Open access peer-reviewed chapter - ONLINE FIRST

Death and Grief: A Complex Thought Point of View

Written By

Luz Marina Cano Molano

Submitted: 02 July 2023 Reviewed: 08 July 2023 Published: 16 March 2024

DOI: 10.5772/intechopen.1003065

Palliative Care - Current Practice and Future Perspectives IntechOpen
Palliative Care - Current Practice and Future Perspectives Edited by Georg Bollig

From the Edited Volume

Palliative Care - Current Practice and Future Perspectives [Working Title]

Georg Bollig and Erika Zelko

Chapter metrics overview

18 Chapter Downloads

View Full Metrics

Abstract

The ultimate goal of palliative care is to alleviate the suffering of both the patient and his family, through the proper understanding, detection, and control of physical, psychosocial, and spiritual symptoms experienced by patients at the end of life, regardless of diagnosis. But, while it is true that death is a natural phenomenon, the process of dying is treated as a disease, and today, we are experiencing the medicalization of death. As a consequence, many people die in hospitals in the most extreme loneliness and pain. In other cases, service provision models have been dichotomized to the point of providing aggressive curative treatment and establishing palliative measures in the face of therapeutic failure. The consequence of this reality is that patients and families are left in the middle of an economic and social conflict, since they do not find a team that allows them to understand the nature of the disease, the diagnosis, and the prognosis, this being a crucial aspect for the decision-making at the end of life.

Keywords

  • death
  • grief
  • complex thought
  • palliative care
  • interdisciplinary team

1. Introduction

The validation of complexity in biopsychosocial processes forces educational institutions to train new professionals with a high degree of comprehensiveness, Palliative Care—Current Practice and Future Perspectives with programs that allow reality to be constructed from multidimensionality, with clear and innovative ideas, objective judgments, assertive decisions, metacognitive skills, which can articulate the previous knowledge with the new one, and understand the multiplicity in the unit. This implies a wide-ranging reconstruction of the curricular structure. On the other hand, the art of caring is an action whose destiny is the good of a human being and his family in a society. Although physicians dedicate much of their training and assistance to the reproduction and maintenance of life, the end of life is relegated to a few pain specialists and spiritual practices that allow patients and their families to accept and resign from the death process. Precisely, the center of palliative care is the human being, and his family to whom palliative care is directed, care at the end of life. The foregoing means that for an effective implementation, a deep knowledge of human reality is required, not only in its somatic or biological aspects but in all the environmental, psychological, social, and spiritual dimensions of the individual. Additionally, death constitutes one of the fundamental themes of philosophy, psychology, and medicine.

Questions about the meaning of death, its reason for being, and the other questions that arise around it are a constant topic in human history. But beyond death, one of the most studied and least multidisciplinary intervened aspects is the meaning of suffering.

Caring for a human being means accompanying him/her/them, being with him, ensuring him/her/them autonomy, and assisting him in his vulnerability. Palliative care is a specific way of applying this care. Likewise, from the transdisciplinary point of view that the work of caring for a patient can acquire, we can refer to the fact that it is about accompanying the human being in their process of illness and death. Here, death not only becomes a problem but life itself and, therefore, entails a series of bioethical and multidimensional issues. When the human being lives in the vicinity of death, he feels and perceives it with greater impetus. He becomes aware of his radical and challenging character. Therefore, in the care of a person at the end of life, the perception of death must be considered very seriously, since this perception, the sense or nonsense of it, is directly related to the person’s state of mind dying. For this reason, before being with this class of patients, it is pertinent and responsible to theoretically confront one’s own death, and that of close beings, in order to intervene around it. This scenario is the engine of this research work. Within the course of life, we do not choose to die, but we have the fundamental right to decide how we will die. Therefore, a qualified team is required to provide comprehensive, loving, and compassionate care at the end of life. This chapter describes the phenomenon of dying from a complex thought point of view. Literature gives a wide definition of death. We know what death is, we have experience the loss of a love one. So, this chapter will introduce the key elements of the phenomenon of dying, starting with understanding what complexity is and why this stage of life must be assessed by a transdisciplinary palliative care team [1, 2].

1.1 What is death?

Death is an inevitable part of life, and yet dying remains one of the most complex and emotional journeys one can undertake. At the heart of dying complexity lies the many different factors that shape our experience of life’s final chapter. Medical, cultural, spiritual, ethical, and emotional considerations all play a role in shaping the way we approach mortality both as individuals and as a society. This chapter explores the complexity of dying and the many factors that contribute to this experience. We will examine the physical and emotional aspects of dying, the role of culture and spirituality, the ethical issues that arise, and the impact of technology and legal considerations. Additionally, we will delve into the different types of dying experiences, from those facing terminal illness to those experiencing sudden death or trauma. By exploring these many facets of death and dying, we hope to provide a more comprehensive understanding of this universal human experience. We also hope to promote greater empathy and compassion for those facing the end of life [1].

1.2 The process of dying

Dying is a complex process that involves many changes to the body. When an individual is dying, their body shuts down slowly, eventually leading to organ failure and ultimately death. According to Matzo [3], there are many physical changes during the dying process, including decreased appetite, difficulty swallowing, and difficulty sleeping. Symptoms such as fatigue, confusion, and a change in breathing pattern are also common.

