Systematic reviews of the epidemiological studies assessing the relation between prenatal exposure to air pollution and reproductive outcomes. BW: birth weight; LBW: low birth weight (<2500 g), VLBW: very low birth weight (<1500 g). SGA: small for gestational age, IUGR: intrauterine growth restriction. TSP: total suspended particulate; PM10: particulate matter <10 µm; PM2.5: particulate matter <2.5 µm, PAH: polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon, POM: polycyclic organic matter; BTEX: benzene, toluene, ethyl-benzene, xylene
Air pollution is largely recognized as a risk factor for several outcomes including increased mortality, increased hospital admissions and emergency visits for both respiratory and cardiovascular diseases, and impairment of respiratory function, including reduced lung function, exacerbation of asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (Brunekreef & Holgate, 2002). Some populations have shown to be more susceptible to these effects, and among them including those people in the tails of the age distribution, i.e. the elderly and infants (Laumbach, 2010).
The study of fetal growth and birth outcomes has become an important emerging field of environmental epidemiology (Sram et al., 2005). Birth outcomes are important indicators of pregnancy and infant care as well as newborn and infant health. Besides that, reduction in fetal growth has been associated with health problems and developmental delays during childhood, from an increase in hospitalizations (Morris et al., 1998) to poor cognitive and neurological development (Richards et al., 2002) as well as with an increased risk of chronic diseases later in life (Barker, 2007).
Fetuses, like infants, present a special vulnerability, compared to adults, regarding environmental toxicants due to differences in exposure, physiological immaturity, and longer life expectancy after exposure (Perera et al., 2002; Schwartz, 2004). Results from epidemiological and experimental studies show that fetuses and infants are especially susceptible to the toxic effects of pollutants such as suspended particles, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH), and tobacco smoke (Perera et al., 2003). In recent years, a growing body of epidemiological research has focused on the potential impact of prenatal exposure to air pollution on birth outcomes.
In recent years a number of authors have reviewed the evidence on the relation between prenatal exposure to air pollutants and reproductive outcomes. In these reviews several outcomes have been related to exposure to air pollution during pregnancy, including low birth weight, reduced birth size, fetal growth retardation, pre-term birth, stillbirth, congenital malformations, and infant mortality.
A limited number of studies have linked different birth defects to routinely measured air pollutants, but results thus far are equivocal at best. Practically the same could be said concerning stillbirth. Very few epidemiologic studies have elaborated on the impact of air pollution on the risk for stillbirth; results were inconsistent and the studies did not elaborate on the susceptible time of pregnancy. As an example, a recent study conducted in northern England found no association between black smoke air pollution and the risk of stillbirth during pregnancy (Pearce et al., 2010).
Some methodological problems have been argued in the epidemiological studies assessing the impact of air pollution on reproductive outcomes. Authors of recent methodological reviews (Ritz & Wilhelm, 2008; Slama et al., 2008; Woodruff et al., 2009) agree that new prospective studies should allow adequate evaluation of fetal growth (i.e. through ultrasound measurements), valid assessment of air pollution exposure, consider different time windows of exposure, and collect sufficient information on confounding variables.
Our objective in this chapter is to examine and summarize the evidence on the relation between ambient air pollution during pregnancy and birth outcomes. Additionally, we aim to describe some methodological problems and make recommendations for future studies.
2. Methodological aspects
In the past decade, there has been a sharp increase in the number of scientific studies describing possible effects of air pollution on perinatal health. These studies resulted in a considerable amount of research articles published on this topic. Reviews of the preceding literature have been published generally concluding that the evidence, although suggestive of an adverse effect, was difficult to synthesize. Variability existed of course in the nature of the pollutants and outcomes investigated but also there were important differences in the availability of data, study design and statistical analysis.
To discuss the contribution of methodological aspects on findings, heterogeneity is the basis to identify priorities and make recommendations for future research. This aim led to several international workshops and published reviews covering the main challenges and the main methodological aspects of perinatal air pollution epidemiology (Slama et al., 2008). Also trying to discern how differences in research methods contributed to variations in findings, the datasets from 20 different studies along six countries have been analyzed using a standardised protocol (Parker et al., 2011), within a recent initiative by international collaborators (Woodruff et al., 2010).
A synopsis of key methodological issues surrounding the study of air pollution effects on perinatal health is highlighted bellow.
2.1. Study design
Time-series is the typical design in air pollution epidemiology, and it has been used to study preterm birth and fetal death (Pereira et al., 1998, Sagiv et al., 2005). Under this design, population-aggregated daily counts of health events relating to daily levels of pollutants are analyzed. The time series approach, by design, controls for confounders constant over time. In consequence, there is much less concern for personal characteristics than for weather-related confounders. However, this approach only addresses short-term effects and relies on temporal variations. It appears that taking into consideration geographical variations and also medium-term temporal contrasts could be more efficient in reducing residual confounding. Furthermore, traditional time-series design assumes that the population at risk remains stable across time, a hypothesis that may be not satisfied dealing with adverse birth outcomes because of seasonality of birth influenced by socio-demographic factors (Bobak et al., 2001).
Linkage of registry data such as birth certificates, with exposure measures of ambient air quality, typically from outdoor stationary monitors has been applied much more in the last decade, resulting in a fast-growing body of evidence on adverse effects of air pollution on fetal development (Salam et al., 2005). This approach has the advantage of allowing large-size studies at a very low cost because it relies on routinely collected data. Its limitation is that relevant information at the individual level is unavailable from birth registers and its absence in analyses may clearly lead to misclassification and confounding.
Potential confounders in this context are socio-economic and occupational status, adverse behaviours such as alcohol or tobacco use, or poor diet. Apart from confusion, effect modification can occur as certain subpopulations of women and fetuses may be especially vulnerable to air pollutants. To this respect, several studies suggest a stronger effect for males that for females (Jedrychowski et al., 2009; Ghosh et al., 2007).
For these reasons, prospective cohort studies with recruitment of women at earlier stages of pregnancy are a promising alternative: They collect detailed information on potential confounders and allow the personal assessment of exposure and the use of biomarkers (Estarlich et al., 2011). As an added value, under some conditions, causality may be inferred from them. Its main limitation is the associated high cost, leading to reduced sample sizes.
The trade-off between small studies rich in individual information and big studies based on registries with scarce information about confounders and risk factors should be taken in consideration (van den Hooven et al., 2009). A possibility is to combine the strengths of these two designs by conducting case–control studies (Hansen et al., 2009) with collection of additional information at the individual level for a sample nested within a big cohort constituted from birth records.
2.2. Exposure assessment
Various approaches may be used to estimate air pollution exposure, from the use of biomarkers of exposure to environmental models. Obviously, the most accurate information of individual exposure should be derived from short-term personal monitoring and biomarkers. However, both are scarcely used because of their extreme cost and inability to discern the appropriate timing of measurement or source contributions. Studies using personal measurements are relatively small in size and commonly used as validation studies of other modelling approaches (Nethery et al., 2009).
As was said before, there are a number of with exposure assessment based on data from monitoring networks. These studies use data from the monitoring station closest to the subject’s home address or interpolating data for neighbouring monitors, for which measurements are averaged over the entire pregnancy or over each trimester of pregnancy. Advantages of this approach are the use of readily available exposure data, simple implementation and, as pollutants are assessed on an hourly or daily basis, high flexibility in terms of the temporal exposure window considered (Lepeule et al., 2010). Nevertheless, the individual exposure assignment based exclusively on them is prone to inaccuracy because the number of sampling locations is often scarce failing to capture the spatial variability. Furthermore sampling locations could be biased towards specific sources of pollution (i.e. traffic, background, industry) and not always provide continuously measured data (i.e. Particles 2.5 µm diameter (PM2.5) in the US is often measured every 3–6 days).
Nitrogen dioxide (NO2) is one air pollutant frequently used as a surrogate for traffic related pollution in prospective studies, both in adults and in children (Jerrett et al., 2008; Brunekreef, 2007). This is the case because outdoor NO2 levels correlate well with traffic generated pollutants. NO2 concentrations may be easily measured using passive samplers, and are routinely measured by air quality networks allowing for correction for temporal variations. Several epidemiologic studies have examined associations between maternal exposure to nitrogen dioxide during pregnancy and reproductive outcomes such as prematurity, fetal growth retardation and birth weight. Some of them have introduced other geostatistical models based on measurement campaigns with fine spatial resolution and geographic information systems (GIS) plus temporal adjustment based on background monitoring stations (Lepeule et al., 2010).
