Scientific research largely depends on technological tools. If molecular biology allowed to manipulate the genome of complex organisms to investigate gene function, today nanotechnologies allow to synthesize objects at the same size scale as that of biological molecules, permitting the exploration of biological phenomena and dynamics at single molecule scale with unprecedented spatial precision and temporal resolution. Thanks to their superior physico-chemical and optoelectronic properties, colloidal semiconductor nanocrystals (NC), such as Quantum Dots (QD) and Quantum Rods (QR) have become attracting for investigators of different scientific fields. Their employment spans from electronics (tunable polarized lasers and organic–inorganic hybrid solar cells) (Hu et al., 2001; Huynh et al., 2002), to biology and medicine (biosensors, imaging and diagnostic contrast agents) (Alivisatos et al., 2005; Bruchez et al., 1998; Medintz et al., 2005). Recent advances in NC engineering, from synthesis to biofunctionalization, are being exploited to produce innovative nanodevices for drug delivery, gene silencing, hyperthermia treatments. However, their great potential to revolutionise basic and applied research founds its major concern in the lack of knowledge about their effects on biological systems, ranging from single cells to whole animals (Maynard et al., 2006). Nanocrystals size compares to that of biological molecules (nucleic acids, proteins, enzymes) and might interfere with the physiology/behaviour of the target living cell/animal, leading to unpredictable effects.
Among the factors to consider to predict the interaction of metal based nanocrystals with biological materials the core and the shell composition, the size and the surface charge of NC play crucial roles (Jiang et al., 2008). At the nanoscale, materials display properties profoundly different form their corresponding bulk chemicals, which may induce peculiar cellular responses, elicit several pathways of internalization, genetic networks, biochemical signalling cascades (Auffan et al., 2009; Choi et al., 2008; Demir E, 2010). The metal based core may adversely affect cell viability, unless properly shielded by surface coatings. Currently, increasing data addressing this important question relies on cell culture systems, and are focussed on the identification of the physicochemical parameters influencing the exposed cells (Hoshino and Yasuhara, 2004; Lewinski et al., 2008; Lovric et al., 2005b). Although cultured cells represent valid models to describe basic interactions with nanomaterials, they do not fulfil the
It is a priority of the scientific community to evaluate the impact of novel nanostructrured materials
In this chapter I will summarize some studies on the freshwater polyp
I would like to point out that all the data described in this chapter result from the interdisciplinary work with researchers in the field of nanomaterial science, which I sincerely thank. The continuous discussions and knowledge’s exchanges between the different disciplines (chemistry, material science, biology, physiology), hided beyond each study, laid the foundations of an interdisciplinary platform for the smart design, testing and safe assessment of novel nanomaterials.
Hydra vulgaris: An ancient model system
Picture of living
Another peculiar feature of
Beside the effects detectable at macroscopic level, the availability of the genome sequence makes it possible to study the molecular mechanisms and gene pathways activated by the addition of external (chemical or physical) stressors. One of the main outcomes of the genomic sequencing projects of cnidarian species (corals, anemones, jellyfish and
Hydra body column has a high capacity for regeneration of both the head and foot. Because of the tissue dynamics that take place in adult Hydra, the processes governing axial patterning are continuously active to maintain the form of the animal. Following amputation at mid-gastric level, the two polyp halves immediately initiate an asymmetric process at the wound site: the upper half undergoes foot regeneration in about two days, whereas the lower half initiates the head regeneration process, which is completed in three days. Biochemical, cellular and molecular analyses showed that these two regions immediately undergo different reorganization to become foot and head regenerating tips, respectively. Cell proliferation and differentiation during the late stages allow adult size to be restored.
3. In vivo interactions between semiconductor nanocrystals and Hydra
3.1. GSH functionalized QDs target specific cell types in Hydra
The tripeptide glutathione (g-L-glutamyl-L-cysteinylglycine, GSH) has been well-known to biochemists for generations. Both the reduced form (GSH) and its oxidized dimer (GSSG) have been implicated in a variety of molecular reactions throughout the animal kingdom. Although it is best known for its role as a free radical scavenger, GSH also performs a number of other functions in cell survival and metabolism, including amino acid transport, detoxification of xenobiotics, maintenance of protein redox state, neuromodulation, and neurotransmission. Almost 50 years ago, Loomis and Lenhoff suggested a role of GSH in signal transduction in Hydra (Loomis, 1955). A class of binding sites for GSH has been described (Bellis et al., 1994; Grosvenor et al., 1992), providing the basis for the behavioural response. However, up today, the GSH receptors have not been isolated. With the aim to identify in vivo GSH receptor/binding proteins we synthesized GSH functionalized fluorescent semiconductor quantum dots and analysed in vivo the elicitation of a behavioural response together with the localization of GSH targeted cells (Tortiglione et al., 2007). The choice of QD arose from the great advantages offered by these new nanotechnological probes over conventional ones which are revolutionising biology and medicine (Medintz et al., 2005). Colloidal semiconductor QD probes have unique photophysical properties, such as size-tuneable emission spectrum, narrow emission peak, broad absorption profile, and high brightness; they are much more stable to the permanent loss of fluorescence than conventional organic fluorophores (Michalet et al., 2005) becoming powerful investigation tools for multicolour, long-term, and high-sensitivity fluorescence imaging. QD functionalization with GSH was obtained by several reaction steps: core/shell CdSe/ZnS QDs were first water solubilized by the addition of an amphiphilic polymer coating (PC), then stabilized by Polyethylene Glycole (PEG) molecules, and finally covalently bound to GSH (Figure 3).
Polymer-coated CdSe/ZnS core shell quantum dots were first conjugated to diamino-modified PEG molecules and then to GSH through amide bond formation. The resulting bioconjugated were extensively characterized to confirm the presence of the surface functionalizations (Tortiglione et al., 2007).
Both PEG-QDs and PEG-GSH-QDs were supplied to living polyps at different concentrations and then observed by fluorescence microscopy. A biological response consisting in mouth opening and QD entry into the gastric cavity was elicited by GSH-QDs. The elicitation of this behaviour, although slightly different from the classical feeding response (consisting of tentacle writhing and mouth opening) and occurring in a small percentage of animals (15%), was specific for GSH coated QDs, and indicated the bioactivity of the new GSH abduct. Fluorescent QD targeted cells were found within the inner endodermal cells, which internalized the QD upon mouth opening (see Figure 4) (Tortiglione et al., 2007).
The fluorescence pattern and intensity lasted unaltered until the animals were fed again, after which the signal started to fade slowly and was diluted throughout the emerging buds (Figure 5).
GSH-QDs do not undergo degradation into the endodermal cells. They follow cell turnover and migration towards the animal ends and the developing bud. Hydra treated with GSH-QDs were fed on alternate days. After three feeding cycles GSH-QDs were found diluted among the endodermal cells, continuously diving. The orange fluorescent punctuated pattern decreases uniformly as new buds are formed on the mother (see lower panel, representing an adult with an emerging bud). Scale bars are 200 μm in all pictures.
