The goal of this study was to identify the baseline host and viral factors of response to antiviral therapy in patients with chronic hepatitis C. Compared with interferon/ribavirin therapy, new current direct-acting antiviral (DAA) combination regimens significantly increased rate of sustained virologic response (SVR) and shorter treatment durations, but is still limited by viral resistance, adverse effects, and high cost especially in developing countries. Human genetic factors and heterogeneity within the HCV genome may be associated with virologic treatment failure before and after antiviral therapy. Further, HCV infection may contribute to the development of HCV-related liver disease and hepatocarcinogenesis, through modulating genetic and epigenetic state of certain genes implicated in control of critical cellular pathways. Previous results confirm the importance of host and viral factors and virus-induced genetic and epigenetic changes in predicting outcome and treatment response.
- hepatitis C virus
- response to therapy
- IFN-based antiviral therapies
- direct-acting antiviral (DAA) agents
- genetic variability
- liver fibrosis
- epigenetic changes
Chronic hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection with the estimated worldwide prevalence of 1.1% is a global health problem, affecting 170 million people worldwide [1, 2]. About 15–45% of infected persons spontaneously clear the virus without any treatment, but remaining 60–80% will develop chronic HCV infection leading to fibrosis, cirrhosis and/or hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) [1, 3]. Previous results suggest that, worldwide, there were 1.75 million new HCV infections and annually an estimated 700,000 persons with chronic HCV die untreated . Until 2014, the standard of care to treat HCV infection was pegylated interferon and ribavirin (PEG-IFN and RBV). However, first generation of (DAAs) NSA3/4A protease inhibitors (PI) were boceprevir and telaprevir, administrated with PEG-IFN and RBV . These protease inhibitors were limited by viral resistance, adverse effect and long treatment duration and high cost especially in development countries . The standard care of therapy is changing rapidly and new (DAAs) therapy such as sofosbuvir, daclatasvir, and the sofosbuvir/ledipasvir combination are part of the preferred regimens in the WHO guidelines with achieve cure rates above 95%. In comparison with older therapies, new therapy is more effective, safer, and better-tolerated with shorter treatment (usually 12 weeks), but high prices of the medicines limit the expansion of HCV in many countries . However, challenges remain in optimizing current drug regimens, limiting the problem of resistance mutations and promote individual therapy [5, 6, 7]. Treatment predictors are important factors for management of therapy in patients with chronic hepatitis C infection.
1.1. Host and virus-related factors associated with response to therapy
Previous studies indicated that baseline host and virus related factors such genotype, viral load, age, gender, stage of liver fibrosis, and
1.2. HCV-host interactions and host genetic alterations
In the specific environment of every host, the outcomes of the HCV infection will be different. There are many factors which influence the therapy outcome and progression of liver disease. These factors include baseline clinical and pathohistological parameters. Also, host genetic landscape has effects on therapy outcomes and development of liver disease phenotypes. Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have been created to track genetic polymorphisms in the human genome which associate with, virus clearance, therapy outcomes, and different stages of liver disease. Thus, this kind of the genome screening could be a useful tool in the diagnostics and the therapy of hepatitis C, and could lead to a personalized therapy.
1.2.1. Role of interferons (IFN) in HCV infection
HCV infection induces production of interferons λ (IFN-λ). IFN-λs bind to IFNL receptors (IFNLR) activating JAK-STAT signaling pathway which induces expression of
1.2.2. The influence of host genetic alterations on the progression of liver fibrosis in chronic HCV infection
On the other hand, the host genetic variability has a significant role in the formation of different liver phenotypes. The phenotypes, such as fibrosis, steatosis, cirrhosis, or hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) are the consequence of virus infection and disease progression. The polymorphisms of the immune response genes have effect on disease progression or inhibition. For example, the patients with chronic hepatitis C, which carry rs12979860CC variant, have higher fibrosis progression rate. This effect is even more pronounced in the younger females and in the carriers of the HCV type 3 . The polymorphisms of apoptosis-related genes
1.3. Impact of hepatitis C virus heterogeneity on therapy outcomes
The persistence of hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection and its poor susceptibility to treatment have been attributed, at least in part, to the high rate of genetic variability exhibited by the virus.
