Abstract
Tunable filters enable dynamic spectrum access for the wireless systems, and the tunable bandpass filters with constant bandwidth (BW) are most favorable for practical applications. This chapter investigates the synthesis and realization techniques for the tunable filters using the coupling matrix with variable entries synthesizes the tunable filter and guides the filter design. The synthesis method and the matrix extraction procedures for the constant-bandwidth bandpass filter are included, and the typical numerical examples are given. This chapter also discusses the relationship between the theoretical matrix and the physical circuits, and then a planar tunable filter design is presented to verify this relationship. Furthermore, the general approach to designing the constant-bandwidth filters using the element variable coupling matrix is concluded. The planar circuit, as well as the 3D structure realizations, are offered to practically demonstrate the synthesis design approach.
Keywords
- tunable filter
- constant bandwidth
- constant shape
- synthesis of tunable filter
- element variable coupling matrix
1. Introduction
The tunable filter is generally employed as a switched filter bank with a substantially reduced size. It self-adaptive selects the frequency spectrum and filters out undesired signals to meet the need for tunability/reconfiguration in wireless systems. As exemplified in Figure 1, the core part of a typical mobile transceiver module is realized by a transceiver IC with many blocks of filters (or multiplexers), switch matrices, power amplifiers, and two antennas. The filters andswitch matrices constitute the unintegrable switched filter banks that are used to select the signal dynamically. It is predictable that if the compact and high-performance tunable filters replace the bulky filter banks, this part of the circuit will consist of only a transceiver IC, two tunable filters, a wideband power amplifier, and two antennas (right side of Figure 1). Nowadays, with a more complex wireless electromagnetic environment, the frequency spectrum is more crowded, and thus it is even more significant to facilitate efficient utilization of the available frequency spectrum. The tunable filter, which plays a crucial role in utilizing the frequency spectrum, has become the hotspot not only in the research area but also for industrial applications.
The filter with tunability and without too much Q degradation known as the high-Q tunable filter has been widely used in the industry. Magnetically tunable filters or yttrium iron garnet (YIG) filter, which provides the tunable band with the high Q factor and multi-octave tuning range, is the essential part in front-ends of the microwave test and measurement instruments [2, 3]. This type of filter can be tunable by magnetically adjusting the ferrimagnetic resonance of the crystal YIG spheres, thus resulting in the filter frequency adjustment. The mechanically tunable filter is another type of high-Q filter that can provide the high-Q tunable passband with a relatively compact size (compared with the YIG filter). This type of filter's frequency or response shape is reconfigured by changing the physical dimensions of the filter structures or disturbing the electromagnetic field in the resonators. The mechanically tunable filter has been commonly employed for tunable wireless infrastructure equipment or reconfigurable communication satellite operators to extend their service life and functionality [4, 5, 6]. A great deal of high-Q mechanically tunable filters, including coaxial, waveguide, or dielectric resonator structures, have been exploited. For example, mechanically adjusting the end-loading capacitors (or equivalent capacitors) of each coaxial resonator, the coaxial filter can be tunable with a wide tuning range [7, 8, 9, 10]. The reconfigurability of the waveguide filter is enabled by reshaping the cavity dimension of the resonator or moving the perturbations inserted in the waveguide cavities [11, 12, 13, 14, 15]. For the dielectric resonator filter, moving the movable disks above the dielectric resonators can tune their resonant frequencies resulting in filter passband tunability [16, 17, 18].
The ever-increasing demand for the miniaturized and highly integrated wireless system requires the future tunable filter with a more compact size and fully electrical control. The giant tuning mechanisms inevitably make YIG filters and mechanically tunable filters oversize. With this regard, the electrically tunable filter with the semiconductor tuning element has been drawing a lot of attention and getting extensively exploited because of its very compact size, fast tuning speed, and straightforward control mechanism, even though the semiconductor tuning element loaded on the resonator will dramatically deteriorate the filter Q factor. Planar tunable filter is a popular research topic because of its easy integration with semiconductor tuning elements. For example, the planar λ/4, λ/2, and multimode resonators loaded by tunable varactors or PIN diodes or both are employed to construct the tunable filters with frequency and bandwidth (BW) control [19, 20, 21, 22, 23]. In addition, emerging tuning semiconductor devices such as Radio Frequency Microelectromechanical Systems (RF-MEMS) and ferroelectric devices are also used as the variable capacitor in the planar tunable filters to alleviate the Q factor deterioration [20, 24, 25, 26]. Aside from the planar filter, the high-Q tunable three-dimensional (3D) filter with tuning semiconductor elements is also a research hotspot because of its low loss, good power handling, and high selectivity. For example, coaxial filters or quasi-coaxial filters [7, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31], dielectric resonator filters [32, 33], and waveguide filters [34] are loaded by the various variable capacitors or switchable devices, thus constructing the tunable/reconfigurable 3D high-Q filters.