The uptake of GSH-QDs was an active endocytotic process, as shown by its inhibition when performing the incubation at 4 °C. Tissue cryosection and dissociation of whole treated polyps into single cell suspensions confirmed the presence of QDs into cytoplasmic granular vesicles. In conclusion this first work showed that GSH-QDs alone can stimulate a response, although in a small percentage (15%) of the treated animals. Possible reasons for this low percentage could be a low concentration of the GSH molecules conjugated to the QD surface or the modified stereochemical conformation of the bound GSH molecules, which does not allow for correct interaction with the protein target. Although the bioactive GSH-QDs could target specific cells, as shown by the fluorescence of the endodermal layer, the nature of the GSH binding protein (as GSH receptor, GSH transporters...) remain to be determined. An important clue emerged from this study was the capability of PEG-QDs to be also internalized by endodermal cells, upong chemical induction of mouth opening. The uptake rate was lower compared to GSH-QDs, indicating different internalization routes and underlying mechanism for the two types of QDs. Considering the multiple roles played by glutathione in metabolic functions, and in particular in the nervous system of higher vertebrates, GSH functionalized nanocrystals prepared and tested in this work represent promising tools for a wide variety of investigations, such as the elucidation of the role played by GSH in neurotransmission and the identification of its putative receptor. Beside these considerations, the capability of PEG-QDs to be up taken by Hydra cells prompted us to investigate more in detail the mechanism of internalization of QDs, the role played by the surface ligand, the surface chemistry and charge, which underlies any bio-non –bio interaction.
3.2. Unfunctionalized Quantum Rods elicit a behavioural response in Hydra vulgaris
The capability of Hydra to internalize, upon chemical induction of mouth opening, PEG-QDs into endodermal cells suggested that also unfunctionalized nanocrystals can play active roles when interacting with living cells. Noteworthy attention should be paid to the chemical composition of surfactant-polymer-coated nanoparticles not only in determining their stability in aqueous media but also in investigating their interaction with cells and intracellular localization. With the aim to test the impact of a new kind of semiconductor nanocrystal on Hydra vulgaris, we demonstrated that specific behaviours might be induced by exposure of whole animals to unfunctionalized nanocrystals and that a careful investigation of the impact of the new material on living cells must be carried out before designing any nanodevice for biomedical purposes (Malvindi et al., 2008).
The nanocrystals under investigation were fluorescent CdSe/CdS quantum rods (from here named QRs). In addition to QD properties, such as bright photoluminescence (PL), narrow emission spectra, and broad UV excitation, QRs have larger absorption cross-sections, which might allow improvement to certain biological applications where extremely high brightness and photostability are required. QRs of length and diameter 35 2 nm and 4.2 0.4 nm, respectively, were synthesised according to a newly developed procedure (Carbone et al., 2007), and transferred to aqueous medium by using the same methodology described above for QDs (Pellegrino, 2004; Sperling, 2006; Williams, 1981). The resulting highly fluorescent PEG coated QRs (Figure 6) were challenged to living polyps, which were monitored over progressive incubation periods.
The scheme shows the asymmetrical shape derived from the synthesis procedure (Carbone et al, 2007). The method involves coinjecting Cd2+ and S2- precursors and preformed spherical CdSe seeds into an environment of hot surfactants, well suited for the anisotropic growth of the second shell-material (CdS) on the first underlying core (CdSe). Resulting QRs are transferred from chloroform to water by wrapping them within an amphiphilic polymer shell (blue shell in the figure). To these polymer-coated QRs, polyethylene glycol (PEG) molecules (red shell) can be bound by using an EDC catalyzed cross linking scheme. The rod samples are an average of 35nm in length and 4 nm in diameter as confirmed by b) the TEM image of the corresponding sample (generously provided by Dr.A.Quarta, Italian Institute of Technology, Lecce, Italy)
Unlabelled cells were detectable by fluorescence microscopy, indicating that QRs were not uptaken by Hydra ectodermal cells. However, an unexpected animal behaviour was observed which consisted of an intense tentacle writhing, i.e. contractions and bending along the axial length of each tentacle, as shown in Figure 7.
The test was initiated by adding CdSe/CdS core/shell QRs to each well containing six polyps and motor activity was monitored by continuous video recording using a Camedia-digital camera (Olympus) connected to a cold light Wild stereo microscope a) Hydra polyp in physiological condition show extended tentacles. b) Within seconds of addition of QRs to the culture medium the polyp’s tentacle begin to writhe, bending toward the mouth. Contractions are not synchronous for all tentacles and lasted for an average of ten minutes (Malvindi et al., 2008).
The elicitation of this behaviour over an average period of ten minutes was dependent on the presence of calcium ions into Hydra medium, as shown by the inhibition of such activity by the calcium chelator EGTA. Interestingly, Hydra chemically depleted of neuronal cells were unresponsive to QRs, indicating that excitable cells are targeted by QRs. The mechanisms underlying neuron excitation are still under investigation, but the shape anisotropy has been shown involved in the elicitation of the activity, as nanocrystals of the identical chemical composition, but shaped as dots were ineffective. We suggested that CdSe/CdS QRs, regardless of surface chemical functionalization, may generate local electric fields associated with their permanent dipole moments that are intense enough to stimulate voltage dependent ion channels, thus eliciting an action potential resulting in motor activity. Results from a geometrical approximation (Malvindi et al., 2008) showed that a QR voltage potential of sufficient intensity to stimulate a voltage gated ion channel can be produced at nanometric separation distances, i.e. those lying between cell membranes and medium suspended QR, regardless of its orientation at the cell surface, thus it is theoretically possible for QRs to elicit neuronal activity. This hypothesis is currently under investigation in vertebrate model systems. In particular, we have preliminary data on the modulation of the electrophysiological properties of mammalian brain slices by QRs, (unpublished data) which indicate that QR response is not specific to our experimental model. Considering the challenges encountered in the design and synthesis of electrical nanodevices for neuronal stimulation (Pappas, 2007) we propose biocompatible, soluble QRs as a novel resource for neuronal devices, for diagnostic and therapeutic applications where non invasive probing and fine tuning of neuronal activity is required.
The peculiarities of our biological model system, such as the low-ionic-strength culture media and the presence of excitable cells directly facing the outer media, allowed us to highlight the neuronal stimulation by a nanometric inorganic particle, which might be difficult to study in vivo in a more complex whole organism. Avoiding the difficulties in investigating vertebrate brain behaviour in vivo, our cnidarian model organisms provided a simple, reliable, and fast system for screening nanoparticle activity in vivo on a functionally connected nerve net.
