1. Introduction
The design, scale-up and optimization of industrial processes conducted in agitated systems require, among other, precise knowledge of the hydrodynamics, mass and heat transfer parameters and reaction kinetics. Literature data available indicate that the mass-transfer process is generally the rate-limiting step in many industrial applications. Because of the tremendous importance of mass-transfer in engineering practice, a very large number of studies have determined mass-transfer coefficients both empirically and theoretically. From the practical point of view, the agitated systems are usually employed to dissolve granular or powdered solids into a liquid solvent [3].
Transfer of the solute into the main body of the fluid occurs in the three ways, dependent upon the conditions. For an infinite stagnant fluid, transfer will be by the molecular diffusion augmented by the gradients of temperature and pressure. The natural convection currents are set up owing to the difference in density between the pure solvent and the solution. This difference in inducted flow helps to carry solute away from the interface. The third mode of transport is depended on the external effects. In this way, the forced convection closely resembles natural convection expect that the liquid flow is involved by using the external force.
One of the key aspects in the dynamic behaviour of the mass-transfer processes is the role of hydrodynamics. On a macroscopic scale, the improvement of hydrodynamic conditions can be achieved by using various techniques of mixing, vibration, rotation, pulsation and oscillation in addition to other techniques like the use of fluidization, turbulence promotes or magnetic and electric fields etc. The transverse rotating magnetic field (TRMF) is a versatile option for enhancing several physical and chemical processes. Studies over the recent decades were focused on application of magnetic field (MF) in different areas of engineering processes [21, 22]. Static, rotating or alternating MFs might be used to augment the process intensity instead of mechanically mixing. The practical applications of TRMF are presented in the relevant literature [6, 16, 18, 23, 26, 27, 29].
Recently, TRMF are widely used to control different processes in the various engineering operations [2, 9, 10]. This kind of magnetic field induces a time-averaged azimuthal force, which drives the flow of the electrical conducting fluid in circumferential direction. According to available in technical literature, the mass-transfer during the solid dissolution to the surrounding liquid under the action of TRMF has been deliberated [21, 22]. These papers present literature survey for the applications of magnetic field (MF) and the magnetically assisted fluidization (MAF) in the mass transfer enhancement.
It should be noticed that the temperature gradient induces buoyancy-driven convective flow in the fluid. This temperature gradient has a significant practical interest to the mass transfer process. It is reported that the difference between the surface temperature of solid sample and the liquid temperature has strong influence on the dissolution process [1].
The main objective of the present study is to investigate the solid dissolution process that is induced under the action of TRMF and the gradient temperature between solid surface and liquid. According to the information available in technical literature, the usage of TRMF and gradient temperature is not theoretical and practical analyzed. The obtained experimental data are generalized by using the empirical dimensionless correlations.
2. Theoretical background
2.1. Equation of magnetic induction
The flow under the action of TRMF may be determined by taking into consideration the following magnetohydrodynamic Ohm law
The current density
The general Eq.(3) may be rewritten as:
Taking into consideration the following expressions
we obtain from the Eq.(3) the well-known advection-diffusion type relation [8, 17]
The above equation (8) is also called the induction equation and it characterizes the temporal evolution of the magnetic field where
is effective diffusion coefficient (magnetic viscosity or magnetic diffusivity).
