Open access peer-reviewed chapter

Simultaneously Recovery of Phosphorus and Potassium Using Bubble Column Reactor as Struvite-K and Implementation on Crop Growth

Written By

Endar Hidayat and Hiroyuki Harada

Submitted: 01 July 2021 Reviewed: 24 August 2021 Published: 12 September 2021

DOI: 10.5772/intechopen.100103

From the Edited Volume

Crystallization and Applications

Edited by Youssef Ben Smida and Riadh Marzouki

Chapter metrics overview

281 Chapter Downloads

View Full Metrics


Struvite-K, similar to NH4-struvite with a composition of Mg:K:P (1:1:1). It is called struvite-K because the K replaces the NH4 in struvite. The composition usually used as fertilizer and can be recycling from wastewater including livestock wastewaters. In addition, Struvite-K which tends to form scale on surfaces of equipment which problem in many industries. The present study was used bubble column reactor which simple and efficient. In addition, the process can be implementation in wastewater industry which low-tech processes. Then, the struvite-K precipitate was implementation on crop growth which compared with coffee husk compost. The results show the removal of P via struvite-K showed 98.5% with the precipitation Mg:P of 0.7 and K:P of 1 with yields of 11.28 gram. Increases of magnesium dosage which decreases of P removal rate and affected of crystal size structure. Compost and struvite-K have similar positive impact on crop growth of (radish and komatsuna) were compared than control. In the other hand, the struvite-K is more effective than compost. This might be indicated that struvite-K is more slow-release nutrient than compost and higher macro nutrient supplied on soil which crop needed.


  • Struvite-K
  • precipitates
  • soil
  • recovery of wastewater
  • fertilizers

1. Introduction

1.1 Bubble column reactor for struvite-K precipitation

Magnesium potassium phosphate hexahydrate, commonly known as struvite-K, is a sparingly crystallize consisting of equal molar amount of magnesium potassium and phosphate and six water of hydration, hence the chemical formula is MgKPO4.6H2O. Struvite-K is formed according to the following reaction:


Struvite-K has been synthesized to show its viability for phosphorus and potassium removal from wastewater [1, 2, 3, 4] and naturally occurring. Tanaka [5] reported that phosphorus and potassium from effluents of livestock wastewater contains (5.5 mM) and (63.9 mM), respectively. This is a new resource for potassium and phosphorus demand for use as fertilizers which following global population in every year. It was estimated the world population to reach between 9 and 10 billion by 2050 [6, 7].

Struvite-K precipitates as a white powder needle-like structure, which tends to form scale on surfaces of equipment. Struvite-K scaling is a well-recognized problem in many industrial processes and domestic applications. The problem is that not only from pipes but also pumps, centrifuges and aerators can be blocked by struvite [8, 9, 10]. In the other hand, this is not problem but solution to supplying nutrient on crop growth.

Struvite-K, similar to NH4-struvite has a desired low solubility and chemical composition of Mg:K:P (1:1:1). It also has a high market value in the agricultural area (Sean 2018). It is called struvite-K because the K replaces the NH4 in struvite (MgNH4PO4.6H2O). The present study, we used synthetic wastewater was designed using bubble column reactor to simulate effluent from livestock wastewater to recovery of phosphorus and potassium as struvite-K which used as fertilizers for increasing global food production.

1.2 Implementation on crop growth

Most of the nutrients absorbed by plants come from organic matter. Therefore, the unique fertilizer formula comes from compost or struvite-K precipitate. They provide a rich source of nutrients and can be added to the soil to promote the growth of various crops. Therefore, compost and struvite-K precipitation are intended to serve the society by increasing farmers’ incomes to revitalize the soil and increase farm yields. We fertilized the two fertilizers from compost and struvite-K precipitate, in order to evaluate the effects of fertilizer on soil and yields of radish (Raphanus sativus L.) and Komatsuna (Brassica rapa var. perviridis).

