The global phenomenon of population ageing is both complex and multi-layered. We know at a global level that different countries are progressing towards becoming aged societies at different rates. We know that within national borders some regions, mainly rural, are affected by ageing more than others. We also know the health and social care systems struggle to respond effectively to ageing because it is complex and, often, runs counter to the structural design of healthcare systems with their emphasis on clinical and organ-specific problems. Ageing challenges these conventional approaches and is compounded by the prevalence of wide-spread ageism at the societal and systemic levels. Therefore, if we are to adapt to population ageing and care for older people effectively, we need to better understand them and their situational contexts. This includes where they live and how their social, biological and clinical trajectories are progressing. Synthesising this kind of multi-layered information also presents challenges because many health and social care systems operate in silos, with limited information exchanges and limited service coordination. One strategy is the concept of a visuospatial data-informed approach. Here we present a conceptual basis for this approach drawn from our work in the Australian health and ageing contexts.
- data visualisation
The global phenomenon of population ageing is both complex and multi-layered. We know at a global level that different countries are progressing towards becoming aged societies at different rates . We know that within national borders some regions, mainly rural, are affected by ageing more than others, especially as younger people leave for urban opportunities in education and employment . We also know the health and social care systems struggle to respond effectively to ageing because it is complex, sometimes messy and, often, it runs counter to the structural design of healthcare systems with their emphasis on specific clinical and organ-specific problems (e.g. heart, lung, kidney, brain etc.). In this context, it is or certainly should be seen as a driver for systemic change.
Ageing challenges these conventional approaches and is compounded by the prevalence of wide-spread ageism at the societal and systemic levels . Therefore, if we are to adapt to population ageing and care for older people effectively, we need to better understand them and their situational contexts. This includes where they live and how their social, biological and clinical trajectories are progressing. Synthesising this kind of multi-layered information also presents challenges because many health and social care systems operate in silos, with limited information exchanges and equally limited service coordination. One approach, explored here, is the concept of a visuospatial data-informed approach. In this paper we present a conceptual basis for this and outline a data visualisation project the authors have developed to address some of these complexities. The data and analysis presented are specific to the Australian context, but we anticipate the applications could be readily modified for other countries.
2. Trends in population ageing
It has become something of a truism to note that populations are ageing globally, which does not diminish the scale of this phenomenon. It is also the case that even within countries, population ageing tends to be unevenly patterned. In many countries, rural populations are ageing faster than urban areas due to out-migration as well as economic factors, climate change, service availability and so on . In the Australian context, this issue can be seen in the way population ageing is moving differentially across states and territories. Major urban areas such as Melbourne, Sydney and Brisbane are less prone to overall ageing because they are major immigration intake centres but even then, specific areas may age faster than others . In other words, the general trend of population ageing can vary by speed and location. This makes it a complicated phenomenon to respond to in health and social care environments because planning and response mechanisms are often slow, while infrastructure funding and construction cycles can run to decades.
3. Demography and destiny
The distribution and composition of the Australian population is highly variable. Across the country, local and state/territory populations are ageing at different rates and on different spatial and temporal trajectories. Current conditions indicate that some major urban areas will have increasing numbers of older people, but the proportions will be lower than many regional and rural areas where outmigration is already a problem. Such conditions may be exacerbated by other factors such as climate change . In addition, Australia already has a pattern of migration away from major urban centres by ‘younger’ retirees, as people seek lifestyle changes and/or lower cost of living situations . These sea-changers can have their own impact on smaller coastal settlements for example, as they buy property, invest and consume goods and services. Such patterns are likely to change as these people age in situ and later the local need for home support services, general medical and specialist medical care . Thus, the epidemiological patterns associated with ageing bring their own challenges to these sea change locations.
4. Epidemiological considerations
While demography is a major driver of epidemiology in general, it is also a powerful influence on factors such as shifting patterns of chronic disease and late-life acute care demands . These can range from the complexities associated with co-morbidities through to the relatively predictable consequences of fall-related injuries in community-dwelling older people . Some of these epidemiological phenomena are distinctly age-related (e.g. macular degeneration) and others can be seen as a consequence of current systemic and clinical arrangements.
