Materials Science » Polymers » "New Polymers for Special Applications", book edited by Ailton De Souza Gomes, ISBN 978-953-51-0744-6, Published: September 12, 2012 under CC BY 3.0 license

Chapter 10

Nitrogen-Rich Polymers as Candidates for Energetic Applications

By Eric Pasquinet
DOI: 10.5772/46245

Article top

Overview

This chapter is dedicated to the memory of Etienne Kosciusko-Morizet

Figure 1.

Figure 2.

Figure 3.

Figure 4.

Figure 5.

Figure 6.

Figure 7.

Figure 8.

Figure 9.

Figure 10.

Figure 11.

Figure 12.

Figure 13.

Figure 14.

Figure 15.

Figure 16.

Figure 17.

Figure 18.

Figure 19.

Figure 20.

Figure 21.

Figure 22.

Figure 23.

Figure 24.

Figure 25.

Figure 26.

Figure 27.

Figure 28.

Figure 29.

Figure 30.

Figure 31.
from ref [78])
Figure 32. from ref [78])

Nitrogen-Rich Polymers as Candidates for Energetic Applications

Eric Pasquinet

1. Introduction

The design of new energetic molecules is based on compounds exhibiting a high density and an elevated heat of formation. These fundamental properties, achieved through the presence of numerous nitrogen atoms and/or explosophoric groups, ensure high performance levels that can be useful in target applications such as explosives, propellants or gas generators.

The same basics also apply when considering the use of polymers, instead of single molecules, as energetic ingredients. However, the quest for high densities and heats of formation appears somewhat more challenging in the case of polymers, since the polymerization process often requires specific chemical functions that may be detrimental to the desired energetic properties. Currently, the most commonly used polymers in the field get their energetic content only from explosophoric groups: NO2 for polyNIMMO (polynitratomethyl methyloxetane) or polyGLYN (polyglycidyl nitrate), N3 for GAP (glycidyl azide polymer), to name a few. This survey gives an overview of research efforts that have been devoted to the synthesis of macromolecules with high nitrogen contents. Such a unique property is expected to produce materials with particularly elevated heats of formation, thus making them very valuable in the field of energetic compounds.

Azaheterocycles are obviously suitable scaffolds for achieving nitrogen-rich polymers. Tetrazole-, tetrazine-, triazole- and triazine-based materials are considered here. Three methodologies have been identified as the main routes for obtaining the target polymers: polymerization of vinylazaheterocycles, incorporation of the desired azaheterocycle in a preformed macromolecular architecture and polycondensation.

2. Tetrazole-based polymers

2.1. Polymerization of vinyltetrazoles

During the last decade, two major papers have reviewed the synthesis and polymerization of vinyltetrazoles, and together they present an extensive literature coverage [1,2].

2.1.1. Synthesis of C-vinyltetrazoles

Polymerization of the starting and/or target vinyl compound is a major concern in the reaction of acrylonitrile with sodium azide leading to C-vinyltetrazole (5-vinyltetrazole) 2. Masking of the double bond of acrylonitrile 1 through addition of dimethylamine [3] or hydrogen chloride [4] circumvents this problem and renders the process more efficient (Figure 1).

media/image1_w.jpg

Figure 1.

2.1.2. Synthesis of N-vinyltetrazoles

Two main strategies have been used for the synthesis of N-vinyltetrazoles. The first one involves alkylation of the tetrazole N-H with a functionalized ethyl chain, followed by elimination. The second one is the catalyzed direct vinylation with vinylacetate or butylvinylether. Recently, a variant of the first approach, using dibromoethane as the alkylating agent, has been developed [5]. This method appears now as the method of choice, since it is a one-step, high-yielding procedure that only needs readily available, non-toxic chemicals. In the majority of cases, a mixture of 1- and 2-vinyltetrazole are produced and selectivity depends on the 5-substituent (Figure 2).

media/image2_w.jpg

Figure 2.

2.1.3. Synthesis of divinyltetrazoles

Following the above-mentioned strategies, divinyltetrazole compounds have been obtained. Vinylation of 5-vinyltetrazole gave a mixture of 1,5- and 2,5-divinyltetrazole 3a-b in a 1/2.3-2.4 ratio [5, 6]. In the vinylation of 5,5’-methylenebis(2-vinyltetrazole) 4, only 2 of the 3 possible isomers were isolated, as the 1,1’-divinyl compound was not detected [5]. Such divinyl products could be useful as nitrogen-rich cross-linkers (Figure 3).

media/image3_w.jpg

Figure 3.

2.1.4. Polymerization of C-vinyltetrazoles

5-Vinyltetrazoles are readily involved in free-radical polymerization (Figure 4). A comparison between C- and N-vinyltetrazoles shows that the former are more active in such processes. A number of reaction media have been used for the polymerization of 5-vinyltetrazoles, and it was shown that the activity was enhanced in more polar solvents, especially in water. Molecular weights also increased in aqueous systems. This trend prompted a polymerization study in ionic solvents. Of the various ionic liquids (ILs) tested, only 1-methyl-3-propylimidazolium bromide gave rise to decent yields. Other ILs gave low yields or even decomposition of the tetrazole ring [7].

media/image4_w.jpg

Figure 4.

Poly-5-vinyltetrazole 6 contains 58.3% nitrogen, which clearly makes it a high-nitrogen compound. However, it seems that its N-vinyl congener has been favored for industrial applications.

2.1.5. Polymerization of N-vinyltetrazoles

Figure 5 presents the most interesting polymers obtained in terms of nitrogen-content or expected energetic output. To the best of our knowledge, polymerization of 5-nitro-1-vinyltetrazole8 is unknown. However, 1-vinyltetrazoles are generally readily polymerized in free-radical conditions, with water as the solvent of choice. The activity depends on the nature of the 5-substituent. For example, 5-amino-1-vinyltetrazole 7 is less active than the unsubstituted compound due to the electron-donating character of the amino group [9,10]. Unusually, yields of poly(5-amino-1-vinyltetrazole) 8 are slightly higher in N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) than in water. Recently, emulsion polymerization gave porous monoliths of the corresponding so-called ‘polyHIPEs’ of 8, exhibiting remarkable mechanical properties [11].

