolyte through TiO2 self-organization. After annealing at 400°C, N-F-doped TNTs showed very good photocatalytic ability and stability. The efficiency of methyl orange (MO) decomposition test is higher than 97%. This method avoids using ammonia which is hazardous. With CeO2 nanoparticles being doped into TNTs, enhanced charge storage capacity of TNTs was achieved (Wen H et al., 2011). Wang J et al., (2012), reported a C3N4 doped TiO2nanorod. The UV-Vis absorbance ability of this modified material is as twice as that of the TiO2.
Photoelectrochemical fuel cells have experienced fast development recently because of the progress in nanomaterials. Using various materials processing techniques, it is possible to obtain various nanostructure forms such as nanoparticles, nanorods, nanothin film and nanotubes for photo fuel cell applications. There are many ways for fabricating nanostructures including hydro/solvothermal method, template-assisted method, sol–gel method, microwave irradiation method and electrochemical direct anodizaiton method. Electrochemical anodization becomes a popular method in recent years because it is easy to control the size of nanotubes. Typical photo sensitive materials such as TiO2, WO3, Fe2O3, CuO and ZnO have been studied. These materials have different band gaps and many researchers reported how to enhance the photo response of them. Doping is a significant and efficient method for improving the photo response of nanomaterials. Metal doping and Non-metal doping are two major types. Besides, organic doping, co-doping alloys and muti-component materials also result in good performance of PEFCs. In summary, PEFCs represent promising energy conversion systems. Future studies should focus on increasing the photoelectric energy conversion efficiency.
Allam N. Grimes C. Formation of vertically oriented TiO2 nanotube arrays using a fluoride free HCl aqueous electrolyte.
Antoniadou M, Kondarides D, Labou D, Neophytides S, Lianos P. An efficient photoelectrochemical cell functioning in the presence of organic wastes.Solar Energy Materials & Solar Cells.2010; 94; 592-597.
Photoelectrochemical oxidation of organic substances over nanocrystallinetitania: Optimization of the photoelectrochemical cell. Catalysis Today. Antoniadou M. Lianos P. 2009 166 171
Antoniadou M. Lianos P. Production of electricity by photoelectrochemical oxidation of ethanol in a PhotoFuelCell
Asahi R. Morikawa T. Ohwaki T. Aoki K. Taga Y. Visible-light photocatalysis in nitrogen-doped titanium oxides.Science. 2001 269 271
Bak T. Nowotny J. Rekas M. Sorrell C. C. Photo-electrochemical hydrogen generation from water using solar energy. Materials-related aspects
Communications. Bauer S. Pittrof A. Tsuchiya H. Schmuki P. Size-effects in. Ti O. nanotubes Diameter. dependent anatase/rutile. stabilization Electrochemistry. 2011 538 541
Self-organized porous titanium oxide prepared in H2SO4/HF electrolytes.Electrochemical and Solid-State Letters. Beranek R. Hildebrand H. Schmuki P. 2003B 12B14.
