Parameters of the two-mode mixing laser-plasma accelerator stage.
A multistage laser-plasma accelerator (LPA) driven by two mixing electromagnetic hybrid modes of a gas-filled capillary waveguide is presented. Plasma wakefields generated by a laser pulse comprising two mixing modes coupled to a metallic or dielectric capillary filled with gas provide us with an efficient accelerating structure of electrons in a substantially long distance beyond a dephasing length under the matching between a capillary radius and plasma density. For a seamless multistage structure of the capillary waveguide, the numerical model of the transverse and longitudinal beam dynamics of an electron bunch considering the radiation reaction and multiple Coulomb scattering effects reveals a converging behavior of the bunch radius and normalized emittance down to ∼1 nm level when the beam is accelerated up to 560 GeV in a 67 m length. This capability allows us to conceive a compact electron-positron linear collider providing with high luminosity of 1034 cm−2 s−1 at 1 TeV center-of-mass (CM) energy.
- future colliders
- lepton colliders
- laser-plasma accelerators
- multistage coupling
- CAN lasers
In the long-standing quest for the fundamental building blocks of nature, the so-called Standard Model of particle physics, energy frontier colliders have played a central role in the forefront research for matter and interactions. For future high-energy particle colliders to explore physics beyond the Standard Model, a proton-proton circular collider at energy of 100 TeV in a 100 km circumference or electron-positron linear collider with energy of the order of 1 TeV in a 30 km length is being considered around the world, exploiting the conventional technologies such as superconducting magnets or RF systems . In contrast to proton colliders that create clouds of debris, electron-positron colliders enable cleaner and more precision experiments of fundamental particle collisions. Nowadays, a diversity of electron-positron linear colliders is proposed as a potential application of advanced accelerator concepts , such as two beam accelerators, dielectric wakefield accelerators, beam-driven plasma wakefield accelerators, and laser-driven plasma wakefield accelerators , promising with much higher accelerating gradients than that of a conventional RF accelerator.
Laser-plasma accelerators (LPAs) [4, 5] can support a wide range of potential applications requiring high-energy and high-quality electron-positron beams. In particular, field gradients, energy conversion efficiency, and repetition rates are essential factors for practical applications such as compact free electron lasers [6, 7] and high-energy frontier colliders [8, 9]. Although LPAs provide enormous accelerating gradients, as high as 100 GV/m at the plasma density of 1018 cm−3, dephasing of relativistic electrons with respect to a correct acceleration phase of the plasma wakefield with the phase velocity that is smaller than the speed of light in vacuum, and energy depletion of the laser pulse limit the electron energy gain in a single stage. A straightforward solution to overcome the dephasing and pump depletion effects is to build a multistage accelerator comprising consecutive LPA stages  such that a final energy gain reaches the requirement of the beam energy without loss of the beam charge and qualities through a coupling segment where a fresh laser pulse is fed to continuously accelerate the particle beam from the previous stage. The propagation of laser pulses in plasmas is described by refractive guiding, in which the refractive index can be modified from the linear free space value mainly by relativistic self-focusing, ponderomotive channeling, and a preformed plasma channel . The self-guided LPA [11, 12, 13, 14] relies only on intrinsic effects of relativistic laser-plasma interactions such as relativistic self-focusing and ponderomotive channeling. On the other hand, the channel-guided LPA exploits a plasma waveguide with a preformed density channel [15, 16, 17] or a gas-filled capillary waveguide made of metallic or dielectric materials . The plasma waveguide is likely to propagate a single-mode laser pulse through a radially parabolic distribution of the refractive index and generates plasma waves inside the density channel, the properties of which are largely affected by a plasma density profile and laser power . In contrast with plasma waveguides, the capillary waveguide can guide the laser due to Fresnel reflection on the inner capillary wall, and plasma waves are generated in an initially homogeneous plasma, relying on neither laser power nor plasma density. The presence of the modal structure imposed by the boundary conditions at the capillary wall affects the propagation of a laser pulse through the capillary and thus the excitation of plasma waves inside the capillary. This characteristic allows us to control acceleration of electrons through the modal structure of the propagation of the laser pulse as long as the laser intensity on the capillary wall is kept below the material breakdown [20, 21].
In this paper, we present a novel scheme of a gas-filled capillary accelerator driven by a laser pulse formed from two-mode mixing of the capillary eigenmodes, so-called electromagnetic hybrid modes . Two coupled eigenmodes with a close longitudinal wave number can generate beating wakefields in the capillary. When the beating period is equal to the dephasing distance, the electrons experience the rectified accelerating field; thereby their energy gain can increase over many accelerating phases exceeding the linear dephasing limit and reach the saturation due to the energy depletion of a drive laser pulse in the single-stage LPA. For efficient acceleration of the electron-positron beam up to an extremely high energy such as TeV energies, the multistage accelerator comprising a series of plasma-filled capillary waveguides is a sound approach, in which the particle beam is injected into the initial stage at the right phase of the wakefield from the external injector and accelerated cumulatively in the consecutive accelerating phase of successive stages. For applications of extreme high-energy particle beams to TeV center-of-mass (CM) energy electron-positron linear colliders, minimizing the transverse normalized emittance of the beam particles is of essential importance to meet the requirement of the luminosity of the order of 1034 cm−2 s−1 at 1 TeV CM energy for the particle physics experiments . The numerical model on the bunched beam dynamics in laser wakefields, based on the exact solution of single particle betatron motion taking into account the radiation reaction and multiple Coulomb scattering, reveals that the transverse normalized emittance and beam radius can be consecutively reduced during continuous acceleration in the presence of optimally phased recurrence of longitudinal and transverse wakefields . The final properties of the particle beams reached to the objective energy meet the requirements of the luminosity without resort to an additional focusing system.
The remaining part of this paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, the complete description on the longitudinal and transverse laser wakefields generated by two electromagnetic hybrid modes with moderate intensities coupled to a gas-filled capillary waveguide is provided. In Section 3, the particle beam dynamics on energy gain, beam loading, and betatron motion in a single stage of the two-mode mixing LPA is investigated, taking into account radiation reaction and multiple Coulomb scattering with plasma ions. In Section 4, a multistage coupling with a variable curvature plasma channel is presented. For the multistage comprising two-mode mixing LPAs, the results of numerical studies on the transverse beam dynamics of a particle bunch are shown. Analytical consideration on the evolution of the normalized emittance of the particle beam in the presence of radiation reaction and the multiple Coulomb scattering is given. In Section 5, the performance of a 1-TeV CM energy electron-positron collider comprising the multistage two-mode mixing LPAs is discussed on the luminosity and beam-beam interaction. In Section 6, we conclude our investigation on the proposed laser-plasma linear collider with a summary.
