This chapter refers to tropane alkaloid compounds best known for their occurrence, biosynthesis, and pharmacological properties in a subsection of the plant family Solanaceae including the Atropa, Duboisia, Hyoscyamus, and Scopolia species, together with their semisynthetic derivatives. Tropane alkaloids are useful as parasympatholytics that competitively antagonize acetylcholine. The bicyclic ring of tropane moiety forms the base of these alkaloids, and the largest number of tropane alkaloids is substituted on the atom C-3 of the tropane ring in the form of ester derivatives. Also, this chapter provides routes to previous methods for synthesizing tropane-2-yl derivatives as well as new routes to synthesize 2-(p-toluenesulphonyl) tropane-2-ene (anhydroecgonine). The new strategy for synthesizing anhydroecgonine might be helpful to adopt the best method of synthesizing tropane-2-yl derivatives.
1.1 Tropane alkaloids occurrence
Tropane alkaloids (Figure 1) are among the oldest medicines known to men. A secondary metabolites containing the tropane nucleus constitute one of the largest and most important group of naturally occurring compounds . Secondary metabolites of Solanaceae plant, sharing tropane skeleton (1) as a common structural feature can be divided into two classes: tropine (2) and ecgonine (3) derivatives . The first group is represented by atropine from
Over 600 naturally occurring alkaloids of tropane can be found in plants such as
1.2 Biosynthesis of tropane alkaloids
Alkaloids possess quite complex structures, and the study of biosynthesis of these alkaloids has a long history. It is generally thought that the tropane moiety arises from complex enzymatic processes involving phytochemical precursors. Incorporation of radioactive labeled precursors has eased monitoring pathway on which the tropane derivatives are formed . Recent studies making use of labeled ornithine (7),
It has been found that oxidation of tropane ring can be achieved by molecular oxygen in the presence of ferrous ions. Also, it has been found that these keto forms of tropane can be catalyzed by an enzyme called reductase . For instance, the biosynthesis pathway to tropane alkaloids, tropinone (10), is reduced by reductase to tropine (2), as it can be seen in Figure 4.
Structural assignments of tropane molecules have exhibited difficult problems, and, as a result, progress in their endeavors has been closely associated with development of modern analytical techniques of spectroscopy, of which mass spectroscopy deserves particular mention such as ESI MS, GC-MS, HPLC-MS, and MALDI MS.
1.3 Pharmacological properties of tropane alkaloids
Concerning the pharmacological effects, these compounds are so important because of their pharmacological properties . Alkaloids such as atropine (4), scopolamine (5), and cocaine (6) and their derivatives are best recognized to have pharmacological actions related in the body to the function of neurotransmitter acetylcholine . Some tropane alkaloids can act as anticholinergic effects or stimulants . Pharmaceuticals of tropane derivatives are economically important. Over 20 active pharmaceutical ingredients containing tropane moiety in their structures are manufactured and used as antispasmodics, anesthetic, and mydriatics (see Figure 5) .
Tropane does not occur naturally in free forms. The favored forms of tropane in plant species are the esters forms. These esters are generally secondary metabolites of the plant species. Tropane esters were isolated from different plant families like Proteaceae, Rhizophoraceae, Euphorbiaceae, and Convolvulaceae, and they are well known to occur in Solanaceae. Most tropane alkaloids in the Solanaceae family arises from the esterification of acids, such as acetic acid, propanoic acid, isobutyric acid, isovaleric acid, 2-methylbutyric acid, tifilic acid (+)-α-hydroxyl-β-phenylpropionic acid, tropic acid, and atropic acid with various hydroxytropanes (α-tropane-diol or α-tropane-triol) . Almost all of the tropane-based pharmaceuticals are natural or semisynthetic esters [5, 17, 18]. There are also alkylated or arylated tropane compounds known as phenyltropane (Figure 6).
2. Chemistry of tropane alkaloid synthesis routes
Although there are many synthetic routes, Robinsons one-pot synthesis of tropane and its derivatives designed in 1917  is still the best choice for the synthesis of such compounds. The parameters have been changed from time to time in order to increase yield to synthesize a specific derivative (Figure 7).
