Screw compressor design parameters.
The various sources of noise in screw compressors have been determined, the most significant of which are gas pulsations and these have been analysed extensively in this chapter. The parameters most affecting them have been identified and different simulation tools have been used to quantify their effect, together with a brief overview of the capabilities of each of them. Resulting from these studies, methods of reducing the pulsations were identified and the improvements resulting from them were predicted. Tests were then carried out on an industrial screw compressor and good agreement was obtained between the predicted and measured levels of noise reduction.
- screw compressor
- gas pulsations
- rotor rattling
- transmission error
Screw compressors are widely used in a number of applications, including refrigeration and air conditioning systems, transportation, the building industry, food processing and the pharmaceutical industry. Their ability to operate with a variety of working fluids and in the presence of injected liquids makes them a preferred choice to other types of compressor.
Over the past 30 years, these machines have been continuously improved, mainly by the introduction of better manufacturing methods, which enabled advanced rotor profiles to be developed. As a result, internal leakage and friction losses between the rotors have been reduced. These and many other improvements have increased their flow capacity, reliability and efficiency.
Screw compressors, however, generate a considerable level of noise during their operation, which sometimes inhibits the scope for their use. In addition, it is becoming increasingly difficult to satisfy new legislation that is focused on controlling noise at its source. More detailed investigation of the causes of noise, in these machines, is therefore necessary. Once these are identified and means of reducing their effect are found, attenuation procedures, such as insulation and absorption, are easier to apply and can reduce noise to even lower levels.
Apart from the direct benefits of noise reduction, there are also indirect benefits, such as in applications with tighter noise regulations, where less efficient types of machine can be replaced by screw compressors, which have higher reliability and lower maintenance costs, thereby bringing further benefits to both their operators and the environment.
Previous research activities have identified three different sources of noise in screw compressors, namely: mechanical noise, fluid flow sources and system vibration. Mechanical sources of noise have been thoroughly investigated by Stošić et al.  and Holmes  who proposed methods for reducing their effects. Investigations of gas pulsations, regarded as the most important fluid source of noise, have been published by different authors. These began in 1986 when Fujiwara and Sakurai  first measured gas pulsations, vibration and noise in a screw compressor. Subsequently, Koai and Soedel [4, 5], developed an acoustic model in which they analysed flow pulsations in a twin screw compressor and investigated their influence upon its performance. More recently, Sangfors [6, 7], Tanttari  and Huagen et al.  developed mathematical models for the prediction of gas pulsations in screw compressor suction and discharge chambers.
These authors explored the influence of various screw compressor parameters upon gas pulsations in the compressor suction and discharge chambers. The influence of the majority of them, which mainly affect the pressure difference between the compressor chambers, will be explained in more detail here. The investigation on gas pulsations carried by Mujić et al.  included the influence of the discharge port shape and area, as other important parameters, previously neglected.
In the present study, the effects of the different influential parameters were evaluated by the use of three different simulation models. A chamber model, which describes the screw compressor working cycle, was developed using MATLAB/SIMULINK. The model is very fast but not capable of predicting higher harmonics accurately. To improve on this, an existing full three-dimensional (3D) CFD model of flow within a screw compressor, and its discharge system, was applied. This model greatly improved the overall accuracy but was too time consuming. As a compromise a third model was developed that combined the best features of the first two. Predictions made with it were obtained in far less computational time with little difference from those obtained from the 3D CFD model, which agreed well with experimental measurements.
The results of the analyses showed that, although many parameters influence the level of gas pulsations, there are no practical means of altering most of them. However, changes in the shape of the compressor discharge port can have a strong effect and can reduce noise, even on existing machines, as was confirmed by tests. For certain working conditions such alterations can cause a minor loss in performance, but, in other cases, they can even lead to improvements.
2. Working principle of screw compressor
Screw compressor operation is based on volumetric changes in all three dimensions. As shown in Figure 1, the compressor consists, essentially, of a pair of meshing helical lobed rotors contained in a casing. The flutes formed between the lobes on each rotor form a series of working chambers in which gas or vapour is contained. Beginning at the top and in front of the rotors, shown on the left, there is a starting point for each chamber where the trapped volume is initially zero. As rotation proceeds in the direction of the arrows, the volume of that chamber increases as the line of contact, between the rotor with convex lobes, known as the male rotor and the adjacent lobe of the female rotor, advances along the axis of the rotors towards the rear. On completion of one revolution, i.e. 360°of the male rotor, the volume of the chamber reaches its maximum and extends, in helical form, along virtually the entire length of the rotor. Further rotation then leads to re-engagement of the male lobe with the succeeding female lobe along a line of contact, starting at the bottom and front of the rotors and advancing to the rear, as shown on the right. Thus, the trapped volume starts to decrease. On completion of a further 360° of rotation by the male rotor, the trapped volume returns to zero.
