InTechOpen uses cookies to offer you the best online experience. By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Nanotechnology and Nanomaterials » "Nanomaterials Based Gas Sensors for SF6 Decomposition Components Detection", book authored by Xiaoxing Zhang, Ju Tang, Song Xiao, Fuping Zeng, Cheng Pan, Yingang Gui, ISBN 978-953-51-3258-5, Print ISBN 978-953-51-3257-8, Published: June 7, 2017 under CC BY-NC 4.0 license. © The Author(s).

Chapter 5

Comparative Study of Materials to SF6 Decomposition Components

By Song Xiao, Xiaoxing Zhang, Ju Tang, Fuping Zeng, Cheng Pan and Yingang Gui
DOI: 10.5772/intechopen.68322

Article top

Comparative Study of Materials to SF6 Decomposition Components

Song Xiao1, Xiaoxing Zhang1, Ju Tang1, Fuping Zeng1, Cheng Pan1 and Yingang Gui2
Show details


In order to judge the inside insulation fault of SF6 insulated equipment, the gas-sensing properties to a series of characteristic SF6 decomposition components, SOF2, SO2F2, SO2, H2S, CF4, HF, and SF6, have been studied. In this study, a comparative study of these gas-sensing materials has been made in theoretical and experimental fields to find the optimal gas-sensing material, and put forward the effective approaches to improve the gas-sensing properties of materials.

Keywords: SF6 decomposed gases, carbon nanotubes, TiO2 nanotubes, graphene gas sensor, gas-sensing comparison

1. Theoretical study comparison

To detect, evaluate, and diagnose the insulation status of SF6 gas insulated equipment using the characteristics of SF6 decomposition, a series of characteristic SF6 decomposition components, SOF2, SO2F2, SO2, H2S, CF4, HF, and SF6, are detected by gas sensors, including metal functionalized single wall carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs) [16], TiO2 nanotubes [79], and graphene gas sensors [10, 11], as shown in Table 1. According to the theoretical calculation results, these three kinds of gas-sensing materials are not sensitive to the background gas SF6 and decomposition component CF4. And the concentration of HF in decomposition components is less than the concentration of the other typical gases. Therefore, we compare the adsorption properties four types of SF6 decomposition components: SOF2, SO2F2, SO2, and H2S, under the detection of metal functionalized SWCNTs, TiO2 nanotubes, and graphene gas sensors.

MaterialDopantTypical decomposition components

Table 1.

The typical decomposition components of SF6 detected by gas sensor.

Metal atom modification not only greatly improves the gas-sensing properties to SF6 decomposition components, but also enhances the gas-sensing selectivity of sensors to different gas molecules. Upon SOF2 and SO2F2 detection, intrinsic gas sensors show weak sensitivity to SOF2 because of the weak interaction between gas molecules and the surface of gas-sensing materials. After metal atoms modification, which acts as the active sites, SOF2 molecule tends to approaches the adsorption site by fluorine atom due the its strong chemical activity. Generally, the strong activity breaks the chemical bonds of SOF2. Similarly, SO2F2 interacts with the metal atom-doped gas-sensing material by chemisorption, reflecting in aspect that the fluorine atom breaks from SO2F2 to build new bond with metal atoms. Upon SO2 and H2S detection, these two small gas molecules are generally adsorbed on the surface of gas sensors by physisorption, which was benefit to gas desorption process. SO2 and H2S get approach to the surrounding of metal dopant by oxygen and sulfur atom, respectively, because of its polyvalency property.

Comparing the gas-sensing properties of different sensor materials, the regular porous structure of TiO2 nanotubes contributes to gas desorption and reusability. In addition, its big specific surface area helps the metal dopant modification and gas-sensing sites. But, TiO2 nanotubes sensor usually needs high work temperature, and its high resistance hinders the transmission of detection signals. In comparison, metal atom-doped SWCNT and graphene sensor can work effectively at room temperature, and its low resistance helps to transfer detection signals, resulting in reducing gas-sensing time.

2. Experimental study comparison

Using the own design platform which is used to test the performance of TiO2 nanotubes sensor, the gas response characteristics and temperature characteristics of the intrinsic TiO2 nanotubes sensor to three main SF6 gas decomposition compositions SO2, SOF2, and SO2F2 were studied. The same sensing experiments were also carried out on Pt and Au-doped TiO2nanotubes sensors. The results are compared as shown in Table 2 for TiO2 nanotubes gas sensor and Table 3 for graphene gas sensor.

Doping metalDoping timeGas-sensing parameters to typical decomposition components
/0 s−74.6%−7.82%−5.52%
Pt10 s−53.3%−24.2%−5.4%
20 s−33.9%−22.1%−19.2%
30 s−13.8%−19.1%−50.6%
40 s−6.7%−5.1%−10.7%

Table 2.