2.1 Synthesis of tropan-2-yl derivatives
The naturally occurring alkaloid, cocaine (6), possesses a functional group at C-2 in the tropane ring system, which has been modified to give various 2-aminotropanes. Willstatter , in his work devoted to the elucidation of the structure of ecgonine (3), obtained the amide (11) which it degraded by Hofmann reaction to 2α-aminotropane (12) (the α-configurations retained throughout this sequence can be assigned for later work) (Figure 8) .
Willstatter also obtained (12) by Curtius reaction of the ester (13), and this reaction has been used earlier by Fodor  to obtain the amino alcohols (14) and (15), although, again, the configurations at C-2 and C-3 were not known when the work was carried out (Figure 9).
Apart from these isolated examples, the most consistent interest in 2-substituted tropanes was shown in connection with the alkaloid dioscorine (16), which was for some time thought to have structure (17) and therefore to be related to tropan-2-one (18). This ketone is an optically active form, which was first prepared by Bell and Archer from ecgonine (3) (Figure 10) .
The action of phosphoryl chloride on ecgonine (3) was shown by Einborn to give the acid chloride of anhydroecgonine (19) . Bell and Archer converted the crude acid chloride directly to the corresponding amide (20), from which L-(+)-tropan-2-one (18) was obtained in fair yield by Hofmann reaction (Figure 11).
When this material was compared with the ketone obtained by degradation of dioscorine (16), the two could not be distinguished , and it was left to Pinder and his co-workers to prove that dioscorine was not in fact a tropane derivative . Pinder found that tropidine (21) reacts with the more usual peracid oxidizing agents to give the N-oxide (22), and in acid solution no reaction took place . However, the action of trifluoroperacetic acid on tropidine trifluoroacetate salt (23) gave the 2β,3β-epoxide (24). Reduction of the epoxide with lithium aluminum hydride yielded tropan-3-β-o1 (25), but it was found impossible to oxidize this amino alcohol to tropan-2-one (18) (Figure 12).
A synthesis of the desired ketone was eventually achieved by a larger route. Treatment of 2-ethoxycarbonyl-pyrrole (26) with phosphoryl chloride and dimethylformide yielded the two isomeric aldehydes, (27) and (28), which were separated fairly easily by fractional distillation in vacuum. Thereafter the crucial stage, a Dieckmann cyclization, led to the β-ketoester (29), which hydrolyzed and was decarboxylated to tropan-2-one (18), outlined in Figure 13 .
Pinder resolved the racemic product into its optically active components and discovered that (+)-tropan-2-one (18) was quite different from the ketone derived from the alkaloid dioscorine (16). With this demonstration that dioscorine (16) was not a tropane derivative, the interest in 2-substituted tropanes diminished, and few papers concerned with these compounds have appeared since 1962.
Tropane-2-one (18) is a convenient source of both tropan-2-αβ-ols. Reduction of the ketone with lithium aluminum hydride yields tropan-2α-ol (25), which is the expected, equatorial product [23, 26]. Reduction of a cyclic ketone with sodium alcohol mixtures also usually gives the thermodynamically more stable, equatorial alcohol , but with sodium in propan-2-ol, pentan-3-ol, tropan-2-one gave mixtures of tropan-2β-ol (30) and tropan-2α-ol (25)  (Figures 13 and 14). Moreover, when the ratio of alcohol to alkoxide ion at the end of the reaction was increased, the product was found to contain increasing amounts up to 90% of tropan-2β-ol (30). These facts suggested that the axial alcohol (25) is more stable thermodynamically, and this was confirmed by subjecting the pure equatorial isomer (25) to equilibration by means of sodium 2-pentoxide in pentan-3-ol containing 10% fluorenone: the equilibrium mixture contained 85% of the axial isomer (25) .
This reversal of the usual axial equatorial stability relationship may be attributed to the presence of strong, intramolecular hydrogen bonding between the axial hydroxyl group and the nitrogen bridge (31). When the possibility of hydrogen bond formation is removed, as in the anions (32) and (33), the equatorial configuration becomes more stable. When the ratio of free alcohol to alkoxide ion at the end of the sodium alcohol reduction is large, the equilibrium will be mainly between the two alcohols (25) and (30); in these conditions, the product will contain a high proportion of the more stable, axial alcohol. Conversely, when the final proportion of alkoxide ion in the reaction mixture is high, a significant equilibrium between anions (32) and (33) will exist, and the product will contain a higher proportion of the equatorial alcohol (30), arising from the more stable anion (32) (Figure 15). These stability relationships enable a useful control of the product ratio to be exercised.