Cai Q. Y. Paulose M. Varghese O. K. CA Grimes The effect of electrolyte composition on the fabrication of self-organized titanium oxide nanotube arrays by anodic oxidation
Chakrapani V. Thangala J. Sunkara M. K. W. O. nanowire W. N. arrays for. photoelectrochemical hydrogen. production
Chan SC, Barteau MA. Preparation of highly uniform Ag/TiO2 and Au/TiO2 supported nanoparticle catalysts by photodeposition.Langmuir. 2005 5588 5595
Chang C. Wang C. Tseng C. Cheng K. Hourng L. Tsai B. Self-oriented iron oxide nanorod array thin film for photoelectrochemical hydrogen production
Formation and characterization of self-organized TiO2 nanotube arrays by pulse anodization.Journal of the American Chemical Society. Chanmanee W. Watcharenwong A. Chenthamarakshan C. R. Kajitvichyanukul P. Tacconi N. Rajeshwar K. 2008 965 974
Chen X. Schriver M. Suen T. Mao S. S. Fabrication of. . nm diameter. Ti O. nanotube arrays. by titanium. anodization Thin. Solid Films. 2007 8511 8514
Chen XB, Mao SS. Titanium dioxide nanomaterials: synthesis, properties, modifications and applications. Chemical Reviews. 2007 2891 2959
Copper oxide nanoparticle made by flame spray pyrolysis for photoelectrochemical water splitting-Part II. Photoelectrochemicalstudy.International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. Chiang C. Aroh K. Franson N. Satsangi V. Dass S. Ehrman S. 2011 15519 15529
Fang D. Luo Z. P. Huanga K. L. Lagoudas D. C. Effect of heat treatment on morphology, crystalline structure and photocatalysis properties of TiO2 nanotubes on Ti substrate and freestanding membrane. 2011 6451 6461
Fen LB, Han TK, Nee NM, Ang BC, Johan MR.Physico-chemical properties of titania nanotubes synthesized via hydrothermal and annealing treatment.Applied Surface Science. 2011 431 435
Fujishima A. Honda K. Electrochemical photolysis of water at a semiconductor electrode.
Gan Y. Gan B. Su L. Biophotofuel cell anode containing self-organized titanium dioxide nanotube arrayMaterials Science and Engineering B. 2011 1197 1206
AngewandteChemie International Edition. Ghicov A. Aldabergerova S. Tsuchiya H. Schmuki P. Ti O. Nb O. nanotubes with. electrochemically tunable. morphologies Angewandte. 2006 6993 6996
Ghicov A. Macak J. M. Tsuchiya H. Kunze J. Haeublein V. Frey L. Schmuki P. Ion implantation and annealing for an efficient N-doping of TiO2 nanotubes.
Nature. Gratzel M. Photoelectrochemical cells. 2001 338 344
Synthesis and photocatalytic applications of Ag/TiO Guo G. M. Yu B. B. Yu P. Chen X. 2nanotubes.Talanta. 2009
Communications. He H. C. Xiao P. Zhou M. Zhang Y. H. Jia Y. C. Yu S. J. Preparation of. well-distributed-Ni Pt. nanoparticles on/into. Ti O. N. Ts by. pulse electrodeposition. for methanol. photoelectro-oxidation Catalysis. 2011 140 143
Science. Huang L. H. Sun C. Liu Y. L. Pt N-codoped. Ti O. nanotubes its photocatalytic. activity under. visible light. Applied Surface. 2007 7029 7035
Isimjan T. T. Rohani S. Ray A. K. Photoelectrochemical water splitting for hydrogen generation on highly ordered TiO2 nanotubes fabricated by using Ti as cathode.
Jia FZ, Yao ZP, Jiang ZH, Li CX.Preparation of carbon coated TiO2 nanotubes film and its catalytic application for H2generation.Catalysis Communications. 2011 497 501
Kaneko M. Nemoto J. Ueno H. Gokan N. Ohnuki K. Horikawa M. Saito R. Shibata T. Photoelectrochemical reaction of biomass and bio-related compounds with nanoporous TiO2 film photoanode and O2 reducing cathode
Kasuga T. Hiramatsu M. Hoson A. Sekino T. Niihara K. Formation of titanium oxide nanotubeLangmuir. 1998 3160 3163
Advanced Functional Materials. Lan Y. Gao X. P. Zhu H. Y. Zheng Z. F. Yan T. F. Wu F. Ringer S. P. Song D. Y. Titanate nanotubes. nanorods prepared. from rutile. powder 2005 1310 1318
Enhanced photoelectrochemical properties of TiO2 nanotubes co-sensitized with US nanoparticles and tetrasulfonated copper phthalocyanine. Colloids and Surfaces A: Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects. Li X. Q. Cheng Y. Liu L. F. Mu J. 2011 226 231
Lianos P. Production of electricity and hydrogen by photocatalytic degradation of organic wastes in a photoelectrochemical cellThe concept of the Photofuelcell: A review of a re-emerging research field.