The synthesis and polymerization of 5-(methyl)hydrazino-1-vinyltetrazole 9 have been described. It was necessary to add the initiator (AIBN) in several portions to enhance the conversion of the starting vinyl compound. However, while 9b (R = Me) yielded 85% of the corresponding polymer 10b, the yield of 10a from 9a (R = H) was limited to about 25-30% and the degree of polymerization was very low. The synthesis of the very nitrogen-rich azide-functionalized polymer 11 was attempted through diazotization of 10a. However, elemental analyses were unsatisfactory because of partial decomposition of the tetrazolylhydrazine moieties [12].

media/image5_w.jpg

Figure 5.

The different examples cited herein highlight the high nitrogen content of polyvinyltetrazoles and their prospects as energetic compounds. In 2003, a pilot-plant production of polyvinyltetrazoles was started in two companies in Russia.

2.2. Incorporation of tetrazole via polymer-analogous transformation

It is well-known that tetrazoles can be obtained by addition of an azide onto a cyano derivative. This method was applied to polyacrylonitrile (PAN) in order to synthesize poly(5-vinyltetrazole) (Figure 6).

media/image6_w.jpg

Figure 6.

When using NaN3/NH4Cl, it was shown that higher temperatures and molecular weights of the initial PAN resulted in a higher incorporation of tetrazole moieties in the polymer [13]. Thus, at 105°C, a PAN with a Mw of 180,000 g/mol was almost completely transformed in the corresponding poly(5-vinyltetrazole) (tetrazole units: 97.5%). The tetrazole content was estimated by 2 independent methods: weight measurements and acid-base titration. According to the authors, this poly(5-vinyltetrazole) synthesis using polymer-analogous transformation is advantageous since there is no commercial source of 5-vinyltetrazole and its synthesis is difficult.

Zinc chloride has also been used as a catalyst to carry out the desired transformation [14]. The best components ratio was NaN3/NH4Cl/RCN 4/4/1. Infrared and NMR spectroscopies demonstrated the total conversion of nitrile functions into tetrazoles. In addition to PAN, other nitrile-containing polymers were succesfully tetrazolated.

Poly(5-vinyltetrazole) for gas generants was also synthesized upon the action of a zinc salt (ZnBr2) but polymerization was carried out in emulsion in the presence of a surfactant [15]. A related patent subsequently extended this water-based synthesis [16]. At 115°C tetrazolation was limited to 70%, but reached 95% at 170°C. Further reaction of the resulting poly(5-vinyltetrazole) with ammonia yielded the corresponding ammonium salt 12 (Figure 7). The latter theoretically contains 61.9% of nitrogen and is therefore a promising material for gas generants. A related triaminoguanidinium salt 13 had been disclosed as early as in 1968 [17]. Taking into account the 6% of PAN units remaining in the starting poly-5-vinyltetrazole, a theoretical value of 69.2% of nitrogen was achieved in the salt (Figure 7).

media/image7_w.jpg

Figure 7.

All these conditions surpass earlier methods that yielded lower levels of tetrazole incorporation (see for example ref [18]).

Polyvinylchloride (PVC) can also be used as a polymer precursor. Upon reaction with a tetrazolate anion, the corresponding polyvinyltetrazole is formed (Figure 8). However, this method seems less practical since partial elimination of hydrogen chloride generates unsaturated fragments in the final product [1].

media/image8_w.jpg

Figure 8.

2.3. Synthesis of tetrazole-based polymers via polycondensation

5-Chloromethyltetrazole 14 is an interesting substrate as it has both a nucleophilic (tetrazole N-H) and a highly electrophilic (CH2-Cl) center. In the presence of triethylamine as a base, the tetrazole ring can be deprotonated which gives rise to poly(methylenetetrazole) 15 in good yields [19,20] (Figure 9).

media/image9_w.jpg

Figure 9.

This polyalkylation product is in fact an oligomer, with Mw below 2000 g/mol (ca 15-20 units). With a measured nitrogen content of up to 67.2%, it surpasses polyvinyltetrazole by almost 10%. In addition, its viscous state is attained at relatively low temperatures, thus making it a very promising candidate in gas-generating systems. It should be noted that 5-chloroethyltetrazole can also participate in a similar process. However, polymerization is slower and yields do not exceed 20%.

The high reactivity of 5-chloromethyltetrazole 14 has been used to graft poly(5-vinyltetrazole). Upon addition of an excess of 14 and triethylamine, a branched poly(5-vinyltetrazole) bearing poly(methylenetetrazole) bridges was obtained in yields around 70%. Ten equivalents of 14 produced the best results. Characterization of the polymer revealed a 6/1 ratio of methylenetetrazole vs vinyltetrazole moieties. The number of vinyltetrazole units between branching junctions was around 2. Its energetic prospects were highlighted by a very elevated density of 1.70 and a nitrogen content of 67.9% [19,20] (Figure 9).

A patent describes the polycondensation of various dinitriles with diazides to produce tetrazole containing polycondensates [21]. Of these, the most valuable polymer for energetic applications is the one obtained from dicyanofuroxane 15. Indeed, despite the fact that the hexamethylene spacer lowers the N content, a high energetic output is expected from the presence of 2 tetrazole and 1 furoxane rings in the unit of polymer 16 (Figure 10).

media/image10_w.jpg

Figure 10.

Isopropyl 2-(5-(1-methylhydrazinyl)tetrazol-1-yl)acetate 17 was polymerized at high temperature to give the corresponding polycondensate 18 [22]. The yield was higher when working at 120°C rather than 140°C, however elemental analyses still showed a lower nitrogen content than expected (44.9 instead of 54.5%). The presence of low molecular weight polymers still bearing isopropoxy groups may account for this discrepancy.

The related monomer N-[1-(2-hydroxyethyl)tetrazol-5-yl]-N-methylhydrazine 19 was also involved in polycondensation processes. With succinyl chloride as the partner, only low molecular weights could be achieved, and results from elemental analysis were unsatisfactory. This was ascribed to the protonation of the hydrazino moieties during polycondensation. More positive results were obtained with hexamethylenediisocyanate but obviously the resulting polycondensate 20b is less attractive for energetic applications due to its lower nitrogen content [23]. Another similar polymer was recently described by the same group [24] (Figure 10).

3. Tetrazine-based polymers

3.1. Polyvinyltetrazines

To the best of our knowledge, monovinyl-1,2,4,5-tetrazines are unknown, and the corresponding polyvinyltetrazines thus remain elusive compounds. However, the first member of the vinyltetrazine family, 3,6-divinyl-1,2,4,5-tetrazine 21 has been described (Figure 11).

media/image11_w.jpg

Figure 11.