The way a person dies can be affected by the specific illness or injury they are facing. For example, in cases of terminal cancer, the dying process may be prolonged and painful, as the cancer cells continue to rapidly divide and cause widespread damage. In contrast, individuals facing sudden acute injuries, such as severe head trauma or a heart attack, may die more quickly due to the sudden shock to their system. These differences in dying experiences are explored in Chochinov’s work [4].

In addition to the physical manifestations experienced during the process of dying, various medical interventions and treatments can be utilized to alleviate these symptoms and enhance the individual’s overall well-being. As highlighted by Kamal and Bull [5], palliative care plays a crucial role in end-of-life care by concentrating on effectively managing symptoms, providing emotional and psychological support, and addressing spiritual needs. Moreover, medical interventions such as pain management, oxygen therapy, and adequate hydration can be employed to enhance the patient’s comfort and offer support throughout this challenging journey.

Supporting individuals through the difficult and distressing process of dying, both for the person experiencing it and their loved ones, involves several important approaches. For instance, incorporating comfort care interventions such as music therapy, massage, and aromatherapy can help alleviate physical and emotional symptoms commonly associated with the dying process [4]. Additionally, family members and caregivers play a crucial role in providing emotional assistance and ensuring that the individual’s preferences for end-of-life care are respected. By gaining an understanding of the physical transformations that take place during the dying process, we can foster greater empathy toward those embarking on this challenging journey and deliver more compassionate and effective end-of-life support.

1.3 The emotional and psychological dimensions of the dying process

The emotional and psychological dimensions of the dying process can present challenges and complexities comparable to the physical transformations. When confronted with the reality of their impending death, individuals often undergo a broad spectrum of emotions, encompassing fear, anger, sadness, and acceptance. MonforteRoyo, Villavicencio-Chávez, Tomás-Sábado, and Balaguer’s study [5] revealed that those facing an incurable illness commonly experience a deep sense of vulnerability and a loss of control, which evokes intense emotional responses to the knowledge of their approaching demise. Individuals who are approaching the end of their lives often grapple with the daunting realization of their impending mortality, which can make coping immensely challenging. This awareness may lead to the manifestation of anxiety, depression, and various forms of spiritual and emotional distress. During this time, the support and presence of family members and caregivers become crucial, as they provide much needed emotional solace and aid in navigating these difficulties. Breitbart et al. [6] suggest that implementing supportive care measures such as counseling, spiritual guidance, and art therapy can offer individuals confronting the end of life an opportunity to discover a sense of purpose and find meaning in their remaining days.

An important aspect of providing end-of-life care involves upholding the dying individual’s wishes and values. This encompasses considerations such as religious or cultural practices and preferences for the involvement of caregivers. Maintaining consistent communication among the dying person, their loved ones, and healthcare providers is crucial to establishing a shared understanding of the individual’s goals for end-of-life care [7]. Open and transparent communication fosters an environment that can alleviate anxiety and instill a sense of control, benefiting both the dying person and their loved ones.

In the end, the emotional and psychological aspects of the dying process are profoundly unique and personal to each individual. Nevertheless, caregivers and loved ones hold a crucial position in offering support and solace throughout this demanding period. By comprehending the intricate emotional responses that individuals may undergo, providing empathetic emotional assistance, and promoting open communication, we can contribute to the attainment of peace and comfort for those approaching the end of their lives [1, 8].

The following are the key aspects that will act as quality-of-life dimensions that interact simultaneously in the dying individual:

  1. The physical process of dying: What happens to the body during the dying process? How do various illnesses or injuries affect the way a person dies?

  2. The emotional and psychological aspects of dying: How do people typically react emotionally to knowing that death is imminent? How can caregivers and loved ones better support those who are dying?

  3. Cultural and historical perspectives on death: How have different cultures and societies approached death, mourning, and bereavement throughout history?

  4. Are there differences in how people approach death depending on their cultural background?

  5. The complexities of grief and bereavement: What is the grieving process like for those left behind after someone dies? How can people work through their grief in a healthy way?

  6. Ethical issues related to death and dying: How do we determine when to stop medical interventions in end-of-life situations? What are some of the ethical considerations that come up when making decisions about death and dying?

  7. The role of spirituality in dying: How do different belief systems approach death and the afterlife? How can spirituality supports individuals and loved ones facing end-of-life issues?

  8. Legal considerations related to death and dying: What are some of the legal issues that arise in end-of-life situations? How do laws and regulations vary by geographic location?

  9. The impact of technology on death and dying: How have medical advancements and technology impacted the way we approach death and dying? What are some of the new ethical dilemmas that arise as technology advances in this area?

  10. Caregiver burnout and support: How do caregivers cope with the emotional and physical demands of caring for someone who is dying? What support is available for caregivers during the dying process and beyond?

  11. Different types of death: How does the process of dying differ for those who have a terminal illness versus those who experience sudden death or trauma? How do different types of death impact the grieving process and those left behind?

  12. Death rituals and funeral practices: How do different cultures approach death rituals and funeral practices? Are there any universal practices that span cultures and religions?

1.4 Edgar Morin’s perspective on the complexity of dying and importance of death rituals

Edgar Morin, a philosopher and anthropologist, has extensively explored the subject of death and dying. A central aspect of his perspective is the belief that death is an inherent part of the human journey, and confronting it is essential for a truly meaningful existence [9].