Recently, GIS-based approaches have become more commonly used to capture small area variations in pollution. The great development experienced by the GIS managing and displaying spatial data has been decisive in this respect. Within GIS-based approaches, air dispersion models, traffic proximity models and Land-use regression are among the most used. Exposure assessments using traffic proximity (Jerrett et al., 2008; Brunekreef, 2007) or distance-weighted traffic densities as a proxy for individual exposure to air pollution relies on the premise that traffic is a major source of local air pollution. A potential problem with this method is the underlying assumption that pollution spreads uniformly away from its source. Land-use regression (LUR) methods apply regression to map air pollution using geographical variables such as land use, traffic intensity and population density as predictors. (Ghering et al., 2011; Iñiguez et al., 2009; Aguilera et al., 2009). LUR models are an attractive option because they are able to capture fine spatial variability at a very low cost.
Whatever the method used for mapping outdoor levels of air pollution, in most studies personal exposure is the estimated concentration at a home address derived from the map. A large proportion of personal exposure is commuting time, workplace exposure or come from indoor sources, therefore personal exposure assessments should be improved by considering time-activity patterns and indoor sources such as tobacco smoke and cooking. In the case of studies dilated in time, taking into account a possible change of address could be also an important point. Obviously, improving exposure assessment and reducing exposure misclassification would lead to strengthen effect estimates.
Another methodological challenge recently highlighted is the convenience of exploring critical windows of exposure shorter than the whole pregnancy. Pregnancy is a period of big change and the timing of exposure could be as important as the intensity. Studies suggest that exposures at the periconceptional period or first trimester may lead to suboptimal placental or fetal development in earliest stages of pregnancy with ulterior adverse consequences on the duration of pregnancy and fetal growth. At this time, there is a lack of toxicological information to help guide selection of relevant exposure periods for most reproductive outcomes, but an appropriate scale, searching for critical windows may be months or trimesters. For low birth weigth (LBW) and preterm birth, first and third trimester air pollution exposures appears as the most relevant, while for birth defects, the development time of the specific organ has to be considered (Ritz, 2010).
Although trimesters is the most common scale, offering comparability with existing studies, exposure windows shorter than trimesters have also been proposed. In this case it is important to consider if that accuracy is possible given the exposure metrics. (Woodruf, 2009). LUR models are meant to characterize spatial rather than temporal variability in air pollution levels. Aiming to explore critical exposure windows within pregnancy, fine temporal resolution added to fine spatial resolution is required. Temporal patterns observed at ambient monitor stations (measured most days) could be used to adjust LUR model estimates as done by Slama et al. (2007). This assumes the spatial surface (variability) is stable over time and additional monitoring may be needed to verify this assumption.
Another point is the statistical treatment of exposure. The usual way is to consider a linear effect but this assumption widely depends on the examined toxicant. High exposures can lead to outcomes such as spontaneous abortions or stillbirth, removing fetuses at risk for and adverse birth outcome such as LBW or preterm birth, translating to non-linearity in dose effects. Therefore, to explore the shape of relationships by means of non-linear models may be advisable.
Finally, it is also advisable the use of multipollutant models to try to disentangle individual effects. However, multipollutant models may be unfeasible due to high correlation in time and space between air pollutants sharing sources. Given that people breath a mixture of air pollutants, to study synergistic effects may also be important.
The majority of published air pollution and perinatal health studies have evaluated the effect of exposure on fetal growth (usually assessed on the basis of attained weight at birth) and the effect on the duration of gestation. Other important but less studied outcomes related to pregnancy are infertility, fetal loss (including stillbirth and spontaneous abortion) and congenital malformations. These outcomes are briefly defined below in order of its eventual occurrence.
Infertility is the failure of a couple to reproduce after a reasonable time with regular and unprotected sexual intercourse to obtain a pregnancy. One year is usually considered as a deadline, then fertility is treated as a dichotomy, assessing the proportion of couples that fail to conceive within a 12-month period. Because there is not a discontinuity in the probability of conception after 12 cycles, a common alternative approach is to examine the monthly probability of conception in a life-table approach. Both approaches can be derived by assessing time to pregnancy.
Fetal loss is defined as a spontaneous end of pregnancy, without living birth, occurring between conception and the end of labor and excluding induced abortions and medical termination of pregnancy and ectopic pregnancies. Since the clinical, physical and psychological consequences of a fetal loss increase with the time of occurrence, fetal losses are divided in three categories according gestational age (GA): early fetal losses, occurring before than 6 weeks (usual time of detection of pregnancy), spontaneous abortions, occurring between 6 weeks and the time when the fetus is viable, and stillbirth, occurring after this point. The gestational age cut-point between spontaneous abortions and stillbirths could vary between 20 and 28 weeks according local legal definitions. However in epidemiological studies, the 20 or 22 gestational weeks cut-points are most often used.
Congenital malformations: The definition of congenital malformations classically includes structural malformations, syndromes and chromosomal anomalies present in the fetus or the newborn as defined by ICD-10 Q00.0 to Q89.9. It is recognized that a number of congenital malformations are detected during childhood or even adulthood. Since some of them are a major cause of abortion (Eurocat, 2005), these functional defects are identified only in a subset of all fetuses affected. The prevalence of (detected) congenital malformations ranges from 2% (when only major malformations are selected) to 7% when minor forms are included.
Prematurity is defined by the duration of gestation in completed weeks or days. The most common cut-point is 37 weeks (259 days). Accordingly, a preterm birth is defined as an infant born before the completion of the 37th week of gestation. Other dichotomous outcome measures with stringent cut-points aiming to define more extreme deviations from the normal gestational duration are: Extremely premature birth (< 28 weeks or 196 days) and Very preterm birth (< 32 weeks or < 224 days). Prematurity is an important indicator of perinatal and future health. In fact, preterm babies account for 75% of perinatal mortality and more than half of the long- term morbidity (Skalkidou A, et al., 2010).
Fetal Growth is also an important predictor of postnatal health, often based on the attained weight at birth. Birth weight is the standard measure of fetal growth because it is a sensible endpoint and data are greatly available by medical registers. Other measures of neonatal anthropometry such as length, head, abdominal circumference, etc. might provide additional information as well as longitudinal information about fetal parameters (ultrasounds), but they are rarely used in epidemiological studies because of their scarce availability. Different metrics based on birth weight have been used to identify suboptimal fetal growth including a reduction in birth weight (as a continuous variable), low birth weight (LBW), very low birth weight (VLBW), small for gestational age (SGA), intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR) and fetal growth restriction (FGR).
A newborn is defined as small for gestational age (SGA) if its birth weight is lower than the 10th percentile of a suitable gestational age-specific weight reference. Therefore, identification of SGA births requires relevant reference curves.
SGA fails at distinguishing “constitutionally small” infants, according to anthropometric characteristics, to those who are “growth retarded,” that is, smaller than what their parental characteristics, sex, gestational duration would predict.
A newborn is defined as
As introduced above, during the last years different authors have reviewed the epidemiological evidences about the potential effects of air pollution exposure during pregnancy and reproductive outcomes. In the table 1 we summarized the pollutant and outcomes included in the main systematic reviews on these topic.
|Review||Period of study||Pollutants included||Outcomes (and # of studies)||Total # of studies|
|Stillbirth||Preterm birth||BW, LBW, VLBW||SGA, IUGR||Perinatal & Infant mortality||Others|
|Glinianaia et al., 2004||1996-2001||TSP, PM10||3||3||3||3||-||-||12|
|Maisonet et al., 2004||1996-2001||TSP, PM10, PM2.5, CO, SO2, NO2, O3||-||5||9||3||-||-||12|
|Sram et al., 2005||1966-2001||TSP, PM10, PM2.5, CO, SO2, NO2, O3, PAH, POM||2||4||9||4||7||-||23|
|Lacasaña et al., 2005||1994-2003||TSP, PM10, PM2.5, CO, SO2, NO2, NOx, O3, PAH||2||10||17||3||8||Congenital malformation (#: 2)||31|
|Bosseti et al., 2010||1966-june 2010||TSP, PM10, PM2.5||-||13||17||4||-||-||30|
|Shah & Balkhair, 2011||TSP, PM10, PM2.5, CO, SO2, NO2, NO, O3, HAP, BETX||-||11||25||10||-||-||41|
Throughout the last decades the crude human birth rate (live births per 1000 population) declined, suggesting a potential decline in fecundity (the potential to conceive). Detection of environmental contaminants in human tissues, together with reports of a global decline in semen quality, promoted the hypothesis that environmental toxicants could be important causal agents of such decline (Foster et al., 2008).
Epidemiological studies demonstrated exposure to ambient levels of air pollutants, especially airborne particulate matter, has been linked in particular to DNA fragmentation (Selevan et al., 2000) (Evenson et al., 2005) and in general to abnormal sperm morphology and reduced sperm performance in men.. Recent experimental animal data indicated that female fertility is also affected by air pollutants (Veras et al., 2010).