2. Laser pulse propagation in a gas-filled capillary tube
For a large-scale accelerator complex such as the energy frontier particle beam colliders, it is axiomatically useful in assembling a long-range multistage structure for the use of long-term experimental operation at a high-precision and high-repetition rate that each electromagnetic waveguide consists of a simple monolithic structure, as referred to the design of the future electron-positron linear colliders based on radio-frequency technologies . Despite the long-standing research on plasma waveguides comprising density channels generated in plasmas with laser-induced hydrodynamic expansion [23, 24] and pulsed discharges of an ablative capillary [25, 26] or a gas-filled capillary [27, 28], a length of such a plasma channel has been limited to about 10 cm. The pulsed discharge capillaries relying on collisional plasma processes have some difficulties in plasma densities less than 1017 cm−3 and the temporal and spatial stabilities of the density channel properties for the operation at a high repletion rate such as 10 kHz [5, 29]. In contrast to pulsed discharge plasma waveguides, metallic or dielectric capillary waveguides filled with gas [18, 30] will be revisited for a large-scale laser-plasma accelerator operated at a practically higher-repetition rate than 10 kHz, because of the passive optical guiding of laser pulses, the propagating electromagnetic fields of which are simply determined the boundary conditions on a static solid wall of the waveguide unless the laser intensity is high enough to cause the material breakdown on a capillary wall [20, 21]. Furthermore, the modal nature of electromagnetic fields arising from the boundary conditions on a solid wall allows us to conceive a novel scheme that can overcome a drawback of LPAs, referred to as dephasing of accelerated electron beams from a correct acceleration phase in laser wakefields.
2.1 Laser-driven wakefields generated by two capillary modes
Considering the electromagnetic hybrid modes EH1n  to which the most efficient coupling of a linearly polarized laser pulse in vacuum occurs, the normalized vector potential for the eigenmode of the
where is the amplitude of the normalized vector potential defined as for the EH1n mode with the vector potential , the electron charge , electron mass
where is the laser wavenumber with the laser wavelength and is the relative dielectric constant. In the quasi-linear wakefield regime , the ponderomotive force exerted on plasma electrons by two coupled capillary laser fields can be written by , where is defined by averaging the nonlinear force over the laser period , i.e., assuming that in the propagation distance , where is the mode mixing length over which two hybrid modes EH1n and EH1m overlap to cause the beatings of the normalized vector potential, e.g., for the EH11 - EH12 mode mixing of a laser pulse with and in a capillary tube with
The electrostatic potential defined by is obtained from Eq. (5).
where is the plasma frequency. The solution of Eq. (4) is
where is the plasma wavenumber in the capillary, , the mode beating wavenumber and
with the real () and imaginary () part of the error function . For and , the longitudinal electric field generated by the laser pulse can be obtained from as
The transverse focusing force is obtained from as
where is the Bessel function of the first order.
The proposed scheme restricts the laser intensity such that the plasma response is within the quasi-linear regime, i.e., , for two reasons. The one is avoidance of the nonlinear plasma response such as in the bubble regime, where symmetric wakefields for the electron and positron beams cannot be obtained for the application to electron-positron colliders [8, 9] and the degradation of the beam quality due to the self-injection of dark currents from the background plasma electrons. The other is an inherent demand that the laser intensity guided in a capillary tube should be lower enough than the threshold of material damage on the capillary wall .
2.2 Coupling control for generating two capillary modes
The coupling efficiency defined by an input laser energy with a spot radius and amplitude coupled to the E1n mode in the capillary with the radius , i.e., is calculated for a linearly polarized Airy beam,
and for a Gaussian beam,
where is the first root of the equation of , as shown in Figure 1a and b, respectively, as a function of . In Eq. (5), the beating term can be maximized by setting at which has the maximum value and the minimum fraction of higher-order modes. As shown in Figure 1, the Airy beam generates the maximum EH11-EH12 mode mixing with and a fraction of higher-order modes with ∼0.5% at , where the coupling efficiencies are , , , , and . The Gaussian beam can generate the EH11-EH12 mode mixing with and a fraction of higher-order modes with ∼5.1% at , where the coupling efficiencies are in the order of , , , , and .
The radial intensity profiles for the EH11, EH12 monomode and EH11-EH12 mixing mode for the Airy beam case are illustrated in Figure 1c–e, respectively. As shown in Figure 1e, a high-intensity region of the mixing mode is confined within a half radius of the capillary, compared to the monomode intensity profiles, which have a widespread robe toward the capillary wall. A centrally concentrated intensity profile of the mixing mode considerably decreases the energy flux traversing on the capillary wall. The normalized flux for EH1n mode at the capillary wall depends on the azimuthal angle as , defined by the ratio of the radial component of the Poynting vector at to the longitudinal component of the on-axis Poynting vector . For the Airy beam with coupled to the capillary with and , the maximum normalized fluxes for the EH11, EH12 mono- and EH11-EH12 mixing modes at or are , , and , respectively. The energy fluence traversing the capillary wall can be estimated by for the peak intensity () and the pulse duration , providing the maximum fluences 19, 66, and 19 mJ/cm2 for the corresponding modes, as shown in Figure 1f. The experimental study of laser-induced breakdown in fused silica (SiO2)  suggests that the fluence breakdown threshold is scaled to be for . According to a more detailed study of laser propagation in dielectric capillaries under non-ideal coupling conditions , the threshold intensity for wall ionization is obtained as () at the wavelength for the capillary radius .
The coupling efficiency of an incident laser pulse to a capillary tube filled with plasma can be improved by the use of a cone-shape entrance of the capillary , suppressing self-focusing effects and increasing the accelerating wakefield excited in the capillary. For the propagation of a laser beam with an approximately Gaussian intensity profile , the evolution of a normalized spot radius can be obtained from the equation , where is the vacuum Rayleigh length, the laser power, and the critical power for relativistic self-focusing with . For the coupling of an Airy beam (or a Gaussian beam) with the radius () to the capillary tube filled with plasma at the electron density of , the cone with the opening radius of () and length () can effectively guide and collect the incident laser energy. The effect of the relativistic self-focusing is estimated by considering the modulation of the refractive index for the EH1n mode, i.e., , where  and . The maximum modulation due to the relativistic self-focusing effect is at most 0.5% for the propagation of the EH11-EH12 mixing modes in a capillary.