As we have noted elsewhere , population ageing is characterised by rising
Our knowledge of the complex interactions between, for example, a dementia diagnosis and a mix of sensory and physical impairments is well-developed but continues to grow in scope . Conventional models, often based on younger age cohorts, of living with a particular condition are inadequate for managing the twin concerns of population ageing and rising chronic disease, a pattern no longer restricted to the more affluent economies . Data from projects such as the Global Burden of Disease Study (GBD) illustrate the consequences of these convergent circumstances in increasing detail . In addition, the development of a variety of international ageing studies and, more specifically, centenarian research projects, have illustrated just how variable these patterns can be, not only between countries but within them as well. Our position here is that our knowledge about age and ageing is still highly developmental and, consequently, improving our capacity to model and respond to particular conditions can only grow in importance (Figures 1 and 2).
The two figures above show the fast-growing urban area of greater Melbourne is likely to experience a decrease in the proportion of people with a dementia between 2020 and 2032, even as the numbers of older people continue to grow. This visual environment, backed by quantitative data, tables and associated analytical tools, provides the service planner with a clearer understanding of where and how resources might be better allocated between 2020 and 2032. And of course, if a new Census improves and alters our understanding of population dynamics, that data can be added to the Power BI environment and alterations made accordingly. This approach has the power to greatly improve planning for both shorter and longer-term resources, from workforce needs such as specialist dementia care nursing staff through to where new aged care facilities would be best located sustainably.
5. Service provision and service providers
There are two general considerations in relation to service providers identified here. The first is the issue of
An additional consideration is the skills of the available workforce and how evenly or unevenly skilled workers are distributed relative to current and emerging need. Currently, the demand for clinical and personal care staff is growing at pace in health, aged and disability services . However, getting workers to take employment across areas of geographic need is another matter entirely. In Australia, this issue is especially problematic and remains unresolved. How then do we incorporate many, or all, of these factors in a single data environment? How do we ‘capture’ the complexities associated with these varied interactions and their dynamic nature? Even if we can achieve this sophistication in our modelling, it is no guarantee that policies and funding will necessarily flow in the right direction – but without it, there is a finite evidence base for prioritisation, planning and the evaluation of funded service provision.
6. Modelled data elements
While the data elements included in this model are limited, this is not to say that the model or the modelling process in necessarily as finite as presented. By this we mean that additional variables or measures can be added as can new data sets or related inputs, such as service providers by type and classification. The point here is that in order to address the issues identified above, we have undertaken a selection process with a view to establishing a base model of the geography of population ageing in Australia and its key correlates.
These data elements identified include:
population estimates and projections by age and sex for the period 2017–2032, based on official data releases from the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW, 2019);
estimated prevalence rates for three dementia sub-type categories – Alzheimer’s disease (AD), vascular dementia (VaD) and the mixed dementias (a category being reassessed at regular intervals as our research and data-informed knowledge grows);
sub-type severity estimates including mild, moderate and severe with a view to identifying the type and level of resource needed to support such individuals in the community;
key health service providers such as acute care hospitals and residential aged care facilities.
These data were connected using the Microsoft Power BI data visualisation software package (https://powerbi.microsoft.com/en-us). All data sets were either geocoded on access or integrated into a spatial frame of references so that the data visualisation capabilities of Power BI permitted the user to see all data elements in a spatial or map-like context. This essentially means that the user can explore, using the zoom function, the whole country on down to a particular state or territory and then to even smaller areas such as a city or local suburb. At every point, because of this geographically enabled data architecture, the data viewed is consistent with the scale at which the user views it.