The persistence of HCV infection and its poor susceptibility to treatment is the consequence of high rate of virus genetic variability. Variability of virus is due to the low fidelity of viral RNA-dependent RNA-polymerase, which lacks proof-reading capacity, thus allowing the generation of quasispecies. Genetic variability is segregated within particular segments of the HCV genome, resulting in a number of highly variable regions . These quasispecies play an important role in the escape from selective pressures by immune responses and antiviral therapies. A decrease or no change in the number of nucleotides substitutions in the protein kinase (PKR) binding domain (PKRBD) and the interferon-sensitivity-determining region (ISDR) were associated with failed to respond to PEG-IFN/RBV treatment . It was reported that the presence of >4 mutations in the PKRBD region of NS5A protein was correlated with SVR to peg-IFN/RBV therapy . Moreover, PKRBD sequences might be used as a prognostic guide for treating HCV-1-infected patients [54, 55]. Absence of substitutions at positions 70 and 91 in Core protein is a significant predictor for the success of IFN-based therapy . On the other side, amino acid substitutions in the Core protein play an important role in early dynamics of viral replication during IFN-based therapy in chronic HCV infection and more frequent occurrence HCC. With respect to new DAAs therapy, efficacy of NS5A inhibitors can be blocked by presence of NS5A resistance-associated substitutions (RASs), but choice of DAA regimen and duration of therapy depends on multiple viral and host factors.
2. Epigenetic changes in HCV-induced liver diseases
Persistent infection with HCV is associated with the development of chronic liver diseases: fibrosis, cirrhosis and ultimately, HCC [56, 57]. Prevention of chronic hepatitis C and its complications is based on antiviral therapy and early detection of reliable molecular markers in persons under the risk [57, 58]. However, current antiviral therapies are not effective in many patients with chronic hepatitis C, so there is a need for a greater understanding of the factors leading to progression to HCC in order to design novel approaches to prevention of HCV-associated complications . Here, we discuss the current knowledge about the inter-relationship between HCV and pathophysiology of HCV-associated chronic liver diseases, with particular focus on the virus-induced host epigenetic changes leading to hepatocarcinogenesis.
2.1. Hepatocellular carcinoma
According to epidemiological evaluation, HCC is the fifth most common cancer and the second most common cause for cancer death in the world . Although the prognosis of patients with HCC has marginally improved over the last few decades, the five-year survival rate remains poor as a result of late diagnosis. Consequently, the majority of patients with advanced HCC do not survive for longer than 6 months from the time of diagnosis . It has been shown that in chronically infected patients, the risk of developing HCC is strictly correlated to fibrosis stage, and the incidence of HCC is more frequent in patients with liver cirrhosis than in those with mild fibrosis . SVR to IFN-based therapies decreases HCC incidence in a large number of HCV patients, indicating the importance of eradicating the virus to prevent carcinogenesis [63, 64]. However, despite a successful virus clearance, the risk of HCC still exists in individuals with severe fibrosis and continuous HCC monitoring is recommended . So, it is of great importance to determine molecular markers of progressive fibrosis, that could indicate the chronically HCV infected persons under the risk of developing HCC [66, 67]. HCV-induced hepatocarcinogenesis is a multifactorial process which results from a complex interaction among host, environmental, and viral factors . It is considered that at least three host cellular pathways are affected in this process: cell cycle, proliferation, and apoptosis . As HCV is an RNA virus with limited integration of its genetic material into the host’s genome, it was first assumed that its ability to transform hepatocytes is linked to indirect mechanisms. Chronic inflammation induced by viral infection results in a permanent degenerative and regenerative processes and occurrence of progressive fibrosis and cirrhosis [69, 70, 71]. In addition, chronic inflammation leads to increased levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS), which damage hepatocytes and can lead to accumulation of genetic and epigenetic alterations in hepatic cells [67, 72]. All these events can promote neoplastic transformation of hepatocytes and the progression of malignant clones . Later studies have shown that HCV is directly involved in hepatocarcinogenesis, through direct action of viral proteins on host tumor suppressors and proto-oncogenes [74, 75]. Several viral proteins have been shown
