The research situation of environmentally friendly gas insulation is expounded in this paper. The basic physical and chemical properties of the insulating gases are analysed, to propose several environment-friendly insulating gas of potential alternative to sulphur hexafluoride (SF6). The insulation characteristics of different components gas mixtures with 90% of nitrogen (N2) and carbon dioxide (CO2) as buffer gas and 10% octafluorocyclobutane (c-C4F8), Trifluoroiodomethane (CF3I) and heptafluorobutyronitrile (C4F7N) as the main insulating gas had been tested with 5–20 mm sphere-plane electrode gaps in non-uniform electric field under the power frequency voltage and positive and negative lightning impulse breakdown. The development prospects of environmentally friendly gas insulation are forecasted. Further analysis of c-C4F8,CF3I and C4F7N (some friendly gases, which have the potential to replace SF6) are conducted trying to points out the further research direction.
- electrical equipment insulation
- environmentally friendly gases
- alternatives gases
Because of its good electrical insulating properties, sulphur hexafluoride (SF6) can satisfy the insulating demands of the electrical apparatus. SF6 is nontoxic and non-combustible, which guarantees the security of its application in the gas insulating apparatus. What is more, the chemical properties of SF6 are stable and it can be compatible with most mental and solid insulating materials. There is little decomposing by-products after discharge or arc, which guarantees the following insulating function and protects apparatus. Nowadays, SF6 has been an important industrial gas with more than 20,000 tons’ produced every year all over the world, and 80% of that is applied as insulating gas in electrical apparatus . With the continuous increase of China’s electrical demand and the expansion of the electrical grid, the demand for insulating gas will continuously increase [2, 3, 4].
Although the characteristics of SF6 can satisfy the requirements as insulation gas in electrical apparatus, such as gas-insulated substations, scientists have recognised that it can influent and aggravate the greenhouse effect in recent years. SF6 is a strong greenhouse gas that will cause serious harm to the environment. The Global Warming Potential GWP of SF6 is 23,900 times stronger than that of CO2 , which means that under the computing period of 100 years. Far more serious is that because of the extremely stable chemical properties, it is very hard to decompose SF6 in nature and it can exist for 3200 years in atmosphere , which will make the environmental influence and greenhouse effect continuously accumulated.
It is important to look for environmentally insulating gas with similar insulating characteristics and physicochemical properties of SF6 to replace SF6. SF6 belongs to inorganic fluorinated gases, and its molecular geometry is octahedron with six-fluorine (F) atoms in outer surface and one sulphur (S) atom in centre. Because of fluorine belongs to the halogens, its peripheral electronic layer is occupied by seven electrons and can become stable structure with one more electron, which allows it to strongly attract electron. Moreover, in the molecule of SF6, F atoms and S atom form more stable covalent bonds by sharing electrons. However, F atoms also have the trend to attract electrons so that the entire molecule has a trend to attract electron. Therefore, it has better insulating characteristics than other gaseous molecular without electronegativity. In addition, although the gas characteristics showed by the structure of macro element cannot show the insulation strength of gas exactly, even counterexample existing, researchers have attached importance to that and the researching emphasis of alternative gas is concentrated on the halogenated gas . In 1997, the research report about the insulation characteristics and arc quenching of alternative gas of SF6 written by the National Bureau of Standards of the U.S.A  introduced many potential alternative gases. Besides, in this work was studied the breakdown voltage under direct current (DC) uniform field of gases, such as organic fluorinated ones, compared with SF6, and this comparison is shown in Table 1. The result of the report shows that most fluorinated gases have good electronic adsorption, which it is related to the addition of fluorine, but not all the organic fluorinated gases have good insulation characteristics. Besides, it is not correct to evaluate the insulation characteristics just based on the elements that constitute a gas, so it is necessary to analyse different gases in detail for comparison. Because the physicochemical properties of octafluorocyclobutane (c-C4F8) are close to SF6, its cost is low and Greenhouse Warming Potential (GWP) is lower than SF6, the report has specially indicated that c-C4F8 and its mixture can be the study subject for long time , so that researchers are focused on the study of this gas.