3.3. Unfunctionalized Quantum Rods reveals regulated portal of entry into Hydra cells
The complexity of the molecular interactions underlying the endocytosis suggests that a great evolutionary effort has been spent to regulate the cellular response to a variety of different environmental stimuli. In multicellular organisms the endocytic and secretory pathways evolved to control all aspects of cell physiology and intercellular communication (neurotransmission, immune response, development, hormone-mediated signal transduction). In this scenario, the emerging nanomaterials, variable in size (from 2 to 100 nm), chemical composition (gold, cadmium telluride, cadmium selenide, iron oxide) and physical properties (charge, spectral profile, colloidal stability, magnetism) represent a new class of compounds interacting with biological systems, which underlying mechanisms need to be carefully investigated. When studying the impact of CdSe/CdS QRs on Hydra (Malvindi et al., 2008), beside the detection of a specific behavioural response, an accurate microscopy analysis was performed in order to assess the putative internalization of the QRs into Hydra cells. At neutral pH, QR uptake was never detectable at the concentrations (7nM) eliciting biological activity. By contrast, using the same concentration of CdSe/CdS QRs, but changing the pH of the Hydra medium toward mild acidic values (pH 4.5- 4), an intense fluorescence was observed (Tortiglione et al., 2009). The labelling pattern as soon as 30 minutes post incubation with QRs appeared like a uniform red fluorescence staining all around the animal (Figure 8a). In the following hours membrane bound nanocrystals appeared compacted within cytoplasmic granular structures, easily detectable as red spots at level of the tentacles first (Figure 8b), and then throughout the body (Figure 8c).
Tissue cryosections made from treated animals allowed to detect not only the ectodermal localization of the internalized QRs, but also the dynamic of the labelled cells, at various time after incubation (Figure 9).
Intact Hydra were treated with QRs at acidic pH for 4 h, and 24 h later fixed and processed for cryosectioning. The green colour is due to tissue autofluorescence, while the red staining indicate the QR presence. Serial longitudinal tissue cryosections obtained at level of the head ( a, b and c ) and body (d) show QRs located into the ectodermal cells, but also inside endodermal cells lining both the tentacles and gastric region. A transversal section (e) confirms the tissue distribution. The labelling pattern before sectioning is shown in (f). Scale bars: 200 μm (a-e), and 500 μm (f).
Remarkably, 24 h post treatment, fluorescent material appeared also into the endodermal cells lining the gastric cavity and the tentacles. At the tentacle base, the fluorescence draws a well defined strip along the tentacle length, shown by cross sections to be localised inside the endodermal cells and not in the tentacle lumen (Figure 9a, 9b, 9c). This cell dynamic, from ectoderm to endoderm, has never been described using conventional organic fluorophores and highlights the importance of using the innovative fluorophore to probe biological processes. The high photostability of the QRs allowed to study with unprecedented brightness and resolution endocytotic processes in Hydra and to track these phenomena over long periods. The same dynamic was observed also during regeneration of treated animals and it probably depends from autophagocytosis process occurring during head regeneration (Tortiglione et al., 2009). Beside these results, we determined the factors involved in the capability of Hydra to uptake QRs at acidic but not neutral pH and investigated the roles played by the nanocrystal surface at one side and by Hydra membranes at the other. QRs used in this study where stabilised by the addition of amino-PEG coating. Zeta potential measurement showed that at acidic pH QRs were positively charged, while at neutral pH their surface net charge was neutral or negative. Modifying the amounts of amino-PEG molecules present on QR surface we were able to tune the QR net charge and thus the up taking process. At acidic pH, the protonation of the PEG amino terminal groups (NH3+) contributes to increase the positive charges while the protonation of the carboxyl groups of the amphiphilic polymer shell causes a reduction of the negative charges (COO2-) at the nanoparticle surface and indeed the sum of the two effects results in a net positive surface of the QR (Figure 10). The different amounts of PEG molecules attached at the same QR surface account for the different behaviours displayed by diverse nanorod samples, independently from their size and shape. QRs presenting positive zeta potential bind to negatively charged membrane lipids, and stimulate endocytosis processes. A scheme of the QR protonation occurring at acidic pH is shown in Figure 10.
A schematic view of the functional groups at the nanoparticle surface responsible for the switching of the surface charge. At basic pH, the carboxy groups are negatively charged and the amino groups are not protonated. At acidic pH, the carboxy and the amino groups are both protonated, which account for a positive zeta potential value measured. At neutral pH, the zeta potential measured in all cases is negative. The blue colour indicates the CdS/CdS core, while the amphiphilic polymer and PEG coatings are pink coloured. Modified from (Tortiglione et al., 2009).
We also investigated the biological factors involved in the internalization of QRs at acidic pH, and found the involvement of a peculiar protein displaying a pH dependent behaviour, named Annexin (ANX) (Moss and Morgan, 2004). ANXB12 is a Hydra protein belonging to the annexins superfamily, able to insert into lipidic membranes and to form ion channels at acidic but not neutral pH (Schlaepfer et al., 1992a; Schlaepfer et al., 1992b). As Hydra treatment with anti-ANX antibody prevented QR uptake, we suggest that ANX mediates the interaction with positively charged QRs, organizing membrane domains and uptake processes, probably throughout the specie-specific amino terminal domain. In presence of anti-ANX antibody, the endocytosis machinery is blocked, likely due to impairment of functional or structural important ANX extracellular domains.
In conclusion, the combined effect of nanorod positive surface charge and structural properties of cell membranes, at acidic pH, resulted in the active internalization of the fluorescent nanoparticles into specific cell types and according to a precise temporal dynamic. The availability of beautifully illuminated animals led to track fluorescent cells during developmental and regeneration processes, and to describe, beside known migration events, new cell dynamics and inter-epithelial/intercellular trafficking phenomena, which intriguing meaning lays the foundations for further investigations. Thus, we provide an example of how, probing cell and animal biology with nanosized compounds, we can uncover novel biological phenomena, aware of our capability of finely tuning and controlling this interaction for specific purposes.
The two examples of Hydra/QR interaction described in the two sections above show two biologically relevant responses induced by the same nanocrystal, determined in one case by the QR intrinsic shape dependent electrical properties, and in the other one by the QR positive surface charge. These studies show that presentation of chemical information at the same size scale as that of cell surface receptors may interfere with cellular processes, eliciting unexpected responses, such as the activation of a behavioural responses, or cell uptake, and that a simple experimental change, such as the pH of the medium used in the bioassay, may determinate dramatic difference in the evoked response. Thus, the interactions occurring at the interface bio-non bio are complex and depending on both players, which need to be fully characterized when designing nanodevices targeting biological systems.
