Plaque characterization by quantitative PS-OCT and histology.
Atherosclerotic vascular disease is a common cause of morbidity and mortality in developed countries (Arroyo & Lee, 1999). In particular, the rupture of atherosclerotic plaques is the most common event initiating acute ischemic heart disease (Shah, 2003). Therefore, it is crucial to detect vulnerable coronary atheromatous plaques prior to their rupture or erosion to prevent irreversible myocardial damage. Autopsy studies have identified several histological characteristics of these vulnerable plaques, such as a large lipid pool, thin fibrous cap (<65 μm), and activated macrophages near the fibrous cap (Falk et al., 1995). Therefore, modalities capable of visualizing the vessel wall might help in detecting lesions with high risks for acute events (Pasterkamp et al., 2000, Peters et al., 1994). There are several plaque imaging modalities. The oldest and most widely used technology is X-ray angiography, which can detect narrowing of the coronary blood vessels. The first imaging technique to demonstrate the benefits of imaging inside the arterial wall is intravascular ultrasound (IVUS). However, the current resolution is not sufficient to visualize the thin fibrous caps and small disruptions within the intimal and medial dissections. In the 1980s, coronary angioscopy, which allows direct visualization of the surface color and superficial morphology of atherosclerotic plaque, thrombus, neointima, and stent struts, was introduced. However, it cannot help in the assessment of subsurface lesions. Other proposed techniques include electron beam computed tomography (EBCT), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), or positron emission tomography (PET); these are noninvasive screening tools that do not subject the patient to catheterization. In addition to the aforementioned techniques, which are merely a selection of the imaging modalities currently used in vivo or that are in the validation stage, the use of optical techniques for biomedical imaging is gaining considerable attention. This is largely due to the potential of optical techniques to provide high-resolution imaging without the need for ionizing radiation and associated risks.
Optical coherence tomography (OCT), which is based on a low-coherence interferometer, has emerged as a rapid, non-contact and noninvasive, high-resolution imaging tool (Huang et al., 1991). From the mid-1990s, the ability of intravascular OCT to provide high-resolution (10–20 μm) cross-sectional images of both in vitro human aorta and coronary arteries has been demonstrated (Brezinski et al., 1996, Fujimoto et al., 1995). The resolution of OCT images was up to 10 times better than that of conventional ultrasound, MRI, and computed tomography (CT) (Jang et al., 2002, Yabushita et al., 2002). Therefore, using OCT, small structural details (such as the width of intimal caps and the presence of fissures in atherosclerotic plaques (Brezinski et al., 1997) could be resolved and intramural collections of lipid within the intima of a vessel wall could be detected (Brezinski et al., 1996, Fujimoto et al., 1995). Furthermore, the objective OCT image criterion for risk-stratifying plaque characterization has been established on the basis of the intrinsic optical properties of a typical plaque, whose constituents are lipid, calcium, and fibrous tissue (Bresinski et al., 1997, Jang et al., 2002, Stamper et al., 2006, Tearney et al., 2006, Yabushita et al., 2002). On this basis, OCT has a detection sensitivity and specificity of 71%–79% and 97%–98% for fibrous plaques, 95%–96% and 97% for fibrocalcific plaques, and 90%–94% and 90%–92% for lipid-rich plaques, respectively (Tearney et al., 2006, Yabushita et al., 2002). Moreover, OCT has also been shown to quantify plaque macrophage content (Tearney et al., 2003) in lipid-rich plaques and to assess the success of intracoronary stent implantation in patients with coronary artery disease during percutaneous intra-arterial procedures (Bouma et al., 2003). At present, a company, LightLab Imaging, is targeting the cardiovascular market using commercializing intravascular OCT technology by providing dedicated imaging wires and occlusion balloon catheters.
In general, OCT images are obtained from measurements of the echo time delay and the intensity of the backscattered light from a specimen. Further, OCT employs the inherent differences in the index of refraction, rather than enhancement with dyes, to differentiate tissue types. However, since the plaque components are heterogeneous, they may sometimes generate reflected signals that confuse or obscure the identity of these components; multiple scattering by the cap also creates difficulties in identifying the plaque due to the diffuse nature of the plaque border (Stamper et al., 2006). Polarization-sensitive OCT (PS-OCT), a functional mode of OCT, combines the advantages of OCT with additional image contrasts obtained by using the birefringence of the specimen as a contrast agent. Many biological tissues have a microscopic fibrous structure and so exhibit intrinsic birefringence. Moreover, changes in birefringence may indicate changes in functionality, structure, or viability of tissues in the early stages of the disease (de Boer et al., 1997).
