The municipal solid waste composting process has been defined as a controlled aerobic microbial process widely used to decompose organic matter to obtain a stable product consisting of a humus-like substance (Michel et al., 1995). The end product or compost is available for agricultural use. However, the main requirement for the safe use or application of compost to agricultural lands is its degree of stability, which implies stable organic matter content (Castaldi et al., 2004, 2008; Mondini et al., 2004). This practice is becoming one of the most promising ways for the reclamation of degraded soils in semiarid areas of the Mediterranean countries like Tunisia (Bouzaiane et al., 2007a). Optimization of the composting process depends on optimization of environmental conditions that promote the development and activity of microbial communities. In fact the microbial biomass (MB) amount plays an important role on the biochemical transformations, on the optimization and on the quality of the end product (Mondini et al., 2002; Jedidi et al., 2004).
The chloroform- fumigation–extraction (CFE) is currently the most common method used to quantify the microbial biomass in soil samples (Vance et al., 1987). Some authors have applied the CFE technique on compost substrates (De Nobili et al., 1996, Hellmann et al., 1997, Mondini et al., 1997; Ben Ayed et al., 2007).
On the other hand, the application of molecular methods to study the composting process and the microbial communities governing the transformation of the organic matter presents some unique challenges. One such challenge is the dynamic nature of the process, characterized by rapid changes in microbial population, temperature and oxygen gradients, and the availability of nutrients for microorganisms. The analysis of nucleic acids extracted from environmental samples allows researchers to study natural microbial communities without the need for cultivation (Peters et al., 2000; Dees and Ghiorse, 2001). Although there have been many published studies on methods for the extraction DNA from environmental samples, very few have focused upon the extraction of DNA from compost. Compost samples may also contain 10–100 times greater humic acid concentrations than mineral soils (Pfaller et al., 1994). Humic acids co-purify with DNA during many purification steps (Ogram et al., 1987). These factors combine to make DNA quantification in compost exceptionally difficult. Methods designed to extract DNA from soils and sediments have been adapted to obtain DNA from composts (Blanc et al., 1999; Kowalchuk et al., 1999). However, the relative effectiveness of extraction and purification methods for isolating compost DNA of sufficient purity has not been examined. Also, potential bias introduced by different extraction protocols has not been investigated yet. In this paper, we adopted the Fast DNA Kit for Soil DNA extraction and purification procedures to extract and purify DNA from compost.
In the present study, we attempted to evaluate (i) the evolution of microbiological parameters such as microbial biomass C, N and DNA content during municipal solid waste composting process and (ii) the relationship between microbial biomass C, N and DNA concentration during municipal solid waste composting process and possibly use these parameters to find out the compost stability.
2. Materials and methods
2.1. Composting process
The compost was prepared at the pilot composting station of Beja City, situated about 100 km to the west of Tunis. At the entry of the composting station, the wastes were stocked on big pile with a pyramidal shape (3.0 m length x 2.5 m width x 1.5 m x high) during 2 months without any previous treatment. The non-biodegradable coarse wastes (mostly plastics and glasses) were manually removed; therefore the remaining wastes were subsequently crushed and sieved to 40 mm in order to decrease the waste heterogeneity. Sawdust and green wastes were added to the wastes and these wastes were stocked on new pile during 3 months for stabilization.
Temperature and humidity were controlled daily, and pile was turned and watered (humidity regularly adjusted to 50%) as soon as the inner temperature of the pile reached or exceed 65 °C. These operations of turning and watering were performed almost twice per month on an average.
2.2. Sampling of organic wastes during the composting process
Ten samples (approximately 5 kg each) were collected every 15 days from day 5 to day 139 from ten randomly selected locations in the pile by digging a small pit to 1 m depth with a shovel. At each sampling time, samples were mixed thoroughly and three portions of 1 kg each were separated. The first portion was stored at -20 °C to constitute a collection of samples, the second was for pH determination, and the third was for microbiological analyses.
