The carbon nanofibers (CNF) consist of graphite platelets arranged in diverse orientations with respect to the fiber axis and present distinctive and special functional properties; these structures have a large number of edges and remarked chemical interaction that favor the absorption capacity , they also have a high-catalytic activity which can be used as solid carbon supports for other catalytic reactions , .
Because all these remarkable features, CNF are quite appropriate for health [4,5] and atmospheric pollutants treatment [6-8], on-chip interconnect integration [9,10] and they can also be used like chemical or biochemical sensing on molecular scale .
To appreciate, a little bit more, the vast world of carbon nanostructures, M.Monthioux and V. Kuznetsov describe, from a carefully point of view , some amazing data about the history of carbon nanostructures; in particular they mention a patent of Thomas Alba Edison in 1892, dealing on the synthesis of carbon filaments for an incandescent lamp, employing a thermal decomposition of gaseous methane. However, such patent can not be considered as the first evidence for the growth of carbon nanotubes nor nanofibers, since the resolution of the available optical microscopes were scarcely able to image filaments smaller than few micrometers in diameter. Thanks to the subsequent invention of the transmission electron microscope (TEM), in 1953 first TEM images of CNF were published .
At the end of the fifties and during the sixties, many laboratories and companies begin to be interested on CNF, for example, R. Bacon had synthesized CNF of about 200nm by the electric arc technique . Later, during the 70’s, A. Oberlin, M. Endo and co-workers have obtained CNF of about 7nm with the chemical vapour deposition (CVD) technique [15-17].
Afterward, new techniques of CNF synthesis were constantly reported in literature. Nowadays, they exist a large quantity of methods to synthesize carbon nanofibers, the most common is the CVD method; this gas-phase process, generally, operate at lower temperatures, the experiment is carried out in a flow furnace at atmospheric pressure. In perhaps the simplest experimental setup, the catalyst is placed in a ceramic boat which is then put into a quartz tube. A reaction mixture consisting of, for example, acetylene and argon is passed over the catalyst bed for several hours at temperatures ranging from 500 to 1100 °C [18-23].
Another technique to vapour-grown CNF production is based on a ‘floating catalyst’ carried in the gas stream inside a continuous flow reactor . Supported catalysts have been used for CNF synthesis to achieve control of fiber width. Silica-supported Fe, Ni or Co catalysts produce narrow tubular CNFs from CO/H2 and ethylene/H2mixtures . A similar technique but on water-soluble supports (Na4SiO4, Na2SiO3, and Na2CO3) is also used .
The CVD traditional technique is now enhanced with plasma technology; it has two advantages compared with the conventional CVD method: low process temperature and more flexible film properties [34-38].
A plasma technique that is also used for carbon nanostructures synthesis is the plasma torch; however a relatively low yield of these structures is produced . Its principal limitation could be the very short residence time (lower than 1ms) of catalyst particles in the plasma because of high axial velocity of plasma jets (axial velocity can attain 300m/s).
The work herein presented is dedicated to the investigation of CNF synthesis using combination energy for two types of plasma (glow discharge and electric arc discharge) in order to diminish energy consumption. Our aim is then, to propose an alternative to the existing plasma methods for CNFs synthesis. Here, we propose an approach consisting in a high frequency glow-arc discharge working under low power consumption (<300W) and low flow rates of hydrocarbon injection (< 0.1 lpm). This method has additional advantages such as very short reaction times, simple to operate (it requires neither substrates nor special pretreatments) and low cost arrangement (expensive vacuum equipment is not involved).
The present work deals with the growth of CNF by a glow-arc HF discharge; the alternating electric field across the electrodes and the temperature in the gap, provide the energy and dynamics necessary for the dissociation of carbon coming from an hydrocarbon gas (CH4 + He) and from graphite electrodes to form CNF assisted by the transition metal catalysts (Ni, Y).
Although the conversion of the carbon and the catalyst to carbon nanostructures by arc discharge and laser method is very efficient, the energy consumption to vaporize the carbon becomes their principal drawback. To atomize a mol of graphite a quantity of 716.6kJ of energy is needed compared with 80kJ/mol if methane gas is used into the plasma discharge. Consequently, we propose an alternating process, by using not a high power DC discharge, but a high frequency and low power discharge assisted by methane as carbon-containing gas.