3.4. Cadmium telluride QDs induce cytotoxic effects in Hydra vulgaris
The freedom to design and modify NCs to accomplish very specific tasks is currently being realized. However, their unique properties, not present in conventional bulk materials, such as enhanced magnetic, electrical and optical properties, have potential implications in NC toxicity, such as elemental composition, charge, shape, surface area and surface chemistry/derivatization. Several data of the inherent toxicity of some NCs are available and indicate that they can affect biological behaviour at the organ, tissue and cellular levels, and activate changes in the expression of stress-related or apoptotic genes (Choi et al., 2008; Rivera Gil et al., 2010). The great amount of data collected up to today regards different materials, biological systems, and are strictly dependent on the cell lines tested (Lewinski et al., 2008). This may be a result of interference with the chemical probes, differences in the innate response of particular cell types, as well as depending upon the different protocols used by different laboratories for the nanoparticle synthesis and characterization, giving rise to not identical nanomaterials. Therefore, for a single nanocrystal, the biological activities of NCs should be assessed by multiple cell-based assays and should more realistically rely on animal models (Fischer and Chan, 2007).
A primary source of QD toxicity results from cadmium residing in the QD core. Toxicity of uncoated core CdSe or CdTe-QD has been discussed in several reports and is associated, in part, with free cadmium present in the particle suspensions or released from the particle core intracellularly (Derfus, 2004; Kirchner et al., 2005; Lovric et al., 2005a). Free radical formation induced by the highly reactive QD core might also play crucial roles in the cellular toxicity. Encapsulation of the CdSe-QD with a ZnS shell or other capping materials has been shown to reduce toxicity, although much work remains to be completed in this field. However, to accurately assess safety of shell or capped particles, the degradation of the shell or capping material, along with its cytotoxicity must also be considered since several groups have found increased toxicity associated to capping materials such as mercaptoacetic acid and Topo-tri-n-octylphosphine oxide (TOPO) (Smith et al., 2008). Taken together, these reports suggest that the integrity of shell and capping materials, as well as toxicity, needs to also be more thoroughly assessed and that shell/capping materials must be assessed for different QD preparations.
Based on these considerations long term studies of effects on both cell viability and signal transduction are needed, and surely the animal studies are definitely required for proper assessment of QD toxicity. To date, rats have been used as model organisms for pharmacological studies, and only recently the use of invertebrates to test Cd based QDs is adding valuable informations in this field. For example, the freshwater macroinvertebrate, Daphnia magna, has been used to evaluate toxicity characteristics of CdSe/ZnSe in relation to surface coatings (Lee, 2009).
Cnidaria are sensitive to many environmental stressors and may become valuable indicators of exposure to disruptive chemicals and other stressors, such as nanomaterials. During animal evolution, an array of gene families and pathways (also known as “environmental genes”) have evolved to face physical, chemical, and biological stressors. While the immune system responds to biotic stressors such as pathogens (Miller et al., 2007), another set of genes named “chemical defensome” (Goldstone, 2008), has been identified to sense, transform, and eliminate potentially toxic chemicals.
Hydra is sensitive to a range of pollutants and has been used to tests on water contamination by heavy metals (Holdway et al., 2001; Pascoe et al., 2003; Pollino and Holdway, 1999). Metal pollutants such as copper, cadmium and zinc have been tested against different Hydra species, and the relative toxicity based on the median lethal concentration (LC50) for all species was ranked from copper, the most toxic, to cadmium, with zinc least toxic (Karntanut and Pascoe, 2002; Karntanut and Pascoe, 2005). Drugs and pharmaceuticals targeted at mammalian receptors have also been shown to adversely affects Hydra (Pascoe et al., 2002), showing the feasibility to use this aquatic invertebrate to accurately assess the potential toxicological effect of any kind of molecule added to the animal culture medium.
In light of this knowledge we evaluated the possibility to use Hydra for nanotoxicology purposes. We addressed the toxicological effects of fluorescent CdTe QDs, presenting different chemical coatings on Hydra using several bioassays: 1) alteration of morphological traits, measurable as morphological median score values 2) alteration of reproductive capabilities, measurable as population growth rates 3) alteration of regeneration or pattern formation. These three phenomena are schematically drawn in Figure 11.
The toxic effects of organic and inorganic pollutants, i.e, CdTe QDs, can be measured using Hydra, due to its unique developmental potentials. The toxicant under investigation can be added to the medium bathing living polyps and the effects on morphology, reproductive and regeneration capabilities can be quantified by standardised protocols. Upper panel: alteration of morphological traits can be measured by assigning numerical scores to progressive morphological changes (Wilby, 1988)(see below). Middle panel: upon regular feeding, the animals undergo asexual reproduction through budding: the number of buds produced by a single polyp over two weeks can be expressed as reproductive rate, which is altered in presence of toxicants. Lower panel: initially reported by A.Trembley (Trembley, 1744), Hydra polyps can regenerate any missing part after bisection of the body column performed at any level, and the presence of toxicants can irreversibly affect this capability.
CdTe nanocrystals are the most successful example of the colloidal quantum dots directly synthesized in aqueous solution. In Figure 12 a schematic representation of the synthesis of TGA-capped QDs is shown. The methodology was first described by Gao (Gao M, 1998) and it is routinely employed in many laboratories, although modifications have been further developed to increase photoluminescence, quantum yields, or for specific applications in various fields ranging from light harvesting and energy transfer to biotechnology (Gaponik and Rogach, 2010). The water-soluble CdTe QDs we analysed using Hydra were surface-capped with thioglycolic acid (TGA) or stabilized by glutathione (GSH), synthesized as described (Rogach and Lesnyak, 2007) and present a mean diameter of 3.1nm and 3.6nm, respectively.
In our previous studies using CdSe/ZnS QDs or CdSe/CdS QRs evident toxicity signs were not detected, even at the highest QD dose tested (300nM) (Tortiglione et al., 2007). In those cases, nanocrystal synthesis was accomplished by burying a CdSe inner core into a ZnS or CdS shell, then wrapping the metal core/shell by an amphiphilic polymer, further stabilised by conjugation to PEG molecules. The CdTe QDs are sized only a few nanometres and differ not only in chemical composition, but also in the synthetic route (directly in aqueous solution) employing different compounds (thioglycolic acid or glutathione...) as stabilising molecules. These differences drove our comparative toxicity studies using CdTe QDs and testing different concentrations and exposure times (Tino et al., 2011).
The basics of the aqueous synthesis of thiol-capped CdTe NCs. In a typical standard synthesis, Cd(ClO4) salts are dissolved in water, and an appropriate amount of the thiol stabilizer is added under stirring, followed by adjusting the pH by dropwise addition of NaOH. Under stirring, H2Te gas is then passed through the solution together with a slow nitrogen flow. CdTe NC precursors are formed at this stage; formation and growth of NCs proceed upon refluxing at 100°C under open-air conditions with a condenser attached (from (Rogach and Lesnyak, 2007).
When challenging living polyps to CdTe QDs, adverse effects on animal behaviour and morphology were immediately observed. In Figure 13 the pictures of polyps carrying progressive damages are shown. These different damages have been annotated using a scoring system ranging from 10 (healthy polyps) to zero (disintegrated animals) (Wilby, 1990), and already used for toxicological studies in Hydra. This system can be efficiently adopted to compare toxicity of diverse compounds or the sensitivity of different species to a given substance.