Two further preparations, of 2-halotropanes, are worthy of note. Nickon found that the addition of 1 molar equivalent of bromine to a methanolic solution of tropinone (10) yielded a granular complex, which rearranged to 2β-bromotropinone (34), by spontaneous transition under ether or by acid catalysis . Earlier, Hobson and Riddell obtained 2β-chlorotropane (36) by decomposition of the
Although tropan-2-one (18) appeared to be a very convenient synthetic precursor of both tropan-2α-ol (30) and tropan-2β-ol (25), the ketone itself was not easy to prepare. The ketone may be obtained in good yield from ecgonine (3) or cocaine (6), but these alkaloids are expensive. The alternative starting material used by Pinder and co-workers, 2-ethoxycarbonyl-pyrrole (26), is also expensive, and the subsequent synthesis was too long for it to be useful for the preparation of large amount of tropan-2-one.
2.2 Synthesis of tropan-2β-ol (21) from tropinone (10)
Tropinone (10) was available in reasonable quantities and was chosen as a convenient source of tropane derivatives. Reduction of this ketone with borohydride gave a mixture of the epimeric tropan-3-ols (38), which were dehydrated to tropidine (21) by Landenburg’s method  as it can be seen in Figure 17.
An allylic oxidation of tropidine (21) with selenium dioxide  to yield a β-unsaturated ketone (39) was an attractive prospect, but this could not be realized: there was no apparent reaction in aqueous dioxin after 50 hours on a boiling water bath. Other allylic reagents, such as
Goering and Mayer  have reported that optically pure bicyclo[3.2.1]oct-2-ene (41) reacts with tert-butyl perbenzoate, in the presence of cuprous ion, to give racemic of (42) presumably via a symmetrical allyl radical (Figure 19).
Epoxidation of unreactive olefins with trifluoroperacetic acid is usually carried out in dichloromethane with phosphate present to buffer the trifluoroacetic acid that is a product of the reaction . The epoxidation of
For example, the epoxidations of (44) and (45) proceeded smoothly with benzonitrile and hydrogen peroxide to (46) and (47), respectively (Figure 22), whereas (44) was found to undergo Baeyer-Villiger cleavage with peracetic acid . The reaction of
2.3 Synthesis of 2-(
p-toluenesulphonyl) tropane-2-ene: anhydroecgonine analog
As mentioned earlier, molecules that contained tropane structure, for example, tropane (1), ecgonine (2), tropinone (3), and cocaine (4) or one of its fragments, show central stimulating effects [40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45], using them as anticholinergic agents [46, 47].
Much of the modification designs involved isomeric studies . Most of the modifications came to the tropane moiety, the bridge nitrogen (N8) , or modification at the C2 position . Many processes for synthesizing anhydroecgonine derivatives without using cocaine as a starting material have been reported in literature. For example, it was shown by Grundmann and Ottman  as well as Okano and Osamu  that the reaction of ethyl cycloheptatriene-7-carboxylate (49) with methylamine gave anhydroecgonine ethyl ester (50) (Figure 23). Conversion of the corresponding carboxylic acid to tropane-2-one has been accomplished by Bell and Archer  in a four-step sequence involving conversion to the carboxamide and Hofmann degradation with sodium hypochlorite.
Because (49) was not readily available, Hobson et al.  as well as Okano and Itoh  developed a relatively inexpensive route starting with corresponding cyano-derivatives which is readily accessible by reaction of tropylium fluoroborate (51) with sodium cyanide to give (52). The nitrile (52) was reacted with methylamine in t-butanol to give the 2-cyano tropidine (53) in high yield (see Figure 24).
In our work on the 1,3,5-cycloheptatriene-2-ylphosphorus derivatives (54) and (55) (Figure 25), little success was achieved in obtaining isolable products from reactions with nitrogen nucleophiles, except in those cases, for example, pyrrole2-aldehyde, where the presence of aldehyde group enabled the intermediate ylide to be trapped .