The synthesis was achieved by using the phenylsulfanylethyl group as a masked vinyl moiety, the latter being the result of oxidation to the sulfone and elimination. Compound 21 was obtained as a volatile, pink oil that solidified in the freezer. Preliminary studies showed that 21 exhibited a limited stability at high temperatures and in the presence of radicals, which obviously precludes its use in polymer chemistry. However, 3,6-divinyl-1,2,4,5-tetrazine can be seen as a tetraaza analogue of the widely used 1,4-divinylbenzene and is therefore believed to be a useful building block in the synthesis of new tetrazine-based molecules and materials [25]. Further work is needed to establish the properties and reactivity of 21. These studies also open the way towards the synthesis of unsymmetrical vinyl-1,2,4,5-tetrazine compounds that may exhibit improved stability and reactivity in polymerization conditions.

3.2. Synthesis of tetrazine-based polymers via polycondensation

One of the most convenient ways to construct the 1,2,4,5-tetrazine (s-tetrazine) ring is by condensation of hydrazine with a diimidate to produce the corresponding 1,2-dihydro-1,2,4,5-tetrazine, followed by oxidation. This strategy has been extended to the synthesis of diverse poly(phenylene-s-tetrazinylene)s by using diimidates. In order to increase the energetic prospects of such polymers, azahetaryl precursors were considered. However, the reaction of hydrazine monohydrate with pyridine-2,6-diimidate 22 did not yield the expected dihydrotetrazine polymer. Instead, the corresponding diamidrazone 23 was isolated in high yield. It is likely that the insolubility of 23 in THF is responsible for the uneffective polycondensation reaction. Diamidrazone 23 was used as the monomer in a microwave-assisted polycondensation to give the poly(2,6-pyridinediyl-dihydro-s-tetrazinylene) 24 which was further oxidized to the desired tetrazine polymer 25 using sodium nitrite/aq. AcOH [26] (Figure 12).

media/image12_w.jpg

Figure 12.

Following the same strategy, the previously unknown 1,3,5-triazine-2,4,6-triamidrazone 26 was subjected to polycondensation to yield the hyperbranched polymer 27. In this case, microwave activation was not necessary. Polymer 27 stands out as the most nitrogenated tetrazine-containing polymer, even if the measured N content was lower than expected, presumably due to water incorporation. A density of 1.56 was determined for 27, which is significantly higher than the value reported for amorphous poly(p-phenylene) (1.11). This clearly shows how the introduction of nitrogen heterocycles in polyarylene structures is valuable in the field of energetic materials as it increases this crucial parameter. Unfortunately 27 was found unreactive to common oxidants, presumably because of its high insolubility. Only very strong oxidative conditions resulted in the formation of s-tetrazine rings, but oxidation remained uncomplete (Figure 12).

The structures of all polymers were confirmed using 13C and 15N solid state NMR [26,27]. High-resolution spectra also indicated low amounts of 4-amino-1,2,4-triazole moieties (coming from the known rearrangement of some 1,2-dihydro-1,2,4,5-tetrazine units).

4. Triazole-based polymers

Synthetic strategies for C-vinyl- and N-vinyltriazoles (1,2,3- or 1,2,4-triazoles) are essentially the same as the ones presented above for vinyltetrazoles. The preparation and polymerization of vinyltriazoles have been reviewed in 2008 [28], 2003 [29,30] and 1974 [31].

4.1. 1,2,4-Triazole-based polymers

4.1.1. Poly(N-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole)s

Figure 13 presents the most interesting polymers obtained in terms of nitrogen content or expected energetic output.

media/image13_w.jpg

Figure 13.

1-Vinyl-1,2,4-triazole 29 was readily polymerized in free-radical conditions, and the process was more efficient in the presence of water. However, it was less active than 1-vinyl-1,2,3-triazole. This trend in activity was found to correlate with the corresponding Hammet constants [29]. Poly(1-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole) 30, obtained in sufficiently aqueous media, was essentially insoluble in water or organic solvents. This polymer is a well-established compound that may be interesting in numerous applications. Recently, open-cell porous monoliths of poly(1-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole) cross-linked with a low amount of N,N-methylenebisacrylamide were prepared (Figure 14). They exhibited interesting mechanical properties due to the presence of water in the polymer structure, as evidenced by NMR [32].

media/image14.png

Figure 14.

For the synthesis of 3-amino-1-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole 31, the classical transvinylation using vinyl acetate in the presence of cuprous chloride was ineffective. The product was obtained through the reaction of acetylene in a basic medium at high temperature [33] (Figure 13). The presence of the amino group resulted in some changes compared to the unfunctionalized derivative: the polymerization activity was three times lower, and poly(3-amino-1-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole) 32 was soluble in water [34]. The nitrogen content was also significantly improved to 50.9%, with a density of 1.30-1.36 equalling that of polyglycidyl azide.

Poly(3-nitro-1-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole) 35 is also a useful target due to the expected output from the nitro group. Alkylation of 3-nitro-1,2,4-triazole 33 with dichloroethane followed by dehydrochlorination gave a mixture of 1- and 4-vinyltriazole. The former (34) was polymerized in DMF and gave a polymer that was soluble only in highly polar solvents [35] (Figure 13).

4.1.2. Poly(C-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole)s

The strategy involving the construction of the vinyl fragment through dehydrohalogenation, dehydration or deamination is also applicable for the synthesis of C-vinyl-1,2,4-triazoles [28,36]. Another approach is the use of the Wittig reaction, exemplified below for salts of poly(C-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole).

4.1.3. Energetic poly(vinyl-1,2,4-triazole)s salts

To further increase the potential of poly(1-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole), protonation with energetic inorganic or organic acids was investigated (Figure 15). Polymerization of protonated 1-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole 36 was successful only with the nitric or perchloric acid-protonated product, since the presence of nitro functionalities in the organic acids tended to inhibit polymerization. Moreover, only about 70% of the nitrate or perchlorate anions remained after polymerization. However, radical polymerization of 1-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole 29 in DMF followed by protonation produced a series of energetic salts of poly(vinyl-1,2,4-triazole) 38. Elemental analyses established that the molar degree of substitution of anions was between 48 and 92% [37]. Thus this process represents a convenient way of improving the performances of the well-known poly(vinyl-1,2,4-triazole) 37.

media/image15_w.jpg

Figure 15.

