Choledochal cysts are congenital bile duct anomalies. These cystic dilatations of the biliary tree can involve the extrahepatic biliary radicles, the intrahepatic biliary radicles, or both. The etiology remains unknown, but choledochal cysts are likely to be congenital in nature. Cyst excision is the definitive treatment of choice for choledochal cyst because of the high morbidity and high risk of carcinoma after internal drainage, a commonly used treatment in the past. CDC is a congenital anomaly involving cystic dilatation of various ducts of biliary tree. The precise etiology of extrahepatic cysts continues to remain unclear. The most commonly accepted theory is an anomalous pancreatobiliary duct junction (APBDJ) and abnormal function of the sphincter of Oddi. Proper imaging plays an essential role in preoperative planning. Proper diagnosis evaluation and management is essential for optimal management. Type I cysts are the most frequently encountered. Choledochal cysts can have variable presentations. Hepatobiliary ultrasound and MRCP are the present day standards for imaging; early diagnosis should be the norm to avoid possible late complications of cholangitis, cirrhosis, hepaticolithiasis and spontaneous perforation. Excision of the cyst with hepaticojejunostomy is the best approach.
- choledochal cyst
- abnormal pancreatico biliary duct junction
- common bile duct
Choledochal cyst (CDC) is the congenital dilatation of the bile ducts. The condition is a relatively rare abnormality with an estimated incidence of 1 in 13,000–15,000 in Western populations. However, this condition is far more common in the East, with an incidence of 1 per 1000 in Japan [1, 2]. The etiology remains unknown, but choledochal cysts are likely to be congenital in nature. Other proposed theories include distal obstruction, Abnormal Pancreatico-biliary Duct Junction (APBDJ), sphnictor oddi dysfunction. The pathologic features of the CDC frequently include an anomalous junction of the pancreatic and common bile ducts pancreaticobiliary malunion (PBMU), intrahepatic bile duct dilatation, and various degrees of hepatic fibrosis. Anatomically choledochal cysts are usually classified into three groups. However, based on the cholangiographic findings of intrahepatic ducts or pancreaticobiliary malunion (PBMU), the so-called long common channel, other forms and subgroups have been described. Left untreated, choledochal cysts can undergo malignant transformation and promote progressive hepatic fibrosis. About 20% case present during adulthood . The gallbladder or bile duct malignancy has been reported as 6–20% and 15–20% in the United States and Japan, respectively [4, 5]. Therefore, treatment includes complete excision of the cysts with Roux-en-Y hepatojejunostomy and close surveillance.
The etiology of choledochal cystic disease remains ill-defined; however, these malformations are considered congenital because they occur in fetuses and in newborns. The most commonly accepted theory for choledochal cysts is based on the observation that they are frequently associated with an anomalous pancreatobiliary duct junction (APBDJ). The “long common channel theory” explained that APBDJ allows reflux of pancreatic enzymes into the common bile duct. The reflux of pancreatic juice results in dissolution of the ductal wall and obstruction at distal end of cyst due to edema/fibrosis .
Another theory proposed that this disease results from derangement in normal embryologic remodeling of ducts and causes varying degrees of destructive inflammation and segmental dilatation [7, 8]. Kusunoki et al. demonstrated suboptimal number of ganglion cells in the narrow portion if the common bile duct in patients with a choledochal cyst, as compared with controls [9, 10]. Based on an experimental study in which cystic dilatation of the common bile duct was produced by ligation of the distal end of the common bile duct in the neonatal lamb, an obstructive factor in the early developmental stage was described as a causative factor.
APBJ is defined as a junction between the pancreatic and bile ducts and is located outside of the duodenal wall . Babbitt analyzed that most choledochal cysts were complicated by APBJ . APBJ is classified into two types (P-C and C-P type) by analyzing the fusion pattern between the pancreatic and bile ducts. In the P-C type, the main pancreatic duct joins the common bile duct, while the common bile duct appears to join the main pancreatic duct in the C-P type .