3. Beam dynamics in a single-stage two-mode mixing LPA
3.1 Electron acceleration
In the linear wakefields excited by two coupled modes EH11 and EH12 in the capillary waveguide, the longitudinal motion of an electron traveling along the capillary axis at a normalized velocity is described as .
where is the electron energy, the accelerating field at , the nonrelativistic wave-breaking field, the particle phase with respect to the plasma wave, and . Here, the phase-matching condition is determined such that the beating wavelength is equal to the dephasing length, i.e.,
Taking into account and for and setting the pulse duration of a drive laser pulse with a Gaussian temporal profile to be the optimum length , the on-axis accelerating field near the matching condition is given by
where is a phase mismatching.
While propagating through plasma and generating wakefields, the laser pulse loses its energy as  where is the characteristic scale length of laser energy deposition into plasma wave excitation, referred to as the pump depletion length. In the linear wakefield regime where a laser pulse duration is assumed to be fixed, the laser energy evolution in the capillary can be written as , taking into account the energy attenuation of two coupled hybrid modes. In the quasi-linear wakefield regime, i.e., , the scaled pump depletion length is given by with for a Gaussian laser pulse [9, 37], while the scaled coupled mode attenuation length yields with the matching condition given by Eq. (12), i.e., for and the glass with the relative dielectric constant . Hence, the damping of wakefields during the laser pulse propagation is dominated by the energy depletion of the laser pulse as given in Eq. (13). Thus, integrating the equations of motion in Eq. (11) over , the energy and phase of the electron can be obtained as
where is the initial electron energy, the initial electron phase with respect to the wakefield, the maximum electron phase in the wakefield for the matching condition in Eq. (12) and the laser pulse length , and
The maximum energy gain to be attainable at is obtained as
Considering the mixing of two lowest order hybrid modes EH11 and EH12 with the coupling efficiencies and , the evolution of the energy gain with respect to is shown in Figure 2a for various detuning phases in comparison with that of the EH11 monomode with and . The effect of phase mismatching on the maximum attainable energy gain is shown in Figure 2b for various normalized laser intensities in the quasi-linear regime. One can see that the growth of energy gain occurs in the relatively wide range of the phase mismatching over and that the maximum attainable energy gain does not strongly depend on the normalized vector potential in the quasi-linear regime. While the single-mode LPA driven by the normalized intensity reaches the maximum energy gain over the accelerating phase , the two-mode mixing LPA with the phase matching, i.e., , is attainable to the maximum energy gain over the accelerating phase region , as shown in Figure 2. It is noted that significant enhancement of the energy gain is attributed to a large energy transfer efficiency from the laser pulse to the wakefield, i.e., over the accelerating phase region , while the energy transfer efficiency for the single-mode LPA is over the accelerating phase region .
The average energy gain of electrons contained in the bunch with the root-mean-square (rms) bunch length and longitudinal Gaussian density distribution can be estimated as , where
Figure 3 shows the evolution of the energy gain and the maximum attainable energy gain averaged over electrons in a Gaussian bunch with various rms lengths. It is noted that the maximum attainable energy gain at exhibits weak dependence on the initial bunch phase for a long bunch and that the minimum energy spread occurs at for different bunch lengths.
3.2 Beam loading
In the linear regime, a solution of the Green’s function for the beam-driven wakefield excited by a charge bunch with bi-Gaussian density distribution , i.e., and for the rms bunch length , rms bunch radius , and particle charge ( for a positron beam and for an electron beam), is written as , where is the coordinate in the co-moving frame of a relativistic electron beam with and is the radial, transverse coordinate of an electron beam having a cylindrical symmetry . Here, the longitudinal and transverse plasma responses are obtained as
and inside the bunch ()
where is the modified Bessel function of the second kind and is the incomplete Gamma function of the second kind. Combining the longitudinal and transverse solutions, the wakefield excited by a bi-Gaussian-shaped bunch is obtained as
where is the electron classical radius, the number of particles in a bunch, and . If we consider a laser-driven wakefield excited by two mixing hybrid modes accelerating the electron beam in a gas-filled capillary, the net longitudinal electric field, i.e., the beam loading field, experienced by the electron beam is given by . From Eqs. (13) and (20), the beam loading field at consisting of the laser- and beam-driven wake, where the electron bunch is located at in the laser co-moving frame, i.e., , yields
where . A loss of the energy gain due to the beam wakefield at the bunch center is
and the rms energy spread due to the beam loading is estimated as
where has the minimum at .
3.3 Betatron motion
In the wakefield, an electron moving along the z-axis undergoes a transverse focusing force at the transverse displacement
Transverse wakefield excited by the electron bunch is obtained from Eq. (20) according to the Panofsky-Wenzel theorem , , leading to the beam focusing force .
At the bunch center , the on-axis beam focusing strength at
where and is Dawson’s integral. Near-axis electrons experience the normalized accelerating and focusing gradients at , as obtained from Eqs. (21), (24), and (26)
where is the bunch form factor for a bi-Gaussian profile with the rms bunch radius and length .
The equations of motion of an electron propagating in the wakefield behind the laser pulse is written as .
where and are the normalized variables of
where , subscripts “0” denote the initial values, and
While the electron stays in the focusing region of the wakefield, i.e., , the electron exhibits betatron oscillation at the frequency given by . Contrarily, when the electron moves to the defocusing region where and
for a bi-Gaussian bunch with the rms radius and length . Figure 4 shows a map of the bunch form factor and the minimum number of electrons contained in a bunch requisite for the beam self-focusing strength larger than the defocusing strength in the laser-driven wakefield for the EH11-EH12 mode mixing LPA. It is noted that the minimum value of the requisite electron number occurs at the bunch length for various bunch radii, e.g., for and for , as shown in Figure 4.
In the bunch containing the requisite number of particles, an electron undergoes betatron motion throughout the whole accelerating phase, as shown in Figure 5, where the trajectory and momentum of the electron in the bunch with the number of electrons and length are calculated from Eq. (30) in 105 segments of the laser wakefield phase excited in the plasma with density . Note that the betatron oscillation exhibits beats with the amplitude modulation due to the accelerating wakefield.
3.4 Effects of radiation reaction and multiple Coulomb scattering
A beam electron propagating in the wakefield undergoes betatron motion that induces synchrotron (betatron) radiation at high energies. The synchrotron radiation causes the radiation damping of particles and affects the energy spread and transverse emittance via the radiation reaction force. Furthermore, a notable difference of plasma-based accelerators from vacuum-based accelerators is the presence of the multiple Coulomb scattering between beam electrons and plasma ions, which counteracts the beam focusing due to the transverse wakefield and radiation damping due to betatron radiation. The comprehensive motion of an electron traveling along the
where is the normalized electron momentum, the radiation reaction force, and the transverse kick in momentum projected onto the
For the classical expression of the radiation reaction force given by .
where is the relativistic Lorentz factor of the electron and , assuming and , the radiation reaction force Eq. (34) is approximately read as .