According to Morin, death transcends individual experiences and holds a collective significance, impacting entire communities. He posits that societies develop rituals and traditions surrounding death as a means to navigate the loss of loved ones and find understanding within their own mortality [10].

In his work “Penser la Mort” (Thinking about Death), Edgar Morin presents his perspective that death should not be perceived as an ultimate end but rather as a transformative process that leads to rebirth. According to Morin, death is an integral part of the natural cycle of life, and rather than fearing it, we should embrace its significance [11].

Morin further contends that death is a concept influenced by social and cultural factors. He argues that different societies exhibit distinct approaches to death, each with its own set of rituals and customs. For instance, certain cultures regard death as a natural component of life and commemorate it as a means to pay tribute to the departed, while others view it as a tragic event to be avoided by any means necessary.

Morin emphasizes the interconnection between our perception of death and our comprehension of life. He proposes that cultivating a healthy attitude toward death necessitates a comprehensive understanding of life, encompassing its diverse facets including joys and sorrows, as well as successes and failures [12]. Moreover, Morin posits that our fear of death originates from our limited awareness and knowledge about it. He suggests that we can transcend this fear by expanding our understanding of death through dialog, reflection, and education [13].

Morin underscores the significance of proactive engagement in the presence of death. He proposes that instead of postponing it until the final moments, we should prepare for death by leading lives filled with intention and purpose [14]. Additionally, Morin presents a distinct and thought-provoking viewpoint on death. He advocates for perceiving death as an inherent component of life, urging us to accept and find reconciliation with it. Through his work, he challenges us to critically evaluate our approaches to death and explore how our attitudes toward death shape not only our own lives but also the lives of those around us [15].

Furthermore, Edgar Morin has dedicated extensive work to exploring the significance of death rituals within human societies. In his book “La Rumeur d’Orléans” (The Rumor of Orleans), Morin asserts that death rituals extend beyond cultural expressions and serve a vital psychological role in assisting us in coping with the existential realities of life and death. According to Morin, these rituals play a crucial role in acknowledging our own mortality and reaffirming our connection to the broader community we inhabit. He suggests that through these rituals, we can mourn our losses while simultaneously celebrating the lives that were lived.

According to Morin, death rituals present an occasion for both individuals and communities to unite in contemplating the passage of time and the inevitability of death. He proposes that rituals such as wakes, funerals, and memorials furnish an opportunity to exchange memories, stories, and emotions, establishing a sense of continuity and connection in the face of bereavement. Furthermore, Morin asserts that death rituals play a crucial role in attributing significance to loss. By providing a framework through which we can process and comprehend death, rituals assist us in reconciling with our own mortality and the departure of our loved ones [12, 14, 15].

Morin also underscores the significance of adapting death rituals to align with the evolving needs of contemporary society. He proposes that these rituals must continuously transform to accommodate the demands of a rapidly changing world, while still providing a vital sense of solace and comfort to those in mourning [12, 14, 15].

Moreover, Morin posits that death rituals offer valuable insights into the cultural, historical, and social contexts in which they are observed. He suggests that scrutinizing these rituals can enrich our comprehension of the values, beliefs, and practices embraced by diverse cultures and societies [12, 14, 15]. Additionally, Morin recognizes that death rituals are not universally standardized, and each society has its own distinct approach to death. He proposes that these differences reflect the remarkable diversity of human experiences, which should be celebrated. Morin also emphasizes the close correlation between our perception of death rituals and our understanding of death itself.

He argues that cultivating a healthy connection with death necessitates a holistic comprehension of life, encompassing its joys and sorrows, and successes and failures [13, 15]. Furthermore, Morin proposes that death rituals should embrace inclusivity, welcoming individuals from diverse backgrounds and walks of life. He argues that genuine compassion necessitates extending our mourning rituals to all members of society, irrespective of their social status or identity [13, 15].

Morin’s perspective on death rituals accentuates their vital role within human society. He suggests that these rituals serve as a means for us to recognize our mortality, grieve our losses, celebrate life, find meaning in death, and cultivate connections with others. Morin also advocates for the evolution of death rituals to meet the evolving needs of contemporary society, promoting inclusive and compassionate approaches, and analyzing these rituals as reflections of cultural and societal values [14, 15].

Throughout history, cultures and societies have exhibited diverse approaches to death, mourning, and bereavement. Varied religious and cultural beliefs have influenced individuals’ perceptions of death and shaped the rituals and customs surrounding the dying process. In certain cultures, death is regarded as a natural and serene transition, while in others, it is considered a tragic event that necessitates intricate mourning practices to honor the departed [16], highlighting that many Eastern cultures, such as China, place significant emphasis on the afterlife within their belief systems regarding death. Ancestor worship and filial piety play central roles in mourning rituals within these cultures.

1.5 Sociocultural aspects of the end of life

An individual’s cultural heritage can have a substantial influence on their attitudes toward and coping mechanisms for death. For instance, cultural practices surrounding mourning and grief can exhibit significant variations, encompassing factors such as the duration of the mourning period and the acceptable range of emotions to be expressed. In certain cultures, mourning is considered a private affair, while in others, it is embraced as a more communal experience. As noted by Zhai and Du [17], cultural values, beliefs, and practices pertaining to grief can impact both the bereavement experience and the efficacy of therapeutic interventions.

Over the course of history, cultures and societies have undergone significant transformations in their attitudes toward death. For instance, during the medieval period in Europe, death was omnipresent and frequently perceived as a divine retribution. Mourning customs were elaborate and often carried out in public, with social status exerting a notable influence on the associated rituals.

