RE doping concentration.
Effects of ionizing irradiation on defect creation processes have been studied in rare earth (RE)-doped (RE = Sm, Gd, Eu, Ce, Nd) aluminoborosilicate glass with use of the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and optical spectroscopy. As a function of RE ion nature, we observe that doping significantly influences the nature of the defects produced during irradiation and more specifically the relative proportions between hole and electron defect centers. Strong decrease of defect production efficiency under ionizing radiation independence on both the RE doping content and on the relative stability of the RE different oxidation states is also clearly revealed. The results could be explained by dynamical reversible trapping of the electron-hole pairs produced during irradiation on the different RE charge states as well as by RE segregation and pre-existing defects speciation in ABS glass structure.
Irradiation effects are an active research field in amorphous silica (aSiO2) due to many technological applications requiring a good maintenance of transparency (e.g. fibers, laser optics and radioactive environments) [1, 2, 3, 4]. Indeed for aSiO2, the optical properties are controlled by the nature and the content of defect produced during an ionizing radiation (laser, X, γ, electrons) [5, 6, 7]. Different works using Electron Paramagnetic Spectroscopy (EPR) and optical absorption have shown that two different defects production processes occur during ionizing irradiation. The first process called intrinsic defects production [8, 9, 10] is correlated to Si–O bonds breaking leading to well-known paramagnetic E′ and Non-Bridging Oxygen Hole Centers (NBOHC) with self-trap excitons acting as possible precursors [11, 12, 13]. Peroxy radicals (POR) paramagnetic defect can also be produced with intrinsic process by the displacement of oxygen into an interstitial position like Frenkel defects [12, 14]. The second defect creation process is called “extrinsic” and is correlated to the presence of different impurities (H, Cl, Transition metals, Rare earth, …) inside aSiO2 materials [8, 15, 16, 17, 18]. In that case, the nature of different possible irradiation paramagnetic defects produced (E′, NBOHC, and POR) does not differ but an higher defect production efficiency is observed associated to saturation processes of defect content depending on impurities nature and content, respectively . Defects production processes in aSiO2 are therefore mainly controlled by the nature and the content of the different impurities.
For more complex oxide glass compositions, the presence of network modifiers ions (Na+, K+, Ca2+) and other network formers ions (B3+, Al3+) stabilizes with an high efficiency different hole trap like Boron-Oxygen Hole Center (BOHC) [20, 21], Aluminum-Oxygen Hole Center (AlOHC)  or Hole trapped defects on Non-Bridging Oxygen (NBO) called HC1, HC2 centers [23, 24]. In addition, the literature shows that the content of electron trap defects like E′ centers and equivalent defects closed to B3+ (BEC center) and Al3+ ions are generally much more lower than hole trap defects content for all oxide glass compositions including silica. Electron trapping on glass impurities like Hydrogen, alkaline, Transition Metals (TM), or Rare Earth (RE) ions could explain differences between the content of hole and electron trapped defects produced during exposure to ionizing radiation [7, 15]. In general for oxide glasses like borosilicate, silicate, and aluminosilicate, the nature and content of different paramagnetic defects observed by EPR spectroscopy will depend on the relative proportion of different network formers (Si4+, Al3+, and B3+) and on network modifiers contents introduced inside the oxide glass. In case of aluminoborosilicate (ABS) glasses studied in this work, the nature and proportion of different paramagnetic defects have been previously determined using the simulation of EPR spectra of different β-irradiated borosilicate glass samples .
Doping processes of oxide glasses with rare earth (RE) ions influence a lot the nature and the content of different paramagnetic defects produced during exposure to ionizing radiation. In case of Sm- , Gd- , and Yb-  doped borosilicate glass compositions, the first effect of doping is the decrease of total paramagnetic defect contents produced during irradiation to one integrated dose. Moreover for Fe-doped soda-lime glasses  and Cr-doped silicate glasses , a complete disappearance of the different paramagnetic defects is observed for doping level around 1 mol. %. Associated to the decrease of paramagnetic defects production efficiency with the doping ion content, the decrease of different structural changes under irradiation detected by Raman spectroscopy [29, 30], (increase of polymerization and the molecular oxygen production, and decrease of Si–O–Si average angle) are also observed at integrated dose higher than 109 Gy. Structural changes in glasses under the effect of ionizing radiation are mainly controlled by alkaline mobility in both network modifiers and charge compensator positions . This result shows therefore strong relationships between the nature and contents of doping ions, irradiation defects creation processes, and the structural changes due to ionizing radiation exposure in oxide glasses.