The typical decomposition components of SF6 detected by TiO2 nanotubes gas sensor.

It is concluded that the Au-doped TiO2 nanotubes sensor has better selectivity to SO2F2 gas. Pt nanoparticles doping changes gas selectivity of TiO2 nanotubes sensor to SO2, SOF2, and SO2F2. Compared with the intrinsic sensor, Au nanoparticles doped significantly changed the selectively of sensor to SO2, SOF2, and SO2F2 (Table 3).

Doping metalGas-sensing parameters to typical decomposition components

Table 3.

The typical decomposition components of SF6 detected by graphene gas sensor.

Pristine graphene is considered a promising adsorbent for H2S selective detection. Compared with the performance on pristine graphene films, Au-doped graphene emerges significant response to H2S, SOF2, and SO2F2 but weak interaction to SO2, with the sequence of SO2F2 > H2S > SOF2 > SO2. Among them, only H2S shows the opposite response with its resistance increase, while SO2, SOF2, and SO2F2 decrease the resistance of Au-doped graphene.

3. Conclusions

In order to evaluate and diagnose the insulation status of SF6 insulated equipment, gas sensor detection becomes an effective new method to realize the function by detecting the decomposition components of SF6. Theoretical simulations are performed to understand the adsorption process of gas sensors and typical components of SF6. And using carbon nanotubes (CNTs) based as novel kind of sensors show high sensitivity and quick responses to target gases. For TiO2-based gas sensor, the adsorption of typical components of SF6 on different surfaces of TiO2 is reviewed in this section. It is found that the metal decoration improves the sensitivity and selectivity to SO2 and SOF2, and SO2F2 also reduces the working temperature for gas detection. Pristine graphene exhibits weak adsorption and absence of charge transfer, which indicates barely satisfactory sensing for decomposed components. SOF2 and SO2F2 exhibit a strong chemisorption interaction with Au-graphene, while H2S and SO2 exhibit quasi-molecular binding effects. Only H2S exhibits n-type doping to Au-graphene, whereas the rest gases exhibit p-type doping. In general, the sensors array composed of modified gas sensors can be used in the GIS to realize the highly precise detection of related gases, thus accurately deducing the related insulation faults.


1 - Xiaoxing Zhang, Yingang Gui, Ziqiang Dai. A simulation of Pd-doped SWCNTs used to detect SF6 decomposition components under partial discharge. Applied Surface Science. 2014;315(10):196-202
2 - Xiaoxing Zhang, Yingang Gui, Hanyan Xiao, Ying Zhang. Analysis of adsorption properties of typical partial discharge gases on Ni-SWCNTs using density functional theory. Applied Surface Science. 2016;379:47-54
3 - Xiaoxing Zhang, Ziqiang Dai, Qinchuan Chen, Ju Tang. A DFT study of SO2 and H2S gas adsorption on Au-doped single-walled carbon nanotubes. Physica Scripta. 2014;89(6):065803
4 - Zhang X, Dai Z, Wei L, Liang N, Wu X. Theoretical calculation of the gas-sensing properties of Pt-decorated carbon nanotubes. Sensors. 2013;13(11):15159
5 - Xiaoxing Zhang, Yingang Gui, Ziqiang Dai. Adsorption of gases from SF6 decomposition on aluminum-doped SWCNTs: A density functional theory study. The European Physical Journal D. 2015;69(7):1-8
6 - Xiaoxing Zhang, Jinbin Zhang, Ju Tang, Bing Yang. Gas-sensing simulation of single-walled carbon nanotubes applied to detect gas decomposition products of SF6. Journal of Computational & Theoretical Nanoscience. 2012;9(8):1096-1100
7 - Zhang X, Tie J, Zhang J. A Pt-doped TiO2 nanotube arrays sensor for detecting SF6 decomposition products. Sensors. 2013;13(11):14764
8 - Xiaoxing Zhang, Lei Yu, Jing Tie, Xingchen Dong. Gas sensitivity and sensing mechanism studies on Au-doped TiO2 nanotube arrays for detecting SF6 decomposed components. Sensors. 2014;14(10):19517
9 - Xiaoxing Zhang, Jinbin Zhang, Yichao Jia, Peng Xiao, Ju Tang. TiO2 nanotube array sensor for detecting the SF6 decomposition product SO2. Sensors. 2012;12(3):3302
10 - Xiaoxing Zhang, Lei Yu, Yingang Gui, Weihua Hu. First-principles study of SF6 decomposed gas adsorbed on Au-decorated graphene. Applied Surface Science. 2016;367:259-269
11 - Zhang X, Yu L, Wu X, Hu W. Experimental sensing and density functional theory study of H2S and SOF2 adsorption on Au-modified graphene. Advanced Science. 2015;2(11):612-612