|Gas||Relative breakdown voltage||Remarks|
|SF6||1||As reference of gas|
Relative breakdown voltage is 1
|C3F8||0.90||With strong absorption to free electron, especially low-power free electron|
|Hexafluorobutadiene (2-C4F6)||About 2.3|
|CHF3||0.27||With weaker absorption to free electron|
Besides c-C4F8, organic halogenated gas, trifluoroiodomethane (CF3I), contains fluorine (F) and iodine (I) has been concentrated by researchers for its much lower GWP and better insulation characteristics. At the same time, ALSTOM company in France and 3M company in US produce an electrical insulation gas mixtures together, named G3, whose main ingredient is heptafluorobutyronitrile (C4F7N), a kind of fluorinated nitrile with Novec 4710 as trade name . Besides, ABB company produces electrical insulation gas mixtures whose main ingredient is fluorinated ketone such as Heptafluoropropyl trifluorovinyl ether (C5F10O) and Undecafluorohexanoyl Fluoride (C6F12O). Properties of some potential alternative gases to SF6 are shown in Table 2.
|Gas||Physicochemical properties||Environmental characteristics||Electrical characteristics|
|Toxicity||Boiling point (unit: °C)||Relative GWP||Relative insulation characteristics ||Relative rising rate of recovery voltage (RRRV) characteristics|
|Fluorinated 1,3-butadiene (C4F6)||Toxic||6~7||≈0||1.4||—|
|Fluorinated 2-butyne (C4F6)||Toxic||−25||≈0||1.7||—|
|Fluorinated 2-butene (C4F8)||Toxic||1.2||—||1.8|
2. Analysis of potential alternative gas
2.1. Octafluorocyclobutane (c-C4F8)
Octafluorocyclobutane, c-C4F8 is an important industrial gas. Nowadays, it is used in plasma etching technology or as refrigerant . Similar to SF6 gas, the performance to absorb electron easily of fluorine in c-C4F8 is shown in the characteristics of the whole molecule, so that c-C4F8 has a stronger absorption to free electron. c-C4F8 is colourless, odourless, nontoxic to human bodies at low concentration, non-combustible, nonexplosive and with GWP of about 8700 relative to CO2. Though it belongs to greenhouse, but in the same conditions, its negative effects are just one third of SF6 . In addition, as organic halogenated gas, c-C4F8 does not contain chlorine or bromine, so it is not harmful to the ozone layer. The molecule of c-C4F8 is circular with a stable chemical structure and does no harm to other solid materials in electrical apparatus, such as aluminium alloy, copper contact and epoxy supporting insulators. Recently, the price of c-C4F8 differs with the purity of gas. The price of this gas with 99.9% purity is about 200 RMB/kg  (1 RMB ≈ 0.16 dollar≈0.13 euro, the same below), as the price of gas with 99.999% purity is about 500 RMB/kg, and that has obviously reduced compared with the price of about thousand RMB per kilogramme 10 years ago. This is related to more applications, such as refrigerant , that are using c-C4F8 and the rise of production. Nowadays, the price of c-C4F8 is only a little bit higher than that of SF6, but if c-C4F8 is applied widely in electrical domain, its price still can be reduced, so the cost is not the obstacle to be applied in electrical apparatus.
Long before, Japanese researchers began to research the electrical properties of c-C4F8 and indicated that it had the feasibility to replace SF6 in electrical apparatus. Then, the researchers of plasma and electric-related domains from the U.S.A. and Mexico began to use Boltzmann equation, calculation of parameter of discharge particle and breakdown test to research the insulation characteristics of c-C4F8. Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Xi’an Jiao Tong University and other high schools in China began the researches about calculation of academic simulation and breakdown test of c-C4F8. The results of researches have shown that the insulation characteristics of pure c-C4F8 are better than SF6, in air pressure at 0.3 MPa and over. The breakdown voltage of the gas mixtures of c-C4F8 and N2 or CO2 is higher than the gas mixtures of SF6 with the same contents, and in low air pressure or atmospheric pressure, the breakdown voltage of the gas mixtures of c-C4F8 can approach the gas mixtures of SF6 with the same contents. In conclusion, c-C4F8 and its gas mixtures have similar insulation characteristics with SF6, and the breakdown voltage differs a little with the composition, mixture ratio and gas pressure, so it can satisfy the demands of actual application.