1.2.1 Radish (Raphanus sativus L.)

Radish (Raphanus sativus L.) belongs to the genus and species of Radish in the cruciferous family. Radishes are grown and consumed all over the world and are considered part of the human diet, although it is not common in certain populations. It is one of the most important and popular root vegetables in tropical, subtropical and temperate regions of the world (including Japan). It is grown as an annual and biannual vegetable crop, depending on its planting purpose. Radishes are mainly cold-season vegetable crops. Asian varieties can tolerate higher temperatures than European varieties. In a mild climate, radishes can be grown almost all year except for the summer months [10]. Its young roots can be eaten raw in salads or cooked as vegetables. It has a spicy taste and is considered an appetizer. Young leaves can also be cooked and eaten as vegetables. Radish preparations are useful for liver and gallbladder diseases. Roots, leaves, flowers and pods are active against Gram-positive bacteria, urinary system diseases, hemorrhoids and stomach pain. In addition, the salt extracted from the roots can be dried and burned into white ash, which can be used to relieve stomach problems [11].

1.2.2 Komatsuna (Japanese mustard spinach)

Japanese mustard spinach (Brassica rapa var. perviridis) is also called Komatsuna in Japanese. It is a common and popular leafy vegetable in the Japanese diet. Komatsuna contains low energy and high nutrients, which is very effective in lowering serum cholesterol. On the other hand, Komatsuna has a compound called sulforaphane, which can help our body fight cancer. Sulforaphane actively kills cancer stem cells and slows the growth of tumors [12]. Komatsu greens are rich in calcium and are commonly used in kimchi in Japan and as feed crops in many Asian countries.

In 2019, the production of Komatsuna in Japan increased by 26.5% compared with 2006, and the planting area increased by 29.2%, with a total output of 114,900 tons [13]. Komatsuna can be worn in relatively temperate regions most of the year, but it is usually grown as a cool seasonal crop (spring and autumn). It can tolerate some extreme cold and hot conditions, but it cannot stand for long periods of time [14]. Economically important members of this family include vegetables such as broccoli, cabbage, chinese cabbage, radish, cauliflower as well as the oil crop canola [15].


2. Materials and methods

2.1 Materials

Sodium dihydrogen phosphate, magnesium chloride and sodium hydroxide were obtained from the Kanto Chemical Co. Inc. (Tokyo/Japan), potassium chloride was obtained from Wako Pure Chemical Industries Ltd. All chemicals and reagents were of analytical grade and used without further purification.

The soil was collected at 0–20 cm of depth in the field center of Prefectural University of Hiroshima. The soil was analyzed in the laboratory at the Department of Environmental Science, Prefectural University of Hiroshima, Japan. Elemental characteristics of soil and compost were described previous work [16]. Radish (Raphanus sativus L.) and komatsuna (Brassica rapa var. perviridis) were collected from market store, which is in the Shobara city, Hiroshima Prefecture.

2.2 Experimental design and treatments.

2.2.1 Bubble column reactor for struvite-K precipitation

The use of different magnesium additives to recover MgKPO4.6H2O (MPP) was investigated. The experimental conditions are summarized in Table 1. Illustrates the experimental setup of the bubble column used in this study which has capacity of 10 L (Figure 1). There was a draught tube structure inside the bubble column. Air was fed using an air pump from the bottom of the tower as instead of mixing for homogeneous of solution. A pH probe was placed directly into the reactor just below the liquid surface. The bubble column was first filled with synthetic wastewater, and then potassium chloride, magnesium chloride and sodium dihydrogen phosphate solutions were fed from the outer reactor to the inner tubes. The pH was adjusted to 12.9 with 0.1 M NaOH solutions. Afterward the solution of potassium chloride, magnesium chloride and sodium dihydrogen phosphate were added continuously with had pH of 3.4 by dose pump until pH of 11 with retention time of 1.98 (defined Eq. (2)).

