Properties of the human BS tissues .
Whole-body cryotherapy (WBC) is a highly effective treatment method of a number of serious diseases. The therapeutic effect of WBC is achieved by stimulating cold receptors of the patient’s skin, which provide supercooling of the skin surface to the level of −2°C. To achieve such a temperature of the skin surface, it is necessary to ensure heat removal with intensity not less than 3500 W/m2. Such a heat flux can remove gas with the temperature not higher than −130°C. Procedures lasting less than 2 minutes do not form therapeutic effect. Procedures lasting more than 3 minutes are dangerous for the patient’s health. WBC procedures are carried out in single- and multi-seat devices. Due to the compact placement of the patient in the WBC area, the share of useful heat load on the cryostatting system is up to 70%. In multi-seat installations, the useful heat load share is not more than 50%. During the WBC procedure, consumption of liquid nitrogen per patient is 3.77 kg. For the effective use of WBC technology, it is necessary to determine the general requirements for the power of cooling systems and the temperature of cryostatting of the WBC area.
- whole-body cryotherapy
- supercooling of the skin surface
- heat removal
- useful heat load
- WBC minimum procedure
- cooling gas temperature
Equipment for whole-body cryotherapy (WBC) has been used in clinics around the world for over 40 years [1, 2]. Despite this, until today there is no universally accepted concept describing the mechanism for achieving the healthcare effect of this physiotherapeutic procedure, and the physical conditions of safety and effectiveness of cryogenic cooling of the patient’s skin surface have not been determined [3, 4, 5, 6]. Temperature of the cooling gas and the duration of its contact with the patient’s skin, being the most important technological parameters of WBC, vary over a wide range. The requirements for the power supply capacity of equipment for the implementation of WBC technology are not defined. In such conditions, manufacturers of devices for WBC procedures gradually increase the value of the minimum gas temperature in the WBC cab. Over 40 years of cryotherapeutic system production, the gas temperature declared by manufacturers of devices for WBC has doubled from 98 K in 1978 [1, 2] to 192 K [4, 5, 6, 7]. By increasing the operating temperature of the equipment, manufacturers significantly reduce the cost of its production. For 40 years, the cost of devices for group WBC has decreased by 30 times. Low prices for equipment provide a high level of sales, so the trend of increasing operating temperature of WBC devices persists. An increase in the temperature level is accompanied by a decrease in the power of systems for cryostatting the WBC zone. The newest installations are equipped with refrigerators with a specific power of the electric driver of not more than 1 kW/m3. At a temperature level of 170 K, a refrigerator with such a power has a heat-removing capacity of not more than 400 W/m3, which is comparable with the physiological heat release of a patient under thermal comfort conditions (150 W) .
Unreasonable changes in WBC technology affect the effectiveness of the procedures. Recently, more and more articles appear, the authors of which express doubt that cryotherapy can provide the healthcare effects described in papers published before 1990 [7, 8]. The reason that many modern WBC systems are not able to provide the conditions for obtaining the healthcare effects described in the last century [1, 2] is the increase in gas temperature in the working zone of new installations. This can be seen even from the titles of the articles [1, 8]. The temperature increase from −170°C (102 K) to −110°C (163 K) changes the absolute value of the temperature by 1.6 times, which cannot but affect the intensity of heat removal, the degree of supercooling of the patient’s body surface, etc. From a thermophysical point of view, it is obvious that from 1978 to 2018 the technology, which is commonly referred to as WBC, has qualitatively changed. And, judging by contemporary publications, this qualitative change had a negative impact on the healthcare effectiveness of the procedures, which until recently were successfully used to treat a number of severe diseases: rheumatoid arthritis, bronchial asthma, psoriasis, etc. [9, 10].
In such conditions, the determination of cause–effect relationships between the WBC technological parameters and the magnitude of the healthcare effect acquires high scientific and social significance. Formation of the thermophysical theory of WBC creates a scientific basis for restoring the production of effective cryotherapeutic installations at the modern technical level.
2. Historic reference
The WBC method is based on providing the total contact of the patient’s skin surface with a cryogenic gas. With a contact duration of up to 3 minutes and a gas temperature of less than 140 K, the WBC procedure provides a number of positive effects that are used in treatment practice [11, 12]. The most demonstrative and controlled sign of the WBC effectiveness is the duration of analgesic action, which can last 6–8 hours . The analgesic effect of WBC was first described and used in treatment practice by a Japanese doctor Yamauchi. For the WBC procedures, a special installation was made, called “Cryotium” by the author of the method . The “Сryotium” design was analogously a refrigeration chamber for long-term storage of perishable products. The chamber was separated from the environment by the lock chamber (Figure 1), which was supposed to reduce the loss of cold air from the main chamber.