The dark shaded portions show the enclosed region where the rotors are surrounded by the casing, which fits closely round them, while the light shaded areas show the regions of the rotors, which are exposed to external pressure. Thus, the large light shaded area on the left corresponds to the low pressure port close to shafts A and C while the small light shaded region between shafts B and D on the right corresponds to the high pressure port.
Exposure of the space between the rotor lobes to the suction port, as their front ends pass across it, allows the gas to fill the passages formed between them and the casing until the trapped volume is a maximum. Further rotation then leads to cut-off of the chamber from the port and progressive reduction in the trapped volume. This continues until the rear ends of the passages between the rotors are exposed to the high pressure discharge port. The gas is then expelled through this at approximately constant pressure as the trapped volume returns to zero.
3. Sources of noise within a screw compressor
During the compressor operating cycle, part of the energy is dissipated in the form of flow and mechanical disturbances such as gas pulsations or rotor rattling. These generate both system vibrations and pressure waves, with a range of frequencies and intensity levels, called noise. It is impossible to remove these noise sources completely, but some improvements are possible if efforts are directed towards the reduction of the disturbances created during the compressor working process. To do that, one has to first distinguish between the different mechanisms of noise generation and to classify them according to both their significance and the possibility of their reduction.
3.1. Mechanical sources of noise
The main source of mechanical noise is intermittent contact between the compressor rotors. This is the result of variation in the torque transferred from the male to the female rotor. New and more efficient rotor profiles introduce a very small negative torque to the female rotor compared with that of the male rotor. This torque, generated by the pressure-induced forces acting on the female rotor, is of the same order of magnitude as that created by other means, such as contact friction and oil drag forces. Since the negative female rotor torque acts in the opposite direction to the other two, the net torque may change in sign from negative to positive within one lobe rotation cycle as indicated by Stošić et al. . This may cause instability in the female rotor rotational motion, resulting in flutter and, in the extreme case, rattling. Stošić et al.  proposed a new type of “silent” profile, which maintains positive torque on the female rotor and prevents this kind of noise from occurring.
Holmes  suggested another reason for noise generation, called transmission error. Transmission error occurs in the driven component of a screw pair when its instantaneous angular position differs from the theoretical angular position. This causes, earlier or later than expected, contact between rotor lobes and generates noise. Holmes suggested the reasons for the existence of the transmission error might be lead mismatch, lead non-linearity, pitch errors, housing bore imperfection, bearing deflections and rotor deflection due to the gas forces. Holmes proposed relieving the rotors’ profiles to enable smoother contact between the lobes and reduce noise.
The noise reduction procedures proposed by both resulted in reported overall noise attenuation of 4–6 dBA.
3.2. Fluid sources of noise
According to Sangfors [6, 7], Koai and Soedel [4, 5], Tanttari  and Huagen et al. , gas pulsations are the main source of noise generated by fluid flow in screw compressors. These are created by unsteady fluid flow through the suction and the discharge ports which change the pressure within the suction and discharge chambers. The flow rate depends mainly on the pressure difference between the chambers and starts with the exposure and finishes with the cut-off of the suction or discharge port, as the rotors revolve past them.
A typical frequency spectrum of pressure pulsations in the suction and discharge chambers of the test screw compressor used in this investigation is shown in Figure 2. As can be seen, the gas pulsations are higher in the discharge chamber than in the suction chamber. However, while the discharge port is completely enclosed in its housing, the suction port may be more exposed to its surroundings, which are separated from the atmosphere only by the suction filter. Therefore, despite the smaller pulsations, noise generated in the suction chamber should require similar attention to that generated in the discharge chamber.
Another cause of fluid flow noise in screw compressors is turbulent fluid flow through the ports and the clearance gaps. Soedel  believes that turbulent noise contributes to the overall sound mainly in the higher frequency ranges between 3 and 6 kHz. However, compressor noise in that frequency spectrum is relatively low. So, this source of noise may be neglected.