In contrast, contemporary Western culture tends to perceive death as a medical occurrence that should be regulated and controlled. As observed by Helm [18], these societal changes have had an impact on individuals’ perspectives and coping mechanisms when it comes to death. In essence, cultural and historical outlooks on death underscore the wide array of human beliefs, values, and customs, and how they shape the end-of-life journey.

By comprehending the cultural variations in death and mourning traditions, healthcare providers can deliver more empathetic and culturally sensitive end-of-life care. This involves collaborating with patients and their families to ensure that end-of-life care decisions align with their cultural and spiritual convictions. Additionally, it entails providing customized emotional support that takes into account the cultural norms surrounding bereavement [19].

1.6 The grieving process

When faced with the loss of a loved one, one pivotal aspect to confront is grief—a complex and highly personalized journey. The grieving process encompasses an array of emotional, physiological, and psychological reactions that can differ significantly based on an individual’s unique connection with the deceased. Emotional responses often encompass feelings of shock, disbelief, anger, guilt, and sadness, while physical manifestations may include fatigue, insomnia, and loss of appetite. Stroebe and Schut [20] emphasize the significance of recognizing that grief is not a linear progression but rather a dynamic and multifaceted experience that can fluctuate and evolve over time.

For individuals, it can be arduous to navigate their grief in a constructive manner, especially when facing more intricate forms of bereavement, such as sudden or traumatic deaths. Adopting healthy coping mechanisms becomes crucial in such cases. These can include seeking solace from loved ones, participating in support groups or therapy sessions, and practicing self-care activities such as exercise or meditation. Nevertheless, certain individuals may necessitate additional interventions or specialized care to address more complex responses to bereavement, such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) or prolonged grief disorder (PGD).

Apart from individual factors, the social and cultural environment surrounding bereavement can also shape how individuals navigate their grief. Cultural norms pertaining to mourning, such as the duration of the mourning period or the acceptable modes of expressing grief, can influence individuals’ perceptions of their own grief and the support they seek. For instance, in certain cultures, grief is regarded as a deeply personal journey to be processed privately, whereas in others, mourning is a communal experience characterized by more open expressions of grief [20].

In general, the intricate nature of grief and bereavement underscores the significance of adopting a compassionate and comprehensive approach to end-of-life care. By recognizing the individual and societal aspects that impact grief, healthcare providers can offer more nuanced and culturally sensitive care, addressing the varied needs and experiences of individuals mourning a loss [20].

1.7 Ethical considerations at the end of life

In recent years, ethical considerations pertaining to end-of-life care have grown increasingly intricate due to advancements in medical technologies and the expanded choices available to individuals regarding medical interventions. One pivotal question that clinicians and families grapple with in end-of-life situations is determining the appropriate time to cease medical interventions. Numerous factors can influence this decision, including the patient’s expressed desires, the severity of their illness, the prospects of recovery, and the potential risks and benefits associated with the interventions [21].

Nonetheless, ultimately, the final decision about when to discontinue medical treatment rests with the individual patient and their loved ones [20].

When faced with decisions concerning death and dying, an array of ethical considerations must be carefully evaluated. One of the foremost factors to consider is the principle of autonomy, which grants individuals the right to make decisions regarding their medical care and treatment. However, autonomy must be balanced with other ethical principles such as non-maleficence, which stipulates that healthcare providers must refrain from causing harm to their patients, and beneficence, which mandates that healthcare providers act in the best interests of their patients.

As an illustration, certain end-of-life scenarios may present challenges in reconciling these principles when the patient’s wishes conflict with the recommendations of healthcare providers [22]. The principle of justice, a crucial ethical consideration, mandates the equitable distribution of healthcare resources. In certain instances, the utilization of extensive medical interventions in end-of-life scenarios might be perceived as an unjust allocation of resources, particularly when other patients could potentially benefit from the same medical technologies. Furthermore, economic factors can also influence decision-making regarding end-of-life care, as certain treatments may entail substantial costs, placing a financial burden on the patient or their family [22].

In general, navigating ethical issues surrounding end-of-life care can be complex. By considering the diverse ethical principles at play and adopting a patient-centered approach to decision-making, healthcare providers can offer more nuanced and compassionate care, ensuring that patients’ preferences are honored, and their dignity is preserved.

1.8 Spirituality, belief systems, and death

Spirituality is a fundamental aspect of the human experience that can provide solace, hope, and a sense of purpose as individuals approach the end of their lives. The role of spirituality in the dying process is intricate and multifaceted, shaped by diverse belief systems and cultural contexts. From traditional religious beliefs to secular philosophies, various approaches to spirituality can significantly influence how individuals and their loved ones confront death and contemplate the concept of an afterlife [23].

Numerous belief systems encompass the concept of an afterlife or spiritual realm, which can evoke feelings of hope or fear contingent upon an individual’s beliefs and personal encounters. Certain religious traditions, such as Christianity and Islam, espouse firm convictions regarding heaven and hell, wherein the departed undergo judgment and are assigned their eternal destination based on their earthly actions. Conversely, other traditions such as Buddhism and Hinduism perceive death as an inherent component of the life cycle, wherein the soul either reincarnates into a new existence or ultimately attains liberation from the cycle of rebirth [8, 24].