3.2. Fetal loss
A previous review of environmental toxicants and reproductive outcomes only suggested as related to fetal loss the exposure to dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane and bisphenol-A (Stillerman et al., 2008). Apart from a proven adverse effect of second-hand smoking exposure (Peppone et al., 2009; George et al., 2006), the evidence of an impact of air pollution on this reproductive outcome remains scarce. Only exposure to airborne particulate matter has been related to fetal loss in a study performed in mice (Veras et al., 2009). The authors found the mean post-implantation loss rate increased by 70% among those exposed to particulate matter before and during pregnancy versus no exposed.
Besides prenatal growth (birth weight and growth restriction), prematurity is the outcome for which there exist more published articles. In their recent review, Bosetti et al (2010) identified 13 studies assessing the relationship between exposure to particulate matter and preterm birth. Most of them (n: 9) considered PM10 as the fraction of interest. Four, generally more recent studies, included fine particulates (PM2.5); and the oldest ones investigated the effects of total suspended particulates (TSP) (Xu et al., 1995; Bobak, 2000). Overall, 9 studies found significant associations between PM exposure during pregnancy and risk of preterm birth. Four out the 13 studies were time series in design, i.e. capturing effects related with short-term exposures. The rest had designs more appropriate for evaluating more chronic exposure: 8 registry-based cohorts and one case-control study. Where a significant relation was found estimates of the association for an increase of 10 µg/m3 for PM10 or TSP in time series studies ranked from an increase in preterm risk of 1% (Xu et al., 1995) to 4.4% (Jiang et al., 2007). Among the studies assessing chronic exposure, significant estimates for a PM10 increase of 10 µg/m3 were around 2-4 %, and of 1% in a case control study in California, USA (Huynh et al., 2006) for a PM2.5 increase of 10 µg/m3 in the last 2 weeks of pregnancy. In another study in California (Ritz et al., 2007), a 29% increase in risk of preterm birth for exposure to PM2.5 above 21.36 µg/m3 during the first trimester was found. Most of the studies examined the relation taking into account air pollution exposure by trimesters. First and third trimester exposures were those most frequently associated with the risk of preterm delivery. Also, in a study in Taiwan using the extended Cox model with time-dependent PM10 exposures for each trimester during pregnancy (Suh et al., 2009), estimates for first and third trimester were slightly higher than those of the second trimester. A recent time series study in the city of Guangzhou (China) (Zhao et al., 2011) using the Generalized Additive Model (GAM) extended Poisson regression model and Principal Component Analysis described a relation between daily PM10 increases of 10 μg/m3 and significant increases in preterm risk less than 1%, suggesting that, at least for short-term exposures, the likely impact of PM on preterm risk is small.
Besides particulate matter, nitrogen oxides (NOx) have also been frequently assessed as the exposure of interest related with preterm risk. In their review up to 2003, Lacasaña et al. (2005) identified 8 articles examining the relation between pregnancy exposures to NOX and risk of preterm delivery, with nitrogen dioxide (NO2) being the most studied pollutant. However, the overall results were inconsistent. In the past six years, nine more studies have been published analyzing the relationship between NO2 exposure during pregnancy and the risk of preterm. Three of the studies found no significant association (Hansen et al., 2008; Brauer et al., 2008; Gehring et al., 2011). Jalaludin et al. (2007) observed an unexplained protective effect for NO2 exposure during the first month and first trimester of pregnancy, while five other studies found a significant relationship between preterm births and NO2 exposure at both the beginning and/or the end of pregnancy. Another recent study conducted in Los Angeles (USA) analyzed the relationship between NOx levels and preterm birth (Wu et al., 2009) and found this association was significant when exposure occurred throughout the pregnancy, even at relatively low air pollution levels. On the contrary, the Brauer et al. (2008) study conducted in Vancouver found a significant relation between NO exposure obtained with the inverse of the distance method and preterm birth, OR: 1.26 (95% Confidence interval, 95% CI: 1.08–1.47). Llop et al. (2010) assessed the concentration-response function. The results suggest a threshold level around 46 μg/m3 of NO2 concentration, after which the risk of preterm birth increases.
Following another recent review (Shah & Balkhair, 2011), 5 studies fulfilling methodological criteria have assessed the relation between sulfur dioxide (SO2) exposure during pregnancy and preterm delivery. All but one (Landgren et al., 1996) reported significant associations with preterm delivery. Three of the studies describing significant associations considered the relationship linear, and reported a increased risk for preterm birth ranging from 3.5% (Bobak et al., 2001; Sagiv et al., 2005) in the Czech Republic and Pennsylvania to 6.4% in Vancouver (Liu et al., 2003) for a 10 μg/m3 increase in SO2 levels. The Xu et al. study (1995) in Beijing, China examined a log linear relationship and found a 21% increase in the risk of preterm delivery for each ln μg/m3 increase in SO2 levels. In general, associations were higher for exposures at late pregnancy, i.e. third trimester or last weeks before birth. On the contrary, in a study in Croatia in the vicinity of a coal power plant, Mohorovic (2004) found the first two months of pregnancy as the critical time for preterm delivery in relation with SO2 exposure.
Carbon monoxide (CO) exposure has also been an object of analysis in relation with preterm birth. Ritz et al (2000; 2007) and Wilhelm and Ritz (2005) have focused on this pollutant in their birth certificate based study in southern California. They first reported carbon monoxide and PM associations for preterm birth in the South Coast Air Basin using data from 1989 to 1993 (Ritz et al., 2000). The study continued from 1994 to 2000 (Wilhelm & Ritz, 2005), and reported an 8-24% increase in risk of preterm birth per 1-ppm (1.145 mg/m3) increase in CO during the first trimester among women who lived close to stations measuring carbon monoxide. Depending on the distance to the monitoring station, they also observed a 9-30% increase in the risk of preterm birth when average CO concentrations were high (1.9 ppm) 6 weeks before birth. Finally, they conducted a case-control survey nested within their birth cohort and collected detailed risk factor information to assess the extent to which residual confounding and exposure misclassification may impact air pollution effect estimates (Ritz et al., 2007). For the first trimester, the odds of preterm birth consistently increased with increasing CO exposures, regardless of the type of data (cohort/sample) or covariate adjustment.. Women exposed to carbon monoxide above 0.91 ppm during the last 6 weeks of pregnancy experienced increased odds of preterm birth. The results did not change substantially after further adjustment, except for time-activity patterns, which strengthened the observed associations. They considered CO may be a better marker of vehicle exhaust toxins than PM2.5, since the latter includes both particles directly emitted in vehicular exhaust and those created secondarily through atmospheric reactions (Ritz et al., 2007).
A few studies included other specific air pollutants. Llop et al (2010) assessed the relation between prenatal exposure to benzene, as a marker for both traffic and industrial sources. The researchers found an association with preterm risk at benzene levels above 2.7 μg/m3 throughout the entire pregnancy. The authors acknowledged, however, this was an isolated finding with no precedent in the literature, and therefore, it should be regarded with caution.
Instead of examining specific air pollutants, researchers have investigated the role of other indicators of traffic or industrial air pollution. Wilhelm & Ritz (2003) used a distance-weighted traffic density measure to take into account residential proximity to and level of traffic on roadways surrounding homes. They obtained a clear exposure-response pattern with preterm birth, with a RR of 1.08 (95% CI: 1.01-1.15) for the highest exposure. In Taiwan, Yang et al. (2003) investigated the association between traffic-related air pollution and preterm deliveries in a zone along the Zhong-Shan Freeway in Taiwan. The prevalence of deliveries of preterm birth infants was significantly higher among mothers who lived within 500 m of the freeway than among mothers who resided 500-1,500 m from the freeway. The adjusted odds ratio was 1.30 (95% CI:1.03-1.65) for delivery of preterm infants born to mothers who lived within 500 m of the freeway. Brauer et al. (2008) used a geostatistical method to assess exposure to traffic air pollution. In this study, however, no associations were observed between the simple road proximity measures and preterm birth < 37 weeks, and there were no cases of births < 30 weeks that were within 50 m of a highway. Similarly, no association was found when traffic proximity was assessed in the Generation R study in Holland (van de Hooven et al., 2009). In a recent study in Shizuoka, Japan, Yorifuji et al. (2011) classified 14,226 liveborn single births from 1997 to 2008, according to proximity to major roads. They found positive associations between proximity to major roads and preterm birth at all considered gestational ages. Living within 200 m increased the risk of birth before 37 weeks by 1.5 times (95% CI : 1.2-1.8), birth before 32 weeks by 1.6 times (1.1-2.4), and birth before 28 weeks by 1.8 times (1.0-3.2). Proximity specifically increased the risk of preterm births with preterm premature rupture of the membranes and with pregnancy hypertension.