2.1.1. Epigenetic changes in HCV-induced HCC
Many lines of evidence suggest that aberrant epigenetic changes associated with viral infection may trigger events that promote the neoplastic transformation of hepatocytes [59, 73]. Epigenetics is defined as heritable state of gene expression without altering DNA sequences. Epigenetic mechanisms include genomic DNA methylation, chemical modifications of histone tails, and non-coding miRNA regulation . Epigenetic changes play a critical role in control of cellular processes through switching genes on and off, thus leading to differential expression of proteins . HCV infection has been shown to induce or correlate with some epigenetic changes that may contribute to HCV-related liver diseases, including hepatocarcinogenesis . It has been proven that certain HCV-encoded proteins induce promoter methylation of multiple genes, thereby affecting their expression [83, 84].
2.1.2. Host genes promoter methylation induced by HCV
DNA methylation represents the addition of methyl group (CH3) to a fifth carbon of cytosine residues within a CG dinucleotide, frequently referred to as cytosine-guanine dinucleotide (CpG). DNA methylation is an essential component of epigenetic machinery that regulates transcriptional state of many genes. Methylated promoters often lack transcriptional activity, which could result in gene inactivation. As a transcriptional regulator, DNA methylation has a considerable impact on the development of many cancers, including HCC [81, 85]. Aberrant promoter hypermethylation of tumor suppressor genes involved in the cell proliferation, apoptosis, cell adhesion, DNA repair, and detoxification is frequently detected in HCC, resulting in loss of the corresponding gene function [86, 87]. It is believed that changes in DNA methylation patterns are early events in hepatocarcinogenesis and they can even occur at the early stages of HCV induced liver fibrosis . This is supported by the results of the study conducted by Zekri et al., in which they demonstrated that methylation of certain host genes increase with liver disease progression, from fibrosis to HCC . Moreover, the same group of authors has been shown that methylation of certain tumor suppressor genes affect the response to the antiviral therapy . Considering this, a better understanding of methylation changes and how they correlate with disease progression will help in finding novel biomarkers for early detection of HCC and its prevention.
2.1.3. HCV-encoded proteins inducing host genes methylation
It has been demonstrated that HCV Core protein up-regulates levels of DNA methyltransferase (DNMT) 1 and 3b and induces promoter hypermethylation of tumor suppressor genes like
2.2. MicroRNA biogenesis and function
MicroRNA (miRNA) are non-coding genetic elements participating in the regulation of gene expression by RNA interference in plants and animals, while in human cells, are associated with viral infection, as well. According to The Encyclopedia of DNA Elements (ENCODE), approximately 75% of the human genome transcribes into a various types of RNA molecules, coding and non-coding [102, 103]. Among non-coding RNA (ncRNA), miRNAs emerged as biologically, physiologically, and clinically significant, considering the fact that they silence translation of partially complementary target messenger (mRNA) molecules. MicroRNAs participate in the regulation of gene expression by RNA interference. In the last 15 years, miRNAs were linked with various types of diseases and disorders, and majority of investigations were based on the changes in their expression levels. MicroRNAs are encoded by a miRNA gene, which transcribes into an immature-primary microRNA (pri-miRNA) molecule, a double stranded, hairpin-like genetic structure. Then, two enzymes-RNase endonuclease III Drosha, and DGCR8 (molecular anchor part of a microprocessor complex), transform pri-miRNA into a 70 nucleotides (nt) long precursor microRNA (pre-miRNA) in the nucleus . The process of miRNA maturation occurs in the cytoplasm, where Dicer