However, these previous studies have mainly focused on the modification of the total paramagnetic defect concentration produced during ionizing radiation as a function of the doping ion nature and content. The goal of this chapter is to systematically present the paramagnetic irradiation defect creation processes in rare earth-doped oxide glasses. First, the influence of RE doping ion nature on the relative paramagnetic defect proportion observed by EPR spectroscopy in the same ABS glass composition will be considered. Then, the influence of both doping ion content and integrated radiation dose on the nature, content, and relative proportion of the different paramagnetic defects produced during ionizing radiation will be considered also. It is known, that the optical spectroscopy is most useful in cases where EPR techniques are not applicable and for diamagnetic defects. Also, transmission and luminescence experiments will be carried out in order to provide additional information on RE doping effect on ABS glass structure. This approach could improve our knowledge about defect creation processes under irradiation for ion doped oxide glasses. For that purpose, different RE-doped ABS glasses (RE = Sm, Gd, Eu, Ce, and Nd where the RE doping level between 0.1 and 1 mol. %) have been irradiated to different doses between 105 and 2 × 109 Gy using a Van de Graaff accelerator.
2. Experimental part
Rare earth-doped ABS glasses were prepared by adding to the base glass with the following composition—59.77% SiO2, 4.00% Al2O3, 22.41% B2O3, 12.12% Na2O, and 1.70% ZrO2 (in mol. %)—different amounts of doping ions. The doping content of RE oxide considered in this work is shown in Table 1. The dried mixed powders were heated at 750°C for 10 h in air in a Pt crucible and melted at 1500°C for 2 h, then quenched on a copper plate. Before cutting, annealing at 500°C for 1–2 h was necessary to remove the internal stress. Samples were polished on a hand grinding wheel with a silicon carbide abrasive having the average grain size of 10 μm (1000 grain) to achieve the average thickness of 0.56 ± 0.05 mm. Each glass was analyzed by X-ray diffraction, in order to confirm the amorphous characteristics of the glass.
All glasses were β-irradiated with 2.5 MeV electrons (10 μA) provided by a Van de Graaff accelerator (LSI, Palaiseau, France) at different integrated doses from 106 to 2 × 109 Gy. The used sample thickness made it possible to obtain uniform irradiation on the entire glass volume. EPR measurements were conducted at room temperature on a X band (ν = 9.420 GHz) EMX Brücker EPR spectrometer using a 100 kHz field modulation, 3 × 10−4 Tesla of amplitude modulation and an applied microwave power of 1 mW. The EPR spectra of all irradiated RE-doped ABS glasses have been normalized to the same receiver gain and to a 100 mg sample weight. Paramagnetic defects total content has been estimated by the area under the defect absorbance EPR spectrum. A maximum error of 10% has been considered in this work taking into account uncertainties in the irradiated glass samples weight measurement, the sample positioning inside spectrometer cavity and defect absorbance EPR spectrum area computation or EPR line intensity measurement. The optical transmission spectra were measured on an Agilent Varian Cary 5000 spectrophotometer in 1 nm steps in the range of 200–1500 nm. The photoluminescence was analyzed by a SHAMROCK spectrograph F5303 mm: 150 lines/mm grating and a 400 mm slit combined with an ANDOR Istar (Andor Company, Belfast, U.K.) intensified charge coupled device. The 266 nm wavelength pulses width of around 8 ns and laser repetition rate of 10 Hz of an INDI Nd:YAG pulsed laser spectra physics were used for the PL excitation. The laser beam is transported via two mirrors, two lenses, and three diaphragms to the sample center with a final diameter of 2 mm. The pulse energy on the sample was ~2 mJ/pulse. The spectral measurements were carried out using different delay time (d) and gate width (G).