The equivalent work in the poly(C-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole) series is also disclosed in a patent [38]. Salts (e.g., the ammonium salt) of 3(5)-bromomethyl-1,2,4-triazole 39 were converted to the 3(5)-vinyl derivatives 40 following a Wittig-type methodology. Free-radical or cationic polymerization produced the corresponding salt of poly(3(5)-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole) 41 (Figure 16). This compound has been used as a fuel in gas-generating compositions.

media/image16_w.jpg

Figure 16.

4.1.4. Incorporation of 1,2,4-triazole via polymer-analogous transformation

Energetic heterocyclic analogues of the well-known polyglycidyl azide (GAP) have been prepared via substitution of the chlorine atom of polyepichlorhydrin 42 by the anion of 3(5)nitro-1,2,4-triazole 43-Na [39]. The reaction proceeded in an almost quantitative fashion (residual chlorine: 0.1-0.4%) when carried out in high-boiling solvents at 100-130°C. Proton NMR enabled the determination of N-1 vs N-2 alkylation at the triazole ring, and a marked selectivity (9/1) towards the N-1 substituted polymer was found (Figure 17). The introduction of sodium azide together with the nitrotriazole salt resulted in a copolymer of glycidylazide and N-glycidyl-3-nitro-1,2,4-triazole.

media/image17_w.jpg

Figure 17.

4.1.5. Synthesis of 1,2,4-triazole-based polymers via polycondensation

Among the few 1,2,4-triazole-based condensation polymers known [40], the most promising as energetic materials are poly(4-amino-1,2,4-triazole)s [41]. The latter can be commonly obtained through isomerization of poly(dihydrotetrazine)s 45, following the general scheme depicted in Figure 18. This process is closely related to the one mentioned in the tetrazine section of this chapter.

media/image18_w.jpg

Figure 18.

Polymer 46-C2 stands out as the most nitrogenated member of this family with a calculated N content of 50.9%. Even though the first synthesis of 46-C2 dates back to 1954 [42], interest for this polymer or similar derivatives has been maintained for a long time for diverse applications [43, 44].

Another polycondensate incorporating 4-amino-1,2,4-triazole units has been mentioned in a patent. The synthesis is based on the simultaneous condensation of 3,5-dihydrazino-4-amino-1,2,4-triazole 47 and diaminoguanidinium azide 48 with formaldehyde/glyoxal (4/1) [45]. The exact structure of the resulting polymer 49 is not disclosed but has been claimed to provide a N/C ratio of 2.3 (Figure 19).

media/image19_w.jpg

Figure 19.

It should also be noted that 3-amino-1,2,4-triazole can be subjected to electrooxidation to yield films of the corresponding polymer [46,47]. However, the use of these films seems to be limited to corrosion protection applications and they obviously cannot be implemented as energetic materials.

4.2. 1,2,3-Triazole-based polymers

4.2.1. Poly(N-vinyl-1,2,3-triazole)s

1-Vinyl-1,2,3-triazole 50 can be classically synthesized via reaction of 1,2,3-triazole with acetylene in the presence of a catalyst [48], or by transvinylation with vinyl acetate [49]. Another possibility is the construction of the 1,2,3-triazole ring through ‘click’ chemistry between a functionalized azide and (substituted) acetylene, followed by elimination. A recent synthesis [50] following this scheme is presented in Figure 20. By using vinylacetylene in this approach, 1,5-divinyl-1,2,3-triazole 52 can be obtained [51]. 1-Vinyl-1,2,3-triazole itself is highly active in classical free-radical polymerization [29] and can also be polymerized to 51 using reversible addition-fragmentation and transfer (RAFT) conditions [50], but 5-nitro-1-vinyl-1,2,3-triazole 53 [49] is inert in this process (see below).

media/image20_w.jpg

Figure 20.

4.2.2. Poly(C-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole)s

4-Vinyl-1,2,3-triazole 56 has been obtained through 'click' chemistry with different acetylene and azido derivatives. A recent example describes the use of vinylacetylene 54 and azidomethyl pivalate 55 as starting materials [52]. This monomer is also active in radical polymerization [53], but less than its N-vinyl congener. Poly(4-vinyl-1,2,3-triazole) 57 has also been synthesized by deprotection of poly[4-vinyl-1(4-methoxybenzyl)-1,2,3-triazole] 58 [54] (Figure 21).

media/image21_w.jpg

Figure 21.

4.2.3. Incorporation of 1,2,3-triazole via polymer-analogous transformation

Reaction of the sodium salt of 4(5)-nitro-1,2,3-triazole 59-Na with polyvinylchloride (PVC) afforded poly(1-vinyl-4-nitro-1,2,3-triazole) 60. By using at least 2 equivalents of 59-Na at 120°C for 1 day, a complete substitution of the chloride functions could be achieved as demonstrated by elemental analysis showing 39.9% of N (calc. 40.0%) [55] (Figure 22).

This is the only method rendering it possible to obtain this nitrated polymer since it cannot be synthesized through polymerization of 1-vinyl-4-nitro-1,2,3-triazole 53. As a matter of fact, in 53, the nitro group acts as an inhibitor under radical and ionic conditions, which is apparently not the case for the isomeric 3-nitro-1-vinyl-1,2,4-triazole 34 (see above).

The same chemistry was applied to copolymers of vinylchloride and 2-methyl-5-vinyl-tetrazole to yield the corresponding nitro-1,2,3-triazole containing copolymers 61a-b. Copolymer 61a exhibited a measured N content of 47.2%.

Similarly, the salt 59-Na was used to quantitatively substitute the chlorine atoms on polyepichlorhydrin 42. As in the nitro-1,2,4-triazole series (see above), a mixture of isomers was obtained, but the selectivity was reversed: the N-2 isomer was the major one (60%) [56] (Figure 22).

4.2.4. Synthesis of 1,2,3-triazole based polymers via polycondensation

The well-established reaction of an azide with an alkyne, that has been extensively used for monomeric 1,2,3-triazole compounds, can be further extended to the synthesis of polymers.

media/image22_w.jpg

Figure 22.