Run no.Mg2+ mMPO4-P mMK+ mMMg/P initial

Table 1.

Characteristic of raw water.

Figure 1.

Experimental set-up.


Set points for minimum and maximum pH values defined a narrow band of 0.3 pH units. After filtering the reactor solution, a white precipitation was obtained; it was desiccated at 60°C for 24 h. Samples were taken directly from the precipitation zone. All experiments were done at room temperature.

2.2.2 Pot treatment designs

The experimental design was completely randomized design, with five treatments and three replications were presented by pots. Seeds were soaked in water for 24 h before sowing at a maximum depth of 1.2 cm. The equal proportions of compost samples (150 g and 10 seeds) i,e Radish (Raphanus sativus L.) and komatsuna (Brassica rapa var. perviridis) were filled and installed in a greenhouse. The LED model (PF15-S5WT8-D with power 5 W) was used as a light source with free space between lamps and a pot about 37 cm. Treatments consisted of C: 100% (control), A1: 0.1% of compost, A2: 0.3% of compost, B1: 0.1% of struvite-K and B2: 0.3% of struvite-K. The pots were watered periodically to prevent drought stress of the plants. The experimental were conducted for 9 days.

2.2.3 Analytical methods of struvite-K precipitates

The concentrations of PO43− were determined by standard method (Japan Industrial Standard method JIS KO 102). The concentrations of potassium and magnesium ions were measured using atomic absorption spectrophotometer (AA-6300, Shimadzu Kyoto, Japan). The white precipitation was dissolved in 0.5 M HNO3 in 1 h for determination of the crystalline components. Microscope images (Olympus CX-32) was used to observe the surface morphology of the crystals. The percent P removal and P recovery are in Eqs. (3) and (4), respectively.


2.2.4 Analytical methods of soil

The sample was ground by using a coffee mill to pass through a sieve <2-mm before analysis [16]. Cation exchange capacity (CEC) were extracted 1 M NH4OAc pH 7 via NH4 with the procedure in below:


The ammonium (NH4) was measured by the phenate spectrophotometric with UV–Vis Spectrophotometer (Jasco V-530) at 640 nm. The detailed procedure in below:

Solution A

  1. Phenol 5 gram

  2. Sodium nitriferricyonide dehydrate 0.1 gram

  3. Homogenized and adjusted with dilution water 500 mL

Solution B

  1. 200 ml of NaCLO (assay 5%) = 200/5 = 40 mL

  2. NaOH = 15 gram

  3. Homogenized and adjusted with dilution water 1000 mL


10 mL from the liquid sample and 5 ml from solution A and B, respectively. Afterward, waiting for 30 minutes before analysis. Standard solution was used NH4Cl with calibration curve, y = 0.1747x – 0.1465. R2 = 0.9999.


3. Results and discussion

3.1 Effect different initial of Mg:P ratios on % P removal and precipitate

Bubble column reactor was used in laboratory studies with hopefully, it can be implementation in wastewater industry. From a structural point of view, they are very simple units equipped with added a dose pump as mixing system that allows for the homogenization of the wastewater with the reactants. The mixing condition inside the reactor represents a fundamental aspect because it affects the struvite formation [17]. An effective mixing promotes the crystals nucleation and growth by improving the mass of ions from the solution to the solid phase. Generally, completely mixed reactors can operate continuously or in batch mode. A batch column reactor works according to a series of phase and the struvite-K production and precipitation occur in the same unit (Figure 2).

Figure 2.

Percentage of P removal with different of initial of Mg:P ratios concentration.