4. Mathematical modelling of the discharge flow process
As mentioned in the introduction, three models for predicting flow properties within a screw compressor were applied to investigate the influence of the operational parameters and the compressor geometry upon gas pulsations. The first is a thermodynamic chamber model of the processes within a screw compressor, as described by Stošić et al. . The second is a 3D CFD model which calculates the details of the fluid flow within a screw compressor, as given by Kovačević et al. . As will be shown, these models are able to identify the influence of both operation and design parameters upon gas pulsations. However, the 1D model is insufficiently accurate while the 3D model requires excessive computational time.
A third, coupled simulation model was therefore employed to overcome the limitations of the first two. The new model provides a reasonably accurate result without the need for substantial computational time.
4.1. Mathematical model of screw compressor thermodynamics
Thermodynamic models of screw compressor performance [4, 6] have been proved to be useful tools for evaluating the influence of some of the design and operating parameters on gas pulsations in the discharge chamber. The one presented here is based on existing models described in [12, 14]. These were primarily developed to investigate the thermodynamic characteristics of a screw compressor within one working cycle. Starting from there, these models are able to calculate screw compressor integral parameters such as mass flow rate, compressor power, volumetric and adiabatic efficiency, etc. An updated model proposed by Mujić et al.  is able to account for changes in the geometry of the port shapes.
Since the mathematical basis of the model used here has already been well publicised, it will be presented in a very compact form, together with results obtained from it compared with those derived from experimental tests.
As shown in Figure 3, the thermodynamic model of a screw compressor is based on the assumption of five separate control volumes. The working chamber is periodically connected to the suction and discharge chambers through flow areas, which vary with time both in shape and size. The working chamber can also be connected to neighbouring chambers through clearances during the phases of the compressor cycle when the suction and discharge ports are closed. Other chambers are permanently connected to each other through openings of constant size throughout the working cycle.
The model assumes that all thermodynamic values, such as pressure, temperature and density, are uniform within these control volumes. Any one of these control volumes can be considered as an open thermodynamic system, which exchanges fluid mass and energy with the environment, as shown in Figure 4. The mass and energy flowing in and out of any control volume affect the mass and energy level of the fluid trapped inside it.
The equation of mass conservation, which describes mass variation in the control volume, is given in Eq. (1):
This equation is common for all the control volumes within the thermodynamic model. The mass inflow into the control volume consists of the suction flow from the previous control volume, the flow of injected fluid and the leakage flow which enters the control volume. The mass outflow from the control volume is obtained from its discharge flow and the leakage flow that leaves the chamber.
The equation for conservation of internal energy within the control volume may then be written as follows:
The rate of change of internal energy within the control volume is equal to the difference of energy fluxes, which the control volume exchanges with its surroundings, together with the heat transfer through the control volume boundaries and the thermodynamic work.
Other phenomena within the control volume and at its boundaries are modelled by a number of algebraic equations, which describe leakage, inlet and outlet fluid velocities, oil injection and similar effects, and the differential kinematic relations which describe the instantaneous operating volume and how it changes with rotational angle or with time. The model also includes a thermodynamic equation of state of the fluid, required to complete and close the equation set.
4.1.1. Comparison of calculated and experimental results
The pressure history predicted by the thermodynamic model is shown for one of many sets of results in Figure 5. The predictions and measurements cover a set of points obtained for an industrial screw compressor at operational speeds in the 2000–6000 rpm range and discharge pressures in the range of 5–12 bar.
These show that this thermodynamic model accounts very well for changes in the outlet pressure, which affect gas pulsations significantly. The model also takes into account variation of the shaft rotational speed and other compressor operational and geometrical parameters as, for example, changes in the discharge port geometry. The computation time is measured in seconds, when this model is employed. This makes it very useful for the analysis of the influence of any of the above-mentioned parameters on the level of the gas pulsations in the discharge chamber.
Although the results show that the predicted values of gas pulsations in the discharge chamber are in line with the amplitudes corresponding to the compressor fundamental frequency and its first harmonic, as is shown in Figure 6, this model does not predict higher harmonics accurately. This confirms that chamber, or even 1D, models are accurate only for a very narrow frequency range . When averaged, for the amplitudes of the fundamental frequency and its first five harmonics, the prediction is from 40% to 65% in error. This value varies for different working conditions and increases for the higher harmonics.
Koai and Soedel , who used a finite element method, showed that it is possible to achieve better agreement using a 3D model, which accounts for the complex geometry of the compressor discharge port and chamber.