Lastly, regarding industrial pollution some studies in Taiwan revealed associations between preterm birth and maternal residence within 3km of a major oil refinery (OR: 1.41, 95% CI 1.08-1.82) (Lin et al., 2001), near three oil refineries (OR: 1.14, 95% CI=1.01-1.28) (Yang et al 2004), within 2 km of a cement plant (OR: 1.30, 95% CI 1.09–1.54) (Yang et al., 2003), within 2 km of an industrial complex, including petrochemical, petroleum, steel, and shipbuilding industries (OR: 1.11, 95% CI 1.02-1.21) (Tsai et al., 2003) or within 3 km of coal-based electricity-generating stations (OR: 1.14, 95% CI 1.01-1.30) (Tsai et al., 2004).
3.4. Fetal growth (crude neonatal anthropometry (birth weight, LBW), GA adjusted neonatal anthropometry (SGA, IUGR), ultrasounds
Fetal growth deficit, measured in different ways and with different indicators, is with no doubt the most studied reproductive outcome in relation to air pollution exposure during pregnancy. Because of its availability from medical records, weight at birth and low birth weight (LBW, i.e. weight at birth < 2500 g) have been the main reproductive outcomes assessed in the first studies examining the impact of air pollution on fetal development. Birth weight may be considered as a fetal growth measure if the analyses are adjusted by gestational age or if LBW studies are restricted to term newborn. Also, a considerable number of studies have also evaluated the impact of air pollution exposure during pregnancy on SGA or IUGR. Particulate matter (either as TSP, PM10 or as PM2.5) and NO2 have been the pollutants most frequently examined in studies on air pollution and birth outcomes. Two of the six reviews mentioned previously have included only particulate matter as exposure.
The use of passive sensors has allowed for a better spatial resolution when assessing individual exposure to air pollution (Raaschou-Nielsen et al., 2000; Gauderman et al., 2005). For these reasons and because studies involving more particles have been subjected to frequent literature reviews, this chapter addresses more detailed studies evaluating the relationship between NO2 exposure and birth weight, as well as weight in grams including low birth weight, or small for gestational age (SGA).
In Table 2, we present a summary of the 17 articles studying the effect of NO2 exposure on birth weight (Lacasana et al., 2005). The number is itself an indication of the growing interest in this issue. Ten out the 17 studies assessed the relationship of NO2 with birth weight, also 10 examined the relationship with LBW, and 9 the relationship with SGA. Among the 10 studies analyzing birth weight, a significant association was found in four studies. In two other studies, an association was clearer when some sub-analysis was made trying to improve exposure assessment by restricting either spatially, i.e. women living <2km away from a monitoring station in the French study in Nancy and Poitiers (Lepeule et al., 2010), or taking into account time activity, i.e. women spending <2hr/day in non-residential outdoor in a cohort of the Spanish INMA study (Aguilera et al., 2009). Of the 10 studies that considered LBW, only 4 found an association with NO2. On the other hand, six of the nine articles studying SGA found an association with NO2. This discrepancy may be due to the number of cases of SGA is greater than that of LBW term. Moreover, the use of SGA, calculated for each week of gestation, enables the effect of gestational length to be more effectively controlled than LBW, which is done by simply selecting births that take place after a certain period of gestation (between weeks 37- 44 weeks). On the other hand, it should be noted that all these studies found an association between LBW and exposure to other pollutants, mainly particulate matter, CO and SO2.
Regarding studies focusing on PM exposure, the paper by Glinianaia et al. (2004) was the first work systematically reviewing the evidence on the association between air pollution and fetal health outcomes. Twelve articles published between 1996 and 2001 were identified that included PM as the exposure of interest. Limitations in design and lack of confounding factors were defined. Authors concluded that currently available evidence was compatible with either a small adverse effect of particulate air pollution on fetal growth or with no effect. In their recently published review, Bosetti et al. (2010) identified 17 articles including information on PM exposure and LBW or very low birth weight (i.e. weight at birth < 1500 g). In most of the reviewed studies (14/17), LBW was the outcome studied; 2 studies considered VLBW infants, and another one considered infants with a birth weight between 2,500 and 3,000 g (Slama et al
For CO exposure, in their recent review, Shah & Balkhair (2011) identified 13 studies reporting results for LBW and four SGA. Among them only three reported an increased risk of LBW, two associated with exposures during the third trimester and the other at first and second trimesters (Lee et al., 2003). Only one of the studies assessing SGA reported a significant higher risk (Liu et al., 2003).
In the same review (Shah & Balkhair 2011), 14 studies were summarized describing results from studies including SO2 and LBW, but only one examined the impact of SO2 on SGA. Five studies reported increased odds of LBW births following SO2 exposure and one reported significant association with Very LBW (Rogers et al., 2000).
Other pollutants such ozone (O3) and benzene have also been included in studies evaluating the effects of air pollution in fetal growth According the review by Shah & Balkhair (2011), no significant effect of O3 on LBW or SGA was reported. Regarding benzene a significant association was found in the Spanish INMA cohort in Sabadell, especially among women spending more time in their residence (Aguilera et al., 2009). However, a recent combined analysis of four cohorts in the INMA study, including Sabadell, Valencia, Asturias and Gipuzkoa cohorts (Estarlich et al., 2011) confirmed the association between NO2 exposure and reductions in both length and weight at birth but not as a result of benzene exposure.
To try to overcome the difficulties of synthesizing previous findings due to differences in study design, several multicenter international initiatives have been launched recently. One of them, previously cited, ICAPPO has recently published its first results (Parker et al., 2011). Another large multicenter international study is the European Study of Cohorts for Air Pollution Effects (ESCAPE) (http://www.escapeproject.eu), is currently working to develop uniform criteria for assessing air pollution effects on reproductive outcomes.. ESCAPE will include information on more than 70,000 mother-child pairs and air-pollution. The results from this project can provide strong evidence on existence of a risk in fetal growth retardation related with exposure to air pollution during pregnancy.
Few studies have examined the relation between air pollution exposure during pregnancy and other anthropometric indicators at birth such as head circumference (HC). Studies in two cohorts of pregnant women have assessed the relationship between prenatal exposure to airborne polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) and fetal growth (Choi et al., 2006). One of these cohorts was from Cracow (Poland) and the other was made up of predominantly African-American and Dominican women from New York City (US). PAH exposure was related to a reduction in birth weight, length and HC among babies from Cracow, where exposure levels were higher. Among the participants from New York, results indicated a greater effect on African-American women, with higher reductions in both birth weight and HC, showing some kind of susceptibility to PAH exposure. In another study Hansen et al. (2007) assessed birth length and HC among 26,617 term births in Brisbane, Australia. Exposures to the four pollutants studied (i.e. PM10, black smoke, ozone and NO2) were not significantly associated with a reduction in HC. However an interquartile range increase in NO2, but not in other pollutants, during the third trimester was associated with a reduction in length: -0.15 cm (95%CI -0.25 to -0.05) for a 10 µg/m3 increase in NO2. In the French Eden cohort (Slama et al., 2006) a reduction of -0.31 cm (95%CI -0.73 to 0.10) in HC at birth was found when comparing NO2 exposure in the highest tertile (>31.4 µg/m3) to that in the lowest tertile. In a study in the Spanish INMA cohort in Valencia (Ballester et al., 2010) a reduction in birth length of -0.07 cm (95%CI -0.15 to 0.02) was associated with a 10 µg/m3 increase in NO2 during the first trimester. When exposure above 40 µg/m3 was compared with exposure equal to or less than 40 µg/m3, a reduction of -0.27 cm (95%CI -0.51 to -0.03) in birth length was found. In the combined analysis of four cohorts within the INMA study a (Estarlich et al., 2011) an increase of 10 µg/m3 in NO2 exposure during pregnancy was associated with a change in birth length of -0.09 cm (95% CI: -0.18 to -0.01). For the subset of women who spent ≥15 hr/day at home, the change in birth length was twice that.
Finally, regarding studies assessing fetal growth using ultrasound data instead of neonatal outcomes, we found only three studies. The first one was an Australian study that examined 15,623 scans at mid pregnancy and assigned air pollution data to each woman’s residential postal code from the closest monitoring station (Hansen et al., 2008). The authors reported a negative impact of several air pollutants, but no impact of NO2. They indicated as a possible cause for inconsistent results the increase in the exposure measurement error with increasing distance from a monitor. The second study (Slama et al., 2009) examined three scans for 271 women at second and third trimesters and a personal assessment of maternal benzene exposure in a French pregnancy cohort. The authors found this exposure associated with a reduction of head dimensions during the second trimester. In the third one, Aguilera et al (2010) conducted a study with 1692 ultrasounds for 562 women within the Sabadell INMA-cohort. An adverse effect of NO2 exposure on fetal growth measures during the second and third trimester was found, after restricting analyses to women with less mobility.