2.3. Temperature and pH determination during the composting process
Temperature inside the windrows was measured, every day during the composting period, with a special sensing device stuck introduced to 60 cm depth in randomly selected points. For pH, 400 g of compost were placed in an Erlenmeyer flask containing 2 l of distilled water and stirred for 3-5 min. The mixture was allowed to settle for 5 min and the pH was measured using a pH meter. For dry weight, 400 g of fresh compost was dried at 105 °C until the weight remained constant.
2.4 Determination of microbial biomass C and N
Microbial biomass C and N were determined by the CFE method, according to Vance et al. (1987) and Brookes (1995), respectively. Twenty grams were fumigated with ethanol-free CHCl3 for 24 h at 25 °C in a dessicator. After removing the fumigant the samples were extracted for 60 min with 80 ml 0.5 mol l-1 K2SO4 solutions (1/4, w/v) and then filtered through a Whatman filter paper. Non-fumigated samples were extracted as above at the time the fumigation started. The amounts of soluble C in the fumigated and non-fumigated compost extract are used to determine biomass C. Organic C was quantified by the potassium dichromate oxidation method (Jenkinson and Powlson, 1976) and subsequent back-titration of the unreduced dichromate. The sample microbial biomass C (MBC) was estimated using the following equation (Jenkinson and Powlson, 1976):
Where CE was the difference between organic C extracted from fumigated and non-fumigated treated samples.
Total N in the extracts was determined according to the Kjeldahl methods as described by Brookes et al., 1985.
The microbial biomass N was estimated using the following equation:
Where NE was the difference between total N extracted from fumigated and non fumigated samples. Amounts of microbial biomass C or N were expressed (mg C or N kg-1 dry weight) on air-dry soil basis and represent the average of three determinations (repeated three times on a single sample).
2.5. DNA extraction
About 0.5g of compost was weighed into DNA extraction matrix tubes using the Bio 101 Fast DNA Kit for Soil (Biogene, France). All extraction steps were carried out according to the manufacturer’s instructions. DNA was eluted in 100µl of elution buffer. Purified DNA was quantified by spectrophotometer (Bio-RAD Smart Spec TM Plus, France) (Leckie et al., 2004). Reserve aliquots were stored at - 20 °C and working stocks at 8 C.
2.6. Statistical analysis
The ANOVA analysis was carried out using the SPSS statistical program for Windows (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL). The means were compared according to the Newman and Keuls multiple range-test at
3.1. Physico-chemical parameters of composting process
The physicochemical characteristics evolution obtained during the municipal solid waste composting process was presented in Table 1.
In this study the temperature progress vary according the two phases of composting process, digestion and maturation (Fig. 1). The phase of digestion starts with a mesophilic phase in which the temperature reached 42 °C. During this mesophilic step, the humidity rate was up to 45%. After 20 days of composting, the temperature reached 65 °C and the thermophilic step started. In this step the humidity decreased significantly. Then, the temperature decreased gradually to reach 40 °C. At the 62 days, and after the addition of sawdust and green wastes in order to enhance the microbial activity, the maturation phase took place. In this phase, like in the digestion phase, the temperature increased gradually to reach 50 °C, stabilised for a short period then decreased. In this phase there was also mesophilic, thermophilic and cooling steps.
3.2. Evolution of microbial biomass C, microbial N and microbial DNA extracts during composting process
The progress of microbial biomasses (BC and BN) over time marked a real variation, particularly with a decrease of BC, BN and DNA concentration registered during the digestion and maturation phases (Figure 2). During the digestion phase of composting process microbial biomass C (
The BC/BN values registered in digestion phase indicate the dominance of three types of microbial communities. Homogeneous microbial community was found during mesophilic and thermophilic steps of municipal solid waste process was found particularly with BC/BN values of 3.3. Heterogeneous microbial communities were found particularly with BC/BN values of 7.92 and 1.54 (Table 1).
The BC/BN values registered in maturation phase indicate the dominance of two types of microbial communities. Heterogeneous microbial communities were found particularly with BC/BN values of 2.3 and 1.6.