Examples of morphological alterations induced by treatment of living Hydra with CdTe QDs. Animals were incubated with TGA-QDs and observed by a stereomicroscope over a period of 72h. Images show progressive morphological changes scored from 10 down to 0, according to the scoring system previously developed (Wilby, 1988)
By fluorescence microscopy we observed intense staining in animals treated with the highest tested QD concentration (300nM), indicating QD uptake (Figure 14). At lower concentrations, the low fluorescent staining did not allow imaging.
Elemental analysis by Inductively Coupled Plasma Atomic Emission Spectrometer (ICP-AES) confirmed the internalization of the CdTeQDs (Ambrosone et al, unpublished).
Polyps were challenged with CdTe QDs and imaged after 2 hours of incubation. The polyp appears contracted, the tentacles clubbed, shortened. The fluorescence is uniform all along the animal (body and tentacles), drawing straight lines perpendicular to the main oral-aboral axis, and corresponding to membranes belonging to adjacent cells aligned during contraction. Granular structures are also present, indicating the initial uptake of QDs by ectodermal cells.
We performed acute toxicity tests (by exposing the animals for two hours to QDs and then monitoring the morphological scores), and chronic toxicity tests performing continuous incubation with the QDs (Ambrosone et al, unpublished). Under both acute and chronic treatment the median score values decreased with progressive exposure time, indicating toxic effect (see Figure 15A). After 72 hr of continuous incubation with 25nM QDs, all animals showed score value equal to zero, meaning that were all fully disintegrated. In Figure 15B, the distribution of the different scores among the treated animals is shown at each time point. Untreated animals showed always score 10 (blue bar, highlighted by the upper red arrow), while treatment with QDs causes a decrease in the score values, more pronounced for the higher QD concentration tested (25nM). In this latter case after 72 hr of continuous incubation all animals were fully disintegrated, as highlighted by the red arrows of Figure 15B.
The toxicity of CdTe QD to Hydra was further evaluated using a different method, based on mortality. The number of death animals was used for survival statistical analysis, and the Karber-Spearmann (Hamilton, 1977) method used to determinate the median lethal concentration and the median lethal scores, as shown in Figure 15C.
Two different methods can be used to assess the toxicity of a given compound on Hydra. The first method (used in A and B) is based on the evaluation of animal morphological traits, while the second one (C) is based on survival rates. In A the time response toxicity curves to equivalent TGA-QD concentrations are compared to the curves obtained by two different concentrations of Cd salts. 25 Hydra were treated with the indicated compound and morphological scores were monitored over 24, 48 and 72hr. In B the number of the animals presenting different scores are reported for each time point in the three graphs (24, 48, 72hr). The red arrows highlights that the score values decreasing from ten (untreated animals) to zero obtained with 25nM concentration, after 72hr of incubation. In C the median lethal time and median lethal concentration were calculated using the Sperman-Karber method.
In this way sub-lethal doses were determined and used for assessing the potential long-term toxic effects induced by CdTe QDs on Hydra reproductive capabilities (Ambrosone et al., 2011; Tino et al., 2011). Growth rate of Hydra tissue is regulated by the epithelial cell cycle, which normal length (about 3 days) is controlled by environmental conditions, i.e., the feeding regime (Bosch and David, 1984). Thus, for a given feeding condition, the growth rate is an indirect measure of the Hydra tissue growth and cell viability. The number of individuals generated by an adult polyps over two-three weeks can be used to calculate the growth rates constant (k), which is the slope of the regression line using the standard equation of logarithmic growth: ln (n/n°) = kt (where n is the number of individuals at the time t, and n° is the number of the founder polyps). Representative growth rate curves determined for QD treated and untreated animals are shown in the graph of Figure 15, and indicate k values lower for QD treated animals compared to control. These differences were found significant by statistical analysis of repeated experiments (Ambrosone et al, unpublished).
Regeneration efficiencies were also estimated bisecting the animals and allowing regeneration in presence of QDs. During the first 48-72hr post amputation a great percentage of animals treated with the highest QD concentration were unable to regenerate a head and were found as stumps without tentacles (stage 0).
Moreover, about 30% of the bisected animals died, demonstrating the high QD toxicity (see Figure 16, upper panel).
Upper panel: representative histogram showing the impact of QDs on Hydra head regeneration. The regeneration stages are classified as in Fig.2. Basically, stage zero indicate the complete inhibition of regeneration (zero tentacles); stage 1, indicates heads with aberrant tentacles (one or two), while stage 2 indicates normal regeneration (tentacles from four to six at this time). The lowest QD concentration tested, 10nM, does not impair head regeneration, while the 25nM dose inhibits the whole process, and furthermore, causes lethality. Lower panel: influence of the QD treatment on Hydra population growth rate. Population growth test started with a population of four full-grown Hydra, incubated 24h with the indicated dose of QD, washed out and monitored every day for bud detachment. The logarithmic growth rate constant (k) is the slope of the regression line using the standard equation of logarithmic growth: ln (n/n0) = kt. In this representative graph the regression line is not drawn. Polyps treated with the highest QD concentration were impaired in the reproductive capabilities, as shown by the altered ratio n/n° along the monitored period (Ambrosone et al, unpublished).
We also compared the effects of thioglycolic acid capped QDs (TGA-QDs) and glutathione capped QDs (GSH-QDs), by using the same approaches and observed that although both nanocrystals were toxic, the most severe effects were induced by TGA capped QDs (Tino et al., 2011). This confirms the importance of the nanocrystal surface chemistry in the interaction with living cells.
The availability of a Hydra whole genome sequence allowed us to study the nanoparticle-induced cellular changes at three levels: non-genomic, genomic and epigenetic. The genes selectively involved in the apoptosis or in the necrosis process, as diverse as the Hymyc transcription factor, Caspase 3, Superoxide dismutase, Hsp70 have been analysed by quantitative real time PCR, and compared to the expression of animals treated with free cadmium salts (Ambrosone et al, unpublished). Aside from genotoxic effects, as nanoparticles could cause more subtle changes to living cells, such as long-term effects on gene expression, after the QD signal has been removed, epigenetic effects are being addressed. At the current stage of investigation, the elucidation of the possible molecular pathways activated by CdTe QDs appears rather complex, and it may concern universal stress response genes, Cd specific response genes or novel unidentified signalling cascades, initiated by the QDs at the cell surface.
In conclusion, by using different approaches, from in vivo evaluation of morphological traits to the impact on growth rate and regeneration, to the molecular analysis of the genes potentially involved in the QD response, we determined animal behaviours and toxicological effects played by CdTe QDs, and proposed Hydra as a valuable model for nanotoxicology studies.
The impact of nanoparticles on a living organism can be assessed by using the freshwater polyp Hydra. This system allows to evaluate in vivo, ex vivo and in vitro the responses of a whole animal to short or long exposures of any organic and inorganic compound, unless unstable in Hydra culture medium.