Taking into accunt the above relation, Eq. (8) may be revritten in the following form
The term,
Taking into account the below definitions of the dimensionless parameters
we get the modified form of the relation (8)
The above form of Eq. (8) may be used to examine the effect of liquid flow on the MF distribution. The non-dimensional forms of these equations may be scaled against the term
This equation includes the following dimensionless groups
and
The magnetic Reynolds number
Taking into account the above definitions of the non-dimensional groups (Eqs (14) and (15)), we obtain the following general relationship of the magnetic induction equation
It should be noticed that the time of magnetic diffusion,
Taking into account the following relation
we obtain the modified form of Eq. (8)
The governing Eq.(19) may be rewritten in a symbolic shape which is useful in the case of the dimensionless analysis
The above Eq.(20) admits the following relation
where
An important consequence of the above expression (Eq.(21)) is that the skin depth (or the penetration depth),
This parameter may be used to describe the well-known skin effect. From the practical point of view, this phenomenon is characterized by the so-called shielding parameter
This dimensionless parameter see ( Eq (23)) is usually applied characterize the interaction between the MF and the electrical conductivity of liquid. The condition
2.2. Influence of transverse rotating magnetic field on solid dissolution process
Under forced convective conditions, the mathematical description of the solid dissolution process may be described by means of the differential equation of mass balance for the component
where
The flux density of component
The diffusion flux density is described by means of the following expression
The relation between
Including the relation (27) in equation (24) gives the following relationship for the mass balance of component
Introducing the relation
in Eq.(28) gives the mass balance of component
The concentration of component
Taking into account the above equation, we find the modified form of Eq.(30)
Eq.(32) may be rewritten by
or
The term in square brackets is so-called the continuity equation and this relation may be simplified in the following form
This leads to the final expression for the mass balance of component
The total diffusion flux density
A more useful form of this equation may be obtained by introducing the proper coefficients as follows
Under the action of TRMF the force
The above relation may be simplified as follows (the electric field vector
The related Lorenz force to the unit of liquid mass may be rewritten in the form
Introducing the relation Eq.(41) in Eq.(38) gives the following relationship
Taking into account the above relation (Eq.(42)) we obtain the following general relationship for the mass balance of component
The obtained Eq.(43) suggests that this dependence may be simplified in the following form
It should be noticed that the coefficient of magnetic diffusion
This coefficient may be defined by means of the following expression
Taking into consideration the above relation (Eq.(46)) we obtain the relationship
The above relation (Eq.(47)) may be treated as the differential mathematical model of the solid dissolution process under the action of TRMF. The right side of this equation represents the source mass of component
where
Introducing Eq.(48) in Eq.(47), gives the following relationship
Taking into account the below definition of the dimensionless parameters
we obtain the governing Eq.(50) in a symbolic form
The non-dimensional form of this equation may be scaled against the convective term
This relation includes the following dimensionless groups characterizing the dissolution process under the action of TRM
Taking into account the proposed relations (53-56), we find the following dimensionless governing equation
From the dimensionless form of Eq.(57) it follows that
Under convective conditions a relationship for the mass-transfer similar to the relationships obtained for heat-transfer may be expected of the form [11]
The two principle dimensionless groups of relevance to mass-transfer are Sherwood and Schmidt numbers. The Sherwood number can be viewed as describing the ratio of convective to diffusive transport, and finds its counterpart in heat transfer in the form of the Nusselt number [3].
The Schmidt number is a ratio of physical parameters pertinent to the system. This dimensionless group corresponds to the Prandtl number used in heat-transfer. Moreover, this number provides a measure of the relative effectiveness of momentum and mass transport by diffusion.
Added to these two groups is the Reynolds number, which represents the ratio of convective-to-viscous momentum transport. This number determines the existence of laminar or turbulent conditions of fluid flow. For small values of the Reynolds number, viscous forces are sufficiently large relative to inertia forces. But, with increasing the Reynolds number, viscous effects become progressively less important relative to inertia effects.
Evidently, for Eq.(59) to be of practical use, it must be rendered quantitative. This may be done by assuming that the functional relation is in the following form [4, 13]
The mass-transfer coefficients in the mixed systems can be correlated by the combination of Sherwood, Reynolds and Schmidt numbers. Using the proposed relation [60], it has been found possible to correlate a host of experimental data for a wide range of operations. The coefficients of relation [60] are determined from experiment. Under forced convection conditions the relation may be expressed as follows [7]
The exponent upon of the Schmidt number is to be 0.33 [5, 12, 14, 19, 25] as there is some theoretical and experimental evidence for this value [24], although reported values vary from 0.56 [28] to 1.13 [15].
Mass transfer process under the TRMF conditions is very complicated and may be described by the non-dimensional Eq.(57). Use of the dimensionless Sherwood number as a function of the various non-dimensional parameters yields a description of liquid-side mass transfer, which is more general and useful. Taking into account that the magnetic Prandtl number
Basing on the considerations given above, the correlations of mass transfer process under the TRMF action have the general form
2.3. Influence of temperature gradient on the solid dissolution controlled process
As mentioned above, the temperature gradient has strong influence on the solid dissolution process. The heat transfer from the sample to the ambient fluid may be modeled by means of the well-known Nusselt type equation.
In the present report we consider the process dissolutions described by a similar but somewhat modified relationship between the dimensionless Sherwood number and the numbers which are defined the intensity of the magnetic effects in the tested experimental set-up with the TRMF generator. It should be assumed that the relationship for the heat transport under the TRMF conditions can be characterized in the following general form
In order to establish the effect of all important parameters on this process in the wide range of variables data we proposed the following general relationship.