Spirituality can have a vital impact on providing support to individuals and their loved ones as they confront end-of-life concerns. Establishing connections with a spiritual community or partaking in personal spiritual practices can bestow solace and furnish a sense of direction and significance in the presence of mortality. Religious and spiritual customs, such as prayer, meditation, and ritual, can serve as avenues for connecting with a higher power or attaining inner tranquility.

Furthermore, spiritual beliefs and practices can assist individuals in finding meaning in their experiences and offer solace and hope to grieving loved ones [25]. In general, the influence of spirituality on the dying process is profoundly personal and influenced by a multitude of factors, encompassing cultural and religious beliefs, individual experiences, and social support systems. By recognizing the significance of spirituality in the journey toward death and honoring the diverse beliefs and practices of individuals and their loved ones, healthcare providers can extend more compassionate and comprehensive care to those grappling with end-of-life matters [26].

1.9 Legal considerations at the end of life

As individuals approach the final stages of their lives, they may confront various legal matters and inquiries pertaining to their care, treatment, and final wishes. Legal considerations related to death and dying can exhibit wide-ranging disparities contingent upon an individual’s geographical location and the specific laws and regulations governing end-of-life care and decision-making.

One of the legal matters that may arise in end-of-life circumstances involves the assessment of decision-making capacity. As individuals approach death, they may become incapable of making decisions regarding their care and treatment, prompting legal inquiries regarding who holds the authority to act on their behalf. Such inquiries can encompass topics related to power of attorney, healthcare proxy, and guardianship laws.

Another legal consideration in end-of-life situations involves the utilization of advanced directives, which are documents that enable individuals to express their preferences regarding the end-of-life care and treatment. Advanced directives can include living wills, which outline specific medical interventions and procedures, as well as durable power of attorney for healthcare, which designates someone to make medical decisions on behalf of the individual. Laws regarding advanced directives can vary across states and countries, underscoring the importance of familiarizing oneself with local regulations.

In certain instances, legal matters pertaining to end-of-life care may involve disagreements between family members or healthcare providers concerning the most appropriate course of action. These disputes can encompass conflicts over decision-making authority, issues surrounding medical consent, and questions regarding the legality of specific treatments or procedures. In such situations, seeking legal counsel may be necessary to resolve conflicts and ensure the individual’s wishes are honored [27, 28].

Laws and regulations concerning end-of-life care and decision-making can exhibit significant variations based on geographical location, reflecting cultural, religious, and social distinctions. For instance, in some countries, euthanasia or physician-assisted suicide may be legally permissible under certain circumstances, while in others, these practices are strictly prohibited. Similarly, laws relating to organ donation, funeral and burial arrangements, and estate planning can differ substantially among states or countries [27, 28].

In general, the legal aspects pertaining to death and dying are intricate and diverse, contingent upon factors such as an individual’s specific situation, cultural heritage, and geographical setting. By comprehending the array of legal issues and regulations, healthcare providers and family members can offer enhanced support to patients, ensuring that their preferences are acknowledged and upheld [27, 28]. Conversely, the progress of technology has exerted a substantial influence on our perception and handling of death and the dying process. Medical breakthroughs and emerging technologies have facilitated enhanced diagnoses, treatments, and palliative care, resulting in extended life expectancies and better quality of life for individuals with terminal illnesses. However, this advancement has also introduced novel ethical predicaments as we navigate end-of-life care, relying on progressively sophisticated machines and interventions.

1.10 Technology and the end of life

One of the primary consequences of technology in the realm of death and dying is the capacity to extend life through medical interventions. The progress made in medical technology has led to employ life-sustaining measures such as mechanical ventilation and artificial nutrition and hydration, enabling individuals to survive despite serious illness or injury. While these interventions may grant patients additional time for potential recovery or important decision-making, they can also potentially prolong suffering and may not align with the individual’s personal wishes or values.

The emergence of novel technologies has facilitated the introduction of inventive palliative care interventions, such as virtual reality encounters and therapeutic robots. These resources have the potential to alleviate pain and anxiety, enhance the quality of life for patients, and minimize the requirement for high-risk medical interventions.

Nevertheless, ethical quandaries can emerge when patients favor these technologies over human interaction, or when uncertainty arises regarding whether their implementation aligns with the individual’s personal wishes or values.

Another consequence of technology in relation to death and dying is the capability to preserve bodily functions and genetic data for potential future applications. Practices such as cryonics, which involve freezing the human body with the aspiration of revival in the future, and genetic technologies, which enable embryo selection and gene editing, evoke ethical concerns regarding the intrinsic value of life and the boundaries of medical intervention. As these technologies progress, it becomes crucial to address these dilemmas and ensure that the utilization of technology in end-of-life care adheres to ethical principles.

The utilization of technology in the context of death and dying gives rise to concerns regarding privacy and consent. Electronic health records, online medical platforms, and telemedicine have facilitated convenient access to healthcare services and remote communication with healthcare providers. However, these technologies may also expose patients to a higher risk of data breaches or compromised privacy.

Furthermore, as technology reshapes the dynamics of the doctor-patient relationship and the delivery of medical care, it becomes essential to address matters pertaining to informed consent and the autonomy of patients and their families.

In general, the influence of technology on death and dying has been substantial and diverse. As we progress in the development of new technologies, it becomes crucial to thoroughly examine their ethical ramifications and guarantee that they are utilized in a manner that aligns with ethical principles and safeguards individuals involved [29].