The relative molecular mass of c-C4F8 is 200, higher than that of SF6 (146.06), and it means that the condensing temperature of c-C4F8 will be high, is about −6°C, higher than −63.6°C of SF6. The insulating gas should exist in gaseous state in the electrical apparatus, thus need to have a low enough liquefaction temperature. One way to reduce its liquefaction point is to add some buffer gas including nitrogen (N2) or carbon dioxide (CO2), which may lead to a weaker insulation strength. So we need to take a balance between the low liquefaction temperature and good insulation property when considering the mixture ratio for c-C4F8gas mixtures. Therefore, c-C4F8 is not suited to be applied in apparatus as pure gas, or it cannot satisfy the demand of arctic alpine regions. Thus, it should be mixed with other gas in some ratios to reduce the condensing temperature of the gas mixtures and be used as gas mixtures.
2.2. Trifluoroiodomethane (CF3I)
Trifluoroiodomethane (CF3I) is colourless, odourless, non-combustible and nonexplosive. CF3I is a new industrial gas that can be used as an environmental refrigerant and alternative fire-extinguishing agent. It can be used as additive or mixed composition to replace traditional refrigerant Freon and fire-extinguishing material “Halon.” Because its GWP is very low, about 1–5 relative to CO2 is much lower than most organic halogenated gases, so its influence on greenhouse is very small. At the same time, it does not contain chlorine and bromine that is commonly present in most refrigerants, so it will not damage the ozone layer, thus the United Nations regards it as new refrigerant to replace Freon . This can prove that CF3I is a kind of environmentally friendly gas, and has related basis in industrial application. As a kind of fire-extinguishing material, its efficiency is outstanding and has little negative influence on environment, and it is well compatible with normal industrial materials, so that it will not cause chemical reaction or erosion. Therefore, it has passed some related standards of the U.S.A . and can be used in aerospace and other areas. In addition, it can rise the security of the electrical apparatus by applying CF3I in electrical apparatus such as cubicle gas insulating switchgear (C-GIS) or compact transformer. It is especially appropriate to be used in populous regions of central city in order to reduce the conflagration or explosion caused by the bug of electrical apparatus. The molecular structure of CF3I is shown in Figure 1 RMB. It is affected by halogens such as F and I, so it has strong absorption to free electron. So that it can absorb free electron at the beginning of discharge when electron avalanche forms, and then it can restrain the formation of collision ionisation, which enhances its insulation property. What is worthy to indicate, that the difference between CF3I and SF6, as well as c-C4F8, comes from the asymmetry of its structure, which makes the polarity effect of the molecule stronger. The three-F atoms in the molecule has stronger absorption to electron than I atom, so the electron cloud in the molecule trends to F atoms, and the density of the electron cloud around the carbon-iodine covalent bond formed by I atom and carbon (C) atom is reduced, and the energy barrier to absorb electron is also reduced. Therefore, the whole molecule has a strong ability to absorb electron.
Because of CF3I is a new industrial gas, its application in China is not widely extended, the production in China is low. Currently, CF3I produced in China costs about 2000 RMB/kg, the price is much higher than SF6 . The main reason why the price of CF3I in China is higher than that for SF6  is that the demand is very low. According to the producers of CF3I (Beijing Yuji Science & Technology Co., Ltd.), after CF3I will be used widely and will be mass-produced, the constant cost of CF3I will reduce a lot with the actual cost lower than 600 RMB/kg. Moreover, by optimising and upgrading, its price will be reduced continuously like that for c-C4F8.
Since year 2000, many researchers in China and abroad begin to research this new insulating gas [21, 22]. Researchers of plasma from Mexico have calculated and measured the ionisation coefficient, attachment coefficient and electron drift velocity during the process of discharge of CF3I and its gas mixtures with N2, SF6 and other gases [23, 24]. The aforementioned work has quantified the reaction between free electron and gas molecule during the process of discharge, and has analysed the insulation strength of gas mixtures from the perspective of the parameters of discharge. Tokyo University of Japan, Tokyo Denki University and Japan Electric Power Company have researched CF3I by testing [25, 26]. They make the breakdown test to CF3I and its gas mixtures with N2, CO2 and air by using lighting impulse. The results show that the insulation strength of pure CF3I is better than that in SF6, about 1.2 times than SF6, and CF3I-CO2 gas mixtures with high content also has better insulation characteristics to be able to replace SF6. Many universities and academies in Europe also research the gas mixtures of CF3I-CO2 and CF3I-N2 in different conditions . The results show that the positive synergistic effect of the gas mixtures of CF3I and N2 is less obvious than that of the gas mixtures of SF6 and N2, which means that in the same mixture ratio, the insulation strength of the gas mixtures of CF3I-CO2 cannot increase with the rising content of CF3I because of the synergistic effect . In addition, the gas mixtures of CF3I and CO2 with low content show better positive synergistic effect. Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Xi’an Jiao Tong University and Chongqing University in China has researched CF3I and its gas mixtures by academic calculation and testing research [27, 28, 29]. Shanghai Jiao Tong University uses Boltzmann’s equation to calculate and analyse the discharge parameters and insulation characteristics of the gas mixtures of CF3I and N2, CO2, He and so on and get the alternating current (AC) breakdown voltage in non-uniform electric field and slightly non-uniform electric field by testing [28, 30]. Other researchers have measured partial discharge voltage and other insulation characteristics of the gas mixtures of CF3I [31, 32]. The results show that CF3I has good electrical insulation characteristics, but the positive synergistic effect of the mixture of CF3I and normal buffering gas is not obvious, so that the insulation characteristics of its gas mixtures are lower than SF6. Therefore, the research about the synergistic effect of CF3I and other gas is the key to be applied in the future.