4. Hydra as a widely applicable tool for high-throughput screens of nanoparticles biocompatibility and (eco)toxicity
The use of simple model organisms to dissect complex biological processes has permitted biology to advance at an impressive pace, and the knowledge generated by integrating genetic and biochemical studies has allowed scientists to begin to understand the molecular basis of complex diseases such as cancer and diabetes. Several pharmaceutical companies developed research programs that use simple organisms to identify and validate drug targets. Since the production of newer engineered nanomaterials and their applications has exponentially increased, high-throughput screens (HTS) are required to evaluate their impact on human and environmental health. In the above sections I gave some examples demonstrating the use of Hydra as valuable model system for the dissection of biological processes evoked by metal based nanocrystals. Because of the small size, short generation time, high fecundity and cost effective maintenance, it can also be used for HTS of nanoparticle biocompatibility, environmental and animal impact. Standard microtiter plates can be used for whole animal assays to assess toxicity and identify the underlying mechanisms by simply changing multiple experimental conditions in adjacent wells, such as medium composition, pH, presence of specific inhibitors/competitors/agonists, and the trials can all be run in parallel, in large scale enabling statistical treatment of the data.
In addition, the new genomic resources open the way to the molecular toxicology field. Several gene families that defend against chemical stressors have been identified in other cnidarians and include oxidases, various conjugating enzymes, ATP-dependent efflux transporters, oxidative detoxification proteins, as well as various transcription factors (Goldstone, 2008; Goldstone et al., 2006). The modulation of their expression in Hydra exposed to the new class of stressors, i.e. nanomaterials, may easily help to dissect the mechanisms underlying nanoparticle toxicity, and to identify those shared by other stressors and those unique to the nanomaterial under investigation.
Considering the key role played by cnidarians in freshwater, estuarine and reefs environments, the obtained results would be of invaluable importance for ecotoxicological studies as well. As nanoparticles may enter natural waters through sewage effluent and landfill leakages and present unknown risk to aquatic species, invertebrate testing may be used not only to advance the level of knowledge in nanoecotoxicology, but also for investigating behaviour and bioavailability of engineered nanoparticles in the aquatic environments.
Since the first publication on Hydra challenged with functional QDs (Tortiglione et al., 2007), the scientific community caught the advantages offered by this simple model to address nanotechnological issues, and many groups involved in the synthesis of nanomaterials demanded to test their synthetic products on Hydra. A picture of living polyps exposed to different nanoparticles is shown in Figure 18. We are currently investigating for each material the cell and molecular bases of interaction with Hydra, from the internalization route relying on the chemistry surface properties, to the molecular machinery activated by these nanosized objects. These results would be of valuable help when designing nanodevices to be interfaced with eukaryotic living cells. Once established the rules governing such interactions we will move toward the functionalization of the nanoparticles, combing the new size dependent physical properties to the specificity of the bioactive conjugated moiety to achieve targeted functioning.
Despite the initial studies limited to fluorescent semiconductor nanocrystals (QDs and QRs) for imaging purposes, the wide arrays of physical properties offered by nanoparticles of different materials supplies a corresponding wide repertoire of new tools to probe biological phenomena. Superparamagnetic nanoparticles (FexOy) could be employed for local heat generation (magnetic hyperthermia) under an alternating magnetic field, and thus exploited for selective cell destruction. Up to date, magnetic hyperthermia has been studied for cancer treatment but not applied to basic research, i.e. to obtain loss of function by cell ablation. Similarly, the property of some nanomaterials to strongly absorb NIR irradiation for conversion into thermal energy has been tested for phototherapy in cellular models, but not as universal tool for cell/animal biology. Nowadays nanotechnology allow to revisit traditional methodologies and extract yet unobserved or inaccessible information in vitro or in vivo. Only the cross-talk between different disciplines (biologists /chemists/physics) can bridge separate expertises, develop innovative tools and successfully apply them to modern research.
In vivo imaging of polyps incubated with different nanocrystals, whose interaction with Hydra in terms of biocompatibility and toxicology is currently in progress. Upper left panel: picture of a living Hydra incubated with bifunctional conjugates (Fe2O3-OTF) based on the linkage of inorganic Fe2O3 nanoparticles to organic oligothiophene fluorophores (OTFs). Nanoparticle core diameter: 8nm; emission λmax= 605nm (Quarta et al., 2008). The presence of the fluorophore allows to track nanoparticle cell uptake, while the magnetic properties can be exploited for magnetic separation of the labelled cells. Upper right panel: Hydra labelled with fluorescent rod shaped nanocrystals, PEG coated CdSe/ZnS QRs. Nanoparticle diameter: 3,5nm, lenght 34nm; emission λmax= 592 nm. These two type of nanocrystals were a precious gift from Dr. Teresa Pellegrino (Italian Institute of Technology, Genova, Italy). Lower left panel: CdTe QD amino stabilised, by cysteamine, (emission λmax= 510nm, diameter: 2.6nm) were added to the medium bathing living Hydras and imaged after 4 hr. These nanocrystals were a generous gift from Dr. Andrey Rogach, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, SAR. Lower right panel: Hydra treated with PEG coated gold nanoparticles (diameter: 14nm) These nanocrystals were surface modified to introduce positive charges on the surface (de la Fuente et al, unpublished) and are internalized at high rate by Hydra ectodermal cells. These nanocrystals were supplied by Dr. Jesus de la Fuente, University of Zaragoza, Spain. At the bottom representative TEM images of the samples above described were generously supplied by the corresponding providers.
I sincerely thank all the co-authors of the papers on Hydra/nanoparticles that I mentioned in this chapter, and those that are in preparation. As I stated earlier, these interdisciplinary works were made possible by the tight collaboration between different groups and expertises, and a great effort stands beyond each one. In particular, I thank Dr. Teresa Pellegrino (Italian Institute of Technology, Genova, Italy), as with her precious collaboration in material synthesis the whole research line was launched; dr.Angela Tino, (Institute of Cybernetics, National research Council of Italy) for daily discussions and data analysis; and people from my lab which shared challenges and enthusiasm for this work. This work is supported by the NanoSci-ERA net project NANOTRUCK (2009-2012).