Advertisement

2. Caregivers

In addition to the above aspects, caregiver burnout is a prevalent occurrence among individuals providing care for those nearing the end of their lives. The emotional and physical demands of caregiving can lead to persistent stress, fatigue, and feelings of isolation. It is vital for caregivers to recognize and effectively address these challenges in order to provide the best possible care for their loved ones.

One effective approach to addressing caregiver burnout is to make use of support services. Palliative care teams, social workers, and hospice volunteers can provide emotional support, offer education about end-of-life care, and assist with practical tasks and medication management. Furthermore, joining support groups, either in-person or online, can create a sense of community and validation for caregivers who may feel overwhelmed or isolated by their responsibilities.

Caregivers can also benefit from implementing personal coping strategies, such as mindfulness, engaging in regular exercise, or seeking therapy. These practices can help in managing stress, reducing feelings of anxiety and depression, and promoting overall well-being. Additionally, practicing self-compassion and establishing realistic expectations are important for caregivers, as they acknowledge that caregiving is a demanding and emotionally charged experience [29].

As the end-of-life journey progresses, caregivers may find it necessary to seek specialized support. For instance, as a patient’s condition worsens, caregivers may require guidance and assistance in managing symptoms or making difficult decisions. Hospice care teams are available to offer this specialized care, providing pain management and guidance on advanced directives. Moreover, hospice care providers can support caregivers during the bereavement period, offering grief counseling and additional resources to help them navigate the challenging transition following the death of their loved one [29].

It is important to recognize that caregiver support extends beyond the end-of-life stage. Many communities provide ongoing support groups, counseling services, and other resources for bereaved caregivers. Additionally, caregivers must prioritize self-care and attend to their own physical and emotional well-being after the death of their loved one. This may involve seeking therapy, maintaining connections with support groups or other community resources, and practicing self-compassion and forgiveness as they navigate their grief.

Caring for someone who is approaching the end of life is a challenging and intricate responsibility, often accompanied by a range of emotions, thoughts, and obligations. However, with appropriate support and effective coping strategies, caregivers can provide compassionate and competent care for their loved ones while prioritizing their own health and well-being [29, 30].

Different circumstances surrounding death can have varying impacts on the individual nearing the end of life and their loved ones. The dying process can differ based on factors such as a terminal illness, sudden death, or traumatic circumstances. In cases of terminal illness, the dying process may unfold gradually, allowing the person and their family to emotionally and spiritually prepare for death. Terminal illness can involve symptoms such as pain and fatigue, and palliative care services can provide assistance and support to both the person approaching the end of life and their families [29, 30].

On the other hand, experiencing sudden death or trauma can be abrupt and overwhelming for the individuals left behind. Witnessing the sudden loss of a loved one can trigger feelings of shock, disbelief, anger, and guilt. Seeking counseling and support may be necessary to cope with the profound loss. The grieving process for those left behind can be influenced by the specific circumstances of the death. For instance, losing someone to suicide can introduce complex grief issues. Stigma and feelings of blame may accompany these types of deaths, intensifying the challenges faced during the grieving process [30].

The cultural or spiritual beliefs held by individuals and their families can shape their perspectives on death and dying. While some cultures view the dying process as a natural and inevitable stage of life, others may have a tendency to avoid discussions or contemplations on death altogether [8].

Advertisement

3. Culture and the end of life

Death, being an unavoidable aspect of life, is honored in various ways across different cultures. Although death rituals may differ based on cultural and religious beliefs, their underlying purpose remains the same: to pay tribute to and commemorate the life of the deceased. In many cultures, funerals or memorial services play a vital role in the grieving and healing journey of the bereaved family [8, 30].

Death is perceived and dealt with differently across various cultures, reflecting their unique beliefs and customs. For instance, in Hinduism, death is considered a natural phase of the life cycle. The body is cremated, and the ashes are scattered in a sacred body of water, symbolizing the soul’s ultimate liberation. In Judaism, the deceased is ritually cleansed, wrapped in a simple white burial garment, and buried within a day, emphasizing the importance of timely burial. Conversely, traditional Chinese culture involves intricate rituals and practices that span multiple days, including the burning of offerings and adherence to Feng Shui principles [8, 31].

While cultural and religious customs vary, certain universal practices are observed across different cultures. Lighting candles or incense and offering prayers for the departed are common ways to guide the soul’s journey to the afterlife. Wearing black as a symbol of grief and mourning is a customary practice during mourning periods in many cultures. Additionally, expressing condolences and sending sympathy cards are shared gestures of support and compassion seen across various cultures and religions [8].

Advertisement

4. Conclusion

In summary, while death is a shared aspect of the human condition, the cultural perspectives and practices surrounding it can greatly differ. However, common threads of paying tribute to the departed and providing solace to the grieving are observed universally. Recognizing and respecting cultural diversity in end-of-life customs is crucial for facilitating a serene and respectful passage from life to death [1, 8].