7. Data visualisation
We make a distinction here between spatial analysis, of the kind conducted using geographic information systems software, and spatial data visualisation. The first relates to specialist software environments that provide a variety of spatial analysis tools and produce explicitly spatial data analyses. In this instance, we focus instead on the latter concept of spatial data visualisation of the kind available within current data visualisation software environments including, for example, Tableau and Microsoft Power BI. While the capabilities of these two software types may appear similar, their actual applications tend to differ at the present time. There is the perhaps obvious likelihood that these environments may become increasingly similar over time as, in particular, data visualisation software providers add a growing range of spatial analysis capabilities to their packages. In addition, many GIS providers are shifting to dashboard and dashboard-like capabilities as well (e.g. ESRI’s ArcGIS).
These results are developmental and intended to illustrate both the importance and viability of managing the concerns discussed above in an accessible visual data environment. One of the considerations we had in approaching this effort was to develop resources that could support researchers and service providers from different backgrounds. Thus, a key principle of the data visualisation is to provide a mutually intelligible information environment that can be used and enhanced to meet the needs of groups whose interests may all be focused on aged care but who come from different backgrounds (e.g. planners versus clinicians) and who may have different priorities. For practical purposes, we have used the Microsoft Power BI data visualisation software in this discussion. A key result here is all data included are accessible within the one ‘frame’ of inquiry but also, each data element can be reviewed separately. This provides a flexible basis of data inquiry and analysis for different types of user and their associated purposes (Figure 3).
The dashboard below illustrates how geographic location, year (past, current and projected), dementia estimates and likely severity (mild, moderate and severe) can all be modelled within the same visual environment. The severity measure gives a sense of the relationship between prevalence and likely clinical and support service need as the dementias tend to be progressive in nature. The estimate of
Each data element can be examined more closely by separating it out from the dashboard for inspection. Thus, the map above shows the location of healthcare facilities within the same area currently visualised. This is also scalable so different users in the greater Melbourne area can inquire on their own particular area of interest or zoom out to explore the spatial relations between their local picture and a larger geographic catchment.
8.1 Small area visualisation
In this data visualisation model, the smallest official geography for which we had data available was the Statistical Area 2 (SA2) level of the official Australian Standard Geographical Classification (ASGC) (https://www.abs.gov.au/websitedbs/D3310114.nsf/home/Australian+Standard+Geographical+Classification+(ASGC)). The Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) does provide some data at smaller areas but only under more confidential data access conditions. Also, all of the data sources utilised here were available at the SA2 level, so they were fully compatible at that geographic level. This simplifies the data structuring and integration processes as well as providing a quick and consistent data analysis and visualisation environment. The issue of speed means that new data at the same geographic level can easily be integrated to update and improve modelling capabilities.
What this means is that small areas can be selected and examined in closer detail to explore particular epidemiological and/or service provider issues or concerns. This is useful for, say, a hospital service planner, a residential aged care service developer, or a provider of in-home support services. They can all examine the same consistent visual data environment at the same or different geographic levels, as required, to anticipate and plan for both population-level needs and business potential. Potentially, small area modelling below the SA2 level could be developed but we have not attempted that here at this time, as a key requirement for such work would be to examine a specific problem or concern of service planners, for example. Nonetheless, several individual SA2s can be selected, highlighted and examined to explore their similarities and differences. This means that smaller ‘catchment’ areas can be produced by individual users.
Figure 5, above, provides a brief illustration of this segmentation approach that permits the user to explore a specific catchment area in more detail. An additional benefit is that by selecting this region in the dashboard, the relevant data for that catchment is explicitly shown only for the relevant SA2s in that catchment. If this was not adequate for a particular purpose, such as plotting a series of patient home visits, the same data can readily be exported to a geographic information systems (GIS) software environment to permit route planning, for example. Thus, both scalability and interoperability are facilitated by the core data visualisation strategy.