The solid dissolution process under the action of TRMF and the gradient temperature between the solid surface and the liquid may be described by means of the following equations system
From the above relation (Eq.(67)), the ratio of Sherwood and Nusselt numbers is given by
where
In the relevant literature the ratio of the Schmidt and Prandtl numbers is called as the dimensionless Lewis number (the ratio of thermal diffusivity to mass diffusivity)
According to Eq.(69) and the above assumptions, the ratio of Sherwood and Nusselt numbers is defined as follows
The enhancement effect of the solid dissolution process due to heat transfer process obtained from Eq.(70) is given by
The ratio
Introducing the thermal diffusivity
Finally, form relation (73) it follows that
3. Experimental details
3.1. Experimental set-up
All experimental measurements of mass-transfer process using the TRMF were carried out in a laboratory set-up including electromagnetic field generator. A schematic of the experimental apparatus is presented in figure 1.
This setup may be divided into: a generator of the rotating electromagnetic field (1), a glass container (2) with the conductivity samples (3-4), an electric control box (5) and an inverter (6) connected with multifunctional electronic switch (8) and a personal computer (7) loaded with special software. This software made possible the electromagnetic field rotation control, recording working parameters of the generator and various state parameters.
From preliminary tests of the experimental apparatus, the glass container is not influenced by the working parameters of the stator. The TRMF was generated by a modified 3-phase stator of an induction squirrel-cage motor, parameters of which are in accordance with the Polish Standard PN-72/E-06000. The stator is supplied with a 50 Hz three-phase alternating current. The transistorized inverter (4) was used to change the frequency of the rotating magnetic field in the range of
For the experimental measurements, MF is generated by coils located axially around of the cylindrical container. As mentioned above, this field is rotated around the container with the constant angular frequency,
3.2. Rock-salt sample
Two conductive samples connected to a multifunction computer meter were used to measuring and recording of the concentration of the achieve solution of the salt. The mass of the rock salt sample decreasing during the process of dissolution is determined by an electronic balance that connected with rocking double-arm lever. On the lever arm the sample was hanging, the other arm connected to the balance. In the present investigation the change in mass of solid body in a short time period of dissolution is very small and the mean area of dissolved cylinder of the rock salt may be used. Than the mean mass-transfer Raw rock-salt (>98% NaCl and rest traces quantitative of chloride of K, Ca, Mg and insoluble mineral impurities) cylinders were not fit directly for the experiments because their structure was not homogeneous (certain porosity). Basic requirement concerning the experiments was creating possibly homogeneous transport conditions of mass on whole interfacial surface, which was the active surface of the solid body. These requirements were met thanks to proper preparing of the sample, mounting it in the mixer and matching proper time of dissolving. As an evident effect were fast showing big pinholes on the surface of the dissolved sample as results of local non-homogeneous of material. Departure from the shape of a simple geometrical body made it impossible to take measurements of its area with sufficient precision. So it was necessary to put those samples through the process of so-called hardening. The turned cylinders had been soaked in saturated brine solution for about 15 min and than dried in a room temperature. This process was repeated four times. To help mount the sample in the mixer, a thin copper thread was glued into the sample’s axis. The processing was finished with additional smoothing of the surface with fine-grained abrasive paper. A sample prepared in this way had been keeping its shape during dissolving for about 30 min. The duration of a run was usually 30 sec. The rate of mass-transfer involved did not produce significant dimensional change in diameter of the cylinder. The time of a single dissolving cycle was chosen so that the measurement of mass loss could be made with sufficient accuracy and the decrease of dimensions would be relatively small (maximum about 0.5 mm).
Before starting every experiment, a sample which height, diameter and mass had been known was mounted in a mixer under the free surface of the mixed liquid. The reciprocating plate agitator was started, the recording of concentration changes in time, the weight showing changes in sample’s mass during the process of solution, and time measuring was started simultaneously. After finishing the cycle of dissolving, the agitator was stopped, and then the loss of mass had been read on electronic scale and concentration of NaCl (electrical conductivity) in the mixer as well. This connection is given by a calibration curve, showing the dependence of the relative mass concentration of NaCl on the electrical conductivity [21].