3.5. Congenital malformations
Among the environmental factors related to the risk of congenital anomalies, air pollution is among the most studied (Ritz 2010). Thus, studies conducted in California and Texas (Gilboa et al., 2005) showed a positive association between specific cardiac defects and various environmental pollutants measured at stations near the residence of mothers between weeks 3 and 8 of gestation, but the evidence was insufficient for other AC. However, Hwang et al (2008) identified associations between oral abnormalities and exposure to ozone during the first two months of pregnancy, but not with other air pollutants. In Atlanta, Strickland et al. (2009) studied exposure to PM10 during 3-7 weeks of gestation and found a small increased risk for one of 12 specific cardiac abnormalities. Hansen et al. (2009) in Brisbane, showed an association with exposure to ozone and SO2 during 3-8 weeks of gestation and two different subgroups of heart defects (pulmonary artery and aorta) and oral defects. In the north of England, Rankin et al. (2009) described a weak positive association between airborne particles measured as black smoke and nervous system abnormalities, and a negative association between exposure to black smoke and SO2 during the first trimester of pregnancy and cardiac abnormalities. Also in England, Dummer et al. (2003) found an increased risk of lethal congenital anomalies (spina bifida and heart defects) in relation to living near incinerators, and an increased risk of fetal death and anencephaly in relation to living near incinerators and crematoriums. Exposure to air pollutants from combustion (SO2, NO2 and PM10) has been associated with tetralogy of Fallot (Dolk et al., 2010).
A systematic review and meta-analysis of epidemiological studies on ambient air pollution and congenital anomalies was recently published (Vrijheid et al., 2011). The authors conducted meta-analyses if at least four studies published risk estimates for the same pollutant and anomaly group. Summary risk estimates were calculated for risk at high versus low exposure level in each study, and risk per unit increase in continuous pollutant concentration.
An analysis of the data indicated that each individual study reported statistically significant increased risks for some combinations of air pollutants and congenital anomalies, among many combinations tested. In meta-analyses, NO2 and SO2 exposures were related to increased risk of coarctation of the aorta (OR per 10 ppb NO2=1.17, 95%CI: 1.00-1.36; OR per 1 ppb SO2=1.07, 95%CI: 1.01- 1.13) and tetralogy of Fallot (OR per 10ppb NO2=1.20, 95%CI :1.02-1.42; OR per 1 ppb SO2=1.03, 95%CI: 1.01-1.05), and PM10 exposure to an increased risk of atrial septal defects (OR per 10 µg/m3=1.14, 95%CI: 1.01-1.28). Meta-analyses found no statistically significant increase in risk of other cardiac anomalies or oral clefts. The authors conclude that they found some evidence for an effect of ambient air pollutants on congenital cardiac anomaly risk. Similar to reviews on other reproductive outcomes, the authors suggest that improvements in the areas of exposure assessment, outcome harmonization, assessment of other congenital anomalies, and mechanistic knowledge are needed to advance this field.
4. Discussion and conclusions
4.1. General overview
One general conclusion of such studies was that although there is evidence prenatal exposure to air pollutants has a detrimental effect on fetal development (Sram et al., 2005) and infant mortality (Lacasana et al., 2005), results are less consistent for other outcomes. Specifically, in studies that have examined the relationship between exposure to pollutants and preterm birth or congenital anomalies, the evidence is insufficient to suggest causality (Hackley et al., 2007) (Vrijheid et al., 2010). Even for findings related with fetal development, recent reviews point out substantial heterogeneity in the results, making it difficult to draw robust conclusions (Shah & Balkhair, 2011). In any case, associations are of small magnitude.
Among the issues that have been identified as crucial in comparing and interpreting the results on prenatal air pollution exposure and fetal development, the following have been highlighted: study design, exposure assessment (time activity and critical windows of exposure) and outcomes definition.
4.2. Biological mechanisms
Numerous biologic pathways have been identified whereby particulate air pollutants might impact the placenta and fetus. Kannan et al. (2006) performed a robust study on plausible fisiopathological mechanisms by which exposure to particulate matter may lead to adverse perinatal outcomes. They identified five mechanistic pathways including a) oxidative stress; b) pulmonary and placental inflammation; c) blood coagulation; d) alteration of endothelial function; and e) hemodynamic responses to particulate exposure. As Ritz & Wilhelm given attention (2008), these pathways may not act independently. For example, an increase in maternal blood pressure and an impaired trophoblast invasion of the spiral arteries may induce uteroplacental hypoperfusion and a state of relative hypoxia surrounding the trophoblast. Some experimental studies have added evidence, as in the study by Veras et al. (2009) where the researchers exposed female mice during pre-gestational and gestational periods to filtered or non-filtered air in exposure chambers in a garden near high density traffic. Then placentas were collected from near-term pregnancies and prepared for microscopical examination and alterations on placental functional morphology were found in placentas from those exposed to non-filtered air. Besides that, fetal weight declined in exposed group.
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH), an important component of fine particulates from combustion sources, have been proposed as having a role in adverse reproductive outcomes. Experimental evidence showed that prenatal exposure of rats to maternal inhalation of benzo(a)pyrene (a PAH known for its potential toxicity) significantly compromised fetal survival rate and birth weight (Archibong et al., 2002). PAH exposure effects on fetal growth have been described in epidemiological studies in humans (Choi et al., 2006). Induction of apoptosis after DNA damage from PAH, endocrine disruption, and binding to the aryl hydrocarbon receptor for placental growth factors, resulting in decreased exchange of oxygen and nutrients have been proposed as the mechanisms for PAH toxicity. On the other hand, adult male exposure to inhaled PAH has also been found to affect fertility in male rates (Ramesh et al., 2008).
On the other hand, NO2 is a potent oxidant and increased lipid peroxidation in the maternal and/or fetal compartment has been found in preterm birth (Moison et al., 1993). Tabacova et al. (1997) investigated the relationship between exposure to nitrogen-oxidizing species and pregnancy complications in an area in Bulgaria highly polluted by oxidized nitrogen compounds. Methemoglobin, a biomarker of individual exposure, was determined, and glutathione balance and lipid peroxide levels were measures of oxidant/antioxidant status. A high percentage of women suffered from pregnancy complications. The most common ones were anemia (67%), threatened abortion/premature labor (33%), and signs of preeclampsia (23%). Methemoglobin was significantly elevated in all three conditions, compared with normal pregnancies. Reduced total glutathione, an indicator of maternal antioxidant reserves, decreased, whereas cell-damaging lipid peroxide levels increased. Mohoroviz found similar results for methemoglobin in a polluted area of Croatia. These results suggest that maternal exposure to environmental oxidants can increase the risk of pregnancy complications through stimulation of the formation methemoglobin, which may lead to hypoxia and hypoxemia in pregnant women and has an important influence on maternal health as well as placental and fetal development. The study in Croatia also described the impact of early exposures (first two months), as this is the time of greatest susceptibility in human gestation. It remains unclear if NO2 is just a marker of air pollution from traffic or other combustions (i.e. PM, PAH or volatile organic compounds VOC), or it is a pollutant playing an important role on.
Another studied pollutant, carbon monoxide (CO) is known to induce fetal hypoxia by forming carboxyhemoglobin at the expense of oxyhemoglobin, thus resulting in an increased risk of fetal underdevelopment and neonatal mortality (Veras et al., 2010). These effects, however, have been described in relation to high CO concentrations related with tobacco exposure, some times higher than those present in ambient air. This fact raises the issue of whether CO may be reflective of the action of other toxins as PAH, metals or VOC (Ritz & Wilhelm, 2008)
Finally, the role of genetic polymorphisms, mainly as effect modifiers, on the relation between maternal air pollution exposure and reproductive outcomes should be considered. Some preliminary studies have reported how some genotypes as GSTM1 and CYP1A1*2A modified the effect of environmental exposure on birth weight and prematurity (Sram et al., 2006).
4.3. Public health implications
Air pollution is still an important public health problem. Exposure to elevated levels of air pollution can cause a variety of adverse health outcomes, including reproductive outcomes, yet being respiratory and cardiovascular diseases the two groups of causes where higher burden is borne. Air quality in developed countries has been generally improved over the last three decades. However, many recent epidemiological studies have consistently shown positive associations between low-level exposure to air pollution and adverse health outcomes. Thus, adverse health effects of air pollution, even at relatively low levels, remain a public concern and strategies to improve air quality around the world are being defined (EU 2005).