4.2. Full 3D CFD model of a screw compressor
A 3D-CFD grid generation model, established by Kovačević et al. , was used to enable predictions of fluid flow in screw compressors to be made by means of commercial solvers Comet, StarCD or CFX. Pressure fluctuations in the compressor ports, including gas pulsations in the discharge chamber, were thus obtained, including fluid-solid interactions. Also, changes in the compressor geometry could be accounted for by means of a CAD interface.
Following recommendations expressed in , this model captured the higher harmonics more accurately.
4.2.1. Numerical grid of the screw compressor
To apply the calculation procedure, the compressor fluid domain is replaced by a numerical grid. The compressor fluid domain is divided into different fluid domains as shown in Figure 7. The grid consists of both moving and stationary parts.
The numerical mesh of the moving rotors is produced by a specially developed grid generator for screw compressor rotor domains, as described in more detail by Kovačević et al. . The same grid generator may also be used for grid generation of stationary parts of the numerical grid, such as idealised suction and discharge domains. These stationary domains can also be mapped using a commercial grid generator, for example, the one included in Star CCM+, as shown in Figure 7. The generated rotor grid is fully structured while stationary chambers can generally be unstructured and may consist of tetrahedral, hexahedral or polyhedral grid elements, as shown in Figure 7. The relatively simple domains of the inlet and outlet pipes have been discretized with hexahedral grid elements. Once generated, the sub-domains are connected over coinciding boundary regions.
4.2.2. Comparison of calculated and measured results
The numerical grid of the compressor fluid domain consisted of 652,017 grid elements. One discharge process was discretized through 50 time steps. Thus, according to the compressor speed, the size of the time step was in the range of 50–150 μs. The convergence criterion inside one time step was satisfied when residuals dropped by three orders of magnitude.
The gas pulsations predicted by the 3D model are shown in Figure 8, compared with the same set of measurements used for comparison with the thermodynamic model.
As expected, the results presented in the frequency spectra, in Figure 9, show an improvement over those obtained from the thermodynamic model presented in Figure 6. This improvement is mainly due to enhanced prediction of the higher harmonics by including the pressure history within the discharge chamber, while taking account of the discharge chamber geometry.
The 3D model estimates non-uniform distribution of the pressure and other flow properties across the control volume, which creates pressure waves that affect the measurements.
Although the 3D model provided more accurate results, the time required for calculation was much longer than that for the thermodynamic model. The calculation of this case required between 24 and 30 hours on a PC with a 2.8 GHz Intel Xeon Dual Core processor and 2.5 GB RAM. Therefore, the evaluation of a number of different influential parameters could take weeks or even months. A new simulation model was therefore proposed to preserve the accuracy of the 3D model while reducing the calculation time.
4.3. Coupled model
The use of coupled models which combine a thermodynamic chamber model with a 3D model has been proposed to estimate pressure and flow changes in IC engine systems . In such models, components of the system of secondary concern are simulated with a thermodynamic model and coupled with full 3D simulations for components of greater interest.
These coupled models combine the advantages of the fast computation and high flexibility of the thermodynamic model, with the enhanced capabilities of the 3D model. This permits more extensive investigation of the flow field, multiphase flow computation and chemical reactions within the cylinders.
A similar approach can be used to evaluate how the compressor operational parameters and its geometry influence gas pulsations. Therefore, a new coupled model was developed to take advantage of the 3D model while, at the same time, reducing computational time .
The main objects of interest were the geometrical shapes of the discharge chamber and the discharge port, both of which are in the fluid domain within the discharge chamber. The gas flow through them was therefore simulated by a 3D model. However, the other domains of the compressor, which were of secondary interest for this purpose, were analysed with sufficient accuracy by the thermodynamic model, already described in Section 4.1. The structure of the coupled model is shown in Figure 10.
The 3D CFD model of the discharge chamber is simpler than the previously described 3D model because it does not contain any moving parts. This excludes the equation of space conservation from the calculation. The numerical mesh of the discharge chambers is shown in Figure 11.
A commercial CFD solver Star CCM+ was used to estimate the fluid flow in the discharge chamber. The thermodynamic model, used to simulate the remaining fluid domains, was programmed as a set of user sub-routines in the CFD code. The 1D model, defined, set the boundary conditions applied at the discharge port and the outlet of the discharge chamber for the 3D model as is shown in Figure 12.