The addition of sawdust and green wastes is considered to be a source of organic matter that stimulates microbial biomass. In fact, the addition of sawdust and green wastes affect the structure and composition of the microbial communities that colonize the municipal solid waste.
TOC, Total organic carbon; TN, total nitrogen; C/N, carbon: nitrogen ratio; DM: dry matter
3.3. Relationship between microbial biomasses BC and BN and DNA content
A good linear relation between microbial BC and BN was found during the digestion and maturation phases, with
A linear relationship between biomass C and DNA concentration was found (Fig. 4A and B). DNA concentrations and BC were highly correlated during the digestion phase of municipal solid waste composting process with
On the other hand there is a linear relationship between biomass N and DNA concentration (Fig. 4C and D). DNA concentrations and BN were highly correlated during the digestion and maturation phases of municipal solid waste composting process with
3.4. Humic acid and protein impurities during composting
DNA extracts from the cooling stage of maturation phase showed the lowest ratio
The extracted DNA with low
The extraction method will be suitable for the DNA purity. The purity will determine the extent to which the microbial DNA template can be amplified by PCR during the composting analysis. However, in this study the humic acid content could not interfere with PCR. Then the PCR products were successfully used for DGGE analysis (data not shown).
The DNA extract was thus suitable to be used for molecular studies on the microbial communities in municipal solid waste composting process.
Pure culture: DNA from Gram positive bacteria. n = 3 determined by spectrophotometry at 260 nm (A260), 280 nm (A280) and 230 nm (A230); (In brackets): standard deviation; within a column different letter after bracket means that the value is significantly difference according to Student-Newmann-Keuls test at
5.1. Physico-chemical parameters of composting process
The composting process at the microbial level involves several interrelated factors, namely temperature, ventilation (O2 imputed), moisture content and available nutrients. Based on temperature, the process of aerobic composting can be divided into three major steps, a mesophilic-heating step, a thermophilic step and a cooling step (Mustin, 1987). During the mesophilic step, the temperature and the water content increased as a consequence of biodegradation of organic compounds. The temperature increment is the consequence of the organic matter oxidation (Hassen et al., 2001). The mesophilic step is followed by the thermophilic step. The latter step occurred between days 20 and days 34 of the composting process. As mentioned by Hachicha et al., 1992 and Marrug et al., 1993, a temperature above 60 °C seriously affect the decomposition rate of the organic waste as a result of a reduction in microbiological activity. The temperature started to decrease after 48 days, and then increased again after the addition of fresh organic matter. A second decrease of the temperature then occurred after 111 days of the process, this decrease led to the depletion of organic matters and the carbon/azotes (C/N) ratio tended to stabilize. By the end of the composting process, the average temperature inside the windrow showed a decrement and reached approximately 30 °C at the end of the process (Ben Ayed et al., 2007).
Composting is a self-heating, aerobic, solid phase, useful way of transforming organic wastes into valuable organic matter for use as an organic amendment for soils. The composting process can provide stable and valuable substrates through the bio-oxidation of the organic fraction deriving from different waste matrices (Castaldi et al., 2004, 2008). Many tests have been considered as maturity indices for compost, and most of them focus on the chemical and physical properties of compost. The most common parameters include compost temperature, pH, cation exchange capacity, dissolved organic C, C/N ratio, humification index, plant growth bioassay, spectroscopic methods, etc. (Garcia
5.2. Evolution of microbial biomass C, microbial N and microbial DNA extracts during composting process
The evolution of microbial biomass C, microbial N and microbial DNA extracts during composting process is probably related to the availability of readily decomposable substrates; in fact when organisms are presented with a substrate they normally multiply rapidly until the substrate is nearly exhausted, when numbers reach a maximum (Joergensen et al., 1990; Ben Ayed et al., 2007). Thereafter, with the exhaustion of these substances caused by the intense microbial activity and by ongoing humification, the microbial biomass decreased. The BC and BN decreased possibly due to the degradation of the depletion of organic substrates available for micro-organisms growth (Manuael
With the progress of the process the DNA content decrease and the extraction and purification method yielded 18.5 µg DNA/g of dry compost in the end of the process. Howeler et al., 2003 found 18.2 µg DNA/g of wet compost yielded by extraction and purification method from compost.
