List of chemical solution deposited oxide buffer layers with
1. Introduction
The main objective of this work is to conduct fundamental research in the broad areas of chemical solution based buffer and high temperature superconductor, namely Yttrium Barium Copper Oxide (YBCO) development. The results of this research provide new insights in buffer/superconductor areas and suggest methods to improve buffer/superconductor multi-layer thin film fabrication. The overall purpose is to develop a potentially lower-cost, high throughput, high yield, manufacturing processes for buffer/superconductor thin multi-layer film fabrication, and to gain fundamental understanding of the growth of solution buffer/superconductor layers for Rolling Assisted Biaxially Textured Substrate (RABiTS) templates. This understanding is critical to the development of a reliable, robust, long-length manufacturing process of second-generation (2G) wires for electric-power applications. In order to reduce the cost of superconductor wires, it is necessary to replace the existing physical vapor deposited three buffer layer RABiTS architecture of Yttrium Oxide, Y2O3 seed/Yttria Stabilized Zirconia, YSZ barrier/Cerium Oxide, CeO2 cap with buffers deposited by industrially scalable methods, such as slot-die coating of chemical solution deposition (CSD) precursors [1- 11]. Spin-coating is typically used to deposit short samples for optimizing the CSD film growth conditions. In a typical chemical solution process, metal organic precursors in suitable solvents are spin/dip/slot-die coated on either single crystal or biaxially textured substrates followed by heat-treating in a tube furnace under controlled conditions. Chemical Solution Deposition (CSD) process offers significant cost advantages compared to physical vapor deposition (PVD) processes [5- 11]. Solution coating is amenable to complex oxides, and the materials utilization (yield) is almost 100%. The high-temperature superconductors (HTS) such as (Bi,Pb)2Sr2Ca2Cu3O10 (BSCCO or 2223 with a critical temperature,
2. Chemical solution deposition of oxide buffers
The schematic of the standard RABiTS architecture developed by Oak Ridge National Laboratory and American Superconductor Corporation [3,4] is shown in Figure 1. The main goal is to replace the most commonlyused RABiTS architectures with a startingtemplate of biaxially textured Ni-5 at.% W substrate with a physical vapor deposited (PVD) seed layer
of Y2O3, a barrier layer of YSZ, and a CeO2 caplayer by a chemical solution deposition method. To develop an all solution buffer/YBCO, it is necessary to either replace all three layers or reduce the number of buffer layers to one. The role of the Y2O3 seed layer is to improve the out-of-plane texture of buffer layer compared to the underlying Ni-5W substrate and Y2O3 is also an excellent W diffusion and good oxygen barrier [4]. The role of YSZ barrier layer is to contain the diffusion of Ni from the substrate into superconductor. In order to grow YBCO superconductor films with critical current densities, it is necessary to contain the poisoning of Ni into YBCO. Finally, the CeO2 cap layer is compatible with CSD based REBCO films and has enabled high critical current density REBCO films. The optimized film thickness for each buffer layer is 75 nm and the typical YBCO layer thickness is ~ 1 µm carrying a critical current of 250-300 A/cm-width at 77 K and self-field. Researchers all over the world have developed several chemical solution deposited oxide buffer layers that are suitable for YBCO film growth. A partial list of several epitaxial oxide buffers grown using a CSD method have been reported in Table 1 [4]. It is possible for us to select a buffer layer to lattice match with either the substrate Ni/Ni-W or with YBCO. The list of chemical solution deposited buffer layers with YBCO superconductor films deposited on such buffers is reported in Table 2.