In this study, we used MgCl2.6H2O as magnesium source which have advantages of being very soluble allowing to recovery a precipitate with a high purity degree [18]. Due to easy management was used in many studies through which the kinetics of the nucleation process have been assessed [19, 20]. While the pH was maintained in alkaline condition of 11 which following based on [21]. Since the conditions favorable precipitation of struvite-K. Based on Figure 3 shows that P removal rate was decreased from 98.5–80% which increasing of molar ratios of Mg:P from 0.8 to 1.22 since strong influence of precipitation in many scientist [22]. While for hydraulic retention time we maintained at 1.98 h; since in around of this was much more consistent than the rate reported in the literature and no effect with difference of HRT in precipitation [3, 4]. Furthermore, P recovery of struvite-K we conducted only for Mg:P of 0,8 since these concentrations was effective for % P removal than others with precipitate of Mg:P of 0,7 and K:P of 1 are shown in Table 2.

Figure 3.

Procedure for measure exchangeable cation and CEC via NH4.

pHDosage Mg:P ratioMg:P (precipitate)K:P (precipitate)% P recovery

Table 2.

Effect of the magnesium dosage on the Mg:P molar concentration ratio in precipitate.

The optimal molar ratios must be assessed case-by-case as it depends heavily on the chemical–physical characteristics of wastewater and the reactor used. On the contrary, other works in which unconventional reagents were exploited, found that greater dosages are necessary. For example, Quintana et al. [23] found a strong influence a Mg:P molar ratio on the abatement of phosphate amount and the major removal was detected when used MgO dosed at molar ratio of 1.5. Moreover, the authors observed that the increase of the molar ratio promoted the removal rate growth (Quintana et al. [24]). In agreement with this consideration, Jaffer et al. [25] affirmed that with Mg:P addition lower than 1.05 the precipitation resulted was greater to avoid the formation of magnesium sodium phosphate [4].

However, an excess of Mg can cause the formation of magnesium phosphate and reducing the precipitation of struvite which following for P removal rate. Korchef et al. [26] observed the phosphate removal caused by precipitation for Mg:P molar ratio under 4 and newberyite (MgHPO4.3H2O) and cattiite (Mg3(PO4)2.22H2O) formation for Mg:P = 5.

3.2 Morphology of struvite-K precipitation

The morphology of struvite-K was observed by using Microscope images (Olympus CX-32). Figure 4A shows needle-like structure. This is agreement with some reported [3, 4, 27, 28]. While for Figure 4B, the needle-like was mixed with block and hexagonal structure. Furthermore, there are more blocks and hexagons seen in Figure 4C. This shows that as the amount of magnesium increases and the removal rate of phosphorus decreases, the structure is affected which mixed with another structure. The increase in the magnesium dosage also reduces the crystal size. The average of crystal size of 22.45 μm (Figure 4A). This is agreement with [29] that increase magnesium dosage reduced the average crystal size. Struvite-K forms a white crystalline solid. When dried in 60°C the struvite-K precipitated into appearance of white powder as shown in Figure 4D. While for the struvite-K yields of 11.28 gram.

Figure 4.

Struvite-K crystals as seen x10/0.25 of Olympus. Image captured with microscope of Olympus CX-32. (A) Initial Mg:P of 0.8, (B) initial Mg:P 1.08, (C) initial Mg:P of 1.22 and (D) image of struvite-K precipitated dried (crystal of white powder).

3.3 Effect of fertilizers on soil cation exchange capacity

The cation exchange capacity (CEC) is a very important soil property for nutrient retention and supply and acts as a bridge between soil and plant [30]. Table 3 presents the characteristics of soil CEC on two-kind of crop growth (radish and komatsuna). The results shows that all treatment of fertilizer (compost and struvite-K) with two-kind of crop growth were higher than control (soil only). However, the highest results seen in treatment of struvite-K with 0.3% percent ratio of soil for both of crop growth. This is indicated that struvite-K is effective as supplying of nutrient sources which have higher macro nutrient such as phosphate, magnesium and potassium. This is agreement with [31] who found application of phosphate fertilizer increasing of soil CEC after 40 years of application. This can be explained that phosphate, potassium and magnesium is the most important factor affecting on soil CEC.

