Comparison of the functional outcome after different types of reconstruction of the circumferential pharyngeal defect.
After adequate extirpation of tumours in the hypopharynx, the defect created should be reconstructed appropriately to provide optimal function. Local cervical skin flaps were first described and employed 60 years ago for the reconstruction of defects after pharyngo-laryngectomy 1. However, the procedures involved had to be carried out in stages, which typically required 4 – 6 months for completion. In addition, the subsequent ability to swallow was frequently limited by the stenosis at the anastomotic junction. Nowadays, with more advanced techniques, reconstruction of the circumferential hypopharyngeal defect is nearly always performed at the time of resection as a single stage procedure 2. The most commonly employed reconstructive options include the use of myocutaneous flaps (pedicled pectoralis major flap or free anterolateral thigh flap) with the skin island sutured and fashioned as a tubular conduit, or the free visceral flap (free jejunal flap).
Radiation therapy has become an integral part of treatment for malignancies in the head and neck region. Apart from being the primary treatment for radiation sensitive cancers, or as part of the organ-preserving therapy for early cancer of the larynx and hypopharynx, it is more commonly used as adjuvant treatment after surgery for advanced stage cancers. Studies showed that the 5-year survival rate as well as the loco-regional tumour control was significantly improved after combined surgical resection and post-operative radiation therapy, compared with single modality treatment.
Ionizing radiation, however, is not without side effects. In this chapter, we will focus on the effect of radiation on the functional and oncological outcome on pharyngeal reconstruction after pharyngo-laryngectomy for carcinoma of the hypopharynx.
2. Problem statement
To investigate the effect of radiotherapy on the functional outcome of pharyngeal reconstruction
To investigate the effect of radiotherapy on the oncological outcome of pharyngeal reconstruction
To formulate the choice of reconstructive options for pharyngeal defects
2.1. Application area
Reconstruction of the defect created after circumferential pharyngectomy for malignancies in the region of the hypopharynx and cervical esophagus
We identified all consecutive patients undergoing reconstruction for circumferential pharyngeal defects after resection of tumours of the hypopharynx and the cervical esophagus over a 30-years interval from 1980 to 2009. All the operations were performed in a single, tertiary referral, university based hospital. The patients’ data were prospectively collected in the head and neck cancer database of the Division of Head and Neck surgery, including patients’ demographic data, types of cancer treated, the operations performed, outcomes of surgery, dose of radiation given and the subsequent follow up information.
During the study period, we had performed circumferential pharyngectomy for 202 patients suffering from tumours involving the pharyngeal region. Those with tumours requiring pharyngo-laryngo-esophagectomy and subsequent gastric pull-up were excluded from the study. All patients had pre-operative work-up for tumour staging, anaesthetic assessment and nutritional build-up if necessary. All of the patients received total laryngectomy and circumferential pharyngectomy. Cervical lymph node dissection was performed if there was evidence of lymphatic metastasis. Intra-operative frozen section examination of the resection margins was performed to ensure microscopic clearance of disease.
The resultant pharyngeal defect in the form of a conduit between the oropharynx above and the esophagus below was reconstructed with either the pectoralis major (PM) flap, free anterolateral thigh (ALT) flap or free jejunal flap as described below.
3. Myocutaneous flap
3.1. Pectoralis major myocutaneous flap
Following Ariyan’s 3 publication in 1979, Withers at al 4 described the technique of folding the skin island of a PM flap into a tube for the reconstruction of circumferential pharyngectomy defects. In essence, a rectangular or trapezoid skin island was designed over the pectoralis major muscle, which was transferred together with its supplying blood vessels, namely the thoracoacromial and lateral thoracic artery, to the neck for reconstruction of the neopharynx (Figure 1). The length of the pharyngeal defect should be accurately measured and the length of the skin island marked out accordingly. In addition to the expected 10% shrinkage in size after harvesting, the length of the skin island should be at least 2cm longer than the defect if the interdigitating suturing method is employed at the lower (esophageal) anastomosis. The width of the skin island should be at least 6cm in order to provide a reconstructed skin tube with a 2cm diameter. In order to include as many perforators as possible, the skin island should be placed entirely on the pectoralis major muscle, and the shape of the skin island should be in the form of a trapezium, with the shorter edge on its upper part. This upper edge of the skin island, when transposed to the neck, will be anastomosed to the cervical esophagus which is always smaller in caliber than that of the oropharynx.