Given the relatively large size of the chamber, several patients were undergoing the WBC procedures simultaneously (from 5 to 12). To obtain cryogenic temperatures, liquid nitrogen was fed to the “Cryotium” heat exchangers instead of freon. The “Сryotium” design appeared by chance. Yamauchi believed that in order to obtain the maximum treatment outcome, the maximum decrease in temperature should be used. This condition became the basis of the design. To reduce the cost of manufacturing “Сryotium,” Japanese engineers used the insulating structure and heat exchangers of the serial refrigeration chamber. The temperature regime in the chamber volume was determined by the requirement of the inadmissibility of air condensation on the surface of a heat exchanger. The temperature of the outer surface of the heat exchanger must be higher than the condensation temperature :
The removal of heat from air to the surface of the heat exchanger was carried out by natural convection.
With natural convection, the calculated temperature gradient between the gas and the heat-removing surface is 20 K:
Minimum possible air temperature in the cab:
The value of the air temperature during the WBC sessions specified by the method’s author  is the lowest possible temperature that could be achieved in this cab design. It is important to note that in “Сryotium” the temperature was maintained by choosing the pressure of liquid nitrogen (LN) vapor in the heat exchanger tubes (Figure 2). The boiling point of LN depends on pressure; by increasing the vapor pressure to a level of
Thus, the “Сryotium” design determined the WBC technology. Perhaps, that is why the author of the method did not give any reason for the WBC temperature regime in his works. The ratios of the boiling points of nitrogen and air, as well as the design features of the device in which the procedures were performed, have randomly created the conditions for a safe and highly efficient procedure.
Yamauchi used the WBC method for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis ; the technique was so effective that it quickly spread to the countries of Western Europe. In Poland and Germany, devices similar to “Cryotium” were put in production. European manufacturers have tried to reproduce the Japanese installation on the base of available information but, for unknown reasons, have changed the basic operating principle of “Cryotium.” This is translated into an increase in the minimum operating temperature from −170 to −160°C . A slight increase in temperature led to a whole chain of changes in cooling technology, which caused a gradual decrease in the efficiency of European (Polish and German) installations for WBC. As already shown above, the temperature level of −170°C was maintained in “Cryotium” without using a temperature control system, only through relief of excess pressure in the LN vapor line (Figure 2a).
The liquid level controller (YC) in the heat exchangers of the “Сryotium” installation according to the sensor signals of the Y level controls the operation of the solenoid valve (SV), through which LN enters the system. The cryogenic liquid enters the heat exchanger (HE) tubes, where it partially evaporates due to the supply of heat from the procedural room air. Vaporization reduces the flow density in the tubes; the vapor–liquid mixture is pushed out from the top of the heat exchanger to the liquid separator (LS). In this apparatus, liquid and vapor are separated. The liquid flows into the lower section of the heat exchanger (HE) and again participates in the removal of heat. LN vapors accumulate at the top of the liquid separator (LS). The vapor pressure is controlled by a safety valve (V), which opens at a pressure of 0.22 MPa. The vapor pressure determines the LN boiling point and the temperature of the tubes of the heat exchanger (HE), which must meet condition (1). The air temperature in the main “Cryotium” cab at the presence of patients rises to −170°C. In the pauses between the procedures, when the heat load on the cooling system is reduced by 10 times , the air temperature in the main cab approaches the temperature of the heat exchanger tubes:
The air temperature in the cab remains at the minimum possible level. In European installations, the air temperature in the cab is controlled by the temperature controller (TC), which, by signals from the temperature sensor (S), opens the liquid nitrogen supply valve (SV). In order to maintain the temperature at −160°C, the TC limits the supply of LN to the heat exchanger (HE) in the period when there are no patients in the cab. The LN level decreases until the sensor (S) registers the set temperature. The upper sections of the heat exchanger (HE), through which the nitrogen passes in the vapor state, are heated to a temperature close to the air temperature in the chamber. The temperature of the inner tube surfaces exceeds the LN boiling point by more than 20 K:
When patients enter the main cab, relatively warm air enters from the lock chamber ( ). Because of this, the air temperature in the cab increases by 50 K or more. The temperature controller opens the SV and resumes the supply of LN to the heat exchanger (HE). However, it takes some time to fill the tubes of the heat exchanger; moreover, the temperature of the upper sections of the heat exchanger (HE) exceeds the boiling point of nitrogen by more than 20 K. Because of this, the LN film boiling occurs at which the intensity of heat removal to the liquid is much lower; therefore, the vapor–liquid mixture passes the heat exchanger (HE) and is discharged through valve (V) into the environment. Under such conditions, the heat exchanger does not cope with heat generation from the surface of the patient’s bodies and cannot restore the specified temperature mode of the chamber until the patients enter the lock chamber. The WBC procedure takes place at a temperature significantly higher than the nominal −160°C . After the patients leave, the thermal load on the cryostatting system is reduced 10 times, the air temperature drops to the nominal level, and the temperature controller stops the supply of LN to the heat exchanger (HE).
The increase in the air nominal temperature in the cab for WBC from −170°C to −160°C fundamentally changed the temperature algorithm of the procedure. The transition to the LN film boiling regime caused a significant overrun of the cryoagent. The operational drawbacks of the nitrogen cooling system and the uncertainty of the air temperature requirements in the main procedural cab created conditions for use in the WBC cryostatting system of three-stage chillers and steam cycles on gas mixtures. Refusing LN resulted in an increase in the nominal temperature in the main cab to −110°C.