The ultimate goal of palliative care is to alleviate the suffering of both the patient and his/her family, through the proper understanding, detection, and control of physical, psychosocial, and spiritual symptoms experienced by patients at the end of life, regardless of diagnosis. But, while it is true that death is a natural phenomenon, the process of dying is treated as a disease, and today, we are experiencing the medicalization of death. As a consequence, many people die in hospitals in the most extreme loneliness and pain. In other cases, service provision models have been dichotomized to the point of providing aggressive curative treatment and establishing palliative measures in the face of therapeutic failure. The consequence of this reality is that patients and families are left in the middle of an economic and social conflict, since they do not find a team that allows them to understand the nature of the disease, the diagnosis, and the prognosis, this being a crucial aspect for the decision-making at the end of life. Total pain, conceived as the sum of physical pain, psychological pain, and spiritual pain, constitutes one of the origins of suffering. The most relevant triggers in addition to physical pain are the process of dying itself, loss of autonomy, and resignification of life.

The foregoing requires a transdisciplinary team with relevant training to intervene in these realities of patients and family members in palliation. Palliative patients need to develop a closure and forgiveness mechanism to die in peace.

As the end of life approaches, the management of symptoms necessitates comprehensive palliative strategies. Similarly, as interventions become more intense, service delivery processes must be enhanced. It should be emphasized that end-of-life care does not conclude with the patient’s death; instead, the focus of the caregiving team shifts toward supporting the family and facilitating the grieving process.

In the context of a complex world, Western culture, rooted in tradition and orthodox values, is encountering an emerging society characterized by diverse and evolving lifestyles, shifting values, and less universally shared perspectives. This transition brings forth new challenges and barriers, such as coexistence in divergent and multicultural settings, changes in identity, marginalization, and the exclusion of social, ethnic, religious, sexual, professional, and academic groups [32].

Recognizing the intricate nature of biopsychosocial processes necessitates educational institutions to equip new professionals with a comprehensive understanding. This entails developing programs that embrace multidimensionality, foster the construction of reality through clear and innovative ideas, enable objective assessments, facilitate assertive decision-making, and cultivate metacognitive skills that allow for the integration of existing knowledge with new information while appreciating the unity within multiplicity [15].

The act of providing care is a purposeful endeavor that serves the well-being of individuals and their families within a societal context. While physicians devote a significant portion of their training and practice to preserving and prolonging life, end-of-life care is often entrusted to a select few pain specialists and spiritual practitioners who facilitate acceptance and surrender to the dying process. Palliative care, however, is specifically aimed at the individual, the human being, and their family during the final stages of life [1, 33].

This implies that for successful implementation, a comprehensive understanding of human existence is necessary, encompassing not only the somatic or biological aspects but also the environmental, psychological, social, and spiritual dimensions of individuals. Furthermore, death is a fundamental subject in the realms of philosophy, psychology, and medicine. Inquiries into the significance of death, its purpose, and the various associated questions have persisted throughout human history. However, beyond death, one of the most extensively examined yet least multidisciplinary aspects is the meaning of suffering [8, 34].

Providing care for a person involves being by their side, supporting their autonomy, and assisting them in their vulnerability. Palliative care embodies a particular approach to delivering this care. Furthermore, from a transdisciplinary perspective, the act of caring for a patient entails accompanying them throughout their journey of illness and death. In this context, death becomes more than just a problem; it encompasses the complexities of life itself. Consequently, it gives rise to a range of bioethical and multidimensional considerations.

When an individual faces the proximity of death, they experience a heightened sense of its presence and significance. They become acutely aware of its profound and challenging nature. Consequently, in the care of someone nearing the end of life, it is crucial to take their perception of death seriously, as it directly influences their psychological state [35, 36]. Thus, it is pertinent and responsible for caregivers to first confront their own understanding of death, as well as that of their loved ones, in order to effectively provide support in this context. This research work is motivated by this very scenario [36].

In the course of life, we do not have the choice to avoid death, but we do possess the fundamental right to determine how we will face it. Therefore, it is essential to have a qualified team that can deliver comprehensive, compassionate, and empathetic are at the end of life [36].