CSD Buffer Layers | Stacking for YBCO | Jc (MA/cm2) | Reference |
CeO2 | YBCO (CSD)/CeO2 (Sputtered)/YSZ (Sputtered)/CeO2 (CSD)/Ni-W | 3.3 | 39 |
YSZ | YBCO (CSD)/CeO2 (CSD)/YSZ (CSD)/CeO2 (CSD)/Ni | 0.5 | 35 |
Y2O3 | YBCO (PLD)/CeO2 (Sputtered)/YSZ (Sputtered)/Y2O3 (CSD)/Ni-W | 1.2 | 31 |
Eu2O3 | YBCO (ex-situ BaF2)/CeO2 (Sputtered)/ YSZ (Sputtered)/Eu2O3 (CSD)/Ni | 1.1 | 20 |
Gd2O3 | YBCO(PLD)/CeO2 (Sputtered)/YSZ (Sputtered)/Gd2O3 (CSD)/Ni-W-Fe | 1 | 36 |
Ce-Gd-O | YBCO (CSD)/CeO2 (CSD)/CGO (CSD)/Gd2O3 (CSD)/Ni | 0.1 | 37 |
SrTiO3 | YBCO (CSD)/STO (CSD)/Ni | 1.3 | 38 |
La2Zr2O7 | YBCO (e-beam)/CeO2 (Sputtered)/YSZ (Sputtered)/LZO (CSD)/Ni | 0.48 | 26 |
La1/4Zr3/4Oy | YBCO (PLD)/La1/4Zr3/4Oy (CSD)/Ni-W | 0.55 | 42 |
Gd2Zr2O7 | YBCO (MOCVD)/GZO (CSD)/Ni | 1.3 | 33 |
Gd3NbO7 | YBCO (PLD)/GNO (CSD)/Ni-W | 1.1 | 30 |
3. Chemical solution deposition of REBCO
Currently, chemical solution based synthesis of YBCO uses a trifluoroacetate (TFA) based precursor approach [5]. In this approach, the precursor solution is prepared by dissolving Yttrium, Barium and Copper trifluoroacetates in methanol. Then the precursor solution is spin/slot-die coated on RABiTS templates followed a two-stage heat-treatment to convert the precursor films to high quality YBCO. In the first stage (pyrolysis), there is a significant bottle neck to processing rates for these films because the shrinkage stresses developed in the films during pyrolysis need to be accommodated using very slow heating rates. The reactions taking place during the synthesis are illustrated below:
Significant efforts were made to increase the growth rate by replacing part of the metal TFA precursors with non-fluorine based precursors and also adjust the water and oxygen pressure during the growth of YBCO films. Another advantage of the TFA process is to introduce mixed rare earths and Zirconium oxides into the starting precursors to enhance the flux-pinning properties of REBCO films [5,40,41]. Chemical solution deposition methodmay prove to be a promising route for producing a low-cost all-CSD buffer/YBCO based coated conductors. The main challenge is to fabricate high-temperature superconductor tapes in kilometer lengths in carrying 1000 A/cm-width. Industries from US and Japan are leading in this area while industries from Europe, Korea, and China are only few years away.
4. Summary
In summary, RABiTS template with several possible architectures based on chemical solution deposition methods have been developed and superconductivity industries around the world are in the process of taking the technology to the pilot scale to produce commercially acceptable 500 meter lengths. The research in the area of second generation high temperature superconductor wire technology to increase the flux pinning properties of YBCO superconductor and to reduce the ac loss in these wires for various electric-power applications such as transmission cables, fault-current limiters and high-field magnets is continuing ahead.
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Electricity Delivery and Energy Reliability (OE) – Advanced Conductors and Cables Program.
References
- 1.
M. Parans Paranthaman and T. Izumi, Editors, “High-Performance YBCO-Coated Superconductor Wires ,”29 2004 2004 533 536 . - 2.
Parans M. Paranthaman “. Superconductor Wires,”. in-Hill Mc Graw. 2006 Yearbook of Science and Technology, McGraw-Hill Publishers, New York (2006)319 322 . - 3.
Phys. Lett. 69Goyal A. Norton D. P. Budai J. D. Paranthaman M. Specht E. D. Kroeger D. M. Christen D. K. He Q. Saffian B. List F. A. Lee D. F. Martin P. M. Klabunde C. E. Hatfield E. Sikka V. K. Fabrication “. of Long. Range Biaxially. Textured High. Temperature Superconducting. Tape on. Rolled Ni. Substrates,” Appl. 1996 1795. - 4.
Goyal A. Paranthaman M. Schoop U. The “. Bi R. A. Approach T. S. Using-Assisted Rolling. Biaxially Textured. Substrates for. High-Performance Y. B. C. O. Superconductors,” M. R. S. Bulletin . 2004 552 EOF 561 EOF . - 5.
Rupich M. W. Verebelyi D. T. Zhang W. Kodenkandath T. Li X. Metalorganic Deposition. of Y. B. C. O. Films for. Second-Generation-Temperature High. Superconductor Wires,”. M. R. S. Bulletin . 2004 572 EOF 578 EOF . - 6.