This result could be explained by (i) the microbial DNases degradation or by (ii) the protection of the DNA by binding to compost humic acids. The formation of humic-DNA complexes should be considered as a process related to the changes in compost matrix, i.e. formation of humic like substances, which is one of the main purposes for the composting process.
Biological parameters such as microbial biomass are useful indicators of biological activity in ecosystems (Benitez et al., 1999). Since, during the composting process microbial biomass C, microbial biomass N and DNA contents could indicate compost stability, defined as the degree of decomposition of the readily biodegradable organic matter.
5.3. Relationship between microbial BC and BN and DNA
A good linear relationship between microbial BC and BN, during the different stages of composting process. The same result was found during three consecutive years of compost amendment at the level of the upper and deep horizon of non cultivated soil (Bouzaiane
In the composting process the humification and mineralization of organic substances occurs simultaneously. The DNA content, BC and BN could be related to the humification index and degree of polymerisation evolutions.
In the digestion phase we think that the micro-organisms diversity is due to the incorporation of extra-cellular DNA from degrade microbial in to bacterial genome as possible source of genetic instructions (transformation, conjugation and transduction).
Similar results were obtained by Bouzaiane et al., 2007b who found a strong relationship between BC, BN estimated by CFE, and extracted DNA in cultivated-compost-amended soil. Marstorp et al., 2000 found also a strong relationship between BC, estimated by CFE, and extracted DNA in a mineral soil. They suggested that DNA could be used as a measure of microbial biomass in agricultural soils with low organic matter content. Tejada et al., 2009 were found a strong correlation between biological and chemical parameters during municipal solid waste composting process.
Tejada et al., 2009 suggested that humification index (HI) and degree of polymerisation (DP) of the compost can be related with biological and chemical parameters in a combined way.
5.4. Humic acid and protein impurities during composting
The humic acid increased during municipal solid waste composting process. Also Tejada et al., 2009 showed that the humic index and degree of polymerisation parameters, both increased during composting process (66% and 41%, respectively at the end of the composting process when compared to values at 0 days).
Composting DNA was often contaminated with humic acid or proteins that interfered with accurate quantification of DNA by UV absorbance at 260 nm (Tebbe and Vahjen, 1993; Kuske et al., 1998). In this work, we used Fast DNA Kit for Soil DNA extraction and UV absorbance at 260 nm to detect very low DNA concentrations in diluted samples (typically 100 to 1000 fold), so that the effect of humic acid contamination could be ignored. UV absorbance at 260 nm was an excellent method for DNA quantification of samples extracted from environmental sources containing high levels of humic acids. A simple and accurate method of humic acid quantification (e.g. absorbance) should also be used to determine the correct dilution required for DNA quantification and to measure the progress of humic acid.
It can be concluded that the microbial biomass C and N and DNA content during the municipal solid waste composting process can be of great use in understanding the compost stability state. This fact does not mean that the study of these biological properties diminishes the study of the chemical properties, but rather, both types of properties can be combined to indicate the compost stability. In fact the linear regression analysis developed in this work indicates a strong relationship between the biological properties. On the other hand the commercial method for extraction DNA was suitable for PCR-DNA amplification of microbial analysis during the composting of municipal solid waste and of the end product such as the compost that could be used for the detection of microbial pathogens.
Special thanks to all who helped in the water treatment and recycling laboratory of CERTE (Centre de Recherche et des Technologie des Eaux).
Ben Ayed. L. Hassen A. Jedidi N. Saidi I. N. Bouzaiane O. Murano F. 2007 Microbial C and N dynamics during composting process of urban solid waste. 25 1(February 2007), 24 29, 0073-4242X.