9. Implications and limitations
It is necessary to emphasise here that this modelling approach is incomplete, as is any model of a complex existing environment in which the full scope of relevant causal and influencing factors may be unknown. This can be seen as a sub-set of the ongoing
In this example, the visualisation is not a fixed or static attempt to describe a known complex situation, in this case dementia prevalence and its impacts, but for the visualisation
For example, the currently available Australian Census data was collected in 2016 and is now quite dated (hence the use of more recent official projections data in this chapter). Assuming a high-quality Census is carried out in 2021, the resulting data will likely require modifications to this current visual environment. This is not the problem it might first appear, since a foundational concept in this modelling strategy is that of an ongoing and progressive updating and refinement process. The use of software such as Microsoft Power BI also means that this type of updating and adjustment can be quick and effective – taking far less time than traditional approaches. An implication of this is that users of the model can adapt their strategies, planning, programs and funding models accordingly. In this sense, the dynamism of the real world, which exists outside the computer-generated model, is more easily and quickly accommodated. This has obvious benefits for both service providers and their older clients since systemic adjustments and changes can be accelerated.
In this chapter we have discussed and illustrated some of the key concerns we see associated with progressive population-level ageing at the sub-national level in the Australian context and the value of a visuospatial data strategy in addressing these concerns. The differential geographic nature of population ageing across Australia means that age-related problems, such as the dementias and associated clinical and social support needs, have a level of complexity not currently manageable, in our view, by other, especially aspatial, means . The capacity illustrated here to connect spatial information to demography, epidemiology and service infrastructure (and allied information from service providers, such as pharmaceutical usage or financial performance), makes this complexity much more manageable in the current moment and into the foreseeable future. The kind of visual data environment illustrated here provides one approach but far from the only one. Many jurisdictions are already utilising visualisation techniques to make both data and its analysis more readily accessible to their audiences (e.g. https://www.census.gov/topics/population/older-aging/library/visualizations.html).
Key factors here include the scalable nature of the information visualisations shown – that is, the user can look at the national, state and even local area all within the same information framework and toggle between these ‘views’ to inform discussions, analysis, policy development and even service provision. Different service providers can be highlighted, or minimised, to explore different questions, and local data can be added to improve small area knowledge and understanding such as frailty . While much, if not most, of this current data is quantitative in nature, this does not preclude the inclusion of qualitative data or findings from qualitative analyses. In other words, this pilot model is potentially extensible in scale, temporality, and data types. Microsoft Power BI already has a text analytics capability (not explored by the researchers at this time) that could connect such analysis to the data architecture developed for this modelling exercise. That is, qualitative client or provider data could be connected directly to geography.
As well as being useful for the Australian situation, the concept is replicable elsewhere. In the context of global population ageing and the variable health and social care systems available to older people , this concept could be extended to inform these jurisdictions about how to more effectively manage age-related complexities. And while this might suit, for example, national government organisations in the first instance, the same capacity is potentially available to sub-national jurisdictions, municipal governments, direct care providers and not-for- profits or advocacy organisations. While we acknowledge that data visualisation is only as good as the data sources it relies on, the potential of these types of tools to improve the accessibility and efficiency of age-related care is considerable. As population ageing progresses, the position of this chapter is that such tools will become increasingly useful and relevant to ensure that the health and wellbeing of ageing populations is supported, and that established systems of care can be both sustainable and adaptive to shifting conditions.