Non-Cryst. Solids 147Brinker C. J. Hurd A. J. Schunk P. R. Frye G. C. Ashley C. S. Review “. of Sol-gel. Thin Film. Formation,” J. Non 1992 424 EOF 436 EOF . - 7.
F.F. Lange, “Chemical Solution Routes to Single-crystal Thin Films,” Science 273 1996 903 EOF . - 8.
R.W. Schwartz, “Chemical Solution Deposition of Perovskite Thin Films,” Chem. Mater.91997 (1997)2325 EOF 2340 EOF . - 9.
Mater. Res. 21Sathyamurthy S. Paranthaman M. Lee Heatherly. Patrick M. Martin E. D. Specht Amit. Goyal Thomas. Kodenkandath Xiaoping. Li Martin. W. Rupich “. Solution-processed lanthanum. zirconium oxide. as barrier a. layer for. high Ic. coated conductors,”. J. 2006 910 EOF 914 EOF . - 10.
On Appl. Supercond. 17Paranthaman M. P. Sathyamurthy S. Bhuiyan M. S. Martin P. M. Aytug T. Kim K. Fayek M. Leonard K. J. Li J. Goyal A. Kodenkandath T. Li X. Zhang W. Rupich M. W. buffer “. M. O. D. approach Y. B. C. O. to fabricate. low-cost second. generation H. T. S. wires,” I. E. E. E. Trans 2007 3332 EOF 3335 EOF . - 11.
Coll M. Gazquez J. Huhne R. Holzapfel B. Morilla Y. Garcia-Lopez J. Pomar A. Sandiumenge F. Puig T. Obradors X. All “. chemical Y. Ba Cu O. superconducting multilayers. Critical role. 2 CeO2 cap layer flatness,” J. Mater. Res. 24 (2009)1446 EOF . - 12.
Glavee G. N. Hunt R. D. Paranthaman M. Low “. Temperature Preparation. Ce of 3 and Ce0.75Zr0.25O2 Thin Films Using Sol-gel Processing Techniques,”34 1999 817 825 . - 13.
Paranthaman M. Shoup S. S. Beach D. B. Williams R. K. Specht E. D. Epitaxial “. Growth of. Ba Zr 3 Films on Single Crystal Oxide Substrates Using Sol-gel Alkoxide Precursors,”32 1997 1697 1704 . - 14.
Ali N. J. Clem P. Milne S.J. Synthesis “. of sols. for the. production of. La -modified Pb. Ti 3 thin films,” J. Mater. Sci. Lett.14 1995 837 840 . - 15.
Paranthaman M. P. Bhuiyan M. S. Sathyamurthy S. Heatherly L. Cantoni C. Goyal A. Improved “. textured La Zr. 227 buffer on La3TaO7 seed for all-MOD Buffer/YBCO coated conductors,” C 468 (2008)1587 EOF . - 16.
Electronic Mater. 36Bhuiyan M. S. Paranthaman M. Sathyamurthy S. Chemical “. solution-based epitaxial. oxide films. on biaxially. textured-W Ni. substrates with. improved out-of-plane. texture for. Y. B. C. O. coated conductors,”. J. 2007 1270 EOF 1274 EOF . - 17.
Mater. Res.Bhuiyan M. S. Paranthaman M. Goyal A. Heatherly L. Beach D. B. Deposition “. of rare. earth tantalite. buffers on. textured-W Ni. substrates for. Y. B. C. O. coated conductor. using chemical. solution deposition. approach,” J. 21 2006 2006 767 773 . - 18.
Mater. Res.Dawley J. T. Ong R. J. Clem P. G. Improving “. sol-gel Y. Ba Cu O7. film morphology. using high-boiling-point. solvents,” J. 17 2002 2002 1678 1685 . - 19.
Sathyamurthy S. Salama K. Application “. of metal-organic. decomposition techniques. for the. deposition of. buffer 123 K. Salama, “Application of metal-organic decomposition techniques for the deposition of buffer layers and Y123 for coated-conductor fabrication ,” C329 2000 58 68 . - 20.