Investigation of the behavior of the 2-(
Its mass spectrum showed a molecular ion peak at m/e 277, and the IR spectrum showed a band at 1600 cm−1 characterizing the double bond. Identification of this compound was confirmed by the 1H-NMR spectrum, which showed signals at δ 3.15 and 3.45 due to the bridgehead protons, H1 and H5; a 1-H multiplet at 6.82 as well as upfield protons between 1.2 and 2.8 ppm (see Structure 57, a = Me).
Similarly the sulfone (56a) was refluxed with an excess of
In the case of the reaction of (56a) with benzylamine, a slightly different result was obtained. The product was obtained as needles, mp 172°C, and elemental analysis, mass spectroscopy, and spectral data confirmed the structure (60) (Figure 28).
The mechanism for the formation of compounds (57a–d) and (60) presumably involves in the first step of the Michael addition of the amine to C1 of the sulfone (56a) to give intermediate compound (61). Further base-catalyzed isomerization gives the compound (62), followed by intramolecular Michael addition which would lead to the compounds (63a–d) and (60) (Figure 29). In the case of the compound (63a–d), further isomerization to the conjugated sulfone took place which was presumably facilitated by the presence of the strong bases, methylamine (pKa 10.659),
The total absence of 2-(
Attempts to react the sulfone (56a) with ammonia were unsuccessful; a solution of the sulfone (58a) in dry acetonitrile was refluxed and ammonia bubbled through for 24 hours. The only product to be isolated was a small quantity of what appeared to be, from its spectral properties, a pure toluene-
The tropane alkaloids made a great contribution to the history of medicine. Intensive research on chemistry and pharmacology of tropane alkaloids led to a fast development of pharmaceutical industries, particularly drugs that have anticholinergic effects. Since the first one-pot synthesis of tropane-3-one by Robinsons in 1917, several routes for synthesizing semisynthetic and synthetic tropane derivatives were published in literature. Chemical synthetic routes from different disciplines and field of research combined in this chapter, in an attempt to illustrate how through continual research, facilitate and develop synthetic chemistry of tropane derivatives. However, the synthesis of the famous tropane derivative, anhydroecgonine from 7-(
Lounasmaa M, Tamminen T. The tropane alkaloids. In: Cordell GA, editor. The Alkaloids. Vol 44, Chemistry and Pharmacology. New York: Academic Press; 1993. pp. 1-115
Jirschitzka J, Schmidt GW, Bernd MR, Schneider JG, D’Auria JC. Plant tropane alkaloid biosynthesis evolved independently in the Solanaceae and Erythroxylaceae. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2012; 109(26):10304-10309. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1200473109
Robins RJ, Abraham TW, Parr AJ, Eagles J, Walton NJ. The biosynthesis of tropane alkaloids in Datura stramonium: The identity of the intermediates between N-methylpyrrolinium salt and tropinone. Journal of the American Chemical Society. 1997; 119(45):10929-10934. DOI: 10.1021/ja964461p
Fodor G. The tropane alkaloids. In: Manske RHF, editor. The Alkaloids; Chemistry and Physiology. Vol. XIII. New York: Academic Press; 1971. pp. 351-396
Gyermek L. Structure-activity relationships among derivatives of dicarboxylic acid esters of tropine. Pharmacology & Therapeutics. 2002; 96:1-21
Leake CD, Pelikan EW. An historical account of pharmacology to the 20th century (book review). Journal of Clinical Pharmacology. 1976; 16:669-671
Sneader W. Plant products analogues and compounds derived from them. In: Sneader W, editor. Drug Discovery; A History. Chichester: Wiley & Sons, Ltd; 2005. pp. 115-150
Holmes HL, Manske RHF. The Alkaloids. New York: Academic Press; 1961