From 2004, we have been presenting the application of PS-OCT in human atherosclerosis, and have proposed approaches to characterize a plaque lesion on the basis of its birefringence property (Kuo et al., 2004, 2005, 2007). Moreover, in a recent study, our laboratory has assessed the arterial characteristics in human atherosclerosis by quantitatively determining both scattering and birefringence properties of vessel tissue from PS-OCT images (Kuo et al., 2007, 2008). Based on our findings, a quantitative PS-OCT image criterion for plaque characterization was constructed. In the remainder of this chapter, the results that we obtained using the PS-OCT system for imaging human atherosclerosis in vitro are summarized. We hope that our results, along with the results from other investigators, will construe a step forward in the application of PS-OCT imaging technology for clinically diagnosing atherosclerosis in the near future.
2. Principle of polarization-sensitive optical coherence tomography (PS-OCT) system
The optical setup of the PS-OCT system used in this study is shown in Figure 1. A collimated beam from a superluminescent diode (SLD) centered at a wavelength of 837 nm with a spectral bandwidth of 17.5 nm was used as a low-coherence light source in a Michelson interferometer. The axial resolution, which depends on the temporal coherence properties of the SLD), was 17 μm, while the lateral resolution (determined by the numerical aperture of the objective) was 10 μm. The incident beam was vertically polarized by a polarizer placed in the interferometer. A nonpolarization beam splitter (BS) was used to split the light wave into signal and reference beams. In the Michelson interferometer, a quarter-wave plate (QWP) with an azimuth angle set at 45 to the horizontal was used to focus the circular polarized light onto the examined specimen. On the other hand, the reference beam light was directed to a plane mirror mounted on a linear translator, which repetitively scanned the reference arm optical path length at a constant speed (1 mm/s). Another QWP (set at 22.5 to the horizontal) in the reference beam path rotated the polarization of the incident laser beam by 45 , thereby becoming the reflected reference beam.
The laser beam was reflected from the specimen and recombined with the reflected reference beam, and then both the horizontal (P wave) and vertical components (S wave) were independently directed toward two photodetectors Dp and Ds, respectively, using a polarized BS (PBS). From the ac coupling of the detector signals, the full interferometric signals were recorded. The amplitudes A i (z) and phases ϕ i (z) of the interference signals at different depths (z) were determined using the Hilbert transform; i = P and S represent the P and S polarization states, respectively. Three parameters—the backscatter intensity R(z), phase retardation
In this study, we adapted a free-space PS-OCT system to precisely control the polarization state of the laser beam used in birefringent imaging. Several other groups have developed a high speed fiber-based PS-OCT system for application as a medical instrument in vivo (Guo et al., 2004, Park et al., 2001, 2004, Saxer et al., 2000). Moreover, an optically clear hemoglobin-based blood substitute has also been used to displace blood and enable OCT imaging with minimal patient discomfort (Villard et al., 2002). Further, several Fourier domain PS-OCT techniques (Park et al., 2005, Yamanari et al., 2006, Zhang et al., 2004) have been reported recently and have received considerable attention due to the high data acquisition rates (e.g., acquisition at 80 to 110 fps), which can eliminate motion artifacts and reduce ischemia during blood-free optical imaging. This allows for comprehensive scanning of long arterial segments during a short balloon occlusion or even 1 bolus liquid flush without occlusion. The first clinical study using this technology is being initiated in order to investigate vulnerable plaque hypothesis in a prospective multicenter manner. By combining the above features, PS-OCT can be used to measure reflected intensity, phase retardation, and fast-axis angle distributions, and thereby provide a greater contrast than is available with conventional OCT systems.
3. In vitro PS-OCT imaging of human atherosclerosis
Specimens of the aorta with white or yellow plaque were obtained from heart transplant recipients at the National Taiwan University Hospital, Taiwan. The photographs of some specimens are shown in Figure 2. The protocol was approved by the ethics committees of the National Taiwan University Hospital. The specimens were dipped in saline (4C), cut into segments smaller than 1 × 1 cm, and examined. Each segment was mounted in a cuvette and moistened with a normal saline bath maintained at 37C during the imaging. Only the intimal surface was exposed for PS-OCT imaging. The aortic specimen regions imaged with PS-OCT were marked for subsequent histopathological examination. After PS-OCT imaging, all the specimens were fixed in 10% neutral formalin for 24 h and then processed for standard paraffin embedding. Serial sections with 4 μm thickness were cut within the region of the PS-OCT examination, and stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H and E) for routine examination. The distribution of the collagen structure in the plaque lesion was also examined using Masson trichrome and picrosirius red staining procedures as well as a polarization microscope. Finally, the entire specimens were classified into normal vessel (N), lipid (L), fibrocalcific (C), and fibrous lesions (F) by a pathologist (J. J. Shyu).