Thus, (azidoalkyl)- or (azidoaryl) acetylenes were polymerized without catalyst to afford materials that were presumed to contain 1,4- and 1,5-substituted 1,2,3-triazole rings in a random distribution [57]. The most interesting compound for energetic applications was polymer 64, obtained from 3-azido-1-butyne 63 (Figure 23).

media/image23_w.jpg

Figure 23.

Similarly, an azido-1,3,5-triazine containing propargyl ether was used as the monomer. Of the different conditions (bulk, solution, with or without catalyst or heating), polymerization in bulk without catalysts was found to be the best way to minimize decomposition reactions and formation of by-products [58]. The hyperbranched product 65 offers an original combination of both triazine and triazole rings, although the nitrogen content was obviously lowered by the remaining propargyl ethers moieties.

5. Triazine-based polymers

To the best of our knowledge, vinyl-1,2,4-triazines are unknown. Some poly-1,2,4-triazines have been obtained by polycondensation [59], however their nitrogen content is much too low for them to be considered as energetic materials. This section will thus focus on polymers containing 1,3,5-triazines (s-triazines), which have been studied for a long time. Ref [60] is a comprehensive review of earlier work.

5.1. Polyvinyl-1,3,5-triazines

2-Vinyl-1,3,5-triazine 67 [61] has been prepared from 1,3,5-triazine 66 but it seems that interest in it faded quickly due to the ease of hydrolysis. 2-Vinyl-4,6-disubstituted-1,3,5-triazines were claimed to be more stable [62].

media/image24_w.jpg

Figure 24.

2,4,6-Trivinyl-1,3,5-triazine would also be an interesting compound (as a nitrogen-containing cross-linker) but the reported yield for its synthesis is poor [61]. In fact, the most valuable vinyltriazine is 2,4-diamino-6-vinyl-1,3,5-triazine 69, which can be prepared in 2 steps from dicyandiamide 68 [63]. Compound 69 has been polymerized in free-radical conditions, either by using potassium persulfate in water [63] or AIBN in DMSO or DMF [64]. The calculated N content of poly(2,4-diamino-6-vinyl-1,3,5-triazine) 70 exceeds 50% (Figure 24).

5.2. Synthesis of 1,3,5-triazine-based polymers via polycondensation

Amino-substituted triazines bearing a leaving group have been heated to obtain the corresponding homopolycondensates. A linear polytriazinylamine 72 was formed from 2,4-diamino-6-phenoxy-1,3,5-triazine 71 [65], whereas a hyperbranched structure 74 resulted from 2-amino-4,6-dichloro-1,3,5-triazine 73 since it was impossible to control the reaction in the sense that only one chlorine atom reacted [66] (Figure 25). Although no elemental analyses were reported to ascertain the structures, these products are believed to exhibit a high nitrogen content. Compound 74 is claimed to approach a cross-linked structure, which is corroborated by its limited degree of softening.

media/image25_w.jpg

Figure 25.

In a similar fashion, 2,4-bis(methylamino)-1,3,5-triazine 75 was reacted with 4,6-dichloro-5-nitro-pyrimidine 76 in the presence of a base. Modest molecular masses were obtained (1000-10000 g/mol), as confirmed by the presence of end-chain NHMe signals in NMR spectra [67]. However, polymer 77 is still of interest thanks to the presence of the energetic nitro group in addition to a reasonable nitrogen content (Figure 25).

Aminoalkyl units can also serve as linkages between triazine rings, as exemplified by the commercially available polymer 78, which has been used as a charring agent in flame-retardant compositions [68] (Figure 26).

media/image26_w.jpg

Figure 26.

Melamine-formaldehyde resins constitute a well-known class of compounds. Not surprisingly, related polymers can also be considered as derivatives with high nitrogen contents. For example, the reaction of trichloromelamine 79 with formaldehyde followed by dehydrochlorination has been claimed to give a structure in which triazine rings are linked together through carbodiimide or dihydrocarbodiimide units [69] (Figure 27).

media/image27_w.jpg

Figure 27.

The chemistry shown above in the case of polytriazinylamines has also been widely explored for the synthesis of polytriazinylethers. The latter are obviously less attractive in terms of nitrogen content. However, commercially available nitro-containing diols are valuable compounds when one wishes to incorporate explosophoric functions in the final material. Thus, 2-nitroresorcinol 80 was reacted with trichlorotriazine 81 (cyanuric chloride) in the presence of a base to produce a cross-linked polymer 82 with triazine units and nitro groups (Figure 28). The interfacial conditions readily employed for such polycondensations were naturally adapted for the synthesis of porous polyHIPEs of this material [70] (see tetrazole and triazole-based polymers for other examples of high-nitrogen polyHIPEs). The chemical structure should be similar to the one obtained by cyclotrimerization of 1,3-dicyanato-2-nitrobenzene [71].

media/image28_w.jpg

Figure 28.

It should also be noted that carbon dinucleophiles are effective in polycondensation reactions with cyanuric chloride. Thus, sodium carbide enabled the construction of cross-linked architectures 83 in which triazine rings were connected by ethynylene moieties [72] (Figure 28).

Another well-known way to obtain triazine compounds is the cyclotrimerization of nitriles. However, only scarce examples deal with azaheterocyclic nitriles. 2,6-dicyanopyridine 84 was converted at high temperatures, in the presence of zinc chloride, to a porous framework 85 with alternating pyridine and triazine nuclei [73]. The measured N content was slightly below that expected (27.7 vs 32.5%) (Figure 29)

media/image29_w.jpg

Figure 29.

The quest for graphitic forms of carbon nitride (g-C3N4) has stimulated a vast amount of research in order to find suitable molecular precursors. With a calculated nitrogen content of 60.9%, C3N4 surely has its place in this overview, although only a few precursors lead to materials approaching the theoretical N/C ratio due to the presence of hydrogen or oxygen. The structure of C3N4 is still under consideration, but surely involves 1,3,5-triazine moieties. Many useful references are provided to the reader in [74]. Theoretical as well as characterization results have indicated that tri-s-triazine structures 86 rather than s-triazines would be intermediates towards g-C3N4 [75] (Figure 30).

media/image30_w.jpg

Figure 30.

6. Miscellaneous

Azide salts of bis(aminoguanidinium) compounds can be condensed with formaldehyde to produce the corresponding polymers 87a-b (Figure 31). Thanks to the azide groups and the intrinsically nitrogen-rich aminoguadinium moieties, the nitrogen content of these polycondensates was remarkably high, up to 77% [45,76]. A related copolymer incorporating 4-amino-1,2,4-triazole units has already been described in the triazole section.

media/image31_w.jpg

Figure 31.