Specialists in the field of WBC did not only pay attention to this but also actively promoted the “modernization” of cryotherapy equipment [13, 14, 15]. The ability to refuse to use LN and significantly reduce the costs of WBC procedures turned out to be so attractive that the specialists “did not notice” that the efficiency of the procedures in the “nitrogen-free” installations was 10 times lower than in “Сryotium” . At the beginning of the twenty-first century, “Criohome” “cryotherapeutic” devices with a nominal temperature of −85°C was used for WBC procedures, i.e., the tendency to increase the temperature persists. Since 1985, the Russian direction of devices for WBC has been developing independently, based on the use of single-seat installations with a nitrogen cooling system (cryosaunas). The temperature in the cab of a single-seat cryosauna during the whole procedure is no higher than −130°C. The conditional constancy of temperature fundamentally changes the degree of supercooling of the skin surface; therefore, cryosaunas ensure the effectiveness of WBC at the level of the original technology implemented in “Cryotium” but with less energy loss. The current state of WBC in Europe is a consequence of the 40-year use of the method in the absence of a reliable concept of the method for obtaining the cryotherapeutic effect and the uncertainty of the technological requirements to specialized equipment [3, 4, 5]. In such conditions, manufacturers of WBC installations have flooded Europe with installations that, by their therapeutic efficacy, do not differ from traditional hypothermia. The popularization of the thermophysical theory of WBC will stop the regression of cryotherapy in Europe and the world.
3. Thermophysical theory of WBC
The WBC thermophysical theory was formulated at St. Petersburg National Research University of Information Technologies, Mechanics and Optics (ITMO University) in order to overcome the uncertainty of the technological requirements for specialized devices for WBC. In developing the theory, information on the conduct of WBC procedures and their effectiveness was used [1, 2, 7, 13]. As a criterion for optimizing the WBC technology, it is reasonable to use the duration of the analgesic effect of cryotherapy. The duration of the analgesic effect or effective time (WBC ET) is easy to determine in practice. To carry out computational experiments at ITMO University, a method was developed for calculating the WBC ET , which made it possible to perform studies on the optimization of the WBC technology in the mode of numerical experiment.
To calculate the WBC ET, a formula is proposed that relates the positive effect with the degree of approaching the skin surface temperature (
The maximum duration of WBC (τmax) is determined taking into account the requirements of the patient’s hypothermic safety, which limit the permissible changes in body temperature on the surface (
Compliance with the established limitations of changing the value of
Figure 3 shows a graphical representation of the patient’s body shell (BS). BS is the outer layer of the body, the mass of which is 30% of the total body mass. BS consists of three types of tissues: epithelium 1, adipose tissue 2, and muscle tissue 3. Layers 1 and 2 endure significant hypothermia without any harm; patient’s safety is ensured when the violation of the normal temperature distribution does not extends beyond the inner boundary of the BS . In the normal state
The simplified physical model of a human BS has become the basis of a mathematical model.
4. Mathematical model of the human body shell
BS is a relatively thin surface layer. The calculated thickness of the BS of an average human is Δ
The energy equation allows you to simulate thermal processes associated with significant changes in the temperature of the study object. The energy equation describes well the processes of changing the state of aggregation; this provides the mathematical model with certain advantages compared to models built based on the heat transfer equation . When replacing derivatives with difference approximants, it is possible to obtain an algebraic expression suitable for automated calculations:
Solving Eq. (8) with respect to the value of enthalpy at the new time layer , we get:
The structure of the cooling object and temperature distribution in the BS layers are described above (Figure 3). Thermophysical properties of the human body shell tissues are shown in Table 1.
|Tissue||ρ, kg/m3||φ, %||
Due to the high water content (φ), all human BS tissues have a high heat capacity, which ensures the accumulation of a significant amount of heat. The heat accumulated in the tissues protects the organs of the body core (BC), heart, lungs, kidneys, and liver from frigorism at a sharp decrease in ambient temperature. Thermal balance of the BS area element
determined by the ratio of the intensity of the heat fluxes transferred by the thermal conductivity of the tissue along the
At BS boundaries, heat transfer is described by boundary conditions. For the outer boundary, the intensity of the convective heat removal is calculated:
where α means the heat transfer coefficient at the natural convection of gas or liquid, , and W/(m2·K); means the temperature of the heat-removing medium, K.
On the inner BS boundary, the temperature of the tissues during WBC does not change and is equal to the body core temperature (0):
Eq. (10) describes the change in the heat content of tissues over time , and in order to form the trial of the WBC technology issues, a similar dependence for temperature should be obtained . At each time step, the temperature value is calculated from the known value of the enthalpy of the array elements:
The described algorithm of computations forms the mathematical model of the human BS, which is suitable for studies of processes of the therapeutic effect of low-temperature liquids and gases.