The PS-OCT images of representative specimens are shown in Figure 3–6. The histological image of the normal vessel wall [Figure 3(a)] showing a medial layer below the intima is compared with the PS-OCT image of the same specimen [Figure 3(b)]. The signal-rich layer closest to the lumen is the intima. In the normal vessel wall, the phase retardation increases uniformly [Figure 3(c)], and the pseudocolor distribution of the fast-axis angle signals is also uniform [Figure 3(d)]. The pale area in Figure 3(e) is a subintimal lipid-loaded region (L), which is morphologically composed mostly of the necrotic debris of foamy cells. Because of the paraffin embedding process, the solvent treatment removes the lipid from these lipid-loaded structures, which therefore appear as empty spaces in stained sections [Figure 3(e)]. The corresponding PS-OCT image [Figure 3(f)] reveals a decreased signal density under a thin homogeneous surface band. Moreover, the phase retardation and fast-axis angle signals are distributed in a slightly more random manner in the atherosclerotic lesion [Figure 3(g) and 3(h), respectively] than in a normal vessel wall [Figure 3(c) and 3(d)].
Moreover, the PS-OCT and histological images showed a plaque having small amounts of fibrous connective tissue (blue stain; black arrows) within a lipid-loaded area [Figure 4(a)]. The signal density (arrows) was stronger, the backscattering signal was more heterogeneous [Figure 4(b)], and the variation in the phase retardation [Figure 4(c)] and fast-axis angle distribution [Figure 4(d)] was more abrupt in the fibrous tissue than in the lipid-loaded region (L). Figure 4(e) shows a typically advanced plaque within the vascular intima; it is characterized by a necrotic lipid core covered by a thicker fibrous cap (CF ~250 μm; stained blue with Masson’s trichrome). Plaque development in the vascular wall involves a reorganization of intimal collagen fibers (Rekhter, 1999). Figure 4(f) shows a relatively deep
lipid-loaded (L) area close to the media. The medial layer had a low backscattering intensity, and hence, the interface between the plaque and the media was not well defined. A comparison of the PS-OCT [Figure 4(g) and 4(h)] images with the histological images [Figure 4(e)] showed gradual changes in phase retardation and fast-axis angle signals, which were due to the accumulation of collagen fiber in the plaque. Further, the changes in the pseudocolor in Figure 4(g) were more uniform within the vessel wall than in those regions indicated by the arrows in Figure 4(c).
Figure 5 also shows an atheroma plaque (*) of a coronary artery stained with trichrome (a, 40×) and picrosirius red (b, 100X), which was examined under a polarization microscope (c, 100×). The structure above the mark (*) is the fibrous cap in the tunica intima, and the structure below the mark (*) is the tunica media. Picrosirius polarized microscopy reveals birefringence regions (e.g., organized collagen in a vessel wall). The intense birefringence of the collagen fiber represented in Figure 5(e), left region, is confirmed by Figure 5(c) wherein the thick collagen fiber can be observed (in orange color). The fine collagen fiber (green color) of Figure 5(c) is also consistent with small changes in the phase retardation shown in the right region of Figure 5(e).
Finally, two fibrocalcific plaques are shown in Figure 6. The PS-OCT image showed a large sharply delineated, signal-rich area of heterogeneous backscattering [Figure 6(b) and 6(f)], as well as strong birefringence [Figure 6(c) and 6(g)]. Different structural orientations were also indicated by the PS-OCT image [i.e., different orientations of a fast-axis angle signal in three parts of the tomogram; see Figure 6(h)] but not by the H and E stained specimen [Figure 6(e)]. Since the calcified lesion was damaged during the sectioning process, only a large empty hole with a few calcified fragments appeared within the calcified plaque.
Using the above experiments, the capability of PS-OCT for imaging atherosclerotic plaques in human specimens has been evaluated. We have demonstrated that the normal vascular intima has a low intrinsic birefringence property, while changes in birefringence characteristics were apparent in fibrous and calcified plaques; moreover, the birefringence characteristics were different from those in normal vessels and lipid-loaded lesions. By using picrosirius staining along with polarization microscopy, we could also identify the thickness of collagen fiber. Recently, the identification of organized collagen fiber in arteries has also been demonstrated by using a single-detector PS-OCT (Giattina et al., 2006). In addition, another report showed that the PS-OCT measurements of birefringence have a strong positive correlation with thick collagen fiber content (r = 0.76, p < 0.001) and also a smooth muscle cells density (r = 0.74, p < 0.01) (Nadkarni et al., 2007).