Lin JY, Chou YT, Shen JL, Yang MD, Wu CH, Chi GC, Chou WC, Ko CH.Effects of rapid thermal annealing on the structural properties of TiO2 nanotubes.Applied Surface Science. 2011 530 534
Optimal self-organized growth of small anodic TiO2 nanotubes with "micro-annealing" effect under complex conditions via reaction-diffusion approach.ElectrochimicaActa. Liu H. Tao L. Shen W. Z. 2011 3905 3913
Liu J. M. Zhao X. Duan L. Cao M. Sun H. Shao J. Chen S. Xie H. Chang X. Chen C. Influence of annealing process on conductive properties of Nb-doped TiO2 polycrystalline films prepared by sol-gel method.
Liu S. Yang L. Xu S. Luo S. Cai Q. Photocatalytic activities of C-N-doped TiO2 nanotube array/carbon nanorod composite.
Liu SH, Yang LX, XuSH,Luo SL, Cai QY.Photocatalytic activities of C-N-doped TiO2 nanotube array/carbon nanorod composite.Electrochemistry Communications. 2009 1748 1751
Efficient electricity production and simultaneously wastewater treatment via a high-performance photocatalytic fuel cell. Water research. Liu Y. Li J. Zhou B. Li X. Chen H. Chen Q. Wang Z. Li L. Wang J. Cai W. 2011 3991 3998
Liu Z. Y. Pesic B. Raja K. S. Rangaraju R. R. Misra M. Hydrogen generation under sunlight by self ordered TiO2 nanotube arrays
Current Opinion in Solid State and Materials Science. Macak J. M. Tsuchiya H. Ghicov A. Yasuda K. Hahn R. Bauer S. Schmuki P. Ti O. nanotubes Self-organized. electrochemical formation. properties applications 2007 3 18
Macak J. M. Tsuchiya H. Schmuki P. High-aspect-ratio Ti. O. nanotubes by. anodization of. titanium Angewandte. Chemie International. Edition 2005 2100 2102
Edition. Macak J. M. Tsuchiya H. Taveira L. Aldabergerova S. Schmuki P. Smooth anodic. Ti O. nanotubes Angewandte. Chemie International. 2005 44 7463 7465
Advanced Materials. Macak J. M. Gong B. G. Hueppe M. Schumk P. Filling of. Ti O. Nanotubes by. self-Doping Electrodeposition 2007 3027 3031
Mahajan V. Mohapatra S. Misra M. Stability of. Ti O. nanotube arrays. in photoelectrochemical. studies
Malwadkar SS, Gholap RS, Awate SV, Korake PV, Chaskar MG, Gupta NM.Physico-chemical, photo-catalytic and O 2-adsorption properties of TiO2 nanotubes coated with gold nanoparticles.
Miller EL, Rocheleau RE, Deng XM.Design considerations for a hybrid amorphous silicon/photoelectrochemicalmultijunction cell for hydrogen production. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. 2003 615 623
Minggu LJ, Daud WRW, Kassim MB, Cronin SB.An overview of photocells and photoreactors for photoelectrochemical water splitting.International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. 2010 5233 5244
Photoelectrolysis of water with TiO2 covered solar-cell electrodes. ApplPhysLett. Morisaki H. Watanabe T. Iwase M. Yazawa K. 1976 338 340
Ollis DF.Photocatalytic purification and remediation of contaminated air and water.CompetesRendus Del Academie Des Sciences SerieII Fascicule C-Chimie. 2000 405 411
Park KW, Han SB, Lee JM.Photo(UV)-enhanced performance of Pt-TiO2 nanostructure electrode for methanol oxidation.Electrochemistry Communications. 2007 1578 1581
Patsoura A. Kondarides D. I. Verykios X. E. Enhancement of photoinduced hydrogen production from irradiated Pt/TiO2 suspensions with simultaneous degradation of azo-dyes
Pihosh Y. Turkevych I. Ye J. Goto M. Kasahara A. Kondo M. Tosa M. Photocatalytic Properties of TiO2 Nanostructures Fabricated by Means of Glancing Angle Deposition and Anodization.