or Argonaute (Ago), and other protein-partners, cooperators cleave pri-miRNA into a 22 nt long miRNA, ready to be recognized by RNA-induced silencing complex-RISC [105, 106]. The recognition and binding of miRNA “seed” sequence to 3′ untranslated region (3’UTR) of target mRNA incompletely complementary with “seed” region at miRNA molecule results in either translational repression, or mRNA degradation. Translational repression and degradation result in the decrease of protein levels, thus changing genetic, biological, and physiological processes, activity of various signaling pathways. So, main characteristic of miRNAs is to regulate amounts of synthesized proteins . miRNAs are present in every human cell, and in body fluids (as circulating), such as serum, plasma, urine, saliva, and even gingival liquid. MicroRNA circulates through the body via body fluids as free-circulating miRNAs, and packed into the exosomes and vesicles, as exosomal miRNAs. Extracellular, exosomal circulating miRNAs may carry over the information about disease progression, infection status, and other clinic pathological parameters of HCV infection and HCC formation and progression, but it is still not completely clear. Liver-specific miRNAs such as miR-122 and miR-192, may be released from damaged liver cells, providing the information about liver. Exosomal and circulating miRNAs, as well as miRNAs extracted from tissue may be involved in inter-cellular communication. Besides the fact that nearly 300 miRNAs are expressed in normal, healthy liver, miR-122 represents the major fraction of liver-specific miRNAS, together with miR-192, miR-199a/b-3p, miR-101/99a, and members of oncogenic let-7 family .
2.2.1. MicroRNA in HCV infection and HCC
MicroRNAs are described as onco miRNAs, some of them as tumor suppressive, and several of them even have dual role in cancer pathogenesis and presumably in other physiological processes and pathological condition . During the HCV infection, onco miRNAs such as miR-21/155/221 activate and might cause formation and facilitate progression of HCC. On the other hand, the decrease of some tumor suppressive miRNAs during the HCV infection might also cause hepatocarcinogenesis, such as miR-198 . Firstly, some miRNAs directly interact with the genome of HCV. Secondly, several miRNAs are potential biomarkers of the presence or progression of the HCV infection. Thirdly, several miRNAs are indicators of HCC formation and/or progression. Fourthly, there are miRNAs associated with HCC genotype and clinicopathological characteristics of infected patients and histopathological characteristics of tumors, while some miRNAs such as miR-134/320c/483-5p may be used as early biomarkers for HCV infection in the future. Finally, some miRNAs, such as miR-122 represent potentially great targets for future therapeutics in the aspects of treatment of HCV-associated liver diseases and HCC. Large numbers of different studies have recently been focused on miRNAs in a different points related to different points of HCV infection, i.e., replication of the virus, viral genotype, response to HCV therapy, lipid status, liver function indicators, stage of liver fibrosis, HCC grading, and response to chemotherapy. Changes in the expression levels of miRNA several micro RNAs such as miR-21/122/134/141/155/192/199/221/320c/373/483-5p/491/758, let-7b, etc., are associated with different stages of the viral life cycle and the progression of infection . Circulating miRNAs, miR-122, and miR-222 have been shown to be valuable as potential future diagnostic tool for HCV infection within the Egyptian patients . Upregulated miR-10a/15a/17-5p were associated with HCV-related HCC, miR-122 was characterized as potential diagnostic tool for HCC within HCV-infected individuals, while overexpression of miR-221/222-3p was characteristic exclusively for HCV-related HCC . MicroRNA 122 is a liver-specific miRNA, a regulator of HCV tendency to infect hepatic cells. miR-122 is crucial for efficient HCV infection and viral spread and speed up the replication of the virus in hepatocytes, and facilitates viral protein synthesis . Besides miR-122, as the mostly studied miRNA in HCV-HCC patients that recognizes two different sites at HCV 5’UTR, increased levels of miR-448 and miR-196 attenuate HCV replication by binding to the Core and NS5A sequences of the HCV genome . Secondly, some miRNAs, such as miR-199a have opposing characteristics during the HCV infection. Namely, miR-199 