Amer. Ceram. Soc.Paranthaman M. Chirayil T. G. List F. A. Cui X. Goyal A. Lee D. F. Specht E. D. Martin P. M. Williams R. K. Kroeger D. M. Morrell J. S. Beach D. B. Feenstra R. Christen D. K. Fabrication “. of Long. Lengths of. Epitaxial Buffer. Layers on. Biaxially-Ni Textured. Substrates using. a. Continuous Reel-to-reel. Dip-coating Unit,”. J. 84 2001 2001 273 278 . - 21.
cicek, “Engineered oxide thin films as 100% lattice match buffer layers for YBCO coated conductors,” Solid-State Electronics100 47 2003 2171 2175 . - 22.
Yang C. Y. Ichinose A. Babcock S. E. Morrell J. S. Mathis J. E. Verebelyi D. T. Paranthaman M. Beach D. B. Christen D. K. Microstructure “. of a. High Jc. Laser-ablated Y. Ba Cu O7-. Sol-gel Deposited. Nd Ga. 3 Buffer Layer/(001) SrTiO3 Multi-layer Structure,”Physica C331 2000 73 78 . - 23.
Bhuiyan M. S. Paranthaman M. Sathyamurthy S. Aytug T. Kang S. Lee D. F. Goyal A. Payzant E. A. Salama K. approach “. M. O. D. for the. growth of. Ce epitaxial 2 buffer layers on biaxially textured Ni-W substrates for YBCO coated conductors,” Superconductor Science & Technology16 2003 1305 1309 . - 24.
Mater. Res.Morrell J. S. Xue Z. B. Specht E. D. Goyal A. Martin P. M. Lee D. F. Feenstra R. Verebelyi D. T. Christen D. K. Chirayil T. G. Paranthaman M. Vallet C. E. Beach D. B. Epitaxial “. Growth of. Gadolinium Oxide. on-Textured Roll. Nickel Using. a. Solution Growth. Technique,” J. 15 2000 2000 621 628 . - 25.
Chirayil T. G. Paranthaman M. Beach D. B. Lee D. F. Goyal A. Williams R. K. Cui X. Kroeger D. M. Feenstra R. Verebelyi D. T. Christen D. K. Epitaxial “. growth of. La Zr 227 thin films on rolled Ni-substrates by sol-gel process for high Tcsuperconducting tapes,”Physica C336 2000 63 69 . - 26.
Mater. Res.Sathyamurthy S. Paranthaman M. Zhai H. Y. Christen H. M. Martin P. M. Goyal A. Lanthanum “. zirconate A. single buffer. layer processed. by solution. deposition for. coated conductor. fabrication,” J. 17 2002 2002 2181 2184 . - 27.
Parans M. Paranthaman T. Aytug S. Sathyamurthy D. B. Beach A. Golyal D. F. Lee B. W. Kang L. Heatherly E. D. Specht K. J. Leonard et. al Bulk “. Solution Techniques. to Fabricate. High Jc. Y. B. C. O. Coated Conductors,”. Physica C. 378381 (2002) 1009-1012. - 28.
Amer. Ceram. Soc.Shoup S. S. Paranthaman M. Goyal A. Specht E. D. Lee D. F. Kroeger D. M. Beach D. B. Epitaxial “. Thin Film. Growth of. Lanthanum Neodymium Aluminate. Films on. Roll-Textured Nickel. Using a. Sol-Gel Method,”. J. 81 1998 1998 3019 3021 . - 29.
on of Oxide Buffer Layers for YBCO Coated Conductors,”IEEE Trans. on Appl. Supercond.Rupich M. W. Palm W. Zhang W. Siegal E. Annavarapu S. Fritzemeier L. Teplitsky M. D. Thieme C. Paranthaman M. Growth “. Characterization of. Oxide Buffer. Layers for. Y. B. C. O. Coated Conductors,”. I. E. E. E. Trans 9 91999 1999 1527 1530 . - 30.
Paranthaman M. Bhuiyan M. S. Sathyamurthy S. Zhai H. Y. Goyal A. Salama K. Epitaxial “. Growth of. Solution Based. Rare Earth. Niobate R. E. Nb 37 Films on Biaxially Textured Ni-W Substrates,”J. Mater. Res.20 2005 6 9 . - 31.
Bhuiyan M. S. Paranthaman M. Kang S. Lee D. F. Salama K. Growth “. of epitaxial. Y. 23 buffer layers on biaxially textured Ni-W substrates for YBCO coated conductors by MOD approach,” Physica C422 2005 95 101 . - 32.