3.3. Rock-salt sample heated by means of the cartridge heater
In the case of this experimental investigations the gradient temperature between the surface and liquid was caused by using the cartridge heater (power ~1200W). This tubular device was inserted into drilled holes of rock-salt sample for heating. Moreover, the heating set-up was contained the temperature controller and sensors. The sensors for the temperature control was placed between the working surface of the sample and the heater. These sensors was also located on the surface of the solid sample. The sketch of rock-salt sample with the heating set-up is graphically presented in figure 2. The sample was kept at a constant temperature (65oC, 70oC or 80oC). The heat transfer from the sample to ambient fluid was realized for the various temperature (20oC, 40oC and 60oC). The system of temperature sensors was used to control the temperature of the water during the solid dissolution process.
3.4. Experimental calculation of mass transfer coefficient
The mass transfer coefficient under the action of TRMF may be calculated form the following equation
The above Eq.(76) cannot be integrated because the area of solid body,
The averaged surface
The volumetric mass transfer coefficient
3.5. Experimental calculation of heat transfer coefficient
The heat transfer from the sample to liquid may by modelled by the following relationship
This equation can be rewritten as
and the averaged heat transfer coefficient is given as follows
The averaged coefficient of heat transfer
4. Results and discussion
Under the TRMF conditions a relationship for the mass-transfer can be described in the general form
The TRMF Reynolds number
The effect of dissolution process under the action of TRF can be described by using the variable
In order to establish the effect of all important parameters on the dissolution process in the analyzed set-up, we propose the following relationship to work out the experimental database
The presented results in figure 3 suggest that these points may be described by a unique monotonic function. The constants and exponents are computed by employing the Matlab software and the principle of least squares and the proposed relationships are collected in table 1.
Figure 4 shows the effect of the constant temperature of the surface of rock-salt sample and the variation of the liquid temperature on the Sherwood number.
Figures 3 and 4 present a graphical form of the collected relations in table 1, as the full curves, correlated the experimental data very well with the percentage relative error
As can be clearly seen (see Figure 3) mass transfer rates expressed as
Comparison of the obtained results for the analyzed process is graphically presented in figure 4. This figure shows that for the given temperature of surface of rock-salt sample the mass transfer coefficients in tested set-up are strongly depended on the values of magnetic Taylor number. These plots also confirm that the gradient temperature has significant effect on the mass transfer process. Initially, the high mass transfer rates is achieved by the liquid temperature 40oC and 60oC. Further increase of the magnetic field intensity leads to even higher mass transfer rates for the liquid temperature is equal to 20oC. It should be noticed that the NaCl-cylinder was placed in the middle of container. When the TRMF rotated slowly the liquid was mixed near the wall of cylindrical container. When the TRMF rotated faster, the resulting liquid movement directly leads to an increase of the mass and heat transfer coefficients. This difference appears to be linked to the increase in the difference between the surface temperature of rock-salt sample and the liquid temperature associated with increasing the influence of TRMF. The high value of the exponents of magnetic Taylor number and the multiplicative coefficients seen in the relations given in table 1 agree with the existence of more intensive flow near the hot surface of the rock-salt sample promoted by the increase of the magnetic induction and the temperature of the cartridge heater.
The enhancement due to heat transfer process is modeled in terms given in Eq.(70). The graphical presentation of the calculated experimental points is presented in figure 6.
The constant
where the ratio of the dimensionless Sherwood and Nusselt numbers is function of the adequate dimensionless groups. The fit of experimental data with Eq.(87) is given in figure 7. The averaged absolute relative error was estimated at 2.12%.
Figure 6 shows that the ratio of mass and heat transfer coefficients (via ratio of Sherwood and Nusselt numbers) increases with the magnetic Taylor number. This figure shows a strong increase in mass transfer process when the TRMF is applied. It was found that the intensification of this process is depended on the temperature gradient between the temperature of surface of salt-rock sample and the liquid temperature.
In order to evaluate the influence of the gradient temperature on the mass transfer under the action of TRMF, the comparison between the obtained database and the empirical correlation for the dissolution process under the TRMF is presented. For comparison these results with literature, it is recommended to correlate them under analogous form. The dissolution process under the action of TRMF is correlated by means of the equation [22]
Taking into account that the dimensionless location of a NaCl-cylindrical sample
As a matter of fact, Eq.(70) may be written by alternate equations as follows
The comparison in this case may be realized by considering the calculated averaged values of the dimensionless Schmidt
The graphical comparison between Eq.(91) and Eq.(92) are illustrated in the plot in figure 8. This figure demonstrates that the dimensionless Sherwood number for the analyzed case
It can be observed that the enhancement of the mass transfer coefficients due to temperature gradient may be evaluated by applying the ratio
Figure 9 shows the obtained relation (see Eq.(93)) as the function of the magnetic Taylor number. It was found that as the intensity of TRMF has strong influence on the mass transfer rate. It is interesting to note that the enhancement of this process in the case of upper values of the magnetic Taylor number is increased for the supported process by using the cartrige heater.