Benitez E. Nogales R. Elvira C. Masciandaro G. Ceccanti B. 1999 Enzyme activities as indicators of the stabilization of sewage sludges composting with Eisenia foetida. , 67 3(March 1999), 297 303, 0960-8524
Bouzaiane O. Cherif H. Saidi N. Jedidi N. Hassen A. 2007a Effects of municipal solid waste compost application on the microbial biomass of cultivated and non-cultivated soil in a semi-arid zone. , 25 4(August 2007), 334 342, 0073-4242X.
Bouzaiane O. Cherif H. Saidi N. Hassen A. Jedidi N. 2007b Municipal solid waste compost dose effects on soil microbial biomass determined by chloroform fumigation-extraction and DNA methods. , 57 4 681 686, 1590-4261
Blanc M. Marilley L. Beffa T. Aragno M. 1999 Thermophilic bacterial communities in hot composts as revealed by most probable number counts and molecular (16S rDNA) methods. , 28 2(February 1999), 141 149, 0168-6496
Brookes P. C. 1995 The use of microbial parameters in monitoring soil pollution by heavy metals. , 19 4(March 1995), 269 279, 0178-2762
Brookes P. C. Landman A. Pruden G. Jenkinson D. S. 1985 Chloroform fumigation and the release of soil nitrogen: a rapid direct extraction method to measure microbial biomass nitrogen in soil. , 17 6(1985), 837 842 0038-0717
Castaldi P. Garau G. Melis P. 2004 Influence of compost from sea weeds on heavy metal dynamics in the soil-plant system. , 13 1322 1328, 1018-4619
Castaldi P. Garau G. Melis P. 2008 Maturity assessment of compost from municipal solid waste through the study of enzyme activities and water-soluble fractions. , 28 3(March 2008), 534 540, 0095-6053X.
Dees P. M. Ghiorse W. C. 2001 Microbial diversity in hot synthetic compost as revealed by PCR-amplified rRNA sequences from cultivated isolates and extracted DNA. , 35 2(April 2001), 207 216, 0168-6496
De Nobili M. Baca M. T. Fornassier F. Mondini C. 1996Ninhydrinreactive nitrogen of CHCl3 fumigated and non fumigated compost extracts as a parameter to evaluate compost stability. In: De Bertoldi, M., Sequi, P., Lemmes, P. & Papi, T. (eds): , 255 261. Blackie Academic & Professional, Glasgow, Scotland.
Franzluebbers A. T. Hons F. M. . Zuberer D. A. 1995Soil organic carbon, microbial biomass and miniralizable carbon and nitrogen in sorghum. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 59 2(March, April 1995), 460 466, 0361-5995
Hachicha R. Hassen A. Jedidi N. Kallali H. 1992Optimal conditions for municipal solid waste. J Waste Recyc, 33 6No. 76 77.
Hassen A. Belguith K. Jedidi N. Cherif A. Cherif M. Boudabbous A. 2001 Microbial characterization during composting of municipal solid waste. , 80 3(December 2001), 185 192, 0960-8524
Hellmann B. Zelles L. Palojarvi A. Quingyun B. 1997Emission of climate relevant trace gases and succession of microbial communities during open-window composting., 63 3(March 1997), 1011 1018, 0099-2240
Howeler M. Ghiorse W. C. Walker L. P. 2003 A quantitative analysis of DNA extraction and purification from compost., 54 1(July 2003), 37 45, 0167-7012
Jedidi N. Hassen A. Van Cleemput O. M’hiri A. 2004 Microbial biomass in soil amended with different types of organic wastes., 22 2(April 1999), 93 99, 0073-4242X.