Among a large variety of tunable filters, the bandpass filter with the tunable center frequency (CF) is attractive for its widespread application. It is preferable to use the minimum number of tuning elements to control the frequency of the bandpass filter and realize the constant absolute bandwidth (BW). This realization will minimize the Q fact degradation introduced by the loaded tuning elements and maintain the filter response shape as the frequency is tuned. It is also the simplest tunable filter with the most straightforward control mechanism. Therefore, the tunable filter with constant bandwidth has been one of the emerging trends in filter design. For example, the planar filters [35, 36, 37], waveguide filters [15], coaxial filters [7], etc., have been all investigated to approach the constant-BW tunable filters.
In general, since the tunable filters have not large-scale replaced the filter banks, the research and development of the tunable filter is still indispensable, especially for the frequency tunable bandpass filter with constant bandwidth. This chapter will mainly deal with the tunable bandpass filter and offer the general synthesis-based approach. The synthesis method, tuning behavior, and physical realization techniques are included and discussed. The synthesis is based on the coupling matrix where the elements are variable, and the coupling matrix with the variable elements can represent the tunable filter response as well as the tuning behavior. The direct relationship between the matrix and the filter realization will be established, and thus various physical structures can be employed to realize the tunable filter accordingly. Furthermore, the constant-BW tunable filter will also be investigated, and the synthesis with its design approach will be included. A planar and a 3D tunable filter design examples will be offered to realize the theory.
2. Element variable coupling matrix (EVCM)
The coupling matrix is the most commonly used technique to synthesize the fixed filter. One can prescribe or optimize the filter function in terms of the fixed filter specification, and then the coupling matrix can be directly extracted from the filter function. After a few iterations of mathematical manipulation/optimization, the coupling matrix can physically correspond to the filter structures. This is the synthesis process for the fixed filter. However, for the tunable filter, the frequency of the resonator is variable. When the filter is tuning (tunable frequency or tunable BW), there are numerous filter prototypes (filter matrices) corresponding to the same filter response. As illustrated in Figure 2, one can extract three different coupling matrices according to the same filter response using different tuning frequencies (
The EVCM is derived from the conventional coupling matrix and can be treated as the tunable version of the coupling matrix. First of all, the conventional coupling matrix can be extracted using the frequency-fixed filter synthesis (e.g. using the matrix manipulation method [5] or optimization process [38]) based on the prescribed frequency response. For the lossless N×N coupling matrix with the termination impedance
where
Here, the denormalized matrix [
For simplification, the external Q factors Qexe/exo for two resonant modes are roughly approximate to
It can be derived that
Now, it can be found that all elements of matrix [
With this interesting feature, a one-to-one correspondence between the tunable filter responses and this matrix can be established. As a result, the matrix can uniquely represent tunable filter responses. Figures 8–10 presents the typical responses by purposely varying the matrix elements [
The physical structure is presented to realize the EVCM, as shown in Figure 11. The given circuit is controlled by loaded varactor diodes, and each control element can be used to tune the entry of the EVCM separately. For example, the variable capacitor
Figures 12–14 presents the measurement results of the physical circuit corresponding to the calculated results of EVCM. As can be seen, the in-band responses of the filter are all very close to the given EVCM. The CF frequency of the filter can be tuned from 0.8 GHz to 1.2 GHz, and a 130-MHz 3-dB BW is kept nearly constant, as implied in Figure 12. These responses closely agree with the EVCM results as shown in Figure 8. The BW varying from 50 to 400 MHz is measured as shown in Figure 13 when the circuit is fully tuned, which corresponds to the EVCM results as shown in Figure 9. Figure 14 shows the RL reconfiguration results of the filter. As shown, the passband is fixed at 1 GHz with 130-MHz BW, while the RL is reconfigured as prescribed by the EVCM (Figure 10) and the rejection is reshaped. The agreement between the experimental circuit and EVCM is obtained. Note that the practical circuit generates the transmission zeros to enforce
3. Synthesis of the constant-BW filter using EVCM
With the introduction of the new matrix, the tunable filter can correspond to an EVCM uniquely. Thus, the tunable filter with constant BW can be synthesized with a few steps of the mathematical manipulations. First, for a tunable resonator, the adjustment of the
For the tunable coupled-resonator filters, it is reasonable to define
Based on the earlier discussion, one may assume that the EVCMs are the linear functions of the variable
The linear EVCM that represents the tunable filter with a specified tuning range and reflects the passband variation or the passband tuning behavior is defined. Now, extracting parameters of the EVCM from the general filtering function is of great importance to design the tunable passband with constant
First, the tuning range from
The coupling matrix response can be mapped to
[
Using linear interpolation, the EVCM can be extracted as:
where
Now the extraction process is completed and the constant-BW tunable filter is synthesized by the EVCM.