Since the scale length of the radiation reaction, i.e., , is much smaller than that of the betatron motion, i.e., , the radiation reaction force is considered as a perturbation in the betatron motion.
A beam electron of the incident momentum , passing a nucleus of charge
where is the plasma Debye length at the temperature and is the effective Coulomb radius of the nucleus with the mass number
The electron orbit and energy are obtained from the solutions of the coupled equations in Eq. (33) describing the single particle motion in the segmented phase, where and are assumed to be constant over the phase advance . Provided the initial values of and are specified from the energy , relative energy spread , and normalized emittance of the injected beam, , , and are first calculated from Eqs. (14) and (30) using , where is the phase at next step. Thus, the effects of the radiation reaction and multiple Coulomb scattering are obtained as follows:
where and are the solutions obtained from Eqs. (30) and (14), respectively; and are correction terms for the effect of the radiation reaction force, given by
with and ; and is a projected angle due to multiple Coulomb scattering, the standard deviation of which is obtained from Eq. (36) for as
The radiated power of the electron in the classical limit is given by [42, 43].
where is the external force and is used. For a relativistic electron with and , taking into account with and , the radiated power can be written as , which means the radiative damping rate . Thus, a total radiation energy loss along the particle orbit is estimated as
3.5 Numerical studies of the single-particle dynamics in a single stage
Numerical calculations of the single-particle dynamics can be carried out throughout the segments in phase for a set of test particles under the initial conditions, and then the underlying beam parameters can be obtained as an ensemble average over test particles: for instance, the mean energy is calculated as , where is the energy of the
where is the dimensionless transverse momentum.
The particle orbit and energy can be numerically tracked by using the solutions of the single particle motion (Eqs. (30) and (14)) associated with the perturbation arising from the effects of the radiation reaction and multiple Coulomb scattering, as given by Eqs. (38) and (39), respectively. The simulation of particle tracking can be carried out by using an ensemble of 104 test particles, for which the initial values at the injection and the deflection angles due to the multiple Coulomb scattering at each segment in a phase step , where is the phase advance in the single stage, are obtained from the random number generator for the normal distribution, assuming that the particle beam with the rms bunch length () containing electrons (16 pC) is injected into the capillary accelerator operated at the plasma density of from the external injector at the injection energy and the initial normalized transverse emittance in the condition initially matched to laser wakefields, namely, the initial bunch radius and momentum with the focusing strength , given by Eq. (28). Figure 6a and b show the results of simulations for the evolution of transverse normalized emittance from various initial values at the initial phase and that of the relative energy spread from the initial spread of for various initial energies due to the effect of the radiation reaction, respectively. The effect of the multiple Coulomb scattering is shown in Figure 6c, indicating a significant growth of the normalized emittance in the latter half of the stage. In this simulation, the multiple Coulomb scattering has been considered for a helium plasma with , , and . Since the normalized emittance, defined by Eq. (42), is approximately calculated as , where and are the amplitudes of the transverse displacement and dimensionless momentum, the evolution of the normalized emittance traces the envelope of the betatron oscillation of the single particle, as seen in Figures 5 and 6. Note that the electron motion of coupled equation in Eq. (29) includes the nonlinear damping term , which induces the amplitude decrease in the electron acceleration phase, while the betatron motion of the electron undergoing only a linear focusing force with a constant is described by a simple harmonic oscillator at a constant energy , i.e., no acceleration field , forming the constant envelope of the betatron amplitude for the matched condition of bunch size , for which the normalized emittance is conserved.
4. Beam dynamics in multistage two-mode mixing LPAs
4.1 Seamless stage coupling with a variable curvature plasma channel
A gas-filled capillary waveguide made of metallic or dielectric materials can make it possible to comprise a seamless staging without the coupling section, where a fresh laser pulse and accelerated particle beam from the previous stage are injected so as to minimize coupling loss in both laser and particle beams and the emittance growth of particle beams due to the mismatch between the injected beam and plasma wakefield. For dephasing limited laser wakefield accelerators, the total linac length will be minimized by choosing the coupling distance to be equal to a half of the dephasing length . A side coupling of laser pulse through a curved capillary waveguide [46, 47, 48] diminishes the beam-matching section consisting of a vacuum drift space and focusing magnet beamline . Furthermore, the proposed scheme comprising seamless capillary waveguides can provide us with suppression of synchrotron radiation from high-energy electron (positron) beams generated by betatron oscillation in plasma-focusing channels and delivery of remarkably small normalized emittance from the linac to the beam collision section in electron-positron linear colliders.
Since the electron beam size with a finite beam emittance causes a rapid growth in a vacuum drift space outside plasma , the coupling segment must be used for spatial matching of the electron beam with the transverse wakefield as well as temporal phase matching with the accelerating wakefield in a subsequent stage. A proof-of-principle experiment on two LPA stages powered by two synchronized laser pulses through the plasma lens and mirror coupling has been reported, showing that an 120 MeV electron beam from a gas jet (the first stage) driven by a 28 TW, 45 fs laser pulse was focused by a first discharge capillary as an active plasma lens to a second capillary plasma channel (the second stage), where the wakefield excited by a 12 TW, 45 fs separate laser pulse reflected by a tape-based plasma mirror with a laser-energy throughput of 80% further increased an energy gain of 100 MeV . In this experiment, a trapping fraction of the electron charge coupled to the second stage was as low as 3.5% . Such a poor coupling efficiency could be attributed to the plasma mirror inserted at a vacuum drift space. To avoid a rapid growth in the vacuum drift space and improve coupling efficiency, a multistage coupling using a variable curvature plasma channel  enables off-axial injection of a fresh laser pulse into the LPA stage without a vacuum gap in the coupling segment; thereby an electron bunch is continuously accelerated through the plasma-focusing channel over the consecutive stages only if the temporal phase-matching between the laser and electron beams can be optimized .