Jenkinson D. S. Powlson D. S. 1976The effects of biocidal treatments on metabolism in soil-I. Fumigation with chloroform., 8 3(1976), 167 177, 0038-0717
Joergensen R. G. Brooks P. C. 1990 Ninhydrin-reactive nitrogen measurements of microbial biomass in 0.5 M K2SO4 soil extracts. , 22 8(1990), 1023 1027, 0038-0717
Kowalchuk G. A. Naoumenko Z. S. Derikx P. J. L. Felske A. Stephen J. R. Arkhipchenko I. A. 1999 Molecular analysis of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria of the beta subdivision of the class proteobacteria in compost and composted materials., 65 2(February 1999), 396 403, 0099-2240
Kuske C. R. Banton K. L. Adorada D. L. Stark P. C. Hill K. K. Jackson P. J. 1998 Small-scale DNA sample preparation method for field PCR detection of microbial cells and spores in soil. , 64 7(July 1998), 2463 EOF 2472 EOF, 0099-2240
Leckie S. E. Prescott C. E. Grayston S. J. Neufeld J. D. Mohn W. W. 2004 Comparison of chloroform fumigation-extraction, phospholipid fatty acid, and DNA methods to determine microbial biomass in forest humus. , 36 3(March 2004), 529 532, 0038-0717
Marstorp H. Guan X. Gong P. 2000 Relationship between dsDNA, chloroform labile C and ergosterol in soils of different organic matter contents and pH. , 32 6(June 2000), 879 882, 0038-0717
Marrug C. Grebus M. Hassen R. C. Keener H. M. Hoitink H. A. J. 1993A kinetic model of yard waste composting process., 1 38 51, 0106-5657X.
Michel F. C. Reddy C. A. Forney L. J. 1995 Microbial-degradation and humification of the lawn care pesticide 2, 4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid during the composting of yard trimmings. , 61 7(July 1995), 2566 2571, 0099-2240
Mondini C. Sanchez Monedero. M. A. Leita L. Bragato G. De Nobili M. 1997 Carbon and ninhydrin reactive nitrogen of the microbial biomass in rewetted compost samples. , 28 1-2, (January, Febuary1997), 113 122, 0010-3624
Mondini C. Contin M. Leita L. De Nobili M. 2002 Response of microbial biomass to air-drying and rewetting in soils and compost. ., 105 1-2, (January 1999), 111 124, 0016-7061
Mondini C. Fornasier F. Sinicco T. 2004 Enzymatic activity as a parameter for the characterization of the composting processes. , 36 10(October 2004), 1587 1594, 0038-0717
Mustin M. 1987 Le Compost: Gestion de la Matière Organique.(Editions François Dubusc), 978-2-86472-008-9Paris 954p.
Ogram A. Sayler G. S. Barkay T. 1987 The extraction and purification of microbial DNA from sediments., 7 2-3, (December1987), 57 66, 0167-7012
Peters S. Koschinsky S. Schwieger F. Tebbe C. C. 2000Succession of microbial communities during hot composting as detected by PCR-single-strandconformation polymorphism-based genetic profiles of small-subunit rRNA genes., 66 3(March 2000), 930 936, 0099-2240
Pfaller S. L. Vesper S. J. Moreno H. 1994The use of PCR to detect a pathogen in compost. , 2 48 54, 0106-5657X.
Steffan R. J. Goksoyr J. Bej A. K. Atlas R. M. 1988 Recovery of DNA from soils and sediments., 54 12(December 1988), 2908 2915, 0099-2240
Tebbe C. C. Vahjen W. 1993 Interference of humic acids and DNA extracted directly from soil in detection and transformation of recombinant DNA from bacteria and yeast., 59 8(August 1993), 2657 2665, 0099-2240
Tejada M. Garcia-Marinez A. M. Parrado J. 2009 Relationships between biological and chemical parameters on the composting of a municipal solid waste. , 100 17(September 2009), 4062 4065, 0960-8524
Vance E. D. Brookes P. C. Jenkinson D. S. 1987 Microbial biomass measurements in forest soils: determination of KC values and tests of hypotheses to explain the failure of the chloroform fumigation-incubation method in acid soils. , 19 6(1987), 689 696, 0038-0717