For illustration, the 4th-/6th-/8th-order fully canonical folded filters are extracted with 20-dB RL, a 100% frequency tuning range (from 0.5 GHz to 1.5 GHz), and a constant 100 MHz
Four-pole filter:
Six-pole filter:
Eight-pole filter:
Figure 15 presents the calculation responses of three extracted EVCMs. It can be seen that the prescribed responses are tuned from 0.5GHz to 1.5 GHz, and their responses are kept nearly constant. Even though such a wide tuning range and 8th-order function are predefined, the maximum estimation error of this synthesis method only affects the RL. When the frequency of the passband is tuned closer to the middle point of the tuning range [
4. Planar and 3D realizations of the constant-BW tunable filter based on the EVCM synthesis
The synthesis method can be used to extract the EVCM according to the prescribed filter specifications. This section will present the planar and 3D tunable filters to realize the extracted EVCMs practically.
4.1 Planar realization example of the constant-BW tunable filter
The resonator of the planar filter example is shown in Figure 16, and the frequency range design method is given in Figure 17. The resonant frequency is tuned by changing variable capacitor
Figures 18 and 19, respectively, present the electrical coupling (EC) and magnetic coupling (MC) configurations between two planar resonators. Their corresponding coupling coefficient curves extracted from the configurations are shown in Figures 20 and 21. As can be seen, both the slope and position of coupling coefficient curves can be independently controlled with these two coupling configurations. Thus, the coupling elements in the EVCM can be physically realized, and both EC and MC are available.
Two feeding structures, i.e. short-end and open-end feeding structures, can be employed to feed this type of filter, as shown in Figure 22a and b. Figures 23 and 24, respectively, present the extracted external quality factor
With all filter parts mentioned earlier, two tunable filters using EC and MC as the mainline coupling path to implement the constant BW are demonstrated. Two filters are the four-pole cascade quartet topology, and their prototypes are the 4th-degree General Chebyshev polynomials with 20-RL and 130-MHz ABW. The transmission zeros of two filters are prescribed at [−10j, −2j, 2j, 10j]. The tuning range of the EC filter is predefined from 1.2 GHz to 1.6 GHz, and the EC filter is from 1.05 GHz to 1.45 GHz. According to the presented synthesis method, two EVCMs can be extracted, which are
for EC filter and
for MC filter. Besides, all filter examples are designed on the Rogers RT/duroid 5880 (
Figures 25 and 26 present the EC and MC filter examples where the cascade quartet configurations are used, thus yielding the prescribed tunable responses with constant BW. The measurement results of the two design examples are shown in Figures 27 and 28. The BW of the two filters is approximately 133 MHz and the tuning ranges are over 27%. Good agreement between simulations and measurements is achieved, and the design objective is fully implemented. It is noted that the MC filter has a more stable BW because of the more flexible choosing range of coupling and
4.2 3D realization example of the constant-BW tunable filter
The ceramic monoblock waveguide filter featured a low-cost and competitive Qu/size ratio that attracted a great deal of attention for 5G applications [39]. The 3D realization example of the constant-BW tunable filter presented in this section will be based on the ceramic monoblock waveguide structure and the high-Q mechanically tunable mechanism.