In the propagation of a laser pulse through a curved plasma channel, the radial equilibrium position of the laser pulse is shifted away from the channel axis due to the balance between the refractive index gradient bending the light rays inward and the centrifugal force pulling them outward. As a result, the minimum of the effective plasma density, which is proportional to a guiding potential, is located outward from the channel axis . Thus, a direct guiding of a laser pulse from the curved channel with a constant curvature to the straight channel causes large centroid oscillations in the straight channel even though the laser pulse is injected to the equilibrium position, leading to loss of the laser energy and electron beam transported from the previous stage as a result of off-axis interaction with plasma wakefields . To diminish the mismatching at the transition from a curved channel to a straight one , a variable curvature plasma channel has been devised such that the equilibrium position guides the laser centroid gradually along the channel axis from the initial equilibrium position to the channel center, where the straight channel axis merges together, as shown in Figure 7a. A seamless acceleration in two-stage LPA coupled with a variable curvature plasma channel has been successfully demonstrated for the guided laser intensity of 8.55 × 1018 W/cm2 (normalized vector potential
4.2 Betatron motion of the particle beam in the seamless multistage
For , the asymptotic form of betatron motion in Eq. (30) yields
where . The variation of the betatron amplitude with respect to the initial amplitude in the
where () is the particle phase with respect to the plasma wave, is the initial phase, and is corresponding to the initial energy of the particle in the
where . In the accelerator system consisting of
where , are the final phase and energy of the particle at the
Here we consider the evolution of transverse normalized emittance for the particle beam acceleration in the multistage capillary accelerator. The definition of transverse normalized emittance given by Eq. (42) is expressed as , where and are the deviation from the mean transverse displacement and normalized momentum , respectively. The particle orbit undergoing betatron motion is written for from Eqs. (43) and (44) as and , where is the betatron phase and . Thus, the ensemble averaged quantities , , and can be obtained: e.g., . Assuming that the energy distribution about the mean energy , i.e., the distribution, is Gaussian with a width of , the energy is approximated about its mean value to the first order in , i.e., , , and . The ensemble averaged quantities can be calculated as averages over the distribution of energy deviations as, e.g., , , and , where and is the frequency corresponding to decoherence time , defined as the time when the phase difference between the low energy part of the beam and the high-energy part is . Considering transverse emittance of the particle beam with initial energy spread that dominates decoherence, the normalized emittance for is given by
where is the dimensionless normalized emittance. If the beam is initially matched to the laser wakefield focusing channel, i.e., , such that in the absence of radiation the beam radial envelope undergoes no betatron oscillation, the normalized emittance can be expressed as
This indicates that in the absence of radiation and multiple Coulomb scattering, the transverse normalized emittance of an initially matched beam is conserved in the laser wakefield acceleration when the amplitude of accelerating field has no variation, i.e., . Note that the decreasing accelerating field at the final phase results in a decrease of the normalized emittance of the injected beam matched to the laser wakefield at the initial phase in the single stage. For the multistage laser wakefield acceleration without a vacuum drift space in the coupling section, properly choosing the injection and extraction phases enables continuous reduction of the normalized emittance in the absence of synchrotron radiation and multiple Coulomb scattering with plasma ions. Since the initial values of the displacement and normalized momentum at the next stage are expressed as and ,
the initial amplitude of betatron oscillation at the next stage is
Accordingly, the emittance at the
Assuming , the dimensionless normalized emittance at the
where is the ratio of the accelerating field amplitude at the final phase to that at the initial phase with and . Setting , the normalized emittance increases or decreases monotonically, depending on or as the particles move along the stage in the absence of radiation and multiple Coulomb scattering.
For an application of laser-plasma accelerators to electron-positron colliders, it is of most importance to achieve the smallest possible normalized emittance at the final stage of the accelerator system, overwhelming the emittance growth due to the multiple Coulomb scattering off plasma ions, being increased in proportion to the square root of the beam energy. We consider the effect of multiple Coulomb scattering on the emittance growth and evaluate an achievable normalized emittance at the end of the accelerator system comprising
where is the wave number of betatron oscillation. In the single stage, the transverse normalized emittance of the particles undergoing the wakefields evolves the growth in the same manner as the injected particle beam without the multiple Coulomb scattering as
Assuming that the beam energy at the
for , where and are the error function, and for ,
where is Dawson’s integral. For , i.e., , the normalized emittance at the
As expected, the normalized emittance in the multistage accelerator operated with the constant accelerating field is conserved to the initial normalized emittance and then limited by an increasing growth due to multiple Coulomb scattering. For , the initial emittance of the injected beam dominates an exponential growth of the normalized emittance, while for , an exponential decrease of the initial emittance is followed by a slow decrease of the normalized emittance arising from the multiple Coulomb scattering .
4.3 Numerical studies of the single-particle dynamics in multistages
Numerical studies on transverse beam dynamics of an electron bunch accelerated in the multistage mode mixing LPA have been carried out by calculating the ensemble of trajectories of test particles throughout consecutive stages, using the single-particle dynamics code based on the analytical solutions of the equations of motion of an electron in laser wakefields with the presence of effects of the radiation reaction and multiple Coulomb scattering, as described in Section 3. Figure 8a shows examples of the phase space distribution of 104 test particles on the plane and evolution of the transverse normalized emittance for 400 stages, in each of which the electron is accelerated between the initial wakefield phase and final phase , in the presence of the radiation reaction and multiple Coulomb scattering. Figure 8b is the result for 60 stages with the stage phase and Figure 8c for 50 stages with , taking into account only the radiation effect. The cases shown in Figure 8a and b obviously correspond to the exponential decrease of the normalized emittance with , while the case shown in Figure 8c corresponds to the exponential increase with . In Figure 8a, the exponential decrease of the normalized emittance is limited, leading to the equilibrium with the growth due to the multiple Coulomb scattering after several stages. In Figure 8c, the exponential increase can be limited by the radiation effects, resulting in an excess of radiation energy loss and the equilibrium with the radiation reaction after 20 stages. For the case shown in Figure 8a, the beam energy is accelerated up to 558.92 GeV with the relative rms energy spread of 0.02% over the whole 400 LPA stages with the stage phase at the operating plasma density of in the accelerator length of 67 m, assuming initially a 10% relative energy spread. From this result, the beam-induced longitudinal (decelerating) wakefield becomes approximately and focusing strength , as calculated from an ensemble average of the radius of an electron bunch with electrons and length of 16 μm, using Eqs. (20) and (26), respectively, at each step of the stage consisting of 100 segments. It is noted that both beam-induced wakefields reach the equilibrium after several stages in consistency with the evolution of the normalized emittance.
The detailed study on the evolution of the transverse normalized emittance in the multistage two-mode mixing LPA has been investigated for three cases with the different stage phases, i.e., (case A), (case B), and (case C), the reduction coefficients for which are 37.3, 1.37, and − 0.438, respectively. Figure 9 shows the evolution of the bunch radius (a)–(c), radiation energy (d)–(f), and transverse normalized emittance (g)–(i), respectively. In Figure 9 (g)–(i), the solid curve indicates the normalized emittance predicted from the analytical formulae of Eqs. (54) and (55), assuming that the average focusing constant is for cases A–C and the growth rate is ∼10% of the reduction coefficient for case C. It is noted that the evolution of the normalized emittance is determined by the equilibrium between the consecutive focusing and the defocusing due to the multiple Coulomb scattering at a large number of stages .