The arrangement shown in Figure 12 enables a full two-way coupling of the models. The pressure and temperature calculated inside the working chamber and the outlet reservoir are used as the boundary conditions passed through the interface to the 3D model, where the flow field in the discharge chamber is calculated. The pressure and velocity values on the boundaries are then used to integrate the boundary mass flows, which are then used to calculate new values in the chamber model. This cycle is repeated until a converged solution is obtained, in which the mass and energy flows, pressures, velocities and densities are in balance. Once converged, the next time step is initiated with the new values of the chamber volume and the flow area and the procedure is repeated.
4.3.1. Comparison of calculated and experimental results
The numerical grid of the compressor fluid domain consisted of 86,000 grid elements. One discharge process was discretized through 90 time steps which represents a male rotor rotation of 1 degree per time step. Depending on the compressor speed, the length of the time step was in the range of 28–83 μs. The convergence criterion inside one time step was satisfied when the residuals dropped by three orders of magnitude. As for the full three-dimensional method, calculation of four cycles of the discharge process was necessary to obtain a convergent solution.
The coupled model was validated by use of the same set of experimental data as for the thermodynamic and 3D models. Examples of the results calculated by the coupled model are shown in Figures 13 and 14. These results show far better prediction of the gas pulsations in the discharge chamber than those obtained from the thermodynamic model, at one position in the computational domain. As can be seen, these are almost identical with those obtained from the 3D model. The coupled model predicts pulsation amplitudes for the compressor fundamental frequency and higher harmonics reasonably well, as is shown in Figure 14.
Overall, the accuracy of the results calculated by the coupled model was considered to be sufficient to be used to analyse the influence of the compressor operational parameters and geometry upon the gas pulsations.
5. Parameters which influence gas pulsations
In order to reduce gas pulsation levels in the discharge chamber, the parameters which influence them have to be determined. Previous studies have reported the influence of some of them, as well as on other aspects of compressor design and operation. However, there was no explanation why these parameters were selected from the many others possible. To investigate this and to find if there are any other significant parameters, previously overlooked, the discharge process was analysed.
5.1. Main factors which affect gas pulsations
The working and discharge chambers, connected through the discharge port, are presented in Figure 15. Both of these are also connected to the rest of the system outside of the compressor. The compressor working chamber is connected to the other working chambers, or to the suction chamber, through leakage paths, while the discharge chamber itself is connected to the discharge pipe. Connection between the chambers and their surroundings is always present. However, the connection between the working and discharge chambers is of a periodic nature. Accordingly, the discharge process of the working chamber starts with the opening of the discharge port and lasts only until the port is closed.
If the heat transfer through the chamber walls is neglected, then the gas condition in the chamber is determined by the change of the chamber volume and by the mass and energy transfer rates between the chamber and its surroundings. The volume of the working chamber is defined by the machine geometry and is expressed as a time-varying volume function, but the volume of the discharge chamber is constant. Therefore, it follows that the gas state in the discharge chamber is influenced only by the mass and energy transfer rates. This corresponds with the fact that gas pulsations in a chamber occur only if mass transfer rates to it are unsteady.
In Figure 15, two mass flows are shown between the discharge chamber and its surroundings. The first is the mass inflow into the discharge chamber from the compressor working chamber. The second is the mass outflow from the discharge chamber into the compressor discharge system consisting of pipes, oil separators and similar components. Both flows are time dependent and need to satisfy continuity Eqs. (3) and (4):
These equations show that both mass flows depend upon the instant gas density and the velocity. The fluid velocity is dependent upon the difference of fluid enthalpies in the chambers. For compressors, this is equivalent to the velocity being proportional to the square root of the pressure difference between the chambers. The gas density is also a parameter which is related to the chamber pressures. Therefore, the pressure difference between the working and discharge chambers is a parameter which influences the gas pulsation levels. Thus, the pressure difference between the discharge chamber and the pipe system is a result of the gas pulsations rather than their cause.
By analysing Eqs. (3) and (4), two more parameters can be identified which influence mass flow and later gas pulsations. The first is the outlet area,
The second parameter, which influences the mass flow, which has not been properly considered in previous studies, is the cross-sectional area between the working and discharge chambers,
The influence of different discharge ports has been noticed but not explained in papers published by Errol and Ahmet  and Mujić et al. . The difference in noise, identified through their research, can be explained only by the different cross-sectional area of the ports. The authors are not aware of any published results of investigations of this phenomenon.