3. EPR spectra of RE-doped ABS glass: b-irradiation dose effect
Without doping, the nature of the different defects produced by ionizing radiation has been previously studied in the non-doped ABS glass composition irradiated with 2.5 MeV electrons by the simulation of the EPR spectra of irradiated samples annealed at different temperatures . The EPR of the non-doped ABS glass irradiated at 1.3 × 108 Gy is presented in Figure 1. The main component of these EPR spectra is associated to the hyperfine structure with 11B (I = 3/2). The defect is called the Boron-Oxygen Hole Center (BOHC) (g1 = 2.0029, g2 = 2.0115, and g3 = 2.0500) and it is attributed to a hole trap on an oxygen link to a boron atom . The second hole center for this glass composition that can be observed at high annealing temperature is the peroxy radical (Si–O–O°) named Oxy defect (g1 = 2.0024, g2 = 2.0110, and g3 = 2.0439) in the literature for silicate glasses . The last hole center determined by the simulation of the EPR spectra for this glass composition is the HC1 center attributed to a hole trapped on a non-bridging oxygen in the vicinity of alkaline ion. Finally, the EPR line around g = 2.0011 is an electron trap and is attributed to the well-known E′ center .
Figure 1 presents the EPR spectra recorded at room temperature of the non-doped and 0.1 mol% RE-doped ABS glasses (RE = Sm, Gb, Eu, Nd, and 0.2 mol% Ce) irradiated with 2.5 MeV electrons (integrated dose of 1.3 × 108 Gy). First, It can be observed clearly on that figure that RE doping at low level (0.1 mol%) influences significantly both the amount of defect produced during irradiation and their relative proportions. More specifically, a decrease of the different hole centers (HC) is analyzed depending on the nature of the doping ion ([HC]Eu > [HC]Sm > [HC]Nd > [HC]Ce). This effect is maximum for 0.2 mol% Ce-doped glasses where the content of hole centers is drastically decreasing in comparison with the non-doped glass composition. For E′ center detected at g = 2.0011 in the non-doped ABS glass, a strong increase as a function of the RE doping ion nature is observed ([E′]Eu < [E′]Sm < [E′]Nd < [E′]Ce). However, for all ABS glass compositions studied, the quantity of electron defect centers (E′) remains smaller than the hole defect centers (BOHC, OXY, HC1) showing therefore the presence of other mechanisms acting as traps for the electrons produced during irradiation.
Evolution of the total paramagnetic defect content for all RE-doped glasses (RE = Sm, Gd, Eu, Nd, and Ce) as a function of the integrated dose is presented in logarithmic scales on Figure 2 for two different RE doping levels: 0.1 and 1 mol%, on Figure 2a and b, respectively.
For non-doped ABS glass, the total defect concentration is increasing with the integrated dose. This behavior can be correlated with extrinsic and/or intrinsic defect creation processes under the effect of ionizing radiation . Two effects can be observed in Figure 2a and b. First, the decrease of the defect produced during irradiation at one integrated dose depending on the nature of the RE doping ion. The second effect is saturation behavior of the defect content as a function of the integrated dose associated to a decrease of the defect content at higher doses for all RE-doped glasses. We can therefore conclude that glass doping processes play an important role on defect creation processes under the effect of ionizing radiation.
4. EPR spectra of RE-doped ABS glass: RE concentration effect
The influence of RE content on defect production under irradiation is shown in Figure 3a and b for two different integrated doses. For all RE doping considered in this work, the defect content is decreasing as a function of the RE doping content inside the glass but with different efficiency depending on the RE nature.
In addition, the relative proportions between the different paramagnetic defects observed by EPR spectroscopy are modified by both the nature of the RE ion and also its content in the host glasses. These effects can be seen on Figures 4
When comparing these results with Eu-doping in the same ABS glass composition, similar effects of doping ion content on defect production efficiency are observed by EPR spectroscopy (Figure 5). But in the case of Eu-doping, a strong decrease of E′ centers contribution in the defect EPR spectra can be seen (Figure 5a). The E′ center becomes undetectable in the EPR spectra at Europium doping levels higher than 0.6 mol.% and the hole defects re-arrangement in the EPR spectra between OXY and BOHC centers can be observed. The highest irradiation dose results in more re-arrangement of hole defects as can be seen from Figure 5b (arrows in the Figure 5b). The influence of Sm- (Figure 6) and Nd- (Figure 7) doping contents are weaker than for Ce-doped ABS glasses for both the decrease in defect production efficiencies and the changes in the relative proportions of defects composing the EPR spectra of these irradiated glass samples. However, a decrease in the relative proportion of the different defect holes centers (BOHC, Oxy, HC1) for the different Nd-doped ABS glasses (Figure 7) can be observed.