2.3. Fluorinated nitrile gas and G3 gas mixtures
ALSTOM company in France and 3M company in U.S.A. have joined to research the alternative to SF6 gas. Among many organic fluorinated gases, they choose the gas, which is also alternative refrigerant, and organic chemical compound that contains four-C atoms and seven-F atoms, with a trade name of Novec 4710  and chemical formula of C4F7N, named G3. Besides, its molecular structure is shown in Figure 2. The gas has replaced a fluorine atom with nitrile group (▬C☰N) on the basis of the fluorinated hydrocarbon gas, and becomes fluorinated nitrile gas. This nitrile group containing carbon-nitrogen triple bond has a special chemical structure to make C4F7N have very good insulation performance, which can reach about two-times of that of SF6. The chemical features of this gas are similar to the organic fluorinated gas with stable chemical characteristics and can be well compatible with other materials used in electrical assets. The relative molecular mass of C4F7N is 195, with a high condensing temperature of −4.7°C, so that it cannot replace SF6 as a single gas, it should become gas mixtures with buffering gas such as N2 or CO2. Because of it is a new insulating gas, related testing research is lacking. According to research result obtained by now, the insulation characteristics of its gas mixtures with CO2 is about 90% of the SF6 mixtures with the same amount of CO2, and this gas can also be used as arc quenching medium being applied in circuit-breakers . Nowadays, this gas is researched and produced by 3M company and its cost is dozens of times higher than other gases , so the cost is one of the obstacles for its industrial application. With the accomplishment of the production technology of the gas and the development of the producers at home, the price could be reduced.
The gas with the chemical formula of C4F7N has two-isomeric compounds, their chemical formulas and element compositions are the same, but for the different positions of nitrile groups, their molecular structures and microcosmic natures are different. For Novec 4710 gas used in G3 gas, its nitrile group is located in the carbon atom in the middle of the organic carbon-chain, and the other isomeric compound has a nitrile group located in the carbon atom at one end of the carbon-chain, which constitute a virulent gas that cannot be used in industry. In addition, during the production of Novec 4710, by avoiding the production and the mixture of the virulent isomeric compound is key to apply this gas in a real environment. What is more, any gas will be decompounded to produce decomposed by-products in the condition of high temperature and pressure during the discharge process. Moreover, it should be continuously researched about how to guarantee that this gas will not produce toxic isomeric compounds or other gases during the process of discharge or arc interruption.
2.4. Fluorinated ketone gas
ABB company in Switzerland has supported a method for evaluating the greenhouse effect of SF6 [34, 35], and it is to take advantage of fluorinated ketone gas as the main ingredient of gas mixtures, which contains organic fluorinated gas with carbonyl group (C〓O) such as C5F10O and C6F12O. This kind of gas is similar to fluorinated nitrile gas. It is a chemical compound, which uses the carbonyl group to replace one F atom of fluorinated hydrocarbon based on fluorinated hydrocarbon. Because of carbonyl group has carbon-oxide double bond, which is unsaturated bond as the same as the carbon-nitrogen triple bond, it has good absorption to free electron, and it shows higher insulation characteristics in macro-performance . According to the existing testing data in China and abroad, the insulation characteristics of pure C5F10O and C6F12O are about two-times higher than SF6 and their GWP value approaches zero, physicochemical properties are stable and they have good compatibility with materials and industrial applicability. The fluorinated carbonyl, which ABB has applied in the gas mixtures has more than five-carbon atoms, so its relative molecular mass is bigger than other insulating gases, such as C5F10O with 266 and C6F12O with 316. Besides,the condensing temperature of C5F10O and C6F12O is very high with 24 and 49°C at room condition, which means that they are liquid at normal temperature and gas pressure. Therefore, this gas cannot be used in any electrical insulating domains as single gas, and it can only be applied as gas mixtures. Limited by its high-condensing temperature, it will have low content in the gas mixtures, which causes the limitation of the insulation strength of the whole gas mixtures, so the synergistic effect of this gas and other gas mixtures is very important. Therefore, the use of this kind of gas forming gas mixtures, which allows it keep high insulation characteristics at low concentrations, is the emphasis of research in the future.