It follows that the two basic parameters which influence the level of gas pulsations in the discharge chamber are the pressure difference and the discharge port area function. In order to reduce the amplitude of gas pulsations in the discharge chamber, these two parameters need to be optimised. It is necessary to explore and to optimise at least one of these two parameters.
The influence of the pressure difference has been explored in many studies. The most relevant are probably the papers from Koai and Soedel  and Sangfors . They recognise pressure difference as a cause for gas pulsations and they have explored the influence of the compressor operational and design parameters upon the gas pulsations.
5.2 Parameters related to working conditions
The discharge pressure is a parameter which will determine the pressure difference between the working and discharge chambers at the moment when the discharge process starts. The pressure difference is the smallest when the discharge pressure is equal to the pressure in the working chamber. This has been reported by Koai and Soedel . They noticed that the gas pulsations are a function of the discharge pressure and have a minimum. This was also confirmed later by Sangfors . According to Huagen et al. , this minimum corresponds to the discharge pressure that matches the machine built-in volume ratio. Koai and Soedel  claim that this minimum does not correspond exactly to that pressure, while Gavric and Badie-Cassagnet  consider that it occurs when there is slight under-compression.
5.2.1. Rotational speed
Sangfors  and Huagen et al.  concluded that the amplitude of the pressure pulsations during the discharge process increases with the rotational speed.
5.3. Compressor design parameters
Reduction of the leakage flow within the compressor, due to smaller clearances, increases the noise level generated in the discharge port. Soedel  and Sangfors  reported that for the same working conditions, changes of compressor clearances alter the working chamber pressure and fluid flow through the discharge port.
5.3.2. Discharge chamber length
According to Sangfors , the gas pulsations and generated sound pressure level (SPL) are affected by the length of the discharge chamber. This influence is significant and the sound pressure level, being a function of the chamber length, has a minimum for a certain chamber length.
5.3.3. Number of rotor lobes
According to Sangfors , the number of rotor lobes influences the noise level. Rotors consisting of more lobes generally generate a lower sound pressure level in operation then those with fewer lobes.
All these parameters have a common factor in that they directly influence the pressure difference between the working and the discharge chambers. Operational parameters such as discharge pressure and compressor speed have a high influence on gas pulsations. However, those parameters depend on the purpose for which the compressor is used. This makes them inappropriate for optimisation. Compressor design parameters such as the built-in volume ratio, the clearances, the number of lobes and the sealing line length also affect gas pulsations. However, attempts to decrease gas pulsations by optimising any of these parameters, usually degrades the compressor performance and hence makes them unsuitable as parameters for optimisation.
Mujić et al.  showed how the time function of the discharge port affects gas pulsations in screw compressors. An example of varying the shape of the discharge port and its influence on gas pulsations will be presented here. For this purpose, models of the discharge process, already described, were used to determine the effect of the discharge port shape upon the level of gas pulsations. The other design parameters, such as the built-in volume ratio, clearances and sealing line length, were maintained constant. By this means any reduction in pulsations and change in efficiency can be attributed exclusively to the variation in port shape.
6. Gas pulsation reduction by use of discharge port alteration
Both experimental and numerical results were obtained for two different port shapes, to investigate their influence on the levels of gas pulsation in the discharge port. The numerical results, already given to evaluate the accuracy of the models, were used and will not be presented again. Instead, only the experimental results for different shapes of discharge port will be analysed.
6.1. Compressor testing range and instrumentation
For the purpose of this investigation an oil-flooded air screw compressor was used because it operates over a larger pressure range and develops higher gas pulsations than an oil-free compressor. In addition, an oil-injected screw compressor does not need synchronising gears, which affect the overall compressor noise level, and it may be driven at moderate speeds. Therefore, the noise generated by the test compressor was mainly caused by the gas pulsations. The compressor parameters are given in Table 1.
|Compressor design parameters||Main||Gate|
|Number of lobes||4||5|
|Centre distance||71 [mm]||Outer diameter||102 [mm]||80 [mm]|
|Rotor length||158 [mm]||Pitch diameter||63 [mm]||79 [mm]|
|Wrap angle||300 [deg]||Inner diameter||62 [mm]||40 [mm]|
|Pressure range||3–12 [bar]||Speed range||2000–6500 [rpm]|
The test compressor was placed in a laboratory test rig, built to CAGI and PNEUROP standards. One set of measuring points covers the compressor speeds from 2000 to 6000 rpm at a discharge pressure of 8 bar, while the other set of points covers discharge pressures from 5 to 12 bar at a speed of 4000 rpm.