This effect could also be correlated to the evolution analyzed for Ce-doped ABS glasses. The changes of the relative proportions of defect as a function of Sm-doping content in ABS glasses (Figure 6) show mainly the decrease of E′ defect component in the EPR spectra. Associated to this decrease, an increase in the relative proportion of OXY center relative to relative to BOHC defect is also detected.
The experiments testify that glass doping processes can influence the proportion between different defects produced during irradiation compared to the non-doped glass composition. This change has been usually correlated to the capacity of the doping ion to act as a trap for the holes and electrons produced during irradiation. Eu3+ ions are known to be good electron traps and one can observe on Figures 1 and 5a the strong decrease of the E′ proportion relatively to the non-doped ABS glasses. Sm3+ ion can also be reduced during the exposure to ionizing radiation but with a weaker efficiency than Eu3+ ions, this effect is also observed on the decrease of the relative proportion of E′ centers in the defect EPR spectra (Figures 1 and 6). By contrast, Ce3+ ions produced during irradiation or during the synthesis of Ce-doped glasses is a well-known hole traps [32, 33]. So these ions (Eu3+, Sm3+, and Ce3+) can therefore compete with the hole trap defects production as represented for Eu-, Sm-, and Ce-doped ABS glasses. Relative proportion between hole and electron defects in the EPR spectra of irradiated RE-doped ABS glasses can be considered as a parameter for the estimation of the interaction of doping ions with the ionizing radiation.
However, other parameters can influence the nature of the different defects produced during irradiation and more specifically the speciation of the RE ions inside the host glasses. Indeed, some authors like Li and coworkers have studied the solubility and the environment of gadolinium in borosilicate glass compositions [34, 35]. They show that this RE ion is preferentially located in the vicinity of boron network former. According to literature, this RE ion is not therefore homogeneously distributed inside glass. This result influence strongly the EPR spectra of irradiated Gd-doped ABS glasses (Figure 1) where the defect EPR spectrum is broad and not resolved due to dipole-dipole interaction between BOHC centers and paramagnetic Gd3+ ions. This effect could also explain the evolution of the EPR spectra of Eu-doped ABS glasses (Figures 5a and 5b) as a function of doping ion content. This figure shows both decrease of the relative proportion of BOHC and E′ centers contributions in the defect EPR spectra. As Eu ions can be considered as an electron trap, the changes in relative proportion between OXY and BOHC defects shown in Figure 6a could show Eu speciation in the vicinity of boron network former. In order to understand the RE doping influence on defect production under ionizing radiation, Magic Angle Spinning Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MAS NMR) of 11B could be a way for studying as a function of RE nature in glasses, their possible influence on BOHC defect production.
The second influence of RE doping inside ABS glasses concerns the efficiency of defect production as a function of both nature of the doping ions and its content (Figure 3). The decrease of paramagnetic defects concentration can be due to the fact that the electron-hole pairs produced during ionizing radiation can support dynamical balance between the two different charge states of RE ions (REn + 1 + (h°/e−) = > REn + h° = > REn + 1 or REn + (h°/e−) = > REn + 1 + e− = > REn). Therefore, this process efficiency of defect production can be correlated to the stability of different oxidation states for different RE ions. Moreover, it is known that increase of the dopant content up to 1 mol.% in highly irradiated (3 × 109 Gy) Fe3+- and Cr3+-doped glasses may lead to the complete disappearance of the defect EPR spectrum [29, 30]. But it is necessary to take into consideration the Fe3+ (Cr3+) ions dipole-dipole interaction effect on the defect EPR spectrum. In that case, the disappearance or decrease of defect EPR spectrum in the doped glasses as a function of doping ion content could also be associated with heterogeneous speciation of defects produced during exposure to ionizing radiation in the vicinity of doping ions.
For all RE doping ABS glasses considered in this work, saturation behavior of defect EPR spectra is analyzed as the function of the integrated dose. This result is explained by the strong efficiency of the dynamical trapping processes of electron-hole pairs on different redox states of RE doping ions with respect to the defect production efficiency under the effect of ionizing radiation in this ABS glass. In addition in Figure 2a and b, the defect content is decreasing in some cases at integrated doses higher than 5 × 108 Gy. Structural changes were observed for irradiated glass samples at doses around 109 Gy due to the effect of ionizing radiation and might be correlated to the alkaline migration . The decrease of defect content at higher doses could therefore show an important role of precursor defect on the alkaline migration processes leading to glass structural changes.