Alivisatos A. P. Gu W. Larabell C. 2005Quantum dots as cellular probes. , 7 55 76
Ambrosone A. Marchesano V. Mattera L. Tino A. Tortiglione C. 2011Bridging the fields of nanoscience and toxicology: nanoparticle impact on biological models. In Parak, W.J., Yamamoto, K., Osinski, M. (ed.), . SPIE, Bellingham, WA, Washington, USA, 7909
Auffan M. Rose J. Bottero J. Y. Lowry G. V. Jolivet J. P. Wiesner M. R. 2009Towards a definition of inorganic nanoparticles from an environmental, health and safety perspective. , 4 634 641
Baun A. Hartmann N. B. Grieger K. Kusk K. O. 2008Ecotoxicity of engineered nanoparticles to aquatic invertebrates: a brief review and recommendations for future toxicity testing. , 17 387 395
Bellis S. L. Laux D. C. Rhoads D. E. 1994Affinity purification of Hydra glutathione binding proteins. , 354 320 324
Bode H. R. 2003Head regeneration in Hydra. , 226 225 236
Bosch T. C. David C. N. 1984Growth regulation in Hydra: relationship between epithelial cell cycle length and growth rate. , 104 161 171
Bruchez M. Moronne M. Gin P. Weiss S. Alivisatos A. P. 1998Semiconductor nanocrystals as fluorescent biological labels. , 281 2013 2016
Carbone L. Nobile C. De Giorgi M. Sala F. D. Morello G. Pompa P. Hytch M. Snoeck E. Fiore A. Franchini I. R. Nadasan M. Silvestre A. F. Chiodo L. Kudera S. Cingolani R. Krahne R. Manna L. 2007Synthesis and micrometer-scale assembly of colloidal CdSe/CdS nanorods prepared by a seeded growth approach. , 7 2942 2950
Cattaneo A. G. G. R. Chiriva-Internati M. Bernardini G. 2009Ecotoxicology of nanomaterials: the role of invertebrate testing. , 6 78 97
Chapman, J.A., Kirkness, E.F., Simakov, O., Hampson, S.E., Mitros, T., Weinmaier, T., Rattei, T., Balasubramanian, P.G., Borman, J., Busam, D., Disbennett, K., Pfannkoch, C., Sumin, N., Sutton, G.G., Viswanathan, L.D., Walenz, B., Goodstein, D.M., Hellsten, U., Kawashima, T., Prochnik, S.E., Putnam, N.H., Shu, S., Blumberg, B., Dana, C.E., Gee, L., Kibler, D.F., Law, L., Lindgens, D., Martinez, D.E., Peng, J., Wigge, P.A., Bertulat, B., Guder, C., Nakamura, Y., Ozbek, S., Watanabe, H., Khalturin, K., Hemmrich, G., Franke, A., Augustin, R., Fraune, S., Hayakawa, E., Hayakawa, S., Hirose, M., Hwang, J.S., Ikeo, K., Nishimiya-Fujisawa, C., Ogura, A., Takahashi, T., Steinmetz, P.R., Zhang, X., Aufschnaiter, R., Eder, M.K., Gorny, A.K., Salvenmoser, W., Heimberg, A.M., Wheeler, B.M., Peterson, K.J., Bottger, A., Tischler, P., Wolf, A., Gojobori, T., Remington, K.A., Strausberg, R.L., Venter, J.C., Technau, U., Hobmayer, B., Bosch, T.C., Holstein, T.W., Fujisawa, T., Bode, H.R., David, C.N., Rokhsar, D.S. and Steele, R.E. ( 2010) The dynamic genome of Hydra. Nature, 464, 592-596.
Choi A. O. Brown S. E. Szyf M. Maysinger D. 2008Quantum dot-induced epigenetic and genotoxic changes in human breast cancer cells. , 86 291 302
Demir E. V. G. Kaya B. Creus A. Marcos R. 2010Genotoxic analysis of silver nanoparticles in Drosophila. , in press, 1 8
Derfus A. C. W. C. W. Bhatia S. N. 2004Probing the Cytotoxicity of Semiconductor Quantum Dots. , 4 11 18
Fischer H. C. Chan W. C. 2007Nanotoxicity: the growing need for in vivo study. , 18 565 571
Galliot B. Chera S. 2010The Hydra model: disclosing an apoptosis-driven generator of Wnt-based regeneration. , 20 514 523
Galliot B. Ghila L. 2010Cell plasticity in homeostasis and regeneration. , 77 837 855
Galliot B. Miljkovic-Licina M. de Rosa R. Chera S. 2006Hydra, a niche for cell and developmental plasticity. , 17 492 502
Gao M. K. S. Mvhwald H. Rogach A. L. Kornovski A. Eyhmiller A. Weller Horst. 1998Strongly photoluminescent CdTe nanocrystals by proper surface modification. , 102 8360 8363
Gaponik N. Rogach A. L. 2010Thiol-capped CdTe nanocrystals: progress and perspectives of the related research fields. , 12 8685 8693
Goldstone J. V. 2008Environmental sensing and response genes in cnidaria: the chemical defensome in the sea anemone Nematostella vectensis. , 24 483 502
Goldstone J. V. Hamdoun A. Cole B. J. Howard-Ashby M. Nebert D. W. Scally M. Dean M. Epel D. Hahn M. E. Stegeman J. J. 2006The chemical defensome: environmental sensing and response genes in the Strongylocentrotus purpuratus genome. , 300 366 384
Grosvenor W. Bellis S. L. Kass-Simon G. Rhoads D. E. 1992Chemoreception in hydra: specific binding of glutathione to a membrane fraction. , 1117 120 125
Hamilton M. A. Russo R. C. Thurston R. V. 1977Trimmed Spearman-Karber Method for Estimating Median Lethal Concentrations in Toxicity Bioassays. , 11 714 719
Holdway D. A. Lok K. Semaan M. 2001The acute and chronic toxicity of cadmium and zinc to two hydra species. , 16 557 565
Holstein T. W. Hobmayer E. Technau U. 2003Cnidarians: an evolutionarily conserved model system for regeneration? , 226 257 267
Hoshino A. Fujioka K. Oku T. Suga M. Sasaki Y. F. Ohta T. Yasuhara M. Suzuki K. Yamamoto K. 2004Physicochemical properties and cellular toxicity of nanocrystal quantum dots depend on their surface modification. , 4 2163 2169
Hu J. Li L. Yang W. Manna L. Wang L. Alivisatos A. P. 2001Linearly polarized emission from colloidal semiconductor quantum rods. , 292 2060 2063
Huynh W. U. Dittmer J. J. Alivisatos A. P. 2002Hybrid nanorod-polymer solar cells. , 295 2425 2427
Jiang W. Kim B. Y. Rutka J. T. Chan W. C. 2008Nanoparticle-mediated cellular response is size-dependent. , 3 145 150
Karntanut W. Pascoe D. 2000A comparison of methods for measuring acute toxicity to Hydra vulgaris. , 41 1543 1548
Karntanut W. Pascoe D. 2002The toxicity of copper, cadmium and zinc to four different Hydra (Cnidaria: Hydrozoa). , 47 1059 1064
Karntanut W. Pascoe D. 2005Effects of removing symbiotic green algae on the response of Hydra viridissima (Pallas 1776) to metals. , 60 301 305
Kirchner C. Liedl T. Kudera S. Pellegrino T. Munoz Javier. A. Gaub H. E. Stolzle S. Fertig N. Parak W. J. 2005Cytotoxicity of colloidal CdSe and CdSe/ZnS nanoparticles. , 5 331 338
Lee J. J. K. Kim J. Park K. Lim K. H. Yoon T. H. Choi K. 2009Acute Toxicity of Two CdSe/ZnSe Quantum Dots with Different Surface Coating in Daphnia magna Under Various Light Conditions. , 25.