After passing through the subcutaneous tunnel, the skin island of the pectoralis major flap is fashioned into a tube. It is then sutured to the oropharynx above and the cervical esophagus below. In order to prevent stricture formation of the circular mucocutaneous anastomosis with the esophagus, the anastomosis is carried out in an interdigitating fashion 5. Three incisions are made at the stump of the cervical esophagus. Similar incisions are made over the skin island so that at anastomosis, skin island flaps can be sutured in an interdigitating fashion with the corresponding flaps from the cervical esophagus. The resultant anastomosis is in a wave-like form rather than circular. Upon healing, the scar stretches the anastomosis wider rather than causing it to stenose.
3.2. Free anterolateral thigh flaps
Free anterolateral thigh fasciocutaneous flap was popularized by Song et al in 1984 6 and later modified by Koshima
4. Free visceral flap
4.1. Free jejunal flap
The free jejunal flap was first described by Seidenberg 9 in 1958. It represents one of the most popular methods for the reconstruction of circumferential pharyngeal defects nowadays (Figure 2). Through an upper midline laparotomy, the required length of the jejunum is harvested. Usually, the segment of the jejunum supplied by the second vascular arcade from the ligament of Treiz is used, as the vessels are relatively straight with a size comparable with that of the recipient vessels in the neck. The size of the jejunal lumen is comparable with that of the cervical esophagus, and an end-to-end anastomosis can usually be accomplished easily. The discrepancy in size usually occurs at the anastomosis between the oropharynx and the jejunum. It can be handled by slitting the jejunal wall at the anti-mesenteric border so that a longer circumference is made available for anastomosis.
In order to minimize the ischaemic time of the jejunal flap, the recipient vessels in the neck should be prepared and ready for microvascular anastomosis before the flap is detached from its blood supply in the abdomen. The jejuno-esophageal anastomosis is performed for fixation of the bowel, followed by vascular anastomosis. Once the perfusion of the bowel is restored, upper anastomosis between the oropharynx and the jejunal flap can be performed leisurely without time constraint.
Post-operative gastrograffin swallow study was performed 10 days after surgery to complete wound healing before oral feeding was resumed. For those patients who developed pharyngo-cutaneous fistula with significant leakage, a control pharyngostome was performed to allow the patient to recover from the inflammation before second stage repair was contemplated. Those minor leakages with no clinical evidence of inflammation were treated conservatively and monitored closely. Contrast swallow study was performed subsequently to confirm complete wound healing before allowing oral feeding. Those patients with significant delay of post-operative adjuvant chemoradiotherapy secondary to anastomotic leakage or necrotic flap requiring multiple surgeries were excluded. All patients were referred to clinical oncologists for post-operative adjuvant chemoradiotherapy.
External beam radiotherapy, when indicated, was commenced as soon as possible after all the surgical wounds were healed. Radiation was delivered by Cobalt 60, 4MV, or 6MV linear accelerator, which was given once per day with daily fraction size of 2Gy, 5 days per week. The spinal cord was shielded after 4500 cGy and the flap for the pharyngeal reconstruction was included in the high dose field of radiation.
All the patients were followed up regularly with clinical and endoscopic examination to detect tumour recurrence and complications such as anastomotic stricture and donor site morbidities. A stage-to-stage comparison of the loco-regional tumour control was performed between different methods of reconstruction.
5.1. Functional results after reconstruction of circumferential pharyngeal defects
Pharyngo-cutaneous fistula leading to anastomotic leakage is a serious complication during the early post-operative period. If not detected and treated early, it will result in severe infection and carotid artery blowout. While surgical technique is important to prevent such complication, the choice of reconstructive options may also affect the incidence of early anastomotic leakage. According to our experience over the past two decades 10, the incidence of early post-operative pharyngo-cutaneous fistula was 23.9% when pectoralis major flap is used, 12.5% when the free anterolateral thigh flap is used, and 4.6% when the jejunal flap is used. Similar results are demonstrated in other series 11-12. Majority (65.5%) of the patients with salivary leakage required exteriorization by creating a control pharyngostome pharyngostomy, followed by a second stage reconstruction after the inflammation subsided. The rest of the patients (34.5%) were managed successfully by conservative approach. There was no significant relationship between pre- or post-operative radiotherapy (p=0.848) and early post-operative fistula formation. However, among the patients who leaked, those with a history of irradiation were significantly more likely to required exteriorization to control the infection (88.2% required exteriorization vs. 11.8% managed conservatively).