TreatmentCEC (meq/100 g)
Compost 0.1%71.8
Compost 0.3%74.1
Struvite-K 0.1%72.5
Struvite-K 0.3%94.0
Compost 0.1%67.8
Compost 0.3%72.3
Struvite-K 0.1%69.1
Struvite-K 0.3%86.4

Table 3.

Characteristics of soil cation exchange capacity.

3.4 Effect of fertilizers on yields of crop growth

As shown in Table 4 presents the stem height, leaf area of radish. Overall, the treatment of fertilizers was highest than control (soil only).

TreatmentStem length (cm)Leaf wide (cm)
Compost 0.1%3.080.68
Compost 0.3%4.460.98
struvite-K 0.1%4.380.8
struvite-K 0.3%6.361.31

Table 4.

Radish (Raphanus sativus L.).

In the treatment of compost, the highest rate of 0.3% with 4.46 and 0.98 cm on stem height and leaf area, respectively. While for treatment of struvite-K the highest rate of 0.3% with 6.36 and 1.31 cm on stem height and leaf area, respectively. For images of radish on pot treatment as shown in Figure 5. Both of fertilizers were given benefits effect on yields of radish and positive correlation with soil CEC. If we comparison, the struvite-K was given more benefits effect which cause the struvite-K is higher contains of macro content such as magnesium, potassium and phosphate as nutrient sources on crop growth. Furthermore, Table 5 presents the stem height and leaf area of komatsuna. The same dosage treatment with radish between 0.1% and 0.3%. Overall, the supplying of fertilizers was given benefits effect on yields of komatsuna. However, the more benefits in the treatment of struvite-K on dosage of 0.3% with 5.24 and 1.27 cm, on stem length and leaf wide, respectively. This might be indicated that struvite-K is more slow-release than compost and higher macro nutrient supplied on soil which needed on crop. Slow-release fertilizer which releases nutrients slowly over a long release time. Furthermore, it can reduce the number fertilization times and amount of fertilizer applied, which have good impact on fertilizer use efficiency [32, 33, 34, 35]. Images of komatsuna on pot treatment as shown in Figure 6.

Figure 5.

Images of radish on pot treatment; (C) 100% (control), (A1) 0.1% of compost, (A2) 0.3% of compost, (B1) 0.1% of struvite-K and (B2) 0.3% of struvite-K.

TreatmentStem lengthLeaf wide
Compost 0.1%4.420.87
Compost 0.3%5.41.22
struvite-K 0.1%4.360.99
struvite-K 0.3%5.741.27

Table 5.

Komatsuna (Japanese mustard plant).

Figure 6.

Images of komatsuna on pot treatment, (C) 100% (control), (A1) 0.1% of compost, (A2) 0.3% of compost, (B1) 0.1% of struvite-K and (B2) 0.3% of struvite-K.


4. Conclusion

The present study used bubble column reactor which simple and efficient. Removal of P via struvite-K showed 98.5% with the precipitates Mg:P of 0.7 and K:P of 1. The yields of 11.28 gram. Compost and struvite-K have positive impact on crop growth of (radish and komatsuna) were compared than control. Which might be caused supplied nutrient source on soil and uptake on crop. However, the struvite-K is more effective than compost may cause contains higher macro nutrient such as magnesium, potassium and phosphate. This is indicated that the recovery process of P and K via struvite-K using bubble column reactor was very effective and efficient to utilization as a fertilizer.



The author (E.H) would like to thanks to Japanese Government (MEXT Scholarship) for financial support during studying in Prefectural University of Hiroshima.


Conflict of interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.