The discharge chamber pressure was measured by the use of an Endevco 8530C Piezoresistive pressure sensor to obtain a pressure function. The sound pressure level (SPL) around the test compressor was measured by pressure level indicators SJK. A sound Level Meter HML 323 was used to evaluate a correlation between the pressure function within the discharge chamber and the overall compressor noise. Measurements of the pressure, temperature, driving torque, air flow and compressor speed were also taken to estimate the compressor performance.
6.2. Modification of the discharge port
The original discharge port was modified to reduce the amplitudes of the gas pulsations by minimising any sudden flow between the working and discharge chambers at the beginning of the discharge process, when the pressure difference between the chambers is highest. According to Eq. (3), this flow is governed by the pressure difference and the size of the port area. Since the built-in volume ratio was not changed, the pressure difference was the same for both modified ports at the moment when discharge started. The original discharge port was designed to have the largest possible opening for any rotor position, in order to reduce flow losses. This was achieved by designing the port shape to correspond with the shape of the rotor trailing edges. Such an approach generates a discharge port area function with a high starting gradient, as shown by the light line in Figure 16. In that case the port has the largest opening when the pressure difference is largest.
To avoid this, a new port shape was devised, as shown by the bold line in Figure 16, where it can be seen clearly that only the port opening curves were changed. This altered the starting gradient of the port area function while maintaining the same built-in volume ratio as the original by keeping the remaining parts of the opening curves unchanged. Therefore, both ports opened at the same rotor position. The opening curves are simple in this second case and consist of only three arcs. They are therefore simpler than in the old port. The pressure function in the discharge chamber, predicted by the simulation models of the discharge process, showed a reduction in gas pulsations.
The shape modification of the port reduces the size of the port area. This difference increases at the beginning of opening and is highest when the port is fully open. It then decreases as the port closes and finally disappears when the leading edges of the following rotor lobes cover the opening curves of the port completely. Such a reduction must cause some flow losses.
6.3. Experimental verification of results
The shape of the compressor discharge port geometry, presented in Figure 16, was changed to verify the predicted results by locating metal inserts to form the new port. These inserts also covered the original opening curves on both sides of the port. These are illustrated in Figure 17 by the two lines on the metal inserts. After modification, a new set of measurements was carried out in order to compare with the predicted gas pulsations.
The measured values of the pressure functions in the discharge chamber for the original and modified discharge ports are compared in Figure 18. These are shown for the original and modified port by light and bold lines, respectively. It can be seen that the gas pulsation amplitudes are reduced across the whole range of working conditions. As shown in Figure 19, the sound pressure level, generated by gas pulsations in the discharge chamber, is reduced.
More specifically, as can be seen in Figure 19, the overall noise in the compressor environment is attenuated by about 3 dB at 4000 rpm over the whole pressure range, while there is a noticeable noise reduction across the compressor speed range, varying from 2 dB at the lowest speed up to 5 dB at the maximum speed for an outlet pressure of 8 bar. The use of the model therefore represents a good step towards identifying the influential parameters and overall noise reduction
Since modification of the discharge port reduced the flow area, the flow losses were increased, thereby affecting the compressor performance. The compressor with the modified port requires more power than that with the original port and a comparison of the specific power for the two versions of the machine is presented in Figures 20 and 21. Figure 20 shows that, over the whole speed range, the compressor with the modified port consumed more power at a constant outlet pressure of
A comparison of the specific power, presented in Figure 21 for a compressor constant speed of 4000 rpm, shows that the compressor with the modified port consumes more power for the majority of the pressure range. However, for the highest pressures in the range, the specific power is lower for the new port. The reason for this is that the new port shape reduces back flow when the compressor operates at higher pressures.
Basic analysis has shown that the two most influential parameters affecting gas pulsations in a screw compressor discharge chamber are the pressure difference between the compressor working and discharge chambers and the discharge port area. Mathematical models applied to calculate the pressure function in a screw compressor discharge chamber have shown that the gas pulsations in a screw compressor discharge port and, consequently, the generated noise can be reduced by making appropriate changes to the shape of the discharge port. This has been confirmed by good agreement obtained over a wide range of speeds and pressures between predicted and measured values in a compressor with two different port shapes.