5. Considerations on electron-positron collider performance
Electron and positron beams being reached to the final energies in the multistage two-mode mixing LPA are extracted at a phase corresponding to the minimum transverse normalized emittance, followed by propagating a drift space in vacuum and a final focusing system to the beam-beam collisions at the interaction point. In a vacuum drift space outside plasma, the particle beam changes the spatial and temporal dimensions of the bunch proportional to the propagation distance due to the finite emittance and energy spread of the accelerated bunch. The evolution of the rms bunch envelope in vacuum without the external focusing force is given by , where is an initial radius and is the characteristic distance of the bunch size growth . The bunch radius after propagation of the distance between the final LPA stage and interaction point is estimated to be , where is the rms bunch radius at the interaction point and , the rms bunch radius and normalized emittance at the exit of the LPA, respectively. In collisions between high-energy electron and positron bunches from the LPAs, the beam particles emit synchrotron radiation due to the interaction, the so-called Beamstrahlung, with the electromagnetic fields generated by the counterpropagating beam. The beamstrahlung effect leads to substantial beam energy loss and degradation on energy resolution for the high-energy experiments in electron-positron linear colliders . Intensive research on beamstrahlung radiation has been explored [50, 51, 52], being of relevance to the design of e+e− linear colliders in the TeV center-of-mass (CM) energies, for which two major effects must be taken into account, namely, the disruption effect bending particle trajectories by the oncoming beam-generated electromagnetic fields and the beamstrahlung effect yielding radiation loss of the particle energies induced by bending their trajectories due to the disruption . The radiative energy loss due to beamstrahlung for a Gaussian beam can be estimated in terms of the beamstrahlung parameter for a round beam with , where () is the fine-structure constant . According to the beamstrahlung simulations , the average number of emitted photon per electron and average fractional energy loss are and , respectively, with . Using these parameters, the average CM energy loss can be calculated as . In the quantum beamstrahlung regime, the collider design must consider the CM energy loss such that their requirements can be reached as well as that of the luminosity. The geometric luminosity is given by , where is the collision frequency. It is pointed out that an appreciable disruption effect turns out to the luminosity enhancement through the pinch effect arising from the attraction of the oppositely charged beams [51, 52]. For Gaussian beams, the disruption parameter for the round beam is , defined as the ratio of the bunch length to the focal length of a thin lens. The luminosity enhancement factor being defined as the ratio of the effective luminosity induced by the disruption to the geometric luminosity in the absence of disruption is estimated from the empirical formula: , where is the inherent divergence of the incoming beam . This scenario allows us to transport both beams into the interaction point through no extra focusing devices, which often induce the degradation of beam qualities prior to their interactions. In this scheme, the vacuum drift region from the end of the LPA to the interaction point can be used for control of the transverse beam size that strongly affect the luminosity and CM energy through the beamstrahlung radiation and disruption. A typical design example of the LPA stage using the gas-filled  two-mode mixing LPA operated with EH11 and EH12 is shown in Table 1.
|Plasma density ||1 × 108 cm−3|
|Plasma wavelength ||33.4 μm|
|Capillary radius ||152.6 μm|
|Capillary stage length||16.75 cm|
|Laser wavelength ||1 μm|
|Laser spot radius ||91 μm (51 μm)|
|Laser pulse duration ||25 fs|
|Normalized vector potential ||1|
|Electromagnetic hybrid mode||EH11 and EH12|
|Coupling efficiency for an Airy beam (a Gaussian beam)||C1 = 0.4022 (0.5980)|
C2 = 0.4986 (0.3531)
|Bunch initial and final phase||Ψ|
|Average accelerating gradient||8.3 GeV/m|
|Laser peak power ||95 TW (18 TW)|
|Laser pulse energy ||2.4 J (0.44 J)|
|Repetition frequency ||50 kHz|
|Laser average power per stage||120 kW (22 kW)|
|Laser depletion ||77%|
An embodiment of the LPA stage may be envisioned by exploiting a tens kW-level high-average power laser such as a coherent amplification network of fiber lasers . Table 2 summarizes key parameters on the performance of 1 TeV CM energy electron-positron linear collider.
|CM energy||1.12 TeV|
|Beam energy||559 GeV|
|Injection beam energy||1 GeV|
|Particle per bunch ||1 × 108|
|Collision frequency ||50 kHz|
|Total beam power||0.9 MW|
|Geometric luminosity ||3.6 × 1032 cm−2 s−1|
|Effective luminosity||1.76 × 1034 cm−2 s−1|
|Effective CM energy||1.09 TeV|
|rms CM energy spread||8.4%|
|rms bunch length ||16 μm|
|Beam radius at IP ||3.3 nm|
|Beam aspect ratio ||1|
|Normalized emittance at IP ||3.7 pm-rad|
|Distance between LPA and IP ||0.2 m|
|Beamstrahlung parameter ϒ*||0.94|
|Beamstrahlung photons ||0.52|
|Disruption parameter ||12|
|Luminosity enhancement ||49|
|Number of stages per beam ||400|
|Linac length per beam||67 m|
|Power requirement for lasers||95 MW (18 MW)|
The electron acceleration and beam dynamics of the two-mode mixing LPA comprising a gas-filled metallic or dielectric capillary have been presented for the performance of the single-stage and multistage configurations. As shown in Table 1, when a laser pulse with an Airy beam (or a Gaussian beam) profile of the spot radius () is coupled to a gas-filled capillary, two electromagnetic hybrid modes EH11 and EH12 are generated with the coupling efficiency () and (), respectively. Furthermore, when the capillary radius is tuned to the matching condition given by Eq. (12), the laser pulse comprising two beating hybrid modes EH11 and EH12 with a Gaussian temporal profile can efficiently excite a rectified accelerating wakefield, where relativistic electrons dominantly propagate in the accelerating phase and continuously gain the energy until depletion of the laser pulse energy, whereby a nearly 100% of the laser energy can be transferred to wakefields in the single stage.
In the two-mode mixing LPA multistage coupled with a variable curvature plasma channel, the transverse dynamics of the electron bunch is dominated by seamless recurrence of the accelerating wakefield in the stages, where the cumulative nature of the particle trajectories is determined by the amplitude ratio of the accelerating field at the final phase to the initial phase in each stage, i.e., . With the converging condition, i.e., , the bunch radius and normalized emittance exhibit an exponential decrease initially and then turn out to be in equilibrium with the growth due to the multiple Coulomb scattering after 20 stages, leading to the rms bunch radius of the order of ∼1 nm and the transverse normalized emittance of the order of ∼0.1 nm-rad at the beam energy 559 GeV with the relative rms energy spread of 0.02% in the final 400 stage of the accelerator length of 67 m, as shown for case A in Figure 9. This capability of producing such high-energy and high-quality electron (or positron) beams allows us to conceive a unique electron-positron linear collider with high luminosity of the order of 1034 cm−2 s−1 at 1 TeV center-of-mass energy in a very compact size.