In 1991, Komi et al. classified APBJ into three groups type I, II, and III according to the running of the accessory pancreatic duct and dilatation of the common channel Types I and II correspond to the C-P type, P-C type and type III was named as complex type of APBJ . The incidence of type I, II, and III APBJ was 35.3, 21.6, 43.1%, respectively (Figures 1 and 2).
In 2003, Tashiro et al. analyzed 1627 patients of CDC and found patients with APBJ overlapped with that in normal cases. Furthermore, reflux of the pancreatic juice was reported in patients without APBDJ. Considering the conditions similar to APBJ, APBJ should be defined as when the long common channel with out any relation to sphincter of Oddi contraction .
3. Classification of choledochal cyst
Based on the site of cystic changes five types of CDC have been described by Todani and colleagues Type
Pathologic changes in the liver including portal fibrosis, central venous dilataion, parenchymal inflammation, and bile duct proliferation. Furthermore, fibrosis of cyst wall lined by columnar epithelium, lymphocytic infiltration and mucosal dysplasia is also seen. Histologic appearances in Type I (and sometimes type IV) CDC is lack biliary mucosa; type II CDC closely resemble gallbladder duplication. Type III cysts are lined by duodenal mucosa, while type V cysts can have extensive hepatic fibrosis . In the walls of CC there is increasing rate of epithelial metaplasia and biliary intraepithelial neoplasia with advancing age. Although the incidence of malignancy at diagnosis of CDC increases with age at diagnosis, the risk of developing a future malignancy in an existing benign CDC during one’s remaining lifetime likely decreases with advancing age. Carcinogenesis is thought to occur via multistep genetic events where early K-ras and p53 mutations are seen in more than 60% of CC-related carcinomas, followed by a late occurring DPC-4 gene inactivation .
Gallbladder carcinoma is identified in 10–25% of CDC-related malignancies 5.10 Malignancy is most commonly associated with types I and IV cysts, while types II, III, and V CC have minimal neoplastic risk. Most reported cases of malignant transformation are cholangiocarcinoma. The presence of an APBDU is thought to play a role in carcinogenesis and hepatocellular damage due to reflux of pancreatic contents into the bile duct .
4. Clinical features
4.1. Prenatal diagnosis
Choledochal cysts are being diagnosed with increasing frequency on prenatal sonography. Ultrasound typically reveals a cyst at the porta hepatis. The differential diagnosis of a cyst in the porta hepatis includes duodenal atresia, mesenteric or omental cysts, hepatic cysts, intestinal duplication, gallbladder duplication, and ovarian cysts . Because choledochal cysts are rare anomalies, prenatal diagnosis can be challenging. Sensitivity and specificity of prenatal ultrasound for choledochal cysts increases if sonologist performing the prenatal ultrasound is experienced MRI does not add significantly to the information found on ultrasound, but both imaging techniques may be complementary to each other.
Choledochal cysts historically presented in two broad categories:
(1) The infantile form, indicated by obstructive jaundice.
(2) The adult form, generally presenting with obstructive jaundice, pancreatitis, or ascending cholangitis.
4.1.1. Infantile form
The infantile form present as obstructive jaundice. Jaundice in choledochal cyst is often intermittent because the obstruction is rarely complete unlike in biliary atresia. Character of jaundice is an important ominous symptom in differentiating obstructive jaundice due to biliary duct cystic dilatation from obstructive jaundice due to biliary atresia. Many of these neonates may have choledochal cysts in conjunction with complete or nearly complete biliary obstruction. Some authors report these patients as having biliary atresia in association with choledochal cyst, whereas others may term these patients as having surgically correctable biliary atresia. Distinguishing between cystic biliary atresia (CBA) and CDC is important because delayed therapy in CBA results in irreversible long-term sequelae. Unlike BA, CDC and CBA can typically be identified with prenatal ultrasound; however, these lesions are often all thought to be CC until surgical intervention . On ultrasound, CBA on USG appears smaller with less dilatation of intrahepatic ducts .