The majority of the material presented in this chapter is reproduced from a PhD Thesis, “A Numerical and Experimental Investigation of Pulsation Induced Noise in Screw Compressors”, by Mujić E, submitted at City University London in 2008, ref. .
Stošić N, Mujić E, Kovačević A, Smith I K. Development of rotor profile for silent screw compressor operation. In: International Conference on Compressors and their Systems 2007; London, UK. London, UK: IMechE; 2007. p. 133–145.
Holmes C S. Transmission error in screw compressors, and methods of THEIR? Compensation during rotor manufacture. In: International Conference on Compressors and their Systems 2005; London, UK. London, UK: IMechE; 2005. p. additional paper.
Fujiwara A, Sakurai N. Experimental analysis of Screw Compressor Noise and Vibration. In: In The 1986 International Compressor Engineering Conference at Purdue; West Lafayette, US. West Lafayette, US:1986.
Koai K L, Soedel W. Gas pulsations in twin screw compressors – Part I: Determination of port flow and interpretation of periodic volume source. In: The 1990 International Compressor Engineering Conference at Purdue; West Lafayette, US. West Lafayette, US: 1990. p. 369–377.
Koai K L, Soedel W. Gas pulsations in twin screw compressors – Part II: Dynamics of discharge system and its interaction with port flow. In: In The 1990 International Compressor Engineering Conference at Purdue; West Lafayette, US. West Lafayette, US: 1990. p. 378–387.
Sangfors B. Computer simulation of gas-flow noise from twin-screw compressors. In: International Conference on Compressor and Their Systems; London, UK. London, UK: IMechE; 1999. p. 707–716.
Sangfors B. Modelling, measurement and analysis of gas-flow generated noise from twin-screw compressors. In: The 2000 International Compressor Engineering Conference at Purdue; West Lafayette, US. West Lafayette, US: 2000. p. 971–978.
Tanttari J. On twin-screw compressor gas pulsation noise. In: The 29th International Congress and Exhibition on Noise Control Engineering; 27–30 August; Nice, France. 2000. p. 2369–2372.
Huagen W, Ziwen X, Xueyuan P, Pengcheng S. Simulation of discharge pressure pulsation within twin screw compressors. Proceedings of the I MECH E Part A Journal of Power and Energy. 2004; 218(4):257–264.
Mujić E, Kovačević A, Stošić N, Smith I K. The influence of port shape on gas pulsations in screw compressor discharge chamber. Proceedings of the IMechE, Part E: Journal of Process Mechanical Engineering. 2008; 222(E4):211–223.
Soedel W. Sound and Vibration of Positive Displacement Compressors. New York, US: Taylor Francis Group; 2006.
Stošić N, Smith I K, Kovačević A. Screw Compressors: Mathematical Modelling and Performance Calculation. Berlin/Heidelberg/New York: Springer; 2005.
Kovačević A, Stošić N, Smith I K. Screw Compressors Three Dimensional Computational Fluid Dynamics and Solid Fluid Interaction. Berlin/Heidelberg/New York: Springer; 2006.
Lee W S, Ma R H, Chen S L, Wu W F, Hsia H W. Numerical simulation and performance analysis of twin screw air compressor. International Journal of Rotating Machinery. 2001; 7(1):65–78.
Kolade B, Morel T, Kong S C. Coupled 1-D/3-D analysis of fuel injection and diesel engine combustion. Journal of Engines. 2004; 113. p. 217–226.
Kovačević A, Mujić E, Stošić N, Smith I K. An integrated model for the performance calculation of screw machines. In: International Conference on Compressors and Their Systems; London, UK. London, UK: IMechE; 2007. p. 757–765.
Erol H, Ahmet G. The noise and vibration characteristics of reciprocating compressor: Effects of size and profile of discharge port. In: The 2000 International Compressor Engineering Conference at Purdue; West Lafayette, US. West Lafayette, US: 2000. p. 677–683.
Mujić E, Kovačević A, Stošić N, Smith I K. Analysis and measurement of discharge port influence upon screw compressor noise. In: TMT 2005; Antalya, Turkey. 2005. p. 993–996.
Gavric L, Badie-Cassagnet A. Measurement of gas pulsations in discharge and suction lines of refrigerant compressors. In: The 2000 International Compressor Engineering Conference at Purdue; West Lafayette, US. West Lafayette, US: 2000. p. 627–634.
Mujić E. A Numerical and Experimental Investigation of Pulsation Induced Noise in Screw Compressors, PhD Thesis, City University London; 2008.