The method here exposed is characterized to have two discharge regimes: a glow discharge and an electric arc discharge. Glow discharge is characterized to have very energetic electrons contrary to other species in plasma with lower kinetic energies, a very characteristically mauve light, under our conditions, is emitted at, approximately, ambient temperature. This discharge is used to pre-heat catalysts to react with the carbon containing gas (CH4) when the electric arc is established. Under this electric arc regime, the sublimation of carbon occurs and the subsequent reaction with the catalyst takes place. The electric arc regime is characterized to be close to local thermodynamical equilibrium, it means that electrons and heavy particles have almost the same kinetic energy or temperature, which easily can reach 4000 K up to 12000 K.
The advantage to employ an alternating current (AC) and HF discharge is to obtain quasi instantaneous breakdown voltage peaks, getting enough specific energy to dissociate and to ionize the carbon supply, and consequently, the CNF synthesis is obtained at lower energy consumption.
During the processes, a particle agglomeration takes place in the inter-electrode gap; this effect has been observed by some authors [40-42]. They have found that the particles flowing through the gap depend on the alternating electric field intensity, gravitational force and friction forces described by the Newton motion equation. The amplitude of oscillation decreases with increasing frequency in the electric field vector. Higher frequencies are then, more appropriate because lower amplitude of particles oscillation results in lower probability of their precipitation to the electrodes, and therefore small power consumption is needed to attain the carbon sublimation.
To characterize some physical parameters during the plasma processes, a spectroscopic technique is applied: the optical emission spectroscopy (OES), which examines the wavelengths of photons emitted by the plasma species, during their transition from an excited state to a lower energy state. Each element emits a characteristic set of impulsions at specific wavelengths according to its electronic structure; by observing these wavelengths the elemental composition of the sample can be determined; furthermore, additional parameters like electronic and rotational temperatures (molecules temperature) and electron density, for example, can be obtained. This technique has the enormous advantage to be a non intrusive method.
3. Experimental set-up.
The plasma discharge was generated inside a reactor where the pressure could be controlled by a very simple pumping system, within a 10-100 kPa range. The electric energy is provided by a high frequency resonant converter specially designed for this purpose (see figure 1(a)) . The AC current can be adjusted from 10mA up to 2A peak to peak. The frequency of the applied voltage will affect the voltage at which breakdown occurs, in stable condition the breakdown voltage is 200V. In general, if DC voltage is used, a higher breakdown voltage will be required . The curves of the electric evolution from glow-toarc discharge as well as the traces of voltage versus current in both regimes were plotted using the real data obtained during the experiments carried out with the setup described in figure 1(a). These results are shown in figure 1(b) . By multiplying the voltage by the current, the instant power applied to the plasma is determined and the rms power values are 51W for glow discharge and 96.7 W for the arc discharge. In the electric diagnostic, it is clear that the arc-regime discharge consumes more power than the glow-regime discharge. The difference, however, is small; in fact, the arc regime requires 45.7W more than the glow regime because the arc discharge exists almost 100% of the time, and the glow regime presents discontinuities. The reason is that some hydrogen atoms are free when the CH4 molecule bonds are broken, and it causes an increment of the electric conductivity of the plasma requiring, then, less power to sustain the arc regime. The temperature dependence of the electric conductivity of various gases (H2, He, N2 and Ar) shows that H2 presents more conductivity than He; this is due to the higher ionization potential of He .
The plasma reactor has a special optical port for measurement. The optical signal of the plasma discharge was guided by an optical fiber mounted in a XY electromechanical system to achieve a vertical and horizontal scanning of the plasma discharge with very precise incremental steps (0.1mm). The final end of the optical fiber is focused into the entrance slit of the monochromator, equipped with an 1800 grooves/mm holographic grating.
The inferior electrode plays at the same time the role of powder catalyst container. The catalysts mixture (34%at.Ni/10.32%at.Y/55.68%at.C) is disposed in the lower electrode (see figure 2). Two configurations of the lower electrode (containing the catalysts) were tested; in figure 2 a perforated structure with 1mm diameter holes is showed and a simplest configuration electrode consisting in a cylindrical carbon electrode with a co-axial hole drilled at its centre, filled with graphite powder and catalyst.