Those with an infantile form need surgical excision and reconstruction within the first several weeks of life to avoid potential complications of cholangitis and hepatopathy. It is recommended to perform operation for asymptomatic choledochal cysts diagnosed prenatally within the first year of life. Congenital anomalies Associated with CC include double common bile duct, sclerosing cholangitis, congenital hepatic fibrosis, pancreatic cyst, and annular pancreas. Thirty one percent of pediatric patients with CDC have congenital cardiac anomaly and are most commonly manifested in infancy [29, 30].
However, CBA patients are symptomatic at earlier ages (less than 3 months old), and one-third of CBA patients develop liver failure or require liver transplantation. Triangular cord sign (a thickness of the echogenic anterior wall of the right portal vein just proximal to the right portal vein bifurcation) and the presence of biliary sludge are characteristic features suggestive of CBA rather than CDC.
4.1.2. Adult form
Common presentations in children in adults include abdominal pain, jaundice, and right upper quadrant mass and are most commonly seen in pediatric patients. The classic triad of abdominal pain, right upper quadrant mass, and obstructive jaundice, although still rare is seen in the pediatric population.
Adults are more likely to present with biliary or pancreatic symptoms and abdominal pain. Abdominal mass and Jaundice are feature sin childhood . Adults with CC may present with symptomatic gallstones or acute cholecystitis, both of which are attributed to biliary stasis. Pain similar to recurrent pancreatitis has been described by some patients . However, these patients may truly be having pancreatitis as a result of mucous plugging in the APBDJ.
Complications in Choledochal cysts in adults include development of cholelithiasis, liver cirrhosis, portal hypertension, hepatic abscess, and biliary carcinoma . Thus, the incidence of postoperative complications is quite high even after primary cyst excision.
Ultrasonography is a preliminary imaging modality for detecting choledochal cysts, which shows a cystic mass in the right upper quadrant apart from the gallbladder. The sensitivity of Ultrasonography for diagnosing choledochal cysts is 71–97%. In recent years, the number of patients who are diagnosed by antenatal ultrasonography is increasing. This method also clearly demonstrates IHBD dilatation and the state of the liver parenchyma. Caroli’s disease, polycystic liver disease and primary sclerosing cholangitis have similar in radiographic appearance. Cysts in polycystic liver disease do not communicate with the biliary tree, while primary sclerosing cholangitis is associated with a distal biliary obstruction and inflammatory bowel disease. A CBD measuring greater than 10 mm in an adults is an indication for further imaging in order to differentiate type I cysts from type IVA disease. Other features suggestive of CDC are a right upper quadrant cyst separate from the gallbladder and presence of a direct communication between the biliary tree and the cystic duct .
5.2. HIDA scan
If a choledochal cyst is suspected on ultrasound. The Technectium-99 HIDA scan has varying sensitivities, with 100% for type I cysts and 67% for type IV. It is particularly useful for showing continuity with bile ducts and diagnosis of cyst rupture in patients with choledochal cysts. Hepatobiliary scintigraphy complements other diagnostic tools in the diagnosis of choledochal cysts in pediatric patients . A HIDA scan is be helpful for distinguishing between choledochal cyst and biliary atresia. Choledochal cyst will have contrast entering the duodenum, whereas in patients with biliary atresia will lack of contrast emptying into the duodenum.
5.3. CT scanning
CT scanning is a useful imaging tool for detecting choledochal cysts, but it is difficult to delineate pancreatic and bile duct union. Multidetector computed tomography (MDCT) provides detailed information on the pancreatic and bile ducts. In patients with suspected APBJ. Intrahepatic ducts, distal common bile ducts, and the pancreatic duct, are reliably identified on CT scan, thus useful in identifying type IV and type V cysts. CT cholangiography is now a historical imaging modality in CDC. The sensitivity of CT cholangiography is 90% for diagnosing choledochal cysts, and only 64% for characterizing the pancreatic duct . The obvious drawbacks of CT or CT cholangiography are nephrotoxicity or hepatotoxicity and radiation exposure. Because of better investigations the use of CT is now very limited.