Li J, Han X, Zhang X, Wang S. Spatiotemporal evolution of global population ageing from 1960 to 2017. BMC public health. 2019 Dec 1;19(1):127
Sabater A, Graham E, Finney N. The spatialities of ageing: Evidencing increasing spatial polarisation between older and younger adults in England and Wales. Demographic Research. 2017 Jan 1;36:731-44
Chang ES, Kannoth S, Levy S, Wang SY, Lee JE, Levy BR. Global reach of ageism on older persons’ health: A systematic review. PloS one. 2020 Jan 15;15(1): e0220857
Grundy EM, Murphy M. Population ageing in Europe. Oxford Textbook of Geriatric Medicine. 2017 Dec 14:11
Wilson T. The demographic constraints on future population growth in regional Australia. Australian geographer. 2015 Jan 2;46(1):91-111
Burkett E, Martin-Khan MG, Scott J, Samanta M, Gray LC. Trends and predicted trends in presentations of older people to Australian emergency departments: effects of demand growth, population aging and climate change. Australian Health Review. 2017 Jun 20;41(3):246-53
Atkins MT, Tonts M. Exploring cities through a population ageing matrix: A spatial and temporal analysis of older adult population trends in Perth, Australia. Australian Geographer. 2016 Jan 2;47(1):65-87
Keough B, Edwards M. Amenity Migration, Aging, and the Environment. Spaces & Flows: An International Journal of Urban & Extra Urban Studies. 2016 Apr 1;7(2)
Ben-Shlomo Y, Cooper R, Kuh D. The last two decades of life course epidemiology, and its relevance for research on ageing. International journal of epidemiology. 2016 Aug 1;45(4):973-88
Sherrington C, Fairhall N, Wallbank G, Tiedemann A, Michaleff ZA, Howard K, Clemson L, Hopewell S, Lamb S. Exercise for preventing falls in older people living in the community: an abridged Cochrane systematic review. British journal of sports medicine. 2020 Aug 1;54(15):885-91
Robertson, H, Nicholas N. Rising multimorbidity in our ageing world Health Management, 2018 Aug 1;18(4):279-84
Hubbard RE, Peel NM, Scott IA, Martin JH, Smith A, Pillans PI, Poudel A, Gray LC. Polypharmacy among inpatients aged 70 years or older in Australia. Medical Journal of Australia. 2015 Apr;202(7):373-7
Kendig H, McDonald P, Piggott J. Population ageing and Australia's future. ANU Press; 2016
Hwang PH, Longstreth Jr WT, Brenowitz WD, Thielke SM, Lopez OL, Francis CE, DeKosky ST, Fitzpatrick AL. Dual sensory impairment in older adults and risk of dementia from the GEM Study. Alzheimer's & Dementia: Diagnosis, Assessment & Disease Monitoring. 2020;12(1):e12054
Arokiasamy P, Uttamacharya U, Jain K, Biritwum RB, Yawson AE, Wu F, Guo Y, Maximova T, Espinoza BM, Rodríguez AS, Afshar S. The impact of multimorbidity on adult physical and mental health in low-and middle-income countries: what does the study on global ageing and adult health (SAGE) reveal?. BMC medicine. 2015 Dec 1;13(1):178
Chang AY, Skirbekk VF, Tyrovolas S, Kassebaum NJ, Dieleman JL. Measuring population ageing: an analysis of the global burden of disease study 2017. The Lancet Public Health. 2019 Mar 1;4(3):e159-67
Britnell M. Human: solving the global workforce crisis in healthcare. Oxford University Press; 2019 Mar 18
Mathen, J. On the inherent incompleteness of scientific theories. Activitas Nervosa Superior, 2011; 53(1), 44-100
Jonsson O, Frögren J, Haak M, Slaug B, Iwarsson S. Understanding the Wicked Problem of Providing Accessible Housing for the Ageing Population in Sweden. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2021 Jan;18(3):1169
Yang HJ. Visualizing spatial disparities in population aging in the Seoul Metropolitan Area. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space.: 0308518X20984167
Taylor D, Barrie H, Lange J, Thompson MQ, Theou O, Visvanathan R. Geospatial modelling of the prevalence and changing distribution of frailty in Australia–2011 to 2027. Experimental Gerontology. 2019 Aug 1;123:57-65
Taylor D, Barrie H, Lange J, Thompson MQ, Theou O, Visvanathan R. Geospatial modelling of the prevalence and changing distribution of frailty in Australia–2011 to 2027. Experimental gerontology. 2019 Aug 1;123:57-65
Dyer SM, Valeri M, Arora N, Ross T, Winsall M, Tilden D, Crotty M Review of International Systems for Long-Term Care of Older People. Flinders University, Adelaide, Australia, 2019