Prakasam H. E. Shankar K. Paulose M. Varghese O. K. CA Grimes A. new benchmark. for Ti. O. nanotube array. growth by. anodization
Photochemical production of hydrogen with zinc-sulfide suspensions.Journal of Physical Chemistry. Reber J. F. Meier K. 1984 5903 5913
Ruan C. M. Paulose M. Varghese O. K. Mor G. K. CA Grimes Fabrication of highly ordered TiO2 nanotube arrays using an organic electrolyte.Journal of Physical Chemistry B. 2005 15754 15759
Sakthivel S. Shankar M. V. Palanichamy M. Arabindoo B. Bahnemann D. W. Murugesan V. Enhancement of photocatalytic activity by metal deposition: characterisation and photonic efficiency of Pt, Au and Pd deposited on TiO2 catalyst
Sang LX, Zhang ZY, Ma CF. Photoelectrical and charge transfer properties of hydrogen-evolving TiO2 nanotube arrays electrodes annealed in different gases.
Seo H. K. Kim G. S. Ansari S. G. Kim Y. S. Shin H. S. Shim K. H. Suh E. K. A. study on. the structure/phase. transformation of. titanate nanotubes. synthesized at. various hydrothermal. temperatures
Shaban YA, Khan SUM.Surface grooved visible light active carbon modified (CM)-n-TiO2 thin films for efficient photoelectrochemical splitting of water. Chemical Physics. 2007 73 85
Nanotechnology. Shankar K. Mor G. K. Prakasam H. E. Yoriya S. Paulose M. Varghese O. K. CA Grimes Highly-ordered. Ti O. nanotube arrays. up to. 2. μm in. length use. in water. photoelectrolysis dye-sensitized solarcells. 2007
Tungsten and nitrogen co-doped TiO2nano-powders with strong visible light response. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental. Shen Y. F. Xiong T. Y. Li T. F. Yang K. 2008 177 185
Study on the formation and photocatalytic activity of titanate nanotubes synthesized via hydrothermal method.Journal of Alloys and Compounds. Sreekantan S. Wei L. C. 2010 436 442
Microscale meshes of Ti3O5nano- and microfibers prepared via annealing of C-doped TiO2 thin films. Materials Science and Engineering B. Stem N. Chinaglia E. F. dos Santos. Filho S. G. 2011 1190 1196
Su Y. Chen S. O. Quan X. Zhao H. M. Zhang Y. B. A. silicon-doped Ti. O. nanotube arrays. electrode with. enhanced photoelectrocatalytic. activity
Physics. Su Y. L. Han S. Zhang X. W. Chen X. Q. Lei L. C. Preparation visible-light-driven photoelectrocatalytic. properties of. boron-doped Ti. O2nanotubes Materials. Chemistry 2008 239 246
Sun L. Li J. Wang C. L. Li F. Chen H. B. Lin C. J. An electrochemical strategy of doping Fe3+ into TiO2 nanotube array films for enhancement in photocatalytic activitySolar Energy Materials and Solar Cells. 2009 1875 1880
ACTA Physico-ChimicaSinica. Tang Y. Tao J. Zhang Y. Wu T. Tao H. Bao Z. Preparetion Characterization of. Ti O. Nanotube Arrays. via Anodization. of Titanium. Films Deposited. on F. T. O. Conducting Glass. at Room. Temperature A. C. T. 2008 2191 2197
Tu YF, Huang SY, Sang JP, Zou XW.Preparation of Fe-doped TiO2 nanotube arrays and their photocatalytic activities under visible light.Materials Research Bulletin. 2010 224 229
Crystallization and high-temperature structural stability of titanium oxide nanotube arrays.Journal of Materials Research. Varghese O. K. Gong D. W. Paulose M. CA Grimes Dickey. E. C. 2003 156 165