3. The power frequency AC breakdown characteristics of the c-C4F8, N2, CO2 gas mixtures
The breakdown voltage under AC voltage of the gas mixtures with a constant content of 10% of c-C4F8 and different content of N2 and CO2 has been measured by testing. Figures 3 and 4 show the variety of the AC-breakdown voltage and maximum electric strength of the c-C4F8, N2, CO2 gas mixtures with the variety of gap distance under different air pressure. The gas discharge test chamber and other internal structure are the same with that in Ref. . The method to inflate gas mixtures to test chamber is introduced in Ref. . The gases tested in the present paper are listed in Table 3.
|Number||c-C4F8/CF3I mixing ratio (%)||N2 mixing ratio (%)||CO2 mixing ratio (%)|
From Figures 3 and 4, it can be observed that the behaviour of c-C4F8 mixtures is similar to the SF6 gas mixtures, the AC-breakdown voltage of the c-C4F8, N2, CO2 gas mixtures gets higher values as the gap distance gets bigger, and it shows saturation effect. The maximum electric strength of the gas mixtures gets lower values as the gap distance gets bigger, and it shows that the gas mixtures has some sensitivity to the non-uniformity of the electric field. As the non-uniformity of the electric field increases, the maximum electric field able to be tolerated reduces, and the trend of change is similar to SF6, N2 and CO2 in Appendix Figures A1 and A2.
Figure 5 shows that under different gap distances, the variety of the AC-breakdown voltage of the c-C4F8, N2, CO2 gas mixtures as the gas pressure changes. The AC-breakdown voltage of c-C4F8 gas mixtures increases linearly as the air pressure increases without hump effect, and this trend is the same to SF6 gas mixtures. From Figures 3–5, we can see that the variety of the breakdown voltage of the c-C4F8 gas mixtures with the same content as the air pressure and the electrodes gap changes is the same to SF6 gas mixtures. However, the curves of breakdown voltage of c-C4F8 gas mixtures with different contents in the graphs are more concentrated than SF6. That is to say, the breakdown voltages of gas mixtures have little difference with different contents, at the same time, it shows that the breakdown voltage of the gas mixtures of c-C4F8 and CO2 is the highest and the gas mixtures with N2 is lower, this is different from the properties of SF6 gas mixtures. When the gap distance is 20 mm, the AC-breakdown voltage of 10%c-C4F8+90%CO2 is about 10% higher than that of 10%c-C4F8+90%N2.
Figure 6 shows under different gas pressures, the variety of the AC-breakdown voltage of the c-C4F8, N2, CO2 gas mixtures as the content changes. If it is make the gas mixtures of 10%c-C4F8 + 90%N2 as the initial matched group, it can be seen that the breakdown voltage of the gas mixtures increases as the content of CO2 increases, and when the content of CO2 exceeds 60%. In other words, with a content of N2 lower than 30%, the increase of the breakdown voltage is more noticeable.
Because of during the process of discharge, N2 will make the ionisation probability of CO2 increase as well, when reducing N2 and increasing CO2 of the c-C4F8 gas mixtures, the breakdown voltage of the triple gas mixtures in Figure 6 does not has an obvious increase immediately, and even it has a trend to reduce a little. Only after the content of N2 is lower than 30% and the content of CO2 is higher than 60%, the breakdown voltage can increase significantly.