The upper pure carbon electrode (10mm diameter, 100mm long) can be automatically adjusted to conserve a constant gap of 5mm. All the operating conditions were performed under stable conditions at 42 kHz of frequency and the power source was varied from 150 to 400 watts. Methane was used as carbon containing gas at a feed rate of 0.1 l/min. Helium flowing at 0.3l/min was used as a plasma gas.
A great advantage of using an alternating electric field is that a fine control of two separated regimes (glow and arc discharge) can be accomplished. Figure 2 shows a glow discharge required for the catalyst heating during a previous time (just a few seconds) to produce some vapours used to react with the carbon containing gas (CH4) when the electric arc is established (figure 3). Under this regime, the sublimation of carbon occurs and the subsequent reaction with the catalyst takes place.
4. Results and discussion
4.1. Optical emission spectroscopy diagnostic
OES is one of the most used techniques for plasma diagnosis. The optical emission measurements of the Swan Band are commonly used in the diagnosis of high or even in low temperature processes by introducing carbon materials in the process.
For plasmas in departure from local thermal equilibrium, the rotational, vibrational and excitation temperatures from electrons can differ from those of the heavy species temperatures. Taking into account the relation between the rotational and translational states, the rotational temperature is derived generally from the temperature of heavy particles. Then, the temperature of heavy particles can be obtained from the measurement of the rotational temperature using the C2(0,0) Swan band situated between 513nm and 517nm.
The evolution of the optical spectrum of the plasma in the Swan band for both atmospheres (He and He + CH4), is presented in figure 12. It is clear from this figure, that the methane gas accelerates the glow-to-arc discharge process; the transition evolution is reduced five times. In addition, the spectrum intensity under He-CH4 atmosphere is higher than under He atmosphere. Applying the method described elsewhere [47, 48], temperature values of 6180K and 4830K are obtained under He and He-CH4 atmospheres, respectively.
These are sufficient high temperatures to accomplish the catalyst, the carbon and the methane sublimation. Unfortunately, the diagnostic can not be prolonged until the final of the experiments, because dusty plasma rapidly fills out the reactor, and consequently, the spectral lines could not be clearly distinguished from the background, leading to a relatively large uncertainty under these conditions.
4.2. Morphological analysis
It is worth to note that the main product accumulation is formed in both electrodes because of the alternative current (figure 5), having, a major percentage of this product accumulated in the upper electrode due to the convection effect. In a dc electric arc discharge, usually employed to generate carbon nanotubes, only the cathode accumulates the carbon product in a more compact way (figure 6) .
The main product was collected from the electrodes and the soot-like deposits from the reactor wall, then it was subjected to ultrasonic treatment in iso-propilic alcohol for 10 minutes and finally it was analyzed by a JEOL JSM-5900LV scan electronic microscopy.
Samples studied are mostly composed by carbon nanofibers (figure 7). An additional purification experiment with toluene solution during 5 min leads in a final product quite free of amorphous carbon, as can be shown in figure 8. Very similar morphological structure was obtained by Matsuura and co-workers , in a plasma reactor with twelve-phase alternating current discharge and 3 kW of power.
To further characterize the CNF microstructure, an analysis was done with JEOL 2010 Transmission Electron Microscope. Images of the samples are displayed in figure 9 and 10, where homogeneous nanofibers were observed; the CNF diameters vary from 30nm to 200nm. Figure 9 shows a CNF with diameter of about 120nm. Figure 10 shows a thicker CNF with relatively periodic joints, as those observed by , with 30nm of external diameter and an inner diameter of about 15nm.
4.3. XRD results.
In figure 11, four X-ray diffraction patterns are superposed. Relatively high CNFs quantity is corroborated with these patterns. Each pattern corresponds to samples obtained under very specific operational conditions. Sample a) is the catalyst-graphite mixture before their exposure to the plasma; this X-ray pattern shows a rich crystalline structure. Sample b) was obtained at low applied power (158W). After the electronic microscopy study (SEM and
TEM) it was found that the CNFs were not representative, however the X-ray pattern still shows a polycrystalline structure. The sample c) was obtained under 360W of applied power. The X-ray spectrum exhibits few defined peaks indicating a reduced crystalline structure of CNFs . The most intense peaks are (0 0 2) and (1 0 0) peaks respectively situated at 26.25 and 42.20 in a 2θ system. The 26.25 angle corresponds to the interplanar spacing d002 of carbon nanofibers and nanotubes . Finally, spectrum d) corresponds to a purified sample. Peak (0 0 2) is more intense than peaks found in other samples.