Fetuses are very susceptible to environmental exposures and disruption of their development may have an impact on child and adult health. Exposure to ambient air pollution is ubiquitous and even if increased risks of adverse reproductive outcomes are small, they can have a big impact measured as number of attributable cases at the population level. Two examples can illustrate this. One cost-benefit analysis of air pollution regulations in the USA (Wong et al., 2004), examined the child-specific health impacts derived from the U.S. Clean Air Act (CAA). It was estimated that from 1990-2010, CAA regulations would prevent 10,000 fewer low birth weight infants, which represented an estimated savings of 230 million U.S. dollars in health care costs. A recent health impact assessment in Korea (Seo et al., 2010) estimated that population-attributable risk of low birthweight related to PM10 pollution ranged between 5% and 19% in seven Korean cities, indicating that a large proportion of LBW could be prevented if air pollution was reduced.
Fetal and child health are a clearly identifiable topic adding argues to need to reinforce international, national and local efforts to improve air quality around the world, as well as providing health professional and the population, especially pregnant women indications and recommendations to prevent hazardous exposures during pregnancy
Fairly all the reviews and methodological papers on this topic published recently agree that current evidence suggests that air pollution may play some role in adverse pregnancy outcomes. Also, it is widely shared that owing the importance on the study and prevention of potential environmental insults during pregnancy this is a clear developing field in epidemiology and biomedical research. Besides that a number of limitations in former studies and some opportunities for better advance in the knowledge on the issue have been identified, leading to proposal of a series of recommendations including the following: Develop collaborations to establish large international cohorts with high availability and quality of exposure and potentially confounding factors, with enough sample size and avoiding as much as possible selection bias; Expand, clearly defined, new outcomes to be considered in studies, including subfertility, fetal loss, pregnancy complications (i.e. preeclampsia, hypertension), as well as measured characteristics after birth (i.e. placental weight, sexual differentiation, perinatal neurological scores); Improve exposure assessment by using models allowing for spatial and temporal resolution and also taking into account time-activity patterns, allowing for identification time-windows of susceptibility during pregnancy; Include biomarkers of exposure to air pollution as well as those of susceptibility (i.e. genetic polymorphisms); Report extensively cohort characteristics as well as information on outcomes, exposure and covariables; Develop experimental studies to help identify relevant biological mechanisms (Slama et al., 2008).
We are very grateful to Melanie Larson for her invaluable help in editing the manuscript.
Aguilera I. Guxens M. Garcia-Esteban R. Corbella T. MJ Nieuwenhuijsen Foradada C. M. Sunyer J. 2009Association between GIS-based exposure to urban air pollution during pregnancy and birth weight in the INMA Sabadell Cohort.
Aguilera I. Garcia-Esteban R. Iñiguez C. MJ Nieuwenhuijsen Rodríguez A. Paez M. Ballester F. Sunyer J. 2010Prenatal exposure to traffic-related air pollution and ultrasound measures of fetal growth in the INMA Sabadell cohort.
Archibong A. E. Inyang F. Ramesh A. Greenwood M. Nayyar T. Kopsombut P. Hood D. B. Nyanda A. M. 2002Alteration of pregnancy related hormones and fetal survival in F-344 rats exposed by inhalation to benzo(a)pyrene.
Ballester F. Estarlich M. Iñiguez C. Llop S. Ramón R. Esplugues A. Lacasaña M. Rebagliato M. 2010Air pollution exposure during pregnancy and reduced birth size: a prospective birth cohort study in Valencia, Spain.
Barker D. J. 2007The origins of the developmental origins theory.
Bell M. L. Ebisu K. Belanger K. 2007Ambient air pollution and low birth weight in Connecticut and Massachusetts.
Bobak M. 2000Outdoor air pollution, low birth weight, and prematurity.
Bobak M. Gjonca A. 2001The seasonality of live birth is strongly influenced by socio-demographic factors.
Bosetti C. MJ Nieuwenhuijsen Gallus S. Cipriani S. La Vecchia C. Parazzini F. 2010Ambient particulate matter and preterm birth or birth weight: a review of the literature.
Brauer M. Lencar C. Tamburic L. Koehoorn M. Demers P. Karr C. 2008A cohort study of traffic-related air pollution impacts on birth outcomes.
Brunekreef B. Holgate S. T. 2002Air pollution and health.
Brunekreef B. 2007Health effects of air pollution observed in cohort studies in Europe.
Choi H. Jedrychowski W. Spengler J. Camann D. E. Whyatt R. M. Rauh V. Tsai W. Y. Perera F. P. 2006International studies of prenatal exposure to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and fetal growth.
Darrow L. A. Klein M. Flanders W. D. Waller L. A. Correa A. Marcus M. Mulholland J. A. Russell A. G. Tolbert P. E. 2009Ambient air pollution and preterm birth: a time-series analysis.
Dejmek J. Solanský I. Benes I. Lenícek J. Srám R. J. 2000The impact of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and fine particles on pregnancy outcome.
Dolk H. Armstrong B. Lachowycz K. Vrijheid M. Rankin J. Abramsky L. Boyd P. A. Wellesley D. 2010Ambient air pollution and risk of congenital anomalies in England, 1991-1999.
Dummer T. J. Dickinson H. O. Parker L. 2003Adverse pregnancy outcomes around incinerators and crematoriums in Cumbria, north west England, 1956-93.
ESCAPE-European Study of Cohorts for Air Pollution Effects.Available online: http://www.escapeproject.eu/accessed on 18 August 2009
Estarlich M. Ballester F. Aguilera I. Fernández-Somoano A. Lertxundi A. Llop S. Freire C. Tardón A. Basterrechea M. Sunyer J. Iñiguez C. 2011Residential Exposure to Outdoor Air Pollution during Pregnancy and Anthropometric Measures at Birth in a Multicenter Cohort in Spain.
EU legislation. Communication of 21 September 2005from the Commission to the Council and the European Parliament- Thematic Strategy on Air Pollution. Available at: http://europa.eu/legislation_summaries/environment/air_pollution/l28159_en.htmaccessed at 15 may 2011]
EUROCAT. EUROCAT Guide 1.3 and reference documents Instructions for the Registration and Surveillance of Congenital Anomalies.EUROCAT, 2005
Evenson D. P. Wixon R. 2005Environmental toxicants cause sperm DNA fragmentation as detected by the Sperm Chromatin Structure Assay (SCSA).
Foster W. G. MS Neal MS Han MM Dominguez 2008Environmental contaminants and human infertility: hypothesis or cause for concern?
George L. Granath F. Johansson A. L. Annerén G. Cnattingius S. 2006Environmental tobacco smoke and risk of spontaneous abortion.
Gehring U. Wijga A. H. Fischer P. de Jongste J. C. Kerkhof M. Koppelman G. H. Smit H. A. Brunekreef B. 2011Traffic-related air pollution, preterm birth and term birth weight in the PIAMA birth cohort study.
Ghosh R. Rankin J. Pless-Mulloli T. Glinianaia S. 2007Does the effect of air pollution on pregnancy outcomes differ by gender? A systematic review.
Glinianaia S. V. Rankin J. Bell R. Pless-Mulloli T. Howel D. 2004Particulate air pollution and fetal health: a systematic review of the epidemiologic evidence.
Gouveia N. Bremner S. A. Novaes H. M. 2004Association between ambient air pollution and birth weight in Sao Paulo, Brazil.
Hackley B. Feinstein A. Dixon J. 2007Air pollution: impact on maternal and perinatal health.
Hammoud A. Carrell D. T. Gibson M. Sanderson M. Parker-Jones K. Peterson C. M. 2010Decreased sperm motility is associated with air pollution in Salt Lake City.
Hansen C. Neller A. Williams G. Simpson R. 2006Maternal exposure to low levels of ambient air pollution and preterm birth in Brisbane, Australia.
Hansen C. Neller A. Williams G. Simpson R. 2007Low levels of ambient air pollution during pregnancy and fetal growth among term neonates in Brisbane, Australia.
CA Hansen Barnett A. G. Pritchard G. 2008The effect of ambient air pollution during early pregnancy on fetal ultrasonic measurements during mid-pregnancy.
CA Hansen Barnett A. G. Jalaludin B. B. Morgan G. G. 2009Ambient air pollution and birth defects in Brisbane, Australia.
Huynh M. Woodruff T. J. JD Parker Schoendorf K. C. 2006Relationships between air pollution and preterm birth in California.
Hwang-F B. Jaakkola J. J. K. 2008Ozone and other air pollutants and risk of oral clefts.