One of the most important functional problems after circumferential pharyngectomy is swallowing. In addition to the restoration of the resected pharyngeal conduit for the passage of food, proper swallowing in these patients requires patent anastomosis without stenosis. Late anastomotic stricture rate was 27.2% in the pectoralis major flap group, 12.5% in the anterolateral thigh flap group, and 2.3% in the jejunal flap group. The mean time to develop dysphagia secondary to the stricture was 18.4 months. The only factor that was found to have significant association with stricture formation was the history of pharyngo-cutaneous fistula during early post-operative period (p=0.023). The history of radiotherapy has not significantly increased the risk of anastomotic stricture.
In the group of patients who had no demonstrable anastomotic stricture, only some of them were able to resume the usual diet before operation, the proportion of which being 35.8% in the pectoralis major flap group, 38.2% in the anterolateral thigh group and 61.9% in the jejunal flap group. The rest of the patients tolerated fluid or soft diet only. The presence of mucus secretion as well as peristalsis in the jejunal flap may aid the passage of food bolus. Table 1 summarizes the functional outcome after different types of reconstruction techniques.
Majority of the patients require a combined surgical resection followed by post-operative adjuvant radiotherapy for treatment of carcinoma hypopharynx. While free jejunal transfer appears to result in the lowest rate of early anastomotic leakage as well as late anastomotic stricture, the radiation tolerance of the visceral flap is always a concern. The jejunum is a radiosensitive organ in its native site in the abdomen. Radiation injury to the gastrointestinal tract is well recognized in patients with pelvic or colorectal malignancies who received external beam irradiation up to 60Gy 13. Acute functional changes include diarrhea, bloating and abdominal pain, and reported late sequelae include chronic diarrhea, malabsorption with steatorrhoea, abdominal spasms, intestinal obstruction, bleeding and fistula formation 14. It is observed that, apart from the total dose of radiation delivered, the volume of the small intestine exposed to the radiation is also important in determining the severity of the presenting symptoms of the patients 15. When biopsies are taken from the mucosa of the jejunal flap before and after radiotherapy and compared under microscopy and scanning electron microscopy 16, it was found that there is generalized edema and loss of villi during early post-radiation period (Figure 3). The thinning of jejunal mucosa, the focal loss of glands and the blunting of the villi are found at 6 months after completion of irradiation and persisted throughout the following 2 years. However, none of the jejunal biopsies displayed any area of necrosis or ulceration secondary to radiation.
5.2. Oncological results after reconstruction of circumferential pharyngeal defects
Despite the increasing popularity of organ-preserving chemoradiation for early stage cancer of the hypopharynx, surgery remains the preferred therapeutic option for locally advanced disease, when post-operative radiotherapy is generally indicated. Evidence shows that adjuvant radiotherapy significantly improved locoregional control as well as survival after surgery for carcinoma at the hypopharyngeal region 17. However, because of the potential risk of radiation damage to the jejunal flap which has been transferred to the neck as a free flap after tumour extirpation, it has been a common practice among the clinical oncologists to reduce the radiation dosage for patients who had received free jejunal flap reconstruction. Our experience showed that the mean radiation dosage given to patients after visceral flap transfer was much lower than those after cutaneous flap reconstruction (54.8Gy vs. 62.2Gy) 18. At this level of radiation, there was no evidence of secondary ischaemia or necrosis of the flap upon completion of the adjuvant treatment. Despite the reduction of radiation dosage in the jejunal group, the difference in the 5-year actuarial loco-regional tumour control between the 2 groups of patients was not significant for TNM stage II (61% vs. 69%, p = 0.9) and III (36% vs. 46%, p = 0.2) disease. However, for stage IV disease, patients with jejunal flap reconstruction had significantly poorer loco-regional tumour control (32% vs. 14%, p = 0.04) (Table 2). This may be explained by the failure of the reduced dose of radiation to deal with the more widespread microscopic tumour deposits in the advanced stage of disease. Despite the apparently better functional outcome using the jejunal flap to reconstruct circumferential pharyngeal defects, the choice of reconstructive options should never compromise the oncological control. The surgeons should communicate with the oncologists, and if a reduced dose of radiation is to be given, then jejunal transfer should not be the first choice of reconstruction in advanced staged carcinoma of the hypopharyngeal region.
Reconstruction of circumferential pharyngeal defects after tumour extirpation remains a therapeutic challenge. In order to achieve the best functional and oncological outcome, the choice of the reconstructive options should be individualized according to the patients’ characteristics.