5. Thermophysical bases of achievement of the WBC healthcare effect
The mathematical model of the human BS allowed us to perform a numerical experiment to study the physical bases of the WBC healthcare efficacy. Quite often [4, 5] WBC is compared with the cold water immersion procedures. The basis for this comparison is that cryogenic gas and cold water remove a significant amount of heat from the body surface. Moreover, under conditions of natural convection, the coefficient of heat transfer from a source of heat to gas is usually 10 times lower than when heat is removed by water . In reliance on this information, attempts to replace WBC with cheaper water procedures have been ongoing for 40 years . Proponents of such a replacement do not take into account the fact that the WBC ET is more than 360 minutes, and water treatments provide pain relief for a maximum of 30 minutes. Such a difference in efficiency should be based on the fundamental differences between the results of heat removal by liquid and gaseous heat carrier.
Simulation of the BS surface cooling process with water with a temperature of 273 K and a cryogenic gas with a temperature of 140 K has allowed revealing such a difference (Figure 4), which reduces to the level of the minimum surface temperature of the cooling object. In cold water, the minimum surface temperature of the cooling object is at least 5.5°C. As the temperature difference between the water and the cooled surface decreases, the intensity of convective heat removal to water decreases to less than 950 W/m2 . The intensity of heat supply from the inner layers of the body to the surface, on the contrary, approaches the level of 880 W/m2. Due to the small difference in heat fluxes at the boundary of the cooling object, the rate of temperature decrease
The use of a cryogenic gas with a temperature of 140 K for cooling the BS surface gives a completely different picture. The graph of surface temperature changes (Figure 3) is almost a straight line, which means that the temperature decreases almost without the rate change:
The minimum temperature value
In the case of cooling with a cryogenic gas, the BS surface is supercooled to the minimum acceptable level. WBC technology is based on the use of this hypothermia to stimulate the cold receptors of the skin. Expression (6) for calculating the duration of positive effects contains a term that allows us to illustrate the intensity of stimulation of cold receptors by changing the temperature of the BS surface. This parameter of the WBC procedure is called the intensity of stimulating action (ISA):
The dependence graph
Data on the amount of heat
The calculated values are given in Table 2. In cryogenic gas, heat removal was 440 kJ/m2, which is 10% more than in cold water. The result obtained is significantly less than that supposed by some WBC popularizers who estimate heat removal from the patient’s body at 1250–2500 kJ/m2 .
|Cooling time, τmax, sec||159||177|
|Minimum surface temperature of the object,
|The minimum temperature at the inner boundary of the fat layer,
|Heat removed by heat carrier from the body surface,
|Heat removed through the inner boundary of the fat layer,
|Heat flux from the body surface at the beginning of the cooling process, , kW/m2||3.5||11.3|
|Heat flux from the body surface at the end of the cooling process, , kW/m2||2.3||0.95|
At the same time, the result obtained is significantly more than can be removed from a WBC device by using 2 kg of liquid nitrogen for one patient’s cooling [6, 10].
The assessment of the power of the specific heat flux, which the BS surface gives to the heat carrier, has essential practical importance. Table 1 shows the maximum values, at the beginning of the procedure, and the minimum values, at the time of completion of the cooling powers of the heat flux to the cold water and the gaseous heat carrier. For designing WBC devices, it is useful to know the mean value of the heat flux, which the heat carrier must remove in a single procedure, 2.9 kW/m2. This value is 29 times greater than the nominal calorific capacity of the human body; therefore, it is often challenged by manufacturers of WBC devices . Estimation of the heat reserve in BS tissues before and after the procedure shows that the heat flux to the heat carrier is provided by the heat capacity of the body shell tissues (Figure 6).
Lowering the surface temperature of the BS creates conditions for increasing heat transfer with thermal conductivity from the deep to the periphery of the body. As a result, there is a change in the distribution of the tissue temperature throughout the entire thickness of the BS. The amount of heat removed from different BS tissues is determined by the enthalpy difference before and after the WBC procedure. Taking into account the constancy of the heat capacity of the tissues in the temperature range from −2 to 40°C , the amount of heat removed can be calculated from the temperature difference:
The amount of accumulated heat removed from one area element:
The total amount of heat released due to supercooling of each of the three types of BS tissues is the sum of portions of heat released in the area elements of this tissue layer:
Part of the heat removed was obtained from internal sources in the epithelial and muscle layers, heat of metabolism
Some of the heat removed came from the patient’s body core; the amount of heat gained can be determined by numerical integration and instantaneous values of the heat flux transferred by thermal conductivity through the inner boundary of the body shell:
The histogram on Figure 7 gives an idea of what is the source of heat removed from the surface of the patient’s body shell. The main share of the heat of 55.2% was gained due to supercooling the epithelial layer. The heat gained by supercooling the fat layer
The calorific capacity of the body does not play any role in the formation of the heat load on the cooling system of the WBC device, which is determined by the heat storage capacity of the body shell tissues. The safety of the WBC procedures is ensured by the correct choice of the contact duration of the body surface with a cryogenic gas. The thermal control system of the body does not affect the safety of procedures.
6. Selecting optimal gas temperature in the WBC zone
In practice, there are two options for carrying out WBC procedures in multi-seat and single-seat installations [7, 21, 22, 23]. The cooling conditions in these installations differ significantly; therefore, the technology of group and individual WBC should be developed separately.