4.4. Raman scattering results
To support our analysis obtained by SEM, TEM and XRD techniques a fourth one was applied. The samples were also analyzed by the Raman scattering technique which is mostly used to characterize the crystalline structure.
The main criterion used in literature [50, 53] to reveal the carbon nanostructures quality by Raman scattering technique, is the ratio between the peaks G to D. The G peak is located around 1590 cm-1 and attributes C-C elongated vibration of graphite layers, indicating a well graphitized carbon nanostructure. Imperfect graphite structure is characterized by the D peak, near 1349 cm-1, and it is also associated with the existence of amorphous carbon fragments rather than structure imperfections. The peak B situated at 159 cm-1 usually represents the radial breathing mode (RBM) in monowall carbon nanotubes. The formation of nanofibers instead of nanotubes could be explained by the presence of hydrogen in the plasma discharge that will terminate the dandling bonds at the edges of stacked graphite platelets .
4.5. Power influence
To study the influence of the power input in the CNF synthesis several values of power input were tested and the obtained products were analyzed by SEM technique. Results of these tests are schematized in figure 13 which shows the CNFs evolution in function of power, that higher CNF yields are obtained at 360W; under this experimental condition the plasma remains very stable. To increase the power capacity several module reactors could be assembled into an array. The simplicity of its electric circuitry and adaptability to an AC glow-arc discharge are some of the most attractive features of this method. Modular plasma discharge working in an array has been already reported by Kuo and Koretzky [58, 59].
4.6. Preliminary results of NOx adsorption by CNF
To determinate the energy of activation in CNF and, then, the process of sorption, CNF samples were contaminated with NOX. Contaminated and uncontaminated CNF, were analyzed by thermogravimetry (figure 14), that usually consists in weight lost in function of temperature determination.
By following the next procedure is possible to obtain the energy activation. Equation (1) represents a first order kinetics adsorption
T is temperature
R = 8.134 J/mol-K,
A: pre-exponencial factor (s-1)
β: heating velocity (K/min): energy activation
is the weight loss in function of T, more specifically,
m o is initial weight at T, m T is the weight in function of T and m f is final weight.
For the uncontaminated and contaminated samples the values of energy activation respectively are: = 68.12 and = 80.98 . These, relatively low values corresponds to a physical absorption.
These results are similar to values obtained by some others authors (for carbon nanostructures the energy activation is between 10 KJ/mol-100KJ/mol [60,61]). The advantage of the physical adsorption, confirmed by thermogravimetric analysis, is that NOx, could be removed from CNF fluid bed by employing physical means such as a pressure camera.
An additional experiment was effectuated to test the capacity of adsorption of CNF, consisting in passing a constant flux of 400ppm of NOx during few minutes, through a CNF bed. By employing a NOx sensor (PG250) it was possible to determinate the removal rate being of about 87%. It is worth to note that additional experiments must be done, in order to confirm the life time of the CNF as support in a fluid bed.
A simple technique for CNFs synthesis is reported, the duration of processes is lower than 5 minutes and it requires neither preheating nor high flux of carrier gas. The synthesis has been achieved by the decomposition of methane in an AC low energy plasma discharge. The formed CNFs, exhibited a diameter of about 80nm with relatively no impurities. This purity allows the CNFs to be used as a catalyst support for subsequent applications in polymer composite formation or polluted gas absorbers.
The power input of the plasma discharge is an important parameter in the process, an optimization of the CNF synthesis was obtained at about 360W. A great advantage of using a high frequency electric field consists in controlling the power transferred during the glow discharge, and electric arc modes.
By comparing the energy consumptions for this AC plasma discharge with others different configurations, it is clearly shown that a CNFs synthesis can be produced with minimal energy consumption when this kind of AC glow-arc discharge is used. 800 kJ are needed to produce 1g of CNFs.
Preliminary experimental results shows that CNF obtained have a potential to be used as toxic gas adsorbers.
To increase the power and CNFs production, these modular plasma reactors can be connected in series or parallel configuration. The advantage of using a carbon-containing gas, instead of carbon consumable electrodes, resides in the small amount of energy that is needed to atomize it. All these attributions, would favor the implementation of a novel device for producing research quantities of CNF with a low cost and simplicity.