4. Power frequency AC-breakdown characteristics of the CF3I, N2, CO2 gas mixtures
To CF3I, it has been measured the breakdown characteristics for a constant content of 10% CF3I and with different concentrations of N2 and CO2 under AC-voltage applied during the tests. The test method and experiment setup are similar to that in Section 2. The gas mixtures and mixing ratio are listed in Table 1. Figures 7 and 8 show that under different air pressures, the variety of the AC-breakdown voltage applied and the maximum electric strength of the CF3I, N2, CO2 gas mixtures as the gap changes. From Figure 7, it can be seen that the breakdown voltage of CF3I gas mixtures gets higher as the electrodes gap gets bigger, but curves of different gas mixtures are more approached even closer compared with SF6 and c-C4F8. The breakdown voltage of CF3I gas mixtures has little difference with different contents of N2 and CO2. Moreover, N2, which has better insulation strength, does not perform better than CO2 when it is mixed with CF3I. In Figure 8, the maximum electric strength of CF3I gas mixtures has a trend to reduce as the electrodes gap increases, but the curves are smoother than c-C4F8, which shows that the sensitivity to the electric non-uniformity of CF3I is lower than c-C4F8.
Figure 9 shows, under different gaps of electrode, the variety of the AC-breakdown voltage for CF3I, N2, CO2 gas mixtures as the gas pressure changes. Similar to the gas mixtures of SF6 and c-C4F8, the AC-breakdown voltage increases linearly as the air pressure increases, and without hump effect or trend of saturation. Curves in Figure 9 are similar to these in Figure 7, the superposition of the curves of gas mixtures with different contents is very high and the performed insulation characteristics are little different.
Figure 10 shows that under different gas pressures, the curves of the variety of the AC-breakdown voltage for CF3I, N2, CO2 gas mixtures changes as the content changes. Generally, with the same mixing ratio of CF3I, the breakdown strength becomes stronger with the increasing ratio of CO2. The same as the judge of the foregoing, the change of the gas mixtures of CF3I is not obvious as the contents of N2 and CO2 change. What is worthy to be concentrated, it is that N2 has higher insulation strength than CO2, but it does not perform in the CF3I gas mixtures.
5. Power frequency AC-breakdown characteristics of C3F7CN/CO2
AC-breakdown characteristics of C4F7CN mixed with CO2 are tested for different concentrations. Figure 11 shows that AC-breakdown voltage of C3F7CN/CO2 gas mixtures varies as the mixture ratio changes between 0 and 10% under different air pressures. Under the same gas pressure, as the mixture ratio of C4F7CN
6. Lightning impulse characteristics of c-C4F8, N2, CO2 gas mixtures
Figures 12 and 13 show the testing curves of the positive lightning impulse voltage of gas mixtures of 10% c-C4F8 with N2 and CO2. The positive lightning impulse voltage increases as the electrodes gap increases without the performance of the trend to saturation in SF6 gas mixtures, and the breakdown voltage increases nearly linearly as the air pressure increases. From the perspective of the excitation energy and the ionisation energy of the microcosmic parameters, c-C4F8 is more appropriate to be mixed with CO2 and the positive lightning impulse breakdown voltage of CO2 is higher than N2. According with Figures 12 and 13, it can be seen that 10%c-C4F8 + 90%CO2 gas mixtures have the highest breakdown voltage and 10%c-C4F8 + 90%N2 gas mixtures have the lowest breakdown voltage.
Figure 14 shows the different curves of positive lightning impulse breakdown voltage of the gas mixtures of 10%c-C4F8 with N2 and CO2 as the content of N2 and CO2 changes. Because of CO2 itself has stronger ability to tolerate positive lightning impulse and it will not have obvious ionisation with c-C4F8 compared with N2, the breakdown voltage increases as the content of CO2 in the gas mixtures increases. Because of the high resonance excitation, energy of N2 in the gas mixtures will have negative impact on CO2 when the content of N2 exceeds 30%. The increase of breakdown voltage of the gas mixtures is not obvious, and when the content of N2 is lower than 30%, the positive lightning impulse breakdown voltage shows more obvious trend to increase as the content of CO2 increases. Comparing 10%c-C4F8 + 90%N2 and 10%c-C4F8 + 90%CO2, it is not hard to find that 10%c-C4F8 + 90%CO2 has obviously higher positive lightning impulse breakdown voltage.