5. Conclusion
The present experimental study shows interestingfeatures cocncerning the effects of transverse rotating magnetic field (TRMF) on the mass transfer process. Inspecting the obtained measuremenst reveals the following conclusions:
The study of mass transfer process under the action of TRMF results is significant enhancement of the solid dissolution rate per localization of a NaCl-cylindrical sample. The mass transfer rate increases with an increase of a magnetic field level. It was found that the TRMF strongly influcnecd the mass transfer process.
It should be noticed that the novel approach to the mixing process presented and based on the application of TRMF to produce better hydrodynamic conditions in the case of the mass-transfer process. From practical point of view, the dissolution process of solid body is involved by using the turbulently agitated systems. In previous publications are not available data describing the mass-transfer operations of the dissolution process under the TRMF conditions and the temperature gradient. Moreover, the influence of the additional indirect heating on the mass-transfer was determined.
With the respect to the other very useful mass transfer equations given in the pertinent literature, the theoretical description of problem and the equations predicted in the present article is much more attractive because it generalizes the experimental data taking into consideration the various parameters, which defined the hydrodynamic state and the intensity of magnetic effects in the tested system (see chapter 2.2).
On the basis of the experimental investigations, the results were successfully correlated by using the general relationship [74]. The influence of the TRMF and the temperature gradient on this process may be also described using the non-dimensional parameters formulated on the base of fluid mechanics equations. These dimensionless numbers allow quantitative representation and characterization of the influence of hydrodynamic state under the TRMF conditions on the mass-transfer process. The dimensionless groups are used to establish the effect of TRMF on this operation in the form of the novel type dimensionless correlation [87].
In order to evaluate the influence of the gradient temperature on the mass transfer under the action of TRMF, the comparison between the obtained database and the empirical correlation for the dissolution process under the TRMF is presented. This coparsion is presented as the specific relation [93]. It can be observed that the enhancement of the mass transfer coefficients due to temperature has strong influence on the mass transfer rate (see Fig.8).
6. Nomenclature
|
magnetic induction |
|
|
concentration |
|
|
specific heat capacity of liquid |
|
|
sample diameter |
|
|
diameter of container |
|
|
diffusion coefficient |
|
|
magnetic diffusion |
|
|
electric field |
|
|
frequency of electrical current (equal to frequency of TRMF) |
|
|
cylindrical surface of dissoluble sample |
|
|
Lorenz magnetic force |
|
|
length of sample |
|
|
characteristic dimension |
|
|
electrical current density vector |
|
|
flux density of component i |
|
|
diffusion flux density |
|
|
relative coefficient of barodiffusion |
|
|
relative coefficient of thermodiffusion |
|
|
relative coefficient of diffusion resulting from additional forced interactions (e.g. magnetic field) |
|
|
mass of dissoluble NaCl sample |
|
|
hydrodynamic pressure |
|
|
heat flow from liquid |
|
|
heat flow from sample |
|
|
shielding parameter | - |
|
temperature |
|
|
temperature of liquid at moment |
|
|
temperature of liquid at moment |
|
|
temperature of sample |
|
|
volume of liquid |
|
|
velocity |
|
|
velocity of component i |
|
|
distance (for localization of sample) |
|
|
heat transfer coefficient |
|
|
mass transfer coefficient |
|
|
skin depth | - |
|
dynamic viscosity |
|
|
magnetic permeability |
|
|
thermal conductivity of liquid |
|
|
kinematic viscosity |
|
|
magnetic viscosity |
|
|
density |
|
|
concentration of component i |
|
|
electrical conductivity |
|
|
time dissolution or time |
|
|
mass flux of component i |
|
|
angular velocity of transverse rotating magnetic field |
|
|
averaged value | |
|
liquid | |
|
sample | |
|
reference value |
AC | alternating current | |
MF | magnetic field | |
TRMF | transverse rotating magnetic field |
|
Hartman number | |
|
Lewis number | |
|
Nusselt number | |
|
mass Peclet number | |
|
magnetic Prandtl number | |
|
Chandrasekhar number | |
|
Reynols number | |
|
Strouhal number | |
|
Schmidt number | |
|
Sherwood number |
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by the Polish Ministry of Science and Higher Education from sources for science in the years 2012-2013 under Inventus Plus project
References
- 1.