Iñiguez C. Ballester F. Estarlich M. Llop S. Fernandez-Patier R. Aguirre-Alfaro A. Esplugues A. Study I. N. M. A. group Valencia. 2009Estimation of personal 2exposure in a cohort of pregnant women.
Gauderman W. J. Avol E. Lurmann F. Kuenzli N. Gilliland F. Peters J. Mc Connell R. 2005Childhood asthma and exposure to traffic and nitrogen dioxide.
Gilboa S. M. Mendola P. Olshan A. F. Langlois P. H. Savitz D. A. Loomis D. Herring A. H. Fixler D. E. 2005Relation between ambient air quality and selected birth defects, seven county study, Texas, 1997-2000.
Jalaludin B. Mannes T. Morgan G. Lincoln D. Sheppeard V. Corbett S. 2007Impact of ambient air pollution on gestational age is modified by season in Sydney, Australia.
Jedrychowski W. Perera F. Mrozek-Budzyn D. Mroz E. Flak E. JD Spengler Edwards S. Jacek R. Kaim I. Skolicki Z. 2009Gender differences in fetal growth of newborns exposed prenatally to airborne fine particulate matter.
Jerrett M. . Shankardass K. . Berhane K. . Gauderman W. J. . Künzli N. . Avol E. . Gilliland F. . Lurmann F. . Molitor J. N. . Molitor J. T. . Thomas D. C. . Peters J. Mc Connell R. 2008Traffic-related air pollution and asthma onset in children: a prospective cohort study with individual exposure measurement.
Jiang L. L. . Zhang Y. H. . Song G. X. . Chen G. H. . Chen B. H. . Zhao N. Q. Kan H. D. 2007A time series analysis of outdoor air pollution and preterm birth in Shanghai, China.
Kannan S. Misra D. P. Dvonch J. T. Krishnakumar A. 2006Exposures to airborne particulate matter and adverse perinatal outcomes: a biologically plausible mechanistic framework for exploring potential effect modification by nutrition.
Kim O. J. Ha E. H. BM Kim Seo J. H. Park H. S. Jung W. J. Lee B. E. Suh Y. J. Kim Y. J. Lee J. T. Kim H. Hong Y. C. 2007PM10 and pregnancy outcomes: a hospital-based cohort study of pregnant women in Seoul.
Lacasana M. Esplugues A. Ballester F. 2005Exposure to ambient air pollution and prenatal and early childhood health effects.
Landgren O. 1996Environmental pollution and delivery outcome in southern Sweden: a study with central registries.
Laumbach RJ. 2010Outdoor air pollutants and patient health.
Lee B. E. Ha E. H. Park H. S. Kim Y. J. Hong Y. C. Kim H. Lee J. T. 2003Exposure to air pollution during different gestational phases contributes to risks of low birth weight.
Lee S. J. Hajat S. Steer P. J. Filippi V. 2008A time-series analysis of any short-term effects of meteorological and air pollution factors on preterm births in London, UK.
Leem J. H. BM Kaplan Shim Y. K. Pohl H. R. CA Gotway Bullard S. M. Rogers J. F. MM Smith . CA Tylenda 2006Exposures to air pollutants during pregnancy and preterm delivery.
Lepeule J. Caïni F. Bottagisi S. Galineau J. Hulin A. Marquis N. Bohet A. Siroux V. Kaminski M. MA Charles Slama R. 2010EDEN Mother-Child Cohort Study Group. Maternal exposure to nitrogen dioxide during pregnancy and offspring birth weight: comparison of two exposure models.
Lin M. C. Chiu H. F. Yu H. S. Tsai S. S. Cheng B. H. Wu T. N. Sung F. C. Yang C. Y. 2001Increased risk of preterm delivery in areas with air pollution from a petroleum refinery plant in Taiwan. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health. A64 637 644 0001-3273X.
Liu S. Krewski D. Shi Y. Chen Y. Burnett R. T. 2003Association between gaseous ambient air pollutants and adverse pregnancy outcomes in Vancouver, Canada.
Liu S. Krewski D. Shi Y. Chen Y. Burnett R. T. 2007Association between maternal exposure to ambient air pollutants during pregnancy and fetal growth restriction.
Llop S. Ballester F. Estarlich M. Esplugues A. Rebagliato M. Iñiguez C. 2010Preterm birth and exposure to air pollutants during pregnancy.
Madsen C. Gehring U. Walker S. E. Brunekreef B. Stigum H. Naess O. Nafstad P. 2010Ambient air pollution exposure, residential mobility and term birth weight in Oslo, Norway.
Maisonet M. Bush T. J. Correa A. Jaakkola J. J. 2001Relation between ambient air pollution and low birth weight in the Northeastern United States.
Maisonet M. Correa A. Misra D. Jaakkola J. J. 2004A review of the literature on the effects of ambient air pollution on fetal growth.
Mannes T. Jalaludin B. Morgan G. Lincoln D. Sheppeard V. Corbett S. 2005Impact of ambient air pollution on birth weight in Sydney, Australia.
Mohorovic L. 2004First two months of pregnancy-critical time for preterm delivery and low birthweight caused by adverse effects of coal combustion toxics.
Moison R. M. Palinckx J. J. Roest M. Houdkamp E. Berger H. M. 1993Induction of lipid peroxidation of pulmonary surfactant by plasma of preterm babies.
Morello-Frosch R. BM Jesdale Sadd J. L. Pastor M. 2010Ambient air pollution exposure and full-term birth weight in California.
Morris S. S. Victora C. G. Barros F. C. Halpern R. Menezes A. M. César J. A. Horta B. L. Tomasi E. 1998Length and ponderal index at birth: associations with mortality, hospitalizations, development and post-natal growth in Brazilian infants.
Nethery E. Brauer M. Janssen P. 2009Time-activity patterns of pregnant women and changes during the course of pregnancy.
Parker J. Rich D. Q. Glinianaia S. V. Leem J. H. Wartenberg D. Bell M. L. Bonzini M. Brauer M. Darrow L. Gehring U. Gouveia N. Grillo P. Ha E. van den Hooven. E. H. Jalaludin B. BM Jesdale Lepeule J. Morello-Frosch R. Morgan G. G. Slama R. Pierik F. H. Pesatori A. C. Sathyanarayana S. Seo J. Strickland M. Tamburic L. Woodruff T. J. 2011The International Collaboration on Air Pollution and Pregnancy Outcomes: Initial Results.
MS Pearce Glinianaia S. V. Rankin J. Rushton S. Charlton M. Parker L. Pless-Mulloli T. 2010No association between ambient particulate matter exposure during pregnancy and stillbirth risk in the north of England, 1962-1992.
Peppone L. J. Piazza K. M. Mahoney M. C. Morrow G. R. Mustian K. M. Palesh O. G. Hyland A. 2009Associations between adult and childhood secondhand smoke exposures and fecundity and fetal loss among women who visited a cancer hospital.
Pereira L. A. Loomis D. Conceição G. M. Braga A. L. Arcas R. M. Kishi H. S. Singer J. M. Böhm G. M. Saldiva P. H. 1998Association between air pollution and intrauterine mortality in São Paulo, Brazil.
Perera F. P. . Illman S. M. . Kinney P. L. . Whyatt R. M. . Kelvin E. A. . Shepard P. Evans D. . Fullilove M. Ford J. . Miller R. L. . Meyer I. H. Rauh V. A. 2002The challenge of preventing environmentally related disease in young children: community-based research in New York City.
Perera F. P. Rauh V. Tsai W. Y. Kinney P. Camann D. Barr D. Bernert T. Garfinkel R. Tu Y. H. Diaz D. Dietrich J. Whyatt R. M. 2003Effects of transplacental exposure to environmental pollutants on birth outcomes in a multiethnic population.
Raaschou-Nielsen O. Hertel O. Vignati E. Berkowicz R. Jensen S. S. Larsen V. B. Lohse C. Olsen J. H. 2000An air pollution model for use in epidemiological studies: evaluation with measured levels of nitrogen dioxide and benzene.
Ramesh A. Inyang F. Lunstra D. D. MS Niaz Kopsombut P. Jones K. M. Hood D. B. Hills E. R. Archibong A. E. 2008Alteration of fertility endpoints in adult male F-344 rats by subchronic exposure to inhaled benzo(a)pyrene. (2008).
Rankin J. Chadwick T. Natarajan M. Howel D. MS Pearce Pless-Mulloli T. 2009Maternal exposure to ambient air pollutants and risk of congenital anomalies.
Richards M. Hardy R. Kuh D. ME Wadsworth 2002Birthweight, postnatal growth and cognitive function in a national UK birth cohort.