4. Extracting optical properties from PS-OCT images
It is well known that optical properties can be used to indicate whether a tissue is in a normal or pathological state (Kortum & Muraca, 1996). Further, accurate knowledge of optical properties is essential for the optimum use of light in diagnosis and the treatment of diseases. In this study, we constructed a quantitative PS-OCT image criterion for plaque characterization. Following PS-OCT imaging, an algorithm was used to determine both scattering (i.e., μs and g eff ) and birefringence properties (i.e. Δn and β) of vessel tissue from the above PS-OCT images. The μs can be thought of as the reciprocal of the average distance a photon travels between scattering events. The g eff factor describes how isotropic or anisotropic the scattering is, and is related to the particle size in the specimen. The Δn value characterizes the differential speed of propagation between two orthogonal polarized states of light in the specimen; it may change with derangement and mechanical failure of the collagen network in the vessel. And the β value could be thought of as a parameter of the fiber orientation in fibrous tissues where birefringence is caused by form birefringence.
First, the user selected regions (such as the white rectangle shown in the left column of Figure 7) corresponding to those evaluated by histopathology. The regions were then automatically divided into several regions of interest (ROIs) (e.g., green dashed inset in the left column of Figure 7) beginning from the intimal surface and including approximately 25 A-scans. Further, the size of each ROI was kept constant. The R, Φ, and β signals within each ROI were laterally (i.e., along the x-axis) delineated and averaged. Subsequently, μs and the root-mean-square scattering angle (θrms ), which can be used to calculate the effective anisotropy factor (g eff = cos(θrms )), were extracted by fitting the reflectivity signals as a function of depth to an extended Huygens-Fresnel model (Kuo et al., 2008, Levitz et al., 2004, Thrane et al., 2000). This is shown in the right column of Figure 7.
Here i2(z) is the mean square of the heterodyne signal current; α, the power to current conversion ratio; PR and PS, the power of the reference and input sample beams; σb, the effective backscattering cross-section; and ωH and ωS, the 1/e irradiance radius at the probing depth in the absence and presence of scattering, respectively. The pixels near the interface, which was due to the specular reflection between the scattering and non-scattering media, were excluded from the fit (Levitz et al., 2004). Furthermore, the profiles of the averaged phase retardation signals have three layers (black arrows in the right column of Figure 7). Δn can be calculated by linear least-squares fitting through the averaged Φ data over the depth of the ROI, and then its slope can be determined from the formula:
Here k0 is the wave vector and d is the thickness of the fitting range. In addition, the mean fast-axis angle calculated by averaging across the width of the ROI at each depth can be determined from Equation (3).
Statistical analyses were performed using SPSS (version 14.0; SPSS Inc.). A p-value < 0.05 was considered to be statistically significant. The test of significant difference of optical parameters was performed by Kruskal-Wallis statistics and used to evaluate whether the four optical properties contributed to the differentiation between different kinds of vessels. After performing a significant test, multiple comparison procedures were then used to determine which means are different. The following equation was used:
Here Ri is the mean rank of the i th group; Rj , the mean rank of the j th group; k, the number of independent variables; nt , the total number of samples; ni and nj , the sample numbers of the i th and j th group, respectively;
k(k–1), the number of comparisons. A Spearman’s ρ correlation test was also used to evaluate whether these four properties have correlations with each other.
Finally, multinomial logistic regressions were used to generate a predictive model based on a linear combination of weights (Xrρ) of optical properties ( ρ= scattering coefficient, effective anisotropy factor, birefringence, and fast-axis angle) as shown in this equation:
Here OR = Odds Ratio,
Figure 3–6, given in previous pages, show illustrative PS-OCT images with the corresponding histopathology of normal, lipid, fibroatheroma, and fibrocalcific plaques. Altogether, 30 aortic specimens and therefore 135 ROIs from each region across totally R, Φ, and β images were collected. The extracted data, μs, geff, Δn, and β, are summarized in Figure 8, where each box shows the median, 25th and 75th percentiles, and the extreme values within a category. Open circles and stars indicate outlier data.
Kruskal-Wallis statistics shows that μs (p = 0.022), Δn (p < 0.001), and β(p < 0.001) have significant differences in normal vessels and three types of atherosclerotic vessels, by measuring how much the ranks of the four groups differ from the mean rank of all groups. The geff value does not show any significant difference (p = 0.104). From the multiple comparison test, we found that F to C shows significant difference in μs; Δn between C and
N, F and N, L and C, and L and F has significant differences; and β between C and N, F and N, L and N, and L and F has significant differences.