Saxton JE. The Alkaloids. New York: Academic Press; 1965
Kitamura Y, AtsukoTaura YK, Miura H. Conversion of phenylalanine and tropic acid into tropane alkaloids by Duboisia leichhardtiiroot cultures. Journal of Plant Physiology. 1992; 140(2):141-146. DOI: 10.1016/S0176-1617(11)80924-7
Humphrey AJ, O'Hagan D. Tropane alkaloid biosynthesis. A century old problem unresolved. Natural Product Reports. 2001; 18(5):494-502. DOI: 10.1039/B001713M
Nakaima K, Hashimoto T. Two tropine reductases, that catalyze opposite stereospecific reductions in tropane alkaloid biosynthesis, are localized in plant root with different cell-specific patterns. Plant & Cell Physiology. 1999; 40:1099-1107
Robins RJ, Walton NJ. The alkaloids: Chemistry and pharmacology. 1993; 44:115-187
Camps P, Munoz-Torrero D. Cholinergic drugs in pharmacotherapy of Alzheimer’s disease. Mini Reviews in Medicinal Chemistry. 2002; 2:11-25
Chin YW, Kinghorn AD, Patil PN. Evaluation of the cholinergic and adrenergic effects of two tropane alkaloids from Erythroxylum pervillei. Phytotherapy Research. 2007; 21:1002-1005
Christen P. Tropane alkaloids: Old drugs used in modern medicine. In: Rahman A, editor. Studies in Natural Products Chemistry, Bioactive Natural Products, Part C. Vol. 22. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science and Technology; 2000. pp. 717-749
Majewski M, Lazny R. Synthesis of tropane alkaloids via enantioselective deprotonation of tropinone. The Journal of Organic Chemistry. 1995; 60:5825-5830
Maksay G, Nemes P, Biro T. Synthesis of tropeines and allosteric modulation of ionotropic glycine receptors. Journal of Medicinal Chemistry. 2004; 47:6384-6391
Oksman-Caldentey KM. Tropane and nicotine alkaloid biosynthesis—Novel approach towards biotechnological production of plant derived pharmaceuticals. Current Pharmaceutical Biotechnology. 2007; 8:2003-2010
Robinson R. Journal of the Chemical Society, Transactions. 1917; 111:762-768. DOI: 10.1039/CT9171100762
Willstätter R, Müller W. Ueber die Constitution des Ecgonins. Berichte der Deutschen Chemischen Gesellschaft. 1898; 31(3):2655-2669
de Jong AWK. Some properties of the ecgonines and their esters. III: The α. β-position of the double bond in ecgonidine, the structural formulae and autoracemisation of the ecgonines. Recueil des Travaux Chimiques des Pays-Bas. 1937; 56(7):678-680
Fodor G, Kovács Ö. 478. The stereochemistry of the tropane alkaloids. Part III. The configuration of scopolamine and of valeroidine. Journal of the Chemical Society (Resumed). 1953:2341-2344
Bell MR, Archer S. Ethyl 3α-phenyltropane-3β-carboxylate and related compounds. Journal of the American Chemical Society. 1960; 82(17):4638-4641
Einhorn A. Ueber Ecgonin. Berichte der Deutschen Chemischen Gesellschaft. 1887; 20(1):1221-1229
Ayer DE, Büchi G, Warnhoff PR, White DM. The structure of dioscorine. Journal of the American Chemical Society. 1958; 80(22):6146
Davies WAM, Pinder AR, Morris IG. The synthesis and resolution of (±)-tropan-2-one. Tetrahedron. 1962; 18(4):405-412
Davies WAM, Jones JB, Pinder AR. 703. An alkaloid of Dioscorea hispida, dennstedt. Part VI. Some investigations on the synthesis of tropan-2-one. Journal of the Chemical Society (Resumed). 1960:3504-3512
Barton DHR. The stereochemistry of cyclohexane derivatives. Journal of the Chemical Society (Resumed). 1953:1027-1040
Riddell WD. Ph.D. thesis. Birmingham; 1968
Hobson JD, Riddell WD. Transannular cyclisations of cyclo-olefinic N-chloro-amines. Chemical Communications (London). 1968; 19:1178-1180
Archer WL, Cavallito CJ, Gray AP. Bisammonium salts. Unsymmetrical derivatives of tropane and related bases1. Journal of the American Chemical Society. 1956; 78(6):1227-1228
Rabjohn N. Selenium dioxide oxidation. Organic Reactions. 1949; 5:331-386