Contrary to the popular belief [7, 13], GWBC and IWBC provide effects on only a fraction of the skin area. In a group installation, the contact area of the cooling gas with the patient’s body in a multi-seat cab is up to 70.5% of the total surface area of the body. In an individual cab, the contact area reaches 66% . Temperature regimes of GWBC and IWBC are fundamentally different.
The GWBC technology was influenced by the design of the device for performing the procedures (Figure 1). Using a low-temperature food storage chamber for WBC procedures, Japanese engineers and doctors were forced to carry out WBC procedures in groups. The dimensions of the chamber were too large for individual procedures. This forced solution is contrary to the general practice of physiotherapy; treatment is always carried out individually.
Systems for implementing technology I, individual cryosaunas, were developed 20 years after multi-seat installations  with consideration of the experience of their operation. Modern installations for IWBC use a nitrogen cooling system (NCS), so they quickly reach a given temperature level and allow you to adjust the temperature of the gas in the WBC zone.
It is impossible to develop universal recommendations on selecting the optimal temperature of the gaseous heat carrier for GWBC and IWBC, since in multi-seat and single-seat installations the algorithm for changing the temperature of the cooling gas during the procedure is different.
To conduct a preliminary analysis of the effect of gas temperature in the WBC zone on the magnitude of the positive effect achieved, it can be assumed that the procedure takes place in isothermal conditions:
It is impossible to implement WBC in the isothermal mode, since it takes some time for the patient to enter the low-temperature zone and exit from it. However, the study of WBC processes in ideal temperature conditions allows us to formulate the general technological conditions of efficiency.
To determine the optimal gas temperature in the WBC zone, the calculated values of the WBC ET obtained by Eq. (6) were used. Simulation of the BS cooling process under conditions of natural gas convection with a temperature from 90 to 190 K allowed us to plot the dependence of the ET value on the gas temperature in the WBC zone (Figure 8).
When isothermally cooling the surface of the patient’s body, the maximum value of ET (325 min) is achieved at a temperature of 140 K. At temperatures below 140 K, the WBC efficiency gradually decreases. At a temperature of 100 K, the value of WBC ЕТ is almost three times lower than the maximum ; therefore, when conducting WBC procedures, it is advisable to use a gas with a temperature from 120 to 140 K . At temperatures above 140 K, the WBC efficiency rapidly decreases. At a temperature of 160 K, the WBC ET of the procedures is 10 times lower than the maximum value and is close to the results achieved during water procedures. The results of the computational experiment on simulation of cooling the body surface with gas with a temperature of 160 K (−110°C) ideally coincide with the results of tests performed by doctors in sports medicine , which in comparing the therapeutic effect of WBC procedures at a temperature of −110°C and water baths with a temperature of 8°C, did not reveal any advantages of the WBC. The results obtained have clear thermophysical reasons. As the temperature of the gaseous heat carrier increases, the intensity of heat removal from the BS surface decreases, and the safe cooling time increases.
When the gas temperature is above 150 K, the danger of supercooling of the body core (
According to the results of simulating the process of cooling the BS surface with a cryogenic gas, it can be argued that for effective procedures the gas temperature in the WBC zone should be not lower than 140 K.
7. Selecting the optimal duration of the WBC procedure
The author of the WBC method, Yamauchi, limited the exposure of the body contact with a cryogenic gas to a period of 180 sec [1, 2]. The minimum air temperature in the Japanese installation was −175°C. According to the contemporary idea that WBC technology is based on metered supercooling of the body shell, the choice of the cooling exposure should be related to the temperature of the gas in the WBC zone. Using the assumption of the constancy of the gas temperature in the WBC zone, it is possible to determine the maximum duration of cooling at different gas temperatures. Computational experiments on the mathematical model of the human BS showed that with an increase in the heat carrier temperature from 90 to 190 K, the safe duration of a patient’s stay in the WBC zone increases from 54 to 237 sec . At a temperature of 140 K, the safe exposure time for cooling is 161 sec. The practice of using WBC has shown that, along with the maximum duration of cooling, it is necessary to limit the minimum duration of stay of patients in a cryotherapeutic installation .
The reasons for this limitation are explained by the graph of dependence
The calculated dependences of the WBC safe exposure (τmax) and the duration of the cooling time (τcool) on the gas temperature (
Numerical experiments on a mathematical model of the human body shell allowed to formulate general ideas about the technological foundations of effective WBC. When developing technological recommendations on the design of installations for the implementation of GWBC or IWBC methods, it is necessary to take into account the algorithm for changing the temperature of the gas in contact with the patient’s body surface.