Ritz B. Yu F. 1999The effect of ambient carbon monoxide on low birth weight among children born in southern California between 1989 and 1993.
Ritz B. Yu F. Chapa G. Fruin S. 2000Effect of air pollution on preterm birth among children born in Southern California between 1989 and 1993.
Ritz B. Yu F. Fruin S. Chapa G. Shaw G. M. Harris J. A. 2002Ambient air pollution and risk of birth defects in Southern California.
Ritz B. Wilhelm M. Hoggatt K. J. Ghosh J. K. 2007Ambient air pollution and preterm birth in the environment and pregnancy outcomes study at the University of California, Los Angeles.
Ritz B. Wilhelm M. 2008Ambient air pollution and adverse birth outcomes: methodologic issues in an emerging field.
Ritz B. 2010Air-pollution and congenital anomalies.
Rogers J. F. Thompson S. J. Addy C. L. Mc Keown R. E. Cowen D. J. Decoufle P. 2000Association of very low birth weight with exposures to environmental sulfur dioxide and total suspended particulates.
Sagiv S. K. Mendola P. Loomis D. Herring A. H. Neas L. M. Savitz D. A. Poole C. 2005A time-series analysis of air pollution and preterm birth in Pennsylvania, 1997-2001.
Salam M. T. Millstein J. Li Y. F. Lurmann F. W. Margolis H. G. Gilliland F. D. 2005Birth outcomes and prenatal exposure to ozone, carbon monoxide, and particulate matter: results from the Children’s Health Study.
Schwartz J. 2004Air pollution and children´s health.
Selevan S. G. Borkovec L. Slott V. L. Zudová Z. Rubes J. Evenson D. P. Perreault S. D. 2000Semen quality and reproductive health of young Czech men exposed to seasonal air pollution.
Seo J. H. Leem J. H. Ha E. H. Kim O. J. BM Kim Lee J. Y. Park H. S. Kim H. C. Hong Y. C. Kim Y. J. 2010Population-attributable risk of low birthweight related to PM10 pollution in seven Korean cities.
Shah P. S. Balkhair T. 2011Knowledge Synthesis Group on Determinants of Preterm/LBW births. Air pollution and birth outcomes: a systematic review.
Skalkidou A. Kieler H. Stephansson O. Roos N. Cnattingius S. Haglund B. 2010Ultrasound pregnancy dating leads to biased perinatal morbidity and neonatal mortality among post-term-born girls.
Slama R. Sinno-Teller S. Thiébaugeorges O. Goua V. Forhan A. Ducot B. Annesi-Maesano I. Heinrich J. Schweitzer M. Magnin G. Bouyer J. Kaminski M. MA Charles 2006Eden Study Group. Relation between atmospheric pollutants and head circumference in utero and at birth: a cohort study relying on ultrasound imaging during pregnancy.
Slama R. Morgenstern V. Cyrys J. Zutavern A. Herbarth O. Wichmann H. E. Heinrich J. 2007LISA Study Group. Traffic-related atmospheric pollutants levels during pregnancy and offspring’s term birth weight: a study relying on a land-use regression exposure model.
Slama R. Darrow L. Parker J. Woodruff T. J. Strickland M. Nieuwenhuijsen M. Glinianaia S. Hoggatt K. J. Kannan S. Hurley F. Kalinka J. Srám R. Brauer M. Wilhelm M. Heinrich J. Ritz B. 2008Meeting report: atmospheric pollution and human reproduction.
Slama R. Thiebaugeorges O. Goua V. Aussel L. Sacco P. Bohet A. Forhan A. Ducot B. Annesi-Maesano I. Heinrich J. Magnin G. Schweitzer M. Kaminski M. MA Charles 2009EDEN Mother-Child Cohort Study Group. Maternal personal exposure to airborne benzene and intrauterine growth.
Somers C. M. 2011Ambient air pollution exposure and damage to male gametes: human studies and in situ ‘sentinel’ animal experiments.
Sram R. J. Binkova B. Dejmek J. Bobak M. 2005Ambient air pollution and pregnancy outcomes: a review of the literature.
Sram R. J. Binkova B. Dejmek J. Chvatalova I. . Solansky I. Topinka J. 2006Association of DNA adducts and genotypes with birth weight.
Stillerman K. P. Mattison D. R. Giudice L. C. Woodruff T. J. 2008Environmental exposures and adverse pregnancy outcomes: a review of the science.
MJ Strickland Klein M. Correa A. Reller M. D. L. Mahle W. T. Riehle-Colarusso T. J. Botto L. D. Flanders W. D. Mulholland J. A. Siffel C. Marcus M. Tolbert P. E. 2009Ambient air pollution and cardiovascular malformations in Atlanta, Georgia, 1986-2003.
Suh Y. J. Kim H. Seo J. H. Park H. Kim Y. J. Hong Y. C. Ha E. H. 2009Different effects of PM10 exposure on preterm birth by gestational period estimated from time-dependent survival analyses.
Tabacova S. Balabaeva L. Little R. E. 1997Maternal exposure to exogenous nitrogen compounds and complications of pregnancy.
Tsai S. S. Yu H. S. Liu C. C. Yang C. Y. 2003Increased incidence of preterm delivery in mothers residing in an industrialized area in Taiwan.
Tsai S. S. Yu H. S. Chang C. C. Chuang H. Y. Yang C. Y. 2004Increased risk of preterm delivery in women residing near thermal power plants in Taiwan.
Van den Hooven. E. H. Jaddoe V. W. de Kluizenaar Y. Hofman A. Mackenbach J. P. Steegers E. A. Miedema H. M. Pierik F. H. 2009Residential traffic exposure and pregnancy-related outcomes: a prospective birth cohort study.
MM Veras . Damaceno-Rodrigues N. R. . Guimarães-Silva R. M. . Scoriza J. N. . Saldiva P. H. . Caldini E. G. Dolhnikoff M. 2009Chronic exposure to fine particulate matter emitted by traffic affects reproductive and fetal outcomes in mice.
MM Veras . Caldini E. G. . Dolhnikoff M. Saldiva P. H. 2010Air pollution and effects on reproductive-system functions globally with particular emphasis on the Brazilian population.
Vrijheid M. Martinez D. Manzanares S. Dadvand P. Schembari A. Rankin J. Nieuwenhuijsen M. 2011Ambient Air Pollution and Risk of Congenital Anomalies: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.
Wang L. Pinkerton K. E. 2007Air pollutant effects on fetal and early postnatal development.
Wigle D. T. Arbuckle T. E. Turner M. C. Bérubé A. Yang Q. Liu S. Krewski D. 2008Epidemiologic evidence of relationships between reproductive and child health outcomes and environmental chemical contaminants.
Wilhelm M. Ritz B. 2003Residential proximity to traffic and adverse birth outcomes in Los Angeles County, California, 1994-1996.
Wilhelm M. Ritz B. 2005Local variations in CO and particulate air pollution and adverse birth outcomes in Los Angeles County, California, USA.
Wong E. Y. Gohlke J. Griffith W. C. Farrow S. Faustman E. M. 2004Assessing the health benefits of air pollution reduction for children.
Woodruff T. J. JD Parker Darrow L. A. Slama R. Bell M. L. Choi H. Glinianaia S. Hoggatt K. J. Karr C. J. Lobdell D. T. Wilhelm M. 2009Methodological issues in studies of air pollution and reproductive health.
Woodruff T. J. JD Parker Adams K. Bell M. L. Gehring U. Glinianaia S. Ha E. H. Jalaludin B. Slama R. 2010International Collaboration on Air Pollution and Pregnancy Outcomes (ICAPPO).
Wu J. Ren C. Delfino R. J. Chung J. Wilhelm M. Ritz B. 2009Association between local traffic-generated air pollution and preeclampsia and preterm delivery in the south coast air basin of California.
Xu X. Ding H. Wang X. 1995Acute effects of total suspended particles and sulfur dioxides on preterm delivery: a community-based cohort study.
Yang C. Y. . Chang C. C. . Chuang H. Y. Ho C. K. . Wu T. N. Tsai S. S. 2003Evidence for increased risks of preterm delivery in a population residing near a freeway in Taiwan.
Yang C. Y. Chang C. C. Chuang H. Y. Ho C. K. Wu T. N. Chang P. Y. 2004Increased risk of preterm delivery among people living near the three oil refineries in Taiwan.
Yorifuji T. Naruse H. Kashima S. Ohki S. Murakoshi T. Takao S. Tsuda T. Doi H. 2011Residential proximity to major roads and preterm births.
Zhao Q. Liang Z. Tao S. Zhu J. Du Y. 2011Effects of air pollution on neonatal prematurity in Guangzhou of China: a time-series study.