7. Lightning impulse characteristics of the CF3I, N2, CO2 gas mixtures
Figures 15 and 16 show the curves of the positive lightning impulse (means that the impulse voltage is applied to sphere electrode, and the plane electrode is connected to ground) breakdown voltage of 10% CF3I with N2 and CO2 of different contents. The positive lightning impulse voltage of CF3I gas mixtures increases with a little saturation as the electrodes gap and air pressure increase. From the difference of breakdown voltages of gas mixtures with different contents and ratios, it can be seen that CF3I has the similar properties with c-C4F8 and it is more appropriate to mix with CO2.
Figure 17 shows the variation of the positive lightning impulse breakdown voltage of the gas mixtures consisting of 10% CF3I and N2 as well as CO2 as the mixture ratio changes. The curves in Figure 17 have the same change with the c-C4F8 gas mixtures, when the content of N2 is lower than 30%, the excitation energy can weaken the ionisation of CF3I and CO2, and the breakdown voltage of the gas mixtures increases obviously and this is the same with the changing trend of c-C4F8 gas mixtures.
Moreover, for the areas with warm climate, electric apparatus such as transformer and high voltage power transmission wire are promising to use c-C4F8 gas mixtures as insulation media forming gas insulation transformer (GIT), gas insulation line (GIL) and cabinet Gas Insulated Switchgear at middle and low voltage (C-GIS).
CF3I and N2 mixed gas can be used as replacement of SF6 gas in the C-GIS at a low pressure, which has bigger advantage on the dielectric strength, liquefaction temperature and cost, especially in 30% proportion of CF3I in mixed gases, that is the most likely to be feasible.
As environmentally friendly insulation gas, CF3I and its gas mixtures is a hot-topic on the global scope for gas insulating systems. The application of CF3I and its gas mixtures in high-voltage apparatus not only meets the requirements and current trends on environmental protection in the international community, but also is a new direction in the field of electrical insulation.
To sum up, taking into account environmental characteristics, insulating properties and liquefaction temperature, CF3I gas mixtures can be applied prior to C-GIS in the middle, low voltage system as well as GIL, GIT and other electrical devices in high-voltage system.
This work is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 51337006).
Yunkun D. Basic research of the environmentally friendly insulating gas CF3I for its application in electric power apparatus [PhD thesis]. Shanghai: Shanghai Jiao Tong University; 2016
Reilly J, Prinn R, Harnisch J, Fitzmaurice J, Jacoby H, Kicklighter D, et al. Multi-gas assessment of the Kyoto protocol. Nature. 1999; 401:3466-3469
Qingchen C, Yongxiang Z, Gao X, Wang M. Paris agreement: A new start for global governance on climate. Progress in Climate Change Research. 2016; 12:61-67
National Development and Reform Commission. China's Policy and Action on Climate Change 2017. Beijing: China Government; 2017
WMO. The state of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere based on global observations through 2016. WMO Greenhouse Gas Bulletin (GHG Bulletin). October 2017; 13, 30:1
CE. Why Climate Policy-Makers can't Afford to Overlook Fully Fluorinated Compounds. Washington: World Resources Institute; 1995
Xiangwan D. Opening a new stage of global green low-carbon development. China Awards for Science and Technology. 2016:6-6
Dengming Xiao. Gas Discharge and Gas Insulation. China: Springer; 2016
Wwvh W, Wwvl W, Connor JT, Astin AV, Engineerin SK. National Bureau of Standards. IRE Transactions on Aeronautical & Navigational Electronics. 2012; 2:111-114
Liu X, Wang J, Wang Y, Zhang Z, Xiao D. Analysis of the insulation characteristics of c-C4F8/CO2 gas mixtures by the Monte Carlo method. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics. 2008; 41:015206
Costello MG, Flynn RM, Bulinski MJ. Fluorinated nitriles as dielectric gases. Google Patents; 2013
Nishimura H, Huo WM, Ali MA, Kim YK. Electron-impact total ionization cross sections of CF4, C2F6, and C3F8. Journal of Chemical Physics. 1999; 110:3811-3822
Devins J. Replacement gases for SF6. IEEE Transactions on Electrical Insulation. 1980:81-86