Gaseous cyanogen (NC-CN) is a promising monomer as it shows a C/N ratio of 1/1. Studies have been devoted to its polymerization and given rise to so-called paracyanogen, either through chemical [77] or photochemical [78] methods. The determination of the exact structure of the polymer is a difficult task and a number of different hypotheses have been postulated (Figure 32). This work is made complicated by the incorporation of solvent or water/oxygen during the polymerization process, which leads to a significant presence of oxygen in the elemental analyses. Therefore, the theoretical figure of 50% of nitrogen can hardly be obtained. However, certain reaction conditions have enabled the synthesis of materials exceeding 40% of N.

media/image32.png

Figure 32.

from ref [78])

7. Conclusions

This review highlights a number of azaheterocycles-based polymer structures containing a high content of nitrogen, frequently around 50%. In some cases, over 60% and 70% N can be achieved, mainly in tetrazole-based materials. The presence of additional explosophoric groups such as nitro may also be encountered in such polymers which strengthens the interest in using them for energetic applications. The diversity of the described structures renders it possible to foresee a wide range of properties for these energetic materials. Consequently, a great opportunity is offered to select the appropriate material for a specific application in this field. Certain patents cited in this survey show that some of these polymers have already been exploited, and many other applied high-nitrogen polymers will surely see the light in the future.