Figure 29 present the tunable ceramic monoblock waveguide resonator. It generally contains the fixed block and the movable cylinder. The low-dielectric (
The coupling configuration between two resonators is shown in Figure 31. The extracted coupling coefficient curves with different key dimensions are presented in Figure 32. It is seen that the coupling coefficient curve is controlled by
The feeding configuration for the tunable ceramic waveguide resonator is given in Figure 33, where the resonator is fed by a coplanar waveguide (CPW) line on the bottom of the fixed block. The external
With the tunable resonator, coupling structure, and feeding configuration discussed earlier, the ceramic waveguide tunable filter can be constructed. For the demonstration, the six-degree Chebyshev low-pass prototype with 17-dB return loss and two TZs (±1.19511j) is employed to form the two-section cascade-triplet topology. The EVCM is extracted for the 5.8–6.2 GHz constant-400-MHz bandwidth filter as:
EM design according to the extracted EVCM is carried out, and the optimized filter structure with the manufactured design sample is given in Figure 35. The feeding circuit is on Rogers RT/duroid 5880.
Figure 36 presents the measured responses of the tunable ceramic waveguide filter. The measured passband moves from 5.76 GHz to 6.22 GHz, but the 3-dB bandwidth maintains 429 ± 7 MHz. The rectangular factor of two skirts is better than 12 dB/20 MHz because of two symmetric transmission zeros. The fitted
5. Conclusions
EVCM is introduced to represent the tunable filter with its tuning behavior. The relationship between the matrix and physical circuit is established, and this correspondence is investigated in detail. The synthesis approach based on EVCM extraction techniques is presented, and the planar as well as the ceramic waveguide tunable filters are designed according to the approach. The experiment is carried out to confirm the theory.
References
- 1.
Liu X. High-Q RF-mems tunable resonators and filters for reconfigurable radio frequency front-ends [Doctor of Philosophy thesis]. Purdue University; 2010 - 2.
Aigle M, Hechtfischer G, Hohenester W, et al. A systematic way to YIG-filter-design. In: 2007 European Microwave Conference. Munich, Germany. 2007. pp. 668-671 - 3.
Adam JD, Davis LE, Dionne GF, et al. Ferrite devices and materials. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2002; 50 :721-737 - 4.
George LM, Leo Y, Jones EMT. Microwave Filters, Impedance-Matching Networks, and Coupling Structures. Dedham, MA: Artech House; 1980 - 5.
Cameron RJ, Kudsia CM, Mansour RR. Microwave Filters for Communication Systems: Fundamentals, Design, and Applications. New York: Wiley-Interscience; 2007 - 6.
Laplanche E, Delhote N, Périgaud A, et al. Tunable filtering devices in satellite payloads: A review of recent advanced fabrication technologies and designs of tunable cavity filters and multiplexers using mechanical actuation. IEEE Microwave Magazine. 2020; 21 :69-83 - 7.
Fouladi S, Huang F, Yan WD, et al. High-Q narrowband tunable combline bandpass filters using MEMS capacitor banks and piezomotors. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2013; 61 :393-402t - 8.
Iskander MA, Nasresfahani M, Mansour RR. A constant-Q tunable combline bandpass filter using angular tuning technique. 2014 44th European Microwave Conference. 2014. p. 1103–1106 - 9.
Mansour BG. A tunable quarter-wavelength coaxial filter with constant absolute bandwidth using a single tuning element. IEEE Microwave and Wireless Components Letters. 2021; 31 :658-661 - 10.
Basavarajappa G, Mansour RR. Design methodology of a high- $Q$ tunable coaxial filter and diplexer. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2019; 67 :5005-5015 - 11.
Yassini B, Yu M, Keats B. A ka -band fully tunable cavity filter. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2012; 60 :4002-4012 - 12.
Arnold C, Parlebas J, Zwick T. Reconfigurable waveguide filter with variable bandwidth and center frequency. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2014; 62 :1663-1670 - 13.
Ossorio J, Vague J, Boria VE, et al. Exploring the tuning range of channel filters for satellite applications using electromagnetic-based computer aided design tools. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2018; 66 :717-725 - 14.
Gowrish B, Mansour RR. A dual-mode frequency reconfigurable waveguide filter with a constant frequency spacing between transmission zeros. In: 2020 IEEE/MTT-S International Microwave Symposium (IMS). 2020. pp. 811-814 - 15.