8. Algorithm for changing the cooling gas temperature during the individual and group WBC procedures
Installations for GWBC consist of two or three heat-insulated rooms with different air temperatures . Patients pass from the treatment room to the chamber with the minimum temperature (main chamber, MC) and back through the lock chambers (LC). In most modern installations, the temperature in the main chamber is maintained at 160 K and in the lock chamber means at 210 K. At the time of entry (exit) of patients into the LC or MC, warmer air enters from adjacent volumes. Because of this, the air temperature in the MC volume increases by at least 25 K. From the body surface of each patient, 3.5 to 4.5 kW of heat is released into the MC volume. Taking into account these factors, the actual GWBC temperature regime depends not only on the choice of the nominal temperatures in MC and LC but also on the power of the cooling system. Another uncertainty factor is the duration of stay of patients in the main cab. There are different opinions about the advisability of pre-cooling the body surface at an intermediate temperature of 210 K. Some researchers believe that a gradual decrease in temperature increases subjective comfort and safety . In other works it is proposed to reduce the time of stay of patients in LC to a minimum . Given all the reasons presented, it is obvious that it is extremely difficult to simulate the GWBC process. The temperature of the cooling gas varies according to a complex schedule, which consists of at least eight stages (Figure 11).
The algorithm of changing the gas temperature in IWBC is much simpler (Figure 11). The patient enters the cab filled with atmospheric air, which is quickly replaced by vapors of liquid nitrogen with a temperature not higher than 140 K. The time to reduce the gas temperature in the IWBC cab to the optimum level depends on the power of the cooling system and is at least 20 sec.
Taking into account the results of simulating the WBC process under conditions of a constant gas temperature, it can be argued that the GWBC procedures using the algorithm shown in Figure 11 do not provide significant therapeutic outcomes. To restore the effectiveness of GWBC, it is necessary to significantly reduce the minimum air temperature in the main treatment cab. Experiments on a mathematical model of the body shell showed that the effectiveness of GWBC reaches the optimal level when the air temperature in the main cab drops to 130 K. However, modern installations for GWBC cannot maintain the temperature at this level, since they use compression cooling systems on gas mixtures . To lower the temperature, it is necessary to use other heat transformation cycles in the cooling system, the power of which will allow compensating for the heat load associated with WBC procedures.
9. The heat load on the cooling system of the WBC zone
When designing cooling systems of the WBC zone, it is necessary to adequately estimate the power of the heat fluxes that need to be compensated. It was shown above that during the WBC procedure, 440 kJ/m2 of the heat is released from the patient’s body surface, and the mean heat flux from the body to the cryogenic heat carrier varies from 3.5 to 2.3 kW/m2 (Table 2). Taking into account the surface area of the body (1.6 m2 ), the heat input from one patient will be 700 kJ; the mean power of the heat input is 4.6 kW. It is necessary to spend at least 2.7 kg of liquid nitrogen only to remove the heat released from a patient’s body surface with a gas with the temperature of
Estimated nitrogen flowrate for removal of the heat from the body surface is 2.7 times higher than in modern nitrogen-cooled WBC installations . To restore the WBC effectiveness, it is necessary to provide cryotherapy installations with sufficiently powerful cooling systems.
The heat input from the patients
The energy efficiency of the installation design for WBC can be estimated by the share of the useful load on the cryostatting system, the coefficient of thermal efficiency:
To estimate the expenditure of energy and select the optimal technology for WBC procedures, it is necessary to conduct a numerical experiment on a mathematical model of a cryotherapeutic device.
10. Mathematical model of cryotherapeutic device
Given the variety of design solutions used in the manufacture of devices for WBC, the mathematical model should have the most generalized form. It is necessary to stop considering particular design features and focus on the fundamental issues. It becomes possible with a one-dimensional model of the WBC zone (Figure 12). The model considers the processes occurring in a volume unit of the WBC zone.
The surface of the patient’s body 1 is cooled with a gaseous heat carrier 2 which fills the volume of the thermal fencing 3. The heat flux is removed from the patient’s body surface
The specific heat input from the patient’s body and the thermal fencing is calculated considering the temperatures of their surfaces:
where α3–2 and α1–2 means the heat transfer coefficients from the thermal fencing and the patient’s body, respectively;
Specific characteristics of devices designed for the implementation of GWBC and IWBC technologies have large differences. In multi-seat installations, the patient accommodation density is 0.4–0.7 person/m3, and the specific volume of free space
In single-seat cryosaunas, the patient accommodation density reaches 2.0 persons/m3, the specific surface area of the patient’s body is 3.2 m2/m3, the thermal fencing area of the WBC zone is 6.4 m2/m3, and the specific free space volume is 84% . High compactness of the patient accommodation is ensured by the fact that the patient does not move during the procedure; therefore, the cab size is comparable to the size of the patient’s body.
The heat input with gas fluxes is determined by the intensity of convective mass transfer of warm gas to the volume of the WBC zone. The heat input by gas convection across the boundary of the WBC zone is determined from the expression:
Large heat flows with gas fluxes are supplied into the WBC zone as patients enter and exit. For example, a multi-seat lock chamber and a cab of a single-seat cryosauna are filled with atmospheric air at the moment patients enter. 93 kJ/m3 of heat enters the lock cab with atmospheric air. When the temperature recovers to the nominal level, the air density in the lock cab increases by 40%; this is accompanied by supplying additional air from the atmosphere, which contributes another 27 kJ/m3 of heat. In one procedure, 120 kJ/m3 of heat transferred by gas convection enters the lock chamber.