Hobson JD, McCluskey JG. Cleavage of tertiary bases with phenyl chloroformate: The reconversion of 21-deoxyajmaline into ajmaline. Journal of the Chemical Society C: Organic. 1967:2015-2017
Georing HL, Mayer U. Journal of the American Chemical Society. 1964; 88:3753-3760
Emmons WD, Pagano AS. Peroxytrifluoroacetic acid. IV. The epoxidation of olefins1. Journal of the American Chemical Society. 1955; 77(1):89-92
Payne GB, Deming PH, Williams PH. Reactions of hydrogen peroxide. VII. Alkali-catalyzed epoxidation and oxidation using a nitrile as co-reactant. The Journal of Organic Chemistry. 1961; 26(3):659-663
Payne GB. A simplified procedure for epoxidation by benzonitrile-hydrogen peroxide. Selective oxidation of 2-allylcyclohexanone. Tetrahedron. 1962; 18(6):763-765
Wiberg KB. The mechanisms of hydrogen peroxide reactions. I. The conversion of benzonitrile to benzamide. Journal of the American Chemical Society. 1953; 75(16):3961-3964
Ogata Y, Sawaki Y. The alkali phosphate-catalyzed epoxidation and oxidation by a mixture of nitrile and hydrogen peroxide. Tetrahedron. 1964; 20(9):2065-2068
Iewin AH, Naseree T, Carroll FI. A practical synthesis of (+) cocaine. Journal of Heterocyclic Chemistry. 1987; 24:19-21. DOI: 10.1002/jhet.5570240104
Katoh T, Kakiya K, Nakai T, Nakamura S, Nishide K, Node M. A new divergent synthesis of (+) and (-) ferrugine utilizing PLE-catalysed asymmetric dealkoxycarbonylation. Tetrahedron: Asymmetry. 2002; 13:2351-2358
Lazny R, Sienkiewicz M, Olenski T, Urbanczyk-Lipkowska Z, Kalicki P. Approches to the enantioselective of ferrugine and its analogues. Tetrahedron. 2012; 68:8236-8244
Singh S. Chemistry design, and structure-activity relationship of cocaine antagonists. Chemical Reviews. 2000; 100:925-1024
Zakusov VV, Kostochka LM, Skoldinov AP. Effect of cocaine molecule fragements on the central nervous system. Biulleten' Eksperimental'noĭ Biologii i Meditsiny. 1978; 86(10):435-438
Takahashi T, Hagi T, Kitano K, Takeuchi Y. 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of 1-methyl-3-oxidopyridinium and sulfonylethenes. A synthesis of 2-tropanols and monofluorinated 2-tropanol. Chemistry Letters. 1989; 18:593-596. DOI: 10.1246/cl.1989.593
Ronald WW, El-Fawal HAN, John FG, Lung CC, Tali S. Anhydroecogonine compounds and their use as anticholinergic agents. Us 582149 A; 13 October 1998
Gino RT, Burtan MB. Anticholinergic compound. Us 4467095 A; 21 August 1984
Lazer ES, Aggarwal ND, Hite GJ, Neiforth KA, Kelleher RT, Spealman RD, et al. Synthesis and biological activity of cocaine analogs I: N-alkylated norcocaine derivatives. Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences. 1978; 67:1656-1658. DOI: 10.1002/jps.2600671204
Atkinson ER, Mcritchie DD. The Journal of Organic Chemistry. 1971; 36:3240
Grundmann C, Ottmann G. Ein Neuer Synthetischer Weg In Die Tropan-Reihe. European Journal of Organic Chemistry. 1957; 605:24-32. DOI: 10.1002/jlac.19576050105
Kyoko O, Osamu I. Process for synthesizing anhydroecyonine derivative. Us 6596868 B2; 22 July 2003
Bell MR, Archer S. Journal of the American Chemical Society. 1958; 80:6149
Hobson JD, Bastable JW, Dunkin IR. Solvolytic rearrangements of azabicyclic compounds. Part 2. Kinetics. Journal of the Chemical Society, Perkin Transactions 1. 1981:1346-1351. DOI: 10.1039/P19810001346
Kyoko O, Osamu I. Reacting a cycloheptatriene derivative with a primary amine or ammonia in presence of bas. Us 0020096 A1; 2001
Alsamarrai ASH, Hobson JD. Synthesis of novel heterocyclic compounds by nuclophilic addition reaction of nitrogen nuclophilic to 2-cycloheptatrienylphosphonium fluoroborate, Jordan. Journal of Applied Sciences. 2000; 2(3):56-64
Alsamarrai ASH. Synthesis of 2-( p-toluenesulphonyl) tropane-2-ene: Anhydroecgonine analog. 2017; 192:252-254. DOI: 10.1080/10426507.2016.1252363