Basavarajappa G, Mansour RR. Design methodology of a tunable waveguide filter with a constant absolute bandwidth using a single tuning element. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2018; 66 :5632-5639 - 16.
Wang C, Blair WD. Tunable high-Q dielectric loaded resonator and filter. In: Proceedings RAWCON 2002 2002 IEEE Radio and Wireless Conference (Cat No02EX573). 2002. pp. 249-252 - 17.
Pance K, Rochford G. Multiple band and multiple frequency dielectric resonators tunable filters for base stations. In: 2008 38th European Microwave Conference. 2008. pp. 488-491 - 18.
Shen T, Zaki KA, Wang C. Tunable dielectric resonators with dielectric tuning disks. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2000; 48 :2439-2445 - 19.
Hunter IC, Rhodes JD. Electronically tunable microwave bandstop filters. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 1982; 30 :1361-1367 - 20.
Hong J-SG, Lancaster MJ. Microstrip Filters for RF/Microwave Applications. NJ, USA: Wiley; 2004 - 21.
Guyette A. Controlled agility: Frequency-agile planar filters with advanced features. IEEE Microwave Magazine. 2014; 15 :32-42 - 22.
Islam H, Das S, Bose T, et al. Diode based reconfigurable microwave filters for cognitive radio applications: A review. IEEE Access. 2020; 8 :185429-185444 - 23.
Lu D, Tang X, Barker NS, et al. Synthesis-applied highly selective tunable dual-mode BPF with element-variable coupling matrix. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2018; 66 :1804-1816 - 24.
Rebeiz G, Entesari K, Reines I, et al. Tuning in to RF MEMS. IEEE Microwave Magazine. 2009; 10 :55-72 - 25.
Tombak A, Maria J-P, Ayguavives FT, et al. Voltage-controlled RF filters employing thin-film barium-strontium-titanate tunable capacitors. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2003; 51 :462-467 - 26.
Entesari K, Saghati AP, Sekar V, et al. Tunable SIW structures: Antennas, VCOs, and filters. IEEE Microwave Magazine. 2015; 16 :34-54 - 27.
Park S-J, Reines I, Patel C, et al. High-Q RF-MEMS 4–6-GHz tunable evanescent-mode cavity filter. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2010; 58 :381-389 - 28.
Kang Q, Shamsaifar K. Electronically Tunable Block Filter with Tunable Transmission Zeros. Google Patents; 2004 - 29.
Anand A, Small J, Peroulis D, et al. Theory and design of octave tunable filters with lumped tuning elements. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2013; 61 :4353-4364 - 30.
Xu J, Yang L, Yang Y, et al. High- $Q$ -factor tunable bandpass filter with constant absolute bandwidth and wide tuning range based on coaxial resonators. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2019; 67 :4186-4195 - 31.
Yang Z, Psychogiou D, Peroulis D. Design and optimization of tunable silicon-integrated evanescent-mode bandpass filters. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2018; 66 :1790-1803 - 32.
Mansour RR. High-Q tunable dielectric resonator filters. IEEE Microwave Magazine. 2009; 10 :84-98 - 33.
Xu J, Zhang XY, Li H, et al. Narrowband single-pole double-throw filtering switch based on dielectric resonator. IEEE Microwave and Wireless Components Letters. 2018; 28 :594-596 - 34.
Pelliccia L, Cacciamani F, Farinelli P, et al. High-Q tunable waveguide filters using ohmic RF MEMS switches. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2015; 63 :3381-3390 - 35.
Park SJ, Rebeiz GM. Low-loss two-pole tunable filters with three different predefined bandwidth characteristics. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2008; 56 :1137-1148 - 36.
Lu D, Tang X, Barker NS, et al. Single-band and switchable dual-/single-band tunable BPFs with predefined tuning range, bandwidth, and selectivity. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2017; 66 :1215-1227 - 37.
Lu D, Yu M, Barker NS, et al. Advanced synthesis of wide-tuning-range frequency-adaptive bandpass filter with constant absolute bandwidth. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2019; 67 :4362-4375 - 38.
Amari S. Synthesis of cross-coupled resonator filters using an analytical gradient-based optimization technique. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2000; 48 :1559-1564 - 39.
Chen Y, Zhang Y, Wu K-L. A dual-mode monoblock dielectric bandpass filter using dissimilar fundamental modes. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques. 2021; 69 :3811-3819