Aksielrud G. A. Mołczanow A. D. 1981 WNT Poland (in polish). - 2.
Al-Qodah Z. Al-Bisoul M. Al-Hassan M. 2001 Hydro-thermal behavior of magnetically stabilized fluidized beds 115 58 67 - 3.
Basmadjian D. 2004 Mass transferPrinciples and applications CRC Press LLC, USA. - 4.
Bird R. B. Stewart W. E. Lightfoot E. N. 1966 Wiley, USA. - 5.
Condoret J. S. Riba J. P. Angelino H. 1989 Mass transfer in a particle bed with oscillating flow 44 10 2107 2111 - 6.
Fraňa K. Stiller J. Grundmann R. 2006 Transitional and turbulent flows driven by a rotating magnetic field 42 187 197 - 7.
Garner F. H. Suckling R. D. 1958 Mass transfer form a soluble solid sphere 4 1 114 124 - 8.
Guru B. S. Hiziroğlu H. R. 2004 Cambridge University Press - 9.
Hristov J. 2003 aMagnetic field assisted fluidization- A unified approach. Part 3: Heat transfer in gas-solid fluidized beds- a critical re-evaluation of the results 19 3 229 355 - 10.
Hristov J. 2003 bMagnetic field assisted fluidization- A unified approach. Part 7: Mass Transfer: Chemical reactors, basic studies and practical implementations thereof. 25 1-3 1 254 - 11.
Incropera F. P. De Witt D. P. 1996 Fundamentals of heat and mass transfer John Wiley & Sons Inc., USA. - 12.
Jameson G. J. 1964 Mass (or heat) transfer form an oscillating cylinder. 19 793 800 - 13.
Kays W. M. Crawford M. E. 1980 Convective heat and mass transfer McGraw-Hill, USA - 14.
Lemcoff N. O. Jameson G. J. 1975 Solid-liquid mass transfer in a resonant bubble contractor 30 363 367 - 15.
Lemlich R. Levy M. R. 1961 The effect of vibration on natural convective mass transfer 7 240 241 - 16.
Melle S. Calderon O. G. Fuller G. G. Rubio M. A. 2002 Polarizable particle aggregation under rotating magnetic fields using scattering dichroism 247 200 209 - 17.
Möβner R. Gerbeth G. 1999 Buoyant melt flows under the influence of steady and rotating magnetic fields 197 341 345 - 18.
Nikrityuk P. A. Eckert K. Grundmann R. 2006 A numerical study of unidirectional solidification of a binary metal alloy under influence of a rotating magnetic field 49 1501 1515 - 19.
Noordsij P. Rotte J. W. 1967 Mass transfer coefficients to a rotating and to a vibrating sphere 22 1475 1481 - 20.
Rakoczy R. Masiuk S. 2009 Experimental study of bubble size distribution in a liquid column exposed to a rotating magnetic field 48 1229 1240 - 21.
Rakoczy R. Masiuk S. 2010 Influence of transverse rotating magnetic field on enhancement of solid dissolution process 56 1416 1433 - 22.
Rakoczy R. 2010 Enhancement of solid dissolution process under the influence of rotating magnetic field 49 42 50 - 23.
Spitzer K. H. 1999 Application of rotating magnetic field in Czochralski crystal growth 38 39 58 - 24.
Sugano Y. Rutkowsky D. A. 1968 Effect of transverse vibration upon the rate of mass transfer for horizontal cylinder 23 707 716 - 25.
Tojo K. Miyanami K. Mitsui H. 1981 Vibratory agitation in solid-liquid mixing 36 279 284 - 26.
Volz M. P. Mazuruk K. 1999 Thermoconvective instability in a rotating magnetic field 42 1037 1045 - 27.
Walker J. S. Volz M. P. Mazuruk K. 2004 Rayleigh-Bénard instability in a vertical cylinder with a rotating magnetic field 47 1877 1887 - 28.
Wong P. F. Y. Ko N. W. M. Yip P. C. 1978 Mass transfer from large diameter vibrating cylinder 56 214 216 - 29.
Yang M. Ma N. Bliss D. F. Bryant G. G. 2007 Melt motion during liquid-encapsulated Czochralski crystal growth in steady and rotating magnetic field. 28 768 776