References

1 - Kizhnyaev VN, Pokatilov FA, Vereshchagin LI2008Carbochain Polymers xith Oxadiazole, Triazole, and Tetrazole Cycles. Polym. sci. ser. C. 50121
2 - Kizhnyaev VN, Vereshchagin LI2003Vinyltetrazoles: Synthesis and PropertiesRuss. chem. rev. 72143164
3 - Henry RA1967Process for Synthesis of Vinyltetrazole Monomers. US Pat. 3,383,389.
4 - Buzilova SR, Shulgina VM, Sakovich GV, Vereshchagin LI1981Synthesis of Vinyl Derivatives of TetrazoleChem. heterocycl. comp. 17960963
5 - Aleshunin PA, Dmitrieva UN, Ostrovskii VA2011Vinyltetrazoles: II. Synthesis of 5-Substituted 1 2 )-VinyltetrazolesRuss. j. org. chem. 47: 1882 EOF1888 EOF
6 - Vereshchagin LI, Buzilova SR, Mityukova TK, Proidakov AG, Kizhnyaev VN, Il’ina VV, Sukhanov GT, Gareev GA, Bogens AK1986Synthesis of Functionally Substituted N-Vinyltetrazoles. Russ. j. org. chem. 2217771783
7 - Vygodskii YS, Mel’nik OA, Kazakova EV, Shaplov AS, Komarova LI, Kizhnyaev VN2008Free-Radical Polymerization of C-Vinyltetrazoles: Effect of the Nature of Ionic SolventsPolym. sci. ser. B. 50193197
8 - Koldobskii GI, Soldatenko DS, Gerasimova ES, Khokhryakova NR, Shcherbinin MB, Lebedev VP, Ostrovskii VA1997Tetrazoles: XXXVI. Synthesis, Structure, and Properties of 5-Nitrotetrazole. Russ. j. org. chem. 3317711783
9 - Kizhnyaev VN, Kruglova VA, Shivernovskaya OA, Ratovskii GV, Protasova LE, Vereshchagin LI1991Electronic Structure and Activity of Vinyltetrazoles in Radical HomopolymerizationIzv. akad. nauk. SSSR ser. khim. 22342238
10 - Kizhnyaev VN, Kruglova VA, Ivanova NA, Ratovskii GV, Buzilova SR, Gareyev GA1989The Radical Polymerization of N-Vinyltetrazoles. Polym. sci. USSR. 3127282734
11 - C. Youssef, R. Backov, M. Treguer, M. Birot, H. Deleuze, 2010Preparation of Remarkably Tough PolyHIPE Materials via Polymerization of Oil-in-Water HIPEs Involving 1-Vinyl-5-AminotetrazoleJ. polym. sci. A: polym. chem. 4829422947
12 - Klapötke TM, Sproll SM2010Nitrogen-Rich Polymers Based on 5 -Bromo-1-vinyl-1H-tetrazoleEur. j. org. chem. 1169-1175.
13 - M. Huang-R, X. Li-G, S. Li-X, W. Zhang, 2004Resultful Synthesis of Polyvinyltetrazole from PolyacrylonitrileReact. function. polym. 595361
14 - N. V. Tsarevsky, K. V. Bernaerts, B. Dufour, Prez. F. E. Du, K. Matyjaszewski, 2004Well-Defined (Co)polymers with 5-Vinyltetrazole Units via Combination of Atom Transfer Radical (Co)polymerization of Acrylonitrile and Click Chemistry-Type Postpolymerization Modification. Macromolecules 3793089313
15 - Miller CG, Williams GK2005Gas Generant and Synthesis. PCT Appl. WO 2005/118715 A2.
16 - Miller CG, Williams GK2006Water-Based Synthesis of Poly(tetrazoles). PCT Appl. WO 2006/050444 A1.
17 - Torley RE, Sprague GS1968Triaminoguanidinium Salts of 5Vinyltetrazole Polymers and a Method for Their Preparation. US Pat. 3,397,186.
18 - Gaponik PN, Ivashkevich OA, Karavai VP, Lesnikovic AI, Cheshavina NI, Sukhanov GT, Gareev GA1994Polymers and Copolymers Based on Vinyltetrazoles. 1. Synthesis of Poly(5-vinyltetrazole) by Polymer-Analogous Conversion of Polyacrylonitrile. Angew. makromol. chem. 2197788
19 - Kizhnyaev VN, Pokatilov FA, Vereshchagin LI2007Branched Tetrazole-Containing PolymersPolym. sci. ser. A. 492834
20 - Kizhnyaev VN, Pokatilov FA, Vereshchagin LI, Smirnov AI2006Method for Preparing Polymethylenetetrazoles. Pat. RU 2318003 C2.
21 - Carpenter WR1968Tetrazole Polymers. US Pat. 3,386,968.
22 - Klapötke TM, Sproll SM2008Synthesis and Characterization of Nitrogen Rich, Energetic Polymers Based on Tetrazoles. Proc. New trends in research of energetic materials, Pardubice, 796804
23 - K. Banert, T. M. Klapötke, S. M. Sproll, 2009Synthesis of N-[1-(2-Hydroxyethyl)-1H-tetrazol-5yl]-N-methylhydrazine as Polymeric Precursor. Eur. j. org. chem. 275-281.
24 - Klapötke TM, Sproll SM2010Investigation of Nitrogen-Rich Energetic Polymers Based on Alkylbridged Bis-(1-methyl-tetrazolylhydrazines)J. pol. sci. A: polym. chem. 48122127
25 - S. Pican, V. Lapinte, J. F. . Pilard, E. Pasquinet, L. Beller, L. Fontaine, D. Poullain, 2009Synthesis of 3,6-Divinyl-1,2,4,5-Tetrazine, the First Member of the Elusive Vinyltetrazine Family. Synlett 5731734
26 - E. Sagot, A. Le Roux, C. Soulivet, E. Pasquinet, D. Poullain, E. Girard, P. Palmas, 2007Synthesis of Linear and Hyperbranched Tetrazine-Based Polyhetarylenes Assemblies with High Nitrogen Content. Tetrahedron 631118911194
27 - P. Palmas, E. Girard, E. Pasquinet, T. Caron, D. Poullain, 2007Spectral Assignments for 1H, 13C and 15N Solution and Solid-State NMR Spectra of s-Tetrazines and Dihydro-s-Tetrazine DerivativesMagn. reson. chem. 456571
28 - Kizhnyaev VN, Pokatilov FA, Vereshchagin LI2008Carbochain Polymers xith Oxadiazole, Triazole, and Tetrazole Cycles. Polym. sci. ser. C. 50121
29 - Tsypina NA, Kizhnyaev VN, Pokatilov FA, Smirnov AI2003N-Vinyltriazoles in Radical Polymerization. Polym. sci. ser. B. 454144
30 - Kizhnyaev VN, Vereshchagin LI, Verkhozina ON, Pokatilov FA, Tsypina NA, Petrova TL, Sukhanov GT, Gareev GA, Smirnov AI2003Triazole and Tetrazole Containing Energetic Compounds. Proc. ICT conference, 75111
31 - Smets GJ1974Some New Polymers, Their Syntheses and Properties. 24th Plenary main. sect. lect. int. congr. pure. appl. chemical. 1123CA 1976:463755.
32 - F. Audouin, M. Birot, E. Pasquinet, O. Besnard, P. Palmas, D. Poullain, H. Deleuze, 2011Preparation, Solid-State NMR and Physico-Chemical Characterization of Surprisingly Tough Open Cell PolyHIPEs Derived From 1-Vinyl-1 2 4 -Triazole Oil-in-Water Emulsions.Macromolecules
33 - Skvortsova GG, Domnina ES, Makhno LP, Voronov VK, Taryashinova DD, Chipanina NN1973Structure and Properties of 3-Amino-1-vinyl-124triazole. Khim. geterosikl. soedin. 11: 1566-1569.
34 - Kizhnyaev VN, Pokatilov FA, Adamova LV, Zelenkov LE, Smirnov AI2008Polymerization of 1-Vinyl-3-amino-1 2 4 -triazole and Some Properties of Related Polymers.Polym. sci. ser. B 50: 16-19.
35 - Attarian OS, Asratian GV, Eliazian GA, Darbinian EG, Matsoian SG1986Synthesis and Polymerization of Vinyl Derivatives of 124Triazole, 3-Nitro-1,2,4-triazole and Tetrazole. Arm. khim. zh. 39: 630-635.
36 - Overberger CG, Yuen PS1970Esterolytic Catalyses by TriazolesJ. am. chem. soc. 9216671671
37 - H. Xue, H. Gao, J. M. Shreeve, 2008Energetic Polymer Salts from 1-Vinyl-1 2 4 -Triazole Derivatives.J. polym. sci. A: polym. chem. 46: 2414-2421.