5. Optical spectra: Effect of RE doping on defect band
The available structural information on defects in glass was derived mainly from the results of electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectrometry. It should be noticed that this method is directly applicable only to the subclass of defects which are paramagnetic. A more formidable problem is the pre-existing intrinsic point defects, which are not of paramagnetic nature. Examples of intrinsic diamagnetic defects believed to occur in silica glass include neutral oxygen vacancies (≡Si-Si≡), two-coordinated silicone (O–Si–O–), and peroxy linkages (≡Si–O–O–Si≡) . The most common extrinsic defects are associated with hydroxyl and chloride impurities . It is obvious that the defect designation in multicomponent glasses is extremely complex. Thus, the combined information obtained from EPR- and optical (absorption and photoluminescence (PL)) spectra can give an additional data on the structure of the glasses and of the pre-existing/radiation-induced imperfections. Often some defects can provide large EPR signal but the induced optical extinction (transmission loss) is very low and vice versa.
A compendium of EPR/optical correlations was reported in the literature [36, 37] and pointed to the most likely origins of many defect-related optical absorption bands in the visible, ultraviolet, and vacuum-ultraviolet spectral regions. But the assignment of the bands is still controversial in some cases. In this section, some preliminary results on optical study of pristine and irradiated ABS glass doped with RE ions are presented.
Non-doped ABS glass has high ultraviolet transmission. No significant defect generation was detected (Figures 8 and 9, black line) in pristine glass. Only small transmission losses in the UV spectral region 230–240 nm were found (Figure 9) to be, it seems, connected with oxygen-deficient centers formed on the basis of silicon . Oxygen-deficient centers (ODC, “oxygen vacancies”) are the natural type of intrinsic defects in non-stoichiometric silicon dioxide . By the existence of these types of defect in silica optical and luminescent properties are defined as described in [38, 39]. The dominating opinion has been still to consider vacancies of bridging oxygen atoms as the precursors of radiation E′ centers [38, 39]. Thus, ODCs play the key role in E′ center formation and their concentrations in glass. In irradiated ABS glass (BK7 or Duran type) the silicon and boron related electron centers (SiEC and BEC are considered to be responsible for this absorption) . Also after irradiation with high dose (more than 109 Gy) some additional transmission losses can be observed in visible part of the spectra at ~360 and 600 nm (Figures 9 and 10, red line) caused by intrinsic radiation defect generation. In , these bands are attributed to the BOHC defects in ABS glass.
Photoluminescence (PL) was detected in both pristine and irradiated ABS glasses. As aforementioned in the spectra of pristine ABS glass the ODCs are displayed in the form of an absorption band at 230–240 nm. According to  ODSs emission is observed at 280 and 450 nm. Under excitation of forth harmonic of Nd:YAG laser (266 nm) we can see only the appearance of broad PL band at ~500 nm for both pristine (Figure 8, black line) and β-irradiated glass samples (Figure 8, red line). It should be noticed that the position, shape, width, and intensity of this band are different for these two glass samples (Figure 8).
Time-resolved luminescence measurements carried out with laser excitation (266 nm) revealed the variety of pre-existing point defects in ABS glass (Figure 10a) most of them are not identified and described in the literature on our opinion. For one exception: the band at 442 nm can be attributed to ODC which is consistent with data . Especially taking into account that β-irradiation terminates this emission completely as well as two others at 336 and 510 nm. At the same time the new one (540 nm (5.3 eV); perhaps attributed to NBOHC ) is arising but emission band at 490 nm is still observed with higher intensity in irradiated ABS glass (Figure 10b). It should be marked here that the band at 336 nm can be also assigned to the ODCs since as it is indicated in  “Si ODCs in the silica glass network are an ensemble of defects such as ‘oxygen vacancies’, which differ in local structural environment, i.e., in the symmetry and strength of the local crystalline fields around the ODC.” That is why the ODCs to be characterized by a rather wide variety of spectral characteristics.