5.4. Magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography (MRCP)
MRCP being a noninvasive investigation provides excellent delineation of pancreatico biliary ducts. It can replace ERCP as a diagnostic method for evaluation of biliary- pancreatic tract. MRCP reliably identifies APBDJ. Sensitivity and specificity of MRCP in diagnosing CDC is (70–100%) and (90–100%), respectively . Although MRCP is limited in its ability to detect minor ductal abnormalities or small choledochoceles. 88 Magnetic resonance Cholangiopancreatography cannot be used for therapeutic purposes; therefore its utility remains limited as a diagnostic tool. Another advantage of MRCP over ERCP is that the pancreatic duct can be visualized upstream to an obstruction .
5.5. ERCP, PTC, intraoperative cholangiography
Invasive imaging studies also play a role in diagnosis and evaluation of the biliary anatomy. These modalities include cholangiography through endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP), percutaneous transhepatic cholangiography (PTC), and intraoperative cholangiogram. Endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) is the gold standard for diagnosis of APBJ. ERCP is a type of invasive direct cholangiography, which may be associated with significant morbidity and mortality. ERCP can be challenging with respect to cannulization of the ampulla, due to recurrent inflammation and scarring. Cholangiography will delineate the anatomy and PBM and filling defects caused by stones, stenosis, or carcinomas. ERCP can be challenging with respect to cannulization of the ampulla. Cholangitis and pancreatitis after invasive cholangiography is higher than in the general population. A high volume of dye load is often required for adequate visualization, especially in the setting of large cysts .
The surgical treatment of choledochal cystic disease has evolved and been refined over the past century. Aspiration and marsupialisation were the earliest forms of surgical therapy, the development of external biliary fistulae. Complete cyst excision and internal drainage by hepaticoduodenostomy (McWhorter in 1924) however, unacceptable mortality rates were encountered. Gross advocated internal drainage by choledochocystduodenostomy in 1933 because of unacceptably high risk of cyst excision at that time. Subsequent patient evaluation, however, revealed morbidity rates approaching 50%, primarily a result of cholangitis from duodenal reflux. The transection level of the common hepatic duct and currently, complete excision of a cyst with cholecystectomy and Roux-en-Y hepaticojejunostomy reconstruction (RYHJ) is the standard therapy in Types I and IV-A cysts . Although the overall morbidity was diminished, the risk of malignant degeneration within the cystic remnant was recognized. Persistent, although markedly diminished episodes of cholangitis in RYHJ reconstructions led to the development of a valved jejunal interposition. No studies have independently confirmed the efficacy of valved intestinal conduits in the prevention of reflux-induced cholangitis. Pericystic inflammation may prevent safe complete-cyst excision. An internal approach, as described by Lilly, requires mucosectomy of the inner epithelial lining prior to reconstruction, but avoids the danger of a difficult posterior dissection.
7. Cyst excision
A laparotomy through a high transverse or oblique right upper quadrant incision gives excellent exposure. The appearance of the liver, spleen, and pancreas is noted. If the anatomy has not been clearly defined preoperatively, an intraoperative cholangiogram should be performed. Aspirated the bile from the cyst and send it for culture and measurement of amylase/lipase. With large cysts, dye should be injection directly into the lower end of the common bile duct and into the common hepatic duct using a butterfly needle. Direct injection into a large cyst may obscure filling of the distal duct, it is important to try to identify the junction of the pancreatic and bile ducts . If the cyst is extremely inflamed and adhesions are very dense, mucosectomy of the cyst should be performed rather than full-thickness dissection to minimize the risk of injuring the surrounding structures such as portal vein and hepatic artery (Figure 3). Where the bile duct begins to narrow down inferiorly, it is dissected circumferentially and encircled. The distal common bile duct is dissected to just within the head of the pancreas and transected. Common channel should be cleared with combination of saline irrigation, balloon catheters and, when possible. Intraoperative endoscopy helps removing plugs. Distal bile duct stump is transfixed with an absorbable suture  (Figure 4).