References

  1. 1. Cano L. Modelo pedagógico y diseño de currículo en Cuidados Paliativos fundamentado en la Transdisciplina. Ediciones FEDICOR ed. Tunja: Fundación Universitaria Juan N. Corpas. Centro Editorial; 2020
  2. 2. Morin E. Para un Pensamiento del Sur. 2011. Available form: https://www.revistasonline.org/public/pdf/MorinPenseeduSudFR.pdf
  3. 3. Matzo M, Sherman DW. Palliative Care Nursing: Quality Care to the End of Life. New York, NY: Springer Publishing Company; 2006. p. 317. 9780826157935. Available from: https://books.google.com.co/books?id=VTM7BniF-tEC
  4. 4. Chochinov HM. Dignity and the essence of medicine: The A, B, C, and D of dignity conserving care. British Medical Journal. 2007;335(7612):184-187. DOI: 10.1136/bmj.39244.650926.47
  5. 5. Tomás-Sábado J, Villavicencio Chávez C, Monforte-Royo C, Guerrero M, Fegg M, Balaguer A. What gives meaning in life in palliative care patients? A comparison between Spanish, German and Swiss populations. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management. 2016;50(6):861-866. DOI: 10.1016/j. jpainsymman.2015.06.015
  6. 6. Breitbart W, Rosenfeld B, Gibson C, Pessin H, Poppito S, Nelson C, et al. Meaning-centered group psychotherapy for patients with advanced cancer: A pilot randomized controlled trial. Psycho-Oncology. 2015;24(12):1583-1587
  7. 7. Bruera E, Suarez-Almazor M, Velasco A, Bertolino M, MacDonald SM, Hanson J. The assessment of constipation in terminal cancer patients admitted to a palliative care unit: A retrospective review. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management. 1994;9(8):515-519
  8. 8. Cano LM. La noología de la muerte. Bogota, Colombia: FEDICOR; 2023. p. 88. ISBN: 978-958-9297-74-2
  9. 9. Morin E. La rumeur d´órleans. L’Histoire immédiate. Éditions du Seuil; 1991
  10. 10. Morin E. Seven Complex Lessons in Education for the Future. Traduction Medellin-Colombia: UNESCO; 2001
  11. 11. Morin E. Culture and Crisis. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press; 2002
  12. 12. Morin E. On Complexity. Paris, France: Hampton Press; 2011
  13. 13. Morin E. Homeland Earth: A Manifesto for the New Millenium. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press; 2014
  14. 14. Morin E. Ethics: On the Condition of Being Human. Paris, France: Routledge; 2015
  15. 15. Morin E. Penser Global: l’humain et son Univers. Paris, France: L’Herne; 2017
  16. 16. Morin E. “Sociologie de la Mort” (Sociology of Death). Paris: Éditions du Seuil; 1990
  17. 17. Ma J, Chi S, Buettner B, Pollard K, Muir M, Kolekar C, et al. Early palliative care consultation in the medical ICU: A cluster randomized crossover trial. Critical Care Medicine. 2019;47(12):1707-1715. DOI: 10.1097/CCM.0000000000004016
  18. 18. Zhai Y, Du X. Loss and grief amidst COVID-19: A path to adaptation and resilience. Brain, Behavior, and Immunity. 2020;87:80-81. DOI: 10.1016/j. bbi.2020.04.053. Epub 2020 Apr 23
  19. 19. Helm. The Death of a Person Has Been Analysed as the ‘Reason’ Na’aman Forthcoming for Grief, and the Element of Love Has Been Called its ‘Background Condition’ (Na’aman Forthcoming) or its ‘Focus’. Vol. 8, No. 3. Landslide: American Bar Association; 2016
  20. 20. Chen CH, Chen YC. The meanings of death beliefs, dying meanings, and death attitudes. OMEGA-Journal of Death and Dying. 2015;70(3):223-237
  21. 21. Stroebe M, Schut H. The dual process model of grief: Past, present, and future. Death Studies. 2015;39(4):210-218
  22. 22. Morin E. “Penser la Mort” (Thinking about Death). Paris: Éditions du Seiul; 1995
  23. 23. Canadian Nurses Association. Ethics in Practice: A Guide for Ethical Decision Making. Ottowa, ON: Canadian Nurses Association; 2017
  24. 24. Truog RD, Robinson WM. Role of brain death and the dead-donor rule in the ethics of organ transplantation. Critical Care Medicine. 2003;31(9):2391-2396
  25. 25. Robinson MR, Thiel MM, Backus MM, Meyer EC. Matters of spirituality at the end of life in the pediatric intensive care unit. Pediatrics. 2006;118:e719-e729. DOI: 10.1542/peds.2005-2298
  26. 26. Eliopoulos C. Gerontological Nursing. 9th ed. Philadelphia, PA: Wolters Kluwer; 2018
  27. 27. Puchalski CM, Vitillo R, Hull SK, Reller N. Improving the spiritual dimension of whole person care: Reaching national and international consensus. Journal of Palliative Medicine. 2014;17(6):642-656. DOI: 10.1089/jpm.2014.9427
  28. 28. American Bar Association Commission on Law and Aging. ABA Consumer’s Tool Kit for Health Care Advance Planning. American Bar Association Commission on Law and Aging; 2020. Available from: https://www.americanbar.org/groups/law_aging/
  29. 29. Kamal AH, Wolf SP, Troy J, Leff V, Dahlin C, Rotella JD, et al. Policy changes key to promoting sustainability and growth of the specialty palliative care workforce. Health Affairs (Millwood). 2019;38(6):910-918. DOI: 10.1377/hlthaff.2019.00018
  30. 30. American Cancer Society. Caregiver Resources. American Cancer Society; 2022. Available from: https://www.cancer.org/content/cancer/en/cancer/coping-with-cancer/caregiversupport.html_Center_to_Advance
  31. 31. Crooms RC, Gelfman LP. Palliative care and end-of-life considerations for the frail patient. Anesthesia and Analgesia. 2020;130(6):1504-1515. DOI: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000004763
  32. 32. Smithsonian Magazine. Eight Enduring Traditions on Death and Dying. Smithsonian Magazine; 2017. Available from: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/
  33. 33. Toh SG, And E, Devi MK. Systematic review on the relationship between the nursing shortage and job satisfaction, stress and burnout levels among nurses in oncology/hematology settings. International Journal of Evidence-Based Healthcare. 2012;10(2):126-141
  34. 34. Torralba F. Hacia una Filosofía de los cuidados Paliativos. Revista Seleccionesde Bioética. 2007;6:17-23
  35. 35. BBC News. How Different Cultures around the World Deal with Death. England: BBC News; 2016. Available from: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-35706238
  36. 36. O’Boyle et al. Quality of life issues in palliative medicine. Journal of Neurology. 1997;244(suppl. 4):18-25

Written By

Luz Marina Cano Molano

Submitted: 02 July 2023 Reviewed: 08 July 2023 Published: 16 March 2024