The incorporation of RE ions into the ABS glass matrix affects its optical properties. The evolution of optical characteristics is discussed in frame of the non-bridging oxygen formation in the glass structure, as well as color centers as a function of the nature of the RE element. By increasing the number of Nd (Gd) ions in ABS glass, it is possible to observe a decrease in the number of non-bridging oxygen per silicon tetrahedron in the glass studied which is confirmed by the estimate of the optical band gap and the Raman spectroscopy data. The presence of two charge states of multivalent Eu and Ce ions having absorption in the UV region complicates the consideration of the effect of the processes on the observed change in the optical band gap energy. The effect of irradiation results in color centers content increase (observed as more intense brown coloration of the irradiated glass) in the following sequence, Nd < Gd < Sm = Eu < Ce. This evolution is reflected on the optical band gap narrowing . Figure 11 presents transmission and PL spectra of the highly Sm-doped (1 mol.%) pristine and irradiated ABS glass. Some transmission losses can be observed for pristine glass from Figure 12: firstly, due to the presence of Sm3+ ions in glass structure (sharp lines in the spectra) and secondly, due to the presence of ODCs (similar to the non-doped ABS glass, see Figure 8). The emission spectra consist of the well-known bands belonging to the Sm3+/Sm2+ ions and the broad band around 500 nm, attributed to the ODCs: intensity of this band decreases significantly by β-irradiation (Figure 11).
The transmission spectra of Gd-doped ABS glass do not change significantly in comparison with non-doped glass except the fact that no prominent transmission losses are observed at 360 and 600 nm in irradiated glass (Figure 12). Emission of ODCs are located in the visible part of PL spectra at ~500 nm as it was seen before for non-doped and Sm-doped ABS glass (Figures 8 and 11, respectively). It was shown  that this emission can also be excited by third harmonic of Nd:YAG laser (355 nm). Unfortunately, no information about ODCs optical characteristics could be obtained in Eu- or Ce-doped ABS glasses because of strong Eu2+, Ce3+/4+ absorption in the UV studied spectral region . It is clearly seen that the absorption and PL characteristics of ODCs in non-doped ABS glass, as well as in glass doped with Sm or Gd ions, are analogous to each other with the exception of unresolved PL bands structure in case of doping (Figure 13).
It was natural to suppose that we have similar types of defect. But for the moment it is not absolutely clear whether these ODCs have essentially different structure or whether they are the same vacancies with distorted environment. Moreover, the modified shape of the PL band can be consistent with the assumption about the effect of segregation of defects and impurities that can influence the variations of the spectral characteristics of the ODCs. In the previous section, the relative increase in the proportion of peroxy radicals (Si–O–O°: Oxy defects) with the Eu concentration as well of the Oxy and the HC1 (Si–O Na+) centers with Ce concentration (Figures 4 and 5) was reported. Probably it means that the structural model of the OXY and HC1 centers tightly depends on the structural model of the ODC and it is still open for discussion. As to our point of view observed experimental facts can be most naturally explained by segregation of impurities and defects in the glass network. The effect of selective incorporation of a RE dopant into the glass due to the heterogeneous glass structure, leading to a RE concentration dependent dopant displacement as well as concentration dependent optical and physical-chemical glass properties which was firstly mentioned in the 1970 . Then phase-separation model was suggested in order to explain structural evolution of RE-doped borosilicate glass [34, 35].
Analysis of the results presented allowed to draw a conclusion that due to RE speciation in the ABS glass structure and heterogeneous distribution between different environments RE doping affects strongly defect production (firstly, pre-existing defects). Additional studies on RE concentration dependent time-resolved luminescence ABS glass might be required.
6. Summary and outlook
The presented study has shown significant changes in defect creation processes under ionizing radiation in ABS glasses as a function of the nature and the content of different rare earth-doping ions (RE = Sm, Gd, Eu, Ce, and Nd). We observe first that doping processes influence significantly the nature of the different defect produced during ionizing radiation and more specifically the ratio between hole and electron defect centers observed by EPR spectroscopy. The specific role of RE doping ion acting as a hole or an electron trap could control the population of different defects produced during irradiation. The second result of doping is a strong decrease in defect production efficiency under the effect of ionizing radiation depending on both the RE doping content in the glass and on the relative stability of the RE different oxidation states. This result could be explained by dynamical reversible trapping of the electron-hole pairs produced during irradiation on the RE ions as well as by RE segregation and pre-existing defects speciation in ABS glass structure.
In order to understand the RE doping influence on defect production under the effect of ionizing radiation, Magic Angle Spinning Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MAS NMR) of 11B could be a way for studying as a function of RE nature in glasses and their possible influence on BOHC defect production.
I would like to thank Thierry Pouthier and Vincent Métayer for their contribution during external β-irradiation experiments. I do appreciate also to Dr. B. Boizot for stimulating my interest in this field and for pointing to my attention several interesting experimental problems as well as for many enlightening discussions.