The basis of the mathematical model of the WBC zone is a one-dimensional energy equation:
In the ideal case,
To account for material balance in the mathematical model of the WBC zone, the continuity equation is used:
So, the transfer of heat by the thermal conductivity of gas is small; expression (30) is simplified and can be transformed by replacing the derivatives with differential approximants:
The numerical solution of the continuity (Eq. (33)) allows to take into account the input of gas mass to compensate for the change in density:
Eqs. (29), (34) and (35) allow to analyze the processes occurring in the WBC zone during the implementation of individual or group technology. To perform a computational experiment, it is necessary to adopt an algorithm for changing the temperature of the cooling gas for IWBC and GWBC.
Formulation of a temperature algorithm for the IWBC process is relatively simple. let us take the time of filling the zone with a cryogenic gas (Figure 11) τI = 20 sec, τII = 150 sec, and τIII = 10 sec and the gas temperature in the isothermal phase II
By Eqs. (26) and (27), the total heat load on the cooling system and the coefficient of thermal efficiency are calculated. It is assumed that the cooling system covers all types of heat load, so the specific power of the refrigerator electric drive can be determined by the heat load and the value of the coefficient of performance at the current temperature level:
where ε5 means the coefficient of performance and the ratio of the heat removed to expenditure of energy in the refrigerator at the temperature level of 140 K, ε5 = 0.25 W/W.
For the instantaneous values of the calculated power of the system refrigerator, the specific expenditure of energy for cooling the IWBC zone per procedure is calculated:
Let us determine the specific values of the liquid nitrogen flowrate per procedure:
The results of the numerical experiment are summarized in Table 3. In the experiment on simulating the GWBC process, the time algorithm presented on the graph (Figure 11) was used; the nominal gas temperature in the main cab was 130 K. Energy indicators for the main and lock chambers were calculated.
|Features of WBC zone|
|Heat input to the WBC zone|
|The expenditure of electrical energy and liquid nitrogen flowrate for cooling|
The energy efficiency of the technology was estimated by the total energy expenditures in the main and lock chambers. The results of the numerical experiment on simulating the GWBC process are summarized in Table 3.
The data in Table 3 show that WBC procedures require the removal of large amounts of heat from the low-temperature zone. Specific heat input to the IWBC zone is
The energy indicators of the GWBC zone are much lower (Table 3). The specific heat input is
Due to the low compactness of the accommodation of patients in the treatment area, the GWBC thermal efficiency coefficient was 0.49. Under conditions of a single-seat installation, the thermal efficiency coefficient was 0.71, which indicates a more rational expenditure of energy. This is clearly illustrated by the histogram of the structure of the heat load on the cooling system of the IWBC and GWBC zones (Figure 13).
In single-seat installations, the heat storage capacity of the thermal fencing makes a significant contribution to the heat load, due to which the share of heat removed from thermal insulation reaches 24%. At the beginning of each procedure, a single-seat cab is filled with atmospheric air, which heats the inner surface of the thermal insulation. When implementing the GWBC technology, the heat load from the insulation is insignificant means of 9%, but the convective heat supply is 24%. The negative impact of convective heat transfer is determined by a large share of the free space in the low-temperature zone.
The data in Table 3 do not allow giving an unambiguous preference for a particular technology. This is due to the fact that all indicators are related to the volume unit of the WBC zone, while the technological task of the process is to cool the surface of the patient’s body shell. If we calculate the specific heat load values and the expenditure of energy for cooling a unit of the shell surface (Table 4), the advantages of the IWBC technology become indisputable. According to all energy indicators, the IWBC technology is 1.5 times more efficient than the GWBC process.
The performed analysis of the healthcare and energy efficiency of the two options for the implementation of the WBC technology allows us to reasonably give preference to individual procedures that not only combine high healthcare efficiency with relatively low expenditure of energy but also to a greater extent correspond to the traditional principle of individuality of therapeutic techniques.
The effectiveness of WBC technology depends on the choice of the duration of contact with cryogenic gas. The minimum duration of WBC procedure at the optimum gas temperature (−130°С) is 120 s. Meanwhile, one should remove 440 kJ/m2 with an average intensity of at least 2.4 kW/m2 and spend not less than 1.7 kg/m2 of liquid nitrogen on heat removal. The electric drive of the cooling system of WBC zone should have an average power of at least 9.3 kW/m2, and in the case of using nitrogen cooling system, the cryoagent consumption should be not less than 2.4 kg/m2.
The research was supported by the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation (Project 11.4942.2017/6.7).