38 - Williams GK, Burns SP, Mishra IB2005Gas Generating Commpositions. PCT Appl. WO 2005/035466 A2.
39 - Sukhanova AG, Sakovich GV, Sukhanov GT2010Reaction of 3-Nitro-124Triazoles with Alkylating Agents. 7. N-Monoalkylation by Monocyclic α-Oxide Polymers. Chem. heterocycl. comp. 46: 478-482.
40 - Korshak VV, Teplyakov MM1969Synthesis of Polymers with Azole Rings. Progr. polim. khim. 198251CA 1970:13074.
41 - T. Nishikubo, M. Hasegawa, 1987Polyaminotriazoles. In: Kroschwitz JI, editor. Encyclopedia of Polymer Science in English. New York: Wiley. 507514
42 - Fisher JW1954Polyaminotriazoles as Fiber-Forming MaterialsJ. appl. chem. 4212219
43 - B. Jorgensen, R. Liepins, 1983Fluorescers and Filters of Unusual Chemical Composition for Low-Energy X-Ray MeasurementsJvac. sci. technol. A. 1894896
44 - T. Suzuki, K. Yamamoto, Y. Hino, Y. Harada, H. Nagura, 1995Secondary Batteries with Nonaqueous electrolytes. Jap. Pat. JP07169459.
45 - P. D. Oja, W. Creek, E. T. Niles, 1968High Nitrogen Polymers Prepared by Reacting Aldehydes with Aminoguanidines, Tetrazoles, or Triazoles. US Pat. 3,375,230.
46 - W. Qafsaoui, H. Takenouti, 2010Corrosion Protection of 2024-T3 Aluminium Alloy by Electro-Polymerized 3-Amino-1 2 4 -triazole in Sulphate Solution Containing Chloride.Corros. sci. 52: 3667-3676.
47 - B. Trachli, M. Keddam, H. Takenouti, A. Srhiri, 2002Protective Effect of Electropolymerized 3-Amino 1 2 4 -triazole Towards Corrosion of Copper in 0.5 M NaCl.Corros. sci. 44: 997-1008.
48 - Voychtcheva OV, Galkine VD, Mikhantyev BI, Chatalov GV1973Vinylation of 123Triazole. Izv. Vyssh. Ucheb. Zaved, Khim. Tekhnol. 16: 1913-1914.
49 - Kizhnyaev VN, Pokatilov FA, Tsypina NA, Ratovskii GV, Vereshchagin LI, Smirnov AI2002Synthesis of N-Vinyl-123triazole Derivatives. Russ. J. org. chem. 38: 1056-1059.
50 - H. Nulwala, D. J. Burke, A. Khan, A. Serrano, C. J. Hawker, 2010N-Vinyltriazoles: a New Functional Monomer Family through Click Chemistry.Macromolecules4354745477
51 - Vereshchagin LI, Tikhonova LG, Maksikova AV, Gavrilov LD, Gareev GA1979Synthesis of Acyl- and Vinyl-substituted 123Triazoles. 15: 544-549.
52 - S. Sanghi, B. Fassbender, M. Tuominen, G. Brunklaus, H. W. Spiess, E. B. Coughlin, 2010Proton Conducting Properties of Poly(4-vinyl-1H-123triazole). Polym. Preprints 51: 76-77.
53 - G. Wouters, G. Smets, 1982Copolymerization of C-Vinyltriazoles and C-Vinyltetrazole with Vinyl Monomers. Makromol. chem. 18318611868
54 - Z. Zhou, S. Li, Y. Zhang, M. Liu, 2006H-123Triazole Based Polymer Materials for Proton Exchange Membranes. Polym. mater. sci. eng. 94: 609.
55 - Petrova TL, Kizhnyaev VN, Tsypina NA, Vereshchagin LI, Smirnov AI2002Method for Preparing Vinylnitrotriazole Polymers. Pat. RU 2261873 C2.
56 - Sukhanov GT, Sukhanova AG, Filippova YV2004Selectivity of N-Monoalkylation and Exhaustive Alkylation in Synthesis of Polymers of N-Glycidyl Derivatives of 3-Nitro-5-R-124and 4-nitro-1,2,3-triazoles. CA 2006:9757.
57 - Baldwin MG, Johnson KE, Lovinger JA, Parker CO1967Dipolar Cycloaddition Polymerization of Compounds Containing Both Azido and Acetylene Groups. Polym. lett. 5803806
58 - Malkov GV, Shastin AV, Estrin YI, Badamshina ER, Mikhailov YM2008Synthesis and Characterization of the Nitrogen-Rich Hyperbranched Polymers- Poly([1,2,3]-Triazole-[1,3,5]-Triazine)s.Propellantsexplos. pyrotech. 33431436
59 - Hergenrother PM1975Poly-as-triazines. J. macromol. sci. revs. macromol. chem. C13189218
60 - Pankratov VA, Vinogradova SV1972Polytriazines. Russ. chem. rev. 416682
61 - American Cyanamid Co1963Triazine Derivatives and Polymers Thereof. US Pat. 935,787.
62 - American Cyanamid Co1958Substituted s-Triazine and Method of Preparation. US Pat. 2,845,422.
63 - Overberger CG, Michelotti FW1958The Preparation of Polymers and Copolymers from Vinylpyrimidines and Triazines. J. am. chem. soc. 80988991
64 - Y. Yuki, N. Hiramatsu, T. Kakurai, T. Noguchi, 1969Polymerization of 2,4-Diamino-6-Vinyl-s-Triazine. Kobunshi Kagaku 26134140
65 - J. T. Thurston, F. C. Schaefer, J. R. Dudley, D. Holm-Hansen, 1951Cyanuric Chloride Derivatives. V. Reaction of Alkoxy-s-Triazines and Aryloxy-s-Triazines with Amines. J. am. chem. soc. 7329922996
66 - Ehlers GFL, Ray JD1964Synthesis and Characterization of Poly-s-TriazinyleneimidesJ. polym. sci. A. 249895003
67 - C. Courvoisier, R. Mercier, E. Pasquinet, D. Poullain, P. Palmas, 2004Synthèse de Polymères Hétérocycliques Azotés à Partir de Précurseurs Triaziniques. Journées de chimie organique, Palaiseau.
68 - Y. Liu, C. Deng-L, J. Zhao, J. Wang-S, L. Chen, Y. Wang-Z, 2011An Efficiently Halogen-Free Flame-Retardant Long-Glass-Fiber-Reinforced Polypropylene System. Polym. degrad. stab. 96363370
69 - T. Komatsu, 2000Heat-Resistant (Dihydro)Carbodiimide Group-Containing Triazine Polymers. JP Pat. 200063467
70 - F. Audouin, M. Birot, E. Pasquinet, H. Deleuze, O. Besnard, D. Poullain, 2008Synthesis of Porous Materials by 2-Nitroresorcinol/Cyanuric Chloride Thermal Polycondensation in Emulsion.J. appl. polym. sci. 10828082813
71 - E. Grigat, H. Schminke-D, R. Pütter, 1965Verfahren zur Herstellung von Hochmolekularen Polytriazinen. BRD Pat. 1190184.
72 - Paushkin YM, Aleksandrova VA, Lunin AF, Pisarenko TA1969Polycondensation of Cyanuric Chloride with Disodium Acetylide. Doklady. akademii. nauk SSSR 184863866CA 1969:106920.
73 - P. Kuhn, M. Antonietti, A. Thomas, 2008Porous, Covalent Triazine-Based Frameworks Prepared by Ionothermal Synthesis. Angew. chem. int. ed. 4734503453
74 - C. L. Schmidt, M. Jansen, 2010New Directions in Carbonitride Research: Synthesis of Resin-Like Dense-Packed C3N4 using a Hydrogen-Free Precursor. J. mater. chem. 20 41834192 .
75 - B. Jürgens, E. Irran, J. Senker, P. Kroll, H. Müller, W. Schnick, 2003Melem (258Triamino-tri-s-triazine), an Important Intermediate during Condensation of Melamine Rings to Graphitic Carbon Nitride: Synthesis, Structure Determination by X-ray Powder Diffractometry, Solid-State NMR, and Theoretical Studies. J.am. chem. soc. 125: 10288-10300.
76 - Niles ET, Oja PD, Pannell CE1969High Nitrogen Containing Monomeric 12Ethylene Bis(aminoguanidine) Compound-Aldehyde Condensation Polymer. US Pat. 3,408,331.
77 - L. W. Jenneskens, J. W. G. Mahy, E. J. Vliestra, S. J. Goede, F. Bickelhaupt, 1994Structural Studies on Paracyanogen and ParaisocyanogenJ. chem. soc. faraday trans. 90327332
78 - F. Cataldo, 1999On Cyanogen PhotopolymerizationEur. polym. j. 35571579