In conclusion, a novel scheme of 1 TeV electron-positron linear collider comprising properly phased multistage two-mode mixing LPAs using gas-filled capillary waveguides can provide a unique approach in collider applications. This scheme presented resorts two major mechanisms pertaining to laser wakefield acceleration, that is, dephasing and strong focusing force as well as very high-gradient accelerating field. The multistage scheme using two-mode mixing capillary waveguides filled with plasma may provide a robust approach leading to the supreme goal for LPAs. The numerical model developed for study on beam dynamics in large-scale LPAs will be useful for assessing effects of underlying physics and the optimum design for future laser-plasma-based colliders. Although the present model has been developed to study the simplest two-dimensional phase-space model of electron beam dynamics in laser wakefield acceleration, the analysis of higher multi-dimensional phase-space model as well as the quantum plasma effect will be extensively pursued in the future work.
The work was supported by the NSFC (No. 11721091, 11774227), the Science Challenge Project (No.TZ2018005), and the National Basic Research Program of China (No. 2013CBA01504).
Gibney E. Who will build the next LHC? Nature. 2016; 536:383-384
Schulte D. Application of advanced accelerator concepts for colliders. In: Chao AW, Chou W, editors. Review of Accelerator Science and Technology. Vol. 9. Singapore: World Scientific; 2016. pp. 209-233. DOI: 10.1142/S1793626816300103
Nakajima K. Seamless multistage laser-plasma acceleration toward future high-energy colliders. Light: Science & Applications. 2018; 7:21. DOI: 10.1038/s41377-018-0037-6
Tajima T, Dawson JM. Laser electron accelerator. Physical Review Letters. 1979; 43:267-270. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.43.267
Nakajima K. In: Chao AW, Chou W, editors. Review of Accelerator Science and Technology. Vol. 9. Singapore: World Scientific; 2016. pp. 19-61. DOI: 10.11412/S1793626816300024
Grüner F, Becker S, Schramm U, Eichner T, Fuchs M, Weingartner R, et al. Design considerations for table-top, laser-based VUV and X-ray free electron lasers. Applied Physics B: Lasers and Optics. 2007; 86:431-435. DOI: 10.1007/s00340-006-2565-7
Nakajima K. Compact X-ray sources-towards a table-top free-electron laser. Nature Physics. 2008; 4:92-93
Schroeder CB, Esarey E, Geddes CGR, Benedetti C, Leemans WP. Physics considerations for laser-plasma linear colliders. Physical Review Accelerators and Beams. 2010; 13:101301. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevSTAB. 13.101301
Nakajima K, Deng A, Zhang X, Shen B, Liu J, Li R, et al. Operating plasma density issues on large-scale laser-plasma accelerators toward high-energy frontier. Physical Review Accelerators and Beams. 2011; 14:091301. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevSTAB.14.091301
Nakajima K, Lu HY, Zhao XY, Shen BF, Li RX, Xu ZZ. 100-GeV large scale laser plasma electron acceleration by a multi-PW laser. Chinese Optics Letters. 2013; 11:013501. DOI: 10.3788/COL201311.013501
Liu JS, Xia CQ, Wang WT, Lu HY, Wang C, Deng AH, et al. All-optical cascaded laser wakefield accelerator using ionization-induced injection. Physical Review Letters. 2011; 107:035001. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.035001
Wang X, Zgadzaj R, Fazel N, Li Z, Yi SA, Zhang X, et al. Quasi-monoenergetic laser-plasma acceleration of electrons to 2 GeV. Nature Communications. 2013; 4:1988-1-1988-9. DOI: 10.1038/ncomms2988
Kim HT, Pae KH, Cha HJ, Kim IJ, Yu TJ, Sung JH, et al. Enhancement of electron energy to the multi-GeV regime by a dual-stage laser-wakefield accelerator pumped by petawatt laser pulses. Physical Review Letters. 2013; 111:165002. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.111.165002
Kim HT, Pathak VB, Pae KH, Lifschitz A, Sylla F, Shin JH, et al. Stable multi-GeV electron accelerator driven by waveform-controlled PW laser pulses. Scientific Reports. 2017; 7:1020. DOI: 10.1038/s41598-017-09267-1
Leemans WP, Gonsalves AJ, Mao HS, Nakamura K, Benedetti C, Schroeder CB, et al. Multi-GeV electron beams from capillary-discharge-guided subpetawatt laser pulses in the self-trapping regime. Physical Review Letters. 2014; 113:245002. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.113.245002
Lu H, Liu M, Wang W, Wang C, Liu J, Deng A, et al. Laser wakefield acceleration of electron beams beyond 1 GeV from an ablative capillary discharge waveguide. Applied Physics Letters. 2011; 99:091502. DOI: 10.1063/1.3626042
Gonsalves AJ, Nakamura K, Daniels J, Benedetti C, Pieronek C, de Raadt TCH, et al. Petawatt laser guiding and electron beam acceleration to 8 GeV in a laser-heated capillary discharge waveguide. Physical Review Letters. 2019; 122:084801. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.122.084801
Osterhoff J, Popp A, Major Z, Marx B, Rowlands-Rees TP, Fuchs M, et al. Generation of stable low-divergence electron beams by laser-wakefield acceleration in a steady-state-flow gas cell. Physical Review Letters. 2008; 101:085002. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.101.085002
Nakajima K, Wheeler J, Mourou G, Tajima T. Novel laser-plasma TeV electron-positron linear colliders. International Journal of Modern Physics A. 2019; 34:1943003. DOI: 10.1142/S0217751X19430036
Cros B, Courtois C, Matthieussent G, Bernardo AD, Batani D, Andreev N, et al. Eigenmodes for capillary tubes with dielectric walls and ultraintense laser pulse guiding. Physical Review E. 2002; 65:026405. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.65.026405
Nakajima K. Laser electron acceleration beyond 100 GeV. The European Physical Journal Special Topics. 2014; 223:999-1016. DOI: 10.1140/epjst/e2014-02151-9
Behnke T, Brau TJE, Foster B, Fuster J, Harrison M, Paterson JM, et al., editors. The international linear collider accelerator. In: The International Linear Collider Technical Design Report. Vol. 1. 2013. pp. 9-26