  1. 1. Bennet, A. Potential for potassium recovery as K-Struvite. [thesis]. University of British Columbia; 2015.
  2. 2. Zeng, Le, and Xiaomei Li. Nutrient removal from anaerobically digested cattle manure by struvite precipitation. Journal of Environmental Engineering Science. 2006; 5(4); 285-294.
  3. 3. Wilsenach, JA, Schuurbiers CAH, van Loosdrecht MCM. Phosphate and potassium recovery from source separated urine through struvite precipitation. Water Research 2007;41(2): 458-466.
  4. 4. Satoshi Y, Ohura S, Harada H, Akagi K, Yoshiharu M, Kawakita H, and Biplob KB. Simultaneous crystallization of phosphate and potassium as magnesium potassium phosphate using bubble column reactor with draught tube. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering: 2013;1(4):1154-1158.
  5. 5. Tanaka T, Koike N, Sto T, Arai T, Taira N. Recovery of phosphate from livestock wastewater by electrolysis. Journal of Japan Society On Water Environment. 2009;32(2): 79-85.
  6. 6. Pew Research Center. Attitudes about aging: A global perspective [Internet]. 2014. Available from; [Accessed:2021-06-28]
  7. 7. UN News Centre. World population projected to reach 9.6 billion by 2050 [Internet]. 2013. Available from; [Accessed:2021-06-28]
  8. 8. Parsons SA, Doyle JD. Struvite scale formation and control. Water Science & Technology. 2004; 49(2):177-1782. wst.2004.0118
  9. 9. Mamais D, Pitt PA, Yao WC, Loicano J, Jenkins D. Determination of ferric chloride dose to control struvite precipitation in anaerobic digesters. Water Environment Research. 1994:66:912-918. https://doi. org/10.2175/wer.66.7.8
  10. 10. Umar UM, Ibrahim I, Iro, Obidola SM. Growth and yield of radish (Raphanus sativus L.) as influenced by different levels of kalli organic fertilizer on the Jos Plateau. Asian Journal of Research in Crop Science. 2019;4(4): 1-8. DOI: 10.9734/AJRCS/2019/v4i430078
  11. 11. Gyewali B, Maharjan B, Rana G, Pandey R, Pathak R, Poudel PR. Effect of different organic manure on growth, yield and quality of Radish (Raphanus sativus L.). SAARC Journal of Agriculture. 2020;18(2):101-114. DOI:
  12. 12. Aiso I, Inoue H, Seiyama Y, Kuwano T. Compared with the intake of commercial vegetable juice, the intake of fresh fruit and komatsuna (Brassica rapa L. var. perviridis) juice mixture reduces serum cholesterol in middle-aged men: a randomized controlled pilot study. Lipids in Health and Disease. 2014,13, 102. DOI: 10.1186/1476-511X-13-102
  13. 13. Japan CROPs [Internet] 2020. Komatsuna. Available from: [Accessed:2021-06-28]
  14. 14. Department of primary industries and fisheries, Queensland [Internet] 2007. Komatsuna. Available from: [Accessed:2021-05-15]
  15. 15. Collett MG, Stegelmeir BL, Tapper BA. Could nitrile derivatives of turnip (Brassica rapa) glucosinolates Be Hepato-or Cholangiotoxic in Cattle?. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 2014;62(30); 7370-7375.
  16. 16. Hiroyuki H, Endar H, Asmak A. Improving coffee husk compost quality. Journal of Nutrition and Dietetic Practice. 2020:4(1);001-009.
  17. 17. Stratful I, Scrimshaw MD, Lester JN. Removal of struvite to prevent problems associated with its accumulation in wastewater treatment works. Water Environ Research. 2004:76;437-443.
  18. 18. Kabdaslı I, Tünay O. Nutrient recovery by struvite precipitation, ion exchange and adsorption from source-separated human urine. A review. Environmental Technology Reviewes. 2018:7; 106-138.
  19. 19. Bhuiyan MIH, Mivinic DS, Beckie RD. A solubility and thermodynamic study of struvite. Environmental Technology. 2007: 28; 1015-1026.