Christophorou LG, Olthoff JK, Green DS. Gases for electrical insulation and arc interruption: Possible present and future alternatives to pure SF6. NIST TN-1425. 2011; 8:391
Xiao D, Zhu L, Li X. Electron transport coefficients in SF6 and xenon gas mixtures. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics. 2000; 33:L145
Christophorou LG, Olthoff JK. Electron interactions with c-C4F8. Journal of Physical and Chemical Reference Data. 2001; 30:449-473
Zhao S, Jiao J, Zhao X, Zhang H, Xiao D, Yan JD. Synergistic effect of c-C4F8/N2 gas mixtures in slightly non-uniform electric field under lightning impulse. In: IEEE Electrical Insulation Conference; 2016. pp. 531-534
Wu B-T, Xiao D-M, Liu Z-S, Zhang L-C, Liu X-L. Analysis of insulation characteristics of c-C4F8 and N2 gas mixtures by the Monte Carlo method. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics. 2006; 39:4204
Macko WMJ. Toxicity review for Iodotrifluoromethane (CF3I). In: Halon Options Technical Working Conference. US. 1999
NFP Association. Standard on Clean Agent Fire Extinguishing Systems. In: NFPA 2001. New Orleans, LA, U.S.: Technical Committee on Halon Alternative Protection Options; 2000. p. 109
De Urquijo J. Is CF3I a good gaseous dielectric? A comparative swarm study of CF3I and SF6. Journal of Physics: Conference Series 86, 2007:012008
Yun-Kun D, Deng-Ming X. The effective ionization coefficients and electron drift velocities in gas mixtures of CF3I with N2 and CO2 obtained from Boltzmann equation analysis. Chinese Physics B. 2013; 22:035101
Kimura M, Nakamura Y. Electron swarm parameters in CF3I and a set of electron collision cross sections for the CF3I molecule. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics. 2010; 43:145202
Cressault Y, Connord V, Hingana H, Teulet P, Gleizes A. Transport properties of CF3I thermal plasmas mixed with CO2, air or N2 as an alternative to SF6 plasmas in high-voltage circuit breakers. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics. 2011; 44:495202
De Urquijo J, Mitrani A, Ruíz-Vargas G, Basurto E. Limiting field strength and electron swarm coefficients of the CF3I–SF6 gas mixture. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics. 2011; 44:342001
De Urquijo J, Juárez A, Basurto E, Hernández-Ávila J. Electron impact ionization and attachment, drift velocities and longitudinal diffusion in CF3I and CF3I–N2 mixtures. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics. 2007; 40:2205
Xiaoxing Z, Junjie Z, Ju T, Song X, Yefei H.“Experimental research on the partial discharge insulation properties of CF3I/CO2 and CF3I/N2 gas mixtures,” Proceedings of the CSEE, vol. 34, pp. 1948-1956, 2014
ZHAO Su, XIAO Dengming, ZHANG Hui, and DENG Yunkun, “Investigation on discharge polarity effect of CF3I/N2 gas mixtures under lightning impulse,” Proceedings of the CSEE, vol. 37, pp. 3636-3642, 2017
Li X, Zhao H, Wu J, Jia S. Analysis of the insulation characteristics of CF3I mixtures with CF4, CO2, N2, O2 and air. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics. 2013; 46:345203
Zhao X, Li B, Xiao D, Deng Y. Breakdown characteristics of CF3I-N2 gas mixtures in a needle-plate geometry. IEEE Transactions on Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation. 24 April 2017; 24:869-875
Xiao S, Cressault Y, Zhang X, Teulet P. The influence of Cu, Al, or Fe on the insulating capacity of CF3I. Physics of Plasmas. 2016; 23:123505
Kochetov I, Napartovich A, Vagin N, Yuryshev N. Mechanism of pulse discharge production of iodine atoms from CF3I molecules for a chemical oxygen–iodine laser. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics. 2009; 42:055201
Kieffel Y. Characteristics of G3—An alternative to SF6. In: IEEE International Conference on Dielectrics; 2016. pp. 880-884
Switzerland: ABB achieves breakthrough in switchgear technology with eco-efficient insulation gas. Tendersinfo News. 2014
Rabie M, Franck CM. Assessment of eco-friendly gases for electrical insulation to replace the most potent industrial greenhouse gas SF6. Environmental Science & Technology. 2017:369-380
Stoller PC, Doiron CB, Tehlar D, Simka P, Ranjan N. Mixtures of CO2 and C5F10O perfluoroketone for high voltage applications. IEEE Transactions on Dielectrics & Electrical Insulation. 2017; 24:2712-2721
Zhao S, Xiao D, Jiao J, Zhao X. Discharge characteristics of c-C4F8/N2 with and without insulator under standard lightning impulse. Presented at the IEEE Electrical Insulation Conference; 2016