N-Doping of anodic TiO2 nanotubes using heat treatment in ammonia Electrochemistry Communications. Vitiello R. P. Macak J. M. Ghicov A. Tsuchiya H. Dick L. F. P. Schmuki P. N. 2006 544 548
Modification of TiO2nanorod arrays by graphite-like C3N4 with high visible light photoelectrochemical activity. ElectrochimicaActa. Wang J. Zhang W. 2012 10 16
Wang MC, Lin HJ, Wang CH, Wu HC.Effects of annealing temperature on the photocatalytic activity of N-doped TiO2 thin films.Ceramics International. 2012 195 200
Wen H. Liu Z. Yang Q. Li Y. Jerry Yu. J. Synthesis and electrochemical properties of CeO2 nanoparticle modified TiO2 nanotube arrays. ElectrochimicaActa. 2011 2914 2918
Wu Q. Ouyang J. J. Xie K. P. Sun L. Wang M. Y. Lin C. J. Ultrasound-assisted synthesis. visible-light-driven photocatalytic. activity of. Fe-incorporated Ti. O. nanotube array. photocatalysts Journal. of Hazardous. Materials 2012 410 417
Xu H. Zhang Q. Zheng C. L. Yan W. Chu W. Application of ultrasonic wave to clean the surface of the TiO2 nanotubes prepared by the electrochemical anodization.
Xu JJ, Ao YH, Chen MD, Fu DG.Photoelectrochemical property and photocatalytic activity of N-doped TiO2 nanotube arrays.Applied SurfaceScience. 2010 4397 4401
Xu YM, Fang XM, Xiong JA, Zhang ZG.Hydrothermal transformation of titanate nanotubes into single-crystalline TiO2nanomaterials with controlled phase composition and morphology. Materials Research Bulletin. 2010 799 804
Materials Chemistry and Physics. Yan G. T. Zhang M. Hou J. Yang J. J. Photoelectrochemical photocatalytic properties. of N. plus S. co-doped Ti. O. nanotube array. films under. visible light. irradiation 2011 553 557
Yuan J. Chen M. X. Shi J. W. Shangguan W. F. Preparations photocatalytic hydrogen. evolution of. N-doped Ti. O. from urea. titanium tetrachloride. International Journal. of Hydrogen. Energy 2006 1326 1331
Yuan Z. Y. Su B. L. Titanium oxide. nanotubes nanofibers. nanowires Colloids. Surfaces A. Physicochemical Engineering Aspects. 2004 173 183
Amphiphilic and photocatalyticbehaviors of TiO2 nanotube arrays on Ti prepared via electrochemical oxidation. Electrochemistry Communications Zeng X. Gan Y. Clark E. Su L. 2009 1748 1751
Catalysis Communications. Zhang S. S. Peng F. Wang H. J. Yu H. Zhang S. Q. Yang J. Zhao H. J. Electrodeposition preparation. of Ag. loaded N-doped. Ti O. nanotube arrays. with enhanced. visible light. photocatalytic performance. 2011 689 693
Technology. Zhang X. Lei L. Zhang J. Chen Q. Bao J. Fang B. Preparation of. P. W. O403−-Ti Cr. nanotubes O. photocatalysts with. the high. visible light. activity Separation. Purification 2009 50 57
Zhang XW, Lei LC, Zhang JL, Chen QX, Bao JG, Fang B.A novel CdS/S-TiO2nanotubes photocatalyst with high visible light activity.Separation and PurificationTechnology. 2009 433 433
Zhao Q. Li M. Chu J. Y. Jiang T. S. Yin H. B. Preparation characterization. of Au. (or Pt)-loaded. titania nanotubes. their photocatalytic. activities for. degradation of. methyl orange. Applied Surface. Science 2009 3773 3778
Zwilling V. Darque-Ceretti E. Boutry-Forveille A. David D. Perrin M. Y. Aucouturier M. Structure and physicochemistry of anodic oxide films on titanium and TA6V alloySurf Interface Anal. 1999 629 637