Comparison of electrical equivalent battery models .
Modelling helps us to understand the battery behaviour that will help to improve the system performance and increase the system efficiency. Battery can be modelled to describe the V-I Characteristics, charging status and battery’s capacity. It is therefore necessary to create an exact electrical equivalent model that will help to determine the battery efficiency. There are different electrical models which will be discussed and examined along with the benefits and demerits. A systematic comparison and analysis using simulation will help us to select an ideal model which will suit best to a specific application.
- lithium-ion batteries
- battery modelling
- state of charge
- electrical equivalent
Renewable energies play a major role in the power quality applications of emerging technologies. Batteries are considered as one of the most important amongst the component. Batteries are energy storage devices that can be utilised in a variety of applications and range in power from low to high. Batteries are connected in series and parallel to match the load requirements. The advantages of lithium-ion batteries include their light weight, high energy density, and low discharge rates. They’re commonly seen in high-power applications like electric vehicles and hybrids. Lithium-ion batteries have a terminal voltage of 3-4.2 volts and can be wired in series or parallel to satisfy the power and energy demands of high-power applications. Battery models are important because they predict battery performance in a system, designing the battery pack and also help anticipate the efficiency of a system [1, 2].
2. Existing electrical equivalent battery models
The mathematical relationship between the elements of Lithium-ion batteries and their V-I characteristics, state of charge (SOC), internal resistance, operating cycles, and self-discharge is depicted in a Lithium-ion battery model. The equivalent circuit model of a Lithium-ion battery is a performance model that uses one or more parallel combinations of resistance, capacitance, and other circuit components to construct an electric circuit to replicate the dynamic properties of Lithium-ion batteries. Time domain analysis is used to produce the most often utilised electrical equivalent models. The simplest model equation for battery model can be represented by Open Circuit Voltage (OCV)
SO0C of a cell is 100% when cell is fully charged and SOC is 0% when cell is fully discharged. The amount of charge removed from 100–0% is the total capacity measured in Ah or mAh.
Following are the models used for Lithium-ion battery to determine the performance on the system .
2.1 Simple battery model Rint model
Figure 1 illustrates the most widely used battery model. It consists of an ideal battery with open circuit voltage (OCV) V0, a constant equivalent internal resistance Rint, and as the terminal voltage. When completely charged, the terminal voltage v(t) may be determined by measuring the open circuit voltage, and Rint can be determined by connecting a load and detecting both the terminal voltage and current.
SOC is represented as z(t) of a cell is 100% when cell is fully charged and SOC is 0% when cell is fully discharged. The amount of charge removed from 100–0% is the total0 capacity (Q) measured in Ah or mAh.
At the point when a battery is completely charged, its Open Circuit Voltage is higher than when it is discharged. The Rint model appears to be relatively simple, however it ignores the variable nature of the internal resistance related to temperature, state of charge, and electrolytic concentration.
2.2 Resistive Thevenin battery model
Figure 2 shows the circuit schematic for the resistive Thevenin battery model. This model has two types of internal resistances, R0 and R1, which are connected to the charging and discharging properties of the battery, respectively. Electrical and non-electrical losses are modelled by the internal resistances R0 and R1. Diffusion Voltages also can be closely found using1 or more RC parallel branches. The model gives better results than Rint model, however transient conditions like the capacitance effect are not considered. As a result, this model is non-dynamic and unsuitable for applications involving electric vehicles and electric hybrids [4, 5, 6, 7, 8].
2.3 An accurate electrical battery model
An Accurate Electrical Battery Model, models the battery capacity, charging state, and run time using a capacitor and a current controlled source. The circuit takes into account the battery life time as well as the slow and fast transient response. A voltage controlled voltage source that is a function of state of charge is used to overcome the barrier between SOC and OCV (Figure 4) .
2.4 Models of electrical equivalent batteries
Table 1 gives the different Electrical equivalent circuit models along with its important features so that it will be useful to predict the performance of the battery and for which application the battery can be used for.
|S. No.||Battery model||Features|
|1||Rint model||Model is static.|
|2||Thevenin electric model||Does not consider the dependency of state of charge.|
|3||Second order RC Thevenin model||Model does not consider the parameters like temperature and capacity.|
|4||Accurate electrical equivalent model||Model considers the battery life time.|
2.5 Electrical characteristics of lithium-ion battery
|Capacity||Nominal capacity: 2600 mAH (0.52 A discharge, 2.75 V)|
|Nominal voltage||3.7 V|
|Internal impedance||≤70 mΩ|
|Discharge cut off voltage||3.0 V|
|Maximum charge voltage||4.20 ± 0.05 V|
|Standard charge discharge current||0.52 A|
|Rapid charge discharge current||1.3 A|
|Maximum pulse discharge current||2.6 A|
2.6 Charging and discharging characteristics
Figures 5 and 6 shows the rate charge and discharge characteristics of the battery Model LIR18650 2600 mAH. The battery charges with Constant Current Constant Voltage mode. The battery is charged at a constant current until it reaches 4.2 volts, then it is charged at a constant voltage until the current drops to zero . The charging time of battery can be calculated as the ratio of battery Ah to the charging current.
3. Simulation results and discussion
Discharge Model (i*>0)
Charge Model (i*<0)
E0 is constant voltage (V), K is polarisation constant in (Ah−1), i* is low frequency current dynamics, Q is maximum battery capacity (Ah), A is exponential voltage (V), B is exponential capacity (Ah−1),
The implementation of the generalised model in MATLAB shows that the characteristics developed by mathematical electrical model of battery in Matlab and are close to the actual characteristics of Lithium-ion Battery Model LIR18650 2600 mAH .
Being a static model, the Rint model does not account for the battery’s charging and discharging properties. Thevenin’s electric model (1RC) ignores dynamic behaviour and neglects to account for state of charge dependency. 2 RC branches would be closer to match the data at the beginning of the transient. 3RC branches can be chosen as a compromise between complexity of model and its fidelity. Various electrical equivalent models are studied along with its different features in the existing models.
Min Chen and Gabriel A. Rinc’on-Mora. Accurate electrical battery model capable of predicting runtime and I–V performance. IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion 2006;21(2).
Xiaoqiang Zhang, Weiping Zhang, and Geyang Lei. A review of Li-ion battery equivalent circuit models. Transactions on Electrical and Electronic Materials 2016;17(6):311-316.
Low Wen Yao, J. A. Aziz, Pui Yee Kong, and N. R. N. Idris. Modeling of lithium-ion battery using MATLAB/Simulink. In: Proceedings of Conference of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society. Vienna, pp. 1729-1734, Nov. 2016.
Barcellona Simone and Piegari Luig. Lithium ion battery models and parameter identification techniques. Energies 2017;10.
Zhang Lijun, Peng Hui, Ning Zhansheng, Zhongqiang Mu, and Sun Changyan. Comparative research on RC equivalent circuit models for lithium-ion batteries of electric vehicles. Applied Sciences 2017;7.
Hyun You, Jun Bae, So Cho, Jong Lee, and Se-Hun Kim. Analysis of equivalent circuit models in lithium-ion batteries. AIP Advances 2018;8.
Haizhou Zhai. Modeling of lithium-ion battery for charging/discharging characteristics based on circuit model. International Journal of Online Engineering, 2017;13(6):86-95.
R. R. Thakkar, Y. S. Rao, and R. R. Sawant. Performance Analysis of electrical equivalent circuit models of lithium-ion battery. In: 2020 IEEE Pune Section International Conference (PuneCon), 2020, pp. 103-107. DOI: 10.1109PuneCon50868.2020.9362386