Spearman’s ρ correlation test shows that only geff correlates with the scattering coefficient (r = –0.584, p = 0.003) in fibrocalcific plaque, while this value correlates with the birefringence value (r = –0.563, p = 0.008) in fibrous lesions. Finally, three regression models, Equations (8)–(10), were used to predict the odds ratio of C to N, F to N, and L to N, respectively.
The prediction results are given in Table 1. This method identified that 17 of 23 lesions are fibrocalcific and that 105 of 112 lesions are not fibrocalcific. In the case of fibrous plaque, 7 of 21 lesions were identified as fibrous and 110 of 114 as not fibrous lesions. Finally, the method identified 33 of 48 lesions as lipid regions and 55 of 87 as not lipid regions. The constructed regression model achieved 90%, 87%, and 65% prediction accuracy for C, F, and L, respectively.
|Histology o bserved||Model p redicted|
|N C F L||27 1 0 7||0 17 1 6||0 2 7 2||16 3 13 33|
Our preliminary data indicated that more than 80% normal arterial samples had μs value between 10 and 39 mm–1and have significant differences from other different types of plaques (p < 0.05); this is consistent with the results obtained by Levitz (Levitz et al., 2004). From the multiple comparison tests, we also noticed that a significant difference in scattering property exists between fibrous and fibrocalcific plaques. These findings are consistent with the results obtained with qualitative image-based plaque characterization methods where fibrous and fibrocalcific plaques can be distinguished by the signal-rich and signal-poor regions respectively (Stamper et al., 2006, Yabushita et al., 2002). However, the effective anisotropy factor demonstrates no significant difference between normal and other atherosclerotic lesions (p = 0.104), perhaps because geff of the fibrocalcific and fibrous lesions were correlated with μs and Δn, respectively. In the case of the birefringence property of the vessel that has not been quantitatively analyzed previously, i.e., β values, they were maximum in the most atherosclerotic lesion at over 70 degrees. Smaller β values were present in the best-fit areas of normal vascular intima. The Δn values were small and more concentrated in normal intima, but they demonstrated larger variations in the entire atherosclerotic lesion. The birefringence coefficient was larger in abundant thicker collagen fibers (Δn = 9.409
In this study, no attempt has been made to differentiate a necrotic core from a lipid pool. Since the signal from the necrotic cores may be too weak for reliable measurements, future studies based on histological stains that can differentiate the two are needed. It is also noteworthy that the Φ and β signals are distributed in a slightly more random manner in the lipid lesion than in the normal vessel wall and fibrous and fibrocalcific plaques. This may be due to the polarization state of light that is to be randomized by multiple scattering in lipid-rich tissue, which reduces the accuracy of birefringence measurements. Alternatively, further modifications of these PS-OCT criteria, such as the addition of a threshold limit for the signal-poor region and incorporation of the standard deviation of the birefringence signal within one ROI, may be required to differentiate lipid lesions better.
Collagen fiber constitutes up to 60% of the total atherosclerotic plaque protein. Uncontrolled collagen accumulation leads to vascular stenosis, whereas excessive collagen breakdown weakens plaques making them prone to rupture (Falk et al., 1995, Rekhter, 1999). Assessing the phase retardation change may be a method to quantify the collagen content in atherosclerotic lesions, and it may provide significant pathophysiological information that can influence clinical decision-making in patients with risk factors. Furthermore, computer-based quantitative analysis can automatically determine the plaque type; this will eliminate the training time for each reader and disparity between different diagnoses. The quantitative information on both arterial scattering and birefringence properties can also be integrated with the qualitative visual information provided by PS-OCT images, and this can support the facilitation of image-based plaque characterization methods. Our preliminary results present an important step in validating this new imaging modality and can provide a basis for the interpretation of PS-OCT images obtained from human specimens. However, an analysis from a considerably larger set of specimens as well as an analysis taking the effect of cluster data (i.e., specimens from the same person) into consideration will be required for developing a more suitable prediction model in the future. Moreover, it is likely that the combination of other functional modalities such as optical coherence elastography (Rogowska et al., 2004, 2006) or spectroscopic OCT (Morgner et al., 2000), which can provide additional indexes (such as cellular and molecular components and mechanical properties of arterial walls), will have a greater predictive value for constructing a risk-stratifying plaque characterization criterion that can be applied in future clinical utilities.
The authors thank Dr. N. K. Chou of the Department of Surgery of National Taiwan University Hospital for providing aortic tissues and Prof. J. J. Shyu of the Department of Veterinary Medicine of National Taiwan University for histology examinations. This research was supported by the National Science Council of Taiwan.