targets sequences of HCV genome and blocks the transcription of HCV RNA . Thirdly, during the HCV infection, miR-155 is usually up-regulated. Higher levels of the well-known onco-miRNA, miR-155 induce proliferation of hepatocytes, increasing the chance of HCC formation . For example, changes in the expression levels of miRNAs such as miR-134/320c/483-5p were shown to be significantly higher within the HCV-infected individuals, compared with healthy controls. In our previous article, we described heterogeneity in behavior of microRNA in cancer studies [109, 117]. Another evidence is supporting our observation on the importance to notice how level changes of the particular miRNA can be important for one event, while having no significance for another similar event, related to the same type of the disease or pathological condition, showing high specificity of some miRNA molecules. Namely, miR-20a/92a levels investigated in the sera of the patients having HCV-related liver disease were associated with the disease severity, and the higher grade of liver fibrosis, while levels of the same miRNAs have not shown any association with grade of liver fibrosis and other pathological characteristics examined within the patients with non-HCV-related liver diseases. Another example of involvement of miRNAs in various segments of HCV-HCC pathology, HCV proteins change levels of miR-193a that results in reduction of sensitivity to chemotherapy of HCC patients . Furthermore, in our article related to the heterogeneity of miRNAs. According to several researches, it has been shown that miR-122 may be anti-tumorigenic properties in mice knockdown studies .
2.2.2. MicroRNA as future therapeutics for HCV and HCC
Considering the fact that several miRNAs can modulate expression of up to a dozens or even hundreds of target genes, it is not surprising that miRNA-based therapy is still challenging. Nevertheless, this multi-targeting ability also represents an advantage for future miRNA-based therapeutics. There are two major approaches for future miRNA-related therapeutics miRNA inhibition (Lock nucleic acid (LNA) anti miRNAs, antago miRNAs, miRNA zippers, small molecules inhibitors of miRNAs, and miRNA sponges) and miRNA substitution strategies (miRNA mimics and miRNA vectors), with the purpose to either silence miRNA activity or to replace absent miRNA molecules [109, 110]. Several studies proposing that miRNA panels could be used in near future as biomarkers for screening of the HCV-related liver diseases. The changes in their expression levels were associated with staging of liver disease progression and anti-HCV therapeutics . Probably, manipulation with several miRNAs at the same time might be crucial in treatment of HCV-HCC. For example, inhibition of upregulated miRNAs involved in viral replication, such as miR-122, simultaneously with miRNAs, in combination with inhibition of miRNA such as miR-155 which promotes cancerogenesis, or mimicking miRNA whose under expression helps HCV replication, and mimicking downregulated miRNA with tumor suppressive function in HCC.
The Family: Flaviviridae, Genus: Hepacivirus, species: Hepacivirus C.
(Guidelines of the International Committee on Virus Taxonomy (ICTV) https://talk.ictvonline.org/)
Chronic HCV infection ultimately leading to HCC will remain a global health problem in the coming decades. Despite increasing knowledge regarding mechanisms of HCV-induced HCC, prevention of HCV-induced HCC is not yet fully established. So, it is important to define both viral- and host genetic and epigenetic patterns on the onset of infection and in early and advanced stages of inflammation and fibrosis in order to predict response to the antiviral therapy, and thus avoid potential complications of persistent HCV infection. Further, for screening a population and making a correct diagnosis about the presence of infection, it is necessary to use standardized commercial tests with universal values and analyze homogenous group of patients. Despite new DAAs therapy, this virus remains unbeatable. When the heterogeneity of the HCV virus, the host genetic and epigenetic variability, and the differences in the therapy outcomes are taken into account, the only right way to fight this disease is personalized therapy.
This study supported by the Ministry of Education, Science and Technological Development of the Republic of Serbia, Grants OI 173049 and TR 3702.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.