  20. 20. Le Corre KS, Valsami-Jones E, Hobbs P, Parsons SA. Impact of reactor operation on success of struvite precipitation from synthetic liquors. Environmental Technology. 2007: 28; 1245-1256.
  21. 21. Harada H, Katayama Y, Afriliana A, Inoue M, Teranaka R, Mitoma Y. Effects of co-existing ions on the phosphorus potassium ratio of the precipitate formed in the potassium phosphate crystallization process. Journal of Environmental Protection. 2017:08(11):1424-1434.
  22. 22. Alessio S, Carlo L, Giulia MC, Raffaele M. Advances in struvite precipitation technologies for nutrients removal and recovery from aqueous waste and wastewater. Review. Sustainability. 2020:12; 7538.
  23. 23. Quintana M, Colmenarejo MF, Barrera J, García G, García E, Bustos A. Use of bioproduct of magnesium oxide production to precipitate phosphorus and nitrogen as struvite from wastewater treatment liquors. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 2004:52; 294-299.
  24. 24. Quintana M, Sánchez E, Colmenarejo MF, Barrera J, García G, Borja R. Kinetics of phosphorus removal and struvite formation by the utilization of by-product of magnesium oxide production. Chemical Engineering Journal. 2005:111; 45-52.
  25. 25. Jaffer Y, Clark TA, Pearce P, Parson SA. Potential phosphorus recovery by struvite formation. Water Research. 2002:36; 1834-1842.
  26. 26. Korchef A, Saidou H, Amor MB. Phosphate recovery through struvite precipitation by CO2 removal: Effect of magnesium, phosphate and ammonium concentrations. Journal of Hazardous Materials. 2011: 186; 602-613.
  27. 27. Chauhan CK, Vyas PM, Joshi MJ. Growth and characterization of Struvite-K crystals. Crystal Research and Technology. 2011: 46(2): 187-194.
  28. 28. Mathew BYM, Schroeder LW. 1979. Crystal structure of a struvite analogue, MgKPO4:6H20. Acta Crystallographica Section B. 1979:35: 11-13.
  29. 29. Chi Z, Kangning Xu, Min Z, Jiyun Li, Chengwen W. Factors affecting the crystal size of struvite-k formed in synthetic urine using a stirred reactor. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research. 2018:57; 17301-17309.
  30. 30. Caravaca F, Lax A, Albaladejo J. Organic matter, nutrient contents and cation exchange capacity in fine fractions from semiarid calcareous soils. Geoderma. 1999: 93; 161-196.
  31. 31. Schjonning P, Christensen BT, Carstensen B. Physical and chemical properties of a sandy loam receiving animal manure, mineral fertilizer or no fertilizer for 90 years. European Journal of Soil Science. 1994:45; 257-268.
  32. 32. Zheng W, Zhang M, Liu Z, Zhou H, Lu H, Zhang W, Yang Y, Li C, Chen B. Combining controlled-release urea and normal urea to improve the nitrogen use efficiency and yield under wheat-maize double cropping system. Field Crops Research. 2016: 197; 52-62.
  33. 33. Timilsena YP, Adhikari R, Casey P, Muster T, Gill H, Adhikari B. Enhanced efficiency fertilisers: A review of formulation and nutrient release patterns. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture. 2015: 95; 1131-1142.
  34. 34. Jat RA, Wani SP, Sahrawat KL, Singh P, Dhaka S, Dhaka B. Recent approaches in nitrogen management for sustainable agricultural production and eco-safety. Archives of Agronomy and Soil Science. 2012: 58; 1033-1060.
  35. 35. Geng J, Ma Q, Zhang M, Li C, Liu Z, Lyu X, Zheng W. Synchronized relationships between nitrogen release of controlled release nitrogen fertilizers and nitrogen requirements of cotton. Field Crops Research. 2015: 184; 9-16.

Written By

Endar Hidayat and Hiroyuki Harada

Submitted: 01 July 2021 Reviewed: 24 August 2021 Published: 12 September 2021