Lenhoff H. M. Muscatine L. Davis L. V. 1968Coelenterate biology: experimental research. , 160 1141 1146
Lewinski N. Colvin V. Drezek R. 2008Cytotoxicity of nanoparticles. , 4 26 49
Loomis W. F. 1955Glutathione control of the specific feeding reactions of Hydra. , 62 208 209
Loomis W. F. Lenhoff H. M. 1956Growth and sexual differentiation of Hydra in mass culture.. 132 555 574
Lovric J. Bazzi H. S. Cuie Y. Fortin G. R. Winnik F. M. Maysinger D. 2005aDifferences in subcellular distribution and toxicity of green and red emitting CdTe quantum dots. , 83 377 385
Lovric J. Cho S. J. Winnik F. M. Maysinger D. 2005bUnmodified cadmium telluride quantum dots induce reactive oxygen species formation leading to multiple organelle damage and cell death. , 12 1227 1234
Malvindi M. A. Carbone L. Quarta A. Tino A. Manna L. Pellegrino T. Tortiglione C. 2008Rod-shaped nanocrystals elicit neuronal activity in vivo. , 4 1747 1755
Maynard A. D. Aitken R. J. Butz T. Colvin V. Donaldson K. Oberdorster G. Philbert M. A. Ryan J. Seaton A. Stone V. Tinkle S. S. Tran L. Walker N. J. Warheit D. B. 2006Safe handling of nanotechnology. , 444 267 269
Medintz I. L. Uyeda H. T. Goldman E. R. Mattoussi H. 2005Quantum dot bioconjugates for imaging, labelling and sensing. , 4 435 446
Michalet X. Pinaud F. F. Bentolila L. A. Tsay J. M. Doose S. Li J. J. Sundaresan G. Wu A. M. Gambhir S. S. Weiss S. 2005Quantum dots for live cells, in vivo imaging, and diagnostics. , 307 538 544
Miller D. J. Hemmrich G. Ball E. E. Hayward D. C. Khalturin K. Funayama N. Agata K. Bosch T. C. 2007The innate immune repertoire in cnidaria--ancestral complexity and stochastic gene loss. , 8, R59.
Moss S. E. Morgan R. O. 2004The annexins. , 5, 219.
Pappas T. C. Wickramanyake W. M. Jan E. Motamedi M. Brodwick M. Kotov N. A. 2007Nanoscale engineering of a cellular interface with semiconductor nanoparticle films for photoelectric stimulation of neurons. , 7 513 519
Pascoe D. Carroll K. Karntanut W. Watts M. M. 2002Toxicity of 17alpha-ethinylestradiol and bisphenol A to the freshwater Cnidarian Hydra vulgaris. , 43 56 63
Pascoe D. Karntanut W. Muller C. T. 2003Do pharmaceuticals affect freshwater invertebrates? A study with the cnidarian Hydra vulgaris. , 51 521 528
Pellegrino T. Manna L. Kudera S. Liedl T. Koktysh D. Rogach A. Keller S. Radler J. Natile G. Parak W. J. 2004Hydrophobic nanocrystals coated with an amphiphilic polymer shell: A general route to water soluble nanocrystals. 4 703 707
Pierobon P. Minei R. Porcu P. Sogliano C. Tino A. Marino G. Biggio G. Concas A. 2001Putative glycine receptors in Hydra: a biochemical and behavioural study. , 14 1659 1666
Pierobon P. Sogliano C. Minei R. Tino A. Porcu P. Marino G. Tortiglione C. Concas A. 2004Putative NMDA receptors in Hydra: a biochemical and functional study. , 20 2598 2604
Pollino C. A. Holdway D. A. 1999Potential of two hydra species as standard toxicity test animals. , 43 309 316
Putnam N. H. Srivastava M. Hellsten U. Dirks B. Chapman J. Salamov A. Terry A. Shapiro H. Lindquist E. Kapitonov V. V. Jurka J. Genikhovich G. Grigoriev I. V. Lucas S. M. Steele R. E. Finnerty J. R. Technau U. Martindale M. Q. Rokhsar D. S. 2007Sea anemone genome reveals ancestral eumetazoan gene repertoire and genomic organization. , 317 86 94
Quarta A. Di Corato R. Manna L. Argentiere S. Cingolani R. Barbarella G. Pellegrino T. 2008Multifunctional nanostructures based on inorganic nanoparticles and oligothiophenes and their exploitation for cellular studies. , 130 10545 10555
Rivera Gil. P. Oberdorster G. Elder A. Puntes V. Parak W. J. 2010Correlating physico-chemical with toxicological properties of nanoparticles: the present and the future. , 4 5527 5531
Rogach A. L. F. T. Klar T. A. Feldmann J. Gaponik N. Lesnyak V. S. A. Eychmuller A. Rakovich Y. P. Donegan J. F. 2007Aqueous Synthesis of Thiol-Capped CdTe Nanocrystals: State-of-the-Art. , 111 14628 14637
Schlaepfer D. D. Bode H. R. Haigler H. T. 1992aDistinct cellular expression pattern of annexins in Hydra vulgaris. , 118 911 928
Schlaepfer D. D. Fisher D. A. Brandt M. E. Bode H. R. Jones J. M. Haigler H. T. 1992bIdentification of a novel annexin in Hydra vulgaris. Characterization, cDNA cloning, and protein kinase C phosphorylation of annexin XII. , 267 9529 9539
Smith A. M. Duan H. Mohs A. M. Nie S. 2008Bioconjugated quantum dots for in vivo molecular and cellular imaging. , 60 1226 1240
Sperling R. A. Pellegrino T. Li J. K. Chang W. H. Parak W. J. 2006Electrophoretic separation of nanoparticles with a discrete number of functional groups. , 16 943 948
Steele R. E. David C. N. Technau U. 2011A genomic view of 500 million years of cnidarian evolution. , 27 7 13
Tino A. Ambrosone A. Mattera L. Marchesano V. Susha A. Rogach A. Tortiglione C. 2011A new in vivo model system to assess the toxicity of semiconductor nanocrystals. . 2011Article ID 792854, 8 pages, doi:10.1155/2011/792854
Tortiglione C. Quarta A. Malvindi M. A. Tino A. Pellegrino T. 2009Fluorescent nanocrystals reveal regulated portals of entry into and between the cells of Hydra. , 4, e7698.
Tortiglione C. Quarta A. Tino A. Manna L. Cingolani R. Pellegrino T. 2007Synthesis and biological assay of GSH functionalized fluorescent quantum dots for staining Hydra vulgaris. , 18 829 835
Trembley A. 1744.
Wilby O. Tesh J. M. 1990The Hydra assay as an early screen for teratogenic potential. , 4 582 583
Wilby O. K. 1988The Hydra regeneration assay. , 108 124
Williams A. I. I. T. 1981Carbodiimide chemistry: recent advances. , 81 589 636