Yamauchi Y, Yamauchi T, Miura K. The analgesic effects of −170°C whole body cryo-therapy on rheumatoid arthritis (R.A.); curable. Pain. 1987; 30(Supp. 1):S261
Yamauchi T, Yamauchi Y, Miura K, Cooper A. Clinical effects of −170°C whole body cryotherapy (W.B.C.T.) on steroid dependant chronic diseases. Journal of Steroid Bio-Chemistry. 1986; 25(Supp. 1):25
Bouzigon R, Grappe F, Ravier G, Dugue B. Whole- and partial-body cryostimulation/cryotherapy: Current technologies and practical applications. Journal of Thermal Biology. 2016; 61:67-81
Carrard J, Lambert A, Genné D. Transient global amnesia following a whole-body cryotherapy session. BML Case Reports. 2017; 2017
Greenwald E, Christman M, Penn L, Brinster N, Liebman T. Cold panniculitis: Adverse cutaneous effect of whole-body cryotherapy. JAAD Case Reports. 2018; 4:344-345
Rose C, Edwards KM, Siegler J, Graham K, Caillaud C. Whole-body cryotherapy as a recovery technique after exercise: A review of the literature. International Journal of Sports Medicine. 2017; 38:1049-1060. DOI: 10.1055/s-0043-114861
Baranov AY. Low-temperature installations for medical purposes. In: Part 1. Apparatus for General Cryotherapy Treatment: (Textbook). St. Petersburg: University ITMO; IHBT; 2016. p. 178
Costello JT, Donnelly AE, Karki A, Selfe J. Effects of whole body cryotherapy and cold water immersion on knee skin temperature. International Journal of Sports Medicine. 2014; 35:35-40
Cámara-Lemarroy CR, Azpiri-López JR, Vázquez-Díaz LA, Galarza-Delgado DA. Abdominal aortic dissection and cold-intolerance after whole-body cryotherapy: A case report. Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine. 2017; 27:e67-e68
Polidori G, Cuttell S, Hammond L, et al. Should whole body cryotherapy sessions be differentiated between women and men? A preliminary study on the role of the body thermal resistance. Elsevier. Medical Hypotheses. 2018; 120:60-64
Krueger М, Costello JT, Achtzehn S, Dittmar KH, Mester J. Whole-body cryotherapy (−110°C) following high-intensity intermittent exercise does not alter hormonal, inflammatory or muscle damage biomarkers in trained males. Cytokine. 2018; 113:277-284. DOI: 10.1016/j.cyto.2018.07.018
Piras A, Campa F, Toselli S, Rocco DM, Raffi M. Physiological responses to partial-body cryotherapy performed during a concurrent strength and endurance session. Applied Physiology, Nutrition, and Metabolism. 2018. DOI: 10.1139/apnm-2018-0202. [Epub ahead of print]
Zagrobelny Z. Krioterapia Miejscowa I Ogolnoustrojowa. Wroclaw: Urban & Partner. 2003. pp. 189 s. 218
Fricke R, Grapow G, Nobbe T, Knauer G. Ganzkörperkältetherapie bei −110°C von zwei minuten bewirkt steigerung von muskelkraft und leistung. Physikalische Medizin Rehabilitationsmedizin Kurortmedizin. 1999; 9:144
Fricke R. Ganzkörperkältetherapie in einer kältekammer mit temperaturen um −110°C. Physikalische Medizin, Balneologie, Med. Klimatologie. 1989, 18. Jahrgang: pp. 1-10
Baranov AY, Malyshevа TA. Modeling unsteady heat transfer in cryomedicine. Journal of International Academy of Refrigeration. 2000; 2:38-41
Tsyganov DI. Cryomedicine: Processes and Devices. Monograph. Moscow: SAINS-PRESS; 2011. p. 304
Poppendieck W, Faude O, Wegmann M, Meyer T. Cooling and performance recovery o trained athletes: A meta-analytical review. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance. 2013; 8:227-242
Vieira A, Bottaro M, Ferreira-Junior JB, Vieira C, Cleto VA, Cadore EL, et al. Does whole-body cryotherapy improve vertical jump recovery following a high-intensity exercise bout? Open access Journal of Sports Medicine. 2015; 6:49-54
Chernyshev IS. Cryogenic Aerotherapy in Modern Medicine/Toolkit. Moscow: Med-Cryonica LLC; 2010. p. 26
Stanek A, Cholewka A, Gadula J, Drzazga Z, Sieron A, Sieron-Stoltny K. Can whole-body cryotherapy with subsequent kinesiotherapy procedures in closed type cryogenic chamber improve BASDAI, BASFI, and some spine mobility parameters and decrease pain intensity in patients with ankylosing spondylitis? BioMed Research International. 2015; 2015:404259
Rymaszewska J, Ramsey D. Whole body cryotherapy as a novel adjuvant therapy for depression and anxiety. Archives of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy. 2008; 10(2):49-57
Bouzigon R, Ravier G, Dugué B, Grappe F. The use of whole-body cryostimulation to improve the quality of sleep in athletes during high international competitions. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2014; 48:572
Makhaniok AA, Levin ML, Dragun VL. Thermophysigal aspects gas cryotherapy. Founded by the national academy of sciences of Belarus. Physico-Technical Series. 2011; 3:S 59-S 71
Westerlund T, Oksa J, Smolander J, Mikkelsson M. Thermal responses during and after whole-body cryotherapy. Journal of Thermal Biology. 2003:601-608