After dissection of GB and cyst, the portal vein is exposed. At times the right hepatic artery crosses in front of the cyst and is adherent to its wall and in this situation right hepatic artery must be carefully freed and preserved. The common hepatic duct is divided at the level of the bifurcation, where it should appear healthy and well vascularised (Figure 5).
To allow a wider bilio-enteric anastomosis, left duct is incised 5–10 mm. Anastomosis to a narrow common hepatic duct should be avoided because of the long-term risk of stricture. The duodenojejunal flexure is identified and the Roux loop jejunum anastomosed at duct bifurcation using fine, interrupted, absorbable monofilament sutures (6/0 or 7/0 PDS) (Figure 6).
Dilatation of the peripheral portion of the IHBD is associated with late complications which include recurrent cholangitis, stone formation, and anastomotic stricture. Intrahepatic cystenterostomy, or balloon dilatation of the stenosis at the time of cyst excision are options for dilatation of IHD.
The prognosis of choledochal cyst is excellent if the diagnosis is made expediently prior to the development of irreversible liver disease or malignancy. The common late complications are cholangitis, obstructive jaundice, pancreatitis, stone formation, and portal hypertension . Long-term outcomes after excision and hepaticojejunostomy reconstruction for choledochal cysts have been reported in different series. Most of these show that with standard treatment of excision and drainage, these patients will have no significant sequelae from this treatment.
The congenital hepatic fibrosis coexistent in patients with type V CCD, it predisposes patient to portal hypertension. The incidence of cholelithiasis due to bile stasis is around 37.5–74%. Hepatolithiasis is most often associated with type IV-A CCD and is related to the presence of membranous or septal stenosis . Total cyst excision reduces the risk of malignancy. However, sporadic malignancy has been reported after the excision of cysts. Cholangiocarcinoma developing after total resection of choledochal cysts after 10 to 34 years has been previously reported .
Biliary tract malignant tumor were associated in 80 patients (9.9%); 40 had bile duct cancer (50.0%), 35 had gallbladder cancer (43.8%), 3 had periampullary cancer, synchronous gallbladder and bile duct cancer was found in 2 patients. With a median follow-up duration of 51.8 months, 26.3% had a recurrence .
Incidence of hepato-biliary cancer in TYPE I, TYPE III, Type Iva, unknown was reported to be 71,1.3, 22.5 and 5%. Significantly more patients classified with type IVa had bile duct cancer and significantly more patients classified with type I had gallbladder cancer (
In a review of 200 children who had cyst excision. Primary cyst excision was performed in 176, 19 had cyst excision converted from other biliary surgery. The mean follow-up period was 10.9 years. In 188 patients Roux-en-Y hepaticojejunostomy was performed, 11 had standard hepaticoduodenostomy, and one had a jejunal interposition hepaticojejunostomy. There was no operative mortality. Eighteen (9.0%) patients had complications including cholangitis choledochus calculi, pancreatitis, and small bowel obstruction. Fifteen of the 18 children required surgical interventions such as revision of the hepaticoenterostomy. There was no occurrence of malignancy .
CDC is a congenital anomaly of hepatobiliary ducts. Various theories have been proposed including congenital origin, APBDJ, and defects in canalization during embryogenesis. CDC has been divided into five types depending on location of cyst. Choledochal cysts can have variable presentations ranging from infantile Cholestasis to pain abdomen jaundice and abdominal lump in adults. MRCP is the main investigation for diagnosis early diagnosis and treatment avoids possible late complications of cholangitis, cirrhosis, hepaticolithiasis and spontaneous perforation. Excision of the cyst with Roux-N Y hepaticojejunostomy is the best approach.