Durfee CG III, Milchberg HM. Light pipe for high intensity laser pulses. Physical Review Letters. 1993; 71:2409. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.71.2409
Xiao YF, Chu HH, Tsai HE, Lee CH, Lin JY, Wang J, et al. Efficient generation of extended plasma waveguides with the axicon ignitor-heater scheme. Physics of Plasmas. 2004; 11:L21-L24. DOI: 10.1063/1.1695354
Levin M, Pukhov A, Zigler A, Sugiyama K, Nakajima K, Hubbard RF, et al. Long plasma channels in segmented capillary discharges. Physics of Plasmas. 2006; 13:083108. DOI: 10.1063/1.2261853
Liu MW, Deng AH, Liu JS, Li RX, Xu JC, Xia CQ, et al. Note: Low density and long plasma channels generated by laser transversely ignited ablative capillary discharges. The Review of Scientific Instruments. 2009; 81:036107. DOI: 10.1063/1.3360925
Hosokai T, Kando M, Dewa H, Kotaki H, Kondo S, Hasegawa N, et al. Optical guidance of terawatt laser pulses by the implosion phase of a fast Z-pinch discharge in a gas-filled capillary. Optics Letters. 2000; 25:10-12
Gonsalves AJ, Rowlands-Rees TP, Broks BHP, van der Mullen JJAM, Hooker SM. Transverse interferometry of a hydrogen-filled capillary discharge waveguide. Physical Review Letters. 2007; 98:025002. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.025002
Gonsalves AJ, Liu F, Bobrova NA, Sasorov PV, Pieronek C, Daniels J, et al. Demonstration of a high repetition rate capillary discharge waveguide. Journal of Applied Physics. 2016; 119:033302. DOI: 10.1063/1.4940121
Ju J, Svensson K, Döpp A, Ferrari HE, Cassou K, Neveu O, et al. Enhancement of x-rays generated by a guided laser wakefield accelerator inside capillary tubes. Applied Physics Letters. 2012; 100:191106. DOI: 10.1063/1.4712594
Curcio A, Petrarca M, Giulietti D, Ferrario M. Numerical and analytical models to study the laser-driven plasma perturbation in a dielectric gas-filled capillary waveguide. Optics Letters. 2016; 41:4233-4236. DOI: 10.1364/OL.41.004233
Du D, Liu X, Korn G, Squier J, Mourou G. Laserinduced breakdown by impact ionization in SiO2 with pulse widths from 7 ns to 150 fs. Applied Physics Letters. 1994; 64:3071-3073. DOI: 10.1063/1.111350
Veysman M, Andreev NE, Cassou K, Ayoul Y, Maynard G, Cros B. Theoretical and experimental study of laser beam propagation in capillary tubes for non-symmetrical coupling conditions. Journal of the Optical Society of America B: Optical Physics. 2010; 27:1400-1408
Andreev NE, Cros B, Maynard G, Mora P, Wojda F. Coupling efficiency of intense laser pulses to capillary tubes for laser wakefield acceleration. IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science. 2008; 36:1746-1750. DOI: 10.1109/TPS.2008.927144
Esarey E, Schroeder CB, Leemans WP. Physics of laser-driven plasma-based electron accelerators. Reviews of Modern Physics. 2009; 81:1229-1284. DOI: 10.1103/RevModPhys.81.1229
Sprangle P, Esarey E, Ting A. Nonlinear theory of intense laser-plasma interactions. Physical Review Letters. 1990; 64:2011-2014
Shadwick BA, Schroeder CB, Esarey E. Nonlinear laser energy depletion in laser-plasma accelerators. Physics of Plasmas. 2009; 16:056704. DOI: 10.1063/1.3124185
Lu W, Huang C, Zhou MM, Mori WB, Katsouleas T. Limits of linear plasma wakefield theory for electron or positron beams. Physics of Plasmas. 2005; 12:063101. DOI: 10.1063/1.1905587
Panofsky WKH, Wenzel WA. Some considerations concerning the transverse deflection of charged particles in radio-frequency fields. The Review of Scientific Instruments. 1956; 27:967. DOI: 10.1063/1.1715427
Chen P, Su JJ, Katsouleas T, Wilks S, Dawson JM. Plasma focusing for high-energy beams. IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science. 1987; PS:218-225 -15
Khachatryan AG, Irman A, van Goor FA, Boller KJ. Femtosecond electron-bunch dynamics in laser wakefields and vacuum. Physical Review Accelerators and Beams. 2007; 10:121301. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevSTAB. 10.121301
Jackson JD. Classical Electrodynamics. 3rd ed. New York: John Wiley & Sons; 1999
Michel P, Schroeder CB, Shadwick BA, Esarey E, Leemans WP. Radiative damping and electron beam dynamics in plasma-based accelerators. Physical Review E. 2006; 74:026501. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.74.026501
Kirby N, Berry M, Blumenfeld I, Hogan MJ, Ischebeck R, Siemann R. Emittance growth from multiple coulomb scattering in a plasma wakefield accelerator. In: Proceedings of Particle Accelerator Conference 2007 (PAC2007); Albuquerque. New Mexico, USA: IEEE; 2007. pp. 3097-3099
Deng A, Nakajima K, Liu J, Shen B, Zhang X, Yu Y, et al. Electron beam dynamics and self-cooling up to PeV level due to betatron radiation in plasma-based accelerators. Physical Review Accelerators and Beams. 2012; 15:081303. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevSTAB. 15.081303
Ehrlich Y, Cohen C, Zigler A, Krall J, Sprangle P, Esarey E. Guiding of high intensity laser pulses in straight and curved plasma channel experiments. Physical Review Letters. 1996; 77:4186-4189
Reitsma AJW, Jaroszynski DA. Propagation of a weakly nonlinear laser pulse in a curved plasma channel. Physics of Plasmas. 2007; 14:053104. DOI: 10.1063/1.2731816
Luo J, Chen M, Wu WY, Weng SM, Sheng ZM, Schroeder CB, et al. Multistage coupling of laser-wakefield accelerators with curved plasma channels. Physical Review Letters. 2018; 120:154801. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.120.154801
Steinke S, Tilborg J, Benedetti C, Geddes CGR, Schroeder CB, Daniels J, et al. Multistage coupling of independent laser-plasma accelerators. Nature. 2016; 530:190-193. DOI: 10.1038/nature16525
Noble RJ. Beamstrahlung from colliding electron-positron beams with negligible disruption. Nuclear Instrumentation and Methods. 1987; 256:427-433
Hollebeek R. Disruption limits for linear colliders. Nuclear Instruments & Methods. 1981; 184:333-347
Chen P, Yokoya K. Disruption effects from the interaction of round e+e− beams. Physical Review D. 1988; 38:987-1000
Wheeler J, Mourou G. Tajima T. In: Chao AW, Chou W, editors. Review of Accelerator Science and Technology. Vol. 9. Singapore: World Scientific; 2016. pp. 151-163. DOI: 10.1142/S1793626816300073