Aytug T. Paranthaman M. Leonard K. J. Zhai H. Y. Bhuiyan M. S. Payzant E. A. Goyal A. Sathyamurthy S. Beach D. B. Martin P. M. Christen D. K. Li X. Kodenkandath T. Schoop U. Rupich M. W. Smith H. E. Haugan T. Barnes P. N. Assessment “. of chemical. solution synthesis. properties of. Gd Zr. 227 thin films as buffer layers for second-generation high-temperature superconductor wires”J. Mater. Res.20 2005 2988 2996 . - 33.
On Appl. Supercond.Zhou Y. X. Zhang X. Fang H. Putman R. T. Salama K. Development “. of Single. Solution Buffer. Layers on. Textured Ni. Substrate for. H. T. S. Coated Conductors,”. I. E. E. E. Trans 15 2005 2005 2711 2714 . - 34.
Chirayil T. G. Paranthaman M. Beach D. B. Morrell J. S. Sun E. Y. Goyal A. Williams R. K. Lee D. F. Martin P. M. Kroeger D. M. Feenstra R. Verebelyi D. T. Christen D. K. Epitaxial “. Growth 23 Yb2O3 Buffer Layers on Biaxially Textured-Ni (100) substrates by Sol-gel Process,” Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. (1999) 51-56. - 35.
Appl. Supercond.13Akin Y. Aslanoglu Z. Celik E. Arda L. Sigmund W. Hascicek Y. S. Textured “. Growth of. Multi-Layered Buffer. Layers on. Ni tape. by-Gel Sol. Process,” I. E. E. E. Trans 2003 2673. - 36.
Aytug T. Paranthaman M. P. Kang B. W. Beach D. B. Sathyamurthy S. Specht E. D. Lee D. F. Feenstra R. Goyal A. Kroeger D. M. Leonard K. J. Martin P. M. Christen D. K. Reel-to-reel “. continuous chemical. solution deposition. of epitaxial. Gd 23 buffer layers on biaxially textured metal tapes for the fabrication of YBa2Cu3O7- coated conductors,”Journal of The American Ceramic Society86 2003 257 265 . - 37.
Takahashi Y. Aoki Y. Hasegawa T. Watanabe T. Maeda T. Honjo T. Shiohara Y. In-plane “. textured buffer. layer for. the-M T. F. A. method O. D. on <100>{001}. Ni tapes. using M. O. D. process,” Physica. C. 392396 (2003) 887. - 38.
Phys. Lett. 80Siegal M. P. Clem P. G. Dawley J. T. Ong R. J. Rodriguez M. A. Overmyer D. L. All “. solution-chemistry approach. for Y. Ba Cu O7. coated conductors,”. Appl 2002 2710. - 39.
On Appl. Supercond.Paranthaman M. P. Qiu X. Kim K. Zhang Y. Li X. Sathyamurthy S. Thieme C. Rupich M. W. Development “. of Solution. Buffer Layers. for R. A. Bi T. S. Based Y. B. C. O. Coated Conductors,”. I. E. E. E. Trans 2011 in press. - 40.
Shiohara Y. Yoshizumi M. Izumi T. Yamada Y. Present “. status future prospect. of coated. conductor development. its application. in Japan,”. Superconductor Science. Technology . 2008 034002. - 41.
Gutiérrez J. Llordés A. Gazquez J. Gibert M. Romá N. Ricart S. Pomar A. Sandiumenge F. Mestres N. Puig T. Obradors X. Strong “. isotropic flux. pinning in. solution-derived Y. Ba Cu O7−x. nanocomposite superconductor. films,” Nature. Materials 2007 367‐373. - 42.
Paranthaman M. P. Sathyamurthy S. Li X. P. Specht E. D. Wee S. H. Cantoni C. Goyal A. Rupich M. W. Modified “. Lanthanum Zirconium. Oxide buffer. layers for. low-cost high. performance Y. B. C. O. coated conductors,”. Physica 470 . Cantoni, A. Goyal, and M. W. Rupich, “Modified Lanthanum Zirconium Oxide buffer layers for low-cost, high performance YBCO coated conductors,” Physica C 470 (2010) 352.